Comparative Histopathology of Grey‐Horse‐Melanoma and Human Malignant Melanoma

Equine melanoma shows striking features particularly with regard to clinical development in grey horses: in contrast to malignant melanoma in humans and in solid coloured horses that are characterized by early onset of metastasis, pigment cell tumours display almost benign clinical features in ageing grey horses. Through evolution, grey horses appear to be in a favourable position in regard to the biological behaviour of melanomas. Yet unknown factors inhibiting or retarding early melanoma metastasis may be responsible for this phenomenon. In this study, immunostaining profiles and histopathologic patterns of equine vs. human melanotic tumours were compared. In addition, the expression of melanoma markers currently used in human melanoma detection and characterization were evaluated for their applicability in equine melanoma diagnosis. Immunohistopathologic investigations revealed that benign grey horse melanomas share common features with human blue nevi and with human malignant desmoplastic melanomas, whereas their resemblance to other types of human cutaneous malignant melanomas is less pronounced. Our data equally underline that S‐100, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), HMB‐45, Ki‐67, T‐311 and CD44 can serve as reliable markers for horse melanomas. Further investigations aiming at identifying factors retarding metastasis in affected grey horses are needed, as they may contribute to the development of novel treatment strategies for human malignant melanoma.     

Collagen XVII is expressed in malignant but not in benign melanocytic tumors and it can mediate antibody induced melanoma apoptosis

The 180?kDa transmembrane collagen XVII is known to anchor undifferentiated keratinocytes to the basement membrane in hemidesmosomes while constitutively shedding a 120?kDa ectodomain. Inherited mutations or auto-antibodies targeting collagen XVII cause blistering skin disease. Collagen XVII is down-regulated in mature keratinocytes but re-expressed in skin cancer. By recently detecting collagen XVII in melanocyte hyperplasia, here we tested its expression in benign and malignant melanocytic tumors using endodomain and ectodomain selective antibodies. We found the full-length collagen XVII protein in proliferating tissue melanocytes, basal keratinocytes and squamous cell carcinoma whereas resting melanocytes were negative. Furthermore, the cell-residual 60?kDa endodomain was exclusively detected in 62/79 primary and 15/18 metastatic melanomas, 8/9 melanoma cell lines, HT199 metastatic melanoma xenografts and atypical nests in 8/63 dysplastic nevi. The rest of 19 nevi including common, blue and Spitz subtypes were also negative. In line with the defective ectodomain, sequencing of COL17A1 gene revealed aberrations in the ectodomain coding region including point mutations. Collagen XVII immunoreaction-stained spindle cell melanomas, showed partly overlapping profiles with those of S100B, Melan A and HMB45. It was concentrated at vertical melanoma fronts and statistically associated with invasive phenotype. Antibody targeting the extracellular aa507-529 terminus of collagen XVII endodomain promoted apoptosis and cell adhesion, while inhibiting proliferation in HT199 cells. These results suggest that the accumulation of collagen XVII endodomain in melanocytic tumors is associated with malignant transformation to be a potential marker of malignancy and a target for antibody-induced melanoma apoptosis.     

Pitfalls in the diagnosis of malignant melanoma

The histological appearance of benign melanocytic naevi and malignant melanomas can be variable, causing in a significant number of cases severe differential diagnostic problems. The early, thin (less than 1 mm) melanomas have to be differentiated from naevi containing dominant junctional or lentiginous component or pagetoid melanocytosis and from some epithelial tumours, while in cases of thick lesion the diagnosis of thick melanoma, Spitz naevus, deep penetrating naevus or cellular blue naevus should be considered for example. The morphology of the so-called atypical Spitz naevus and atypical pigmented spindle cell naevus show overlapping with malignant melanoma and sometimes in these cases the biological behaviour cannot be assessed. The variable appearance of malignant melanoma is illustrated by the fact that different superficial soft tissue tumours with epithelioid and/or spindle cells or with pigment can mimic it. The rare balloon cell and signet ring cell melanoma is a mimicker of primary or metastatic carcinoma and the desmoplastic variant is often misdiagnosed as benign mesenchymal lesion. Lymph node metastasis of melanoma, when the primary tumour is not known, may raise the possibility of interdigitating reticulum cell tumour or anaplastic large cell lymphoma.     

