Neuronal differentiation from postmitotic precursors in the ciliary ganglion

In the chick ciliary ganglion, neuronal number is kept constant between St. 29 and St. 34 (E6-E8) despite a large amount of cell death. Here, we characterize the source of neurogenic cells in the ganglion as undifferentiated neural crest-derived cells. At St. 29, neurons and nonneuronal cells in the ciliary ganglion expressed the neural crest markers HNK-1 and p75(NTR). Over 50% of the cells were neurons at St. 29; of the nonneuronal cells, a small population expressed glial markers, whereas the majority was undifferentiated. When placed in culture, nonneuronal cells acquired immunoreactivity for HuD, suggesting that they had commenced neuronal differentiation. The newly differentiated neurons arose from precursors that did not incorporate bromodeoxyuridine. To test whether these precursors could undergo neural differentiation in vivo, purified nonneuronal cells from St. 29 quail ganglia were transplanted into chick embryos at St. 9-14. Subsequently, quail cells expressing neuronal markers were found in the chick ciliary ganglion. The existence of this precursor pool was transient because nonneuronal cells isolated from St. 38 ganglia failed to form neurons. Since all ciliary ganglion neurons are born prior to St. 29, these results demonstrate that there are postmitotic neural crest-derived precursors in the developing ciliary ganglion that can differentiate into neurons in the appropriate environment.     

Overexpression of ciliary neurotrophic factor in vivo rescues chick ciliary ganglion neurons from cell death

Ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons undergo target-dependent cell death during embryonic development. Although ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) was identified in vitro by its ability to support the survival of chick CG neurons, its function as a target-derived neurotrophic factor has been questioned by those working on mammalian-derived forms of CNTF. We have purified and cloned a chicken CNTF [chCNTF; formerly growth-promoting activity (GPA)] that is expressed in CG targets during the period of cell death and is secreted by cells transfected with chCNTF. In the present study we used a retroviral vector, RCASBP(A), to overexpress chCNTF in CG target tissues. Elevation of chCNTF biological activity three- to fourfold in the embryonic eye rescued an average of 31% of the neurons that would have normally died in vivo. In some individuals, nearly all of the neurons were rescued. ChCNTF had no effect on the number of neurons observed prior to cell death, nor were there any deleterious effects of either viral infection or overexpression of CNTF. These results show that chCNTF is able to function in vivo as a trophic factor for CG neurons, and suggest that limited availability of trophic support is one of the factors regulating CG neuron survival during development. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 34: 283–293, 1998     

Cholinergic neuronotrophic factors: III. Developmental increase of trophic activity for chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons in their intraocular target tissues

Between stages 34 and 40 in the chick embryo, the ciliary ganglion (CG) undergoes a 50% loss of neurons. Such neuronal death is a common feature in neural development and it has been proposed that neurons are dependent for survival on trophic support from their target tissues. Using an in vitro bioassay it was previously shown in this laboratory that trophic activity for CG neurons is highly concentrated in eye structures containing CG target tissues. In the present study we have found that trophic activity in the eye increases markedly between stages 37 and 39, the time when neuronal death in the ciliary ganglion is ending. Thus, a developmental increase in trophic activity within the eye may be involved in determining neuronal survival in the CG. Furthermore, this study provides the first indication that the trophic content of target tissue is itself developmentally regulated.     

Interactions between neurons and their targets during in vivo synaptogenesis.

In vivo synaptogenesis is described in a simple vertebrate system, the chick ciliary ganglion, a parasympathetic autonomic ganglion. An attempt is made to integrate anatomical, physiological and biochemical observations during synapse formation in the ganglion and in the peripheral target structures; the iris, ciliary muscle, and smooth muscle of the choroid coat. The relationship between synaptogenesis and neuron survival is explored, and it is shown that a critically timed interaction between the neuron and target organ is necessary for full neuronal maturation and survival. The existence of an active competition between neurons for survival is documented, and the possible relationship between neuronal cell death and specificity of connections is discussed.     

