VH gene family repertoire of resting B cells. Preferential use of D-proximal families early in development may be due to distinct B cell subsets

The fetal VH gene repertoire was shown previously to be characterized by overrepresentation of D-proximal families, VH 7183 and VH Q52, compared with adult bone marrow B cells in which VH genes were expressed in a more stochastic fashion. To determine the underlying mechanisms of these findings, adult vs fetal progenitors were placed in the same supportive microenvironment and the resulting B lineage cells analyzed for VH gene family expression. The supportive microenvironment was provided by established adult bone marrow stromal cell layers. In this way the relative importance of environmental vs genetic influences could be determined. The fetal B cells and pre-B cells that developed on adult stromal cells maintained a fetal-like VH gene family repertoire with preference for D-proximal families VH 7183 and Q52. In contrast, adult cultured B cells maintained the adult-like repertoire with predominance of the largest family VH J558. Only after long-term incubation was there a change in the expression of particular VH gene families. These findings suggest that the D-proximal VH gene family preference observed early in ontogeny is associated more with the inherent genetic potential of B cell progenitors that predominate during fetal life and less with environmental influences.     

VH gene expression by nontransformed pre-B cells upon differentiation in vitro

Mice have more than 1000 VH gene segments, and each pre-B cell must choose a single one for rearrangement to encode the V portion of the antibody H chain. Presumably, all or most of the functional VH gene segments must be chosen by the population of B lymphocytes if the organism is to express the diversity that is observed in the immune system. Control of the selection of a VH gene segment for expression is not understood. We have found that the members of the VH gene family closest to the constant genes, the 7183 family, are transcribed in a manner that is specific for the stage of B cell development after pre-B cells derived from spleens of 6- to 8-wk-old nude mice are induced to differentiate in vitro by a mixture of dendritic cells and mitogen-activated T lymphocytes (DC-T). DC-T from spleens and lymph nodes induce transient high levels of synthesis of RNA from the 7183 VH family, whereas DC-T from Peyer's patches of mice of the same age as those from which spleen and lymph node DC-T were prepared did not induce the expression of RNA from that gene family. Spleen and Peyer's patch DC-T induce secretion of similar total amounts of antibody. Therefore, the RNA synthesis from members of at least one VH gene family is specific both for the lymphoid tissue in which B cell differentiation occurs and for the developmental stage of the B lymphoid cells.     

VHDJH formation and DJH replacement during pre-B differentiation: non-random usage of gene segments.

The Abelson murine leukemia virus (A-MuLV) transformed cell line 300-19 was derived from the bone marrow of an adult NIH/Swiss outbred mouse. The original 300-19 clonal isolate carried DHH rearrangements of both JH alleles, a molecular genotype characteristic of early pre-B cells. During propagation in culture, the 300-19 line frequently generates secondary rearrangements of its JH alleles including rearrangements which append VH segments to the pre-existing DJH complexes to form complete VHDJH variable region genes and secondary D to JH rearrangements which replace the pre-existing DJH rearrangement by joining an upstream D to a downstream JH. The two types of secondary rearrangement events occur at approximately equal frequency. Approximately 30% of the VH to DJH joins lead to the production of mu heavy chains providing support for a regulated model of allelic exclusion. Like pre-B cell lines from other origins, the 300-19 line preferentially utilized VH gene segments from the more JH-proximal (3') families to form VHDJH rearrangements. However, the VH segments preferentially employed by 300-19 were from a different family than those previously demonstrated to be utilized by pre-B lines of BALB/c origin; we relate these different utilization patterns to differences in the organization of the more 3' VH families between the two strains. The initial DJH rearrangements of the 300-19 line employed more 3' (JH-proximal) D segments; however, the DJH replacements preferentially employed the most 5' D segment. We discuss this phenomenon in the context of a mechanism which may target recombinase to regions of the chromosome more 5' to the D locus (VH-containing regions) once an initial DJH complex is formed.     

