Single-molecule microscopy reveals new insights into nucleotide selection by DNA polymerase I

The mechanism by which DNA polymerases achieve their extraordinary accuracy has been intensely studied because of the linkage between this process and mutagenesis and carcinogenesis. Here, we have used single-molecule fluorescence microscopy to study the process of nucleotide selection and exonuclease action. Our results show that the binding of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) to a primer-template is stabilized by the presence of the next correct dNTP, even in the presence of a large excess of the other dNTPs and rNTPs. These results are consistent with a model where nucleotide selection occurs in the open complex prior to the formation of a closed ternary complex. Our assay can also distinguish between primer binding to the polymerase or exonuclease domain and, contrary to ensemble-averaged studies, we find that stable exonuclease binding only occurs with a mismatched primer terminus.     

Conformational dynamics of DNA polymerase probed with a novel fluorescent DNA base analogue

DNA polymerases discriminate between correct and incorrect nucleotide substrates during a "nonchemical" step that precedes phosphodiester bond formation in the enzymatic cycle of nucleotide incorporation. Despite the importance of this process in polymerase fidelity, the precise nature of the molecular events involved remains unknown. Here we report a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) system that monitors conformational changes of a polymerase-DNA complex during selection and binding of nucleotide substrates. This system utilizes the fluorescent base analogue 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenothiazine (tC) as the FRET donor and Alexa-555 (A555) as the acceptor. The tC donor was incorporated within a model DNA primer/template in place of a normal base, adjacent to the primer 3' terminus, while the A555 acceptor was attached to an engineered cysteine residue (C751) located in the fingers subdomain of the Klenow fragment (KF) polymerase. The FRET efficiency increased significantly following binding of a correct nucleotide substrate to the KF-DNA complex, showing that the fingers had closed over the active site. Fluorescence anisotropy titrations utilizing tC as a reporter indicated that the DNA was more tightly bound by the polymerase under these conditions, consistent with the formation of a closed ternary complex. The rate of the nucleotide-induced conformational transition, measured in stopped-flow FRET experiments, closely matched the rate of correct nucleotide incorporation, measured in rapid quench-flow experiments, indicating that the conformational change was the rate-limiting step in the overall cycle of nucleotide incorporation for the labeled KF-DNA system. Taken together, these results indicate that the FRET system can be used to probe enzyme conformational changes that are linked to the biochemical function of DNA polymerase.     

Nucleotide-induced DNA polymerase active site motions accommodating a mutagenic DNA intermediate

DNA polymerases occasionally insert the wrong nucleotide. For this error to become a mutation, the mispair must be extended. We report a structure of DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) with a DNA mismatch at the boundary of the polymerase active site. The structure of this complex indicates that the templating adenine of the mispair stacks with the primer terminus adenine while the templating (coding) cytosine is flipped out of the DNA helix. Soaking the crystals of the binary complex with dGTP resulted in crystals of a ternary substrate complex. In this case, the templating cytosine is observed within the DNA helix and forms Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds with the incoming dGTP. The adenine at the primer terminus has rotated into a syn-conformation to interact with the opposite adenine in a planar configuration. Yet, the 3'-hydroxyl on the primer terminus is out of position for efficient nucleotide insertion.     

Crystal structures of open and closed forms of binary and ternary complexes of the large fragment of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I: structural basis for nucleotide incorporation.

The crystal structures of two ternary complexes of the large fragment of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I (Klentaq1) with a primer/template DNA and dideoxycytidine triphosphate, and that of a binary complex of the same enzyme with a primer/template DNA, were determined to a resolution of 2.3, 2.3 and 2.5 A, respectively. One ternary complex structure differs markedly from the two other structures by a large reorientation of the tip of the fingers domain. This structure, designated 'closed', represents the ternary polymerase complex caught in the act of incorporating a nucleotide. In the two other structures, the tip of the fingers domain is rotated outward by 46 degrees ('open') in an orientation similar to that of the apo form of Klentaq1. These structures provide the first direct evidence in DNA polymerase I enzymes of a large conformational change responsible for assembling an active ternary complex.     

