Cutting edge: B cell antigen receptor signaling occurs outside lipid rafts in immature B cells

B cell Ag receptor (BCR) signaling changes dramatically during B cell development, resulting in activation in mature B cells and apoptosis, receptor editing, or anergy in immature B cells. BCR signaling in mature B cells was shown to be initiated by the translocation of the BCR into cholesterol- and sphingolipid-enriched membrane microdomains that include the Src family kinase Lyn and exclude the phosphatase CD45. Subsequently the BCR is rapidly internalized into the cell. Here we show that the BCR in the immature B cell line, WEHI-231, does not translocate into lipid rafts following cross-linking nor is the BCR rapidly internalized. The immature BCR initiates signaling from outside lipid rafts as evidenced by the immediate induction of an array of phosphoproteins and subsequent apoptosis. The failure of the BCR in immature B cells to enter lipid rafts may contribute to the dramatic difference in the outcome of signaling in mature and immature B cells.     

Ig alpha/Ig beta complexes generate signals for B cell development independent of selective plasma membrane compartmentalization

Ligand-induced BCR association with detergent-resistant plasma membrane compartments (lipid rafts) has been argued to be essential for initiating and/or sustaining Igalpha/Igbeta-dependent BCR signaling. Because a fraction of the BCR and an even larger fraction of the preBCR associates with lipid rafts in the apparent absence of ligand stimulation, it has been proposed that raft-associated receptor complexes mediate the ligand-independent basal signaling events observed in resting B lineage cells. However, there is no direct evidence that localization of Igalpha/Igbeta-containing complexes to detergent-resistant membrane compartments is absolutely required for the signaling events that drive B cell development. To address these issues we have designed surrogate preBCR/Igalpha/Igbeta complexes that are incapable of ligand-induced aggregation and that are preferentially targeted to either raft or nonraft compartments. An analysis of their ability to promote the preBCR-dependent proB-->preB cell transition of murine B cell progenitors revealed that expression of these surrogate receptor complexes at levels that approximate that of the conventional preBCR can drive B cell development in a manner independent of both aggregation and lipid raft localization.     

The B cell-specific major raft protein,Raftlin, is necessary for the integrity of lipid raft and BCR signal transduction

Recent evidence indicates that membrane microdomains, termed lipid rafts, have a role in B-cell activation as platforms for B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) signal initiation. To gain an insight into the possible functioning of lipid rafts in B cells, we applied liquid chromatography electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (LC-ESI-MS/MS) methodologies to the identification of proteins that co-purified with lipid rafts of Raji cells. Among these raft proteins, we characterized a novel protein termed Raftlin (raft-linking protein). Like the Src family kinase, Raftlin is localized exclusively in lipid rafts by fatty acylation of N-terminal Gly2 and Cys3, and is co-localized with BCR before and after BCR stimulation. Disruption of the Raftlin gene in the DT40 B-cell line resulted in a marked reduction in the quantity of lipid raft components, including Lyn and ganglioside GM1, while overexpression of Raftlin increased the content of raft protein. Moreover, BCR-mediated tyrosine phosphorylation and calcium mobilization were impaired by the lack of Raftlin and actually potentiated by overexpression of Raftlin. These data suggest that Raftlin plays a pivotal role in the formation and/or maintenance of lipid rafts, therefore regulating BCR-mediated signaling.     

A requirement for lipid rafts in B cell receptor induced Ca(2+) flux

Although the major biochemical events triggered by ligation of the B-cell receptor (BCR) have been well defined [1] [2], little is known about the spatio-temporal organization of BCR signaling components within the cell membrane and the mechanisms by which signaling specificity is achieved. Partitioning of signaling complexes into specialized domains in the plasma membrane may provide a mechanism for channeling specific stimuli into distinct signaling pathways. Here, we report that multiple tyrosine-phosphorylated proteins accumulate transiently upon BCR activation in detergent-insoluble membrane microdomains known as lipid rafts. We found an activation-dependent translocation to the rafts of the BCR itself, as well as phospholipase Cgamma2 (PLCgamma2), an enzyme critical for BCR-induced Ca(2+) flux in B cells. An intact raft structure was required for BCR-induced tyrosine phosphorylation of PLCgamma2 and the induction of Ca(2+) flux. Taken together, these data provide a functional role for lipid rafts in BCR signaling.     

