2004 SIVB Congress Symposium Proceedings “Thinking Outside the Cell”: Plant Protoplast Technology: Status and Applications

Summary Plant protoplasts provide an enabling technology to underpin aspects of development, physiology, and genetics. Reliable procedures are available to isolate and culture protoplasts from monocotyledons and dicotyledons. Several parameters influence the topipotency of protoplasts and their derived cells, particularly the source tissue, culture medium, and environmental factors. Novel approaches to maximize the efficiency of protoplast-to-plant systems include techniques already established for animal and microbial cells, such as electrostimulation and exposure of protoplasts to surfactants and artificial respiratory gas carriers, especially perfluorochemicals and hemoglobin. Somatic hybridization by protoplast fusion is undergoing a resurgence of interest, since it enables nuclear and cytoplasmic genomes to be combined at the interspecific and intergeneric levels without prior knowledge of gene location, or involvement of recombinant DNA technology. DNA uptake into protoplasts has applications in transient and stable transformation, including the generation of transplastomic plants of commercial importance in molecular pharming. Other applications of isolated protoplasts are in studies of membrane function, cell structure, and longer-term toxicological assessments. Despite the century that has elased since protoplasts were first isolated, they still make a significant contribution to many aspects of modern plant biotechnology.     

Genetic changes induced in higher plant cells by a laser microbeam

Introducing foreign genes into higher plants has proved to be complicated, with the exception of transformation of protoplasts of some plants (Negrutiu et al. 1987). In particular, culture of protoplasts and regeneration to plants are difficult in many monocotyledonous crops. Therefore, it would be desirable to avoid extensive tissue culture by introducing cloned genes directly into cells. A laser microbeam can perforate plant cell walls, thus facilitating uptake of genes into cells.     

Environmentally Induced Changes in the Cell Walls of Tomato Leaves in Relation to Cell and Protoplast Release

Factors involved in the isolation of protoplasts from the leaves of tomato plants grown over a wide range of environmental conditions have been studied. Increases in calcium pectate in summer grown (“hard”) plants are suggested as a barrier to cell wall degradation. A one-step method involving the addition of sodium citrate to pectinase plus cellulase gives high yield of protoplasts from hard plants. Attempts to convert isolated palisade cells to protoplasts have failed. The plant culture conditions are described such that protoplasts may be isolated throughout the year using low enzyme concentrations.     

Plant protoplast technology: Current status

Robust and reproducible protoplast-to-plant systems are crucial for underpinning genetic manipulation technology involving somatic hybridisation and transformation. Novel and effective approaches for maximising the efficiency of such protoplast cultures include supplementation of media with surfactants and artificial gas carriers, such as perfluorochemicals and haemoglobin. Physical parameters, particularly electrostimulation, also enhance the development of protoplasts and protoplast-derived cells in culture. DNA uptake into protoplasts is now a routine and universally accepted procedure in plant biotechnology for introducing and evaluating both short-term (transient) and long-term (stable) expression of genes in cells and regenerated plants. Importantly, protoplast fusion overcomes pre- and post-zygotic sexual incompatibility barriers and generates novel germplasm through new nuclear-cytoplasmic combinations. In this respect, considerable progress has been made in generating somatic hybrid plants, particularly in citrus, brassicas and potato. Isolated protoplasts are also a unique single cell system for evaluating aspects of ultrastructure, genetics and physiology, with potential for the biosynthesis of novel secondary products, including commercially-important recombinant proteins (e.g. antibodies), and as systems in toxicity screening. Recent advances in protoplast technology have benefited from advances in animal and microbial cell culture, with interesting parallels existing between these systems. Further innovations will necessitate the strengthening of interdisciplinary links in these research fields and the requirement for continued dialogue and co-operation between workers with diverse but complementary skills.     

Isolation of Protoplasts from Pollen Tetrads

PRODUCTION of haploid plants by anther culture is restricted to only a few taxa¹. If protoplasts could be isolated from pollen tetrads they might behave in culture similarly to somatic cell protoplasts² and serve as the starting material for the production of haploid plants for a wide range of plant species. Such isolated microspore protoplasts might also be suitable for fusion studies in relation to somatic hybridization of plants².     

