Net biome production of managed forests in Japan

Net biome production (NBP) is considered as the most appropriate concept for analyz-ing long-term and large-scale changes of the carbon cycle induced by land use. We have esti-mated NBP potential of Japanese managed forests, based on their age structure, to be 16 Mt C/a. Fifty-nine percent of this sink is located in the warm-temperate broadleaf forest zone and the re-maining 39% is located in the cool-temperate broadleaf forest zone. This potential of NBP could be achieved under a long rotation period (70 a) and may serve as a target for sink enhancement ef-forts with the potential to uptake up to 4% of current fossil fuel emissions.     

Environmental change and the carbon balance of Amazonian forests

Extreme climatic events and land‐use change are known to influence strongly the current carbon cycle of Amazonia, and have the potential to cause significant global climate impacts. This review intends to evaluate the effects of both climate and anthropogenic perturbations on the carbon balance of the Brazilian Amazon and to understand how they interact with each other. By analysing the outputs of the Intergovernmental Panel for Climate Change (IPCC) Assessment Report 4 (AR4) model ensemble, we demonstrate that Amazonian temperatures and water stress are both likely to increase over the 21st Century. Curbing deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon by 62% in 2010 relative to the 1990s mean decreased the Brazilian Amazon's deforestation contribution to global land use carbon emissions from 17% in the 1990s and early 2000s to 9% by 2010. Carbon sources in Amazonia are likely to be dominated by climatic impacts allied with forest fires (48.3% relative contribution) during extreme droughts. The current net carbon sink (net biome productivity, NBP) of +0.16 (ranging from +0.11 to +0.21) Pg C year^?1 in the Brazilian Amazon, equivalent to 13.3% of global carbon emissions from land‐use change for 2008, can be negated or reversed during drought years [NBP = ?0.06 (?0.31 to +0.01) Pg C year^?1]. Therefore, reducing forest fires, in addition to reducing deforestation, would be an important measure for minimizing future emissions. Conversely, doubling the current area of secondary forests and avoiding additional removal of primary forests would help the Amazonian gross forest sink to offset approximately 42% of global land‐use change emissions. We conclude that a few strategic environmental policy measures are likely to strengthen the Amazonian net carbon sink with global implications. Moreover, these actions could increase the resilience of the net carbon sink to future increases in drought frequency.     

The European carbon balance. Part 3: forests

We present a new synthesis, based on a suite of complementary approaches, of the primary production and carbon sink in forests of the 25 member states of the European Union (EU‐25) during 1990–2005. Upscaled terrestrial observations and model‐based approaches agree within 25% on the mean net primary production (NPP) of forests, i.e. 520±75 g C m^?2 yr^?1 over a forest area of 1.32 × 10⁶ km² to 1.55 × 10⁶ km² (EU‐25). New estimates of the mean long‐term carbon forest sink (net biome production, NBP) of EU‐25 forests amounts 75±20 g C m^?2 yr^?1. The ratio of NBP to NPP is 0.15±0.05. Estimates of the fate of the carbon inputs via NPP in wood harvests, forest fires, losses to lakes and rivers and heterotrophic respiration remain uncertain, which explains the considerable uncertainty of NBP. Inventory‐based assessments and assumptions suggest that 29±15% of the NBP (i.e., 22 g C m^?2 yr^?1) is sequestered in the forest soil, but large uncertainty remains concerning the drivers and future of the soil organic carbon. The remaining 71±15% of the NBP (i.e., 53 g C m^?2 yr^?1) is realized as woody biomass increments. In the EU‐25, the relatively large forest NBP is thought to be the result of a sustained difference between NPP, which increased during the past decades, and carbon losses primarily by harvest and heterotrophic respiration, which increased less over the same period.     

