Variable region sequence analysis of anti-DNA antibodies: evidence for a family of closely related germ-line VH genes encoding lupus autoantibodies.

Cloning and sequencing of the V regions of the anti-DNA monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), H438 and H130, indicate that H438 is encoded by a J558 VH gene, a single D region nucleotide, and unmutated JH1, V kappa-1C and J kappa 1 genes, and the H130 L chain is encoded by a V kappa-21 subgroup gene J kappa 1 gene. Identification of VH438, which shared VH hybridization pattern with 6% of a panel of 352 MRL/lpr hybridomas, suggests that the frequency of J558 use among spontaneously activated B cells in MRL/lpr mice is greater than previously reported. The VHH438 J558 family gene is identical to VHPAR, which encodes the independently derived MRL/lpr autoantibody, MRP-2, and is highly homologous to the previously reported VHH130, which is identical to a BALB/c germ-line VH gene. Comparison of consensus sequences of homologous autoantibodies and previously reported restriction mapping suggest that a minimum of three highly related J558 germ-line genes encode lupus autoantibodies.     

Neonatal and adult primary B cells use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes in their (T,G)-A-L-specific repertoire

Although there is a nonrandom usage of VH gene families by primary B cells early in ontogeny, at issue is whether the preferential rearrangement of 3' germ-line VH genes, e.g., VH7183 and VHQ52 family genes, influences the neonatal B cell repertoire that can be expressed in response to Ag. In order to address this issue, and to determine whether neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line VH and V kappa genes as adult B cells in their primary response, we have analyzed at the molecular level the neonatal antibody response to (T,G)-A-L and compared it with the adult primary response. Among the TGB5 Id+, GT+ antibodies, which dominate the neonatal response to (T,G)-A-L, two VH gene families were used: J558 (high frequency) and 36-60 (low frequency). The majority of Id+ neonatal hybridomas used the same germ-line VH gene (H10, from the VHJ558 family), but with enormous diversity in the D region, and one of two germ-line V kappa 1 genes (V kappa 1A, V kappa 1C). These are the same germ-line V-genes used by most primary adult Id+ hybridomas, and the frequency of expression of this germ-line V-gene combination appears equivalent in the neonatal and adult primary repertoires. Therefore, it is clear from this study that as early as day 5, neonatal B cells can use the same germ-line V-genes as adult primary B cells in their Ag-specific repertoire.     

Direct quantitative in situ hybridization studies of Ig VH utilization. A comparison between unstimulated B cells from autoimmune and normal mice

This study examines Ig VH utilization in murine lupus with emphasis on the relative contribution of 3' and 5' gene families. We used in situ hybridization with 35S-labeled ssRNA probes to detect VH expression in individual spleen cells. Cells were taken from unmanipulated animals, and were not stimulated in vitro. This approach allows analysis of VH usage among only those B cells which have undergone activation in vivo, while minimizing the potential for skewing in vitro. We compared usage of the 3' 7183 and Q52 families with the more 5' J558 family in adult NZB, MRL-lpr/lpr, and nonautoimmune NIH Swiss mice. VH utilization in the autoimmune strains was proportionate to VH family size, and was not biased toward the 3' families when compared with the Swiss repertoire. Moreover, 3' skewing did not develop in NZB mice with increasing age. Thus, systemic autoimmunity is not associated with impaired normalization of the adult repertoire away from the 3' bias of early ontogeny. Instead, our data support a stochastic model for VH gene usage in the activated B cells and plasma cells of adult lupus mice.     

