Genetic and molecular analysis in Cristobalina sweet cherry,a spontaneous self-compatible mutant

Self-compatibility in a naturally self-incompatible species like sweet cherry is a highly interesting trait for breeding purposes and a powerful tool with which to investigate the basis of the self-incompatible reaction in gametophytic systems. However, natural self-compatibility in sweet cherry is a very rare phenomenon. Cristobalina is a local Spanish sweet cherry cultivar that has proven to be spontaneously self-compatible. In this work, the nature of the self-compatibility in Cristobalina has been studied using genetic and molecular approaches. Pollination studies and microscopic observations of pollen tube growth were carried out to confirm the self-compatible character and the results obtained indicate that self-compatibility is caused by a failure of the pollen and not the style factor. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of progenies derived from Cristobalina revealed that self-compatibility in this genotype is not related uniquely to one of the two pollen S alleles, but that pollen grains carrying either of the two haplotypes can overcome the incompatibility barrier. Moreover, PCR analysis and microscopic observation of pollen tube growth in progeny derived from Cristobalina also confirmed that the self-compatible descendants can carry either of the two S haplotypes of their progenitor. Isolation and sequencing of the style S-RNases and pollen SFBs revealed that the DNA sequences of these factors are the same as those described in other self-incompatible sweet cherry cultivars with the same S alleles. Possible mechanisms to explain self-compatibility in Cristobalina are discussed.     

Identification of quantitative trait loci associated with self-compatibility in a Prunus species

Self-compatibility in Rosaceous fruit species is based on a single-locus qualitative trait. However, the evidence observed in different species has indicated the presence of modifier genes outside the S locus affecting the expression of self-compatibility/self-incompatibility. The study of a progeny obtained from the cross of the almond genotypes ‘Vivot’× ‘Blanquerna’ has allowed the construction of a genetic map based on microsatellite markers and the identification for the first time in the Rosaceae family of two additional loci located outside the S locus and affecting the expression of self-compatibility/self-incompatibility. A quantitative trait locus (QTL) was located relatively close to the S locus, on linkage group 6 (G6), whereas the second one was located on G8. These QTLs appear to be involved in conferring self-compatibility to genotypes not possessing the S _f allele. These results are consistent with almond being a self-incompatible species with a genetic background of pseudo-self-compatibility controlled by modifier genes. The effect of the S _f allele and the two QTLs may contribute to explain the wide range of fruit sets observed when self-pollinating different almond genotypes.     

Inheritance of self-compatibility in almond: breeding strategies to assure self-compatibility in the progeny

To assure self-compatibility in the progenies, three different crosses were conducted for the first time in an almond breeding programme: self-pollination (266 descendants from 30 families), crosses between parents sharing an S-allele (108 descendants from five families) and crosses with homozygous self-compatible parents (62 descendants from five families). Depending on the cross, self-compatibility in the progenies was determined by observing pollen tube growth (by means of fluorescence microscopy), stylar S-RNases analysis or allele-specific PCR. The results obtained fit with the accepted hypothesis of inheritance of self-compatibility and the three crossing strategies used ensured 100% of self-compatible descendants. These strategies increase the efficiency of the breeding programme and avoid the laborious task of evaluating this characteristic. From the breeding point of view, self-fertilisation and crosses between relatives tend to produce inbreeding. Furthermore, these methods reduce the possibilities of choosing the parental combination. The use of homozygous self-compatible parents does not have any of these disadvantages. As far as we know, this is the first time that allele-specific PCR has been used for early selection of self-compatible seedlings. The advantages and disadvantages of the three methodologies used to determine self-compatibility are discussed.     

The self-compatibility mechanism in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica napus</Emphasis> L. is applicable to F<Subscript>1</Subscript> hybrid breeding

Brassica napus, an allopolyploid species having the A genome of B. rapa and the C genome of B. oleracea, is self-compatible, although both B. rapa and B. oleracea are self-incompatible. We have previously reported that SP11/SCR alleles are not expressed in anthers, while SRK alleles are functional in the stigma in B. napus cv. ‘Westar’, which has BnS-1 similar to B. rapa S-47 and BnS-6 similar to B. oleracea S-15. This genotype is the most frequent S genotype in B. napus, and we hypothesized that the loss of the function of SP11 is the primary cause of the self-compatibility of ‘Westar’. To verify this hypothesis, we transformed ‘Westar’ plants with the SP11 allele of B. rapa S-47. All the transgenic plants and their progeny were completely self-incompatible, demonstrating self-compatibility to be due to the S haplotype having the non-functional SP11 allele in the A genome, which suppresses a functional recessive SP11 allele in the C genome. An artificially synthesized B. napus line having two recessive SP11 alleles was developed by interspecific hybridization between B. rapa and B. oleracea. This line was self-incompatible, but F₁ hybrids between this line and ‘Westar’ were self-compatible. These results suggest that the self-compatibility mechanism of ‘Westar’ is applicable to F₁ seed production in B. napus.     

