Blood lymphocyte culture system: quantitative analysis of X-ray-induced chromosome aberrations in man, muntjac and cattle

Peripheral blood lymphocytes of 3 mammalian species, man, muntjac and cattle, which have various amounts of DNA and divergent karyotypes, were exposed to 100-400 rad of X-rays, and frequencies of dicentrics and other aberrations were analysed at first post-irradiation metaphases. During experiments, various preparative or physical and biological factors that could influence the yield of chromosome aberrations were taken into account. The frequency of dicentrics scored at first post-irradiation metaphases showed best fit to both linear and quadratic dose-response curves, y = a + bD and y = bD + cD2 with a high correlation coefficient of 0.98 (P less than 0.001). The frequency of dicentrics obtained at different post-irradiation fixation times did not show significant variation, indicating a homogeneous sensitivity of peripheral lymphocytes to X-irradiation. BrdU incorporation following X-irradiation showed no increase in the frequency of chromosome aberrations. The frequency of dicentrics in man, muntjac and cattle showed a close correlation with their DNA content, but no meaningful correlation was found between the yield of dicentrics and the chromosome arm number or the nuclear volume. The ratio of dicentric yields, 1.00:0.67:1.04 obtained in man, muntjac and cattle were comparable to the ratio of their DNA contents, 1.00: 0.65: 1.07. The base-line frequency of SCEs was similar in the 3 species and no significant variation in SCE frequency was noticed even after administration of 400 rad of X-rays.     

The relative radiosensitivities of human,rabbit and rat-kangaroo chromosomes

Lymphocytes of man, rabbit and potoroo (Potorous tridactylus) were exposed, in vitro, to various doses of X-rays and analysed at their first mitotic division for chromosome structural abnormalities. The ratio of yields of dicentric aberrations in the three species was, respectively, 1.00∶0.46∶0.29 and of deletions 1.00∶0.62∶1.13. Similar results were obtained for human and rabbit cells exposed to fast neutrons. — In lymphocytes of six mammalian species, including man, Brewen et al. (1973) found a linear relationship between chromosome arm number and relative dicentric frequencies. Our data for potoroo cells (24 chromosome arms) fit in well with this linear response but our rabbit data do not: on the basis of chromosome arm number the dicentric frequency in rabbit (80 arms) should be similar to that for man (81 arms) whereas dicentrics are less than half as frequent in rabbit cells. — The differences in DNA content (man:rabbit, 1.00∶0.92) and lymphocyte nuclear volumes (1.00∶0.84) are too small to explain the differential dicentrie frequencies. It is suggested that the capacity for accurate DNA repair may differ between species and be reflected in different frequencies of chromosome exchange.     

Dose-response relations for dicentric yields in GO lymphocytes of man and crab-eating monkey following acute and chronic gamma-irradiations.

A comparison has been made of dicentric yields in G₀ lymphocytes between man and crab-eating monkey, Macaca fascicularis, after acute and chronic γ-irradiations. With acute irradiation (49.6 rad/min) there was no significant difference between them, but for the chronic irradiation (17.1 rad/h) a significant difference was observed between the species. When the dose-response relations were fitted to the linear-quadratic model (Y = D + βD²), the species-difference observed for chronic irradiation was almost entirely due to change in the value of β. In addition, after chronic irradiation the β-value for monkey was almost negligible, but that for man was significant. Post-irradiation incubation experiment showed that cells with dicentrics were partly eliminated during the course of chronic irradiation, because there were appreciable reductions of dicentric yields (ca. 25% for both man and monkey at 400 rad) together with mitotic indices (ca. 30% and 60% for man and monkey, respectively, at 400 rad). Accordingly, it would be reasonable to postulate that G₀ repair for dicentrics other than selection mechanism must play a major role in the effects of low dose rate. It can be further suggested that G₀-repair capacity for chromosal damages leading to dicentrics may be different among different primate species.     

A comparative study of the frequencies of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in somatic and germ cells of the rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta)

Frequencies of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in spermatogonia, peripheral blood lymphocytes and bone-marrow cells of the rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta) and in human blood lymphocytes, were determined at different exposures of X-rays. The dose-response curve for the induction of reciprocal translocations in spermatogonia suggested a “hump” at about 200 rad. The absolute frequencies of chromosome aberrations in somatic and germ cells of the rhesus monkey were low in comparison with most other mammalian species and the ratio between aberrations in the two tissues was 25 to 1 at the 100 rad level. Although the numbers of “effective chromosome arms” in man and rhesus monkey are similar (81 vs. 83), the rhesus monkey showed a lower rate of induction of dicentrics in blood lymphocytes than man at all doses, reaching statistical significance at the 300 rad level.     