南北过渡带常绿落叶阔叶混交林碳通量特征及其对环境因子的响应

森林生态系统强大的碳源/汇功能是实现"碳中和"和"碳达峰"战略目标最经济、有效的自然气候解决方案和固碳增汇手段。准确评估森林生态系统的碳汇能力,对于明确森林碳储量有重要意义。为明确亚热带-暖温带气候过渡带的常绿落叶阔叶混交林的碳通量特征及其驱动因素,2011-2020年利用涡度相关法开展了大别山常绿落叶阔叶混交林碳通量和环境要素的观测试验。结果表明:大别山常绿落叶阔叶混交林净生态系统CO₂交换量、生态系统呼吸(Reco)、总初级生态生产力分别为-788.13 gC m^-2 a^-1、1074.14 gC m^-2 a^-1、1862.27 gC m^-2 a^-1,该森林生态系统整体表现为碳汇,其固碳能力与相近纬度的常绿落叶阔叶混交林基本持平,并高于针阔叶混交林、毛竹林等其他类型的森林生态系统。10年间,大别山常绿落叶阔叶混交林的固碳能力有所增强。影响大别山常绿落叶阔叶混交林碳通量的主要环境因子为温度与太阳辐射,气温(Ta)、净辐射(Rn)、光合有效辐射和总辐射与生态系统碳生产力和GPP呈显著正相关(P＜0.001),Reco与Ta和Rn呈显著正相关(P＜0.001)。研究结果为气候变化响应敏感的南北气候过渡带森林生态系统的碳储量估算、碳循环过程模拟提供观测数据支持和科学依据。     

辽宁东部的主要植被类型及其分布

辽宁东部位于铁岭一营口一线以东地区。北部为山地,属于长白植物区系区。南部为辽东半岛丘陵,属于华北植物区系区,并具有一些耐寒性的亚热带植物。红松(Pinus koraiensis)、沙松(Abies holophylla)—阔叶混交林和油松 (Pinus tabulaeformis)、赤松(P.densiflora)、落叶阔叶林是辽宁东部的地带性植被。但是,目前次生的蒙古栎(Quercus mongolica)林和各类灌丛分布很广。以开原一南杂木一青城子一青椅山线为界把辽东分为两个植被地带：1)北部为温带针叶阔叶混交林地带;2)南部为暖温带落叶阔叶林地带。在暖温带落叶阔叶林地带内,熊岳一青椅山线的东南部为亦松栎林亚地带,西北部为油松栎林亚地带。     

Latitudinal patterns of magnitude and interannual variability in net ecosystem exchange regulated by biological and environmental variables

Over the last two and half decades, strong evidence showed that the terrestrial ecosystems are acting as a net sink for atmospheric carbon. However the spatial and temporal patterns of variation in the sink are not well known. In this study, we examined latitudinal patterns of interannual variability (IAV) in net ecosystem exchange (NEE) of CO₂ based on 163 site-years of eddy covariance data, from 39 northern-hemisphere research sites located at latitudes ranging from ∼29°N to ∼64°N. We computed the standard deviation of annual NEE integrals at individual sites to represent absolute interannual variability (AIAV), and the corresponding coefficient of variation as a measure of relative interannual variability (RIAV). Our results showed decreased trends of annual NEE with increasing latitude for both deciduous broadleaf forests and evergreen needleleaf forests. Gross primary production (GPP) explained a significant proportion of the spatial variation of NEE across evergreen needleleaf forests, whereas, across deciduous broadleaf forests, it is ecosystem respiration (Re). In addition, AIAV in GPP and Re increased significantly with latitude in deciduous broadleaf forests, but AIAV in GPP decreased significantly with latitude in evergreen needleleaf forests. Furthermore, RIAV in NEE, GPP, and Re appeared to increase significantly with latitude in deciduous broadleaf forests, but not in evergreen needleleaf forests. Correlation analyses showed air temperature was the primary environmental factor that determined RIAV of NEE in deciduous broadleaf forest across the North American sites, and none of the chosen climatic factors could explain RIAV of NEE in evergreen needleleaf forests. Mean annual NEE significantly increased with latitude in grasslands. Precipitation was dominant environmental factor for the spatial variation of magnitude and IAV in GPP and Re in grasslands.     

