DNA replication initiation as a key element in thymineless death

Thymine deprivation results in the loss of viability in cells from bacteria to eukaryotes. Numerous studies have identified a variety of molecular processes and cellular responses associated with thymineless death (TLD). It has been observed that TLD occurs in actively growing cells, and DNA damage and DNA recombination structures have been associated with cells undergoing TLD. We measured the loss of viability in thymine-starved cells differing in the number of overlapping replication cycles (n), and we found that the magnitude of TLD correlates with the number of replication forks. By using pulsed field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), we determined the proportion of linear DNA (DSBs) and the amount of DNA remaining in the well after treatment with XbaI (nmDNA) under thymine starvation in the absence or presence of both rifampicin (suppressing TLD) and hydroxyurea (maintaining TLD). Our results indicate that DSBs and nmDNA are induced by thymine starvation, but they do not correlate with the lethality observed in the presence of the drugs. We asked whether TLD was related to chromosomal DNA initiation. DNA labeling experiments and flow cytometric analyses showed that new initiation events were induced under thymine starvation. These new DNA replication initiation events were inhibited in the presence of rifampicin but not in the presence of hydroxyurea, indicating that TLD correlates with the induction of new initiation events in Escherichia coli. In support of this finding, cells carrying a deletion of the datA site, in which DNA initiation is allowed in the presence of rifampicin, underwent TLD in the presence of rifampicin. We propose that thymineless-induced DNA initiation generates a fraction of DNA damage and/or nmDNA at origins that is critical for TLD. Our model provides new elements to be considered when testing mammalian chemotherapies that are based on the inhibition of thymidylate synthetase.     

Sources of thymidine and analogs fueling futile damage-repair cycles and ss-gap accumulation during thymine starvation in Escherichia coli

Thymine deprivation in thyA mutant E. coli causes thymineless death (TLD) and is the mode of action of popular antibacterial and anticancer drugs, yet the mechanisms of TLD are still unclear. TLD comprises three defined phases: resistance, rapid exponential death (RED) and survival, with the nature of the resistance phase and of the transition to the RED phase holding key to TLD pathology. We propose that a limited source of endogenous thymine maintains replication forks through the resistance phase. When this source ends, forks undergo futile break-repair cycle during the RED phase, eventually rendering the chromosome non-functional. Two obvious sources of the endogenous thymine are degradation of broken chromosomal DNA and recruitment of thymine from stable RNA. However, mutants that cannot degrade broken chromosomal DNA or lack ribo-thymine, instead of shortening the resistance phase, deepen the RED phase, meaning that only a small fraction of T-starved cells tap into these sources. Interestingly, the substantial chromosomal DNA accumulation during the resistance phase is negated during the RED phase, suggesting futile cycle of incorporation and excision of wrong nucleotides. We tested incorporation of dU or rU, finding some evidence for both, but DNA-dU incorporation accelerates TLD only when intracellular [dUTP] is increased by the dut mutation. In the dut ung mutant, with increased DNA-dU incorporation and no DNA-dU excision, replication is in fact rescued even without dT, but TLD still occurs, suggesting different mechanisms. Finally, we found that continuous DNA synthesis during thymine starvation makes chromosomal DNA increasingly single-stranded, and even the dut ung defect does not completely block this ss-gap accumulation. We propose that instability of single-strand gaps underlies the pathology of thymine starvation.     