Interspersion of the VHQ52 and VH7183 gene families in the NFS/N mouse

Deletion mapping analysis has shown that members of the VH7183 and VHQ52 gene families are interspersed in the NFS/N mouse. To obtain direct evidence that members of these gene families are physically linked, an NFS/N liver library was constructed and genomic clones were analyzed for hybridization to both VHQ52 and VH7183 gene probes. Four clones were identified which contained both VHQ52 and VH7183 hybridizable restriction fragments. Two clones containing rearranged VHQ52 genes were also found to hybridize with the VH7183 gene probe. Sequence analysis of three of the VH7183-containing restriction fragments indicate that all are pseudogenes which contain interruptions at either the 5' and/or 3' ends of the VH coding region. Given the D-proximal location of at least a portion of the VHQ52 gene family relative to VH7183 in NFS/N mice, and the known correlation between D proximity and the frequency of VH gene utilization, 22 NFS/N-derived pre-B cell lines were analyzed for VHQ52 gene utilization. More than 40% of the identified H chain (VHDJH) rearrangements in this survey used members of this gene family. Furthermore, analysis of poly(A)+ RNA from NFS/N fetal liver and adult spleen also indicates preferential utilization of VHQ52 family in fetal liver. Kinetic studies show, however, that there are no changes in relative utilization throughout fetal ontogeny. The implications of these findings for the expression and randomization of the VH repertoire are discussed.     

Patterns of Ig V region expression among neonatal hemagglutinin-responsive B cells. Evidence for non-random VH gene representation during later stages of development

Hybridoma libraries were established whose specificities reflect those within the BALB/c hemagglutinin-responsive B cell repertoire at 1 or 2 wk of age. These libraries were generated through chronic immunization regimes that induce responses dominated by clonotypes available at the age of initial immunization. Dot blot analyses of cytoplasmic RNA from these hybridomas were performed to determine the Ig H chain V region (VH) families associated with the repertoire at each age. Although genes from most known VH families can generate hemagglutinin-specific antibodies, clonotypes prevalent during the first week of life disproportionately use VH7183 gene segments. In contrast, hybridomas representative of the repertoire in 2-wk-old individuals preferentially use VHS107, VH36-60, and VHX24 gene segments. These results demonstrate changes in VH gene family predominance that correlate with the age-related patterns of clonal emergence and turnover previously shown in the hemagglutinin-reactive B cell pool. Taken together, these findings suggest that the very early neonatal Ag-responsive B cell pool closely reflects preferential VH gene rearrangements within the pre-B cell compartment. Further, they suggest that either non-random strategies of VH gene expression, or selective clonal expansion strategies based on VH, operate even at later stages of development.     

B-1a, B-1b and B-2 B cells display unique VHDJH repertoires formed at different stages of ontogeny and under different selection pressures.

Analyses of VHDJH rearrangements isolated from murine peritoneal B-1a cells (CD5+, IgMhi, B220lo), peritoneal B-1b cells (CD5-, IgMhi, B220lo), and conventional splenic B cells provide evidence that a unique repertoire of VH regions is displayed by each of these B-cell subsets. The B-1a subset is characterized by a low N-region diversity, by a high frequency of sequence homologies in the VH-D and D-JH junctions, and by a limited exonuclease nibbling of the terminals of the joining gene segments. Through expansion in ageing mice, B-1a clones with these properties are favoured. B-1b cells are similar to conventional B-2 cells with respect to N-region diversity, but are unique in terms of D gene expression. Thus, while most murine pre-B and B cells preferentially use DSP and DFL gene segments in a given reading frame (RF1), B-1b cells frequently express D genes in another reading frame (RF2). Together, these findings provide structural evidence for a model where B-1a, B-1b and B-2 cells are produced by separate progenitors that are active at different stages of ontogeny.     

VH gene family utilization in colonies derived from B and pre-B cells detected by the RNA colony blot assay.

The immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region (VH) genes of the mouse have been categorized into families based upon sequence homology. Utilizing the RNA colony blot assay we have determined the expression of eight of these families in B cell colonies derived from either surface immunoglobulin positive (sIg+) adult spleen B cells or sIg- fetal liver pre-B cells. We demonstrate, based upon the analysis of greater than 6000 individual colonies, that VH gene usage is a characteristic of the mouse strain studied. C57BL/6 mice most frequently (45%) utilize family VHJ558, the largest VH family, whereas BALB/c mice most frequently (22%) utilize family VH7183, the most JH proximal family in BALB/c mice. Moreover, colonies derived from sIg- fetal liver derived precursors show similar patterns, suggesting that selection based on exogenous antigen is not an important parameter in determining VH gene family usage.     

Ontogeny and distribution of the murine B cell Fc gamma RII.

The distribution and expression of the IgG FcRII (Fc gamma RII) on normal murine B cells was examined. Using multicolor flow cytometry, spleens from neonatal mice of increasing age and adult bone marrow were analyzed for expression of the Fc gamma RII. In addition, B cells from peripheral lymphoid organs, as well as panel of B cell tumors, were tested. The results demonstrate that the Fc gamma RII is expressed on all pre-B cells and immature B cells in the neonatal spleen and adult bone marrow, on all mature B cells in peripheral lymphoid organs, and on switched B cells in Peyer's patches. Furthermore, the Fc gamma RII was found to be present on B cell tumors representative of all stages of B cell maturation and differentiation. Taken together, the results indicate that Fc gamma RII is expressed during the entire lifetime of the B cell. In addition, examination of spleen cells from neonatal mice revealed a large number of pre-B cells, phenotypically defined as B220+, IgM-. These pre-B cells were present at birth, peaked in number between 2 and 3 wk of age, and became a minor population by day 30. Further phenotypic analysis of these cells demonstrated the expression of the BLA-1 and BP-1 Ag, and the lack of T cell and NK cell markers, thus confirming their assignment to the B cell lineage. Finally, the Fc gamma RII present on these pre-B cells was shown to be functional, by virtue of its ability to bind aggregated IgG.     

Contribution of the CD5+ B cell to D-proximal VH family expression early in ontogeny.

In this study, the contribution of the CD5+ B cell to the preferential expression of VH 7183 and Q52 observed early in development was determined. CD5+ and CD5- B cells from BALB/c mice were isolated by fluorescence-activated cell sorter and the expression of particular VH gene families was determined directly by in situ hybridization. The results indicate that CD5+ B cells obtained from both adult and neonatal animals express Q52 at increased levels compared with CD5- B cells. Preferential expression of VH 7183 was observed only in the neonatal CD5- B cell subset. Thus, the increased expression of VH 7183 early in development is caused by the CD5- subset whereas increased Q52 expression is caused by the CD5+ subset. These results indicate that the fetal/neonatal conventional B cell is distinct from conventional adult B cells in terms of Ig gene repertoire expression.     

Neonatal and adult primary B cells use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes in their (T,G)-A-L-specific repertoire

Although there is a nonrandom usage of VH gene families by primary B cells early in ontogeny, at issue is whether the preferential rearrangement of 3' germ-line VH genes, e.g., VH7183 and VHQ52 family genes, influences the neonatal B cell repertoire that can be expressed in response to Ag. In order to address this issue, and to determine whether neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes as adult B cells in their primary response, we have analyzed at the molecular level the neonatal antibody response to (T,G)-A-L and compared it with the adult primary response. Among the TGB5 Id+, GT+ antibodies, which dominate the neonatal response to (T,G)-A-L, two VH gene families were used: J558 (high frequency) and 36-60 (low frequency). The majority of Id+ neonatal hybridomas used the same germ-line VH gene (H10, from the VHJ558 family), but with enormous diversity in the D region, and one of two germ-line V kappa 1 genes (V kappa 1A, V kappa 1C). These are the same germ-line V-genes used by most primary adult Id+ hybridomas, and the frequency of expression of this germ-line V-gene combination appears equivalent in the neonatal and adult primary repertoires. Therefore, it is clear from this study that as early as day 5, neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line V-genes as adult primary B cells in their Ag-specific repertoire.     

