Effects of External Transport on Discrimination Between Perfect and Mismatch Duplexes on Gel-Based Oligonucleotide Microchips

Abstract

Using hydrogel-based oligonucleotide microchips developed previously for the choice of drugs during leukemia treatment and the other diseases, it is shown that the acceleration of external transport by mixing buffer solution with peristaltic pump not only enhances the observable fluorescence signals, but also improves significantly the discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes at the intermediate stage of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchips. The discrimination efficiency for a given hybridization time grows monotonously with the frequency of flow pulsations. The mixing with frequency 10 Hz accelerates the hybridization rate approximately thrice and improves the discrimination efficiency 1.5–2.5 times higher for overnight hybridization. To study these effects, we have developed the special peristaltic pump mixing solution in a hybridization chamber of 35 μl in volume (area ~1 × 1 cm² and height 0.3 mm). We present also the brief theoretical summary for the interpretation and assessment of the observed experimental features.     

Kinetics of hybridization on surface oligonucleotide microchips: theory, experiment, and comparison with hybridization on gel-based microchips

The optimal design of oligonucleotide microchips and efficient discrimination between perfect and mismatch duplexes strongly depend on the external transport of target DNA to the cells with immobilized probes as well as on respective association and dissociation rates at the duplex formation. In this paper we present the relevant theory for hybridization of DNA fragments with oligonucleotide probes immobilized in the cells on flat substrate. With minor modifications, our theory also is applicable to reaction-diffusion hybridization kinetics for the probes immobilized on the surface of microbeads immersed in hybridization solution. The main theoretical predictions are verified with control experiments. Besides that, we compared the characteristics of the surface and gel-based oligonucleotide microchips. The comparison was performed for the chips printed with the same pin robot, for the signals measured with the same devices and processed by the same technique, and for the same hybridization conditions. The sets of probe oligonucleotides and the concentrations of probes in respective solutions used for immobilization on each platform were identical as well. We found that, despite the slower hybridization kinetics, the fluorescence signals and mutation discrimination efficiency appeared to be higher for the gel-based microchips with respect to their surface counterparts even for the relatively short hybridization time about 0.5-1 hour. Both the divergence between signals for perfects and the difference in mutation discrimination efficiency for the counterpart platforms rapidly grow with incubation time. In particular, for hybridization during 3 h the signals for gel-based microchips surpassed their surface counterparts in 5-20 times, while the ratios of signals for perfect-mismatch pairs for gel microchips exceeded the corresponding ratios for surface microchips in 2-4 times. These effects may be attributed to the better immobilization efficiency and to the higher thermodynamic association constants for duplex formation within gel pads.     

Effect of mixing on reaction-diffusion kinetics for protein hydrogel-based microchips

Protein hydrogel-based microchips are being developed for high-throughput evaluation of the concentrations and activities of various proteins. To shorten the time of analysis, the reaction-diffusion kinetics on gel microchips should be accelerated. Here we present the results of the experimental and theoretical analysis of the reaction-diffusion kinetics enforced by mixing with peristaltic pump. The experiments were carried out on gel-based protein microchips with immobilized antibodies under the conditions utilized for on-chip immunoassay. The dependence of fluorescence signals at saturation and corresponding saturation times on the concentrations of immobilized antibodies and antigen in solution proved to be in good agreement with theoretical predictions. It is shown that the enhancement of transport with peristaltic pump results in more than five-fold acceleration of binding kinetics. Our results suggest useful criteria for the optimal conditions for assays on gel microchips to balance high sensitivity and rapid fluorescence saturation kinetics.     

Discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes with oligonucleotide gel microchips: role of thermodynamic and kinetic effects during hybridization

The efficiency of discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes during hybridization on microchips depends on the concentrations of target DNA in solution and immobilized probes, buffer composition, and temperature of hybridization and is determined by both thermodynamic relationships and hybridization kinetics. In this work, optimal conditions of discrimination were studied using hybridization of fluorescently labeled target DNA with custom-made gel-based oligonucleotide microchips. The higher the concentration of immobilized probes and the higher the association constant, the higher the concentration of the formed duplexes and the stronger the corresponding fluorescence signal, but, simultaneously, the longer the time needed to reach equilibrium. Since mismatched duplexes hybridize faster than their perfect counterparts, perfect-to-mismatch signal ratio is lower in transient regime, and short hybridization times may hamper the detection of mutations. The saturation time can be shortened by decreasing the probe concentration or augmenting the gel porosity. This improves the detection of mutations in transient regime. It is shown that the decrease in the initial concentration of oligonucleotide probes by an order of magnitude causes only 1.5-2.5-fold decrease of fluorescence signals after hybridization of perfect duplexes for 3-12 h. At the same time, these conditions improve the discrimination between perfect and mismatched duplexes more than two-fold. A similar improvement may be obtained using an optimized dissociation procedure.     

Parallel thermodynamic analysis of duplexes on oligodeoxyribonucleotide microchips.

A microchip method has been developed for massive and parallel thermodynamic analyses of DNA duplexes. Fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides were hybridized with oligonucleotides immobilized in the 100 x 100 x 20 mum gel pads of the microchips. The equilibrium melting curves for all microchip duplexes were measured in real time in parallel for all microchip duplexes. Thermodynamic data for perfect and mismatched duplexes that were obtained using the microchip method directly correlated with data obtained in solution. Fluorescent labels or longer linkers between the gel and the oligonucleotides appeared to have no significant effect on duplex stability. Extending the immobilized oligonucleotides with a four-base mixture from the 3'-end or one or two universal bases (5-nitroindole) from the 3'- and/or 5'-end increased the stabilities of their duplexes. These extensions were applied to increase the stabilities of the duplexes formed with short oligonucleotides in microchips, to significantly lessen the differences in melting curves of the AT- and GC-rich duplexes, and to improve discrimination of perfect duplexes from those containing poorly recognized terminal mismatches. This study explored a way to increase the efficiency of sequencing by hybridization on oligonucleotide microchips.     

Kinetics of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchips with gel pads

The kinetics of hybridization on the oligonucleotide microchip with gel pads is studied both theoretically and experimentally. The monitoring of kinetics was performed with the measurements of fluorescence intensity produced by the labeled target oligonucleotides. As is shown, the hybridization time depends on the stability of the formed duplexes, the concentrations of target and probe oligonucleotides, and the diffusion of target oligonucleotides in solution and gel pad. The initial stage of hybridization is determined by the flow of target oligonucleotides from solution, then, followed by the diffusive propagation with approximately constant concentration of oligonucleotides at the boundary of gel pad and, finally, by the exponential saturation. The theoretical predictions of hybridization kinetics reveal a good correspondence with the experimental results and may be used for the choice of the optimal hybridization conditions. The possible applications of kinetic hybridization curves to the discrimination problems and assessment of diffusion coefficients in gel pads are briefly discussed. Finally, we discuss the relationships between the binding kinetics and the general functioning of biomolecular microchips.     

Manual Manufacturing of Oligonucleotide, DNA, and Protein Microchips

A simple procedure for manufacturing microchips containing various gel-immobilized compounds is described. A gel photopolymerization technique is introduced to produce micromatrices of polyacrylamide gel pads (25 × 25 × 20 μm and larger) separated by a hydrophobic glass surface. A pin device for the manual application of a compound in solution onto the activated polyacrylamide gel pad for immobilization is described. Oligonucleotide, DNA, and protein microchips have been produced by this method and tested by hybridization and immunoanalysis monitored with a fluorescence microscope. The effect of the lengths of the immobilized oligonucleotides and the hybridized RNA and DNA on hybridization of the oligonucleotide microchips was evaluated. This method can also be used for manufacturing microchips containing a variety of other compounds.     

Microarray analysis of microbial virulence factors.

