Plasmids in avirulent strains of Agrobacterium.

Twelve strains of Agrobacterium radiobacter isolated from naturally occurring crown galls or soil were found to be avirulent on sunflower, tomato, Kalanchoe, and carrot. Eleven strains contained plasmids of molecular weights 77 X 10(6) to 182 X 10(6) as determined by electron microscopy. One strain contained only a smaller plasmid (50 X 10(6) daltons). Several strains had both large and small (ca. 11 X 10(6) daltons) plasmids; one strain contained two large plasmids (112 X 10(6) and 136 X 10(6) daltons). Hybridization reactions of virulence plasmids from Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains C58 and A6 with plasmids from each of the A. radiobacter strains revealed that some A. radiobacter plasmids had less than 10% homology to either the C58 or A6 plasmids. Plasmids from some strains had approximately 50% homology with the C58 plasmid, but only one A. radiobacter plasmid contained more than 10% homology to the A6 plasmid. The presence of large plasmids in A. radiobacter strains did not correlate with sensitivity to agrocin 84; however, the utilization of the amino acid derivatives octopine and nopaline was generally correlated to partial base sequence homology to the C58 plasmid. We conclude that all large plasmids found in Agrobacterium strains are not virulence associated, although they may share base sequence homology with a virulence-associated plasmid. Further, plasmids from tumorigenic strains may be more closely related by base sequence homology to plasmids from nonpathogenic strains than to plasmids from other pathogenic strains.     

Rp4 Promotion of Transfer of a Large Agrobacterium Plasmid Which Confers Virulence

Introduction of RP4 plasmid into Agrobacterium tumefaciens promotes the transfer on solid medium of large virulence-associated plasmids from virulent donor strains to a plasmidless avirulent recipient. Exconjugants were selected for the ability to utilize octopine or nopaline as the sole source of arginine, traits which are coded for by virulence-associated plasmids in the strains employed here. All exconjugants retained the arginine auxotrophy of the recipient strain, and were resistant to ampicillin and kanamycin, drugs to which RP4 confers resistance. Five exconjugant clones from one cross were shown by alkaline sucrose gradient analysis to contain both RP4 plasmid and the large virulence-associated plasmid of the donor strain. All five exconjugants exhibited virulence on carrot, sunflower and kalanchoe plants. These results indicate that virulence and the ability to degrade octopine are plasmid-borne traits in A. tumefaciens strains 15955 and A6, and extend the evidence that large plasmids in A. tumefaciens are vectors of virulence genes.     

Dynamic structure of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmids.

Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58F is a variant of strain C58 which generates a high proportion of avirulent mutants in the presence of the virulence (vir) gene inducer acetosyringone. These mutants are altered in the Ti plasmid and do not respond to the acetosyringone signal (C. Fortin, E. W. Nester, and P. Dion, J. Bacteriol. 174:5676-5685, 1992). The physical organization of the Ti plasmid was compared in strain C58 and its variant. One feature distinguishing pTiC58F from its parent plasmid was the presence of the insertion element IS426. Three copies of this element were detected in the strain C58 chromosome, whereas two additional copies were found in strain C58F, including one copy in the Ti plasmid. This particular copy of IS426 was associated with the region of arginine and nopaline catabolism of pTiC58F. Most of the avirulent mutants recovered following growth of strain C58F in the presence of acetosyringone were complemented by clones carrying either virA or virG. Element IS426 was no longer found in the arginine and nopaline catabolism region of the Ti plasmids from the virA and virG mutants, but it resided in the particular KpnI fragment containing the modified vir locus. Behavior of a strain C58F derivative, which was inactivated in a chromosomal component required for the response to acetosyringone, was consistent with the possibility that vir gene induction is essential to the massive production of avirulent mutants.     

