T cell recognition of Mlsc. I. Influence of MHC gene products in Mlsc-specific T cell recognition

Monospecific T cell clones have been proven to be powerful tools for the characterization of T cell recognition in many Ag-specific as well as allo-specific T cell responses. In this report, in order to elucidate the mechanism of T cell recognition of minor stimulating locus Ag (Mlsc) determinants, Mlsc-specific cloned T cells were employed together with primary T cell responses to clarify the role of MHC-gene products in Mlsc-specific T cell recognition. The results indicated that T cells recognize Mlsc determinants in conjunction with I-region MHC gene products. Moreover, certain MHC haplotypes (e.g., H-2a and H-2k) appear to function efficiently in the "presentation" of Mlsc, whereas other haplotypes (e.g., H-2b and H-2q) function poorly if at all in presenting Mlsc. Experiments with the use of stimulators derived from F1 hybrids between the low stimulatory H-2b, Mlsc strain, C3H.SW, and a panel of Mlsb, H-2-different or intra-H-2 recombinant strains strongly suggested that expression of E alpha E beta molecules on stimulators plays a critical role for Mlsc stimulation. The functional importance of the E alpha E beta product in Mlsc recognition was further demonstrated by the ability of anti-E alpha monoclonal antibody to inhibit the response of cloned Mlsc-specific T cells. Inhibition of the same Mlsc-specific response by anti-A beta k antibody suggests that the A beta product may also play a role in T cell responses to Mlsc.     

MHC interaction and T cell recognition of carbohydrates and glycopeptides.

The T cell independence of complex polysaccharide Ag has suggested the possibility that carbohydrates may be incapable of T cell recognition because of a failure to interact with MHC restriction elements and/or a failure of MHC/carbohydrate complexes to interact with and be recognized by Ag-specific TCR. We have used two approaches to obtain information about T cell recognition of carbohydrate. First, we have determined the capacity of a series of oligosaccharides and glycolipids to bind a murine class II MHC molecule, IAd. No significant binding was observed with the 26 compounds tested, but the limitation to these studies was that there was a relatively limited collection of synthetic carbohydrate and glycolipid structures of limited complexity available for analysis. The second approach involved the study of the effect of glycosylation of a known peptide T cell epitope (OVA 323-339) on MHC binding of the peptide and on T cell recognition. Three patterns of effects were observed: 1) no effect on either binding or T cell recognition. This pattern was observed when the carbohydrate was located at residues removed from the core MHC-binding region. When the carbohydrate was located within the core MHC-binding regions, either 2) glycosylation destroyed both MHC binding and T cell recognition; or 3) glycosylation did not ablate MHC binding or T cell recognition. In this latter instance, there was evidence to indicate that the carbohydrate moiety was an important part of the antigenic determinant recognized by T cells.     

Agent-based modeling of the context dependency in T cell recognition

Antigen recognition by T cells is a key event in the adaptive immune response. T cells scan the surface of antigen-presenting cells (APCs) or target cells for specific peptides bound to MHC molecules. In the physiological setting, a typical APC presents tens of thousands of diverse endogenous self-derived peptides complexed to MHC (pMHC complexes). When 'foreign' peptides are presented, they constitute a small fraction of the total surface peptide repertoire. As T cells seem to be capable of discerning minute amounts of 'foreign' peptides among a complex background of self-peptides, endogenous peptides are generally assumed to play no role in recognition. However, recent results suggest that these background peptides may alter the sensitivity of T cells to foreign peptides. Current experimental limitations preclude analysis of peptide mixtures approaching physiological complexity, making it difficult to further address the role of complex background peptides. In this paper, we present a computational model to test how complex, varied peptide populations on an APC could potentially modulate a T cell's ability to detect the presence of small numbers of agonist peptides among a diverse population. We use the model to investigate the notion that under physiological conditions, T cell recognition of foreign peptides is context dependent, that is, T cells process signals gathered from all pMHC interactions, not just from a few agonist peptides while ignoring all others.     

Clustering class I MHC modulates sensitivity of T cell recognition

T cell recognition of peptide-MHC is highly specific and is sensitive to very low levels of agonist peptide; however, it is unclear how this effect is achieved or regulated. In this study we show that clustering class I MHC molecules on the cell surface of B lymphoblasts enhances their recognition by mouse and human T cells. We increased clustering of MHC I molecules by two methods, cholesterol depletion and direct cross-linking of a dimerizable MHC construct. Imaging showed that both treatments increased the size and intensity of MHC clusters on the cell surface. Enlarged clusters correlated with enhanced lysis and T cell effector function. Enhancements were peptide-specific and greatest at low concentrations of peptide. Clustering MHC class I enhanced recognition of both strong and weak agonists but not null peptide. Our results indicate that the lateral organization of MHC class I on the cell surface can modulate the sensitivity of T cell recognition of agonist peptide.     