Ultrastructural differences during embryonic cell death in normal and peripherally deprived ciliary ganglia

Normally occurring neuron death and that brought about by prior removal of the peripheral target organ was studied ultrastructurally in embryonic chick ciliary ganglion in order to better understand the mechanism of cell death in this system. Before the period of cell death, all neurons in the normal ganglion developed a well-organized rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) which coincided with peripheral synapse formation. None of the peripherally deprived neurons underwent this change, suggesting that some interaction with the periphery, possibly synapse formation, triggered them into the secretory state. Cell death in peripherally deprived neurons was signalled by nuclear changes followed by freeing of ribosomes from polysomes and RER and presumably cessation of protein synthesis. In contrast, normal cell death was brought about by dilation of the RER with eventual cytoplasmic disruption, nuclear changes appearing only secondarily. It is suggested that failure to form or maintain peripheral synapses could result in the accumulation of transmission-related proteins with consequent cisternal dilation, and eventual cell death.     

Cloning, expression during development, and evidence for release of a trophic factor for ciliary ganglion neurons.

Ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons undergo a period of cell death during development that may be regulated by the limited availability of trophic factor produced by their target tissues. We have previously reported the purification of a ciliary neurotrophic factor from adult chick sciatic nerve that we called growth promoting activity (GPA). Here we demonstrate that GPA can be purified and cloned from embryonic day 15 (E15) chick eyes, which contain all the target tissues of the CG. Our studies show the following: GPA mRNA is induced in embryonic chick eyes during the period of CG neuron cell death; GPA mRNA is expressed specifically in the layer of the eye that contains the targets of the CG and in primary cultures of smooth muscle cells isolated from the choroid layer of the eye; and biologically active GPA is released from cells transfected with a GPA cDNA.     

Fate of ganglionic synapses and ganglion cell axons during normal and induced cell death

In order to understand the significance of cell death in the formation of neural circuits, it is necessary to determine whether before cell death neurons have (a) sent axons to the periphery; (b) reached the proper target organs; and (c) have established synaptic connections with them. Axon counts demonstrated that, after sending out initial axons, ciliary cells sprouted numerous collaterals at the time of peripheral synapse formation. Subsequently, large numbers of axons were lost from the nerves, slightly later than the onset of ganglion cell death. A secondary loss of collaterals later occurred unaccompanied by cell death. Measurements of conduction velocity and axon diameters indicated that all ganglion cell axons grew down the proper pathways from the start, but it was not possible to determine whether all axons had actually formed proper synapses. This was ascertained, however, in the ganglion itself where preganglionic fibres were shown to synapse selectively with all ganglion cells before cell death. During this period, degenerating preganglionic synapses were observed on normal cells. It can therefore be inferred that at least some preganglionics established proper synapses before dying and that a single synapse is not sufficient to prevent cell death. In this system neither preganglionic nor ganglionic cell death seems designed to remove improper connections but rather to remove cells that have not competed effectively for a sufficient number of synapses, resulting in a quantitative matching up of neuron numbers.     

The development of the neurons of the glossopharyngeal (IX) and vagal (X) sensory ganglia in chick embryos

The timetable of cell generation, neuronal death and neuron numbers in the fused proximal glossopharyngeal (IX) and vagal (X) ganglion and distal IX and X ganglia were studied in normal and nerve growth factor (NGF) treated chick embryos. 3H-thymidine was injected between the 3rd and 7th days of incubation and embryos sacrificed on the 11th day. Neurons in the distal IX and X ganglia were generated between the 2nd and 5th days of incubation, the peak mitotic activity occurring on the 4th and 3rd days, respectively. Neurons of the proximal IX and X ganglion were generated between the 4th and 7th days, with maximum neuron generation on the 5th day of incubation. Counts of neurons in the 3 ganglia between the 5th and 18th days of incubation showed a maximum of 22,000 on the 8th day in the proximal IX and X ganglion and this decreased to 12,000 by the 13th day. In the distal IX ganglion, the neuron number decreased by 44% from 4,500 on the 6th day to 2,500 by the 11th day. A similar decrease of 43% was found in the distal X ganglion, the neuron number falling from 11,500 on the 7th day to 6,500 by the 11th day of incubation. Neuronal cell death in these ganglia extended from the 5th to the 12th day of incubation, maximum cell death occurring at or after the cessation of mitotic activity. NGF administration from the 5th to the 11th day of incubation did not have a measurable effect on the neurons of proximal IX and X and distal IX ganglia, but increased neuronal survival by 30% in the distal X ganglion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Prevention of apoptosis in CNTF-dependent neurons by a mutant ICE and by viral protein CrmA but not by proto-oncogene product Bcl-2