植被气候关系与我国的植被分区

气候制约着植被的地理分布,植被是区域气候特征的反映和指示,两者之间存在密不可分的联系.揭示植被与气候之间的关系是正确认识植被分布的前提,是进行植被区划的理论基础.植被区划是植被研究的归纳和总结,是其他自然地理区划和农林业区划的基础.本文在简要回顾中国植被气候关系及植被分区的研究历史的基础上,对我国以往的主要植被分区原则、依据和方案进行了评述,对有争议的主要植被界线进行了讨论.我们认为,在当今我国大部分地区的原生植被已遭到破坏的现实情况下,根据原生植被及其衍生植被类型的分布,确定其分布与限制性气候因子的关系,以此来进行植被带(区)的划分,不仅反映植被气候间密不可分的关系,在实践上也便于操作.尽管在一些植被带的命名、具体界线的划定上有分歧,但最近的中国植被分区方案大都认为我国基本的植被区有8至9个,即针叶林、针阔叶混交林、落叶阔叶林、常绿落叶阔叶混交林、常绿阔叶林以及雨林季雨林、草原、荒漠以及高寒植被.通过分析主要植被带附近的植被、气候等特征,本文认为,1)秦岭淮河线是一条重要的水分气候带,而不是温度带,不是亚热带植被的北界;2)我国亚热带植被的北界基本上沿长江北岸,从杭州湾经太湖、安徽宣城、铜陵经大别山南坡到武汉往西,与WI值130-140 ℃·月一致;3)我国热带区域的面积极小,仅分布在海南岛的东南部和台湾南端及其以南地区; 4) 我国东部地区暖温带的水热条件南北差异甚大,建议以秦岭淮河为界,将暖温带划分为两个植被带,即落叶阔叶疏林带和落叶常绿阔叶混交林带;华北地区的地带性植被为落叶阔叶疏林.最后,本文还强调了对应于气候变化进行动态植被分区的重要性.     

森林生态效益补偿优先级机制研究及应用——基于碳汇总量与变化量视角

森林生态效益补偿制度对于提高森林建设者积极性、促进森林生态效益提升具有重要意义。然而,我国森林生态效益补偿实践中依然存在仅以森林面积为补偿依据导致激励错位的问题。基于此,结合国家"双碳"目标,提出一种基于碳汇总量与变化量双向视角的综合森林生态效益补偿优先级机制,选取我国重要生态功能区秦巴山区为案例,分别从森林碳汇总量与变化量视角量化各区县生态补偿优先级,并构建二者结合的综合优先级模型,以促进在生态补偿实践中的资金分配公平性与激励性。研究发现,(1)在研究期内大多区县森林碳汇总量增长,但存在个别区县森林碳汇功能降低的现象,具体原因存在差异;(2)碳汇总量优先级与碳汇变化量优先级清单存在差异。总量优先级高的区县,变化量优先级较低,因此,生态补偿应综合考虑各区县森林碳汇在两个维度的表现;(3)综合优先级排名结果呈现"高值-中值-低值"的不同区间特征,该补偿机制在综合优先级高值区激励区县扩建森林、新增森林碳汇,在中值区激励区县保育森林,在低值区鼓励区县结合森林现状从扩建与保育两个方向提升森林碳汇功能。以森林碳汇保育与增汇成果为导向,有效探索碳汇功能在生态补偿中的实践价值,为我国区域森林生态效益补偿实践的公平性与科学性提供研究基础。     

Effects of land use change and management on the European cropland carbon balance

We model the carbon balance of European croplands between 1901 and 2000 in response to land use and management changes. The process‐based ORCHIDEE‐STICS model is applied here in a spatially explicit framework. We reconstructed land cover changes, together with an idealized history of agro‐technology. These management parameters include the treatment of straw and stubble residues, application of mineral fertilizers, improvement of cultivar species and tillage. The model is integrated for wheat and maize during the period 1901–2000 forced by climate each 1/2‐hour, and by atmospheric CO₂, land cover change and agro‐technology each year. Several tests are performed to identify the most sensitive agro‐technological parameters that control the net biome productivity (NBP) in the 1990s, with NBP equaling for croplands the soil C balance. The current NBP is a small sink of 0.16 t C ha^?1 yr^?1. The value of NBP per unit area reflects past and current management, and to a minor extent the shrinking areas of arable land consecutive to abandonment during the 20th Century. The uncertainty associated with NBP is large, with a 1‐sigma error of 0.18 t C ha^?1 yr^?1 obtained from a qualitative, but comprehensive budget of various error terms. The NBP uncertainty is dominated by unknown historical agro‐technology changes (47%) and model structure (27%), with error in climate forcing playing a minor role. A major improvement to the framework would consist in using a larger number of representative crops. The uncertainty of historical land‐use change derived from three different reconstructions, has a surprisingly small effect on NBP (0.01 t C ha^?1 yr^?1) because cropland area remained stable during the past 20 years in all the tested land use forcing datasets. Regional cross‐validation of modeled NBP against soil C inventory measurements shows that our results are consistent with observations, within the uncertainties of both inventories and model. Our estimation of cropland NBP is however likely to be biased towards a sink, given that inventory data from different regions consistently indicate a small source whereas we model a small sink.     