The T cell repertoire may be biased in favor of MHC recognition

The receptors of two T cell hybridomas that recognize class I and class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules, respectively, have been compared. In both cases these receptors are hybrid molecules formed as a result of cellular fusion. The receptors contain the same alpha chain, contributed by the tumor cell fusion partner, and related beta chains, contributed by the normal T cell component. Thus, surprisingly, the same alpha chain can contribute to recognition of class I and class II MHC molecules. Moreover, the finding that in two independent examples hybrid receptor molecules created randomly by in vitro cell fusion recognize MHC supports the theory that the T cell repertoire has an intrinsic affinity for MHC.     

T cell receptor junctional regions and the MHC molecule affect the recognition of antigenic peptides by T cell clones.

Nine independent pigeon cytochrome c-specific T cell clones were analyzed by using a panel of antigenic peptide analogs presented in association with three allelic IE-encoded MHC glycoproteins. Eight of the T cell clones expressed a TCR composed of a unique alpha- and beta-chain amino acid sequence, and concordantly, each of these T cell clones exhibited a unique Ag specificity. This was true for several clones which differed only in TCR V-J junctional regions. Interestingly, for a given clone, the response to some of the peptide analogs depended to a large extent on the allelic form of the presenting MHC molecule. A simple interpretation of these data would suggest that certain positions of the peptide Ag are most important for Ag-MHC molecule interactions, and that these specific interactions can influence the antigenic epitope recognized by the TCR. We suggest that an antigenic peptide binds to an MHC glycoprotein in a distinct way, but may retain a measure of flexibility.     

T cell receptor binding transition states and recognition of peptide/MHC

T cell receptor recognition of peptide/MHC has been described as proceeding through a "two-step" process in which the TCR first contacts the MHC molecule prior to formation of the binding transition state using the germline-encoded CDR1 and CDR2 loops. The receptor then contacts the peptide using the hypervariable CDR3 loops as the transition state decays to the bound state. The model subdivides TCR binding into peptide-independent and peptide-dependent steps, demarcated at the binding transition state. Investigating the two-step model, here we show that two TCRs that recognize the same peptide/MHC bury very similar amounts of solvent-accessible surface area in their transition states. However, 1300-1500 A2 of surface area is buried in each, a significant amount suggestive of participation of peptide and associated CDR3 surface. Consistent with this interpretation, analysis of peptide and TCR variants indicates that stabilizing contacts to the peptide are formed within both transition states. These data are incompatible with the original two-step model, as are transition state models built using the principle of minimal frustration commonly employed in the investigation of protein folding and binding transition states. These findings will be useful in further explorations of the nature of TCR binding transition states, as well as ongoing efforts to understand the mechanisms by which T cell receptors recognize the composite peptide/MHC surface.     

T cells that recognize peptide sequences of self MHC class II molecules exist in syngeneic mice.

T cell reactivity toward self MHC class II molecules has been recognized in syngeneic MLR in a number of studies, where the T cells are believed to recognize the combination of self/nonself peptide and self MHC molecule. We investigated the stimulation of T cell proliferation by synthetic peptides of sequences corresponding to the first polymorphic amino terminal domain of alpha- and beta-chains of self I-A molecules. Both unprimed and primed T cells responded to a number of peptides of alpha 1 and beta 1 domains of self I-Ad molecules. The response was dependent on the presentation of I-Ad peptides by syngeneic APC and was blocked by anti-class II MHC mAb. Upon further investigation it was observed that I-Ad peptides could inhibit the stimulation of Ag-specific MHC class II-restricted T cell hybridoma due to self presentation of peptides rather than to direct binding of free peptides to the TCR, further supporting their affinity/interaction with intact self MHC class II molecules. The peptide I-A beta d 62-78 showed high affinity toward intact self MHC II molecule as determined by the inhibition of Ag-specific T cell stimulation and yet was nonstimulatory for syngeneic T cells, therefore representing an MHC determinant that may have induced self tolerance. Thus we have shown that strong T cell proliferative responses can be generated in normal mice against the peptides derived from self MHC class II molecules and these cells are part of the normal T cell repertoire. Therefore complete tolerance toward potentially powerful immunodominant but cryptic determinants of self Ag may not be necessary to prevent autoimmune diseases.     