Analysis of single protoplasts and regenerated plants by PCR and RAPD technology

Summary We investigated the use of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and the associated random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD) technique in the analysis of DNA and specific genes in plant cells at different stages of regeneration in in vitro cultures. We demonstrate that both procedures can be used to differentiate reproducibly between closely related species as well as to reveal levels of DNA polymorphism in regenerated plants. We also demonstrate that both procedures, using protocols that we have developed, are applicable at all tissue culture stages, from single isolated protoplasts to regenerated plants. Possible explanations for the variation levels detected in regenerated wheat plants are advanced.     

Genetic transformation of wheat: progress during the 1990s into the Millennium

Wheat transformation technology has progressed rapidly during the past decade. Initially, procedures developed for protoplast isolation and culture, electroporation- and polyethylene glycol (PEG)-induced DNA transfer enabled foreign genes to be introduced into wheat cells. The development of biolistic (microprojectile) bombardment procedures led to a more efficient approach for direct gene transfer. More recently, Agrobacterium-mediated gene delivery procedures, initially developed for the transformation of rice, have also been used to generate transgenic wheat plants. This review summarises the considerable progress in wheat transformation achieved during the last decade. An increase in food production is essential in order to sustain the increasing world population. This could be achieved by the development of higher yielding varieties with improved nutritional quality and tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses. Although conventional breeding will continue to play a major role in increasing crop yield, laboratory-based techniques, such as genetic transformation to introduce novel genes into crop plants, will be essential in complementing existing breeding technologies. A decade ago, cereals were considered recalcitrant to transformation. Since then, a significant research effort has been focused on cereals because of their agronomic status, leading to improved genetic transformation procedures (Bommineni and Jauhar 1997). Initially, the genetic transformation of cereals relied on the introduction of DNA into protoplasts and the subsequent production of callus from which fertile plants were regenerated. More recently, major advances have been accomplished in the regeneration of fertile plants from a range of source tissues, providing an essential foundation for the generation of transgenic plants. This review summarises procedures, vectors and target tissues used for transformation, high-lights the limitations of current approaches and discusses future trends. The citation of references is limited, where possible, to the most relevant or recent reports.     

DEVELOPMENTAL STUDIES IN PORPHYRA (RHODOPHYCEAE). III. EFFECT OF CULTURE CONDITIONS ON WALL REGENERATION AND DIFFERENTIATION OF PROTOPLASTS1

Protoplasts isolated from thalli of four Porphyra species regenerated successfully into differentiated plantlets. The efficiency of protoplast isolation and the developmental patterns of the regenerating protoplasts depended on the type of tissues from which they were isolated. However, culture conditions greatly influenced the patterns of development at the cellular and organismal levels. Sorbitol, nitrogen, and agar concentration in the medium controlled rates of cell division, thickening of cell walls, development of rhizoids, and formation of calluses or differentiated blades. Agitation disturbed the attachment of the protoplasts to a substrate. Cells in agitated cultures produced suspensions of single cells and non-polarized small calluses. Calluses which developed from protoplasts survived in storage for over two years. The stored calluses, and cells and protoplasts that were isolated from them, were subcultured successfully. We forsee extensive use of Porphyra cell suspensions for strain selection and vegetative propagation of cultivars. This technology, which makes vegetative cloning of selected Porphyra plants possible, may eliminate the need for cultivation and storage of the conchocelis phase. Protoplasts are also being used as tools for studies in genetic engineering of these commercial species.     

Plant Regeneration from Supersweet Maize Protoplasts Derived from Gametophytic Cell Suspensions

Plant regeneration from protoplasts isolated from haploid cell suspensions of commercial supersweet maize (SS 7700) was achieved and the plants were survival after transfer into soil in pots. Protoplast plating efficiency obtained from feeder layer system was 130 folds higher as compared with conventional liquid culture method, the composition of protoplast culture medium, the pore size of supportive membrane filter and the relationship between protoplasts and feeder cells were critical for callus formation. An enriched medium containing vitamins, organic acids, amino-acids and other organic substances such as coconut water could extremely improve callus formation. Filters with pore size within the range of 0.22–8.0 μm in diameter was useful. Filters with smaller pore size of 0.04 μm or larger 11 μm appeared to decrease the frequency of protocolony formation. The feeder cells which belong to the same species (Zea mays) as protoplasts greatly increased protoplast plating efficiencies as compared to those of feeder cells belonging to other species such as Avena nuda and Nicotiana tabacum. Among 11 protoplast-regenerated plants examined, 10 plants were haploid and one plant was diploid.     