Visualizing lipid raft dynamics and early signaling events during antigen receptor-mediated B-lymphocyte activation

Recent biochemical evidence indicates that an early event in signal transduction by the B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) is its translocation to specialized membrane subdomains known as lipid rafts. We have taken a microscopic approach to image lipid rafts and early events associated with BCR signal transduction. Lipid rafts were visualized on primary splenic B lymphocytes from wild-type or anti-hen egg lysozyme BCR transgenic mice, and on a mature mouse B-cell line Bal 17 by using fluorescent conjugates of cholera toxin B subunit or a Lyn-based chimeric protein, which targets green fluorescent protein to the lipid raft compartment. Time-lapse imaging of B cells stimulated via the BCR with the antigen hen egg lysozyme, or surrogate for antigen anti-IgM, demonstrated that lipid rafts are highly dynamic entities, which move laterally on the surface of these cells and coalesce into large regions. These regions of aggregated lipid rafts colocalized with the BCR and tyrosine-phosphorylated proteins. Microscopic imaging of live B cells also revealed an inducible colocalization of lipid rafts with the tyrosine kinase Syk and the receptor tyrosine phosphatase CD45. These two proteins play indispensable roles in BCR-mediated signaling but are not detectable in biochemically purified lipid raft fractions. Strikingly, BCR stimulation also induced the formation of long, thread-like filopodial projections, similar to previously described structures called cytonemes. These B-cell cytonemes are rich in lipid rafts and actin filaments, suggesting that they might play a role in long-range communication and/or transportation of signaling molecules during an immune response. These results provide a window into the morphological and molecular organization of the B-cell membrane during the early phase of BCR signaling.     

Live cell imaging reveals that the inhibitory FcgammaRIIB destabilizes B cell receptor membrane-lipid interactions and blocks immune synapse formation

The FcgammaRIIB is a potent regulator of BCR signaling and as such plays a decisive role in controlling autoimmunity. The use of advanced imaging technologies has provided evidence that the earliest events in Ag-induced BCR signaling include the clustering of the BCR, the selective and transient association of the clustered BCR with raft lipids, and the concentration of BCR clusters in an immune synapse. That lipid rafts play a role in FcgammaRIIB's regulation of BCR signaling was suggested by recent studies showing that a lupus-associated loss of function mutation resulted in the receptor's exclusion from lipid rafts and the failure to regulate BCR signaling. In this study, we provide evidence from both biochemical analyses and fluorescence resonance energy transfer in conjunction with both confocal and total internal reflection microscopy in living cells that the FcgammaRIIB, when coligated with the BCR, associates with lipid rafts and functions both to destabilize the association of the BCR with raft lipids and to block the subsequent formation of the B cell's immune synapse. These results define new early targets of FcgammaRIIB inhibitory activity in the Ag-induced B cell activation pathway.     

Syk-mediated tyrosine phosphorylation is required for the association of hematopoietic lineage cell-specific protein 1 with lipid rafts and B cell antigen receptor signalosome complex

Hematopoietic lineage cell-specific protein 1 (HS1) is an F-actin- and actin-related proteins 2 and 3 (Arp2/3)-binding protein that undergoes a rapid tyrosine phosphorylation upon B cell antigen receptor (BCR) activation. Density gradient centrifugation of Triton X-100 lysates from B lymphocytes demonstrated that HS1 was translocated in response to BCR cross-linking into lipid raft microdomain along with Arp2/3 complex and Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome protein. HS1-green fluorescent protein was localized in membrane patches enriched with GM1 gangliosides and BCR in the cells treated with anti-IgM antibody. Colocalization of HS1-green fluorescent protein with BCR was also correlated with tyrosine phosphorylation of HS1. Interestingly a murine HS1 mutant at the tyrosine residues Tyr388 and Tyr405 targeted by Syk failed to respond to BCR cross-linking for either translocation into lipid rafts or colocalization with BCR within cells. Furthermore HS1 was unable to translocate into lipid rafts in a chicken B cell line deficient in Syk. Reintroducing a Syk construct into the Syk knock-out cells recovered effectively both tyrosine phosphorylation and translocation of HS1 into lipid rafts. In contrast, translocation of HS1 into rafts was normal in a Lyn knock-out B cell line, and an HS1 mutant at the tyrosine residue Tyr222 targeted by Lyn maintained the ability to partition into rafts upon BCR cross-linking. These data indicate that Syk plays an important role in the translocation of HS1 into lipid rafts and may be responsible for actin assembly recruitment to rafts and subsequent antigen presentations.     