VH gene family repertoire of resting B cells. Preferential use of D-proximal families early in development may be due to distinct B cell subsets

The fetal VH gene repertoire was shown previously to be characterized by overrepresentation of D-proximal families, VH 7183 and VH Q52, compared with adult bone marrow B cells in which VH genes were expressed in a more stochastic fashion. To determine the underlying mechanisms of these findings, adult vs fetal progenitors were placed in the same supportive microenvironment and the resulting B lineage cells analyzed for VH gene family expression. The supportive microenvironment was provided by established adult bone marrow stromal cell layers. In this way the relative importance of environmental vs genetic influences could be determined. The fetal B cells and pre-B cells that developed on adult stromal cells maintained a fetal-like VH gene family repertoire with preference for D-proximal families VH 7183 and Q52. In contrast, adult cultured B cells maintained the adult-like repertoire with predominance of the largest family VH J558. Only after long-term incubation was there a change in the expression of particular VH gene families. These findings suggest that the D-proximal VH gene family preference observed early in ontogeny is associated more with the inherent genetic potential of B cell progenitors that predominate during fetal life and less with environmental influences.     

A new murine Ig VH gene family

A novel murine VH gene family, termed VH10, has been found and characterized. Based on RFLP analysis, this family exhibits extensive polymorphism among inbred strains of mice and encompasses two to five members, depending on the Igh haplotype. Analyses of recombinant inbred strains suggest a map position of this family 5' to the 7183 and Q52 VH gene families. A VH10 gene has been found to encode anti-DNA autoantibodies from lupus mice; another one may be a pseudogene.     

Ig VH gene family repertoire of plasma cells derived from lupus-prone MRL/lpr and MRL/++ mice

VH gene family usage was determined in both spontaneous, in vivo activated plasma cells and LPS-induced plasma cells from individual MRL/lpr mice by using in situ hybridization. It was found that VH gene family expression in spontaneous plasma cells varied from mouse to mouse. Some mice expressed VH families in an apparently random manner similar to that obtained with polyclonal activation. Other mice showed an exaggerated expression of particular VH gene families. VH J558 was overrepresented most frequently, but overrepresentation of VH 7183, Q52, and 36-60 was also observed. Importantly, LPS-induced VH gene family expression in these same mice displaying biased VH family usage in spontaneous plasma cells, appeared normal with no evidence for similar biases in the LPS-induced repertoire. Anti-DNA antibody concentrations and the degree of glomerulonephritis were determined for each mouse to measure the severity of disease. The level of expression of the J558 family was positively correlated with disease severity. The results suggest that the initial autoantibody response is highly diverse but becomes more restricted as the disease progresses.     

Interspersion of the VHQ52 and VH7183 gene families in the NFS/N mouse

Deletion mapping analysis has shown that members of the VH7183 and VHQ52 gene families are interspersed in the NFS/N mouse. To obtain direct evidence that members of these gene families are physically linked, an NFS/N liver library was constructed and genomic clones were analyzed for hybridization to both VHQ52 and VH7183 gene probes. Four clones were identified which contained both VHQ52 and VH7183 hybridizable restriction fragments. Two clones containing rearranged VHQ52 genes were also found to hybridize with the VH7183 gene probe. Sequence analysis of three of the VH7183-containing restriction fragments indicate that all are pseudogenes which contain interruptions at either the 5' and/or 3' ends of the VH coding region. Given the D-proximal location of at least a portion of the VHQ52 gene family relative to VH7183 in NFS/N mice, and the known correlation between D proximity and the frequency of VH gene utilization, 22 NFS/N-derived pre-B cell lines were analyzed for VHQ52 gene utilization. More than 40% of the identified H chain (VHDJH) rearrangements in this survey used members of this gene family. Furthermore, analysis of poly(A)+ RNA from NFS/N fetal liver and adult spleen also indicates preferential utilization of VHQ52 family in fetal liver. Kinetic studies show, however, that there are no changes in relative utilization throughout fetal ontogeny. The implications of these findings for the expression and randomization of the VH repertoire are discussed.     

