A simple and rapid method for evaluating the survival of xeroderma pigmentosum lymphoid lines after irradiation with ultraviolet light

Summary A simple, rapid and reproducible test has been developed to measure the viability of cells after irradiation with ultraviolet light (UV). Epstein-Barr virus-transformed lymphoid lines, derived from patients with xeroderma pigmentosum (XP), were irradiated with UV, and the post-UV viability of the lymphoid lines was determined by the trypan blue dye exclusion method. The relative post-UV survival of the patients' lymphoid lines was similar to the relative post-UV survival of the patients' fibroblast strains.     

Differential features of sister-chromatid exchange responses to ultraviolet radiation and caffeine in xeroderma pigmentosum lymphoblastoid cell lines

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) induced by ultraviolet (UV) irradiation and viability after UV irradiation were studied in lymphoblastoid cell lines derived from 7 patients with xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) and 6 normal donors. UV irradiation caused significant increases of SCEs in both XP and normal cells. In 3 XP cell lines, which were deficient in unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) and sensitive to the killing effect of UV, very high SCE frequencies were observed after UV irradiation. Cells from a patient with the De Sanctis-Cacchione syndrome were the most sensitive to UV in terms of both SCE induction and cell killing. In 2 of 4 UDS-proficient XP cell lines tested, the incidences of UV-induced SCEs were similar to those in normal cell lines, but in 2 other UDS-proficient lines from 2 XP patients with skin cancer, the frequencies of UV-induced SCEs were significantly higher than in normal cells.Continuous post-UV treatment with 1 mM caffeine markedly enhanced UV-induced SCEs in 3 of 4 UDS-proficient XP cell lines but had only slight effects on cells from the 4th UDS-proficient XP patient and from normal individuals.     

DNA damage-processing in E. coli: on-going protein synthesis is required for fixation of UV-induced lethality and mutation

UV irradiation of E. coli produces photoproducts in the DNA genome. In consequence, some bacteria lose viability (colony-forming ability) or remain viable as mutant cells. However, the end-points of viability inactivation (lethality) or mutation are determined by cellular processes that act on the UV-damaged DNA. We have investigated the in vivo time course for processes that deal with cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) which can be specifically removed by photoreactivation (PR). At different times during post-UV incubation, samples were challenged with PR and assayed for viability or mutation. We used excision-defective E. coli B/r cells and worked under yellow light to avoid background PR. During post-UV incubation (0-100min) in fully supplemented defined medium, inactivation and mutation were initially significantly reversed by PR but the extent of this reversal decreased during continued incubation defining "fixation" of lethality or mutation, respectively. In contrast, if protein synthesis was restricted during the post-UV incubation, no fixation developed. When chloramphenicol was added to inhibit protein synthesis after 30min of supplemented post-UV incubation, at a time sufficient for expression of UV-induced protein(s), fixation of lethality or mutation was still annulled (no change in the effectiveness of PR developed). Lethality fixation did progress when protein synthesis was restricted and the cells were incubated in the presence of puromycin or were either clpP or clpX defective. We discuss these and related results to suggest (1) on-going protein synthesis is required in the fixation process for lethality and mutation to sustain an effective level of a hypothetical protein sensitive to ClpXP proteolysis and (2) this protein plays a critical role in the process leading to exchange between Pol III activity and alternative polymerase activities required as each cell deals with damage in template DNA.     

Increase in ultraviolet sensitivity by overexpression of calpastatin in ultraviolet-resistant UVr-1 cells derived from ultraviolet-sensitive human RSa cells

Human RSa cells are highly sensitive to apoptotic-like cell death by ultraviolet irradiation (UV) while UVr-1 cells are their variant with an increased resistance to UV. Three days after UV at 10 J/m2, the viability of RSa cells was approximately 17% while that of UVr-1 cells was 65%. This different survival might reflect apoptotic cell death since apoptosis-specific DNA ladder was more clearly observed in RSa cells than in UVr-1 cells after UV. Addition of ALLN/calpain inhibitor I to the culture medium after UV resulted in similar survival (14 - 18%) between RSa and UVr-1 cells. Immunoblot analysis showed down-regulation of protein kinase CTheta, Src, Bax and mu-calpain after UV was more prominent in UVr-1 than in RSa cells. Activated mu-calpain appeared within 1 h post-UV only in UVr-1 cells. The expression of calpastatin, a specific endogenous inhibitor of calpain, was higher in RSa than in UVr-1 cells. To further examine the role of calpain in UV-induced cell death, cDNA of human calpastatin was transfected into UVr-1 cells. The results showed that overexpression of calpastatin suppressed down-regulation of Src, mu-calpain and Bax. Concomitantly, colony survival after UV was reduced in calpastatin-transfected cells as compared to vector control cells. Our results suggest that activation of calpain might account for, at least in part, the lower susceptibility to UV-induced cell death in UVr-1 cells.     