Pathways of resistance to thymineless death in Escherichia coli and the function of UvrD

Thymineless death (TLD) is the rapid loss of viability in bacterial, yeast, and human cells starved of thymine. TLD is the mode of action of common anticancer drugs and some antibiotics. TLD in Escherichia coli is accompanied by blocked replication and chromosomal DNA loss and recent work identified activities of recombination protein RecA and the SOS DNA-damage response as causes of TLD. Here, we examine the basis of hypersensitivity to thymine deprivation (hyper-TLD) in mutants that lack the UvrD helicase, which opposes RecA action and participates in some DNA repair mechanisms, RecBCD exonuclease, which degrades double-stranded linear DNA and works with RecA in double-strand-break repair and SOS induction, and RuvABC Holliday-junction resolvase. We report that hyper-TLD in uvrD cells is partly RecA dependent and cannot be attributed to accumulation of intermediates in mismatch repair or nucleotide-excision repair. These data imply that both its known role in opposing RecA and an additional as-yet-unknown function of UvrD promote TLD resistance. The hyper-TLD of ruvABC cells requires RecA but not RecQ or RecJ. The hyper-TLD of recB cells requires neither RecA nor RecQ, implying that neither recombination nor SOS induction causes hyper-TLD in recB cells, and RecQ is not the sole source of double-strand ends (DSEs) during TLD, as previously proposed; models are suggested. These results define pathways by which cells resist TLD and suggest strategies for combating TLD resistance during chemotherapies.     

The Escherichia coli mazEF suicide module mediates thymineless death

In 1954, Cohen and Barner discovered that a thymine auxotrophic (thyA) mutant of Escherichia coli undergoes cell death in response to thymine starvation. This phenomenon, called thymineless death (TLD), has also been found in many other organisms, including prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Though TLD has been studied intensively, its molecular mechanism has not yet been explained. Previously we reported on the E. coli mazEF system, a regulatable chromosomal suicide module that can be triggered by various stress conditions. MazF is a stable toxin, and MazE is an unstable antitoxin. Here, we show that cell death that is mediated by the mazEF module can also be activated by thymine starvation. We found that TLD depends on E. coli mazEF and that under thymine starvation, the activity of the mazEF promoter P(2) is significantly reduced. Our results, which describe thymine starvation as a trigger for a built-in death program, have implications for programmed cell death in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.     

Influence of Thymine Starvation on the Integrity of Deoxyribonucleic Acid in Escherichia coli

The influence of thymine starvation on the single-strand molecular weight of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) from Escherichia coli was determined by sedimentation through gradients of alkaline sucrose. Growth of cells for as long as 150 min in thymineless medium did not significantly reduce the molecular weight below the control value of 2.4 +/- 0.3 x 10(8) daltons. Incubation of cells in thymineless medium after exposure to 500 ergs/mm(2) of ultraviolet light or 20 krad of (137)Cs gamma rays did not appear to block the rejoining of single-strand breaks associated with irradiation. Thus, DNA repair enzymes, presumably including DNA ligase, are not significantly inhibited by thymine starvation.     

Mechanism of mutation by thymine starvation in Escherichia coli: clues from mutagenic specificity.

To probe the mechanisms of mutagenesis induced by thymine starvation, we examined the mutational specificity of this treatment in strains of Escherichia coli that are wild type (Ung+) or deficient in uracil-DNA-glycosylase (Ung-). An analysis of Ung+ his-4 (ochre) revertants revealed that the majority of induced DNA base substitution events were A:T----G:C transitions. However, characterization of lacI nonsense mutations induced by thymine starvation demonstrated that G:C----A:T transitions and all four possible transversions also occurred. In addition, thymineless episodes led to reversion of the trpE9777 frameshift allele. Although the defect in uracil-DNA-glycosylase did not appear to affect the frequency of total mutations induced in lacI by thymine deprivation, the frequency of nonsense mutations was reduced by 30%, and the spectrum of nonsense mutations was altered. Furthermore, the reversion of trpE9777 was decreased by 90% in the Ung- strain. These findings demonstrate that in E. coli, thymine starvation can induce frameshift mutations and all types of base substitutions. The analysis of mutational specificity indicates that more than a single mechanism is involved in the induction of mutation by thymine depletion. We suggest that deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate pool imbalances, the removal of uracil incorporated into DNA during thymine starvation, and the induction of recA-dependent DNA repair functions all may play a role in thymineless mutagenesis.     