Stably transformed callus of wheat by electroporation-induced direct gene transfer

Fertile plants of wheat have been regenerated from protoplasts in several laboratories. The objective of this study was to develop a transformation system using protoplasts as target cells. Protoplasts were isolated from cell suspensions initiated from an anther-derived callus. The protoplasts were transformed by electroporation using pBARGUS or pBAS, both carrying the Basta resistance (BAR) gene. A total of 2,761 calli were produced from electroporation transformed protoplasts in 3 independent experiments. Six calli survived selective culture on 10 mg/l phosphinothricin (PPT), a concentration that completely inhibited the growth of non-transformed wheat callus. Five PPT resistant calli showed phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (PAT) activity, whereas the sixth probably was a mutant. The transformed wheat calli could tolerate PPT concentrations up to 2,560 mg/l. Southern blot analyses confirmed the integration of the BAR gene in wheat genomes. The integrated DNA sequence may have partially methylated and tandemly repeated at least once. These results demonstrate the production of stably transformed wheat calli by electroporation-mediated direct gene transfer into protoplasts.     

Seaweed protoplasts: status,biotechnological perspectives and needs

Protoplasts are living plant cells without cell walls which offer a unique uniform single cell system that facilitates several aspects of modern biotechnology, including genetic transformation and metabolic engineering. Extraction of cell wall lytic enzymes from different phycophages and microbial sources has greatly improved protoplast isolation and their yield from a number of anatomically more complex species of brown and red seaweeds which earlier remained recalcitrant. Recently, recombinant cell wall lytic enzymes were also produced and evaluated with native ones for their potential abilities in producing viable protoplasts from Laminaria. Reliable procedures are now available to isolate and culture protoplasts from diverse groups of seaweeds. To date, there are 89 species belonging to 36 genera of green, red and brown seaweeds from which successful protoplast isolation and regeneration has been reported. Of the total species studied for protoplasts, most belonged to Rhodophyta with 41 species (13 genera) followed by Chlorophyta and Phaeophyta with 24 species each belonging to 5 and 18 genera, respectively. Regeneration of protoplast-to-plant system is available for a large number of species, with extensive literature relating to their culture methods and morphogenesis. In the context of plant genetic manipulation, somatic hybridization by protoplast fusion has been accomplished in a number of economically important species with various levels of success. Protoplasts have also been used for studying foreign gene expression in Porphyra and Ulva. Isolated protoplasts are also exploited in numerous miscellaneous studies involving membrane function, cell structure, bio-chemical synthesis of cell walls etc. This article briefly reviews the status of various developments in seaweed protoplasts research and their potentials in genetic improvement of seaweeds, along with needs that must to be fulfilled for effective realization of the objectives envisaged for protoplast research.     

Influence of primary callus induction conditions on the establishment of barley cell suspensions yielding regenerable protoplasts

Summary With the aim of the development of a culture method for efficient plant regeneration from barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) protoplasts, we examined several culture conditions for primary calli from immature embryos of cvs. Dissa and Igri, which were used for initiation of cell suspensions. Among the primary callus culture conditions tested, growth condition of donor plants had a great impact on these efficiencies; Igri protoplasts derived from embryos of plants grown in a greenhouse gave rise to albino plants and few green shoots while several cell lines originating from embryos of plants grown in a growth chamber (16h light, 12°C) yielded protoplasts developing into green plants. In contrast, cell suspensions were produced at higher frequencies from calli derived from embryos of greenhouse-grown Dissa plants. In Igri, increased levels of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyaceticacid (2,4-D) significantly reduced the efficiency of cell suspension establishment and plant regeneration from protoplasts was achieved only with suspension cells derived from calli induced at the lowest level (2.5 mg/l), while the effect of the 2,4-D concentration was not clear in Dissa. The developmental stage of immature embryos also affected the efficiency of cell suspension establishment, and the optimal embryo size was determined to be approximately 1mm in diameter. These results demonstrate the importance of callus induction conditions for successful barley protoplast culture.     

