Working at the cutting edge: the creation of allosteric ribozymes

The appropriate folding of catalytic RNA is a prerequisite for effective catalysis. A novel ribozyme, the maxizyme, has been generated and its activity can be controlled allosterically. The maxizymes work both in vitro and in vivo indicating the potential utility of this novel class of ribozyme as a gene-inactivating agent with a biosensor function.     

Addition of an extra substrate binding site and partial destabilization of stem structures in HDV ribozyme give rise to high sequence-specificity for its target RNA

Because the substrate binding site (P1) of HDV ribozyme consists of only seven nucleotides, cleavage of undesired RNA is likely to occur when applied for a specific long RNA target such as mRNA. To overcome this problem, we designed modified trans-acting HDV ribozymes with an extra substrate-binding site (P5) in addition to the original binding site (P1). By inserting an additional seven base-pair stem (P5 stem) into the J1/2 single-stranded region of the ribozyme core system and partial destabilization of the P2 or P4 stem, we succeeded in preparation of new HDV ribozymes that can cleave the target RNA depending on the formation of P5 stem. Moreover, the ribozyme with a six-nucleotide P1 site was able to distinguish the substrate RNA with a complete match from that with a single mismatch in the P1 region. These results suggest that the HDV ribozyme system is useful for the application in vivo.     

A multifunctional expression vector for an anti-HIV-1 ribozyme that produces a 5'- and 3'-trimmed trans-acting ribozyme, targeted against HIV-1 RNA, and cis-acting ribozymes that are designed to bind to and thereby sequester trans-activator proteins such as Tat and Rev.

We previously constructed a multiribozyme expression vector by combining cis- and trans-acting ribozymes and we showed that several ribozymes, each directed against a different target in the HIV genome and acting independently in a 'shotgun' manner, markedly increased the efficiency of cleavage of HIV RNA in vitro [Ohkawa et al., Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 90, 11302 (1993)]. However, the cis-acting ribozymes that had trimmed the 5' and 3' ends of each trans-acting ribozyme were designed merely to await for degradation by RNases when they were used in vivo. Since several trans-activator proteins are essential for viral replication of HIV-1, we wondered whether a decoy function could be coupled with the cleavage activity of ribozymes. We therefore introduced the TAR or the RRE sequence into the stem II region of each cis-acting ribozyme. When the activity of each resulting cis-acting ribozyme that had been endowed with the decoy function was examined in vitro, it was found to retain almost full trimming activity. Moreover, cis-acting ribozymes with either the TAR or the RRE sequence were shown to be able to trap Tat or Rev protein successfully. It is, therefore, possible to endow the stem II region with a specific protein-binding function without the loss of ribozyme function. Thus, cis-acting ribozymes, endowed with the decoy function, can first trim the 5' and 3' ends of each trans-acting ribozyme and are then still available for trapping trans-activator proteins possibly prior to their degradation by RNases when they are to be used in vivo. Furthermore, it is also expected that the reduction in production of HIV RNA that is achieved by sequestering the trans-activator proteins might provide the trans-acting ribozymes, targeted to HIV RNA, with a better chance of eliminating the remaining HIV RNA.     

Effects of variations in length of hammerhead ribozyme antisense arms upon the cleavage of longer RNA substrates.

The efficacy of intracellular binding of hammerhead ribozyme to its cleavage site in target RNA is a major requirement for its use as a therapeutic agent. Such efficacy can be influenced by several factors, such as the length of the ribozyme antisense arms and mRNA secondary structures. Analysis of various IL-2 hammerhead ribozymes having different antisense arms but directed to the same site predicts that the hammerhead ribozyme target site is present within a double-stranded region that is flanked by single-stranded loops. Extension of the low cleaving hammerhead ribozyme antisense arms by nucleotides that base pair with the single-stranded regions facilitated the hammerhead ribozyme binding to longer RNA substrates (e.g. mRNA). In addition, a correlation between the in vitro and intracellular results was also found. Thus, the present study would facilitate the design of hammerhead ribozymes directed against higher order structured sites. Further, it emphasises the importance of detailed structural investigations of hammerhead ribozyme full-length target RNAs.     