DNA synthesis in a synchronized culture ofEscherichia coli 15 TAUbar after continuous and interrupted thymine starvation

After transfer to a thymine-containing medium the DNA synthesis did not increase with increasing intervals of thymine starvation. On the other hand, the starvation interrupted at regular intervals by 5 min thymine pulses resulted in an increased DNA synthesis. Induction of a bacteriophage which is prevented by the pulses is discussed as a possible reason for the observed difference in kinetics of the DNA synthesis following continuous and interrupted thymine starvation. Turbidity of the culture increased roughly three times, both during the continuous and the interrupted thymine starvation. The increase of the turbidity after prolonged interrupted starvation was lower than that which would correspond to the observed increase of the DNA synthesis according to the hypothesis of a critical mass of the cell resulting in the initiation (Donachie, 1968).     

Effect of Thymine Starvation on Deoxyribonucleic Acid Repair Systems of Escherichia coli K-12

Thymine starvation of Escherichia coli K-12 results in greatly increased sensitivity to ultraviolet light (UV). Our studies, using isogenic strains carrying rec and uvr mutations, have shown the following. (i) Common to all strains tested is a change from multihit to single-hit kinetics of survival to UV after 60 min of thymine starvation. However, the limiting slope of UV survival curves decreases in the rec(+)uvr(+) strain and changes very little in several rec mutant strains and one uvrB mutant strain. Thus, when either the rec or uvr system is functioning alone, the limiting slopes of the UV survival curves are relatively unaffected by thymine starvation. (ii) Thymine starvation does not significantly inhibit repair processes carried out by either repair system alone; i.e., host cell reactivation of irradiated phage (carried out by the uvr system), excision of thymine dimers (uvr), or X-ray repair (rec). (iii) In a rec(+)uvr(+) strain, repair appears to be a synergistic rather than additive function of the two systems. However, after thymine starvation, repair capacity is reduced to about the sum of the repair capacities of the independent systems. (iv) The kinetics of thymineless death are not changed by rec and uvr mutations. This indicates that the lesions responsible for thymineless death are not repaired by rec or uvr systems. (v) Withholding thymine from thy rec(+)uvr(+) bacteria not undergoing thymineless death has no effect on UV sensitivity. Under these conditions one sees higher than normal UV resistance in the presence or absence of thymine. This is due to increased repair carried out by the uvr system. To explain these results we postulate that thymine starvation does not inhibit either the rec or uvr repair pathway directly. Rather it appears that thymine starvation results in increased UV sensitivity in part by inhibiting a function which normally carries out efficient coordination of rec and uvr pathways.     

Role of RecA and the SOS Response in Thymineless Death in Escherichia coli

Thymineless death (TLD) is a classic and enigmatic phenomenon, documented in bacterial, yeast, and human cells, whereby cells lose viability rapidly when deprived of thymine. Despite its being the essential mode of action of important chemotherapeutic agents, and despite having been studied extensively for decades, the basic mechanisms of TLD have remained elusive. In Escherichia coli, several proteins involved in homologous recombination (HR) are required for TLD, however, surprisingly, RecA, the central HR protein and activator of the SOS DNA–damage response was reported not to be. We demonstrate that RecA and the SOS response are required for a substantial fraction of TLD. We show that some of the Rec proteins implicated previously promote TLD via facilitating activation of the SOS response and that, of the roughly 40 proteins upregulated by SOS, SulA, an SOS–inducible inhibitor of cell division, accounts for most or all of how SOS causes TLD. The data imply that much of TLD results from an irreversible cell-cycle checkpoint due to blocked cell division. FISH analyses of the DNA in cells undergoing TLD reveal blocked replication and apparent DNA loss with the region near the replication origin underrepresented initially and the region near the terminus lost later. Models implicating formation of single-strand DNA at blocked replication forks, a SulA-blocked cell cycle, and RecQ/RecJ-catalyzed DNA degradation and HR are discussed. The data predict the importance of DNA damage-response and HR networks to TLD and chemotherapy resistance in humans.     