Comparative histopathology of grey-horse-melanoma and human malignant melanoma

Equine melanoma shows striking features particularly with regard to clinical development in grey horses: in contrast to malignant melanoma in humans and in solid coloured horses that are characterized by early onset of metastasis, pigment cell tumours display almost benign clinical features in ageing grey horses. Through evolution, grey horses appear to be in a favourable position in regard to the biological behaviour of melanomas. Yet unknown factors inhibiting or retarding early melanoma metastasis may be responsible for this phenomenon. In this study, immunostaining profiles and histopathologic patterns of equine vs. human melanotic tumours were compared. In addition, the expression of melanoma markers currently used in human melanoma detection and characterization were evaluated for their applicability in equine melanoma diagnosis. Immunohistopathologic investigations revealed that benign grey horse melanomas share common features with human blue nevi and with human malignant desmoplastic melanomas, whereas their resemblance to other types of human cutaneous malignant melanomas is less pronounced. Our data equally underline that S-100, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), HMB-45, Ki-67, T-311 and CD44 can serve as reliable markers for horse melanomas. Further investigations aiming at identifying factors retarding metastasis in affected grey horses are needed, as they may contribute to the development of novel treatment strategies for human malignant melanoma.     

Lacunarity Analysis: A Promising Method for the Automated Assessment of Melanocytic Naevi and Melanoma

The early diagnosis of melanoma is critical to achieving reduced mortality and increased survival. Although clinical examination is currently the method of choice for melanocytic lesion assessment, there is a growing interest among clinicians regarding the potential diagnostic utility of computerised image analysis. Recognising that there exist significant shortcomings in currently available algorithms, we are motivated to investigate the utility of lacunarity, a simple statistical measure previously used in geology and other fields for the analysis of fractal and multi-scaled images, in the automated assessment of melanocytic naevi and melanoma. Digitised dermoscopic images of 111 benign melanocytic naevi, 99 dysplastic naevi and 102 melanomas were obtained over the period 2003 to 2008, and subject to lacunarity analysis. We found the lacunarity algorithm could accurately distinguish melanoma from benign melanocytic naevi or non-melanoma without introducing many of the limitations associated with other previously reported diagnostic algorithms. Lacunarity analysis suggests an ordering of irregularity in melanocytic lesions, and we suggest the clinical application of this ordering may have utility in the naked-eye dermoscopic diagnosis of early melanoma.     

Ultrastructural organization of nucleoli in benign naevi and malignant melanomas

We have studied the ultrastructural organization of nucleoli in benign naevi and malignant melanomas. In benign naevus cells the nucleoli displayed a compact ribonucleoprotein distribution, with one or two large fibrillar centres. In malignant melanoma cells the nucleoli were large with an irregular, nucleolonema-like ribonucleoprotein distribution and they exhibited numerous, small fibrillar centres. Statistical evaluation of the size of fibrillar centres indicated a mean value of 0.482 micron 2 +/- 0.136 SD for naevi and 0.221 micron 2 +/- 0.128 SD for malignant melanomas. These features, together with the more dispersed chromatin pattern of malignant melanoma nuclei compared with those of benign naevus cells, are proposed as diagnostic parameters which differentiate benign naevi from malignant melanomas at the ultrastructural level.     

Immunohistochemical study of pepsinogen C expression in cutaneous malignant melanoma: association with clinicopathological parameters

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to evaluate the pepsinogen C expression in malignant cutaneous melanomas and analyze its possible relationship to clinical and pathological parameters. Pepsinogen C is an aspartyl proteinase primarily involved in the digestion of proteins in the stomach and represents one of the main androgen-inducible proteins in breast cancer cells. METHOD: Tumoral pepsinogen C expression was retrospectively analyzed in 35 paraffin-embedded tissues from patients with primary malignant cutaneous melanoma and in 10 samples from 10 benign lesions (4 dermal melanocytic nevi, 4 compound melanocytic nevi and 2 dysplastic melanocytic nevi), using immunohistochemical methods. RESULTS: The benign lesions were consistently negative for pepsinogen C, whereas 20 of the 35 malignant melanomas (57%) showed positive immunostaining for pepsinogen C. The percentage of pepsinogen C-positive tumors was significantly higher in men than in women (p=0.01) and in epithelioid melanomas than in fusocellular or mixed type melanomas (p=0.003). In addition, the percentage of pepsinogen-C positive tumors was positively and significantly correlated with lesion thickness (p=0.003), Clark's level of invasion (p=0.028) and tumor stage (p<0.001). CONCLUSION: Pepsinogen C could be a new prognosticator of unfavorable outcome in cutaneous malignant melanoma.     