Significance of nucleobase shape complementarity and hydrogen bonding in the formation and stability of the closed polymerase-DNA complex

DNA polymerases insert a dNTP by a multistep mechanism that involves a conformational rearrangement from an open to a closed ternary complex, a process that positions the incoming dNTP in the proper orientation for phosphodiester bond formation. In this work, the importance and relative contribution of hydrogen-bonding interactions and the geometric shape of the base pair that forms during this process were studied using Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment, 3'-exonuclease deficient) and natural dNTPs or non-hydrogen-bonding dNTP analogues. Both the geometric fit of the incoming nucleotide and its ability to form Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds with the template were found to contribute to the stability of the closed ternary complex. Although the formation of a closed complex in the presence of a non-hydrogen-bonding nucleotide analogue could be detected by limited proteolysis analysis, a comparison of the stabilities of the ternary complexes indicated that hydrogen-bonding interactions between the incoming dNTP and the template increase the stability of the complex by 6-20-fold. Any deviation from the Watson-Crick base pair geometry was shown to have a destabilizing effect on the closed complex. This degree of destabilization varied from 3- to 730-fold and was found to be correlated with the size of the mismatched base pair. Finally, a stable closed complex is not formed in the presence of a ddNTP or rNTP. These results are discussed in relation to the steric exclusion model for the nucleotide insertion.     

Structural insights into mechanisms of catalysis and inhibition in Norwalk virus polymerase

Crystal structures of Norwalk virus polymerase bound to an RNA primer-template duplex and either the natural substrate CTP or the inhibitor 5-nitrocytidine triphosphate have been determined to 1.8A resolution. These structures reveal a closed conformation of the polymerase that differs significantly from previously determined open structures of calicivirus and picornavirus polymerases. These closed complexes are trapped immediately prior to the nucleotidyl transfer reaction, with the triphosphate group of the nucleotide bound to two manganese ions at the active site, poised for reaction to the 3'-hydroxyl group of the RNA primer. The positioning of the 5-nitrocytidine triphosphate nitro group between the alpha-phosphate and the 3'-hydroxyl group of the primer suggests a novel, general approach for the design of antiviral compounds mimicking natural nucleosides and nucleotides.     

Insight into the catalytic mechanism of DNA polymerase beta: structures of intermediate complexes

The catalytic reaction mediated by DNA polymerases is known to require two Mg(II) ions, one associated with dNTP binding and the other involved in metal ion catalysis of the chemical step. Here we report a functional intermediate structure of a DNA polymerase with only one metal ion bound, the DNA polymerase beta-DNA template-primer-chromium(III).2'-deoxythymidine 5'-beta,gamma-methylenetriphosphate [Cr(III).dTMPPCP] complex, at 2.6 A resolution. The complex is distinct from the structures of other polymerase-DNA-ddNTP complexes in that the 3'-terminus of the primer has a free hydroxyl group. Hence, this structure represents a fully functional intermediate state. Support for this contention is provided by the observation of turnover in biochemical assays of crystallized protein as well as from the determination that soaking Pol beta crystals with Mn(II) ions leads to formation of the product complex, Pol beta-DNA-Cr(III).PCP, whose structure is also reported. An important feature of both structures is that the fingers subdomain is closed, similar to structures of other ternary complexes in which both metal ion sites are occupied. These results suggest that closing of the fingers subdomain is induced specifically by binding of the metal-dNTP complex prior to binding of the catalytic Mg(2+) ion. This has led us to reevaluate our previous evidence regarding the existence of a rate-limiting conformational change in Pol beta's reaction pathway. The results of stopped-flow studies suggest that there is no detectable rate-limiting conformational change step.     

Structure of the replicating complex of a pol alpha family DNA polymerase

We describe the 2.6 A resolution crystal structure of RB69 DNA polymerase with primer-template DNA and dTTP, capturing the step just before primer extension. This ternary complex structure in the human DNA polymerase alpha family shows a 60 degrees rotation of the fingers domain relative to the apo-protein structure, similar to the fingers movement in pol I family polymerases. Minor groove interactions near the primer 3' terminus suggest a common fidelity mechanism for pol I and pol alpha family polymerases. The duplex product DNA orientation differs by 40 degrees between the polymerizing mode and editing mode structures. The role of the thumb in this DNA motion provides a model for editing in the pol alpha family.     

