Responses of net ecosystem CO2 exchange in managed grassland to long-term CO2 enrichment, N fertilization and plant species

The effects of elevated pCO₂ on net ecosystem CO₂ exchange were investigated in managed Lolium perenne (perennial ryegrass) and Trifolium repens (white clover) monocultures that had been exposed continuously to elevated pCO₂ (60 Pa) for nine growing seasons using Free Air CO₂ Enrichment (FACE) technology. Two levels of nitrogen (N) fertilization were applied. Midday net ecosystem CO₂ exchange (mNEE) and night-time ecosystem respiration (NER) were measured in three growing seasons using an open-flow chamber system. The annual net ecosystem carbon (C) input resulting from the net CO₂ fluxes was estimated for one growing season. In both monocultures and at both levels of N supply, elevated pCO₂ stimulated mNEE by up to 32%, the exact amount depending on intercepted PAR. The response of mNEE to elevated pCO₂ was larger than that of harvestable biomass. Elevated pCO₂ increased NER by up to 39% in both species at both levels of N supply. NER, which was affected by mNEE of the preceding day, was higher in T. repens than in L. perenne. High N increased NER compared to low N supply. According to treatment, the annual net ecosystem C input ranged between 210 and 631 g C m⁻² year⁻¹ and was not significantly affected by the level of pCO₂. Low N supply led to a higher net C input than high N supply. We demonstrated that at the ecosystem level, there was a long-term stimulation in the net C assimilation during daytime by elevated pCO₂. However, because NER was also stimulated, net ecosystem C input was not significantly increased at elevated pCO₂. The annual net ecosystem C input was primarily affected by the amount of N supplied.     

Estimation of the whole-plant CO2 compensation point of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.)

The whole-plant CO₂ compensation point (Γ_plant) is the minimum atmospheric CO₂ level required for sustained growth. The minimum CO₂ requirement for growth is critical to understanding biosphere feedbacks on the carbon cycle during low CO₂ episodes; however, actual values of Γ_plant remain difficult to calculate. Here, we have estimated Γ_plant in tobacco by measuring the relative leaf expansion rate at several low levels of atmospheric CO₂, and then extrapolating the leaf growth vs. CO₂ response to estimate CO₂ levels where no growth occurs. Plants were grown under three temperature treatments, 19/15, 25/20 and 30/25°C day/night, and at CO₂ levels of 100, 150, 190 and 270 μmol CO₂ mol⁻¹ air. Biomass declined with growth CO₂ such that Γ_plant was estimated to be approximately 65 μmol mol⁻¹ for plants grown at 19/15 and 30/25°C. In the first 19 days after germination, plants grown at 100 μmol mol⁻¹ had low growth rates, such that most remained as tiny seedlings (canopy size <1 cm²). Most seedlings grown at 150 μmol mol⁻¹ and 30/25°C also failed to grow beyond the small seedling size by day 19. Plants in all other treatments grew beyond the small seedling size within 3 weeks of planting. Given sufficient time (16 weeks after planting) plants at 100 μmol mol⁻¹ eventually reached a robust size and produced an abundance of viable seed. Photosynthetic acclimation did not increase Rubisco content at low CO₂. Instead, Rubisco levels were unchanged except at the 100 and 150 μmol mol⁻¹ where they declined. Chlorophyll content and leaf weight per area declined in the same proportion as Rubisco, indicating that leaves became less expensive to produce. From these results, we conclude that the effects of very low CO₂ are most severe during seedling establishment, in large part because CO₂ deficiency slows the emergence and expansion of new leaves. Once sufficient leaf area is produced, plants enter the exponential growth phase and acquire sufficient carbon to complete their life cycle, even under warm conditions (30/25°C) and CO₂ levels as low as 100 μmol mol⁻¹.     