Chromosome aberration yields in human lymphocytes induced by fractionated doses of x-radiation.

Unstimulated (G0) human peripheral blood lymphocytes were exposed at 37 degrees C to doses of 200 or 500 rad of X-rays delivered in two equal fractions. The dose fractions were separated by intervals of up to 7 h in the 200 rad study and up to 48 h for 500 rad. In both studies the mean levels of dicentrics and total unstable aberrations began to decline when fractions were delivered with intervals of greater than 2 h. With 200 rad the yield had decreased to an additive baseline (i.e. equal to only twice the yield of a single 100-rad fraction) by an interval of 4 h. Following 500 rad the yield declined until 8 h and then remained 20% above the additive baseline even when 48 h separated the fractions. Possible explanations for this discrepancy are discussed. In a second experiment PHA stimulated lymphocyte cultures were exposed to 2 doses of 125 rad of X-rays up to 7 h apart in an attempt to demonstrate the late peak in aberration yields originally reported by Lane [5]. Control cultures received unsplit doses of 250 rad at the time of the corresponding second 125-rad fraction. No evidence of a late peak in dicentric yield was observed. The yield remained approximately the same irrespective of the time interval between fractions but these split dose yields were significantly different from the accompanying unsplit controls.     

Genetic hazards of ionizing radiations: cytogenetic extrapolations from mouse to man

The frequencies of X-ray induced asymmetrical interchanges (dicentrics) and acentric fragments (deletions) at several doses were measured in the circullating leukocytes of six species. The leukocytes of the species used had similar DNA contents but different chromosome and chromosome arm numbers. The data for dicentrics were fitted separately for each species by regression analysis to the model Y_j = b_jD + c_jD². All species gave a good fit to this model. As expected, when the dicentric data for all species were pooled and fitted to this model a poor fit was obtained. However, if a term for arm number was included, so that the model Y_j = (N_j?1) (bD+cD²) was fitted, a significant amount of the variation among species could be accounted for. At each dose there was an approximately linear relationship between the yield of dicentrics and the arm number. Man, with an effective arm number of 81, had twice as many dicentrics as the mouse, with an effective arm number of. These results strongly suggest that the chromosome arm number of a species influences the yield of asymmetrica interchanges. The chromosome arm number did not appear to influence the yield of deletions, and the yields induced in the mouse and man at easch dose were equal.These results show that man is twice as sensitive as the mouse to the induction of translocations, whereas the two species are equally sensitive to the indcution of deletions and, in all probability, to the production of mutations.     

Dose-response relations for dicentric yields in G0 lymphocytes on man and crab-eating monkey following acute and chronic γ-irradiations

A comparison has been made of dicentric yields in G₀ lymphocytes between man and crab-eating monkey, Macaca fascicularis, after acute and chronic γ-irradiations. With acute irradiation (49.6 rad/min) there was no significant difference between them, but for the chronic irradiation (17.1 rad/h) a significant difference was observed between the species. When the dose-response relations were fitted to the linear-quadratic model (Y = αD + βD²), the species-difference observed for chronic irradiation was almost entirely due to change in the value of β. In addition, after chronic irradiation the β-value for monkey was almost negligible, but that for man was significant. Post-irradiation incubation experiment showed that cells with dicentrics were partly eliminated during the course of chronic irradiation, because there were appreciable reductions of dicentric yields (ca. 25% for both man and monkey at 400 rad) together with mitotic indices (ca. 30% and 60% for man and monkey, respectively, at 400 rad). Accordingly, it would be reasonable to postulate that G₀ repair for dicentrics other than selection mechanism must play a major role in the effects of low dose rate. It can be further suggested that G₀-repair capacity for chromosal damages leading to dicentrics may be different among different primate species.     

Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes from man and crab-eating monkey: The dose-response relationships at low doses

To obtain information on the relation beteween yiels of chrmosome aberrations and dose at low-dose levels, experiments were conducted with 5, 10, 20, 30 and 50 rad of ¹³⁷Cs γ-rays, on lymphocytes from man and crab-eating monkey (Macaca fascicularis). The dose-response relationship for dicentrics was obtained from the combined data of these low-dose experiments with those of our previous onse at high doses (100–400 rad) When the difference between observed yields and those expected from the linear-quadratic model were computed, the dose-response curve had a good fit for man, but not for the monkey. The linear regression lines between 0 and 30 rad were calculated, because the expected values of α/β for man and monkey would be about 100 and 60 rad.The human date gave a satisfactory fit to a linear model, i.e., a linear increase in aberration frequency with dose, whereas this was not so for those of the monkey. Furtyhermose, there was some suggestive evidence for the existence of plateau in dicentrics yields between 10 and 30 rad for the monkey and between 20 and 30 rad for human lymphocytes, but more data would be needed to verify this suggestion, particularly for human lymphocytes.     

Genotoxic effects of radiotherapy and chemotherapy on the circulating lymphocytes of breast cancer patients. I. Chromosome aberrations induced in vivo

Unstable chromosome aberrations were scored in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) serially collected from 21 breast cancer patients before and after radiotherapy (RT), chemotherapy (CT) and combined treatments. Local radiotherapy as treatment for mammary cancer induced unstable chromosome aberrations in peripheral blood lymphocytes. Only a fraction of these lymphocytes were exposed to irradiation during treatment and the chromosomal damage observed in PBL was equivalent to that induced by irradiation in vitro with 2 Gy at high dose rate, i.e., about 4% of the total dose delivered locally. Chemotherapy alone did not induce such anomalies. Apart from the observed interindividual variations in either the level or the fate of dicentrics with time, different features of chromosome damage were found when chemotherapy was given before or after local cobaltotherapy: secondary chemotherapy did not alter the frequency and the overdispersed distribution of dicentrics observed after first-line radiotherapy; in contrast, when CT was given before radiotherapy, a lower dicentric frequency was scored, the distribution of dicentrics was not always found to be overdispersed and there was a time-dependent decrease in dicentrics after in vivo exposure.     

Evaluation and re-evaluation of genetic radiation hazards in man: II. The arm number hypothesis and the induction of reciprocal translocation in man

The arm number hypothesis proposed by Brewen and colleagues in 1973 has been examined in the light of information thus far available from mammalian studies. In experiments with peripheral blood lymphocytes (radiation in vitro), a linear relationship between dicentric yield and the effective chromosome arm number of the species was obtained in the mouse, Chinese hamster, goat, sheep, pig, wallaby and man. However, the data are not consistent with such a relationship in several primate species (marmoset, rhesus monkey, cynomolgus monkey, squirrel monkey and the slow loris), the cat and the dog. In the rabbit, the data are conflicting.In the mouse and Chinese hamster the frequencies of reciprocal translocations recorded in spermatocytes descended from irradiated spermatogonia are in line with the expectation based on the arm number hupothesis, whereas in the golden hamster, rabbit and the rhesus monkey they are not. In man and the marmoset, the limited data are not inconsistent with a 2-fold higher sensitivity of these species relative to the mouse although they do not rule out a difference as high as 4-fold. In the guinea-pig, the situation is unclear.New data on the transmission of reciprocal translocations in mice suggest that the frequency in the F₁ progeny may be close to one-quarter of that recorded in the spermatocytes of the irradiated fathers (spermatogonial irradiation) at an exposure level of 150 R, whereas at higher exposures, the reduction factor is about one-eighth, the latter being in line with the earlier finding.All these results taken together suggest that inter-specific extrapolation from the radiosensitivity of somatic cells (to dicentric induction) to that of germ cells (to translocation induction) is fraught with uncertainty at present. Certain aspects that need to be studied in more detail in the context of induced chromosome aberrations are discussed.     

Time course study of the chromosome-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle in maize.