The genetics of self-incompatibility inLeavenworthia crassa rollins (Cruciferae)

Six plants of a self-incompatible population ofLeavenworthia çrassa were grown from seed collected in nature and cross-pollinated in all combinations. The incompatibility relationships between sibs were determined in eleven of the F₁ families. A one-locus sporophytic incompatibility system was established. None of the parents was homozygous at the S locus. At least five, and possibly all six, of the parents did not share an S allele. Only one pair of alleles was shown to have different interactions in the pollen and stigmata. The identity and expression of the S alleles were determined in six families. Eight pairs of alleles were independently expressed in both the pollen grains and the stigmata. Sixteen pairs of alleles showed dominance of one allele over the other in the pollen grains or the stigmata or both.F₁ plants of two crosses between different self-incompatible races were self-incompatible. F₁ plants of six crosses between self-incompatible and self-compatible races were self-incompatible; in five of the families, the frequency of pseudo-compatibility was higher than in the self-incompatible parent. Self-incompatible hybrids from a cross between a self-incompatible and a self-compatible population provide a method for rapidly determining allelic interactions in plants with a sporophytic incompatibility system.The research was carried out at the Biological Laboratories, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S.A.     

INTERSPECIFIC INCOMPATIBILITY IN SOLANUM SPECIES

Pandey , K.K. (Crop Res. Div., D.S. & I.R., Lincoln, Christchurch, New Zealand.) Interspecific incompatibility in Solanum species. Amer. Jour. Bot. 49(8): 874–882. Illus. 1962.—A diallel cross involving 11 self-incompatible and 3 self-compatible species of Solanum was made to study the genetic basis of interspecific incompatibility. Interspecific incompatibility was not limited to crosses in which a self-compatible species was used as the male parent onto a self-incompatible species (unilateral incompatibility). A number of crosses between self-incompatible species were incompatible. In one cross, Q vernei X verrucosum, a self-compatible species was successful as a pollen parent with a self-incompatible species. Unlike other hybrids between self-compatible and self-incompatible species, which are self-incompatible, these F₁ hybrids were self-fertile, and cross-fertile among themselves and with both parents. The self-fertile S. polyadenium was cross-incompatible as a female as well as a male parent with all other species. It is suggested that the unilateral incompatibility is a property of the allele S_C which originated as a consequence of one kind of breakdown of the S_I gene; the S_C allele produces “bare” pollen growth substances which are inactivated in an incompatible style. It is proposed that the failure of the principle of unilateral interspecific incompatibility in solanaceous species may be due to the action of alleles at the second incompatibility locus revealed in certain Mexican species. It is assumed that the South American species are selected intraspecifically only for the action of S alleles but that in certain interspecific crosses and rarely in intraspecific crosses the alleles at the second locus may be expressed, thus interfering with the usual action of S alleles. The F₁ hybrids Q verrucosum (self-fertile) X simplicifolium (self-sterile) were self-incompatible at the tetraploid as well as the diploid level, and their cross-compatibility behavior was consistent with the expected activity of the S_C and S_I alleles of the 2 parents respectively.     

Introgression of self-compatibility from Coffea heterocalyx to the cultivated species Coffea canephora

Self-compatibility segregation was assessed in two successive backcross progenies originating from an interspecific cross between Coffea canephora (self-incompatible) and Coffea heterocalyx (self-compatible). After self- and cross-pollination, pollen tube behaviour in styles was observed under ultraviolet fluorescence microscopy and fruit-set was determined at harvesting time. Segregation ratios in the two progenies were consistent with monofactorial control of self-compatibility. Self-compatible plants exhibited higher fruit-set than self-incompatible ones in open-pollination conditions. Segregation of AFLP markers was scored in the first backcross progeny. By molecular linkage analysis, the S locus could be mapped to a short linkage group.     