VH gene analysis of spontaneously activated B cells in adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. J558 bias is not limited to classic lupus autoantibodies

To determine the genetic origins of lupus auto-antibodies, we analyzed the relationship between VH gene usage and auto-Ag-binding properties of 352 B cell hybridomas derived from MRL-lpr/lpr mice. The hybridomas were derived from neonatal, 1-month-old, 3-month-old, and 6-month-old mice. The experimental strategy provided that the hybridomas were monoclonal at initial evaluation, so the Ag binding and V gene frequencies of the entire population could be determined. Initially, 1032 Ig-producing hybridomas were evaluated for binding to six Ag; VH gene family use was determined in 119 anti-DNA and anti-rabbit thymus extract (RTE) antibodies (autoantibodies) and in 233 age-matched Ig that did not bind to any of the six Ag (nonbinders). Neonatal B cells, including cross-reactive IgM autoantibodies and nonbinder IgM, used relatively 3' VH genes. The majority of B cells in adult mice used VH genes of the J558 family. Although J558 use was significantly higher among the autoantibodies (anti-DNA and anti-RTE) than among the nonbinder Ig, this difference was due to a higher frequency of J558 use by 1-month-old mice. At 3 months, J558 use by the nonbinder Ig increased to the same frequency of J558 use as in the autoantibody population. J558 use in both groups of antibodies exceeded a previously reported estimation of J558 expression in the functional B cell repertoire of young adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Several subgroups of antibodies that share properties with pathogenic Ig, including IgG, cross-reactive Ig, and anti-dsDNA autoantibodies, demonstrated a marked preferential expression of the J558 family. These results suggest that there is an age-related bias in the activation of B cells using J558 VH genes in MRL-lpr/lpr mice that is under the influence of a selective force distinct from, or in addition to, an ssDNA or RTE auto-Ag-driven response.     

VH gene family utilization in colonies derived from B and pre-B cells detected by the RNA colony blot assay.

The immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region (VH) genes of the mouse have been categorized into families based upon sequence homology. Utilizing the RNA colony blot assay we have determined the expression of eight of these families in B cell colonies derived from either surface immunoglobulin positive (sIg+) adult spleen B cells or sIg- fetal liver pre-B cells. We demonstrate, based upon the analysis of greater than 6000 individual colonies, that VH gene usage is a characteristic of the mouse strain studied. C57BL/6 mice most frequently (45%) utilize family VHJ558, the largest VH family, whereas BALB/c mice most frequently (22%) utilize family VH7183, the most JH proximal family in BALB/c mice. Moreover, colonies derived from sIg- fetal liver derived precursors show similar patterns, suggesting that selection based on exogenous antigen is not an important parameter in determining VH gene family usage.     

Relationship of human variable region heavy chain germ-line genes to genes encoding anti-DNA autoantibodies

In order to identify the V region genes encoding systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)-derived anti-DNA autoantibodies, we have determined the nucleotide sequence of heavy chain mRNA from several DNA-binding immunoglobulins secreted by human hybridomas. We used the technique of cDNA primer extension for determining sequences of the VH, D, and JH gene segments of anti-DNA autoantibodies from three different primary hybridoma growths from an SLE patient and one hybridoma from a leprosy patient. Immunoglobulins from two of the SLE hybridomas expressed the same idiotype, Id-16/6, which is also expressed on immunoglobulins in sera of patients with active SLE. Their mRNA sequences showed complete homology to each other in the V, D, and J genes and more than 99% homology to the VH26 germ-line gene sequence, a member of the human VHIII gene family. The VH mRNA sequence of the third SLE hybridoma, 21/28, which was idiotypically unrelated to the other two, was 93% homologous to a different VH germ-line gene sequence, HA2, a member of the human VHI gene family. The fourth anti-DNA-producing hybridoma, 8E10, was derived from a leprosy patient of different ethnic origin than the SLE patient. It was idiotypically related to 21/28 and expressed a VH segment gene identical to that of 21/28. Hybridomas 21/28 and 8E10 shared sequence homology with the VH26 anti-DNA antibodies in the first complementarity-determining region. In addition, 21/28 shared sequence homology with the Id-16/6+ group in the region encoded by the D and J gene segments. Our findings indicate that some SLE autoantibodies are encoded by unmodified or scarcely modified VH germ-line genes that are conserved in the human population and identify two distinct VH germ-line genes that can encode segments of anti-DNA immunoglobulins.     