秦岭太白山桦林的稳定性

本文论述了桦林的稳定性。文中认为桦林地质时期和现代都可形成地带性森林,它是凉温湿润气候的顶极群落,分布在暖温带落叶阔叶林与湿冷生针叶林之间的凉温湿润地带。因此这类林的区系组成无论地质时期或现代,都是以暖温带落叶阔叶林和寒温带针叶林的混合成分为特征。     

秦岭太白山桦林的稳定性

本文论述了桦林的稳定性。文中认为桦林地质时期和现代都可形成地带性森林,它是凉温湿润气候的顶极群落,分布在暖温带落叶阔叶林与湿冷生针叶林之间的凉温湿润地带。因此这类林的区系组成无论地质时期或现代,都是以暖温带落叶阔叶林和寒温带针叶林的混合成分为特征。     

Leaf domatia and foliar mite abundance in broadleaf deciduous forest of north Asia

Plant morphology may be shaped, in part, by the third trophic level. Leaf domatia, minute enclosures usually in vein axils on the leaf underside, may provide the basis for protective mutualism between plants and mites. Domatia are particularly frequent among species of trees, shrubs, and vines in the temperate broadleaf deciduous forests in north Asia where they may be important in determining the distribution and abundance of mites in the forest canopy. In lowland and montane broadleaf deciduous forests at Kwangn;akung and Chumbongsan in Korea, we found that approximately half of all woody species in all forest strata, including many dominant trees, have leaf domatia. Pooling across 24 plant species at the two sites, mites occupied a mode of 60% (range 20-100%) of domatia and used them for shelter, egg-laying, and development. On average, 70% of all active mites and 85% of mite eggs on leaves were found in domatia; over three-quarters of these were potentially beneficial to their hosts. Further, mite abundance and reproduction (expressed as the proportion of mites at the egg stage) were significantly greater on leaves of species with domatia than those without domatia in both forests. Effects of domatia on mite abundance were significant only for predaceous and fungivorous mite taxa; herbivore numbers did not differ significantly between leaves of species with and without domatia. Comparable patterns in broadleaf deciduous forest in North America and other biogeographic regions suggest that the effect of leaf domatia on foliar mite abundance is general. These results are consistent with several predictions of mutualism between plants and mites, and indicate that protective mutualisms may be frequent in the temperate zone.     

东北森林带森林生态系统固碳服务空间特征及其影响因素

东北森林带作为国家主体生态区划"两屏三带"国家生态安全格局中的重要组成部分,在全球碳平衡中发挥着重要的碳汇作用。以东北森林带为研究区域,采用净生态系统生产力(NEP)评估其森林固碳服务,通过Anselin Local Moran's Ⅰ算法识别固碳服务的"热点"、"冷点"和"异常点",并分析探讨其空间格局与影响因素。结果表明:(1)东北森林带森林生态系统整体上是碳汇。2014年东北森林带森林固碳总量为36.41 Tg C/a,单位面积固碳量为89.57 g C m~(-2)a~(-1)。(2)固碳服务的热点区主要分布在大兴安岭北部和长白山中北部,冷点区主要分布在大兴安岭东部、小兴安岭和长白山南部,固碳服务的高值异常区域主要分布在森林边缘的农林交错带,低值异常区域主要分布在人为干扰严重的城市蔓延区。(3)东北森林带森林生态系统整体上受人为因素的影响小,其固碳服务与NDVI显著正相关。(4)城市扩张等人为干扰是固碳服务异常降低的根本原因,植被本身生长状况不佳和较高的温度是导致固碳服务的异常降低的重要影响因素。     

贺兰山天牛科昆虫区系组成及垂直分布

2013-2015年对贺兰山不同海拔和垂直植被带的天牛科昆虫进行系统调查,结果表明:贺兰山共有天牛科昆虫6亚科31属45种,其中,沟胫天牛亚科属、种数最多,有14属21种,其种数占总种数46.67%,天牛亚科有9属12种,幽天牛亚科有4属5种,花天牛亚科有2属4种,锯天牛亚科2属2种,膜花天牛亚科仅有1属1种。区系组成上,古北界有17种,占总种数的37.78%,其中中亚成分占35.29%,广布型28种,占总种数的62.22%。在我国昆虫地理区划中的分布共有13个分布类型,全国广布型最多,占总种数的20%。以蒙新区种类为主体,并与东北区和华北区关系密切联系。在垂直分布上,以山前阔叶林带采集到的天牛种类最多,有22种,占总数的48.89%;从低海拔的山前荒漠半荒漠带到高海拔的山地针叶林带,天牛物种数量逐渐增加;除山地草原带外,随海拔增高,古北界种类逐渐增多。通过聚类分析显示,山地针叶林带和针阔混交林带天牛种类组成相似性较高;山地灌丛带、山地疏林带和山前阔叶林带相似性较高;山前荒漠半荒漠带、山地草地带与其他植被带天牛组成差异较大。     