dGTP Starvation in Escherichia coli Provides New Insights into the Thymineless-Death Phenomenon

Starvation of cells for the DNA building block dTTP is strikingly lethal (thymineless death, TLD), and this effect is observed in all organisms. The phenomenon, discovered some 60 years ago, is widely used to kill cells in anticancer therapies, but many questions regarding the precise underlying mechanisms have remained. Here, we show for the first time that starvation for the DNA precursor dGTP can kill E. coli cells in a manner sharing many features with TLD. dGTP starvation is accomplished by combining up-regulation of a cellular dGTPase with a deficiency of the guanine salvage enzyme guanine-(hypoxanthine)-phosphoribosyltransferase. These cells, when grown in medium without an exogenous purine source like hypoxanthine or adenine, display a specific collapse of the dGTP pool, slow-down of chromosomal replication, the generation of multi-branched nucleoids, induction of the SOS system, and cell death. We conclude that starvation for a single DNA building block is sufficient to bring about cell death.     

Thymineless death inLactobacillus acidophilus R-26

Thymineless death (TLD) was studied inLactobacillus acidophilus R-26. Thymine synthesis was inhibited with 5-fluorouracil (FU) or deoxyadenylate (dAMP) or by the absence of folic acid. In the case of FU, the maximum rate of dying was obtained at concentrations exceeding 0.1 μg/ml. This concentration did not affect the growth of the bacteria in the presence of thymine (4 μg/ml) and uracil (10 μg/ml). At higher FU concentrations up to 10 μg/ml, the course of TLD was unaltered, but the growth of bacteria in complete medium was slower. In the case of dAMP, the same course of TLD was obtained at a concentration of 150 μg/ml. If 1,500 μg dAMP/ml was used, the pre-death lag phase was shortened the rate of dying being unaltered. These concentrations of dAMP retarded the growth of bacteria even in a complete medium. If the thymine synthesis was prevented by the absence of folic acid the rate of dying was much lower than that caused by the presence of FU or dAMP. This was true even if the aminopterin was added. The authors conclude that the folic acid starvation did not inhibit completely the synthesis of thymine.     

Thymineless Death in Bacillus subtilis: Correlation Between Cell Lysis and Deoxyribonucleic Acid Breakdown

Bacillus subtilis carrying an inducible defective phage is several times more sensitive to thymineless death than a mutagenized derivative that behaves as a nonlysogen. When the integrity of the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) of both strains was examined during thymine starvation by transformation experiments, sedimentation studies, and measurements of acid-soluble DNA degradation products, it was shown that extensive DNA breakdown occurred only in the lysogenic strain. During thymine starvation of this strain, there is a progressive proclivity to lysis, followed by leakage of DNA and DNA degradation products. Such leakage was not observed in the nonlysogen. A correlation between proclivity to lysis and extensive DNA degradation is indicated.     

Detection of thymine [2+2] photodimer repair in DNA: selective reaction of KMnO4.

The specific reaction of potassium permanganate with thymine in single-stranded DNA was employed to analyze thymine [2+2] dimer repair in DNA and in DNA/peptide nucleic acid hybrid duplexes. This simple and highly sensitive chemical assay is convenient for monitoring repair of thymine dimers in oligonucleotides.     

Initiation of Deoxyribonucleic Acid Synthesis After Thymine Starvation of Bacillus subtilis

Evidence for premature initiation of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) replication after thymine starvation of Bacillus subtilis W23T(-) is presented, based on (i) increase in the number of ade(+) relative to met(+) transformants yielded by the DNA isolated from cultures after starvation (the ade(-) marker being near the origin of replication, whereas met(-) is close to the terminus), and (ii) increase in both the initial rate and final level of tritiated thymine incorporation in the presence of chloramphenicol after release from starvation. The marker ratio data agree quantitatively with the hypothesis that the initiation is induced only on one arm of each chromosome which was replicating prior to starvation.     