Nucleotide excision repair and photoreactivation in the entomopathogenic fungi Beauveria bassiana, Beauveria brongniartii, Beauveria nivea, Metarhizium anisopliae, Paecilomyces farinosus and Verticillium lecanii

AIMS: To compare the DNA repair capabilities of the entomopathogenic fungus (EPF) bassiana to the EPF Beauveria brongniartii, Beauveria nivea, Metarhizium anisopliae, Paecilomyces farinosus, Verticillium lecanii, and the fungi Aspergillus niger and Neurospora crassa. METHODS AND RESULTS: Germination of B. bassiana conidiospores following ultraviolet (UV) irradiation was used to show that nucleotide excision repair and photoreactivation decrease the post-UV germination delay. These two modes of repair were characterized and compared between the aforementioned EPF, A. niger and N. crassa using a physiological assay where per cent survival post-UV irradiation was scored as colony forming units. CONCLUSIONS: The results showed B. bassiana and M. anisopliae are the most UV-tolerant EPF. The DNA repair capabilities indicated that EPF do not have all DNA repair options available to fungi, such as A. niger and N. crassa. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: A key factor detrimental to the survival of EPF in agro-ecosystems is UV light from solar radiation. The EPF literature pertaining to UV irradiation is varied with respect to methodology, UV source, and dose, which prevented comparisons. Here we have characterized the fungi by a standard method and established the repair capabilities of EPF under optimal conditions.     

Characterization of the enhancing effect of caffeine on sister-chromatid exchanges induced by ultraviolet radiation in excision-proficient xeroderma pigmentosum lymphoblastoid cells

Cells of some excision-proficient xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cell lines are highly sensitive to post-UV caffeine treatment in terms of sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) induction as well as cell lethality. In the present study, we conducted a detailed investigation of the enhancing effect of caffeine on SCE frequency induced by UV in excision-proficient XP cells, and obtained the following results. (1) Continuous post-UV treatment with 1 mM caffeine markedly enhances UV-induced SCEs and such enhanced SCEs occur with similar frequency during either the 1st or the 2nd cell cycle in the presence of caffeine and 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd). (2) The high sensitivity of the cells to post-UV caffeine treatment persists for at least 2 days after UV when irradiated cells are held in either the proliferating or the nonproliferating state prior to the addition of BrdUrd. (3) Caffeine exerts its effect on cells in S phase. (4) Neither BrdUrd in the medium nor the incorporated 5-bromodeoxyuridine monophosphate (BrdUMP) in DNA plays an appreciable role in the expression of the enhancing effect of caffeine. The most likely explanation for our findings is as follows. In excision-proficient XP cells, the cause of SCE formation such as UV-induced lesions or resulting perturbations of DNA replication persists until the 2nd round or more of post-UV DNA replication. If caffeine is given as post-UV treatment, such abnormalities may be amplified, resulting in a synergistic increase in SCE frequency.     

Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101, increases post-UV DNA synthesis, but sensitises some strains of Escherichia coli to UV