A rabbit antiserum detects a VH J558 subgroup marker highly expressed among anti-alprenolol antibodies

A rabbit antiserum raised against anti-alprenolol mAb 14C3 detects common antigenic determinants (ADC3) in 10 out of 14 anti-alprenolol mAb that use different germ-line VH and/or Vk genes. The anti-14C3 antiserum binds only to H chains in immunoblots, therefore suggesting that at least part of the ADC3 determinants may be encoded by H chain V region genes. Analysis of VH gene family usage among the anti-alprenolol mAb reveals that the expression of ADC3 correlates with utilization of VH genes that belong to the J558 gene family, regardless of the JH, Vk, and Jk genes. To determine whether the ADC3 determinants are general V region markers or whether they are unique to anti-alprenolol antibodies, we have extended our analysis to a random panel of antibodies that also use VH genes of the J558 family. Among 23 mAb of various specificities, 14 react with the anti-14C3 antiserum in immunoblot and in ELISA, irrespective of antibody specificity. Adsorption of the antiserum on one of these positive antibodies results in a loss of reactivity toward both anti-alprenolol and unrelated antibodies. Therefore, several but not all antibodies that use a J558 VH gene also express the complete set of epitopes defining ADC3. These results strongly suggest that ADC3 are markers of a subset of J558 VH gene products. The anti-14C3 antiserum may thus constitute a "serologic probe" for identification of a VH gene subgroup from the J558 gene family.     

Nucleotide sequences of eight human natural autoantibody VH regions reveals apparent restricted use of VH families

Eight full length cDNA were isolated from EBV transformed human PBL derived from different normal individuals. Five were derived from antibodies with the characteristics of natural polyreactive antibodies. Three were either monoreactive or bireactive. The most striking feature of the structure of these molecules was their utilization of VH families. Although three used the large VHIII family and one used the large VHI family, the other four used genes derived from two of the recently defined small human VH families VHIV and VHV. Three of the molecules represent VHIV expressed sequences and one is the first example of a VHV gene used in an antibody of defined specificity. The nucleotide sequences of some of the molecules were remarkably similar in their VH gene segments to previously described VH genes. The data suggest that natural autoantibodies may use a restricted portion of the VH repertoire, and, in addition, that some polyreactive antibodies may be germ line encoded. The implication of these findings for the origin and diversity of the human B cell repertoire is discussed.     

The Ig VH repertoire of fetal liver-derived pre-B cells is influenced by the expression of a gene linked to X-linked immune deficiency.

Ig VH repertoire differences between normal and x-linked immune deficiency- (xid) expressing mice are well established. To test the hypothesis that such differences might exist as early as the pre-B stage of ontogeny we generated panels of xid fetal liver derived Abelson murine leukemia virus transformants with H chain Ig VDJ rearrangements. Cells from CBA/Tufts.xid mice used VH genes from many families, with no demonstrable preference for 3' genes. Analysis of cells derived from (CBA/Tufts.xid X CBA/Tufts)F1 mice showed preferential usage of 3' family genes in the phenotypically normal females, even though V to DJ joins were made in vivo. The defective male mice did not show this marked preferential usage. A similar, but less marked, effect on VH gene usage was seen in mice with X-linked immune deficiency and a BALB/c background. Taken together, these results show that either X-linked immune deficiency, or a closely linked gene, affects fetal pre-B cells such that the usual pattern of predominant usage of 3' family genes is altered.     