T cell recognition of an engineered MHC class I molecule: implications for peptide-independent alloreactivity

Previously, we described H-2K(bW9) (K(bW9)), an engineered variant of the murine MHC class I molecule H-2K(b) (K(b)), devoid of the central anchor ("C") pocket owing to a point mutation on the floor of the peptide binding site; this substitution drastically altered selection of bound peptides, such that the peptide repertoires of K(b) and K(bW9) are largely nonoverlapping in vivo. On the basis of these observations, we used K(bW9) and K(b) to revisit the role of peptides in alloreactive T cell recognition. We first compared Ab and TCR recognition of K(bW9) and K(b). Six of six K(b)-specific mAbs, directed against different parts of the molecule, recognized K(bW9) well, albeit at different levels than K(b). Furthermore, K(bW9) readily served as a restriction element for a peptide-specific syngeneic CTL response. Therefore, K(bW9) mutation did not result in gross distortions of the TCR-interacting surface of class I, which was comparable between K(b) and K(bW9). Interestingly, when K(bW9) was used to stimulate allogeneic T cells, it induced an infrequent CTL population that cross-reacted against K(b) and was specific for peptide-independent MHC epitopes. By contrast, K(b)-induced alloreactive CTLs recognized K(b) in a peptide-specific manner, did not cross-react on K(bW9), and were present at much higher frequencies than those induced by K(bW9). Thus, induction of rare peptide-independent CTLs depended on unique structural features of K(bW9), likely due to the elevated floor of the peptide-binding groove and the consequent protruding position of the peptide. These results shed new light on the relationship between TCR and peptide-MHC complex in peptide-independent allorecognition.     

T cells from nonresponder mice. MHC restricted and unrestricted recognition of insulin

Two types of insulin-reactive T cell hybridomas expressing TCR-alpha beta were derived from nonresponder H-2b mice immunized with pork insulin. One type had characteristics of conventional class II-restricted Th cells. These CD4+ CD8- I-Ab-restricted T cells recognized a self determinant, present within the insulin B-chain. This determinant was distinct from the immunodominant A-chain loop determinant that is recognized by the majority of T cells induced after immunization with normally immunogenic beef insulin. Our results suggest that this determinant is readily generated during immunologic processing of insulins, including nonimmunogenic pork insulin and self insulin. A second type of T cell lacking CD4 and CD8 recognized a distinct B-chain determinant of insulin in a class II-dependent, but MHC unrestricted, fashion. These cells may represent a novel subpopulation which has bypassed conventional selection during development in the thymus.     

MHC molecules protect T cell epitopes against proteolytic destruction.

There is a subtle duality in the role of proteolytic enzymes in Ag processing. They are required to fragment protein Ag ingested by APC. However, prolonged exposure to proteolytic enzymes may lead to a complete degradation of the Ag, leaving nothing for the T cell system to recognize. What ensures that some of the Ag is salvaged? Using a cell-free system we demonstrate that an Ag fragment, once bound to a MHC class II molecule, is effectively protected against proteolytic destruction by cathepsin B and pronase E. The bound fragment, however, can be modified by aminopeptidase N. We suggest that MHC class II molecules play an important regulatory role in the physiologic processing of Ag.     

T cell responses specific for subregions of allogeneic MHC molecules.

The repertoire of C3H (H-2k) CD4+ T cells for I-Ab allopolymorphisms was analyzed by studying the responses of unprimed populations of T cells and of I-Ab-specific T cell clones for recombinant MHC molecules containing combinations of polymorphic subregions of the alpha- and beta-chains from the I-Ab and I-Ak molecules. In this system, polymorphisms in the predicted MHC alpha-helices were more potent than polymorphisms in the beta-strands in stimulating unprimed alloreactive T cells. Similarly, 75% of I-Ab-specific T cell clones responded to recombinants containing b polymorphisms in both the alpha- and beta-chains helices and tolerated the substitution of k polymorphisms in the beta-pleated sheet. Furthermore, 20% of the clones responded to a molecule containing allogeneic b residues in just the beta-chain helix. The results demonstrate that the T cell response to allogeneic MHC molecules consists largely of sets of T cells with overlapping specificities for subregions of the MHC molecule. In addition, they highlight the importance of the alpha-helices in these responses and a diminished role for polymorphisms in the beta-strands when, as in the present case, MHC structure and conformation is tolerant of beta-sheet substitutions. These results sharply contrast with observations made in the analysis of Ag-specific T cells and lead to the suggestion that a subset of alloreactive T cells are not peptide specific and can directly recognize MHC polymorphisms.     