Integration of photosynthetic acclimation to CO2 at the whole-plant level

Primary events in photosynthetic (PS) acclimation to elevated CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) occur at the molecular level in leaf mesophyll cells, but final growth response to [CO₂] involves acclimation responses associated with photosynthate partitioning among plant organs in relation to resources limiting growth. Source–sink interactions, particularly with regard to carbon (C) and nitrogen (N), are key determinants of PS acclimation to elevated [CO₂] at the whole-plant level. In the long term, PS and growth response to [CO₂] are dependent on genotypic and environmental factors affecting the plant's ability to develop new sinks for C, and acquire adequate N and other resources to support an enhanced growth potential. Growth at elevated [CO₂] usually increases N use efficiency because PS rates can be maintained at levels comparable to those observed at ambient [CO₂] with less N investment in PS enzymes. A frequent acclimation response, particularly under N-limited conditions, is for the accumulation of leaf carbohydrates at elevated [CO₂] to lead to repression of genes associated with the production of PS enzymes. The hypothesis that this is an adaptive response, leading to a diversion of N to plant organs where it is of greatest benefit in terms of competitive ability and reproductive fitness, needs to be more rigorously tested. The biological control mechanisms which plants have evolved to acclimate to shifts in source–sink balance caused by elevated [CO₂] are complex, and will only be fully elucidated by probing at all scales along the hierarchy from molecular to ecosystem. Use of environmental manipulations and genotypic comparisons will facilitate the testing of specific hypotheses. Improving our ability to predict PS acclimation to [CO₂] will require the integration of results from laboratory studies using simple model systems with results from whole-plant studies that include measurements of processes operating at several scales. Abbreviations: CAM, crassulacean acid metabolism; FACE, Free-Air CO₂ Enrichment; Pi, inorganic phosphate; LAR, leaf area ratio (m² g^-1); LWR, leaf weight ratio (g g^-1); NAR, net assimilation rate (g m^-2 d^{- 1}); PS, photosynthetic; RGR, relative growth rate (g g^-1 d^-1); R:S, root/shoot ratio; rubisco, ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase; RuBP, ribulose bisphosphate; SLA, specific leaf area (m² g^-1); SPS, sucrose phosphate synthase; WUE, water use efficiency (g biomass g H₂O^-1).     

Responses of tree sap-feeding herbivores to elevated CO2

Five species of sap-feeding homoptera were studied on Fagus sylvatica and Acer pseudoplatanus and exposed to elevated concentrations of carbon dioxide (600 μL L^–1). The concentration of total soluble amino acids in foliage of F. sylvatica was unaffected by growing saplings in elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. Although experiments on individual aphids indicated poorer performance of Phyllaphis fagi (fewer, smaller nymphs produced), resultant populations did not differ from those in ambient (350 μL L^–1) conditions. The area of beech foliage stippled by the leafhopper Fagocyba cruenta was similar at ambient and elevated CO₂ concentrations. The concentration of total amino acids and that of serine of A. pseudoplatanus foliage were significantly lower at elevated CO₂ concentrations. However, the relative growth rates of two aphid species Drepanosiphum platanoidis and Periphyllus testudinaceus and one leafhopper Ossiannilssonola callosa were not significantly different in elevated CO₂. No evidence was found that, under the conditions of these experiments, populations of aphids and leafhoppers will change as concentrations of CO₂ increase.     

Respiration of crop species under CO2 enrichment

Respiratory characteristics of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cvs Gabo and WW15), mung bean (Vigna radiata L. Wilczek cv. Celera) and sunflower (Helianthus annuus L. cv. Sunfola) were studied in plants grown under a normal CO₂ concentration and in air containing an additional 340 (or 250) μl l^?1 CO₂. Such an increase in global atmospheric CO₂ concentration has been forecast for about the middle of the next century. The aim was to measure the effect of high CO₂ on respiration and its components. Polarographic and, with wheat, CO₂ exchange techniques were used. The capacity of the alternative pathway of respiration in roots was determined polarographically in the presence of 0.1 mM KCN. The actual rate of alternative pathway respiration was assessed by reduction in oxygen consumption caused by 10 mM salicylhydroxamic acid. Each species responded differently. In wheat, growth in high atmospheric CO₂ was associated with up to 45% reduction in respiration by both roots and whole plants. Use of respiratory inhibitors in polarographic measurements on wheat roots implicated reduction in the degree of engagement of the alternative pathway as a major contributor to this reduced respiratory activity of high-CO₂ plants. No change was found in the total sugar content per unit wheat root dry weight as a result of high CO₂. In none of the species was there an increase in the absolute, or relative, contribution by the alternative pathway to total respiration of the root systems. Thus the improved photosynthetic assimilate supply of plants grown in high CO₂ did not lead to increased diversion of carbon through the non-phosphorylating alternative pathway of respiration in the root. On the contrary, in wheat grown in high CO₂ the reduced loss of carbon through that route must have contributed to their larger dry weight.     

Respiratory responses of higher plants to atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Although the respiratory response of native and agricultural plants to atmospheric CO₂ enrichment has been reported over the past 75 years, only recently have these effects emerged as prominent measures of plant and ecosystem response to the earth's changing climate. In this review we discuss this rapidly expanding field of study and propose that both increasing and decreasing rates of leaf and whole-plant respiration are likely to occur in response to rising CO₂ concentrations. While the stimulatory effects of CO₂ on respiration are consistent with our knowledge of leaf carbohydrate status and plant metabolism, we wish to emphasize the rather surprising short-term inhibition of leaf respiration by elevated CO₂ and the reported effects of long-term CO₂ exposure on growth and maintenance respiration. As is being found in many studies, it is easier to document the respiratory response of higher plants to elevated CO₂ than it is to assign a mechanistic basis for the observed effects. Despite this gap in our understanding of how respiration is affected by CO₂ enrichment, data are sufficient to suggest that changes in leaf and whole-plant respiration may be important considerations in the carbon dynamics of terrestrial ecosystems as global CO₂ continues to rise. Suggestions for future research that would enable these and other effects of CO₂ on respiration to be unravelled are presented.     