CTAB-mediated enrichment for active forms of novel dimeric maxizymes

We demonstrated previously that shortened forms of (stem II-deleted) hammerhead ribozymes with low intrinsic activity form very active dimers with a common stem II (very active short ribozymes capable of forming dimers were designated maxizymes). As a result of such a dimeric structure, heterodimeric maxizymes are potentially capable of cleaving a substrate at two different sites simultaneously. In this case, active heterodimers are in equilibrium with inactive homodimers. Longer forms of common stem II can lead to enrichment of the active heterodimers in vitro. In this study, we investigated whether the cationic detergent CTAB, which is known to enhance strand displacement of nucleic acids, might inhibit the dimerization of maxizymes. Significantly, under all conditions examined, CTAB instead enhanced the activity of a variety of maxizymes, with the extent of enhancement depending on the conditions. The activity of our least stable, least active maxizyme was enhanced 100-fold by CTAB. The strand displacement activity of CTAB thus appears to enhance the conversion of alternative conformations of inactive maxizymes, with intra- and inter-molecular hydrogen bonds, to active forms. Thus, our smallest maxizyme can also be considered a potential candidate for a gene-inactivating agent in vivo, in view of the fact that various facilitators of strand displacement reactions are known to exist in vivo (indeed, a separate experiment in cell culture supported the conclusion that our smallest maxizyme is a good gene-inactivating agent). Although activities of ribozymes in vitro do not necessarily reflect their activities in vivo, our findings suggest that the activity of ribozymes in vivo can be better estimated by running ribozyme kinetics in the presence of CTAB in vitro.     

Allosterically controllable maxizymes cleave mRNA with high efficiency and specificity

Ribozymes are small and versatile nucleic acids that can cleave RNA molecules at specific sites. However, because of the limited number of cleavable sequences on the target mRNA, in some cases conventional ribozymes do not have precise cleavage specificity. To overcome this problem, an allosteric version (a maxizyme) was developed that displayed activity and specificity in vivo. More than five custom-designed maxizymes have demonstrated sensor functions, which indicates that the technology might be broadly applicable in molecular biology and possibly in the clinic.     

Addition of an Extra Substrate Binding Site and Partial Destabilization of Stem Structures in HDV Ribozyme Give Rise to High Sequence-Specificity for its Target RNA

Because the substrate binding site (P1) of HDV ribozyme consists of only seven nucleotides, cleavage of undesired RNA is likely to occur when applied for a specific long RNA target such as mRNA. To overcome this problem, we designed modified trans-acting HDV ribozymes with an extra substrate-binding site (P5) in addition to the original binding site (P1). By inserting an additional seven base-pair stem (P5 stem) into the J1/2 single-stranded region of the ribozyme core system and partial destabilization of the P2 or P4 stem, we succeeded in preparation of new HDV ribozymes that can cleave the target RNA depending on the formation of P5 stem. Moreover, the ribozyme with a six-nucleotide P1 site was able to distinguish the substrate RNA with a complete match from that with a single mismatch in the P1 region. These results suggest that the HDV ribozyme system is useful for the application in vivo.     

HIV-1 TAR as anchoring site for optimized catalytic RNAs

Ribozymes have a great potential for developing specific gene silencing molecules. One of the main limitations to ensure the efficient application of ribozymes is to achieve effective binding to the target. Stem-loop domains support efficient formation of the kissing complex between natural antisense molecules and their target sequence. We have characterized catalytic antisense RNA hybrid molecules composed of a hammerhead ribozyme and a stem-loop antisense domain. A series of artificial RNA substrates containing the TAR-RNA stem-loop and a target for the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed and challenged with a catalytic antisense RNA carrying the TAR complementary stem-loop. The catalytic antisense RNA cleaves each of these substrates significantly more efficiently than the parental hammerhead ribozyme. Deletion of the TAR domain in the substrate abolishes the positive effect. These results suggest that the enhancement is due to the interaction of both complementary stem-loop motifs. A similar improvement was corroborated when targeting the LTR region of HIV-1 with either hammerhead- and hairpin-based catalytic antisense RNAs. Our results indicate that the TAR domain can be used as an anchoring site to facilitate the access of ribozymes to their specific target sequences within TAR-containing RNAs. Finally, we propose the addition of stable stem-loop motifs to the ribozyme domain as a rational way for constructing catalytic antisense RNAs.     