A modifier locus affecting the expression of the S-RNase gene could be the cause of breakdown of self-incompatibility in almond

Self-compatibility has become the primary objective of most almond (Prunus amygdalus Batsch) breeding programmes in order to avoid the problems related to the gametophytic self-incompatibility system present in almond. The progeny of the cross ‘Vivot’ (S ₂₃ S _fa) × ‘Blanquerna’ (S ₈ S _fi) was studied because both cultivars share the same S _f allele but have a different phenotypic expression: active (S _fa) in ‘Vivot’ and inactive (S _fi) in ‘Blanquerna’. In addition, the microscopic observation of pollen tube growth after self-pollination over several years showed an unexpected self-incompatible behaviour in most seedlings of this cross. The genotypes of this progeny showed that the S _fi pollen from ‘Blanquerna’ was not able to grow down the pistils of ‘Vivot’ harbouring the S _fa allele, confirming the active function of this allele against the inactive form of the same allele, S _fi. As self-compatibility was observed in some S ₈ S ₂₃ and S ₈ S _fa individuals of this progeny, the S _f haplotype may not always be linked to the expression and transmission of self-compatibility in almond, suggesting that a modifier locus may be involved in the mechanism of self-incompatibility in plants.     

Inheritance of S(f)-RNase in Japanese apricot ( Prunus mume) and its relation to self-compatibility

Self-compatible cultivars of Japanese apricot ( Prunus mume Shieb. et Zucc.), a tree species that normally shows S-RNase-based self-incompatiblity, have a horticultural advantage over self-incompatible cultivars. Inheritance of self-compatibility and a common S(f)-RNase allele that is observed in self-compatible cultivars was investigated using progenies from controlled crosses. Total DNAs were isolated from the parents and progenies of seven crosses that included at least one self-compatible cultivar as a parent. These DNAs were PCR-amplified with the Pru-C2 and PCE-R primer pair to determine S-haplotypes of the parents and progenies. A novel S-haplotype, S(8), was found. In all crosses examined, the S(f)-RNase gene was inherited from either the seed or pollen parent as a pistil S-allele in a non-functional S-haplotype. Self-compatibility of about 20 trees each from reciprocal crosses of 'Benisashi ( S(7) S(f))' and 'Shinpeidayu ( S(3) S(f))', and 26 selections from 16 different crosses was tested by pollination and pollen-tube growth studies. Cosegregation of the S(f)-RNase allele and self-compatibility was confirmed with all but selection 1K0-26 ( S(3) S(7)). Selection 1K0-26 ( S(3) S(7)) that originated from 'Benisashi ( S(7) S(f))' x 'Koshinoume ( S(3) S(f))' appeared to be self-compatible even without the S(f)-RNase allele. The possible role of pollen- S, a presumably existing pollen component of gametophytic self-incompatibility, is discussed.     

Self-compatibility in aLycopersicon peruvianum variant (LA2157) is associated with a lack of style S-RNase activity

A series of crosses between a naturally-occurring self-compatible accession ofLycopersicon peruvianum and a closely-related self-incompatible accession were used to demonstrate that the mutation to self-compatibility is located at the S-locus. Progeny of the crosses contain abundant style proteins of about 30 kDa that segregate with the S₆and S₇-alleles from the SI parent and the S_c-allele from the SC parent. The S₆and S₇-associated proteins have ribonuclease activity whereas the S_c-associated protein is not an active ribonuclease. This finding indicates that S-RNases are determinants of self-incompatibility in the style and that the ribonuclease activity is essential for their function.     

Is self-compatibility the main breeding system in borage (Borago officinalis L.)?

The polygenic postzygotic self-incompatible system reported in borage (Borago officinalis L.) is refuted. The behaviour of pollen tubes after self- and cross-pollination, analysis of the crossability coefficient, seed set after continuous generations of self-pollination and the effects of inbreeding depression in borage were studied. Evidence of self-compatibility was established. The influence of protandry in a self-compatible system is also discussed. Received: 15 July 1999 / Accepted: 3 November 1999     

Protein expression of a self-compatible allele from Lycopersicon peruvianum: introgression and behavior in a self-incompatible background

Lycopersicon peruvianum (wild tomato) is a gametophytic self-incompatible (SI) species. One natural population has been shown to harbor a self-compatible (SC) allele. A stylar protein associated with the self-compatibility allele has been elucidated using SDS-PAGE. The temporal and spatial expression of this protein is presented and compared with protein expression of two SI alleles. Hybrids containing the SC and SI alleles were used in a backcrossing program to introgress the SC allele into SI backgrounds in six independent lines. Controlled pollinations and SDS-PAGE were used to identify and select classes of progeny. After four backcross generations (approximately 97% recovery of the SI backgrounds) the SC allele still confers self-fertility in lines that contain this allele, providing evidence that the mutation to SC occurred at the S-locus and that the associated protein is likely responsible.     