The interleukin-1beta converting enzyme (ICE) gene family, (homologues of C. elegans cell death gene product Ced-3) plays an important role in controlling programmed cell death. Nerve growth factor (NGF) promotes survival of cultured embryonic chicken dorsal root ganglion neurons. Ciliary ganglion neurons depend exclusively on ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) for survival. Complete depletion of NGF or CNTF from culture medium induces apoptosis in both types of neurons. We can prevent apoptosis, due either to NGF or CNTF withdrawal and in either type of neuron, by overexpression of a mutant inactive ICE and an ICE inhibitor, the product of cowpox virus gene crmA. Bcl-2 does not prevent apoptosis in CNTF-dependent ciliary neurons or DRG neurons as it does in NGF-dependent neurons. These results suggest that neuronal cell death is mediated through a common effector mechanism involving the Ice family of genes, whereas different suppression mechanisms are engaged depending upon the specific neurotrophic factors present.     

GDNF and neurturin are target-derived factors essential for cranial parasympathetic neuron development

During development, parasympathetic ciliary ganglion neurons arise from the neural crest and establish synaptic contacts on smooth and striate muscle in the eye. The factors that promote the ciliary ganglion pioneer axons to grow toward their targets have yet to be determined. Here, we show that glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and neurturin (NRTN) constitute target-derived factors for developing ciliary ganglion neurons. Both GDNF and NRTN are secreted from eye muscle located in the target and trajectory pathway of ciliary ganglion pioneer axons during the period of target innervation. After this period, however, the synthesis of GDNF declines markedly, while that of NRTN is maintained throughout the cell death period. Furthermore, both in vitro and in vivo function-blocking of GDNF at early embryonic ages almost entirely suppresses ciliary axon outgrowth. These results demonstrate that target-derived GDNF is necessary for ciliary ganglion neurons to innervate ciliary muscle in the eye. Since the down-regulation of GDNF in the eye is accompanied by down-regulation of GFRalpha1 and Ret, but not of GFRalpha2, in innervating ciliary ganglion neurons, the results also suggest that target-derived GDNF regulates the expression of its high-affinity coreceptors.     

The development of ACH- and GABA-activated currents in normal and target-deprived embryonic chick ciliary ganglia

We have examined the expression of functional ACh and GABA receptors on embryonic chick ciliary ganglion neurons between Stages (St) 29 and 44 (Embryonic Day 6 to Embryonic Day 18). Whole-cell currents activated by ACh or GABA were measured in neurons 3-6 hr after dissociation to estimate the level of functional receptors in vivo. The mean peak IACh increased sevenfold between St 29 (321 pA) and St 44 (2345 pA) in two steps, separated by a plateau between St 35 and St 38 (E9 to E12). Cell size, estimated from measurements of membrane capacitance, increased only threefold over the same interval. Moreover, IACh and cell size were not well correlated at any stage examined. IGABA increased twofold between St 29 and St 38; the change was gradual and without any indication of two phases. The increase in IACh during development was not dependent on innervation of target cells within the eye. We removed the primordial eye between St 11 and St 13 (E2) and allowed the embryos to mature to various stages. Despite a small (20-50%) reduction in IACh at every stage examined, IACh still increased dramatically (about 10-fold) between St 29 and St 44 in target-deprived neurons. IACh was not uniquely affected by early target removal; IGABA and capacitance were also slightly reduced in target-deprived neurons.     