The B chromosome of maize has been used in a study of dicentric chromosomes. TB-9Sb is a translocation between the B and chromosome 9. The B-9 of TB-9Sb carries 60% of the short arm of 9. For construction of dicentrics, a modified B-9 chromosome was used, B-9-Dp9. It consists of the B-9 chromosome plus a duplicated 9S region attached to the distal end. In meiosis, fold-back pairing and crossing over in the duplicated region gives a chromatid-type dicentric B-9 that subsequently initiates a chromatid-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle. In the male, it forms a single bridge in anaphase II of meiosis and at the first pollen mitosis. However, the cycle is interrupted by nondisjunction of the B centromere at the second pollen mitosis, which sends the B-9 dicentric to one pole and converts it from a chromatid dicentric to a chromosome dicentric. As expected, the new dicentric undergoes the chromosome-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle and produces double bridges. A large number of plants with chromosome dicentrics were produced in this way. The presence of double bridges in the root cells of plants with a chromosome dicentric was studied during the first 10 wk of development. It was found that the number of plants and cells showing double bridges declined steadily over the 10-wk period. Several lines of evidence indicate that there was no specific developmental time for dicentric loss. "Healing" of broken chromosomes produced by dicentric breakage accounted for much of the dicentric loss. Healing produced a wide range of derived B-9 chromosomes, some large and some small. A group of minichromosomes found in these experiments probably represents the small end of the scale for B-9 derivatives.     

Lack of synergistic effect between X-ray and UV irradiation on the frequency of chromosome aberrations in PHA-stimulated human lymphocytes in the G1 stage.

PHA-stimulated human lymphocytes in the G1 stage were irradiated with UV radiation and X-rays, and the cells were analyzed for chromosomal aberrations in the first mitotic division. The frequency of dicentric chromosomes after single X-irradiation in the G1 stage was about twice the yield in the G0 stage. No increase in the yield of dicentrics was observed after combined irradiation with UV and X-rays. This is contrary to the finding for G0 lymphocytes, where a 2-fold increase of chromosome aberrations was observed. UV irradiation of G1 lymphocytes induced chromatid-type aberrations whereas no significant yield of dicentric chromosomes was observed. This is in agreement with previous findings in Chinese hamster cells in the G1 stage [7]. Irradiation of G0 lymphocytes with UV radiation induce a low frequency of dicentric chromosomes. Thus, the present data indicate that the ratio between chromosome-type and chromatid-type aberrations is different in the G1 and G0 stages in human lymphocytes irradiated with UV radiation.     

Indirect immunofluorescence of inactive centromeres as indicator of centromeric function

Summary Two previous single case reports from the literature showed the presence or absence of centromeric antigens at the site of the inactive centromeres in one (X;X) and in one (9;11) dicentric chromosome. We studied nine different dicentric chromosomes using anticentromeric antibodies and immunofluorescence techniques. In the four autosomal dicentrics the inactive centromere was consistently positive while the dicentrics composed of two X chromosomes were either positive or negative; one case of (X;Y) dicentric was negative. The results indicate that the X chromosome mode of replication may be involved in the suppression of immunofluorescence at the site of the inactive centromere and that one centromere of the dicentric chromosome may lose its function but conserve some of its antigenic properties. This indicates that not all these antigens play a rôle in the microtubules-centromere interaction.     

Aberrations induced by fission neutrons in human peripheral lymphocytes

Analysis of dose-response relationship was carried out for chromosome aberrations produced in human peripheral lymphocytes by fission neutrons at doses of 25, 50, 100 or 200 rad.Statistical treatment showed experimental data to be fitted by a regression curve described by the mathematical model Y = a+bD. A linear relation to dose characterized both one-break and two-break aberration yields. Numerical values of coefficients are reported for yields of dicentrics, chromosome fragments, minutes, aberrant cells, total number of aberrations, and total breakage.Based on chromosome fragments and aberrant cells, relative biological efficiency (RBE) value derived for fission neutrons relative to 180 kV X-rays for chromosome fragments was 2.53, and for aberrant cells it was 2.80.     

Chromosome aberration in human lymphocytes after X-irradiation in vitro. II. Analysis of primary processes in the formation of dicentric chromosomes

The rejoining distance for the formation of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes has been derived on the basis of microdosimetric concepts. For the formation of a dicentric chromosome, primary lesions produced by absorption events can interact within the nucleus over a distance of at least 1 μm. The dispersion of dicentrics is near to 1 and corresponds to a site number between 17 and 120.     

Distribution of the various radiation-induced chromosomal rearrangements in relation to the dose and sampling time

The quantitative analysis of the chromosome rearrangements detected in 2128 R-banded metaphases, obtained from gamma-irradiated human lymphocytes after 48 to 96 h in culture is reported. Depending on the culture time, and possibly on the dose of radiation (from 1 to 3 Gy), the most frequent type of rearrangement was either dicentrics or reciprocal translocations. In first generation mitoses, the frequency of cells without rearrangement ranged from 0.66 to 0.18, and the mean number of rearranged chromosomes per cell from 0.79 to 3.28. The dose-response curve follows a quadratic function for dicentric aberration yields, but not for other rearrangements.     