POLLEN TUBE GROWTH AND INCOMPATIBILITY FOLLOWING INTRA- AND INTER-SPECIFIC POLLINATIONS IN LILIUM LONGIFLORUM

The growth of pollen tubes of a sampling of Lilium species in styles of L. longiflorum incubated at 24 C for 48 hr after pollination indicated two types of interspecific incompatibility. Pollen tubes of two self-compatible species of section Leucolirion, the section including L. longiflorum, stopped growth abruptly upon reaching the stylar canal, were of abnormal morphology, and were incapable of continued growth with longer incubation. Pollen tubes of self-compatible or self-incompatible species of sections Sinomartagon, Pseudolirium, Liriotypus, and Daurolirion approached but did not exceed the length of intraspecific incompatible pollen tubes in styles of L. longiflorum. Pollen tube morphology was normal and tubes were capable of continued growth with additional incubation. Unilateral interspecific incompatibility occurred in reciprocal crosses between self-incompatible L. longiflorum and self-compatible L. regale and L. formosanum, but exceptions occurred in Aurelian hybrids. Incubation of interspecifically pollinated L. longiflorum styles at 39 C, which removes the self-incompatibility reaction, had no effect on interspecific incompatibility.     

Expression of a self-incompatibility gene in a self-compatible line of Brassica oleracea.

In cruciferous plants, self-pollination is prevented by the action of genes situated at the self-incompatibility locus or S-locus. The self-incompatibility reaction is associated with expression of stigma glycoproteins encoded by the S-locus glycoprotein (SLG) gene. Only a few cases of self-compatible plants derived from self-incompatible lines in the crucifer Brassica have been reported. In these cases, self-compatibility was generally ascribed to the action of single genes unlinked to the S-locus. In contrast, we report here a line of Brassica oleracea var acephala with a self-compatible phenotype linked to the S-locus. By means of both biochemical and immunochemical analyses, we showed that this self-compatible (Sc) line nonetheless possesses stigmatic SLGs (SLG-Sc) that are expressed with a similar spatial and temporal pattern to that described for the SLGs of self-incompatible Brassica plants. Moreover, the SLG-Sc products segregate with the self-compatibility phenotype in F2 progeny, suggesting that changes at the S-locus may be responsible for the occurrence of the self-compatibility character. A cDNA clone encoding the SLG-Sc product was isolated, and the deduced amino acid sequence showed this glycoprotein to be highly homologous to the pollen recessive S2 allele glycoprotein. Hence, self-compatibility in this Brassica Sc line correlates with the expression of a pollen recessive-like S allele in the stigma.     

Gene conversion from SLG to SRK resulting in self-compatibility in Brassica rapa

Self-compatible S-54 homozygotic plants were found in progenies of an F(1) hybrid cultivar in Chinese cabbage. Pollination tests revealed that this self-compatibility is controlled by the S locus and caused by the loss of the recognition function of the stigma. SRK, the gene for the recognition molecule in the stigma, was normally transcribed and translated in the self-compatible plants. The 1034-bp region in the receptor domain of SRK in the self-compatible plants was 100% identical to SLG in S-54, while that in self-incompatible S-54 homozygotic plants was 95.1% identical. These results suggest that the self-compatibility of the S-54 homozygotes is due to amino-acid changes caused by gene conversion from SLG to SRK.     

Isolation of S-alleles from a wild population of Brassica campestris L. at Balcesme,Turkey and their characterization by S-glycoproteins

Summary S-alleles of self-incompatibility were isolated from a wild population of Brassica campestris growing at Balcesme, Turkey. Out of 88 plants observed, 73 were self-incompatible and 4 were self-compatible. In certain families, selfed progenies from a self-incompatible plant segregated into fewer than three incompatibility classes, which is consistent with a one-locus sporophytic genetic control of self-incompatibility. Out of 25 combinations of S-alleles tested, dominance interactions were observed in 6 of them on the pollen side and on 5 of them on the stigma side. The 35 S-homozygotes thus isolated consisted of 18 independent S-alleles. The number of S-alleles in this population was estimated to be more than 30. The S-locus glycoproteins (SLGs) corresponding to the respective S-alleles were identified by iso-electric focusing (IEF)-gel immunoblotting with a polyclonal antiserum against SLG⁸. SLGs in a stigma were generally composed of several bands, one major and a few minor ones, whose molecular weight was similar to each other, and the major and minor bands were heritable in correlation with each other. SDS-PAGE analysis of SLGs differentiated a few juxtaposed bands between 50 and 60 kDa, and the variations in these bands were considered to be due to differences in the number of polysaccharide residues. General features of the variation of S-genes and their SLGs between the populations in Balcesme, Turkey and Oguni, Japan, were comparatively similar to one another, despite the different surroundings and history of these populations.     