Target-derived molecules that influence the development of neurons in the avian ciliary ganglion

The developing avian ciliary ganglion has been a particularly amenable system for the identification, isolation, and characterization of putative target-derived molecules that mediate retrograde interaction. To date a number of biochemically distinct activities that regulate neuronal survival, transmitter phenotype, and chemosensitivity of ciliary ganglion neruons have been identified. Of these, only two survival-promoting molecules have been purified to homogeneity: ciliary neurotrophic factor and a related molecule, growth-promoting activity. A somatostatin-inducing activity found in cultured choroid cells is very likely to be chick activin A. Other molecules that regulate acetylcholine and acetylcholine receptor expression comigrate on a gel filtration column at a molecular weight of 50–60 kD, but they have yet to be isolated. Once molecules that mimic retrorgrade influences are identified, a number of criteria must be met before their physiological significance can be established. These criteria are (1) availability of the molecule from the target at the appropriate time in development: (2) ability of the neurons to respond to the molecule at the appropriate time in development: (3) demonstration that blocking the activity or availability of the molecule is able to block the target-derived developmental change expressed in the neurons. Of the molecules that are thought to retrogradely influence ciliary neuron development, only growth-promoting activity is known to meet criteria 1 and 2, and experiments of growth-promoting activity in vivo will exacerbate normal cell death. 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Differential effects of ret and TRKB on axonal branching and survival of parasympathetic neurons

Interactions between neurons and their targets of innervation influence many aspects of neural development. To examine how synaptic activity interacts with neurotrophic signaling, we determined the effects of blocking neuromuscular transmission on survival and axonal outgrowth of ciliary neurons from the embryonic chicken ciliary ganglion. Ciliary neurons undergo a period of cell loss due to programmed cell death between embryonic Days (E) 8 and 14 and they innervate the striated muscle of the iris. The nicotinic antagonist d‐tubocurarine (dTC) induces an increase in branching measured by counting neurofilament‐positive voxels (NF‐VU) in the iris between E14‐17 while reducing ciliary neuron survival. Blocking ganglionic transmission with dihyro‐β‐erythroidin and α‐methyllycacontine does not mimic dTC. At E8, many trophic factors stimulate neurite outgrowth and branching of neurons placed in cell culture; however, at E13, only GDNF stimulates branching selectively in cultured ciliary neurons. The GDNF‐induced branching at E13 could be inhibited by BDNF. Blocking ret signaling in vivo with a dominant negative (dn)ret decreases survival of ciliary and choroid neurons at E14 and prevents dTC induced increases in NF‐VU in the iris at E17. Blocking TRKB signaling with dn TRKB increases NF‐VU in the iris at E17 and decreases neuronal survival at E17, but not at E14. Thus, RET promotes survival during programmed cell death in the ciliary ganglion and contributes to promoting branching when synaptic transmission is blocked while TRKB inhibits branching and promotes maintenance of neuronal survival. These studies highlight the multifunctional nature of trophic molecule function during neuronal development. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Develop Neurobiol, 2013     

Trophic effects of androgen: development and hormonal regulation of neuron number in a sexually dimorphic vocal motor nucleus.

In Xenopus laevis, the laryngeal motor nucleus (n. of cranial nerves IX-X) is part of a sexually differentiated, androgen sensitive neuromuscular system devoted to vocalization. Adult males have more n. IX-X neurons than females; however, during development of n. IX-X, the rate of neurogenesis does not appear to differ between the sexes. In this study, we explored the role of naturally occurring cell death in the development of this nucleus and asked whether cell death might be involved in establishing the sex difference in neuron number. Counts of n. IX-X neurons reveal that at tadpole stage 56, males and females have similar numbers of n. IX-X neurons, but by stage 64 male neuron numbers are greater. This sex difference arises owing to a greater net loss of neurons in females-males lose approximately 25% of their n. IX-X neurons between stages 56 and 64, while females lose approximately 47%. Sexual differentiation of n. IX-X neuron number coincides with a period of developmental cell death, as evidenced by terminal transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling and the presence of pyknotic nuclei in n. IX-X. A role for gonadal hormones in controlling cell number was examined by treating tadpoles with exogenous androgen and determining the number of n. IX-X neurons at stage 64. Dihydrotestosterone (DHT) treatment from the beginning of the cell death period (stage 54) until stage 64 had no effect on the number of n. IX-X neurons in males but did significantly increase n. IX-X neuron number in females. This increase was sufficient to abolish the sex difference normally observed at stage 64. Although DHT induced increases in female neuron number, it did not induce increases in cell proliferation or addition of newly born neurons to n. IX-X. DHT may therefore have increased neuron number by protecting cells from death. We conclude that androgens can influence the survival of n. IX-X neurons during a period of naturally occurring cell death, and that this action of androgen is critical to the development of sex differences in n. IX-X neuron number.     