Strain-dependent expression of VH gene families

The tremendous diversity of the antibody specificity repertoire stems from the ability of each developing B cell to select one out of many possible variable, diversity, and joining gene segments by specific rearrangement of the DNA. The mechanism by which V region gene segments is selected is not known. Moreover, evidence for both random and nonrandom expression of VH genes in mature B cells has been presented previously. In this report, the technique of in situ hybridization is used to accurately measure at the single cell level VH gene family expression in LPS-induced cells from several strains. In this way, at least one-third of the B cells are stimulated and a large sampling of activated splenocytes from each strain analyzed. The use of in situ hybridization eliminates any potential biases resulting from transformation protocols. In addition, because all populations of cells are analyzed by both in situ hybridization and immunocytochemical staining with anti-IgM, the proportion of cells detected by in situ hybridization could be compared with the proportion of B cells, blasts, and plasma cells in the population. It was concluded from these comparisons that the cells being detected by in situ hybridization under the conditions described are plasmablasts and plasma cells. Therefore, an accurate measure of the functional and expressed VH gene repertoire could be made. The results clearly demonstrate strain-dependent variation in VH gene family expression, particularly VH 7183 and VH J558 with up to three-fold differences observed. Thus, either there is considerable strain variation in the number of functional VH gene family segments or the expression of VH genes is not entirely random.     

Isotype, VH genes, and antigen-binding analysis of hybridomas from newborn normal BALB/c mice

In this study we report on the characterization of a panel of 62 hybridomas generated by fusing unstimulated spleen cells from neonatal (less than 24 hr old) normal BALB/c mice with the non-secreting Sp 2/0 cell line. The vast majority (98%) of these hybridomas secreted Ig but only 20% produced IgM. The isotype of the remaining hybridomas was determined as being IgG2b. Interestingly, when splenocytes from 1-day-old mice were stimulated with LPS for 48 h prior to the fusion event, 84% of the hybridomas were secreting IgM. The hybridoma supernatants were screened either by ELISA or RIA for binding reactivity using a panel of 17 Ag, proportionally divided between self and non-self. A binding reactivity could be assigned in 44% of cases. Of these, 29% were monoreactive, i.e., reactivity occurred with one Ag only, while the remaining 15% were multireactive. The majority (21 of 27) of hybridomas with a defined reactivity were directed against self-Ag. These included autologous red blood cells, DNA, histone H1, thyroglobulin, and Ag of the cell surface of T cells. The frequency of utilization of VH genes was determined using DNA probes for eight VH gene families. While all VH gene families appeared to have been used, one, VH 7183, had a slight but significant (p less than 0.02) higher utilization than expected by random expression. The frequency of all the other VH gene families was not significantly different from random utilization. No correlation was found between Ag reactivity in the supernatants and the utilization of a particular VH gene family. These findings indicate that early in the ontogeny the predominant reactivity of B cells is for self-Ag and, unlike what it is commonly believed, the IgM isotype is not dominant within these endogenously activated B cells at this time of ontogeny when genes from all VH families are utilized.     

Characterization of monoclonal antibodies specific for sequential influenza A/PR/8/34 virus variants

A panel of monoclonal antibodies specific for a corresponding panel of sequentially selected variants of influenza A/PR/8/34 virus has been established. Although the monoclonal antibodies are paratypically distinct, idiotypic relatedness has been observed. Two cross-reactive idiotypes have been defined that are associated with the 7183 and S107 VH gene families, respectively. Three of the four monoclonal antibodies utilize the VK21 group of light chains, and three VH genes belong to the VH7183 family and one to the VH S107 family. Antibodies encoded by genes deriving from the VH7183 family share a cross-reactive idiotype, a marker of the VH region as well as distinct individual idiotopes. These antibodies are produced by different clones using related VH and VK genes.     

Deletion mapping of Ig VH gene segments expressed in human CD5 B cell lines. JH proximity is not the sole determinant of the restricted fetal VH gene repertoire.

VH gene segments expressed in a panel of monoclonal human CD5 B cell lines have been positioned on the IgH locus by deletion mapping. The analysis yielded a relative order of VH fragments of the VH2, VH4, VH5, and VH6 gene families that was consistent with, and provided a further refinement of existing maps of the human IgH locus. We demonstrate that four of six VH gene segments expressed in the CD5 B cell lines map > 500 kb from the cluster of JH segments. Two of the gene segments, positioned at approximately 850 kb (58p2) and approximately 500 kb (1-9III) from the JH segments, respectively, belong to the previously identified small cohort of second trimester fetal VH gene segments. The data show that JH proximity is not the sole determinant of restricted VH gene utilization in early human ontogeny.     