Reexamining the role of the accessory plasmid pAtC58 in the virulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain C58

Isogenic strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens carrying pTiC58, pAtC58, or both were constructed and assayed semiquantitatively and quantitatively for virulence and vir gene expression to study the effect of the large 542-kb accessory plasmid, pAtC58, on virulence. Earlier studies indicate that the att (attachment) genes of A. tumefaciens are crucial in the ability of this soil phytopathogen to infect susceptible host plants. Mutations in many att genes, notably attR and attD, rendered the strain avirulent. These genes are located on pAtC58. Previous work also has shown that derivatives of the wild-type strain C58 cured of pAtC58 are virulent as determined by qualitative virulence assays and, hence, pAtC58 was described as nonessential for virulence. We show here that the absence of pAtC58 in pTiC58-containing strains results in reduced virulence but that disruption of the attR gene does not result in avirulence or a reduction in virulence. Our studies indicate that pAtC58 has a positive effect on vir gene induction as revealed by immunoblot analysis of Vir proteins and expression of a PvirB::lacZ fusion.     

Multiple genes coding for octopine-degrading enzymes in Agrobacterium.

Most biotype 2 strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens and A. radiobacter which utilize nopaline also degrade octopine. In all such strains studied, the ability to degrade octopine did not appear to be transferred to plasmidless recipient cells under conditions of plasmid transfer in which the ability to utilize nopaline was transferred. An octopine-degrading mutant was isolated in a strain cured of its plasmid, suggesting that genes of octopine degradation may have a chromosomal location in some strains. In strains in which octopine utilization is coded by plasmid genes, octopine degradation was always inducible, whereas in strains which degrade both octopine and nopaline, octopine utilization was constitutive although nopaline degradation was inducible. When plasmids coding for octopine-utilizing ability were transformed into a strain containing either a nopaline- or null-type plasmid, transformants able to degrade octopine were either not observed or were unstable upon purification. All of these data suggest that plasmids associated with virulence are incompatible with one another, and therefore imply that the major groups of plasmids associated with virulence have a common origin.     

Evidence for diverse types of large plasmids in tumor-inducing strains of Agrobacterium.

Homology between the large plasmids of 15 pathogenic Agrobacterium strains isolated from various parts of the world has been measured and was found to vary over a wide range, from 3 to 100%. Two genetically distinct groups of plasmids can be identified: one closely related to the plasmid of A. tumefaciens A6, an octopine-utilizing strain, and the other closely related to the plasmid of A. tumefaciens C-58, a nopaline-utilizing strain. The plasmids of four Agrobacterium strains do not belong to either group. One of these four strains utilizes octopine, one utilizes nopaline, and two utilize neither. Three strains contained two large plasmids. In one of these strains, the two plasmids were not homologous to one another. Chromosomal homologies for the Agrobacterium strains surveyed also vary over a wide range, but do not correlate with plasmid homologies. Neither do plasmid homologies correlate with any numerical classification scheme. The significance of these plasmid homology studies for crown gall tumorigenesis is considered.     

Isolation and genetic analysis of an Agrobacterium tumefaciens avirulent mutant with a chromosomal mutation produced by transposon mutagenesis.

A transposon 5 (Tn5) insertion was introduced into the genome of A. tumefaciens (A-208 strain harboring a nopaline type Ti-plasmid) using a conjugative pJB4JI plasmid containing Tn5. Five thousand transconjugants were assayed for virulence on carrot (Daucus carota L.) disks; 54 isolates were avirulent or very attenuated. The cellular localization (plasmid or chromosome) of the Tn5 insertion in those isolates were identified by Southern hybridization analysis. An avirulent mutant (B-90 strain) with the Tn5 insertion in the chromosome was selected and characterized. The mutant had the same growth rate as that of the parent strain in L-broth. The mutant and the parent strain had similar attachment ability to carrot root cells. Tn5 was inserted into one site of the chromosome. The wild-type target chromosomal region (1281 base pairs) was cloned and sequenced. An open reading frame (ORF) consisting of 395 base pairs was identified. The wild-type DNA fragment (1.6 kb) containing the ORF introduced into B-90 strain complemented the avirulent phenotype of the strain. A soluble protein was predicted from the ORF. The Tn5 was inserted near the 3'-terminal of the ORF. Homology search of this ORF found no significant homology to known genes and proteins. Thus, the ORF identified in this paper seems to be a new chromosomal virulence gene of A. tumefaciens.     

VirD2 gene product from the nopaline plasmid pTiC58 has at least two activities required for virulence.

