Overexpression of a novel soybean gene modulating Na+ and K+ transport enhances salt tolerance in transgenic tobacco plants

Salt is an important factor affecting the growth and development of soybean in saline soil. In this study, a novel soybean gene encoding a transporter (GmHKT1) was identified and its function analyzed using transgenic plants. GmHKT1 encoded a protein of 419 amino acids, with a potential molecular mass of 47.06 kDa and a predicted pI value of 8.59. Comparison of the genomic and cDNA sequences of GmHKT1 identified no intron. The deduced amino acid sequence of GmHKT1 showed 38–49% identity with other plant HKT‐like sequences. RT‐PCR analysis showed that the expression of GmHKT1 was upregulated by salt stress (150 mM NaCl) in roots and leaves but not in stems. Overexpression of GmHKT1 significantly enhanced the tolerance of transgenic tobacco plants to salt stress, compared with non‐transgenic plants. To investigate the role of GmHKT1 in K⁺ and Na⁺ transport, we compared K⁺ and Na⁺ accumulation in roots and shoots of wild‐type and transgenic tobacco plants. The results suggested that GmHKT1 is a transporter that affected K⁺ and Na⁺ transport in roots and shoots, and regulated Na⁺/K⁺ homeostasis in these organs. Our findings suggest that GmHKT1 plays an important role in response to salt stress and would be useful in engineering crop plants for enhanced tolerance to salt stress.     

Comparative Study of Alkaline, Saline, and Mixed Saline–Alkaline Stresses with Regard to Their Effects on Growth, Nutrient Accumulation, and Root Morphology of Lotus tenuis

Both saline and alkaline conditions frequently coexist in nature; however, little is known about the effects of alkaline and salt?Calkaline stresses on plants. We performed pot experiments with four treatments, control without salt addition and three stress conditions??neutral, alkaline, and mixed salt?Calkaline??to determine their effects on growth, nutrient accumulation and root architecture in the glycophytic species Lotus tenuis. Neutral and alkaline salts produced a similar detrimental effect on L. tenuis growth, whereas the effect of their combination was synergistic. Neutral salt addition, alone or mixed with NaHCO₃, led to significant leaf Na⁺ build up and reduced K⁺ concentration. In contrast, in plants treated with NaHCO₃ only, Na⁺ levels and the Na⁺/K⁺ ratio remained relatively unchanged. Proline accumulation was not affected by the high pH in the absence of NaCl, but it was raised by the neutral salt and mixed treatments. The total root length was reduced by the addition of NaCl alone, whereas it was not affected by alkalinity, regardless of the presence of NaCl. The topological trend showed that alkalinity alone or mixed with NaCl turned the root more herringbone compared with control roots, whereas no significant change in this index was observed in the treatment with the neutral salt only. The pattern of morphological changes in L. tenuis root architecture after the alkaline treatment (in the absence of NaCl) was similar to that found in the mixed salt?Calkaline treatment and different from that observed in neutral salt. A unique root morphological response to the mixed salt?Calkaline stress was the reduction in the ratio between xylem vessels and root cross-sectional areas.     

导入TaNHX2基因提高了转基因普那菊苣的耐盐性

我国部分地区土地盐碱化的日益严重,对作物的生长和生态环境产生了显著影响,因此通过植物基因工程手段培育耐盐碱的转基因作物品种对改善作物的生存能力和生态环境,提高作物产量具有重要的意义。采用农杆菌介导法将来自小麦(Triticum aestivum Linn)的Na⁺ /H⁺逆向转运蛋白的基因(vacuolar Na⁺/H⁺ exchanger or antiporter,简称NHX、NHE或NHA),对普那菊苣(Cichorium intybus L.cv.Puna)植株进行了遗传转化。经抗生素筛选以及针对TaNHX2基因的PCR检测和Southern杂交分析,证明获得了28株转TaNHX2基因的普那菊苣植株。用不同浓度NaCl溶液对普那菊苣野生型和T₀代种子、愈伤组织和幼苗生长情况胁迫的研究,结果表明:转TaNHX2基因普那菊苣植株表现出一定的抗性,比野生型明显提高。在300 mmol/L NaCl胁迫下转基因植株种子的出芽率、外植体出愈率和分化率是野生型植株的2-4倍,而500 mmol/L NaCl浓度为野生型和转基因外植体能否生长的临界点。在此临界值下野生型外植体或不能形成愈伤组织、或幼苗不能正常生根、或已生根幼苗不能正常成长,而转基因外植体可以继续形成愈伤组织并正常生根生长。同时对500 mmol/L NaCl胁迫下野生型和转基因普那菊苣幼苗其体内丙二醛含量(MDA)、过氧化氢酶(POD)和超氧化物歧化酶(SOD)活性进行测定,结果表明 转基因植株比野生型植株的MDA含量降低了1-3倍,POD活性提高了1-3倍,SOD活性提高了2-3倍,分析发现普那菊苣的耐盐性与其体内的丙二醛含量(MDA)、过氧化氢酶(POD)和超氧化物歧化酶(SOD)活性密切相关。     