Experession and integration of genes introduced into highly synchronized plant protoplasts

Summary Chimaeric genes containing the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) coding sequence were introduced into protoplasts of suspension-cultured tobacco cells using improved conditions of electroporation (Okada et al. 1986). CAT activity became detectable in the protoplasts within 3 h, was maximal during a period of 18–36 h after electroporation, and then declined gradually. Alpha-amanitin added to the medium abolished the transient expression of the CAT gene. The closed circular form of input DNA was as effective as the linear form for the transient expression. The suspension culture was treated with aphidicolin, and S, G₂, M and G₁ phases were identified in the highly synchronized cell cycle obtained by releasing the cells from the inhibition of DNA synthesis. When a chimacric CAT gene was introduced into M phase protoplasts prepared from the synchronized culture, the transient expression of the CAT gene was 3–4 times higher than when it was introduced into protoplasts of other cell cycle phases. The frequency of stable transformation with a chimaeric neomycin phosphotransferase II gene was studied using the same system. G-418-resistant transformants were obtained from M phase protoplasts at frequencies 2–8 times those obtained from protoplasts at other cell cycle phases. The results indicate that the absence of the nuclear membrane in mitotic cells favours delivery to the nucleus of exogenous DNA introduced into the cytoplasm.     

Direct DNA transfer to plant cells

A range of somatic cell and molecular techniques are now available to supplement conventional plant breeding. The introduction and expression of foreign DNA has been used to modify basic aspects of physiology and development, to introduce commercially important characteristics such as herbicide and insect resistance into plants and to insert genes suitable as dominant selectable markers for somatic hybridisation. Several techniques for direct DNA delivery are available, ranging from uptake of DNA into isolated protoplasts mediated by chemical procedures or electroporation, to injection and the use of high-velocity particles to introduce DNA into intact tissues. Direct DNA uptake is applicable to both stable and transient gene expression studies and utilises a range of vectors, including those employed for gene cloning. Although the frequency of stable transformation is low, direct DNA uptake is applicable to those plants not amenable to Agrobacterium transformation, particularly monocotyledons.     

Somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration from protoplasts isolated from embryogenic cell suspensions of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

We describe the early formation of somatic embryos followed by plant regeneration from protoplasts isolated from an embryogenic wheat cell suspension, which was initiated from small granular (0.2 to 1 mm in size) embryogenic calli. These granular calli formed embryogenic cell suspensions within 20 days in liquid culture, and were selected gradually from young inflorescence-derived nodular embryogenic calli of the winter wheat cv. Kehong 1041. The division frequency of protoplasts was 11 to 16%, and the frequency of differentiation into plants was about 0.001% (number of plants formed divided by the total number of protoplasts plated). About 20% of somatic embryos present in the culture formed directly from protoplast-derived cells within 15 days of cultures.     

Analysis of the initial stages of plant protoplast development using 33258 Hoechst: reactivation of the cell cycle

A microfluorimetric procedure, employing the fluorescent stain 33258 Hoechst, has been developed for the investigation of the process of DNA synthesis during the initial stages of culture of tobacco ( N. tabacum cv. Xanthi) leaf protoplasts.
In this system, the freshly-isolated protoplasts exhibited a unimodal distribution of nuclear DNA content characteristic of the diploid state. The almost immediate onset of DNA synthesis during culture resulted in a doubling of nuclear DNA levels prior to the first mitoses. Although the majority of the protoplasts subsequently entered into synchronous mitosis and cell division, a proportion of the remainder developed into large polyploid cells. Upon further culture, the polyploid cells became subdivided into clusters of small diploid cells. Measurement of total cell protein and cell volumes during culture indicated that a relationship existed between these parameters and the initiation of mitosis. The significance of these observations is discussed.     