Virulence genes virD1 and virD2 are required for T-DNA processing in Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The regions within virD2 contributing to T-DNA processing and virulence were investigated. Some insertional mutations in virD2 prevented T-DNA border endonucleolytic cleavage and produced an avirulent phenotype. However, a non-polar insertion immediately after bp 684 of the 1344 bp open reading frame of virD2 did not inhibit endonucleolytic cleavage but still caused a loss of virulence. This suggested that in addition to T-DNA border cleaving activity, the VirD2 protein has another virulence function which resides in the C-terminal half of the protein. Comparative nucleotide sequence analyses of virD2 showed that the first 684 bp were 81% homologous to virD2 of an octopine Ti plasmid whereas the remaining 660 bp were only 44% homologous. A plasmid containing the virD region from octopine Ti plasmid could restore both virulence and processing to a nopaline virD2 mutant. No complementation resulted when a nopaline virD2 clone containing a region similar to eukaryotic nuclear envelope transport sequences was deleted from the 3' end. These results suggest that virD1 and only the first half of virD2 are required to encode for the T-DNA processing endonuclease, and that the 3'-half of virD2 encodes a function separate from endonuclease activity that is required for virulence.     

An Agrobacterium virulence factor encoded by a Ti plasmid gene or a chromosomal gene is required for T-DNA transfer into plants

Mutagenesis of the vir region on the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens revealed a new locus, virJ , that is induced by the plant-wound signal molecule, acetosyringone (AS). virJ lies between virA and virB , and is transcribed in the same direction. The amino acid sequence of virJ is similar to a region of a previously characterized chromosomal gene, acvB , required for virulence. virJ can complement the avirulent phenotype of an acvB mutant, indicating that virJ and acvB encode the same factor required for tumorigenesis. Southern analysis revealed that virJ is present on the Ti plasmid of an octopine but not a nopaline strain whereas acvB is present on the chromosomes of both octopine and nopaline strains. While virJ is regulated by AS under the control of the virA/virG two-component regulatory system, acvB is not induced by AS. VirJ possesses a putative signal peptide and was found predominantly in the periplasmic fraction. The strain lacking both acvB and virJ had an impaired ability to transfer T-DNA into plant cells, suggesting that the factor encoded by virJ or acvB is required for T-DNA transfer from A. tumefaciens to plant cells. acvB is the first chromosomal gene implicated in T-DNA transfer, but whether it functions specifically for this process is not clear. We hypothesize that virJ evolved from acvB , presumably for a more specialized role in tumorigenesis.     

Transport of nonmetabolizable opines by Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

We have examined the uptake of [14C]octopine and [14C]nopaline by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains containing the C58 chromosomal background in medium suitable for the induction of vir genes. All strains tested could transport both of these opines, regardless of the presence or type of Ti plasmid (octopine or nopaline) present in the bacterium. The transport of these opines required active cellular metabolism. Nonradioactive octopine, nopaline, and arginine competed effectively with [14C]octopine and [14C]nopaline for transport into A. tumefaciens A136, suggesting that the transport of these opines occurs via an arginine transport pathway not encoded by the Ti plasmid.     

Ti plasmid-specified chemotaxis of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58C1 toward vir-inducing phenolic compounds and soluble factors from monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous plants.

Twelve phenolic compounds with related structures were analyzed for their ability to act as chemoattractants for Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58C1 and as inducers of the Ti plasmid virulence operons. The results divided the phenolic compounds into three groups: compounds that act as strong vir inducers and are chemoattractants for A. tumefaciens C58C1 harboring the nopaline Ti plasmid pDUB1003 delta 31, but not the isogenic cured strain; compounds that are at best weak vir inducers and are weak chemoattractants for Ti plasmid-harboring and cured A. tumefaciens C58C1; and compounds that are vir noninducers and are also nonattractants. A strong correlation between vir-inducing ability and Ti plasmid requirement for chemotaxis is thus established. In addition, chemical structure rules for vir induction and chemotaxis are outlined. Positive chemotaxis toward root and shoot homogenates from monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous plants was observed. At low extract concentrations, chemotaxis was enhanced by the presence of Ti plasmid. The chemoattractants do not derive from intact cell walls. Lack of attraction is not responsible for the apparent block to monocot transformation by A. tumefaciens.     

Growth inhibition and loss of virulence in cultures of Agrobacterium tumefaciens treated with acetosyringone.