燕麦对松嫩草地三种主要盐分胁迫的生理适应策略

为明确燕麦幼苗对松嫩盐碱草地3种主要盐分Na Cl、Na HCO_3和Na_2CO_3的适应机制,设定不同浓度梯度(48—144 mmol/L)的胁迫处理液,测定燕麦幼苗的生长与生理指标变化。结果表明,尽管试验设定的Na Cl浓度并不影响幼苗的存活率,但在各组胁迫处理下,随着浓度的增加,燕麦幼苗的分蘖数、植株高度、茎叶与根系的生物量均呈下降趋势,下降幅度为Na_2CO_3Na HCO_3Na Cl。另外,与Na Cl胁迫相比,Na_2CO_3与Na HCO_3胁迫下茎叶与根中积累了更多的有毒Na~+,同时K~+下降幅度也更大,并且根系中含有更高的Na~+与更低的K~+以及更高的Na~+/K~+。在Na Cl胁迫下,燕麦幼苗积累大量的无机Cl~-和脯氨酸来维持细胞内的渗透与离子平衡,而Na HCO_3与Na_2CO_3胁迫造成了燕麦幼苗体内阴离子的亏缺,此时幼苗主要通过积累大量的有机酸和更多的脯氨酸来维持渗透与离子平衡。上述结果表明,碱性盐Na_2CO_3与Na HCO_3对植物的胁迫伤害程度大于中性盐Na Cl,并且Na_2CO_3的毒害效应最强,而燕麦幼苗对不同的盐分胁迫伤害也有会产生不同的生理适应策略。     

Enhanced drought and salt tolerance by expression of AtGSK1 gene in poplar

A GSK3/shaggy-like kinase (AtGSK1) has been implicated in the regulation of drought and salt tolerance. We transferred AtGSK1 from Arabidopsis thaliana to a hybrid poplar (Populus alba × P. tremula var. grandulosa) to determine the effect of the transgene expression in the transgenic trees. The results from northern blot and RT-PCR analyses showed that the expression level varied among the transgenic lines. During their culture on tissue culture media, the transgenic poplars formed vigorous growing roots even in the presence of 125 mM NaCl and callus in the presence of 150 mM NaCl. When the transgenic poplars were growing in pots and provided with NaCl solution, they stayed much healthier than did nontransgenic poplars, showing higher rates of photosynthetic rates, stomatal conductance, and evaporation rates under the stress. Whereas the total level of leaf Na⁺ level increased dramatically in transgenic poplars under severe saline conditions (150 mM NaCl), that of leaf K⁺ decreased in the same plants under the same conditions. Total root Na⁺ level increased in nontransgenic poplars under severe saline conditions. In contrast, total root K⁺ level decreased in the same plants under the same conditions. The chloride content and relative electrical conductivity of the transgenic poplars after salt stress treatment were lower than those of nontransgenic poplars. The transgenic poplars were also tolerant to up to 20 % PEG remaining significantly healthy when compared with nontransgenic poplars with necrosis and chlorosis symptoms. Another dramatic feature of the transgenic poplars was wilting tolerance for prolonged drought treatment up to 2 weeks. The results provide evidence that the expression of AtGSK1 gene conferred drought and salt tolerance in the transgenic poplars.     