Developmental differences in B cell receptor-induced signal transduction

We have compared early signaling events at various stages of B cell differentiation using established mouse cell lines. Clustering of pre-B cell antigen receptor (BCR) or BCR induced the tyrosine phosphorylation of various proteins in all cells, although the phosphorylation pattern differed. In spite of the pre-BCR-induced tyrosine phosphorylation, we could not detect an intracellular Ca(2+) signal in pre-B cells. However, co-clustering of the pre-BCR with CD19 did induce Ca(2+) mobilization. In contrast to the immature and mature B cells, where the B cell linker protein (BLNK) went through inducible tyrosine phosphorylation upon BCR clustering, we observed a constitutive tyrosine phosphorylation of BLNK in pre-B cell lines. Both BLNK and phospholipase C (PLC)gamma were raft associated in unstimulated pre-B cells, and this could not be enhanced by pre-BCR engagement, suggesting a ligand-independent PLC gamma-mediated signaling. Further results indicate that the cell lines representing the immature stage are more sensitive to BCR-, CD19- and type II receptors binding the Fc part of IgG (Fc gamma RIIb)-mediated signals than mature B cells.     

Transient translocation of the B cell receptor and Src homology 2 domain-containing inositol phosphatase to lipid rafts: evidence toward a role in calcium regulation

Membrane microdomains (lipid rafts) are enriched in selected signaling molecules and may compartmentalize receptor-mediated signals. Here, we report that in primary human B lymphocytes and in Ramos B cells B cell receptor (BCR) stimulation induces rapid and transient redistribution of a subset of engaged BCRs to lipid rafts and phosphorylation of raft-associated tyrosine kinase substrates. Cholesterol sequestration disrupted the lipid rafts, preventing BCR redistribution, but did not inhibit tyrosine kinase activation or phosphorylation of mitogen-activated protein kinase/extracellular regulated kinase. However, raft disruption enhanced the release of calcium from intracellular stores, suggesting that rafts may sequester early signaling events that down-regulate calcium flux. Consistent with this, BCR stimulation induced rapid and transient translocation of the Src homology 2 domain-containing inositol phosphatase, SHIP, into lipid rafts.     

Membrane cholesterol content accounts for developmental differences in surface B cell receptor compartmentalization and signaling

Recent studies argue for an important role for cholesterol in maintaining plasma membrane heterogeneity and influencing a variety of cellular processes, including signaling, adhesion, and permeability. Here, we document that tolerance-sensitive transitional immature B cells maintain significantly lower membrane unesterified cholesterol levels than mature-stage splenic B cells. In addition, the relatively low level of cholesterol in transitional immature B cells impairs compartmentalization of their B cell receptor (BCR) into cholesterol-enriched domains following BCR aggregation and reduces their ability to sustain certain aspects of BCR signaling as compared with mature B cells. These studies establish an unexpected difference in the lipid composition of peripheral transitional immature and mature B cells and point to a determining role for development-associated differences in cholesterol content for the differential responses of these B cells to BCR engagement.     

The tetraspanin CD81 is necessary for partitioning of coligated CD19/CD21-B cell antigen receptor complexes into signaling-active lipid rafts

Tetraspanins have been hypothesized to facilitate the organization of functional multimolecular membrane complexes. In B cells the tetraspanin CD81 is a component of the CD19/CD21 complex. When coligated to the B cell Ag receptor (BCR), the CD19/CD21 complex significantly enhances BCR signaling in part by prolonging the association of the BCR with signaling-active lipid rafts. In this study CD81 is shown to associate with lipid rafts upon coligation of the BCR and the CD19/CD21 complex. Using B cells from CD81-deficient mice we demonstrate that in the absence of CD81, coligated BCR and CD19/CD21 complexes fail to partition into lipid rafts and enhance BCR signaling from rafts. Furthermore, a chimeric CD19 protein that associates only weakly if at all with CD81 fails to promote the association of coligated BCR with lipid rafts. The requirement for CD81 to promote lipid raft association may define a novel mechanism by which tetraspanins function as molecular facilitators of signaling receptors.     

Fc gamma RIIB1/SHIP-mediated inhibitory signaling in B cells involves lipid rafts

