MITOCHONDRIAL-DNA VARIATION IN THE CRESTED NEWT SUPERSPECIES: LIMITED CYTOPLASMIC GENE FLOW AMONG SPECIES

The crested newt has a widespread European distribution and encompasses four taxa recently elevated to full species: Triturus cristatus, T. carnifex, T. dobrogicus, and T. karelini. These are distinct on morphological, chromosomal, and isozymic grounds and have fairly sharp transition zones. A widespread survey (12 countries, 49 geographic sites, 210 individuals) of mtDNA variation (20–27 restriction enzyme sites mapped per individual) was made in order to 1) correlate mtDNA variation with morphological features defining the species, 2) determine the degree of differentiation within and among species, and 3) detect any introgression among species. The mtDNAs of these species were clearly differentiated (d = 3.9–7.1%). Additionally, geographic structuring was observed within T. carnifex and T. karelini, each displaying two divergent mitochondrial genome types (d = 3.5% and 4.7%, respectively). The other two (more northerly distributed) species were genetically homogeneous over most (T. cristatus) or all (T. dobrogicus) of their ranges. In the case of T. cristatus, one may infer bottlenecking as a result of Pleistocene glaciation events. This may also apply in part to T. dobrogicus, but high population connectedness and gene flow in this lowland river species may alone be sufficient for homogenization of mtDNA. Patterns of mtDNA variation were largely concordant with morphology; some interspecific mitochondrial gene flow was observed, but only close to or in the transition zones. Analyses of mapped restriction-site data by UPGMA and parsimony methods (using the closely related T. marmoratus as an outgroup) produce very similar dendrograms. The levels of divergence found concur with the systematics of the group, but the differentiation within T. carnifex and T. karelini is notable.     

GENE FLOW AND MITOCHONDRIAL DNA VARIATION IN THE KILLIFISH,FUNDULUS HETEROCLITUS

Two subspecies of killifish, Fundulus heteroclitus, inhabit the Atlantic coast of the United States. The contact zones between them are typified by morphological, physiological, nuclear gene, and mitochondrial DNA clines. Considerable debate exists about the importance of restricted gene flow and natural selection in maintaining these clines. To evaluate the relative importance of these two evolutionary forces we employed analysis of mtDNA as an independent measure of gene flow. Solutions of equilibrium diffusion equations suggested that killifish dispersal must be less than 2 km to maintain previously observed allozyme frequency clines in the absence of strong selection. To determine whether populations separated by distances greater than 2 km accumulate significant genetic differences we examined a total of N = 480 individuals from five killifish populations spanning a continuous shoreline distance of 8.4 km. Distribution of the 25 detected haplotypes indicated that most of the variation was within rather than between sampling locations. No evidence of geographic structure was detected, nor were there any significant genetic differences between killifish populations. With these data, gene flow was evaluated by estimating effective migration rate (N_em) between the populations. N_em was estimated from G_st(N_em = 49.4), from F_st (N_em = 24.1), by the private alleles approach (N_em = 18.5) and via four phylogenetic analyses (N_em ranged from 11.4 to 16.9). Regardless of the analysis, N_em was greater than one; the threshold level at which gene flow is strong enough to prevent differentiation due to genetic drift. This suggests that while the characteristics that distinguish Fundulus subspecies may have arisen in isolation, the current clinal distributions exhibited along the Atlantic coast are most likely maintained by selection.     

MITOCHONDRIAL GENE GENEALOGY AND GENE FLOW AMONG ISLAND AND MAINLAND POPULATIONS OF A SEDENTARY SONGBIRD,THE GREY-CROWNED BABBLER (POMATOSTOMUS TEMPORALIS)