Properties of the 3' to 5' exonuclease associated with calf DNA polymerase delta

The 3' to 5' exonuclease of calf thymus DNA polymerase delta has properties expected of a proofreading nuclease. It digests either single-stranded DNA or the single-stranded nucleotides of a mismatched primer on a DNA template by a nonprocessive mechanism. The distribution of oligonucleotide products suggests that a significant portion of the enzyme dissociates after the removal of one nucleotide. This mechanism is expected if the substrate in vivo is an incorrect nucleotide added by the polymerase. Digestion of single-stranded DNA does not proceed to completion, producing final products six to seven nucleotides long. Digestion of a long mismatched terminus accelerates when the mismatched region is reduced to less than six nucleotides. At the point of complementation, the digestion rate is greatly reduced. These results suggest that short mismatched regions are a preferred substrate. The use of a mismatched primer-template analogue, lacking the template single strand, greatly lowers digestion efficiency at the single-stranded 3'-terminus, suggesting that the template strand is important for substrate recognition. When oligonucleotides were examined for effectiveness as exonuclease inhibitors, (dG)8 was found to be the most potent inhibitor of single-stranded DNA digestion. (dG)8 was less effective at inhibiting digestion of mismatched primer termini, again suggesting that this DNA is a preferred substrate. Overall, these results indicate that the exonuclease of DNA polymerase delta efficiently removes short mismatched DNA, a structure formed from misincorporation during DNA synthesis.     

The structure of a high fidelity DNA polymerase bound to a mismatched nucleotide reveals an "ajar" intermediate conformation in the nucleotide selection mechanism

To achieve accurate DNA synthesis, DNA polymerases must rapidly sample and discriminate against incorrect nucleotides. Here we report the crystal structure of a high fidelity DNA polymerase I bound to DNA primer-template caught in the act of binding a mismatched (dG:dTTP) nucleoside triphosphate. The polymerase adopts a conformation in between the previously established "open" and "closed" states. In this "ajar" conformation, the template base has moved into the insertion site but misaligns an incorrect nucleotide relative to the primer terminus. The displacement of a conserved active site tyrosine in the insertion site by the template base is accommodated by a distinctive kink in the polymerase O helix, resulting in a partially open ternary complex. We suggest that the ajar conformation allows the template to probe incoming nucleotides for complementarity before closure of the enzyme around the substrate. Based on solution fluorescence, kinetics, and crystallographic analyses of wild-type and mutant polymerases reported here, we present a three-state reaction pathway in which nucleotides either pass through this intermediate conformation to the closed conformation and catalysis or are misaligned within the intermediate, leading to destabilization of the closed conformation.     

A thymine isostere in the templating position disrupts assembly of the closed DNA polymerase beta ternary complex

The high fidelity of the DNA polymerization process is critically important for the stability of the cellular genome. The role of template and incoming nucleotide base pairing in polymerase fidelity has recently been explored by the use of nucleotide isosteres, which preserve the steric but not the electronic properties of the corresponding bases. The DNA repair enzyme, DNA polymerase beta (Pol beta), is among the most discriminating, being inactive when the thymine isostere difluorotoluene (DFT) is present in the templating base position. To explore the physical basis for this inactivity, we have performed NMR studies on [methyl-13C]methionine-labeled Pol beta complexed with double-hairpin DNA, used to model the gapped nucleotide substrate, and having either a thymine or a DFT isostere at the templating base position. The six methionine residues distributed throughout the enzyme provide useful conformational probes of the lyase and polymerase domains and subdomains. Analysis of the proton shift of Met282 that results from formation of an abortive Pol beta-gapped DNA-dATP complex is consistent with an open to closed conformational change of the enzyme predicted from crystal structures. In contrast, the same resonance is nearly unshifted when a ternary complex is formed from dATP and gapped DNA in which a DFT isostere replaces thymine at the templating base position. Alternatively, the resonances of Met191 and Met155, located in the catalytic subdomain, show perturbations upon formation of the abortive ternary complex, which are qualitatively similar, but significantly weaker, than the changes observed when thymine is present at the templating base position. The changes in the Met155 and Met191 methyl resonances are in fact more similar to those observed in the binary Pol beta-dATP complex. These studies demonstrate that the block in catalysis is directly related to the absence of the set of conformational transitions that include the "open" to "closed" transition monitored by Met282.     

Effects of benzo[a]pyrene DNA adducts on Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) primer-template interactions: evidence for inhibition of the catalytically active ternary complex formation

Benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide (B[a]PDE) adducts are strong blocks of DNA replication in vitro, allowing the rare incorporation of a nucleotide across from the lesion and negligibly small extent of further bypass. To study the mechanistic details of this process, a gel-retardation assay was used to measure the dissociation constants for the binding of DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) (KF) to the primer-templates containing a (+)-trans- or (+)-cis-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct. When the primer was terminated one nucleotide before the adduct, the presence of a (+)-trans-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct did not affect the binding while a (+)-cis-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct caused a slight decrease in affinity. The presence of any dNTP decreased the affinity of KF to the modified primer-templates. (In contrast, a strong increase of the affinity to unmodified primer-templates was observed in the presence of the next correct dNTP.) Limited protease digestion experiments indicated that a closed ternary complex of KF with the modified primer-templates was not detectable in the presence of any dNTP, whereas it was clearly observed with unmodified template in the presence of the next correct nucleotide. These findings suggest that these adducts may interfere with the conformational change to the catalytically active closed ternary complex and/or cause significant destabilization of this complex. When the primers extended to the position across from the adduct, the affinity of KF was significantly decreased irrespective of the identity of the base across from the adduct, possibly explaining the low bypass of the lesion. Interestingly, the stability of these DNA-polymerase complexes correlated with nucleotide insertion kinetics for the unmodified and (+)-trans-B[a]PDE-modified templates.     

Mechanistic insights into replication across from bulky DNA adducts: a mutant polymerase I allows an N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene adduct to be accommodated during DNA synthesis

The molecular mechanism that allows a polymerase to incorporate a nucleotide opposite a DNA lesion is not well-understood. One way to study this process is to characterize the altered molecular interactions that occur between the polymerase and a damaged template. Prior studies have determined the polymerase-template dissociation constants and used kinetic analyses and a protease digestion assay to measure the effect of various DNA adducts positioned in the active site of Klenow fragment (KF). Here, a mutator polymerase was used in which the tyrosine at position 766 of the KF has been replaced with a serine. This position is located at the junction of the fingers and palm domain and is thought to be involved in maintaining the active site geometry. The primer-template was modified with N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene (AAF), a well-studied carcinogenic adduct. The mutant polymerase displayed a significant increase in the rate of incorporation of the correct nucleotide opposite the adduct but was much less prone to incorporate an incorrect nucleotide relative to the wild-type polymerase. Both the wild-type and the mutant polymerase bound much more tightly to the AAF-modified primer-template; however, unlike the wild-type polymerase, the binding strength of the mutant was influenced by the presence of a dNTP. Moreover, the mutant polymerase was able to undergo a dNTP-induced conformational change when the AAF adduct was positioned in the active site, while the wild-type enzyme could not. A model is proposed in which the looser active site of the mutant is able to better accommodate the AAF adduct.     

Real-time single-molecule studies of the motions of DNA polymerase fingers illuminate DNA synthesis mechanisms

DNA polymerases maintain genomic integrity by copying DNA with high fidelity. A conformational change important for fidelity is the motion of the polymerase fingers subdomain from an open to a closed conformation upon binding of a complementary nucleotide. We previously employed intra-protein single-molecule FRET on diffusing molecules to observe fingers conformations in polymerase–DNA complexes. Here, we used the same FRET ruler on surface-immobilized complexes to observe fingers-opening and closing of individual polymerase molecules in real time. Our results revealed the presence of intrinsic dynamics in the binary complex, characterized by slow fingers-closing and fast fingers-opening. When binary complexes were incubated with increasing concentrations of complementary nucleotide, the fingers-closing rate increased, strongly supporting an induced-fit model for nucleotide recognition. Meanwhile, the opening rate in ternary complexes with complementary nucleotide was 6 s⁻¹, much slower than either fingers closing or the rate-limiting step in the forward direction; this rate balance ensures that, after nucleotide binding and fingers-closing, nucleotide incorporation is overwhelmingly likely to occur. Our results for ternary complexes with a non-complementary dNTP confirmed the presence of a state corresponding to partially closed fingers and suggested a radically different rate balance regarding fingers transitions, which allows polymerase to achieve high fidelity.     

Replication factors required for SV40 DNA replication in vitro. I. DNA structure-specific recognition of a primer-template junction by eukaryotic DNA polymerases and their accessory proteins.