Development and distribution of B lineage cells in the domestic cat: analysis with monoclonal antibodies to cat mu-, gamma-, kappa-, and lambda-chains and heterologous anti-alpha antibodies

To trace the development and distribution of B lineage cells in the domestic cat (Felis catus), we have produced monoclonal antibodies against mu-, gamma-, kappa-, and lambda-chains of feline immunoglobulins (Ig). Goat antibodies against human mu-, alpha-, and lambda-chains, which are reactive with shared determinants on their feline counterparts, were used in conjunction with the panel of mouse monoclonal antibodies. Cytoplasmic mu+ pre-B cells and surface IgM+ B lymphocytes were observed in 42 day fetal liver in which pre-B cells were more abundant than IgM+ B cells. Pre-B cells also were found in bone marrow in young cats, and continued to be generated in the marrow throughout life. In the spleen, adult levels of B cells were attained by 12 wk of age, at which time the frequencies of surface IgM+, IgG+, and lambda+ cells were 49, 3, and 40%, respectively. The distributions of Ig isotypes also were determined among plasma cells as a function of age and tissue localization. IgM plasma cells were predominant in the bone marrow of 1-wk-old cats, whereas IgG plasma cells were the prevalent isotype in adult bone marrow. In the mesenteric lymph nodes of adult animals, the frequency distributions of IgM, IgG, and IgA plasma cells were similar to the frequency distributions of IgM, IgG, and IgA isotypes among bone marrow plasma cells. IgA+ plasma cells predominated in the intestinal lamina propria, in which IgG+ and IgM+ plasma cells were relatively infrequent. In the tissues of both young and adult animals, the ratio of lambda:kappa expression was approximately 3:1. We conclude that the pattern of B cell development in the cat resembles that found in other mammals, except that the kappa to lambda ratio is reversed.     

Ig gene rearrangement and expression in the progeny of B-cell progenitors in the course of clonal expansion in bone marrow cultures.

In cultures of murine bone marrow cells colonies of 10(3)-10(4) cells were identified which consisted to a large part of pre-B and B cells. Cell mixing experiments with genetically marked cells indicated that each colony is derived from a single progenitor cell not yet committed to the expression of either IgH locus. A concanavalin-A-mediated electrofusion method allowed us to rescue and amplify individual cells from a given colony by hybridization with X63.Ag8.653 cells. The molecular analysis of 12 such hybridomas revealed that all IgH loci were rearranged into DJH or productive or nonproductive VHDJH complexes. Most kappa and all lambda light chain loci were in germline configuration. Kappa chain expression was only seen in heavy (mu) chain expressing hybridomas. Hybridomas from a given colony were heterogeneous in terms of DJH and VHDJH rearrangements and in no cell was more than one productive VHDJH complex detected. None of the productive VHDJH complexes contained a VH gene of group 1 (J558), the largest VH gene family with about half of the VH genes. This is in marked contrast to VH gene usage in splenic B cells.     

Strain-dependent expression of VH gene families

The tremendous diversity of the antibody specificity repertoire stems from the ability of each developing B cell to select one out of many possible variable, diversity, and joining gene segments by specific rearrangement of the DNA. The mechanism by which V region gene segments is selected is not known. Moreover, evidence for both random and nonrandom expression of VH genes in mature B cells has been presented previously. In this report, the technique of in situ hybridization is used to accurately measure at the single cell level VH gene family expression in LPS-induced cells from several strains. In this way, at least one-third of the B cells are stimulated and a large sampling of activated splenocytes from each strain analyzed. The use of in situ hybridization eliminates any potential biases resulting from transformation protocols. In addition, because all populations of cells are analyzed by both in situ hybridization and immunocytochemical staining with anti-IgM, the proportion of cells detected by in situ hybridization could be compared with the proportion of B cells, blasts, and plasma cells in the population. It was concluded from these comparisons that the cells being detected by in situ hybridization under the conditions described are plasmablasts and plasma cells. Therefore, an accurate measure of the functional and expressed VH gene repertoire could be made. The results clearly demonstrate strain-dependent variation in VH gene family expression, particularly VH 7183 and VH J558 with up to three-fold differences observed. Thus, either there is considerable strain variation in the number of functional VH gene family segments or the expression of VH genes is not entirely random.     