Hybridization with oligonucleotide microchips (microarrays) was used for discrimination among strains of Escherichia coli and other pathogenic enteric bacteria harboring various virulence factors. Oligonucleotide microchips are miniature arrays of gene-specific oligonucleotide probes immobilized on a glass surface. The combination of this technique with the amplification of genetic material by PCR is a powerful tool for the detection of and simultaneous discrimination among food-borne human pathogens. The presence of six genes (eaeA, slt-I, slt-II, fliC, rfbE, and ipaH) encoding bacterial antigenic determinants and virulence factors of bacterial strains was monitored by multiplex PCR followed by hybridization of the denatured PCR product to the gene-specific oligonucleotides on the microchip. The assay was able to detect these virulence factors in 15 Salmonella, Shigella, and E. coli strains. The results of the chip analysis were confirmed by hybridization of radiolabeled gene-specific probes to genomic DNA from bacterial colonies. In contrast, gel electrophoretic analysis of the multiplex PCR products used for the microarray analysis produced ambiguous results due to the presence of unexpected and uncharacterized bands. Our results suggest that microarray analysis of microbial virulence factors might be very useful for automated identification and characterization of bacterial pathogens.     

Optical properties of fluorochromes promising for use in biological microchips

Fourteen fluorochromes (free and oligonucleotide-bound) and five ligands commonly used to quantitatively assess DNA duplexes or complexes with proteins in microchips were studied by measuring their fluorescence excitation and emission spectra. The spectral changes are described that were caused by oligonucleotide binding, solution hybridization, or varying the temperature. The data are discussed from the standpoint of applicability and limitations of the fluorochromes and the ligands in qualitative and quantitative assays for DNA duplexes in microchips.     

DNA microarrays on nanoscale-controlled surface

We have developed new surface to ensure a proper spacing between immobilized biomolecules. While DNA microarray on this surface provided each probe DNA with ample space for hybridization with incoming target DNAs, the microarray showed enhanced discrimination efficiency for various types of single nucleotide polymorphism. The high discrimination efficiency holds for all tested cases (100:<1 for internal mismatched cases; 100:<28 for terminal mismatched ones). In addition, by investigating influence of hybridization temperature and washing condition on the fluorescence intensity and the discrimination efficiency with and without controlled mesospacing, it was observed that the nanoscale-controlled surface showed good discrimination efficiency in a wide range of temperature (37–50°C), and hybridization behavior on the surface was in agreement with the solution one. Intriguingly, it was found that washing process after the hybridization was critical for the high discrimination efficiency. For the particular case, washing process was so efficient that only 30 s washing was sufficient to reach the optimal discrimination ratio.     

Effects of various fluorochromes and competition between labeled oligonucleotides on their hybridization to oligonucleotides immobilized on biological microchips

Some technical tips are described on how to improve the discrimination between perfect and imperfect duplexes formed by hybridization of fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides to biological microchips. Model experiments were performed to assess the precision of the method. Effects of labeling on the efficiency of hybridization and some properties of competitive hybridization were studied using short synthetic oligonucleotides and three most popular fluorochromes as examples.     

Microarray Analysis of Microbial Virulence Factors

Hybridization with oligonucleotide microchips (microarrays) was used for discrimination among strains of Escherichia coli and other pathogenic enteric bacteria harboring various virulence factors. Oligonucleotide microchips are miniature arrays of gene-specific oligonucleotide probes immobilized on a glass surface. The combination of this technique with the amplification of genetic material by PCR is a powerful tool for the detection of and simultaneous discrimination among food-borne human pathogens. The presence of six genes (eaeA, slt-I, slt-II, fliC, rfbE, and ipaH) encoding bacterial antigenic determinants and virulence factors of bacterial strains was monitored by multiplex PCR followed by hybridization of the denatured PCR product to the gene-specific oligonucleotides on the microchip. The assay was able to detect these virulence factors in 15 Salmonella, Shigella, and E. coli strains. The results of the chip analysis were confirmed by hybridization of radiolabeled gene-specific probes to genomic DNA from bacterial colonies. In contrast, gel electrophoretic analysis of the multiplex PCR products used for the microarray analysis produced ambiguous results due to the presence of unexpected and uncharacterized bands. Our results suggest that microarray analysis of microbial virulence factors might be very useful for automated identification and characterization of bacterial pathogens.     

Towards quality control for DNA microarrays.