Distinguishing between ongoing gene flow and purely historical association of populations can be difficult without data on times of population separation and effective population sizes. To help discriminate between these two scenarios, I examined mitochondrial DNA sequence diversity in three geographically close populations of the grey-crowned babbler (Pomatostomus temporalis) separated by water barriers of known age in the Northern Territory, Australia, using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), direct sequencing, and genealogical methods of inference. PCR primers were designed to obtain sequences from region I, a highly variable segment of the control region. Sequence diversity in all populations was consistent with neutrality. In the population on Melville Island, a Pleistocene land-bridge island, sequence variability is as high as on the mainland and consists of two mitochondrial lineages differing by 2%. Phylogenetic analyses of the sequence variation observed among 44 individuals suggest that the number of times lineages in one population trace back to ancestors of a different population (between-population coalescent events) was too high to be compatible with a model of population divergence solely by drift since rising of the water barriers, implying instead recent or ongoing gene flow across water barriers. Similar estimates of F_st, the fraction of genetic diversity apportioned among populations, were obtained when calculated using the divergence times of alleles and when estimated from Nm values derived from trees and ranging from 0.29-0.55. Both the phylogenies and patterns of allelic divergence suggest that the population on Melville Island exchanges migrants with both continental populations, although statistical tests indicated that some alternative phylogenies implying restricted gene flow among the populations could not be discounted.     

GENE FLOW IN LICHENS

Experimental studies of the evolutionary biology of lichen fungi have been hampered by massive difficulties of in vitro culture and artificial crosses are still not possible. Gene flow in these organisms is demonstrated here for the first time by the analysis of secondary products in the progeny of individuals from natural populations of mixed chemotypes of the Cladonia chlorophaea complex. All of the chemotypes in this study have been interpreted as distinct sibling species. In the Appalachian Mountains of North Carolina, however, the grayi and merochlorophaea chemotypes are found to belong to a single interbreeding populations that is reproductively isolated from the cryptochlorophaea chemotype. In the Coastal Plain, the cryptochlorophaea chemotype hybridizes with the local endemic perlomera chemotype. This study has major impact for species concept in lichens because consideration of neither morphologial tendencies nor biogenetic relationships of the secondary products could have predicted its result.     

POPULATION STRUCTURE AND ESTIMATES OF GENE FLOW IN THE HOMOSPOROUS FERN POLYSTICHUM MUNITUM

Levels and distribution of genetic variation were investigated in the homosporous fern, Polystichum munitum. Homosporous ferns differ from higher vascular plants in that they possess potentially bisexual gametophytes which can produce a completely homozygous sporophyte in a single generation. Because of this, it has long been maintained that ferns possess an inbreeding mating system, resulting in low levels of genetic variation and high levels of homozygosity within populations. The four populations sampled maintain high levels of genetic variation (P? = 0.542; H? = 0.111; ā = 2.23), comparable to that maintained by populations of outcrossing seed plants. The mean fixation index, F, for the four populations was 0.052, indicating no significant deviations from Hardy-Weinberg genotypic expectations. Polystichum munitum distributes most of its genetic variation within rather than among populations. Population-genetic structure was assessed by subdividing each of two large populations into 10 × 10-m subpopulations. Comparisons of genetic variation within and among subpopulations indicated little genetic substructure within either of the artificially subdivided populations. Estimates of interpopulational gene flow (Nm) are extremely high, comparable to those reported for gymnosperms. Statistical estimates of intragametophytic selling are very low, ranging from 0 to 3%. This study suggests that Polystichum munitum is an outcrossing species. Evidence from this and other investigations indicates that fern species do not typically self-fertilize and that mating systems in ferns vary as they do among species of seed plants.     

GENETIC STRUCTURE AND MALE-MEDIATED GENE FLOW IN THE GHOST BAT (MACRODERMA GIGAS)