Chemical and enzymatic probing of effector-mediated changes in the conformation of a maxizyme

The protein encoded by chimeric BCR-ABL mRNA causes chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML). We showed previously that a novel allosterically controllable ribozyme, of the type known as a maxizyme, can cleave this mRNA, with high specificity and high-level activity in vivo. We designed the maxizyme in such a way that it was able to form an active core with which to capture the catalytically indispensable Mg2+ ions only in the presence of the BCR-ABL mRNA junction. In order to probe the putative conformational changes, we used a weakly alkaline solution (pH 9.2) in the presence of 25 mM Mg2+ ions to hydrolyze differentially phosphodiester bonds that were located in different environments. Phosphodiester bonds in single-stranded regions were clearly more susceptible to attack by alkali than those within a double-stranded helix. As indicated by earlier data obtained in vivo, our results demonstrated that the active conformation was achieved only in the presence of the junction within the chimeric BCR-ABL mRNA. Moreover, we demonstrated that the use of mild alkaline solutions to probe RNA structures is very informative.     

Specificity of novel allosterically trans- and cis-activated connected maxizymes that are designed to suppress BCR-ABL expression

Chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) is associated with the presence of the Philadelphia chromosome, which is generated by the reciprocal translocation of chromosomes 9 and 22. In the case of L6 (b2a2) mRNA, it is difficult to cleave the abnormal mRNA specifically because the mRNA includes no sequences that can be cleaved efficiently by conventional hammerhead ribozymes near the BCR-ABL junction. We recently succeeded in designing a novel maxizyme, which specifically cleaves BCR-ABL fusion mRNA, as a result of the formation of a dimeric structure. As an extension of our molecular engineering of maxizymes, as well as to improve their potential utility, we examined whether an analogous conformational change could be induced within a single molecule when two maxizymes were connected via a linker sequence. An active conformation was achieved by binding of the construct to the BCR-ABL junction in trans, with part of the linker sequence then acting as an antisense modulator in cis (within the complex) to adjust the overall structure. Results of studies in vitro in the presence of cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) (but not in its absence) suggested that a certain kind of connected maxizyme (cMzB) might be able to undergo a desired conformational change and, indeed, studies in vivo confirmed this prediction. Therefore, we successfully created a fully functional, connected maxizyme and, moreover, we found that the activity and specificity of catalytic RNAs in vivo might be better estimated if their reactions are monitored in vitro in the presence of CTAB.     

Design and specificity of hammerhead ribozymes against calretinin mRNA.

We obtained a partial sequence of mouse calretinin mRNA from cDNA clones, and designed hammerhead ribozymes to cleave positions within it. With a view to optimising hammerhead ribozymes for eliminating the mRNA in vivo, we varied the length and sequence of the three duplex 'arms' and measured the cleavage of long RNA substrates in vitro at 37 degrees C (as well as 50 degrees C). Precise cleavage occurred, but it could only go to completion with a large excess of ribozyme. The evidence suggests that the rate-limiting step with a large target is not the cleavage, but the formation of the active ribozyme: substrate complex. The efficiency varied unpredictably according to the target site, the length of the substrate RNA, and the length of the ribozyme; secondary structure in vitro may be responsible. We particularly investigated the degree of sequence-specificity. Some mismatches could be tolerated, but shortening of the total basepairing with the substrate to less than 14 bp drastically reduced activity, implying that interaction with weakly-matched RNAs is unlikely to be a serious problem in vivo. These results suggest that specific and complete cleavage of a mRNA in vivo should be possible, given high-level expression of a ribozyme against a favourable target site.     

UV cross-link mapping of the substrate-binding site of an RNase P ribozyme to a target mRNA sequence.

RNase P ribozyme cleaves an RNA helix that resembles the acceptor stem and T-stem structure of its natural ptRNA substrate. When covalently linked with a guide sequence, the ribozyme can function as a sequence-specific endonuclease and cleave any target RNA sequences that base pair with the guide sequence. Using a site-directed ultraviolet (UV) cross-linking approach, we have mapped the regions of the ribozyme that are in close proximity to a substrate that contains the mRNA sequence encoding thymidine kinase of human herpes simplex virus 1. Our data suggest that the cleavage site of the mRNA substrate is positioned at the same regions of the ribozyme that bind to the cleavage site of a ptRNA. The mRNA-binding domains include regions that interact with the acceptor stem and T-stem and in addition, regions that are unique and not in close contact with a ptRNA. Identification of the mRNA-binding site provides a foundation to study how RNase P ribozymes achieve their sequence specificity and facilitates the development of gene-targeting ribozymes.