Time-course of apoptosis in the olfactory epithelium of rainbow trout exposed to a low copper level

Copper at low doses is known to specifically induce olfactory neuron death in fish olfactory epithelium. Using light and electron transmission microscopy, we have investigated the features and the time-course of receptor cell death in rainbow trout exposed for 15 days to 20 mug Cu(2+)/l. Ultrastructural observations demonstrate that degenerating cells, which included both mature and immature neurons, exhibited morphological changes characteristic of a cell death by apoptosis. Quantitative analysis shows that the number of apoptotic cells increased significantly already after 1 day of exposure, reaching a peak at day 5. From this timepoint of exposure, no more mature neuron was noted in the olfactory epithelium. Following a significant decrease in the number of apoptotic cells at day 10, a second wave of neuron death was noted at day 15. These findings argue for the occurrence of a neurogenesis process to balance the receptor cell death, despite continued copper exposure, and for a higher vulnerability to the metal of olfactory neurons presenting more advanced stages of cell differentiation. The molecular mechanisms by which copper may induce olfactory neuron apoptosis are discussed.     

Target-derived BMP signaling limits sensory neuron number and the extent of peripheral innervation in vivo

The role of target-derived BMP signaling in development of sensory ganglia and the sensory innervation of the skin was examined in transgenic animals that overexpress either the BMP inhibitor noggin or BMP4 under the control of a keratin 14 (K14) promoter. Overexpression of noggin resulted in a significant increase in the number of neurons in the trigeminal and dorsal root ganglia. Conversely, overexpression of BMP4 resulted in a significant decrease in the number of dorsal root ganglion neurons. There was no significant change in proliferation of trigeminal ganglion neurons in the noggin transgenic animals, and neuron numbers did not undergo the normal developmental decrease between E12.5 and the adult, suggesting that programmed cell death was decreased in these animals. The increase in neuron numbers in the K14-noggin animals was followed by an extraordinary increase in the density of innervation in the skin and a marked change in the pattern of innervation by different types of fibers. Conversely, the density of innervation of the skin was decreased in the BMP4 overexpressing animals. Further Merkel cells and their innervation were increased in the K14-noggin mice and decreased in the K14-BMP4 mice. The changes in neuron numbers and the density of innervation were not accompanied by a change in the levels of neurotrophins in the skin. These findings indicate that the normal developmental decrease in neuron numbers in sensory ganglia depends upon BMP signaling, and that BMPs may limit both the final neuron number in sensory ganglia as well as the extent of innervation of targets. Coupled with prior observations, this suggests that BMP signaling may regulate the acquisition of dependence of neurons on neurotrophins for survival, as well as their dependence on target-derived neurotrophins for determining the density of innervation of the target.     

Regulation of neuronal K(+) currents by target-derived factors: opposing actions of two different isoforms of TGFbeta.