Acetosyringone, a phenolic inducer of the virulence (vir) genes of Agrobacterium tumefaciens, inhibited the growth of the nopaline-type strains T37 and C58 incubated under acidic conditions. In the course of a 6-day incubation with acetosyringone, avirulent clones were produced in different proportions by strains T37 and C58 and also by a spontaneous variant of strain C58, denominated C58F. The proportion of avirulent clones in acetosyringone-treated cultures often exceeded 50% for strains T37 and C58F and was of the order of 1% for strain C58. Control cultures not exposed to acetosyringone did not yield avirulent clones. Two other vir inducers, sinapinic acid and syringaldehyde, also inhibited growth and promoted accumulation of avirulent clones in cultures of strains C58F and T37. On the other hand, various acetosyringone analogs reported not to induce the vir genes did not act as growth inhibitors. All of the T37 and most of the C58F avirulent clones examined still carried a Ti plasmid. In all instances examined, avirulent clones still carrying a Ti plasmid were mutated in this plasmid. Mutants of strain C58F lacked the capacity to induce a virB::lacZ fusion in the presence of acetosyringone.     

Isolation of a non-tumor-inducing mutant of the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain B6.

A nonpathogenic mutant of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain B6 was isolated and its properties compared with the parental strain in an effort to localize the mutation. Both B6 and its mutant (B6-95) had similar colony color and morphology, were ketolactose positive, utilized octopine, and contained plasmid DNA. Kinetic analysis of DNA reannealing showed that total DNA homology and plasmid DNA homology between B6 and B6-95 was at least 90%. The length of both plasmids was found to be 58 micrometer. Plasmid DNA from both B6 and the mutant was digested with endonucleases and the fragments separated by agarose gel electrophoresis. In all cases the pattern for B6 was identical with that of B6(-95). The Ti plasmid from B6 and the mutant was transferred to an avirulent, plasmidless strain of A. tumefaciens by in vitro conjugation and transformation. All of the B6 transconjugants and transformants were virulent, whereas all of the mutant transconjugants and transformants were avirulent. Electrophoretic patterns of endonuclease-digested plasmid DNA from transformants were identical to those of plasmid DNA from B6. Therefore, we conclude that the virulence mutation lies on the Ti plasmid.     

Transfer of the Ti plasmid from Agrobacterium tumefaciens into Escherichia coli cells

We have screened strains of Agrobacterium tumefaciens for spontaneous mutants showing constitutive transfer of the nopaline Ti plasmid pTiC58 during conjugation. The Ti plasmid derivatives obtained could be transferred not only to A. tumefaciens but also to E. coli cells. The Ti plasmid cannot survive as a freely replicating plasmid in E. coli, but it can occasionally integrate into the E. coli chromosome. However, insertion in tandem of plasmids carrying fd replication origins (pfd plasmids) into the T-DNA provides an indicator for all transfer events into E. coli cells, providing fd gene 2 protein is present in these cells. This viral protein causes the excision of one copy of the pfd plasmid and allows its propagation in the host cell. By using this specially designed Ti plasmid, which was also made constitutive in transfer functions, we found plasmid exchange among A. tumefaciens strains and between A. tumefaciens and E. coli cells to be equally efficient. A Ti plasmid with repressed transfer functions was transferred to E. coli with a rate similar to the low frequency at which it was transferred to A. tumefaciens. The expression of transfer functions of plasmid RP4 either in A. tumefaciens or in E. coli did not increase the transfer of the Ti plasmid into E. coli cells, nor did the addition of acetosyringone, an inducer of T-DNA transfer to plant cells. The results show that A. tumefaciens can transfer the Ti plasmid to E. coli with the same efficiency as within its own species. Conjugational transmission of extrachromosomal DNA like the narrow-host-range Ti plasmid may often not only occur among partners allowing propagation of the plasmid, but also on a 'try-all' basis including hosts which do not replicate the transferred DNA.     

Ti plasmid and chromosomal ornithine catabolism genes of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58.