Functional activity in vivo of effector T cell populations. II. Anti-tumor activity exhibited by syngeneic anti-MoMULV-specific cytolytic T cell clones

The functional activity in vivo of murine tumor-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte populations and clones was studied. Tumor cell destruction induced after the i.v. injection of cytolytic effector cells was quantitated by monitoring the elimination of 131IUdR-labeled tumor cells in the peritoneal cavity by using whole-body counting techniques. Mixed leukocyte-tumor cell cultures were established by using spleen cells from C57BL/6 regressor mice that had rejected an intramuscular tumor induced by the injection of MSV-MoMuLV virus. This effector cell population was observed to eliminate syngeneic MoMuLV-induced tumor cells in a dose-dependent manner. Treatment of the effector cell population with monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibodies plus complement totally abrogated their ability to induce tumor cell destruction in the peritoneal cavity. MSV-MoMuLV-specific Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cell clones derived by micro-manipulation of T lymphocyte-tumor cell conjugates were also tested for functional activity in vivo. Several clones induced a rapid, specific elimination of 131I-labeled MBL-2 tumor cells from the peritoneal cavity after i.v. injection, whereas others were inactive. Both active and inactive clones were highly cytolytic and secreted MAF/IFN-gamma lymphokines. In contrast to previous results obtained in a tumor allograft model, the MSV-MoMuLV-specific cytolytic T cell clones that were active in vivo did not proliferate in vitro in response to stimulation with irradiated tumor cells plus filler spleen cells in the absence of an added source of interleukin 2.     

Induction of syngeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes against a B cell tumor. III. MHC class I-restricted CTL recognizes the processed form(s) of idiotype.

The purpose of this work was to determine the molecular nature of the idiotypic Ig of a B cell tumor, 2C3, involved in the induction of anti-idiotypic cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL). We previously reported that hyperimmunization of mice with irradiated 2C3 cells provides effective tumor protection by inducing MHC class I-restricted CTL. Due to the enormous heterogeneity of the splenic CTL further study could not be undertaken on the idiotype (Id)-CTL interaction. Subsequently an anti-idiotypic CTL line, A102, and a highly Id-specific CTL clone, 102.F5, have been developed. In the present investigation we report that the processed forms of idiotypic determinants are responsible for induction and activation of these specific effector CTL. Inhibition studies using anti-TcR and anti-MHC class I mAbs showed that the TcR-CD3 complex of the anti-idiotypic CTL recognized 2C3 Id in the context of MHC class I antigens. The cytotoxicity of these CTL could not be inhibited with affinity-purified 2C3 Ig used as such or after pulsing with splenic antigen-presenting cells (APC). Furthermore, using brefeldin A (BFA) and chloroquine (CLQ), which are specific inhibitors of cytosolic and endosomal antigen processing pathways, respectively, it has also been observed that exposure of 2C3 to BFA but not CLQ prevents its cytolysis by both anti-idiotypic CTL line and clone. These results clearly indicate that endogenously produced idiotypic determinants of 2C3 Ig are processed in pre-Golgi vesicle, possibly in the ER, along with MHC class I antigens and then are transported to the membrane. Treatment of 2C3 with BFA, however, did not exert any effect on the expression of membrane-associated Ig of 2C3 cells. Therefore, it is the processed form rather than the bona fide receptor Ig on the cell surface that is recognized by the Id-specific CTL.     

T cell subset interactions in the regulation of syngeneic tumor immunity

Suppressor T cell (Ts) regulation of immunity to chemically induced syngeneic tumors has been investigated with regard to the mechanism of Ts stimulation and cell-to-cell communication. It has been determined that suppressor cells generated by the presence of tumor antigen participate in a suppressive circuit involving both cells and cell-derived factor(s) in the expression of suppressive effects. Evidence is provided that these interactions occur via idiotype--antiidiotype recognition in a manner similar to those in hapten-specific immune response. Conditions for induction of Ts activity in vivo have been artificially created by a variety of means, including the intravenous administration of soluble antigen and the inhibition of antigen-presenting function by anti-I-A antibodies or by in vivo treatment with ultraviolet irradiation. Suppression appears to be directed against the Ly-1+ cell, which mediates tumor immunity in this system. The summary of evidence suggest that responses to tumor antigen are in many aspects analogous to those occurring in response to more conventional antigens, but are subject to the dampening effects of suppressor cells generated continually during the period of primary tumor growth.     