Plasmid pKM101, which carries muc genes that are analogous in function to chromosomal umu genes, protected Escherichia coli strains AB1157 uvrB+ umuC+, JC3890 uvrB umuC+, TK702 uvrB+ umuC and TK501 uvrB umuC against ultraviolet irradiation (UV). Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101 selected for its increased spontaneous mutator effect, also gave some protection to the UmuC-deficient strains, TK702 and TK501. However, it sensitised the wild-type strain AB1157 to low, but protected against high doses of UV, whilst sensitising strain JC3890 to all UV doses tested. Even though its UV-protecting effects varied, pGW16 was shown to increase both spontaneous and UV-induced mutation in all strains. Another derivative of pKM101, plasmid pGW12, was shown to have lost all spontaneous and UV-induced mutator effects and did not affect post-UV survival. Plasmids pKM101 and pGW16 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strains AB1157 and TK702, whereas pGW12 had no effect. Similarly, the wild-type UV-protecting plasmids R46, R446b and R124 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strain TK501, but the non-UV-protecting plasmids R1, RP4 and R6K had no effect. These results accord with the model for error-prone DNA repair that requires umu or muc gene products for chain elongation after base insertion opposite non-coding lesions. They also suggest that the UV-sensitizing effects of pGW16 on umu+ strains can be explained in terms of overactive DNA repair resulting in lethal, rather than repaired UV-induced lesions.     

The effect of UV irradiation on proliferation and life span of human diploid fibroblast-like cells

Summary The effect of low dose UV irradiation on the reinitiation of proliferative activity and on the life span of human diploid fibroblast-like cells is described. Cells were exposed to UV at confluence or after maintenance in an arrested state. Cell division was stimulated immediately after UV irradiation or after an additional post-UV incubation period. Arrested populations of all in vitro ages exhibited a greater sensitivity to UV and the reinitiation of proliferation was enhanced by post-UV incubation before stimulation. Ultraviolet light had no effect on life span regardless of in vitro cell age, culture state at the time of exposure, or the presence of a postirradiation period of arrest.     

Enhancement of UV survival, UV- and MMS-mutability, precise excision of Tn10 and complementation of umuC by plasmids of different incompatibility groups

29 conjugative resistance and colicin plasmids from 19 different incompatibility (Inc) groups were examined for their ability to enhance post-ultraviolet (UV) survival and UV- and methyl methanesulfonate(MMS)-induced mutability in Salmonella typhimurium LT2 strains. 14 Muc+ plasmids enhanced each of the survival and mutation-related properties tested, while 14 Muc- plasmids showed no enhancing effects in any tests. One Muc+ plasmid, pRG1251 (IncH1), enhanced post-UV survival and each of the mutation-related properties tested, except MMS-induced mutagenesis. Two further noteworthy plasmids, R391 (IncJ) and R394 (IncT), produced apparent strain-dependent effects in S. typhimurium which differed from those reported to have been found in Escherichia coli. Plasmid R391 enhanced post-UV survival in S. typhimurium, in contrast to its UV-sensitizing effects in E. coli. In both hosts plasmid R391 enhanced UV- and MMS-induced mutagenesis. Plasmid R394 had no enhancing effects on UV survival or UV- and MMS-induced mutagenesis in S. typhimurium, in contrast to its reported enhancement of MMS-induced mutagenesis in E. coli. Conjugal transfer of R394 to E. coli strain AB1157 and assays of mutagenesis-related traits supported results observed in S. typhimurium. Muc+ plasmids were found to enhance the frequency of precise excision of the transposon Tn10 when inserted within hisG or trpA in S. typhimurium strains. Precise excision could be further enhanced in S. typhimurium by UV-irradiation. Analysis of Tn10 mutants with altered IS10 ends indicated that intact inverted repeats at the ends of Tn10 were required for efficient enhancement of precise excision.     

Survival-related DNA repair phenomena in cultured rat-kangaroo cells

Cultured cells (line PtK-2) from the marsupial mammal rat-kangaroo, or potoroo (Potorous tridactylis), which photoreactivate (PR) both UV-induced dimers and lethality, excise few dimers, and are only slightly sensitized by post-UV exposure to caffeine, were subjected to caffeine and hydroxyurea (HU) treatments during the 30-min PR period. It was found that neither caffeine nor HU inhibited PR of lethality as measured by colony-forming ability. Further, the cells exhibited no photoprotective properties and 3 mM caffeine potentiated the same slight survival decrease in both photoreactivated and unphotoreactivated cells. It is evident that caffeine does not inhibit PR or the survival-related dark repair systems to any great extent, and hence the caffeine-sensitive post-UV dark repair found in this (and possibly other) mammalian cell lines may not be related directly to survival-dependent pyrimidine dimer removal, but instead to lesions or repair processes other than, but not excluding, pyrimidine dimers.     