The Australian ghost bat is a large, opportunistic carnivorous species that has undergone a marked range contraction toward more mesic, tropical sites over the past century. Comparison of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) control region sequences and six nuclear microsatellite loci in 217 ghost bats from nine populations across subtropical and tropical Australia revealed strong population subdivision (mtDNA φ_ST = 0.80; microsatellites UR_ST = 0.337). Low-latitude (tropical) populations had higher heterozygosity and less marked phylogeographic structure and lower subdivision among sites within regions (within Northern Territory [NT] and within North Queensland [NQ]) than did populations at higher latitudes (subtropical sites; central Queensland [CQ]), although sampling of geographically proximal breeding sites is unavoidably restricted for the latter. Gene flow among populations within each of the northern regions appears to be male biased in that the difference in population subdivision for mtDNA and microsatellites (NT φ_ST = 0.39, UR_ST = 0.02; NQ φ_ST = 0.60, UR_ST = ?0.03) is greater than expected from differences in the effective population size of haploid versus diploid loci. The high level of population subdivision across the range of the ghost bat contrasts with evidence for high gene flow in other chiropteran species and may be due to narrow physiological tolerances and consequent limited availability of roosts for ghost bats, particularly across the subtropical and relatively arid regions. This observation is consistent with the hypothesis that the contraction of the species' range is associated with late Holocene climate change. The extreme isolation among higher-latitude populations may predispose them to additional local extinctions if the processes responsible for the range contraction continue to operate.     

EXCLUSION OF THE ROLE OF SECONDARY CONTACT IN AN ALLELE FREQUENCY CLINE IN THE MUSSEL MYTILUS EDULIS

We examined the hypothesis that secondary contact generates an allele-frequency cline at the aminopeptidase-I locus (Lap) in the marine mussel, Mytilus edulis. It has been proposed that variation at the Lap locus is neutral and that the cline results from secondary contact between differentiated oceanic and estuarine populations (Levinton, 1980). We tested this hypothesis by comparing the genotypic distributions in samples from the cline to distributions that incorporate mixing effects. We employed a statistical model that determines the degree of contact using a maximum likelihood estimator and then incorporates the mixing estimates into an expected distribution of genotypes. Wahlund effects resulting from possible admixture are thereby incorporated into the expected distribution. Failure of the model to reconcile the observed with the expected distribution of genotypes indicates that the observed population structure does not result from admixture. The null hypothesis of mixing was unable to explain about 33% of the samples. Combined tests demonstrated the general departure from the mixing model to be highly significant. The distribution of heterozygote discrepancies across the cline was inconsistent with the expectations of a mixing model. Therefore we reject explanations for the structure of the Lap cline that involve secondary contact. Selection directed at the Lap locus appears necessary to explain the genotypic structure of clinal populations.     

DIALECTS AND GEOGRAPHICAL VARIATION IN THE SONG OF THE SPLENDID SUNBIRD NECTARINIA COCCINIGASTER

The male Splendid Sunbird has only one song type, each note of which has a simple frequency/time profile. An analysis of the songs of males from several localities near Legon (5^.63° N, 0.19° N) showed that there are clear-cut song dialects characterizing each population. Those parts of the song giving rise to dialects are the time interval between consecutive pairs of notes (the time interval pattern) and the frequency/time profile of each note.
The dialects were preserved over a period of three years (the duration of the study) and there was little variation in the song of a ringed bird over a period of two months. The boundary between dialects is apparently quite sharp, occurring perhaps within a distance of 50 m.
Marked geographical variation in the song occurs, and is expected because of the mosaic of dialects that presumably exist throughout the sunbird's range in southern Ghana. For dialects to be effective in keeping populations together, those characteristics of the song which give rise to dialects should be readily and quickly discerned and need not require a statistical demonstration. This condition holds for the song of the Splendid Sunbird.
The results are compared with the ideas of Nottebohm (1964) and Thielcke (1969) on the maintenance and usefulness of song dialects.     