We present a framework for detecting probes in oligonucleotide microarrays that may add significant error to measurements in hybridization experiments. Four types of so-called degenerate probe behavior are considered: secondary structure formation, self-dimerization, cross-hybridization, and dimerization. The framework uses a well-established model for computing the free energy of nucleic acid sequence hybridization and a novel method for the detection of patterns in hybridization experiment data. Our primary result is the identification of unique patterns in hybridization experiment data that are shown to correlate with each type of degenerate probe behavior. A support function for identifying degenerate probes from a large set of hybridization experiments is given and some preliminary experimental results are given for the Affymetrix HuGeneFL GeneChip. Finally, we show a strong relationship between the Affymetrix discrimination measure for a probe and the free-energy estimate from theoretical models of hybridization. In particular, probes on the HuGeneFL GeneChip with high free-energy estimates (weak hybridization) have almost always approximately zero discrimination. The framework can be applied to any Affymetrix oligonucleotide array, and the software is made freely available to the community.     

Microarray-based method for combinatorial library sequence mapping and characterization

Here we describe a DNA-chip-based method for high-throughput sequence mapping. This involves competitive hybridization between short and differentially labeled fluorescent oligonucleotide probes and glass-supported PCR products. Competition between an excess of oligonucleotide probes targeting the same sequence segment improves sequence discrimination and reduces sensitivity to experimental conditions such as probe concentrations, hybridization, and washing temperatures and durations. The method was found to be particularly adapted to sequence mapping of combinatorial libraries obtained by DNA shuffling between members of a gene family. We present an application of this technique for the characterization of recombination biases in combinatorial libraries used in directed evolution.     

Regioselective immobilization of short oligonucleotides to acrylic copolymer gels.

Four types of polyacrylamide or polydimethyl-acrylamide gels for regioselective (by immobilization at the 3' end) of short oligonucleotides have been designed for use in manufacturing oligonucleotide microchips. Two of these supports contain amino or aldehyde groups in the gel, allowing coupling with oligonucleotides bearing aldehyde or amino groups, respectively, in the presence of a reducing agent. The aldehyde gel support showed a higher immobilization efficiency relative to the amino gel. Of all reducing agents tested, the best results were obtained with a pyridine-borane complex. The other supports are based on an acrylamide gel activated with glutaraldehyde or a hydroxyalkyl-functionalized gel treated with mesyl chloride. The use of dimethylacrylamide instead of acrylamide allows subsequent gel modifications in organic solvents. All the immobilization methods are easy and simple to perform, give high and reproducible yields, allow long durations of storage of the activated support, and provide high stability of attachment and low non-specific binding. Although these gel supports have been developed for preparing oligonucleotide microchips, they may be used for other purposes as well.     

Microchips based on three dimensional gel cells: history and perspective

The review describes the history of creation and development of the microchip technology and its role in the human genome project in Russia. The emphasis is placed on the three-dimensional gel-based microchips developed at the Center of Biological Microchips headed by A.D. Mirzabekov since 1988. The gel-based chips of the last generation, IMAGE chips (Immobilized Micro Array of Gel Elements), have a number of advantages over the previous versions. The microchips are manufactured by photo-initiated copolymerization of gel components and immobilized molecules (DNA, proteins, and ligands). This ensures an even distribution of the immobilized probe throughout the microchip gel element with a high yield (about 50% for oligonucleotides). The use of methacrylamide as a main component of the polymerization mixture resulted in a substantial increase of gel porosity without affecting its mechanical strength and stability, which allowed one to work with the DNA fragments of up to 500 nt in length, as well as with rather large protein molecules. At present, the gel-based microchips are widely applied to address different problems. The generic microchips containing a complete set of possible hexanucleotides are used to reveal the DNA motifs binding with different proteins and to study the DNA-protein interactions. The oligonucleotide microchips are a cheap and reliable tool of diagnostics designed for mass application. Biochips have been developed for identification of the tuberculosis pathogen and its antibiotic-resistant forms; for diagnostics of orthopoxviruses, including the smallpox virus; for diagnostics of the anthrax pathogen; and for identification of chromosomal rearrangements in leukemia patients. The protein microchips can be adapted for further use in proteomics. Bacterial and yeast cells were also immobilized in the gel, maintaining their viability, which open a wide potential for creation biosensors on the basis of microchips.     