The pTiC58 plasmid noc genes of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58 code for nopaline oxidase (nocC), nopaline permease (nocP), the inducible periplasmic protein n1 (nocB), and a function(s) required for ornithine catabolism (nocA). In addition, strains C58 and Ach-5 of A. tumefaciens have chromosomal ornithine catabolism genes. The chromosomal orc gene codes for ornithine dehydrogenase. Strain C58 is normally orc, but orc+ mutants can be selected. We have characterized both chromosomal orc and pTiC58 nocA plasmid genes. Complementation of most chromosomal orc mutants by pTiC58 restored growth on both nopaline and L-ornithine but did not restore ornithine dehydrogenase activity. We conclude that ornithine is an intermediate of nopaline degradation and that the Ti plasmid and chromosome both code for ornithine-degradative enzymes. A model for nopaline catabolism is presented.     

Changes in properties of phytopathogenic bacteria effected by plasmid pRD1

Transfer of plasmid pRD1 from Escherichia coli K12J62-1 to phytopathogenic bacteria, Agrobacterium tumefaciens, Xanthomonas beticola and Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora caused changes in conjugant properties not determined by the plasmid and the emergence of the properties not present in the parent strains. Clones have been obtained with intermediate properties between donor and recipient, including those with altered or lost virulence. In transconjugants of A. tumefaciens virulence increased. In transconjugants of X. beticola and E. carotovora subsp. carotovora highly virulent as well as avirulent forms have been observed. The loss of virulence in X. beticola correlated with the Nif^* phenotype. Plasmid pRD1 also affected the biochemical properties of the new hosts.     

Overexpression of virD1 and virD2 genes in Agrobacterium tumefaciens enhances T-complex formation and plant transformation.

The VirD1 and VirD2 proteins encoded by an inducible locus of the virulence (vir) region of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmid are required for site-specific nicking at T-DNA border sites. We have determined the nucleotide sequence of a 3.6-kilobase-pair fragment carrying the virD locus from nopaline Ti plasmid pTiC58. In contrast to the previous report (Hagiya et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82:2669-2673, 1985), we found that the first three open reading frames were capable of encoding polypeptides of 16.1, 49.7, and 21.4 kilodaltons. Deletion analysis demonstrated that the N-terminal conserved domain of VirD2 was absolutely essential for its endonuclease activity. When extra copies of the virD1 and virD2 genes were present in an A. tumefaciens strain carrying a Ti plasmid, increased amounts of T-strand and nicked molecules could be detected at early stages of vir induction. Such strains possessed the ability to transform plants with higher efficiency.     

Host range conferred by the virulence-specifying plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

The host range of Agrobacterium tumefaciens 1D1109, known to induce crown gall only on grapevine (Vitis spp.), was extended to include many plant species by transferring a tumor-inducing plasmid (pTi) from strain 1D1, a broad-host-range pathogen. The pTi plasmid was mobilized by the conjugative plasmid pRK2, which was inserted into 1D1 by mating with Escherichia coli J53(pRK2). The resulting transconjugants were screened for their ability to induce crown gall tumors on hosts other than grapevine by inoculation into sunflower. Transconjugants that were virulent on sunflower were then tested on 36 different host plants and compared with host-limited strain 1D1109 and the donor strain. Two transconjugants induced tumors on the same 28 plant species as those of the original plasmid donor 1D1(pRK2) (pTi). These results show that pRK2 promoted transfer of the pTi plasmid and suggest that the pTi plasmid rather than the A. tumefaciens chromosome determined the host range of the pathogen. Insertion of pRK2 alone did not extend the host range of strain 1D1109. Insertion of pS-a into A. tumefaciens 1D1 by mating with E. coli J53-1 (pS-a) resulted in the concomitant loss of pTi and virulence. There appears to be incompatibility between pTi and pS-a.     

The Agrobacterium tumefaciens virD3 gene is not essential for tumorigenicity on plants.

Genetic studies indicate that three of the four polypeptides encoded within the virD operon of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmid are essential for virulence. In order to determine whether the fourth polypeptide, VirD3, has any role in virulence, complementation analysis was used. An A. tumefaciens strain, A348 delta D, which lacked the entire virD operon in the Ti plasmid pTiA6, was constructed. Plasmids containing defined regions of the virD operon were introduced into this strain, and virulence was tested by the strains' abilities to form tumors on Kalanchoe leaves, tomato stems, and potato tubers. As expected, deletion of the virD operon led to an avirulent phenotype. The virulence of this strain could be restored by providing virD1, virD2, and virD4 in trans. No requirement for virD3 in tumor formation was observed in these assays.