Analysis of variable region genes encoding a human anti-DNA antibody of normal origin. Implications for the molecular basis of human autoimmune responses

In order to investigate the genetic basis for natural anti-DNA immune responses, we isolated and sequenced the variable gene elements (VH and VL) encoding an anti-DNA antibody expressed by a human hybridoma of normal origin (Kim4.6) and compared these sequences with those reported for four other human anti-DNA antibodies. The Kim4.6 antibody leader and VH segments were identical in nucleotide sequence with the VH1.9III germ-line VH3 gene, and the Kim4.6VL segment showed 98% nucleotide sequence identity with a V lambda I subgroup gene expressed in a Burkitt's lymphoma. Comparative analysis of Kim4.6 and other human hybridoma anti-DNA antibodies indicated that anti-DNA immune responses are diverse in terms of VH and VL gene utilization but may exhibit a bias toward rearrangement of VH genes that are over-represented in the fetal pre-B cell repertoire. Moreover, Kim4.6 and three of four other sequenced human anti-DNA antibodies appear to use a germ-line diversity gene, DXP'1, which may represent a counterpart of the DFL16.1 segment utilized in murine responses to the hapten nitrophenyl. Taken together, our findings indicate that anti-DNA immune responses can be encoded by nonmutated VH genes and that the elements and molecular mechanisms which engender this response are essentially the same among natural and lupus-associated anti-DNA antibodies. Our data also suggest that natural autoimmune responses originate early in B cell ontogeny as is consistent with the hypothesis that autoreactivity plays a major role in shaping the normal immune repertoire.     

VH repertoire in progeny of long term lymphoid-cultured cells used to reconstitute immunodeficient mice

VH gene utilization in the progeny of long term lymphoid-cultured cells used for reconstitution of severe combined immunodeficient mice under varying conditions was determined. Hybridomas made from the spleens of these animals were evaluated for clonality and donor origin and a panel of 146 independent hybridomas were subsequently examined for VH expression. Hybridomas derived from the spleens of SCID mice reconstituted with fresh cells, used as a control, utilized VH families in proportion to their numerical representation in the genome. However, hybridomas from the spleens of mice reconstituted with long term cultured cells utilized a predominance of the two VH gene families most proximal to JH, characteristic of cells early in B lymphocyte development. Coinjection of thymocytes with cultured fetal liver cells, to provide good levels of T lymphocytes, did not alter this pattern of VH utilization. Irradiation (3 Gy) of the mice before cultured cell injection, which leads to more complete reconstitution of the B cell compartment, was effective in removing this bias in the VH repertoire. Hybridomas derived from these mice expressed their VH genes more in proportion to family size, characteristic of cells later in B lymphocyte development. In this manner, long term lymphoid-cultured cells can be used to study the transitions that occur in VH repertoire expression which appear to be mediated by either B lymphocyte developmental microenvironment or population size.     

Individual VH genes detected with oligonucleotide probes from the complementarity-determining regions

The germ-line and expressed Ig repertoire was examined with three oligonucleotide probes from the CDR regions of VH18/2, a VH gene from the largest human VH gene family, VHIII. Each oligonucleotide probe detected small numbers of germ-line bands (1-5) under conditions in which single base differences can be detected; more than half of these bands were polymorphic. The combined results from pairs of oligonucleotides from CDR1 and CDR2 identified a single band on Southern blots, as did a probe from the 5' end of CDR2. This band contains the 18/2 germ-line gene. The nucleotide sequence of expressed VH genes that hybridized to both CDR probes or to the 5' CDR2 probe were greater than or equal to 97% homologous to 18/2 in both the framework and CDR regions. This group of closely related VH genes, the 18/2 CDR family, appears to be overexpressed. The role of polymorphisms and differential expression of individual V genes in multigenic autoimmune diseases, as well as the organization and expression of individual V genes, can be examined with pairs of oligonucleotides from CDR1 and the 3' end of CDR2, or with probes from the 5' end of CDR2.