The usefulness of c-Kit in the immunohistochemical assessment of melanocytic lesions

C-Kit (CD117), the receptor for the stem cell factor, a growth factor for melanocyte migration and proliferation, has shown differential immunostaining in various benign and malignant melanocytic lesions. The purpose of this study is to compare c-Kit immunostaining in benign nevi and in primary and metastatic malignant melanomas, to determine whether c-Kit can aid in the differential diagnosis of these lesions. c-Kit immunostaining was performed in 60 cases of pigmented lesions, including 39 benign nevi (5 blue nevi, 5 intradermal nevi, 3 junctional nevi, 15 cases of primary compound nevus, 11 cases of Spitz nevus), 18 cases of primary malignant melanoma and 3 cases of metastatic melanoma. The vast majority of nevi and melanomas examined in this study were positive for c-Kit, with minimal differences between benign and malignant lesions. C-Kit cytoplasmatic immunoreactivity in the intraepidermal proliferating nevus cells, was detected in benign pigmented lesions as well as in malignant melanoma, increasing with the age of patients (P=0.007) in both groups. The patient's age at presentation appeared to be the variable able to cluster benign and malignant pigmented lesions. The percentage of c-Kit positive intraepidermal nevus cells was better associated with age despite other variables (P=0.014). The intensity and percentage of c-Kit positivity in the proliferating nevus cells in the dermis was significantly increased in malignant melanocytic lesions (P=0.015 and P=0.008) compared to benign lesions (compound melanocytic nevi, Spitz nevi, intradermal nevi, blue nevi). Immunostaning for c-Kit in metastatic melanomas was negative. Interestingly in two cases of melanoma occurring on a pre-existent nevus, the melanoma tumor cells showed strong cytoplasmatic and membranous positivity for c-kit, in contrast with the absence of any immunoreactivity in pre-existent intradermal nevus cells. C-Kit does not appear to be a strong immunohistochemical marker for distinguishing melanoma from melanocytic nevi, if we consider c-Kit expression in intraepidermal proliferating cells. The c-Kit expression in proliferating melanocytes in the dermis could help in the differential diagnosis between a superficial spreading melanoma (with dermis invasion) and a compound nevus or an intradermal nevus. Finally, c-Kit could be a good diagnostic tool for distinguishing benign compound nevi from malignant melanocytic lesions with dermis invasion and to differentiate metastatic melanoma from primary melanoma.     

Primary cilium depletion typifies cutaneous melanoma in situ and malignant melanoma

Cutaneous melanoma is a lethal malignancy that arises spontaneously or via in situ precursor neoplasms. While melanoma in situ and locally invasive malignant melanoma can be cured surgically, these lesions can sometimes be difficult to distinguish from melanocytic nevi. Thus, the identification of histolopathologic or molecular features that distinguish these biologically distinct lesions would represent an important advance. To this end, we determined the abundance of melanocytic primary cilia in a series of 62 cases composed of typical cutaneous melanocytic nevi, melanoma in situ, invasive melanoma, and metastatic melanoma. Primary cilia are sensory organelles that modulate developmental and adaptive signaling and notably, are substantially depleted from the neoplastic epithelium of pancreatic carcinoma at a stage equivalent to melanoma in situ. In this series, we find that while nearly all melanocytes in 22 melanocytic nevi possessed a primary cilium, a near-complete loss of this organelle was observed in 16 cases of melanoma in situ, in 16 unequivocal primary invasive melanomas, and in 8 metastatic tumors, each associated with a cutaneous primary lesion. These findings suggest that the primary cilium may be used to segregate cutaneous invasive melanoma and melanoma in situ from melanocytic nevi. Moreover, they place the loss of an organelle known to regulate oncogenic signaling at an early stage of melanoma development.     

Multiparameter analysis of naevi and primary melanomas identifies a subset of naevi with elevated markers of transformation

Here we have carried out a multiparameter analysis using a panel of 28 immunohistochemical markers to identify markers of transformation from benign and dysplastic naevus to primary melanoma in three separate cohorts totalling 279 lesions. We have identified a set of eight markers that distinguish naevi from melanoma. None of markers or parameters assessed differentiated benign from dysplastic naevi. Indeed, the naevi clustered tightly in terms of their immunostaining patterns whereas primary melanomas showed more diverse staining patterns. A small subset of histopathologically benign lesions had elevated levels of multiple markers associated with melanoma, suggesting that these represent naevi with an increased potential for transformation to melanoma.     