Seed germination,seedling survival,and physiological response of sunflowers under saline and alkaline conditions

Salinization and alkalization of soil are widespread environmental problem and the alkali stress is more destructive than the effects caused by salt stress. To compare the mechanism of salt and alkali stresses, a sunflower variety (Helianthus annuus L. cv. Baikuiza 6) was tested under saline or alkaline conditions by mixing two neutral salts (NaCl and Na₂SO₄) or two alkaline salts (NaHCO₃ and Na₂CO₃). The results showed that saline conditions differed greatly from alkaline conditions in their threshold intensities where sunflower can germinate, survive and grow. Under saline conditions, the emergence time was delayed, and the emergence rate and seedling survival rate also decreased with increasing salinity. However, under alkaline conditions, the rate of seedling survival decreased sharply but the emergence time and emergence rate did not change. In addition, the damaging effects of alkali stress on growth and photosynthesis were more severe than those of saline. In shoots, the main inorganic osmolyte and cation was K⁺ rather than Na⁺; the primary organic osmolytes were organic acid and soluble sugar rather than proline. Organic acid, NO₃ ⁻, and Cl⁻ (only under saline condition) were the main source of anion. In addition, the osmotic adjustment and ion balance differed among sunflower roots, stems, and leaves. In conclusion, saline and alkaline conditions are two different stress conditions and there are special responses to two stress conditions for sunflower.     

The K+/H+ antiporter LeNHX2 increases salt tolerance by improving K+ homeostasis in transgenic tomato

The endosomal LeNHX2 ion transporter exchanges H⁺ with K⁺ and, to lesser extent, Na⁺. Here, we investigated the response to NaCl supply and K⁺ deprivation in transgenic tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) overexpressing LeNHX2 and show that transformed tomato plants grew better in saline conditions than untransformed controls, whereas in the absence of K⁺ the opposite was found. Analysis of mineral composition showed a higher K⁺ content in roots, shoots and xylem sap of transgenic plants and no differences in Na⁺ content between transgenic and untransformed plants grown either in the presence or the absence of 120 mm NaCl. Transgenic plants showed higher Na⁺/H⁺ and, above all, K⁺/H⁺ transport activity in root intracellular membrane vesicles. Under K⁺ limiting conditions, transgenic plants enhanced root expression of the high‐affinity K⁺ uptake system HAK5 compared to untransformed controls. Furthermore, tomato overexpressing LeNHX2 showed twofold higher K⁺ depletion rates and half cytosolic K⁺ activity than untransformed controls. Under NaCl stress, transgenic plants showed higher uptake velocity for K⁺ and lower cytosolic K⁺ activity than untransformed plants. These results indicate the fundamental role of K⁺ homeostasis in the better performance of LeNHX2 overexpressing tomato under NaCl stress.     

Na<Superscript>+</Superscript>/H<Superscript>+</Superscript> and K<Superscript>+</Superscript>/H<Superscript>+</Superscript> antiporters AtNHX1 and AtNHX3 from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis> improve salt and drought tolerance in transgenic poplar

The tonoplast and plasma membrane localized sodium (potassium)/proton antiporters have been shown to play an important role in plant resistance to salt stress. In this study, AtNHX1 and AtNHX3, two tonoplast Na⁺(K⁺)/H⁺ antiporter encoding genes from Arabidopsis thaliana, were expressed in poplar to investigate their biological functions in the resistance to abiotic stresses in woody plants. Transgenic poplar plants expressing either gene exhibited increased resistance to both salt and water-deficit stresses. Compared to the wild type (WT) plants, transgenic plants accumulated more sodium and potassium ions in the presence of 100 mM NaCl and showed reduced electrolyte leakage in the leaves under water stress. Furthermore, the proton-translocating and cation-dependent H⁺ (Na⁺/H⁺ or K⁺/H⁺) exchange activities in the tonoplast vesicles isolated from the leaves of transgenic plants were higher than in those isolated from WT plants. Therefore, constitutive expression of either AtNHX1 or AtNHX3 genetically modified the salt and water stress tolerance of transgenic poplar plants, providing a potential tool for engineering tree species with enhanced resistance to multiple abitotic stresses.     