Cysteinylation of MHC class II ligands: peptide endocytosis and reduction within APC influences T cell recognition

Peptides bind cell surface MHC class II proteins to yield complexes capable of activating CD4(+) T cells. By contrast, protein Ags require internalization and processing by APC before functional presentation. Here, T cell recognition of a short peptide in the context of class II proteins occurred only after delivery of this ligand to mature endosomal/lysosomal compartments within APC. Functional and biochemical studies revealed that a central cysteine within the peptide was cysteinylated, perturbing T cell recognition of this epitope. Internalization and processing of the modified epitope by APC, was required to restore T cell recognition. Peptide cysteinylation and reduction could occur rapidly and reversibly before MHC binding. Cysteinylation did not disrupt peptide binding to class II molecules, rather the modified peptide displayed an enhanced affinity for MHC at neutral pH. However, once the peptide was bound to class II proteins, oxidation or reduction of cysteine residues was severely limited. Cysteinylation has been shown to radically influence T cell responses to MHC class I ligands. The ability of professional APC to reductively cleave this peptide modification presumably evolved to circumvent a similar problem in MHC class II ligand recognition.     

Promiscuity of MHC class Ib-restricted T cell responses

Murine infection with the Gram-positive intracellular bacterium Listeria monocytogenes activates CD8(+) T cells that recognize bacterially derived N-formyl methionine peptides in the context of H2-M3 MHC class Ib molecules. Three peptides, fMIGWII, fMIVIL, and fMIVTLF, are targets of L. monocytogenes-specific CD8(+) T cells. To investigate epitope cross-recognition by H2-M3-restricted CD8(+) T cells, we deleted the sequence encoding fMIGWII from a virulent strain of L. monocytogenes. Infection with fMIGWII-deficient L. monocytogenes unexpectedly primed CD8(+) T cells that stain with fMIGWII/H2-M3 tetramers and lyse fMIGWII-coated target cells in vivo. Because the fMIGWII sequence is nonredundant, we speculated that other bacterially derived Ags are priming these responses. HPLC peptide fractionation of bacterial culture supernatants revealed several distinct L. monocytogenes-derived peptides that are recognized by fMIGWII-specific T cells. Our results demonstrate that the dominant H2-M3-restricted CD8(+) T cell population, although reactive with fMIGWII, is primed by other, non-fMIGWII peptides derived from L. monocytogenes. Although this degree of Ag receptor promiscuity is unusual for the adaptive immune system, it may be a more common feature of T cell responses restricted by nonpolymorphic MHC class Ib molecules.     

T cell antigen receptor engagement and specificity in the recognition of stress-inducible MHC class I-related chains by human epithelial gamma delta T cells

Human gamma delta T cells with the TCR variable region V(delta)1 occur mainly in epithelia and respond to stress-induced expression of the MHC class I-related chains A and B, which have no function in Ag presentation. MIC function as ligands for NKG2D-DAP10, an activating receptor complex that triggers NK cells, costimulates CD8 alpha beta and V(gamma)9V(delta)2 gamma delta T cells, and is required for stimulation of V(delta)1 gamma delta T cells. It is unresolved, however, whether triggering of V(delta)1 gamma delta TCRs is also mediated by MIC or by unidentified cell surface components. Soluble MICA tetramers were used as a binding reagent to demonstrate specific interactions with various V(delta)1 gamma delta TCRs expressed on transfectants of a T cell line selected for lack of NKG2D. Tetramer binding was restricted to TCRs derived from responder T cell clones classified as reactive against a broad range of MIC-expressing target cells and was abrogated when TCRs were composed of mismatched gamma- and delta-chains. These results and the inability of V(delta)1 gamma delta T cells to respond to target cells expressing the ULBP/N2DL ligands of NKG2D, which are highly divergent from MIC, indicate that MIC delivers both the TCR-dependent signal 1 and the NKG2D-dependent costimulatory signal 2. This dual function may serve to prevent erroneous gamma delta T cell activation by cross-reactive cell surface determinants.