Eukaryotic DNA polymerase delta and its accessory proteins are essential for SV40 DNA replication in vitro. A multi-subunit protein complex, replication factor C (RF-C), which is composed of subunits with apparent molecular weights of 140,000, 41,000, and 37,000, has primer/template binding and DNA-dependent ATPase activities. UV-cross-linking experiments demonstrated that the Mr = 140,000 subunit recognizes and binds to the primer-template DNA, whereas the Mr = 41,000 polypeptide binds ATP. Assembly of a replication complex at a primer-template junction has been studied in detail with synthetic, hairpin DNAs. Following glutaraldehyde fixation, a gel shift assay demonstrated that RF-C alone forms a weak binding complex with the hairpin DNA. Addition of ATP or its nonhydrolyzable analogue, ATP gamma S, increased specific binding to the DNA. Footprinting experiments revealed that RF-C recognizes the primer-template junction, covering 15 bases of the primer DNA from the 3'-end and 20 bases of the template DNA. Another replication factor, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) binds to RF-C and the primer-template DNA forming a primer recognition complex and extends the protected region on the duplex DNA. This RF-C.PCNA complex has significant single-stranded DNA binding activity in addition to binding to a primer-template junction. However, addition of another replication factor, RF-A, completely blocked the nonspecific, single-stranded DNA binding by the RF-C.PCNA complex. RF-A therefore functions as a specificity factor for primer recognition. In the absence of RF-C, DNA polymerase delta (pol delta) and PCNA form a complex at the primer-template junction, protecting exactly the same site as the primer recognition complex. Addition of RF-C to this complex produced a higher order complex which is unstable unless its formation is coupled with translocation of pol delta. These results suggest that the sequential binding of RF-C, PCNA, and pol delta to a primer-template junction might directly account for the initiation of leading strand DNA synthesis at a replication origin. We demonstrate this directly in an accompanying paper (Tsurimoto, T., and Stillman, B. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 1961-1968).     

Metal-induced DNA translocation leads to DNA polymerase conformational activation

Binding of the catalytic divalent ion to the ternary DNA polymerase β/gapped DNA/dNTP complex is thought to represent the final step in the assembly of the catalytic complex and is consequently a critical determinant of replicative fidelity. We have analyzed the effects of Mg(2+) and Zn(2+) on the conformational activation process based on NMR measurements of [methyl-(13)C]methionine DNA polymerase β. Unexpectedly, both divalent metals were able to produce a template base-dependent conformational activation of the polymerase/1-nt gapped DNA complex in the absence of a complementary incoming nucleotide, albeit with different temperature thresholds. This conformational activation is abolished by substituting Glu295 with lysine, thereby interrupting key hydrogen bonds necessary to stabilize the closed conformation. These and other results indicate that metal-binding can promote: translocation of the primer terminus base pair into the active site; expulsion of an unpaired pyrimidine, but not purine, base from the template-binding pocket; and motions of polymerase subdomains that close the active site. We also have performed pyrophosphorolysis studies that are consistent with predictions based on these results. These findings provide new insight into the relationships between conformational activation, enzyme activity and polymerase fidelity.     

Role of the C-terminal residue of the DNA polymerase of bacteriophage T7.

The crystal structure of the DNA polymerase encoded by gene 5 of bacteriophage T7, in a complex with its processivity factor, Escherichia coli thioredoxin, a primer-template, and an incoming deoxynucleoside triphosphate reveals a putative hydrogen bond between the C-terminal residue, histidine 704 of gene 5 protein, and an oxygen atom on the penultimate phosphate diester of the primer strand. Elimination of this electrostatic interaction by replacing His(704) with alanine renders the phage nonviable, and no DNA synthesis is observed in vivo. Polymerase activity of the genetically altered enzyme on primed M13 DNA is only 12% of the wild-type enzyme, and its processivity is drastically reduced. Kinetic parameters for binding a primer-template (K(D)(app)), nucleotide binding (K(m)), and k(off) for dissociation of the altered polymerase from a primer-template are not significantly different from that of wild-type T7 DNA polymerase. However, the decrease in polymerase activity is concomitant with increased hydrolytic activity, judging from the turnover of nucleoside triphosphate into the corresponding nucleoside monophosphate (percentage of turnover, 65%) during DNA synthesis. Biochemical data along with structural observations imply that the terminal amino acid residue of T7 DNA polymerase plays a critical role in partitioning DNA between the polymerase and exonuclease sites.     

Human DNA polymerase η is pre-aligned for dNTP binding and catalysis

Pre-steady-state kinetic studies on Y-family DNA polymerase η (Polη) have suggested that the polymerase undergoes a rate-limiting conformational change step before the phosphoryl transfer of the incoming nucleotide to the primer terminus. However, the nature of this rate-limiting conformational change step has been unclear, due in part to the lack of structural information on the Polη binary complex. We present here for the first time a crystal structure of human Polη (hPolη) in binary complex with its DNA substrate. We show that the hPolη domains move only slightly on dNTP binding and that the polymerase by and large is pre-aligned for dNTP binding and catalysis. We also show that there is no major reorientation of the DNA from a nonproductive to a productive configuration and that the active site is devoid of metals in the absence of dNTP. Together, these observations lead us to suggest that the rate-limiting conformational change step in the Polη replication cycle likely corresponds to a rate-limiting entry of catalytic metals in the active site.