SOS1 gene overexpression increased salt tolerance in transgenic tobacco by maintaining a higher K(+)/Na(+) ratio

Crop productivity is greatly affected by soil salinity, so improvement in salinity tolerance of crops is a major objective of many studies. We overexpressed the Arabidopsis thaliana SOS1 gene, which encodes a plasma membrane Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter, in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi-nc). Compared with nontransgenic plants, seeds from transgenic tobacco had better germination under 120 mM (mmol L⁻¹) NaCl stress; chlorophyll loss in the transgenic seedlings treated with 360 mM NaCl was less; transgenic tobacco showed superior growth after irrigation with NaCl solutions; and transgenic seedlings with 150 mM NaCl stress accumulated less Na⁺ and more K⁺. In addition, roots of SOS1-overexpressing seedlings lost less K⁺ instantaneously in response to 50 mM NaCl than control plants. These results showed that the A. thaliana SOS1 gene potentially can improve the salt tolerance of other plant species.     

Overexpression of AaPal,a peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein from Alkalomonas amylolytica,improves salt and alkaline tolerance of Escherichia coli and Arabidopsis thaliana

The outer membrane lipoprotein, Pal, plays a major role maintaining the integrity of outer membrane and cell morphology in Gram-negative bacteria. Here, we represent A novel role of AaPal in tolerance to salt and alkaline stresses. The cell density of Escherichia coli expressing AaPal was approx. three times as that of control strain when grown in the presence of 1 M NaCl or at pH 9.0 for 14 h, and transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana grew taller and stronger than wild-type plants when subjected to 200 mM NaCl or pH 9.0 stress. This tolerance was attributed to higher concentrations of K⁺ and lower concentrations of Na⁺ in the transgenic organism. Our study provides a potential use of AaPal in the improvement of salt and alkaline tolerance in bacteria and plants.     

Expression of a Suaeda salsa Vacuolar H+/Ca2+ Transporter Gene in Arabidopsis Contributes to Physiological Changes in Salinity

A cDNA (SsCAX1) encoding a tonoplast-localised Ca²⁺/H⁺ exchanger was isolated from a C₃ halophyte Suaeda salsa (L.). To clarify the role of SsCAX1 in plant salt tolerance, Arabidopsis plants expressing SsCAX1 were treated with NaCl. Transgenic Arabidopsis plants displayed decreased salt tolerance. Although Na⁺ content was close to wild-type plants, transgenic plants accumulated more Ca²⁺ and retained less K⁺ in leaves than the wild-type plants in salinity. Furthermore, transgenic lines held higher leaf membrane leakage than wild-type lines under NaCl treatment. In addition, transgenic plants showed a 23% increase in vacuolar H⁺-ATPase activity compared with wild-type plants in normal condition. But the leaf V-H⁺-ATPase activity had subtle changes in transgenic plants, while significantly increased in wild-type plants under saline condition. These results suggested that regulated expression of Ca²⁺/H⁺ antiport was critical for maintenance of cation homeostasis and activity of V-H⁺-ATPase under saline condition.     

Overexpression of Rice CBS Domain Containing Protein Improves Salinity, Oxidative, and Heavy Metal Tolerance in Transgenic Tobacco

We have recently identified and classified a cystathionine ??-synthase domain containing protein family in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) and rice (Oryza sativa L.). Based on the microarray and MPSS data, we have suggested their involvement in stress tolerance. In this study, we have characterized a rice protein of unknown function, OsCBSX4. This gene was found to be upregulated under high salinity, heavy metal, and oxidative stresses at seedling stage. Transgenic tobacco plants overexpressing OsCBSX4 exhibited improved tolerance toward salinity, heavy metal, and oxidative stress. This enhanced stress tolerance in transgenic plants could directly be correlated with higher accumulation of OsCBSX4 protein. Transgenic plants could grow and set seeds under continuous presence of 150?mM NaCl. The total seed yield in WT plants was reduced by 80%, while in transgenic plants, it was reduced only by 15?C17%. The transgenic plants accumulated less Na⁺, especially in seeds and maintained higher net photosynthesis rate and Fv/Fm than WT plants under NaCl stress. Transgenic seedlings also accumulated significantly less H₂O₂ as compared to WT under salinity, heavy metal, and oxidative stress. OsCBSX4 overexpressing transgenic plants exhibit higher abiotic stress tolerance than WT plants suggesting its role in abiotic stress tolerance in plants.     