Microtubule organization and cell division in embryogenie protoplast cultures of white spruce (Picea glauca)

Summary Immunofluorescence methods were developed for examining the distribution of microtubules in freshly isolated and cultured protoplasts and regenerated somatic embryos of white spruce (Picea glauca). Freshly isolated protoplasts consisted of both uniand multinucleate types. Uninucleate protoplasts established parallel cortical microtubules during cell wall formation and cell shaping, divided within 24 h and developed into somatic embryos in culture. Dividing cells were characterized by preprophase bands (PPBs) of microtubules, atypical spindle microtubules focused at the poles and a typical phragmoplast at telophase. Multinucleate protoplasts also established parallel arrays of cortical microtubules during cell wall formation. In addition their nuclei divided synchronously within 4 days, then cell walls formed between the daughter nuclei. Individual multinucleate protoplast-derived colonies subsequently gave rise to elongate suspensor cells thereby forming embryo-like structures by 7 days.     

Expanding the Symbiodinium (Dinophyceae,Suessiales) Toolkit Through Protoplast Technology

Dinoflagellates within the genus Symbiodinium are photosymbionts of many tropical reef invertebrates, including corals, making them central to the health of coral reefs. Symbiodinium have therefore gained significant research attention, though studies have been constrained by technical limitations. In particular, the generation of viable cells with their cell walls removed (termed protoplasts) has enabled a wide range of experimental techniques for bacteria, fungi, plants, and algae such as ultrastructure studies, virus infection studies, patch clamping, genetic transformation, and protoplast fusion. However, previous studies have struggled to remove the cell walls from armored dinoflagellates, potentially due to the internal placement of their cell walls. Here, we produce the first Symbiodinium protoplasts from three genetically and physiologically distinct strains via incubation with cellulase and osmotic agents. Digestion of the cell walls was verified by a lack of Calcofluor White fluorescence signal and by cell swelling in hypotonic culture medium. Fused protoplasts were also observed, motivating future investigation into intra‐ and inter‐specific somatic hybridization of Symbiodinium. Following digestion and transfer to regeneration medium, protoplasts remained photosynthetically active, regrew cell walls, regained motility, and entered exponential growth. Generation of Symbiodinium protoplasts opens exciting, new avenues for researching these crucial symbiotic dinoflagellates, including genetic modification.     

Protoplast regeneration from gametophytes and sporophytes of some species in the order Laminariales (Phaeophyceae)

Summary Protoplasts were isolated from sporophytes and from gametophyte cultures of several species in the order Laminariales. For each example, the isolation and culture procedures were investigated systematically, to identify conditions leading to plant regeneration. After dedifferentiation through a filamentous stage, protoplasts isolated from adultLaminaria saccharina sporophytes regenerated polystichous bladelets. In contrast, cells isolated fromLaminaria digitata sporophytes proved recalcitrant in culture, except when the donor plants were undifferentiated sporelings. The most critical factors for protoplast development were the origin of explants, the osmoticum used for cell isolation, cultivation in plain seawater, and the absence of stress during the first two weeks of culture. We also found that protoplast isolation from the sporophytes of members of the Laminariales results in the release of hydrogen peroxide, up to 5–120 μM final concentration in the macerating medium, a characteristic which may be related to protoplast recalcitrance. Protoplasts isolated from the gametophytic phase readily regenerated into normal gametophytes, capable of gametogenesis and producing sporophytes by fertilization.     

Regeneration of Fertile Barley Plants from Mechanically Isolated Protoplasts of the Fertilized Egg Cell

A simple procedure is described for the mechanical isolation of protoplasts of unfertilized and fertilized barley egg cells from dissected ovules. Viable protoplasts were isolated from ~75% of the dissected ovules. Unfertilized protoplasts did not divide, whereas almost all fertilized protoplasts developed into microcalli. These degenerated when grown in medium only. When cocultivated with barley microspores undergoing microspore embryogenesis, the protoplasts of the fertilized egg cells developed into embryo-like structures that gave rise to fully fertile plants. On average, 75% of cocultivated protoplasts of fertilized egg cells developed into embryo-like structures. Fully fertile plants were regenerated from ~50% of the embryo-like structures. The isolation-regeneration techniques may be largely genotype independent, because similar frequencies were obtained in two different barley varieties with very different performance in anther and microspore culture. Protoplasts of unfertilized and fertilized eggs of wheat were isolated by the same procedure, and a fully fertile wheat plant was regenerated by cocultivation with barley microspores.