Strategies for optimizing DNA hybridization on surfaces

Specific and predictable hybridization of the polynucleotide sequences to their complementary counterparts plays a fundamental role in the rational design of new nucleic acid nanodevices. Generally, nucleic acid hybridization can be performed using two major strategies, namely hybridization of DNA or RNA targets to surface-tethered oligonucleotide probes (solid-phase hybridization) and hybridization of the target nucleic acids to randomly distributed probes in solution (solution-phase hybridization). Investigations into thermodynamic and kinetic parameters of these two strategies showed that hybridization on surfaces is less favorable than that of the same sequence in solution. Indeed, the efficiency of DNA hybridization on surfaces suffers from three constraints: (1) electrostatic repulsion between DNA strands on the surface, (2) steric hindrance between tethered DNA probes, and (3) nonspecific adsorption of the attached oligonucleotides to the solid surface. During recent years, several strategies have been developed to overcome the problems associated with DNA hybridization on surfaces. Optimizing the probe surface density, application of a linker between the solid surface and the DNA-recognizing sequence, optimizing the pH of DNA hybridization solutions, application of thiol reagents, and incorporation of a polyadenine block into the terminal end of the recognizing sequence are among the most important strategies for enhancing DNA hybridization on surfaces.     

Mutation detection by stacking hybridization on genosensor arrays

A new strategy for analysis of point mutations using oligonucleotide array (genosensor) hybridization was investigated. In the new approach, a single-stranded target strand is preannealed with a labeled "stacking oligonucleotide," and then the partially duplex labeled target molecule is hybridized to an array of glass-tethered oligonucleotide probes, targeted to the region on the target immediately adjacent to the stacking oligomer. In this configuration, the base-stacking interactions between the "capture probe" and the contiguously stacking oligomer stabilize the binding of the target molecule to its complementary probe on the genosensor array. The temperature of hybridization can be adjusted so that the target molecule will bind to the glass-tethered probe only in the presence of the stacking oligomer, and a single mismatch at or near the terminal position ol the capture probe disrupts the stacking interactions and thereby eliminates or greatly reduces the hybridization. This stacking hybridization approach was investigated using a collection of synthetic targets, probes, and stacking oligonucleotides, which permitted identification of conditions for optimal base mismatch discrimination. The oligonucleotide probes were tethered to the glass using a simple, improved attachment chemistry in which a 3'-aminopropanol function introduced into the probe during chemical synthesis binds covalently to silanol groups on clean, underivatized glass. "Operating parameters" examined in the stacking hybridization system included length of capture probe, position, type and number of mismatches between the probe and the target, temperature of hybridization and length of washing, and the presence of terminal phosphate group in the probe, at its junction with the stacking oligomer. The results suggest that in the stacking hybridization configuration: 1. Optimal mismatch discrimination with 9-mer probes occurs at 45 degrees C, after which little or no improvement in mispair rejection occurred on lengthy continued washing at 45 degrees C. 2. At 25 degrees C optimal mismatch discrimination occurred with 7- or 8-mer probes, or with 9-mer probes containing an additional internal mismatch. 3. The presence of a phosphate group on the 5'-end of the glass-tethered probe had no general effect on mismatch discrimination, but influenced the relative stability of different mismatches in the sequence context studied. These results provide a motivation for continued development of the stacking hybridization technique for nucleic acid sequence analysis. This approach offers several advantages over the traditional allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization technique, and is distinct from the contiguous stacking hybridization sitrategy that the Mirzabekov laboratory has introduced (Yershov et al. (1996) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93, 4913-4918; Parinov et al. (1996) Nucleic Acids Res. 24, 2998-3004).     

Direct detection of 16S rRNA using oligonucleotide microarrays assisted by base stacking hybridization and tyramide signal amplification

A simple method has been developed and validated for direct, sensitive detection and specific identification of 16S rRNA. We first report our direct investigation of discrimination efficiency for sequence variations in RNA using oligonucleotide microarrays assisted by base stacking hybridization, and demonstrate that the sequence variations of double base substitution, single base substitution and single base deletion in RNA could be directly identified. With the help of tyramide signal amplification (TSA), the detection sensitivity of this method for four clinically important bacterial species was below 0.5, 5, 1 and 1 ng of total RNA, which are 100-1000 fold more sensitive than the published methods.