Metabolic complexity in the RNA world and implications for the origin of protein synthesis

Summary A model is presented for the evolution of metabolism and protein synthesis in a primitive, acellular RNA world. It has been argued previously that the ability to perform metabolic functions logically must have preceded the evolution of a message-dependent protein synthetic machinery and that considerable metabolic complexity was achieved by ribo-organisms (i.e., organisms in which both genome and enzymes are comprised of RNA). The model proposed here offers a mechanism to account for the gradual development of sophisticated metabolic activities by ribo-organisms and explains how such metabolic complexity would lead subsequently to the synthesis of genetically encoded polypeptides. RNA structures ancestral to modern ribosomes, here termed metabolosomes, are proposed to have functioned as organizing centers that coordinated, using base-pairing interactions, the order and nature of adaptor-mounted substrate/catalyst interactions in primitive metabolic pathways. In this way an ancient genetic code for metabolism is envisaged to have predated the specialized modern genetic code for protein synthesis. Thus, encoded amino acids initially would have been used, in conjunction with other encoded metabolites, as building blocks for biosynthetic pathways, a role that they retain in the metabolism of contemporary organisms. At a later stage the encoded amino acids would have been condensed together on similar RNA metabolosome structures to form the first genetically determined, and therefore biologically meaningful, polypeptides. On the basis of codon distributions in the modern genetic code it is argued that the first proteins to have been synthesized and used by ribo-organisms were predominantly hydrophobic and likely to have performed membrane-related functions (such as forming simple pore structures), activities essential for the evolution of membrane-enclosed cells.     

A speculation on the origin of protein synthesis

It is suggested that protein synthesis may have begun without even a primitive ribosome if the primitive tRNA could take up two configurations and could bind to the messenger RNA with five base-pairs instead of the present three. This idea would impose base sequence restriction on the early messages and on the early genetic code such that the first four amino acids coded were glycine, serine, aspartic acid and aspargine. A possible mechanism is suggested for the polymerization of the early message.This paper is dedicated to the memory of Dr. Aharon Katzir.     

A speculation on the origin of protein synthesis.

It is suggested that protein sythesis may have begun without even a primitive ribosome if the primitive tRNA could take up two configuration and could bind to the messenger RNA with five base-pairs instead of the present three. This idea would impose base sequence restriction on the early messages and on the early genetic code such that the first four amino acids coded were glycine, serine, aspartic acid and aspargine. A possible mechanism is suggested for the polymerization of the early message.     

Hypotheses on the establishment of a genetic code and transfer of information from proteinoids to nucleic acids

An hypothesis is proposed in which the specificity of interaction between an aminoacid and a nucleotide sequence of a tRNA would be enhanced by a ternary association with a specific proteinoid. These strict relations would have led to the present genetic code that we know. It is also proposed that the origin of the enzymatic activity of the primitive proteinoids would have arisen from the presence of different substrates during polymerisation, which would have favored specific sequences of aminoacids by forming more stable complexes with them, corresponding to the lowest free enthalpy. The information included in the aminoacid sequences of the proteinoids would have been transferred to messenger type RNA, according to a mechanism reverse of that for the present process for protein synthesis, and then to DNA.     

Conformational studies on nucleotide-amino acid interactions leading to origin of life

Living processes may be defined as the self-sustained chemical reactions based on the special chemical machinery of nucleic acid-directed protein synthesis. Its genesis may be traced to the molecular interaction between nucleotides and amino acids leading to a primitive adaptor-mediated ordered synthesis of polypeptides. A primitive decoding system is described and its characteristics are shown to imitate, in a primitive manner, the present-day elaborate machinery of protein synthesis. This molecular interaction theory may be rightly considered as the missing link between the Protochemical and biological Evolution. The origin of chiral specificity observed in living organisms is also traced to this specific molecular interaction in the protobiological milieu.     

The evolution of the protein synthesis system,II

The sequence of events previously proposed for modern protein synthesis is reviewed. It begins with an abiological synthesis of a template, and evolves through two model autocatalytic systems to a primitive cell that has a rudimentary biological protein synthesis system. A possible scheme for the origin of tRNA's is described so as to fill the gap between the model and the modern system. Fragments of genes that existed in and around the primitive system are proposed to be precursors of tRNA's. Since these fragments must have been undesirable components for the system, the origin and evolution of tRNA's may be regarded as an excellent answer by the primitive system to adverse circumstances.     