The expression of the Ig H chain repertoire in developing bone marrow B lineage cells

Analyses of rearranged Ig H chain V region genes of bone marrow pre-B cells demonstrate extensive sequence diversity, particularly within the third hypervariable region (HCDR3). This diversity is constrained, however, through preferential utilization of certain D gene segments and possibly VH gene segments and a preponderance of productive rearrangements, primarily those expressing D gene segments in a preferred reading frame. The predominance of productively rearranged V genes with D regions translated in a preferred frame, is, at least in part, the consequence of selective clonal expansion encompassing at least five to six divisions subsequent to VH-D-JH rearrangement. Selection for clonal expansion appears to be dependent on recognition of the nascent H chain product of certain productively rearranged genes.     

Phenotypic and functional characterization of murine B lymphocyte precursors isolated from fetal and adult tissues

Murine fetal liver and adult bone marrow cells identified by monoclonal 14.8 antibody were enriched on antibody-coated polystyrene petri dishes. Cell surface immunoglobulin (sig)-bearing cells were depleted before this enrichment procedure, and the resulting preparations of 14.8+, slg- cells were characterized as to morphology, immunoglobulin gene expression, and functional potential in vivo and in vitro. All cells with detectable mu chains of IgM in the cytoplasm (cmu) were found to be included in the 14.8+ population. The enriched cells did not contain significant numbers of committed granulocyte-macrophage progenitor cells or putative hemopoietic stem cells. Selected cells from 16-day fetal liver were large, a majority of the cells had a lobulated rather than a spherical nuclear outline, and less than 1% had detectable cmu. Enriched cells from 19-day fetal liver were on the average smaller than those from 16-day-gestation liver and had a more typical lymphoid morphology; 30% were cmu+. Adult bone marrow 14.8+, slg- cells were similar to 19-day fetal liver cells in morphology, and approximately half were cmu+. These selected precursor cells retained the capacity to mature in vivo and in vitro. Fetal and adult 14.8+, slg- cells were efficient in generating newly formed B cells in vivo, and this maturation step appeared to be dependent on the presence of microenvironmental accessory cells. However, the ability of positively selected cells to mature in vitro was markedly decreased, and this potential was not rescued by providing known sources of accessory cells. Possible reasons for this difference are considered. This technique for positively selecting cells has allowed us to directly compare for the first time B cell precursors from fetal and adult tissues and will be invaluable for resolution of the cell compartments in the differentiation of B lymphocyte precursors, in the study of accessory cells known to facilitate this process, in the definition of humoral factors which may act on pre-B cells, in the study of immunoglobulin gene rearrangements which take place during normal differentiation, and for further comparative studies of fetal and adult lymphopoiesis.     

The CD24 antigen discriminates between pre-B and B cells in human bone marrow.