Photolyase-dimer-DNA complexes and exclusion stimulation in Escherichia coli: Depolarization of the plasma membrane

Using cells that overproduce DNA photolyase, we found that UV irradiation (3 J/m²) efficiently inactivates accumulation of methylthiogalactoside (TMG) when RexAB proteins of phage lambda are present. The effect requires both formation of photolyase-dimer-DNA (PDD) complexes and expression of the RexAB proteins. It is reversed completely by a flash of visible light if given immediately after UV and becomes irreversible after post-UV incubation for about 15 min. Inactivation is significant after only 5 min of post-UV incubation, is accompanied by a loss of previously accumulated TMG, and does not require de novo protein synthesis. Passive transport of O-nitrophenylgalactoside by inactivated cells is typical of energy-depleted membranes. We suggest that PDD complexes mimic a developmental intermediate of phage superinfection and stimulate formation of the RexB membrane channel recently proposed by others to explain classical “exclusion”. This suggestion is supported by additional data showing an inactivation of colony-forming ability by exclusion stimulation and an inability of PDD complexes to inactivate accumulation of TMG if RexB is present in larger relative amounts than RexA (a detail characteristic of exclusion stimulated by phage superinfection).     

Isolation and characterization of nucleotide excision repair deficient mutants of the entomopathogenic fungus, Beauveria bassiana

To better understand DNA repair in the entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana, three ultraviolet (UV) light sensitive mutants were isolated and characterized to be deficient in nucleotide excision repair (NER). The UV sensitive mutants were scored by comparison to survival of the parental isolate, GK2016, after 36 J/m² UV-C irradiation. At this dose, conidial survival of GK2016 was 98% and the mutants LC75, LC194, and LC85 had survival values of 63%, 45%, and 31%, respectively. An immunological method which measured the removal of pyrimidine-(6-4)-pyrimidone photoproducts during repair confirmed the decreased ability of LC75, LC194, and LC85 to remove these UV-induced dimers by NER. The mutants were also found to be deficient in NER at swollen/ germinating conidia and blastospore life cycle stages. The germination of the moderately UV sensitive mutant, LC75, was similar to that of the parental isolate, GK2016, after UV irradiation and incubation to enhance NER. The more sensitive mutants, LC194 and LC85 were 2.1- or 2.7-fold, respectively, less likely to germinate after UV irradiation based on their ability to carry out NER. These NER deficient mutants, the first to be derived from B. bassiana, reveal the importance of NER in spore survival post-UV irradiation.     

RESPONSES AND CORRELATED RESPONSES TO ARTIFICIAL SELECTION ON THORAX LENGTH IN DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

Two sets of four replicate lines of Drosophila melanogaster were selected for large and small thorax with controls. F, progeny of crosses between the selected lines within each size category showed (a) a reduction in preadult viability in large lines relative to control and small lines when they were cultured at medium or high density in competition with a standard mutant marked competitor stock, and (b) an increase in larval development time in large lines relative to control and small lines. Natural selection for increased body size in adults may therefore be opposed by adverse effects on larval viability. The results are discussed in terms of the developmental mechanisms probably responsible for the change in body size. The preadult survival of the large and control lines was measured at three different temperatures, and there was no evidence for a significant interaction between size and temperature. The observed evolutionary increase in body size in response to reduced temperature in Drosophila must therefore involve either different genes from those subject to selection for size at a single temperature, or a fitness component other than preadult survival. There was no significant asymmetry in response to selection, and thorax length showed heterosis in crosses between the selected lines.     

Growth of human malignant lymphoid cell lines in serum-free medium

Human T lymphoid cell lines (MOLT-4f, MOLT-3, HSB-2, CEM) and human B lymphoid cell lines (BJAB, RAJI, WIL-2) were grown longterm (up to 8 months) in serum-free medium. This medium consisted of Iscove's modified Dulbecco's medium (IMDM), supplemented with bovine serum albumin (BSA) and transferrin (TF). This serum-free medium containing albumin and transferrin is designated AT-IMDM. Lipids were not essential. Cell viability remained high, greater than 80%, in the serum-free medium and the cells maintained their distinctive characteristics. Interleukin-2 (IL-2) production capacity was maintained by the human T lymphoid cell lines JURKAT-77 and MO in short term culture. This simple medium composed of relatively inexpensive and readily available components should be useful for studies of lymphoid cell growth and differentiation and lymphoid cell products.     