A Medicago truncatula EF-Hand Family Gene,MtCaMP1, Is Involved in Drought and Salt Stress Tolerance

Background

Calcium-binding proteins that contain EF-hand motifs have been reported to play important roles in transduction of signals associated with biotic and abiotic stresses. To functionally characterize gens of EF-hand family in response to abiotic stress, an MtCaMP1 gene belonging to EF-hand family from legume model plant Medicago truncatula was isolated and its function in response to drought and salt stress was investigated by expressing MtCaMP1 in Arabidopsis.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Transgenic Arabidopsis seedlings expressing MtCaMP1exhibited higher survival rate than wild-type seedlings under drought and salt stress, suggesting that expression of MtCaMP1 confers tolerance of Arabidopsis to drought and salt stress. The transgenic plants accumulated greater amounts of Pro due to up-regulation of P5CS1 and down-regulation of ProDH than wild-type plants under drought stress. There was a less accumulation of Na⁺ in the transgenic plants than in WT plants due to reduced up-regulation of AtHKT1 and enhanced regulation of AtNHX1 in the transgenic plants compared to WT plants under salt stress. There was a reduced accumulation of H₂O₂ and malondialdehyde in the transgenic plants than in WT plants under both drought and salt stress.

Conclusions/Significance

The expression of MtCaMP1 in Arabidopsis enhanced tolerance of the transgenic plants to drought and salt stress by effective osmo-regulation due to greater accumulation of Pro and by minimizing toxic Na⁺ accumulation, respectively. The enhanced accumulation of Pro and reduced accumulation of Na⁺ under drought and salt stress would protect plants from water default and Na⁺ toxicity, and alleviate the associated oxidative stress. These findings demonstrate that MtCaMP1 encodes a stress-responsive EF-hand protein that plays a regulatory role in response of plants to drought and salt stress.     

Coexpression of ScNHX1 and ScVP in Transgenic Hybrids Improves Salt and Saline-Alkali Tolerance in Alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.)

Salt and saline-alkali are major environmental factors limiting the growth and productivity of alfalfa, the most economically important forage legume worldwide. In this study, alfalfa plants transgenic for both ScNHX1 (encoding vacuolar membrane Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter from Suaeda corniculata) and ScVP (encoding vacuolar H⁺-PPase from S. corniculata) were produced by cross-pollination. Transgenic alfalfa plants coexpressing ScVP/ScNHX1 showed enhanced salt and saline-alkali tolerance to 300 or 200 mM NaCl with 100 mM NaHCO₃ treatments, compared with wild-type plants. In addition, ScVP/ScNHX1-coexpressing alfalfa plants accumulated more Na⁺ in leaves and roots than wild-type plants and showed increased tolerance to higher salt and saline-alkali stress. Using the fluorescent carboxy-SNARF probe, the intracellular pH was visualized in the transgenic and wild-type plants under salt and saline-alkali stress. The results showed that the overnight treatment caused a massive change in pH in ScVP/ScNHX1-coexpressing alfalfa plants and they showed that there was significantly higher vacuolar alkalization under salt stress compared with wild-type plants. However, saline-alkali treatment enhanced vacuolar acidification more in the wild-type plants than in transgenic plants. Taken together, our results indicate that coexpression of multiple, effective genes in transgenic plants can enhance resistance to salt and saline-alkali stress.     

Overexpression of SeNHX1 improves both salt tolerance and disease resistance in tobacco

Recently, we found NHX1, the gene encoding a Na⁺/H⁺ exchanger, participated in plant disease defense. Although NHX1 has been confirmed to be involved in plant salt tolerance, whether the NHX1 transgenic plants exhibit both salt tolerance and disease resistance has not been investigated. The T1 progenies of Nicotiana tabacum L. lines expressing SeNHX1 (from Salicornia europaea) were generated for the present study. Compared with PBI-type control plants, SeNHX1 transgenic tobaccos exhibited more biomass, longer root length, and higher K⁺/Na⁺ ratio at post germination or seedling stage under NaCl treatment, indicating enhanced salt tolerance. The vacuolar H⁺ efflux in SeNHX1 transgenic tobacco was increased after treatment of NaCl with different concentration. Meanwhile, the SeNHX1 transgenic tobaccos showed smaller wilted spot area, less H₂O₂ accumulation in leaves after infection of Phytophthora parasitica var. nicotianae. Further investigation demonstrated a larger NAD(P)(H) pool in SeNHX1 transgenic tobacco. These evidences revealed that overexpression of SeNHX1 intensified the compartmentation of Na⁺ into vacuole under salt stress and improved the ability of eliminating ROS after pathogen attack, which then enhanced salt tolerance and disease resistance simultaneously in tobacco. Our findings indicate NHX1 has potential value in creating crops with both improved salt tolerance and disease resistance.     