When bone marrow (BM) lymphoid cells from 12 adult healthy donors were labeled by CD24 antibodies and analyzed by flow cytometry, two positive populations of cells were demonstrated in each sample (by a separated bimodal specific immunofluorescence). One population had intermediate CD24-Ag density (termed CD24+ cells) whereas the other had high CD24-Ag density (termed CD24(2+) cells). CD24+ cells represented 5.8 +/- 2.7% of the total lymphoid BM cells and CD24(2+) cells 5.6 +/- 2.5%. Using dual fluorescence analysis on eight samples, all CD24+ cells expressed the CD21 and CD37 mature B cell Ag and also surface IgM (sIgM), but this population lacked CD10 Ag. These cells also expressed CD19 Ag, and at a higher density than CD24(2+) cells. They were also positive for HLA-DR Ag. Conversely, CD24(2+) cells were shown to be early cells of the B cell lineage. While all the CD24(2+) cells were HLA-DR+ and CD19+, 64 +/- 16% of them expressed CD20 Ag (at a lower density than CD24+ cells), 65 +/- 21% CD10 Ag, and 22 +/- 8% were positive for cytoplasmic mu-chains (c mu). None of these cells expressed the CD21 and CD37 mature B cell Ag or sIgM. Additional experiments on four different healthy donors demonstrated that 30 +/- 9% of the CD24(2+) cells expressed the CD34 Ag and that the CD24+ cells did not express it. Thus, the CD24 Ag permits discrimination between two populations of the B cell lineage present in adult BM: 1) A CD24(2+) cell population including "pre" pre-B cells (HLA-DR+, CD19+, CD10+/-, CD20-, CD21-, CD34+, CD37-, c mu-), "intermediate" pre-B cells (HLA-DR+, CD19+, CD10+, CD20+, CD21-, CD34-, CD37-, c mu-), and "true" pre-B cells (HLA-DR+, CD19+, CD10+, CD20+, CD21-, CD34-, CD37-, c mu+). 2) A CD24+ cell population including B cells of the standard phenotype (HLA-DR+, CD19+, CD10-, CD20+, CD21+, CD34-, CD37+, c mu-, sIgM+).     

Pre-B cells: bone marrow persistence in anti-mu-suppressed mice, conversion to B lymphocytes, and recovery after destruction by cyclophosphamide.

Chronic treatment of mice from birth with anti-mu antibodies aborts development of B lymphocytes and plasma cells. In these studies we show that bone marrow from anti-mu-treated mice contains a population of cells with cytoplasmic IgM, but which lack detectable cell-surface IgM. These cells are analogous to pre-B cells, defined in ontogenetic studies as the immediate precursors of B lymphocytes. Pre-B cells from bone marrow of anti-mu treated mice retain their functional integrity, as evidenced by their ability to give rise to sIgM+, LPS-responsive lymphocytes in culture. We also show that cyclophosphamide treatment destroys pre-B cells and that recovery of pre-B cells in bone marrow precedes the regeneration of sIgM+ B lymphocytes. Generation of B lymphocytes in adult mice apparently occurs exclusively in the bone marrow because induction of extramedullary hemopoiesis in spleen was not accompanied by the appearance of pre-B cells in that organ.     

Unusual germline DSP2 gene accounts for all apparent V-D-D-J rearrangements in newborn, but not adult, MRL mice.

Anti-dsDNA autoantibodies in MRL mice contain a higher than average frequency of atypical complementarity-determining regions 3, including those made with D-D rearrangements. It has been reported that MRL mice have an intrinsically high frequency of creating VDDJ rearrangements; however, we show in this study that the majority of these apparent D-D rearrangements in B cell progenitors can be accounted for by a very novel germline D(H) gene in mice of the Igh(j) haplotype. This gene has the appearance of a D to D rearrangement due to the duplication of 9 bp common to most DSP2 genes. Germline DSP2 genes from Igh(j) mice were amplified, cloned, and sequenced, showing the presence of this novel gene as well as a new allele of a conventional DSP2 gene. Sequencing of D-J rearrangements revealed that Igh(j) mice also have a different allele of DFL16.1 and apparently lack DFL16.2. Despite the existence of this new DSP gene, analysis of VDJ rearrangements from adult bone marrow pre-B cells of MRL/lpr mice still revealed the presence of complementarity-determining region 3 containing apparent D-D joinings in 4.6% of the sequences. C3H pre-B cells had 4.2% of sequences with apparent VDDJ rearrangements, and BALB/c pre-B cells had approximately 2%. DDJ intermediates were also observed, but at a lower frequency. However, strikingly, no VDDJ rearrangements were observed in newborn sequences, suggesting the process of assembly of VDJ rearrangements is fundamentally different in newborn mice vs adult mice.