ESTIMATES OF INTRAGAMETOPHYTIC SELFING AND INTERPOPULATIONAL GENE FLOW IN HOMOSPOROUS FERNS

Relatively little information is available on mating systems and interpopulational gene flow in species of homosporous pteridophytes. Because of the proximity of antheridia and archegonia on the same thallus, it has long been maintained that intragametophytic selling is the predominant mode of reproduction in natural populations of homosporous ferns and other homosporous plants. Furthermore, quantitative estimates of interpopulational gene flow via spore dispersal are lacking. In this paper, we examine five species of homosporous ferns (Botrychium virginianum, Polystichum munitum, P. imbricans, Blechnum spicant, and Dryopteris expansa) and present estimates of 1) rates of intragametophytic selling, 2) levels of interpopulational gene flow, and 3) interpopulational genetic differentiation (F_ST). Our data demonstrate that mating systems vary among species of ferns, just as they do among species of seed plants. The data also suggest that levels of interpopulational gene flow are generally high. The F_ST values indicate little genetic divergence among populations for all species except Dryopteris expansa, which exhibits significant levels of interpopulational genetic differentiation. Patterns of genetic diversity in the five species examined are related to the mating system and rate of interpopulational gene flow in each species. The F_ST values for all species except Botrychium virginianum are in close agreement with those predicted for an island model of population structure.     

GENE FLOW IN CAVE ARTHROPODS: A QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE APPROACH

Slatkin's method (1981) for analyzing gene flow levels is applied to eleven species of cave arthropods. This provides insights into the strength of gene flow as a force affecting the evolution of cave organisms, while serving as a test of Slatkin's method. The results show that patterns of gene flow are consistent with the dispersal abilities and the ecological requirements of each species. Troglobites in general have lower gene flow values than troglophiles or trogloxenes. However, the geology of the area, its vegetation profile, and the geographic distance among the populations considered are also important in determining the gene flow levels. Gene flow patterns in three cave species, Ptomaphagus hirtus, Neaphaenops tellkampfii tellkampfii and Hadenoecus subterraneus, are compared in detail. These species inhabit the same highly interconnected karst area in south-central Kentucky but differ in their ecological requirements. The results suggest that gene flow levels are more dependent upon the intrinsic characteristics of each species than upon the availability of routes for dispersal. Overall estimates of gene flow were coupled with a more detailed population-structure analysis in four terrestrial cave arthropods: Speonomus delarouzeei, Hadenoecus cumberlandicus, Hadenoecus subterraneus and Euhadenoecus puteanus. The results stress the need for this type of analysis for subdivided species, in which estimates of the average gene flow can produce misleading results. Moreover, they show how these types of measures are more relevant in describing historical patterns of gene exchange than in indicating current levels of gene flow.     

VOCAL DIALECTS AND THE STRUCTURE OF GEOGRAPHIC VARIATION IN MORPHOLOGICAL AND ALLOZYMIC CHARACTERS IN THE RUFOUS-COLLARED SPARROW,ZONOTRICHIA CAPENSIS

The geographical patterns of variation shown at 20 allozyme and non-enzymatic protein-coding loci, in 8 external, and in 12 skeletal morphological characters in the rufous-collared sparrow, Zonotrichia capensis, were analyzed in order to test the local (genetic) adaptation hypothesis regarding the origin and maintenance of vocal dialects in birds. Approximately 20 males were collected from each of four sites within each of six different dialect zones. There was significant variability in both external and skeletal morphology among all 24 sites and among dialect groups. Average Wright's corrected fixation coefficient (F_ST) was 0.118, indicating significant genetic differentiation among all sites, regardless of dialect. Hierarchical F statistics indicated that only 50% of among site variability was due to a dialect effect. Puna dialect sites were highly differentiated from all other sites with respect to both morphology (external and skeletal measures) and allozyme frequencies. Heterogeneity at the PGM-1 locus among puna scrub sites was the major cause of the high average F_ST across all sites, and within the puna scrub dialect. Average genetic differentiation among non-puna sites (F_ST = 0.018) was similar to differentiation among sites within each of the five non-puna dialect groups (mean F_ST = 0.0132 ± 0.0069). Hierarchical F statistics indicated that none of the among-site differentiation in this subset of samples was due to a dialect effect. These observations are not consistent with the local adaptation hypothesis. All significant genetic heterogeneity occurred among sites in mountainous habitats, and we suggest that topography and patchiness of habitat may have been major factors involved in population differentiation, rather than vocal dialects.