渗透胁迫和离子毒害对转Bt基因棉幼苗生长及离子分布的影响

研究了渗透和盐胁迫处理对转Bt基因抗虫棉(Gossypium hirsutum) 99B种子的萌发和幼苗生长的影响,以及幼苗不同器官离子吸收和分配的差异。结果表明:渗透和盐胁迫均对转Bt基因抗虫棉幼苗的生长有抑制作用,其中PEG的抑制作用最强,而3种盐的抑制程度以CaCl₂>NaCl>Na₂SO₄,且在Na⁺含量相同时,Cl^-的毒害大于SO₄^2-。渗透胁迫下使根、茎和叶中的Na⁺和Cl^-含量提高,K⁺、Ca²⁺、SO₄^2-含量和K⁺/Na⁺、Ca²⁺/Na⁺和SO₄^2-/Cl^-比值降低,且地上部的变化幅度大于地下部的,其中以PEG的影响最为显著,其次是CaCl₂,Na₂SO₄处理最弱。这些说明,转Bt基因抗虫棉99B的耐盐性较弱。     

The over-expression of Chrysanthemum crassum CcSOS1 improves the salinity tolerance of chrysanthemum

Soil salinity represents a major constraint on plant growth. Here, we report that the over-expression of the Chrysanthemum crassum plasma membrane Na⁺/H⁺ antiporter gene CcSOS1, driven by the CaMV 35S promoter, improved the salinity tolerance of chrysanthemum ‘Jinba’. In salinity-stressed transgenic plants, both the proportion of the leaf area suffering damage and the electrical conductivity of the leaf were lower in the transgenic lines than in salinity-stressed wild type plants. After a 6 day exposure to 200 mM NaCl, the leaf content of both chlorophyll (a+b) and proline was higher in the transgenic than in the wild type plants. The activity of both superoxide dismutase and peroxidase was higher in the transgenic than in the wild type plants throughout the period of NaCl stress. The transgenic plants had a stronger control over the ingress of Na⁺ into the plant, particularly with respect to the youngest leaves, and so maintained a more favorable K⁺/Na⁺ ratio. The result suggests that a possible strategy for improving the salinity tolerance of chrysanthemum could target the restriction of Na⁺ accumulation. This study is the first to report the transgenic expression of a Na⁺ efflux carrier in chrysanthemum.     

Saline-induced changes of epicuticular waxy layer on the Puccinellia tenuiflora and Oryza sativa leave surfaces

Background

The epicuticular waxy layer of plant leaves enhances the extreme environmental stress tolerance. However, the relationship between waxy layer and saline tolerance was not established well. The epicuticular waxy layer of rice (Oryza sativa L.) was studied under the NaHCO₃ stresses. In addition, strong saline tolerance Puccinellia tenuiflora was chosen for comparative studies.

Results

Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images showed that there were significant changes in waxy morphologies of the rice epicuticular surfaces, while no remarkable changes in those of P. tenuiflora epicuticular surfaces. The NaHCO₃-induced morphological changes of the rice epicuticular surfaces appeared as enlarged silica cells, swollen corns-shapes and leaked salt columns under high stress. Energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectroscopic profiles supported that the changes were caused by significant increment and localization of [Na⁺] and [Cl⁻] in the shoot. Atomic absorption spectra showed that [Na⁺]_shoot/[Na⁺]_root for P. tenuiflora maintained stable as the saline stress increased, but that for rice increased significantly.

Conclusion

In rice, NaHCO₃ stress induced localization and accumulation of [Na⁺] and [Cl⁻] appeared as the enlarged silica cells (MSC), the swollen corns (S-C), and the leaked columns (C), while no significant changes in P. tenuiflora.