The influence of anoxia or oxygenation on the induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes by 15-MeV neutrons

Dicentric and total aberration yields induced in human lymphocytes by 15-MeV neutrons under conditions of oxygenation and of anoxia have been fitted to a dose-response curve using the function Y = D + βD². An oxygen-enhancement ratio (OER) ranging from 3.7 at low yields to 1.6 at high yields was calculated from the co-efficients of the dicentric yield curves and evidence is presented which suggests that oxygen does not act as a dose-modifying agent in this system. High dose RBE values of 1.2 and 2.1 with respect to 250 kVp X-rays for oxygenated and anoxic conditions were also obtained. Coefficients for total aberration yield gave similar values to dicentrics for both OER and RBE     

Analysis of chromosome aberrations in human peripheral lymphocytes induced by in vitro α-particle irradiation

Irradiation of human lymphocytes by α-particles under different conditions has been seen to be substantially more effective in the induction of dicentric chromosomes than irradiation by ψ-rays. However, the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) determined in these studies RBE are likely to be due in part to differing exposure conditions. Therefore, a technique designed to insure iniformity of irradiation was developed in the present study, and complications due to the cell cycle kinetics were controlled. After stimulation with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA), separated lymphocytes were allowed to attach for 3 h to the thin foil bottom of an irradiation chamber. Cell monolayers were exposed with α-particles from²⁴¹Am. Strong over-dispersion was noted for the cell-to-cell variance of the number of dicentrics. The dose response of dicentrics was linear, with a yield of 0.27 dicentrics per cell and per Gy. This corresponds to a low dose RBE of 15 relative to¹³⁷Cs γ-ray exposure under the same experimental conditions.     

Apoptosis preferentially eliminates irradiated g0 human lymphocytes bearing dicentric chromosomes

G(0) human peripheral blood lymphocytes were X-irradiated to determine whether there is a direct relationship between radiation-induced dicentric chromosomes and the triggering of apoptosis. Immediately after X-ray exposure, control and irradiated lymphocytes were analyzed for viability, apoptosis and chromosome damage using the premature chromosome condensation technique. A batch of lymphocytes was kept in liquid holding for 48 h and then loaded on Ficoll-Paque medium to separate apoptotic (high-density) and normal (normal-density) cells. Then the same end points were analyzed in high-density and normal-density fractions of control and irradiated lymphocytes. After 48 h of liquid holding, the majority of apoptotic cells contained dicentric chromosomes. These results demonstrate that in human lymphocytes, the type of chromosome damage influences the induction of programmed cell death and provide direct evidence that cells bearing dicentrics are eliminated by apoptosis. G0 lymphocytes are the most common tissue used in biodosimetry studies, and the amount of chromosomal damage detected depends on the time between exposure and sampling. Since the radiation-induced apoptotic cells show the presence of dicentrics, radiation-induced damage can be underestimated. These results may have relevance in evaluations of the efficacy of radiotherapy based on the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations.     

Radiation-induced chromosomal aberrations in human lymphocytes. I. Dependence on the dose of gamma-rays and an anomaly at low doses

Cultures of human lymphocytes obtained from blood of healthy adult donors were irradiated with different doses of ⁶⁰Co γ-rays and the irradiated cells were analysed in metaphase 50 h after irradiation. The effect (total yield of abberations of chromosome type, or total yield of exchange type abberations) produced by the lowest dose (5 rad) appears to be statistically significant in a sample of 1500 cells. In the usual dose range (25–400 rad), both parabolic and linear-quadratic equations give a satisfactory fit of experimental data (dicentrics, fragments, or all aberrations of chromosome type). Low doses of γ-rays, however, produced more aberrations than expected, if one extrapolates dose-effect curves from higher doses. Both relations should be considered, therefore, merely as empirical equations. Dicentrics show at low doses (10–30 rad) a plateau which appears to be statistically significant. Some indications are obtained that the total number of chromosome-type aberrations is a more reliable criterion of cytogenetic damage than the usually accepted yeild of dicientrics and rings.