Cell-free synthesis of polypeptides lacking an amino-terminal methionine by using a dicistroviral intergenic internal ribosome entry site

An amino-terminal methionine corresponding to a recombinant AUG initiation codon sometimes affects the functions of proteins. To test the performance of translation mediated by a dicistroviral internal ribosome entry site (IRES), which initiates protein synthesis with elongator tRNAs, we optimized the conditions for cell-free translation. Although the IRES is 188 nucleotides long, a further 50 nucleotides of the upstream sequence stabilized translation efficiency. Optimal ion concentrations were affected by the sequences of the constructs. In a wheat-germ system, IRES-mediated translation produced 78 microg/ml of firefly luciferase from the AUG-deleted sequence, suggesting that dicistroviral IRESs will be able to yield polypeptides with a specific N-terminal amino acid other than methionine.     

Translation kinetics in cultured mouse hepatoma cells. Regulation of albumin synthesis by amino acids

The synthesis of albumin in the liver has been shown to correlate with the availability of essential amino acids in the diet. We have investigated this phenomenon in the highly differentiated mouse hepatoma cell line, Hepa. Cells were grown for three days in complete medium with daily changes. The cells were then incubated for 22 h in media containing varying concentrations of individual essential amino acids. The deficient media were then changed; 1.5 h later the cells were labeled for 0.5 h with [3H]leucine. Albumin was immunoprecipitated and total protein was acid-precipitated from postribosomal supernatants of detergents-solubilized cells. With the exception of isoleucine, the relative rates of albumin synthesis decreased as a function of amino acid concentration from 4.3% in complete medium to 2.5% in totally deficient media. This specific reduction in albumin synthesis was confirmed by analysis of labeled Hepa proteins displayed on sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gels. Essential amino acid limitation reduced total protein synthesis by 50%. This is the result of a decrease in the translation efficiency of total mRNA from 5 to 3 polypeptides/message min-1 and is consistent with a reduction in the initiation rate. In contrast, the 70% decrease in albumin synthesis was a result of a reduced number of functional albumin messages/cell. The translation efficiency of these albumin messages remained unchanged at 1.     

The RNA/protein symmetry hypothesis: experimental support for reverse translation of primitive proteins

Although the "RNA-world" theory, or the RNA-first theory is renowned for a promising theory of biogenesis, it is also possible that both RNAs and proteins have coevolved forming a stable metabolic complex from the very beginning. I investigated this possibility assuming that the genetic information flowed symmetrically in the era of the origin of life, i.e. the primitive translation machinery worked in both directions (from RNA to protein and from protein to RNA). According to this RNA/protein symmetry theory, the genetic information would have come from existing cellular proteins via reverse translation. This process would have been completed in a short period of time without searching an enormous RNA sequence space. Furthermore, reverse translation would have ensured biological continuity; proteins that were essential for cellular metabolism would have been utilized in the same way as before the protein sequence information would have been transferred into the RNA sequences. I also propose a possible mechanism for the process of reverse translation. The reverse translation would proceed in the 3' to 5' direction using a set of at least 20 reverse transfer RNAs (rtRNAs) that can recognize their specific amino acid residue and carry their corresponding codon. A source of genetic information would be a primary sequence of a protein molecule. Several basic steps of reverse translation were demonstrated using rtRNA(Arg).     

Analysis of plasmid genome evolution based on nucleotide-sequence comparison of two related plasmids of Escherichia coli

Plasmid Rsc13, a small derivative of the plasmid R1, contains a region necessary for replication as well as a complete copy (4957 bp) of the ampicillin resistance transposon, Tn3. We determined the nucleotide sequence of the replication region of Rsc13 to be 2937 bp and then compared this region (designated the 2.9-kb region) to the analogous region of pSM1, a small derivative of the plasmid R100 which has common ancestry with R1. Rsc13 and pSM1 were 96% homologous in this 2.9-kb region except for a discrete region of about 250 bp which showed only 44% homology. The sequence and distribution of nucleotide substitutions between Rsc13 and pSM1 supported a map of possible genes and sites which have previously been seen in the replication region of Rsc13 and pSM1 which showed only 44% homology. Analysis of the amino acid sequence and predicted conformation of the two RepA2 polypeptides, however, suggested that they were very similar. We proposed that the repA2 region of R1 and R100 was replaced by a substitution of a short DNA segment from another plasmid which was evolutionarily related to R1 and R100 but had more divergence. This event may have been mediated by a mechanism similar to that of gene conversion as described in eukaryotic systems.     