Melanoma metastatic to the breast: utility of fine needle aspiration and immunohistochemistry

OBJECTIVE: To describe the morphologic spectrum of metastatic malignant melanoma (MM) cells involving the breast and to explore the diagnostic utility of HMB45, Mart-1, Melan-A and T311 (antityrosinase) antibodies in fine needle aspiration material of MM metastatic to the breast. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic material from 21 cases (18 women) was reviewed for cytomorphology (epithelioid, spindled, mixed) and immunocytochemical staining attributes for Mart-1, HMB45, T311, Melan-A and cytokeratin based on tissue availability. RESULTS: Seventeen cases (81%) demonstrated epithelioid cell morphology, with 14% exhibiting mixed and 5% spindled morphologies. All 21 cases (100%) were immunoreactive with Mart-1 antibody, with 81% (17/21) immunoreactive for HMB45. In 38% of cases there was a similar percentage of cells immunoreactive for Mart-1 and HMB45, while 48% showed a higher percentage of cells immunoreactive for MART-1 than HMB45. Immunoreactivity with T311 was seen in 8 of 11 cases tested (73%). All six cases tested (100%) were immunoreactive with Melan-A. Staining for cytokeratin was negative in all eight cases tested. CONCLUSION: Because the majority of MM metastatic to the breast shows epithelioid cell morphology, it may mimic primary breast carcinoma. Mart-1 should be part of the immunocytochemical panel utilized to confirm the diagnosis of MM metastatic to the breast.     

Clinical signs and differential diagnosis of iris melanoma

Iris melanoma is the rarest type of uveal melanomas. Only 4-5% of uveal melanomas occur on the iris. Although the iris can be easily examined due to its location, differentiation of melanocytic malformations such as naevi or melanomas is difficult for the examiner. According to publications by Rones and Zimmermann, histological examinations showed 22% of tumors to be malignant and 78% to be benign. This lead to iridectomy and iridocyclectomy as therapeutic solutions to gain ground over enucleation. Follow-up of the clinical signs, transillumination, ultrasonic biomicroscopy, iris fluorescein angiography and photo-documentation of the clinical signs can be of great help in diagnosis of pigmented iris tumours. Growth of the tumour, secondary glaucoma, hyphaema, significant vascularisation of the tumour and increasing extent of pigmentation can be signs of malignant behaviour.     

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology and Immunocytochemistry of Metastatic Melanoma

The cytological and immunological findings of 81 metastatic melanomas are described. Fine needle aspiration was performed from secondary deposits in lymph nodes (38), subcutaneous and soft tissue (36), abdomen (5), lung (1) from 67 patients with histologically verified malignant melanoma. One patient had disease which had spread into the cerebrospinal fluid. Cytomorphologically the cases were classified as classical (47%), carcinoma-like (22%), spindle cell type (14%), lymphoma like (6%), undifferentiated (6%), myxoid type (3%), and clear cell type (2%). All cases were immunologically characterized using antibodies to S-100, vimentin and cytokeratin. All cases were S-100 positive and the majority (96%) reacted with antibodies to vimentin. A weak heterogenous reactivity to cytokeratin antibody was detected in only eight cases. The HMB45 antibody was applied to 20 cases and 16 (80%) of these tumours were positive. In summary, we found that an immunological characterization was necessary to conclusively diagnose over 50% of metastatic melanomas which presented with an equivocal cytological picture.     

Apaf-1 expression in human cutaneous melanoma progression and in pigmented nevi

Malignant melanoma is notoriously refractive to therapy and resistant to apoptosis. This may reflect the downregulation of Apaf-1, an important mediator of mitochondrial-dependent apoptosis, observed in vitro in melanoma cell lines and by immunohistochemistry for Apaf-1 protein in histological samples of primary and metastatic melanomas. Although it has been suggested that loss of Apaf-1 expression may be an indicator of malignant transformation in melanoma, previous studies on Apaf-1 expression in benign pigmented nevi were performed without reference to their histologic type. Here we have evaluated the expression of Apaf-1 mRNA by fluorescence in situ hybridization and of Apaf-1 protein by immunohistochemistry in a large panel of human melanomas and in eight types of pigmented nevi, considered potential precursors for cutaneous melanoma. We observe a strong negative correlation between melanoma progression assessed according to Clark classification and the expression of Apaf-1. A significant decrease in Apaf-1 expression was observed between Clark II and Clark III lesions, the stages usually associated with a transition from horizontal to vertical growth phase of melanoma. There was also statistically significant difference in Apaf-1 mRNA expression between melanomas of Breslow thickness <1 mm and >4 mm. No Apaf-1 expression could be detected in lymph node melanoma metastases. These results suggest that Apaf-1 expression may become a prognostic marker for progress of human cutaneous melanoma and further support the notion that loss of Apaf-1 may be an important contributory factor in the development of the disease.     