Influence of broadleaf trees on soil chemical properties: A retrospective study in the Sub-Boreal Spruce Zone,British Columbia,Canada

A retrospective study examined the influence of broadleaf trees, principally paper birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.), on soil properties under mixedwoods with lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta var. latifolia Dougl. ex Loud.) in the Sub-Boreal Spruce zone of central British Columbia, Canada. After 23 years, approximately 50% of the forest floor mass typical of mature forests in this zone had already accumulated on an initially denuded surface, but this new forest floor was poor in woody components. Correlation analysis found no relationship between the degree of broadleaf occupancy and total forest floor accumulation, but a significant qualitative influence on chemical properties of the non-woody forest floor components: higher pH, total N, available P, extractable Ca, Mg, and K, and lower C:N ratios. No such relationships existed for the surface (0–20 cm depth) mineral soils.     

哀牢山常绿阔叶林水源涵养功能及其在应对西南干旱中的作用

为了解云南哀牢山中山湿性常绿阔叶林在2010年初西南地区特大干旱中是否遭遇水分胁迫,及其水源涵养功能在应对干旱中的作用,测定了该森林土壤和主要树种在2010年旱季的水分状况,并对比研究了原生林和森林经砍伐烧垦后形成的毛蕨菜-玉山竹群丛的土壤持水、凋落物持水、水面蒸发和土壤水分季节动态。结果表明:常绿阔叶林主要树种在2010年初西南特大干旱中并未遭受水分胁迫(最旱月叶片凌晨水势高于-0.4 MPa)。虽然常绿阔叶林土壤含水量和地下水位在最旱月都达到了有观测以来的最低点,但主要根系分布区的土壤水势仍不低于-0.5 MPa,并高于毛蕨菜-玉山竹群丛。森林较好的水分状况和原生常绿阔叶林较好的水源涵养功能有关。常绿阔叶林的土壤总持水量尤其是非毛管持水量要显著大于毛蕨菜-玉山竹群丛,同时也大于云南地区的一些次生林和人工林。常绿阔叶林地表丰富的凋落物通过持水和抑制土壤蒸发也对水源涵养有一定作用。哀牢山常绿阔叶林良好的水源涵养功能,充足的土壤地下水储存弥补了旱季和特大干旱中降水的不足。结果指示原生林在水源涵养中不可替代的作用,以及加强原生林保护在提高区域抗干旱能力中的重要意义。     

Chronic water stress reduces tree growth and the carbon sink of deciduous hardwood forests

Predicted decreases in water availability across the temperate forest biome have the potential to offset gains in carbon (C) uptake from phenology trends, rising atmospheric CO₂, and nitrogen deposition. While it is well established that severe droughts reduce the C sink of forests by inducing tree mortality, the impacts of mild but chronic water stress on forest phenology and physiology are largely unknown. We quantified the C consequences of chronic water stress using a 13‐year record of tree growth (n = 200 trees), soil moisture, and ecosystem C balance at the Morgan–Monroe State Forest (MMSF) in Indiana, and a regional 11‐year record of tree growth (n > 300 000 trees) and water availability for the 20 most dominant deciduous broadleaf tree species across the eastern and midwestern USA. We show that despite ~26 more days of C assimilation by trees at the MMSF, increasing water stress decreased the number of days of wood production by ~42 days over the same period, reducing the annual accrual of C in woody biomass by 41%. Across the deciduous forest region, water stress induced similar declines in tree growth, particularly for water‐demanding ‘mesophytic’ tree species. Given the current replacement of water‐stress adapted ‘xerophytic’ tree species by mesophytic tree species, we estimate that chronic water stress has the potential to decrease the C sink of deciduous forests by up to 17% (0.04 Pg C yr^?1) in the coming decades. This reduction in the C sink due to mesophication and chronic water stress is equivalent to an additional 1–3 days of global C emissions from fossil fuel burning each year. Collectively, our results indicate that regional declines in water availability may offset the growth‐enhancing effects of other global changes and reduce the extent to which forests ameliorate climate warming.     