A Majority of Human Melanoma Cell Lines Exhibits an S Phase-Specific Defect in Excision of UV-Induced DNA Photoproducts

It is well established that efficient removal of highly-promutagenic UV-induced dipyrimidine photoproducts via nucleotide excision repair (NER) is required for protection against sunlight-associated malignant melanoma. Nonetheless, the extent to which reduced NER capacity might contribute to individual melanoma susceptibility in the general population remains unclear. Here we show that among a panel of 14 human melanoma strains, 11 exhibit significant inhibition of DNA photoproduct removal during S phase relative to G0/G1 or G2/M. Evidence is presented that this cell cycle-specific NER defect correlates with enhanced apoptosis and reduced clonogenic survival following UV irradiation. In addition, melanoma strains deficient in S phase-specific DNA photoproduct removal manifest significantly lower levels of phosphorylated histone H2AX at 1 h post-UV, suggesting diminished activation of ataxia telangiectasia and Rad 3-related (ATR) kinase, i.e., a primary orchestrator of the cellular response to UV-induced DNA replication stress. Consistently, in the case of DNA photoproduct excision-proficient melanoma cells, siRNA-mediated depletion of ATR (but not of its immediate downstream effector kinase Chk1) engenders deficient NER specifically during S. On the other hand simultaneous siRNA-mediated depletion of ataxia telangiectasia mutated kinase (ATM) and DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs) exerts no significant effect on either phosphorylation of H2AX at 1 h post-UV or the efficiency of DNA photoproduct removal. Our data suggest that defective NER exclusively during S phase, possibly associated with decreased ATR signaling, may constitute an heretofore unrecognized determinant in melanoma pathogenesis.     

The expression and modulation of IL-1 alpha in murine keratinocytes

Murine and human keratinocytes produce an IL-1-like factor that appears to be similar if not identical to monocyte-derived IL-1. IL-1 may be an important mediator in cutaneous inflammatory responses, however, little is currently known concerning factors that may modulate IL-1 expression in keratinocytes. To address this issue we examined the effect of LPS, UV, and the cell differentiation state on murine keratinocyte IL-1 mRNA expression. Our results indicated that as with the murine P388D1 monocyte cell line, PAM 212 keratinocytes constitutively express abundant amounts of IL-1 alpha mRNA. On exposure to LPS (100 micrograms/ml) for 8 h there was more than 10 times the increase in PAM 212 IL-1 alpha mRNA which was accompanied by a sixfold increase in supernatant IL-1 activity. Similarly UV irradiation had a significant effect on keratinocyte IL-1 alpha expression. High dose UV (300 mJ/cm2) inhibited PAM 212 IL-1 alpha expression at 4, 8, 24, 48 h post-UV whereas a lower dose of UV (100 mJ/cm2) inhibited UV at 4 and 8 h post-UV, but induced IL-1 expression at 24 and 48 h post-UV. The expression of IL-1 alpha varied with the differentiation state of the keratinocytes. Freshly removed newborn murine keratinocytes were found to constitutively express IL-1 alpha mRNA. Keratinocytes grown in low [Ca2+] tissue culture media (0.05 mM) for 6 days, functionally and phenotypically become undifferentiated and express increased quantities of IL-1 alpha mRNA, whereas cells grown in high [Ca2+] media (1.2 mM) for 6 days become terminally differentiated and IL-1 expression ceased. Keratinocytes cultured for 3 days in low [Ca2+] conditions expressed an intermediate level of IL-1 alpha. In contrast, little or no IL-1 beta mRNA was detected in either the PAM 212 cells or newborn murine keratinocytes. Thus LPS, UV, and cell differentiation state have a significant effect on expression of IL-1 alpha in murine keratinocytes.     