One type of membrane microdomain, enriched in glycosphingolipids and cholesterol and referred to as lipid rafts, has been implicated in the generation of activating signals triggered by a variety of stimuli. Several laboratories, including ours, have recently demonstrated that the B cell receptor (BCR) inducibly localizes to the rafts upon activation and that functional lipid rafts are important for BCR-mediated "positive" signaling. In the later phases of the immune response, coligation of the BCR and the inhibitory receptor Fc gamma RIIB1 leads to potent inhibition of BCR-induced positive signaling through the recruitment of the inositol phosphatase SHIP to Fc gamma RIIB1. One potential model is that the Fc gamma RIIB1 itself might be excluded from the rafts basally and that destabilization of raft-dependent BCR signaling might be part of the mechanism for the Fc gamma RIIB1-mediated negative regulation. We tested this hypothesis and observed that preventing BCR raft localization is not the mechanism for this inhibition. Surprisingly, a fraction of Fc gamma RIIB1 is constitutively localized in the rafts and increases further after BCR + FcR coligation. SHIP is actively recruited to lipid rafts under negative stimulation conditions, and the majority of Fc gamma RIIB1-SHIP complexes localize to lipid rafts compared with non-raft regions of the plasma membrane. This suggested that this negative feedback loop is also initiated in the lipid rafts. Despite its basal localization to the rafts, Fc gamma RIIB1 did not become phosphorylated after BCR alone cross-linking and did not colocalize with the BCR that moves to rafts upon BCR engagement alone (positive signaling conditions), perhaps suggesting the existence of different subsets of rafts. Taken together, these data suggest that lipid rafts play a role in both the positive signaling via the BCR as well as the inhibitory signaling through Fc gamma RIIB1/SHIP.     

Clustering of the B cell receptor is not required for the apoptotic response

We examined the role of BCR cell membrane redistribution in anti-IgM-induced apoptosis in three human B cell lines, RA#1, 2G6, and MC116, that differ in their relative levels of sIgM expression. The apoptotic response was found to be dependent on the nature of the anti-IgM and the cell line. In the cell lines, RA#1 and MC116, sIgM aggregated into patches that were insensitive to the disruption of cholesterol-rich membrane microdomains by nystatin or beta-MCD. The B cell line 2G6 was able to reorganize sIgM into a tight coalescent cap upon anti-IgM treatment. However, in this case, the lipid raft inhibitors nystatin and beta-MCD disrupted the patching. In 2G6 cells, BCR-mediated apoptosis was not affected by nystatin treatment, whereas it increased in beta-MCD pretreated cells. Thus, no evident correlation was found between apoptosis and BCR cell membrane redistribution or lipid raft formation in either of the three cell lines. The data indicate that the apoptotic signal transduction pathway is independent of BCR translocation into lipid rafts and/or aggregation.     

Transitional B lymphocyte subsets operate as distinct checkpoints in murine splenic B cell development

Signaling through the Ag receptor is required for peripheral B lymphocyte maturation and maintenance. Defects in components of the B cell receptor (BCR) signalosome result in developmental blocks at the transition from immature (heat-stable Ag (HSA)(high)) to mature (HSA(low)) B cells. Recent studies have subdivided the immature, or transitional, splenic B cells into two subsets, transitional 1 (T1) and transitional 2 (T2) cells. T1 and T2 cells express distinct surface markers and are located in distinct anatomic locations. In this report, we evaluated the BCR signaling capacity of T1 and T2 B cell subsets. In response to BCR engagement, T2 cells rapidly entered cell cycle and resisted cell death. In contrast, T1 cells did not proliferate and instead died after BCR stimulation. Correlating with these results, T2 cells robustly induced expression of the cell cycle regulator cyclin D2 and the antiapoptotic factors A1/Bfl-1 and Bcl-x(L) and exhibited activation of Akt. In contrast, T1 cells failed to up-regulate these markers. BCR stimulation of T2 cells also led to down-regulation of CD21 and CD24 (HSA) expression, resulting in a mature B cell phenotype. In addition, T2 cells from Bruton's tyrosine kinase-deficient Xid mice failed to generate these proliferative and survival responses, suggesting a requirement for the BCR signalosome specifically at the T2 stage. Taken together, these data clearly demonstrate that T2 immature B cells comprise a discrete developmental subset that mediates BCR-dependent proliferative, prosurvival, and differentiation signals. Their distinct BCR-dependent responses suggest unique roles for T1 vs T2 cells in peripheral B cell selection.     

High-resolution FRET microscopy of cholera toxin B-subunit and GPI-anchored proteins in cell plasma membranes

"Lipid rafts" enriched in glycosphingolipids (GSL), GPI-anchored proteins, and cholesterol have been proposed as functional microdomains in cell membranes. However, evidence supporting their existence has been indirect and controversial. In the past year, two studies used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy to probe for the presence of lipid rafts; rafts here would be defined as membrane domains containing clustered GPI-anchored proteins at the cell surface. The results of these studies, each based on a single protein, gave conflicting views of rafts. To address the source of this discrepancy, we have now used FRET to study three different GPI-anchored proteins and a GSL endogenous to several different cell types. FRET was detected between molecules of the GSL GM1 labeled with cholera toxin B-subunit and between antibody-labeled GPI-anchored proteins, showing these raft markers are in submicrometer proximity in the plasma membrane. However, in most cases FRET correlated with the surface density of the lipid raft marker, a result inconsistent with significant clustering in microdomains. We conclude that in the plasma membrane, lipid rafts either exist only as transiently stabilized structures or, if stable, comprise at most a minor fraction of the cell surface.     