Tissue Factor Expression and Serum Level in Patients with Melanoma does not Correlate with Disease Progression

Not only does tissue factor (TF) play a crucial role in hemostasis and thrombosis, but it is also involved in tumor progression and metastatic potency in some malignant tumors. We evaluated the clinical relevance of TF expression in melanocytic tumors and TF serum level in patients with malignant melanoma. TF expression in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions was examined by immunoperoxidase staining in 20 nevi, 41 primary, and 24 metastatic melanoma lesions. TF was detected in 94, 95, and 100% of these lesions, respectively. The staining pattern was membranous and cytoplasmic both in nevi and melanoma cells. This finding was confirmed by western blot analysis using cultured human melanocytes, nevi cells, and melanoma cell lines. TF was also expressed on blood vessels in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions. Expression of TF in primary melanoma lesions was not associated with any clinicopathological variables. In addition, the serum level of TF was elevated in 14% of patients with melanoma; however, it was not correlated with disease progression. These results suggest that TF was ubiquitously expressed in melanocytic cells and its expression was not correlated with disease progression and/or metastatic potency of melanoma cells.     

Tissue factor expression and serum level in patients with melanoma does not correlate with disease progression.

Not only does tissue factor (TF) play a crucial role in hemostasis and thrombosis, but it is also involved in tumor progression and metastatic potency in some malignant tumors. We evaluated the clinical relevance of TF expression in melanocytic tumors and TF serum level in patients with malignant melanoma. TF expression in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions was examined by immunoperoxidase staining in 20 nevi, 41 primary, and 24 metastatic melanoma lesions. TF was detected in 94, 95, and 100% of these lesions, respectively. The staining pattern was membranous and cytoplasmic both in nevi and melanoma cells. This finding was confirmed by western blot analysis using cultured human melanocytes, nevi cells, and melanoma cell lines. TF was also expressed on blood vessels in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions. Expression of TF in primary melanoma lesions was not associated with any clinicopathological variables. In addition, the serum level of TF was elevated in 14% of patients with melanoma; however, it was not correlated with disease progression. These results suggest that TF was ubiquitously expressed in melanocytic cells and its expression was not correlated with disease progression and/or metastatic potency of melanoma cells.     

Immuno-diagnosis of malignant melanoma

The diagnosis of malignant melanoma must be followed by treatment shown to be effective. Therefore a correct diagnosis, including staging, that will permit a meaningful prognosis and treatment, is essential. The usefulness and great specificity of immunological methods is based on the detection of antigens characteristic of neoplastic and reactive cells. In cases of malignant melanoma, immunohistochemistry has limited practical value in the routine diagnosis of melanocytic lesions. The method may be important, however, in the differential diagnosis of, for example, malignant melanoma vs. non-melanocytic anaplastic neoplasia, malignant vs. benign melanocytic lesions, etc. Recent advances in relating the immunostaining of antigens to the development of tumor cells, such as proliferation and apoptosis, metastatic potential, etc. have given considerable importance to the immunomorphological evaluation of malignant melanomas. Likewise, immunotherapy requires the immunophenotyping of the reactive cells of the immune system.     

Immunological aspects of benign melanocytic tumours and melanoma in situ

Summary Extracts were prepared from 15 malignant melanomas, 10 naevi, 8 pieces of skin containing atypical melanocytes and 4 samples of normal skin. Peripheral blood leucocytes from 52 patients with benign naevi that had altered sufficiently to cause the patient to seek attention, 57 patients with malignant melanomas, and 98 normal individuals were tested against these extracts in a capillary leucocyte migration test. Melanoma extracts preferentially inhibited the leucocytes of melanoma patients and to a lesser extent those of naevus patients. Melanoma patients' leucocytes were more frequently inhibited by naevus extracts (whether from intradermal or from compound naevi) than were the leucocytes of naevus patients and control donors. Extracts of skin containing atypical melanocytes (perimelanomatous skin and lentigenous skin) selectively inhibited melanoma patients' leucocytes.