Genetic Code Evolution Started with the Incorporation of Glycine,Followed by Other Small Hydrophilic Amino Acids

We propose that glycine was the first amino acid to be incorporated into the genetic code, followed by serine, aspartic and/or glutamic acid—small hydrophilic amino acids that all have codons in the bottom right-hand corner of the standard genetic code table. Because primordial ribosomal synthesis is presumed to have been rudimentary, this stage would have been characterized by the synthesis of short, water-soluble peptides, the first of which would have comprised polyglycine. Evolution of the code is proposed to have occurred by the duplication and mutation of tRNA sequences, which produced a radiation of codon assignment outwards from the bottom right-hand corner. As a result of this expansion, we propose a trend from small hydrophilic to hydrophobic amino acids, with selection for longer polypeptides requiring a hydrophobic core for folding and stability driving the incorporation of hydrophobic amino acids into the code.     

phi29 DNA polymerase residue Phe128 of the highly conserved (S/T)Lx(2)h motif is required for a stable and functional interaction with the terminal protein

Bacteriophage phi29 encodes a DNA-dependent DNA polymerase belonging to the eukaryotic-type (family B) subgroup of DNA polymerases that use a protein as primer for initiation of DNA replication. By multiple sequence alignments of DNA polymerases from such a family, we have been able to identify two amino acid residues specifically conserved in the protein-priming subgroup of DNA polymerases, a phenylalanine contained in the (S/T)Lx(2)h motif, and a glutamate belonging to the Exo III motif. Here, we have studied the functional role of these residues in reactions that are specific for DNA polymerases that use a protein-primed DNA replication mechanism, by site-directed mutagenesis in the corresponding amino acid residues, Phe128 and Glu161 of phi29 DNA polymerase. Mutations introduced at residue Phe128 severely impaired the protein-primed replication capacity of the polymerase, being the interaction with the terminal protein (TP) moderately (mutant F128A) or severely (mutant F128Y) diminished. As a consequence, very few initiation products were obtained, and essentially no transition products were detected. Interestingly, phi29 DNA polymerase mutant F128Y showed a decreased binding affinity for short template DNA molecules. These results, together with the high degree of conservation of Phe128 residue among protein-primed DNA polymerases, suggest a functional role for this amino acid residue in making contacts with the TP during the first steps of genome replication and with DNA in the further replication steps.     

Site-specific mutagenesis of cDNA clones expressing a poliovirus proteinase

The cleavage of poliovirus precursor polypeptides occurs at specific amino acid pairs that are recognized by viral proteinases. Most of the polio-specific cleavages occur at glutamine-glycine (Q-G) pairs that are recognized by the viral-encoded proteinase 3C (formerly called P3-7c). In order to carry out a defined molecular genetic study of the enzymatic activity of protein 3C, we have made cDNA clones of the poliovirus genome. The cDNA region corresponding to protein 3C was inserted into an inducible bacterial expression vector. This recombinant plasmid (called pIN-III-C3-7c) utilizes the bacterial lipoprotein promoter to direct the synthesis of a precursor polypeptide that contains the amino acid sequence of protein 3C as well as the amino- and carboxy-terminal Q-G cleavage signals. These signals have been previously shown to allow autocatalytic production of protein 3C in bacteria transformed with plasmid pIN-III-C3-7c. We have taken advantage of the autocatalytic cleavage of 3C in a bacterial expression system to study the effects of site-specific mutagenesis on its proteolytic activity. One mutation that we have introduced into the cDNA region encoding 3C is a single amino acid insertion near the carboxy-terminal Q-G cleavage site. The mutant recombinant plasmid (designated pIN-III-C3-mu 10) directs the synthesis of a bacterial-polio precursor polypeptide that is like the wild-type construct (pIN-III-C3-7c). However, unlike the wild-type precursor, the mutant precursor cannot undergo autocatalytic cleavage to generate the mature proteinase 3C. Rather, the precursor is able to carry out cleavage at the amino-terminal Q-G site but not at the carboxy-terminal site. Thus, we have generated an altered poliovirus proteinase that is still able to carry out at least part of its cleavage activities but is unable to be a suitable substrate for self-cleavage at its carboxy-terminal Q-G pair.     