The developmental expression of macroscopic Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in chick ciliary ganglion neurons is dependent on an avian ortholog of TGFbeta1, known as TGFbeta4, secreted from target tissues in the eye. Here we report that a different isoform, TGFbeta3, is also expressed in a target tissue of ciliary ganglion neurons. Application of TGFbeta3 inhibits the functional expression of whole-cell Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents evoked by 12 hour treatment with either TGFbeta1 or beta-neuregulin-1 in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vitro. TGFbeta3 had no effect on voltage-activated Ca(2+) currents. A neutralizing antiserum specific for TGFbeta3 potentiates stimulation of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents evoked by a target tissue (iris) extract in cultured ciliary ganglion neurons, indicating that TGFbeta3 is an inhibitory component of these extracts. Intraocular injection of TGFbeta3 causes a modest but significant inhibition of the expression of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo. Further, intraocular injection of a TGFbeta3-neutralizing antiserum stimulates expression of Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo, indicating that endogenous TGFbeta3 regulates the functional expression of this current. The normal developmental expression of functional Ca(2+)-activated K(+) currents in ciliary ganglion neurons developing in vivo is therefore regulated by two different target-derived isoforms of TGFbeta, which produce opposing effects on the electrophysiological differentiation of these neurons.     

Trophic effects of androgen: Development and hormonal regulation of neuron number in a sexually dimorphic vocal motor nucleus

In Xenopus laevis, the laryngeal motor nucleus (n. of cranial nerves IX‐X) is part of a sexually differentiated, androgen sensitive neuromuscular system devoted to vocalization. Adult males have more n. IX‐X neurons than females; however, during development of n. IX‐X, the rate of neurogenesis does not appear to differ between the sexes. In this study, we explored the role of naturally occurring cell death in the development of this nucleus and asked whether cell death might be involved in establishing the sex difference in neuron number. Counts of n. IX‐X neurons reveal that at tadpole stage 56, males and females have similar numbers of n. IX‐X neurons, but by stage 64 male neuron numbers are greater. This sex difference arises owing to a greater net loss of neurons in females—males lose ∼25% of their n. IX‐X neurons between stages 56 and 64, while females lose ∼47%. Sexual differentiation of n. IX‐X neuron number coincides with a period of developmental cell death, as evidenced by terminal transferase‐mediated dUTP nick‐end labeling and the presence of pyknotic nuclei in n. IX‐X. A role for gonadal hormones in controlling cell number was examined by treating tadpoles with exogenous androgen and determining the number of n. IX‐X neurons at stage 64. Dihydrotestosterone (DHT) treatment from the beginning of the cell death period (stage 54) until stage 64 had no effect on the number of n. IX‐X neurons in males but did significantly increase n. IX‐X neuron number in females. This increase was sufficient to abolish the sex difference normally observed at stage 64. Although DHT induced increases in female neuron number, it did not induce increases in cell proliferation or addition of newly born neurons to n. IX‐X. DHT may therefore have increased neuron number by protecting cells from death. We conclude that androgens can influence the survival of n. IX‐X neurons during a period of naturally occurring cell death, and that this action of androgen is critical to the development of sex differences in n. IX‐X neuron number. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 40: 375–385, 1999     

Ciliary ganglion neurons in cell culture: high affinity choline uptake and autoradiographic choline labeling

Chick ciliary ganglion neurons grown in dissociated cell culture have a high affinity uptake mechanism for choline that has the properties expected for cholinergic neurons. The uptake has an apparent K_m of ca. 0.3 μM and is blocked by addition of 10 μM hemicholinium-3 or replacement of Na⁺ by Li⁺ in the uptake medium. When the choline uptake mechanism is used to label ciliary ganglion neuron-myotube cultures autoradiographically, over 99% of the neurons are labeled. A few cells with neuronal morphologies in such cultures (<1%) are labeled by γ-[³H]aminobutyric acid uptake. The number of [³H]choline-labeled neurons and the amount of Na⁺-dependent choline uptake is the same for ciliary ganglion neurons grown with and without skeletal myotubes. Rat superior cervical ganglion neurons, grown in cell culture under conditions that induce them to synthesize acetylcholine and form cholinergic synapses, are labeled by [³H]choline uptake, though not as heavily as ciliary ganglion neurons. In contrast, chick dorsal root ganglion neurons, a presumed population of noncholinergic neurons, are not labeled by [³H]choline uptake. Thus high affinity choline uptake can be used to label autoradiographically the cholinergic neurons tested, while at least one population of noncholinergic neurons remains unlabeled.