Characterization of self-compatibility in sweet cherry varieties by crossing experiments and molecular genetic analysis

Self-compatibility is a major breeding objective in sweet cherry. The identification and characterization of new sources of self-compatibility will be useful for breeding and research purposes. In this work, self-compatibility of four local Spanish sweet cherry varieties was investigated by crossing experiments and molecular genetic analysis of two self-incompatibility loci. Crossing experiments included self- and cross-pollinations in the laboratory followed by microscopic observation of pollen tube growth and fruit set assay in the field. After crossing experiments, two accessions, ‘Son Miró’ and ‘Talegal Ahín’, were self-compatible while the other two were self-incompatible. Inheritance of S-locus and microsatellite EMPaS02 (linked to self-compatibility, Sc) were investigated in self-pollination progeny of both self-compatible genotypes. Results indicate that self-compatibility in ‘Talegal Ahín’ is similar to self-compatibility described in sweet cherry ‘Cristobalina’ and may be caused by the same mutation. That is a pollen part mutation not linked to the S-locus but linked to microsatellite EMPaS02 in cherry LG3. In ‘Son Miró’ self-compatibility seems more complex, affecting pollen and style function, and probably involving more than one mutation not described previously in sweet cherry. Together with ‘Cristobalina’, the newly described self-compatible varieties ‘Son Miró’ and ‘Talegal Ahín’ confirm the existence of unique self-compatible plant material in local germplasm from Spain that should be conserved and characterized for its use in breeding and research.     

A self-compatible mutant S allele conferring a dominant negative effect on the functional S allele in Ipomoea trifida

A spontaneously occurring self-compatible mutant has been identified in Ipomoea trifida, a species possessing sporophytic self-incompatibility controlled by a single multiallelic S locus. Analysis of the segregation of compatibility/incompatibility phenotypes in selfed and crossed progenies of the self-compatible mutant plant indicated that the self-compatibility trait was caused by a mutation at the S locus; the mutated S allele was therefore designated Sc. RFLP analysis of progeny plants segregating for the Sc allele using the SSP gene (a gene linked closely to the S locus of I. trifida) as a probe confirmed that the mutation was present at the S locus. Self-incompatibility responses were examined in F₁ progenies obtained from crosses between the self-compatible mutant and self-incompatible plants homozygous for one of three S alleles, S ₁ , S ₃ and S ₂₂ , where the dominance relationship is S ₂₂ >S ₁ >S ₃ . All F₁ progeny plants from crosses with S ₂₂ and S ₁ homozygotes were self-incompatible and exhibited the respective phenotypes of each self-incompatible parent (either S ₂₂ or S ₁ ) in both stigma and pollen. However, of the F₁ progeny plants from the cross with the S ₃ homozygote, those carrying the genotype ScS ₃ were all self-compatible and cross-compatible as both female and male parents with the S ₃ homozygote. These results indicate that the dominance relationship between the four S alleles is: S ₂₂ >S ₁ >Sc>S ₃ and so reveal the unexpected finding that the mutated Sc allele is dominant over a functional S ₃ allele. A possible explanation for this observation is that the gene product encoded by the Sc allele confers a dominant negative effect on the S ₃ gene product. Received: 21 June 2000 / Accepted: 18 July 2000     

Self-incompatibility in the Commelinaceae

This paper reports on a survey of self-incompatibility in 110species of 22 genera in the family Commelinaceae. Genera fromboth tribes, Tradescantieae and Commelineae are included. Fifty-fivespecies were found to be self-incompatible, 50 species self-compatible,and five species comprised individuals which were self-incompatibleand individuals which were self-compatible. This variabilityand its possible evolutionary significance are discussed. Self-incompatible species had actinomorphic flowers and themajority of these were in the Tradescantieae. Species with zygomorphicflowers which were more commonly found in the Commelineae wereself-compatible. The ubiquitous presence of binucleate pollengrains supports previous data that self-incompatibility is ofthe gametophytic type. The site of pollen tube arrest, however,was on the stigma at or near the base of the stigma papillacells. There were two exceptions to this viz. an unnamed Dichorisandraspecies and Siderasis fuscata where pollen tube arrest was stylar. The significance of these data to taxonomy also receives comment. Commelinaceae, incompatibility, self-compatibility