Aminoacyl thiol esters and the origins of genetic specificity

Reasons for believing that primitive mechanisms of translation may have employed thiol esters of the amino acids rather than oxygen esters are summarized. It is suggested that coenzyme A (HSCoA), which fulfills the role of aminoacyl transfer in the synthesis of peptide antibiotics, is a primitive analogue of tRNA which performs a similar role in protein synthesis. HSCoA—an adenylic acid moiety containing phosphates esterified at the 3′ and 5′ positions and linked to a peptide-like structure terminating in a reactive thiol—possesses chemical features suggestive of both peptides and polynucleotides. Examination of the chemistry of HSCoA-like molecules shows that a rather similar compound can carry out a repeating intramolecular peptide synthesis in the absence of enzymes. Condensation of further nucleotides onto the adenylic acid moiety gives rise to parallel modes of peptide and oligonucleotide synthesis. A “self-improving” ability to select available amino acids is inherent in the proposed mechanism of peptide synthesis. The hypothesis plausibly explains the universal occurrence of a sulphur-containing amino acid at the N terminus of nascent proteins.     

The histone variant H3.3 marks active chromatin by replication-independent nucleosome assembly

Two very similar H3 histones-differing at only four amino acid positions-are produced in Drosophila cells. Here we describe a mechanism of chromatin regulation whereby the variant H3.3 is deposited at particular loci, including active rDNA arrays. While the major H3 is incorporated strictly during DNA replication, amino acid changes toward H3.3 allow replication-independent (RI) deposition. In contrast to replication-coupled (RC) deposition, RI deposition does not require the N-terminal tail. H3.3 is the exclusive substrate for RI deposition, and its counterpart is the only substrate retained in yeast. RI substitution of H3.3 provides a mechanism for the immediate activation of genes that are silenced by histone modification. Inheritance of newly deposited nucleosomes may then mark sites as active loci.     

The primary structure of the 32-kDa subunit of human replication protein A

Replication protein A (RP-A) is a complex of three polypeptides of molecular mass 70, 32, and 14 kDa, which is absolutely required for simian virus 40 DNA replication in vitro. We have isolated a cDNA coding for the 32-kDa subunit of RP-A. An oligonucleotide probe was constructed based upon a tryptic peptide sequence derived from whole RP-A, and clones were isolated from a lambda gt11 library containing HeLa cDNA inserts. The amino acid sequence predicted from the cDNA contains the peptide sequence obtained from whole RP-A along with two sequences obtained from tryptic peptides derived from sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel-purified 32-kDa subunit. The coding sequence predicts a protein of 29,228 daltons, in good agreement with the electrophoretically determined molecular mass of the 32-kDa subunit. No significant homology was found with any of the sequences in the GenBank data base. The protein predicted from the cDNA has an N-terminal region rich in glycine and serine along with two acidic and two basic segments. Monoclonal antibodies have been raised against the 70- and 32-kDa subunits of RP-A. The cloned cDNA has been overexpressed in bacteria using an inducible T7 expression system. The protein made in bacteria is recognized by a monoclonal antibody that is specific for the 32-kDa subunit of RP-A. This monoclonal antibody against the 32-kDa subunit inhibits DNA replication in vitro.     

On the role of the mature part of an Escherichia coli outer membrane protein (OmpA) in translocation across the plasma membrane

The 325-residue OmpA protein, which is synthesized as a precursor with a 21-residue signal sequence, is a polypeptide of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K-12. The signal peptide is able to direct translocation across the plasma membrane of virtually any fragment of this protein. It had, therefore, been concluded that information required for this translocation does not exist within the mature part of the protein. This view has been criticized and it was suggested that our data showed that both the signal sequence and residues within the first 44 amino acid residues of the mature protein contributed to an optimal translocation mechanism. It is shown that, at least as far as is detectable, this is not so. The apparent rates of processing of various pro-OmpA constructs were measured. It was found that these rates did not depend on the presence of amino acid residues 4 through 45 but on the size of the polypeptides; the processing rate decreased with decreasing size. A possible explanation for this phenomenon is offered. While the results do not exclude the possibility that a defined area of the mature protein is involved in optimizing translocation, there is so far no evidence for it.