东灵山林区不同森林植被水源涵养功能评价

森林植被发挥着涵养水源的作用,主要表现在以下几个方面:对降水的截留与再分配;调节河川径流,调节林内小气候,减小林内地表蒸发,改善土壤结构,减少地表侵蚀等. 通过对几种林分各层拦蓄降水和保土功能指标定性评价的基础上,用综合评定法对不同林分水源涵养和保土功能进行综合评价,选择出综合功能最好的林分,以期为北京山区的生态环境建设、植被恢复与保护提供一定的依据。在测定东灵山4种森林植被林冠层、枯枝落叶层和土壤层蓄水和土壤保持功能指标的基础上,采用综合评定法对4种森林植被水源涵养和土壤保持功能进行了评价。结果表明:各植被类型的林冠层截留各不相同,在雨季(6-9 月份) 辽东栎林的截留率最大,华北落叶松的最小;枯落物最大持水深以辽东栎林的最大,油松的最小;土壤水文特性各异,0-80 cm 土层平均容重以落叶阔叶林的最小,华北落叶松的最大;稳渗速率以落叶阔叶林的最大,油松的最小,初渗速率以辽东栎林的最大,油松的最小。不同林分水源涵养和土壤保持综合能力由大到小顺序为落叶阔叶混交林、辽东栎林、华北落叶松林、油松林。常绿阔叶灌丛水源涵养和土壤保持综合能力评价值(0.1039) 比其它植被类型少3个数量级,说明其水源涵养和土壤保持功能明显优于其它植被类型。由此可见,树种组成丰富、林下灌草盖度高、枯落物储量多的落叶阔叶混交林水源涵养和土壤保持能力最强,优于单一的阔叶林,而油松林最差。     

浙江省生态公益林碳储量和固碳现状及潜力

生态公益林是为保护和改善人类生存环境,维持生态平衡而建立的。以浙江省的生态公益林为研究对象,共调查和估算了全省21个县149个样地(年龄从5a到50a),包括常绿阔叶林、针阔混交林、马尾松林和杉木林4种主要林型的碳储量和碳平衡。结果说明:浙江省生态公益林生态系统碳密度的加权平均值为164.43tC.hm-2;其中常绿阔叶林生态系统碳储量最高,达216.18tC.hm-2;针阔混交林其次,达181.36tC.hm-2;针叶林最低。浙江省森林以幼龄林(小于30a的占87.5%)和马尾松林(大于55%)为主离成熟状态还相差很远,尤其是针叶林远低于全国平均水平和中高纬度地区碳密度。全省生态公益林净生态系统生产力加权平均得0.08tC.hm-.2a-1,在碳积累上还有很大的潜力。通过封育改造、择伐补阔或以灌促阔等森林管理措施,加快针叶林向针阔混交林直至常绿阔叶林演替,将最大化中国亚热带地区的幼林或受干扰森林的未来碳储量(最高增长31.44%),并成为较大的碳汇。     

基于Ripley L和O-ring函数的森林景观空间分布格局及其关联性

采用空间点格局分析中的Ripley L和O-ring函数,以大兴安岭盘古林场森林资源二类调查数据为例,对比分析2种方法在森林景观类型的空间分布格局及其关联性研究中的差异.结果表明: 2种方法获得的景观空间分布格局在整体趋势上反映一致,都是在中小尺度上呈聚集分布,之后随着尺度的增大主要表现为随机分布特征;景观类型间的关联性存在显著差异,其中,Ripley L函数结果表明,天然落叶松林、天然白桦林分别与针阔混交林在中小尺度上呈负相关,而在更大尺度上整体表现出无关联性或正关联性的趋势,其余景观类型间在所有研究尺度上呈显著负相关; O-ring函数结果则表明,4种森林景观类型两两之间均呈现出相似的关联性变化趋势,即在小尺度上均表现为负相关,在中等尺度上均呈现出不相关性,但在更大尺度上呈正相关趋势;对同一景观类型(或景观类型组),2种方法在不同尺度等级上的空间分布格局及其关联性的判别一致率存在较大差异,其一致性判别率在所有研究尺度上整体呈现出基本不变、先下降后增加和一直下降3种趋势.