HAT3-mediated acetylation of PCNA precedes PCNA monoubiquitination following exposure to UV radiation in Leishmania donovani

Histone modifications impact various processes. In examining histone acetyltranferase HAT3 of Leishmania donovani, we find elimination of HAT3 causes decreased cell viability due to defects in histone deposition, and aberrant cell cycle progression pattern. HAT3 associates with proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), helping load PCNA onto chromatin in proliferating cells. HAT3-nulls show heightened sensitivity to UV radiation. Following UV exposure, PCNA cycles off/on chromatin only in cells expressing HAT3. Inhibition of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway prior to UV exposure allows accumulation of chromatin-bound PCNA, and reveals that HAT3-nulls are deficient in PCNA monoubiquitination as well as polyubiquitination. While poor monoubiquitination of PCNA may adversely affect translesion DNA synthesis-based repair processes, polyubiquitination deficiencies may result in continued retention of chromatin-bound PCNA, leading to genomic instability. On suppressing the proteasome pathway we also find that HAT3 mediates PCNA acetylation in response to UV. HAT3-mediated PCNA acetylation may serve as a flag for PCNA ubiquitination, thus aiding DNA repair. While PCNA acetylation has previously been linked to its degradation following UV exposure, this is the first report linking a HAT-mediated PCNA acetylation to PCNA monoubiquitination. These findings add a new dimension to our knowledge of the mechanisms regulating PCNA ubiquitination post-UV exposure in eukaryotes.     

Growth of human malignant lymphoid cell lines in serum-free medium

Summary Human T lymphoid cell lines (MOLT-4f, MOLT-3, HSB-2, CEM) and human B lymphoid cell lines (BJAB, RAJI, WIL-2) were grown longterm (up to 8 months) in serum-free medium. This medium consisted of Iscove's modified Dulbecco's medium (IMDM), supplemented with bovine serum albumin (BSA) and transferrin (TF). This serum-free medium containing albumin and transferrin is designated AT-IMDM. Lipids were not essential. Cell viability remained high, greater than 80%, in the serum-free medium and the cells maintained their distinctive characteristics. Interleukin-2 (IL-2) production capacity was maintained by the human T lymphoid cell lines JURKAT-77 and MO in short term culture. This simple medium composed of relatively inexpensive and readily available components should be useful for studies of lymphoid cell growth and differentiation and lymphoid cell products. This research was supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health, CA 12800, and the Concern Foundation of Los Angeles, and CA 09120 (C. U.)     

Decreased DNA repair capacity of UV-irradiated cells following interferon treatment

The aim of this study was to examine the effect of interferons (IFNs) on the recovery of UV-damaged cells by means of measuring cell viability rates. The influence of the recombinant human interferons IFN-alpha, IFN-beta and IFN-gamma on the repair capacity of the UV-irradiated human cell lines WISH and HeLa was studied. The ability of cells to repair UV-induced damage was determined by the comet assay and both short- and long-term survival assays in proliferating cell cultures. We found that INFs negatively regulated DNA repair in cells damaged by UV light. One day after treatment, in both cell lines tested, IFN-alpha had a stronger inhibitory effect than IFN-gamma. Combined treatment with different IFNs exhibited a stronger inhibitory effect on cell recovery than treatment with each of them. The protein kinase inhibitor wortmanin further aggravated the effect of IFNs on cell survival.     

Photolyase-dimer-DNA complexes and exclusion stimulation in Escherichia coli: Depolarization of the plasma membrane

Using cells that overproduce DNA photolyase, we found that UV irradiation (3 J/m²) efficiently inactivates accumulation of methylthiogalactoside (TMG) when RexAB proteins of phage lambda are present. The effect requires both formation of photolyase-dimer-DNA (PDD) complexes and expression of the RexAB proteins. It is reversed completely by a flash of visible light if given immediately after UV and becomes irreversible after post-UV incubation for about 15 min. Inactivation is significant after only 5 min of post-UV incubation, is accompanied by a loss of previously accumulated TMG, and does not require de novo protein synthesis. Passive transport of O-nitrophenylgalactoside by inactivated cells is typical of energy-depleted membranes. We suggest that PDD complexes mimic a developmental intermediate of phage superinfection and stimulate formation of the RexB membrane channel recently proposed by others to explain classical exclusion. This suggestion is supported by additional data showing an inactivation of colony-forming ability by exclusion stimulation and an inability of PDD complexes to inactivate accumulation of TMG if RexB is present in larger relative amounts than RexA (a detail characteristic of exclusion stimulated by phage superinfection).