DNA repair and the genetic effects of thymidylate stress in yeast

Folate antagonists, such as aminopterin, methotrexate and various sulfonamides, block de novo thymidylate biosynthesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The resulting starvation for thymine nucleotides is lethal and recombinagenic in RAD wild-type strains. In this paper we report our studies of these effects in repair-deficient yeast. Antifolate treatment of various rad mutants revealed that repair defects influence the killing and recombination caused by thymidylate deprivation. Compared to a RAD wild-type strain, diploids homozygous for rad3, rad6 or rad18 were more resistant to cell killing. Thus, contrary to findings with conventional DNA-damaging agents, the lethal effects of thymidylate starvation appear to be ameliorated by certain DNA repair deficiencies. On the other hand, a rad50 strain was extremely sensitive to the antifolates. Within this series of diploids, increasing sensitivity to thymidylate starvation was accompanied by an increase in recombination frequencies. The degrees of lethality and recombination, induced by thymidylate depletion, were correlated with the severity of DNA-strand breakage in the RAD and rad50 strains. Experiments with diploids homozygous for rad52, rad54 or rad57 suggested that aborted recombination events, provoked by thymidylate deprivation, caused chromosome loss. Furthermore, the repair defects in these mutants indicated that double-strand breaks are among the lethal lesions induced by thymine nucleotide starvation. Finally, we discuss the possibility that the recombinagenicity of thymidylate stress may account for one type of acquired resistance to methotrexate in mammalian cells.     

The effect of thymine starvation on chromosomal structure of Escherichia coli JG-151

Labelled DNA extracted from control and thymine starved cells was qualitatively characterized with respect to sedimentation properties in alkaline sucrose gradients. DNA isolated from cells undergoing loss of division ability demonstrated decreasing sedimentation velocity. Sedimentation profiles of DNA extracted from cells which were starved for thymine under conditions which allowed spontaneous recovery of division ability to occur, demonstrated an increase in DNA sedimentation velocity toward normal control value. It appears that while thymine starvation can result in single strand breaks, this damage is not irreversible, for under certain conditions rejoining of the breaks can occur.     

Anucleate cell production and surface extension in a temperature-sensitive chromosome initiation mutant of Bacillus subtilis.

At 45 C, in a temperature-sensitive initiation mutant (TsB134) of Bacillus subtilis 168 Thy- tryp-, growing in a glucose-arginine minimal medium, chromosome completion occurred over a period of 80 to 90 min, after which there was no further nuclear division. Normal symmetrical cell divisions continued for a generation afterwards, so that nuclei were segregated into separate cells. During this period asymmetric divisions started to occur. Septa appeared at 25 to 30% from one end of the cell, giving a small anucleate cell and a larger nucleate cell. During inhibition of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) synthesis by thymine starvation under the restrictive conditions, asymmetrical division also occurred until there was approximately one nucleus per cell (about one generation time). Asymmetric division, giving anucleate cells, then occurred. Similar results were obtained when DNA synthesis was inhibited by nalidixic acid. After 3 h at 45 C, the rate of anucleate cell production in the presence and absence of thymine was constant at one division per 85 min per chromosome terminus present when DNA synthesis stopped. In the absence of DNA synthesis (during thymine starvation) at 35 C, growth in cell length was linear (i.e., the rate was constant), but at 45 C during thymine starvation the rate gradually increased by more than twofold. It is suggested that this was due to the establishment of new sites of growth associated with anucleate cell production. In the presence of thymine at 45 C, the rate of length extension increased by more than fourfold, which it is suggested was caused by the appearance of new growth zones as a result of chromosome termination and a contribution associated with anucleate cell production. If the mutant was incubated at 45 C for 90 min, both in the presence and absence of thymine, then anucleate cell formation could continue on restoration to 35 C in the absence of thymine...