Cutting edge: differential sequestration of plasma membrane-associated B cell antigen receptor in mature and immature B cells into glycosphingolipid-enriched domains

Glycosphingolipid-enriched domains (GEDs) are believed to act as platforms for transduction of B cell Ag receptor (BCR)-induced signals from the cell surface. We sought to study whether differential sequestration of BCR into GEDs may contribute to the described intrinsic signaling differences between mature and immature B cells. In this study we found that mature B cells copolarize the BCR with GEDs following BCR aggregation, whereas transitional immature B cells do not. Although anti-BCR treatment leads to receptor aggregation by immature stage B cells, the aggregated complexes do not colocalize with GEDs. We found this difference to be independent of the isotype of the receptor, thereby associating this difference in BCR-GED colocalization to the developmental stage of the B cell. These findings suggest a structural basis for the developmentally regulated differences observed in Ag receptor-mediated signal transduction.     

Activation of Bad trafficking is involved in the BCR-mediated apoptosis of immature B cells

The activity of Bad, a pro-apoptotic protein, is regulated by reversible phosphorylation. Moreover, sequestration of Bad within subcellular compartments may be a new mechanism of apoptosis regulation. In this study, we report that Bad interacts with 14-3-3 protein in WEHI-231 immature B cells. This association is disrupted following BCR stimulation in correlation with Bad translocation to mitochondria and apoptosis. Confocal microscopy was further used to examine the co-localization of Bad with lipid rafts in WEHI-231 and murineex vivoB cells. Bad was found colocalized to lipid rafts in freshly isolated mature B lymphocytes, in contrast to immature cells. Finally, co-immunoprecipitation experiments performed on WEHI-231 B cells revealed that PP1α interacts with Bcl-2 and Bad, and dissociation of the complex was found correlated with appearance of apoptosis. Bcl-2 seemed to be required to assemble the complex which may regulate Bad phosphorylation status and consequently cell survival. Collectively, present data outline the role of Bad trafficking in the BCR-mediated apoptosis and suggest that differences in intracellular Bad trafficking may be involved in the differential outcome of BCR signaling.     

Plasticity of B cell receptor internalization upon conditional depletion of clathrin

B cell antigen receptor (BCR) association with lipid rafts, the actin cytoskeleton, and clathrin-coated pits influences B cell signaling and antigen presentation. Although all three cellular structures have been separately implicated in BCR internalization, the relationship between them has not been clearly defined. In this study, internalization pathways were characterized by specifically blocking each potential mechanism of internalization. BCR uptake was reduced by approximately 70% in B cells conditionally deficient in clathrin heavy chain expression. Actin or raft antagonists were both able to block the residual, clathrin-independent BCR internalization. These agents also affected clathrin-dependent internalization, indicating that clathrin-coated pits, in concert with mechanisms dependent on rafts and actin, mediate the majority of BCR internalization. Clustering G(M1) gangliosides enhanced clathrin-independent BCR internalization, and this required actin. Thus, although rafts or actin independently did not mediate BCR internalization, they apparently cooperate to promote some internalization even in the absence of clathrin. Simultaneous inhibition of all BCR uptake pathways resulted in sustained tyrosine phosphorylation and activation of the extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), strongly suggesting that downstream BCR signaling can occur without receptor translocation to endosomes and that internalization leads to signal attenuation.     

Polyvalent antigens stabilize B cell antigen receptor surface signaling microdomains

The B cell Ag receptor (BCR) can distinguish subtle differences in Ag structure and trigger differential responses. In this study, we analyzed the effects of Ag valency on the signaling and Ag-targeting functions of the BCR. Although both paucivalent and polyvalent Ags induced the redistribution of the surface BCR into polarized caps, polyvalent Ag-induced BCR caps persisted. Ganglioside G(M1), a lipid raft marker, and tyrosine-phosphorylated proteins, but not CD45 and transferrin receptor, were concentrated in BCR caps, suggesting BCR caps as surface-signaling microdomains. Prolonged BCR caps were concomitant with an increase in the level and duration of protein tyrosine phosphorylation and a reduction in BCR internalization and movement to late endosomes/lysosomes. Thus, Ag valency influences B cell responses by modulating the stability of BCR-signaling microdomains and BCR trafficking.