The response of heterotrophic CO2 flux to soil warming

In a forest ecosystem at steady state, net carbon (C) assimilation by plants and C loss through soil and litter decomposition by heterotrophic organisms are balanced. However, a perturbation to the system, such as increased mean soil temperature, will lead to faster decay, enhancing CO₂ release from decomposers, and thus upsetting the balance. Recent in situ experiments have indicated that the stimulation of soil respiration following a step increase in annual average soil temperature declines over time. One possible explanation for this decline may be changes in substrate availability. This hypothesis is examined by using the ecosystem model G'DAY, which simulates C and nitrogen (N) dynamics in plants and soil. We applied the model to observations from a soil‐warming experiment in a Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) stand by simulating a step increase of soil temperature. The model provided a good qualitative reproduction of the observed reduction of heterotrophic respiration (R_h) under sustained warming. The simulations showed how the combined effects of faster turnover and reduced substrate availability lead to a transient increase of R_h. The simulated annual increase in R_h from soil was 60% in the first year after perturbation but decreased to 30% after a decade. One conclusion from the analysis of the simulations is that R_h can decrease even though the temperature response function for decomposition remains unchanged. G'DAY suggests that acclimation of R_h to soil warming is partly an effect of substrate depletion of labile C pools during the first decade of warming as a result of accelerated rates of mineralization. The response is attributed mainly to changing levels of C in pools with short time constants, reflecting the importance of high‐quality soil C fractions. Changes of the structure or physiology of the decomposer community were not invoked. Therefore, it becomes a question of definition whether the simulated dynamics of the declining response of CO₂ release to the warming should be named acclimation or seen as a natural part of the system dynamics.     

The response of soil CO2 flux to changes in atmospheric CO2, nitrogen supply and plant diversity

We measured soil CO₂ flux over 19 sampling periods that spanned two growing seasons in a grassland Free Air Carbon dioxide Enrichment (FACE) experiment that factorially manipulated three major anthropogenic global changes: atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) concentration, nitrogen (N) supply, and plant species richness. On average, over two growing seasons, elevated atmospheric CO₂ and N fertilization increased soil CO₂ flux by 0.57 µmol m^?2 s^?1 (13% increase) and 0.37 µmol m^?2 s^?1 (8% increase) above average control soil CO₂ flux, respectively. Decreases in planted diversity from 16 to 9, 4 and 1 species decreased soil CO₂ flux by 0.23, 0.41 and 1.09 µmol m^?2 s^?1 (5%, 8% and 21% decreases), respectively. There were no statistically significant pairwise interactions among the three treatments. During 19 sampling periods that spanned two growing seasons, elevated atmospheric CO₂ increased soil CO₂ flux most when soil moisture was low and soils were warm. Effects on soil CO₂ flux due to fertilization with N and decreases in diversity were greatest at the times of the year when soils were warm, although there were no significant correlations between these effects and soil moisture. Of the treatments, only the N and diversity treatments were correlated over time; neither were correlated with the CO₂ effect. Models of soil CO₂ flux will need to incorporate ecosystem CO₂ and N availability, as well as ecosystem plant diversity, and incorporate different environmental factors when determining the magnitude of the CO₂, N and diversity effects on soil CO₂ flux.     

Responses of CAM species to increasing atmospheric CO2 concentrations

Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) species show an average increase in biomass productivity of 35% in response to a doubled atmospheric CO₂ concentration. Daily net CO₂ uptake is similarly enhanced, reflecting in part an increase in chlorenchyma thickness and accompanied by an even greater increase in water‐use efficiency. The responses of net CO₂ uptake in CAM species to increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentrations are similar to those for C₃ species and much greater than those for C₄ species. Increases in net daily CO₂ uptake by CAM plants under elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations reflect increases in both Rubisco‐mediated daytime CO₂ uptake and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPCase)‐mediated night‐time CO₂ uptake, the latter resulting in increased nocturnal malate accumulation. Chlorophyll contents and the activities of Rubisco and PEPCase decrease under elevated atmospheric CO₂, but the activated percentage for Rubisco increases and the K_M(HCO₃ ^? ) for PEPCase decreases, resulting in more efficient photosynthesis. Increases in root:shoot ratios and the formation of additional photosynthetic organs, together with increases in sucrose‐Pi synthase and starch synthase activity in these organs under elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations, decrease the potential feedback inhibition of photosynthesis. Longer‐term studies for several CAM species show no downward acclimatization of photosynthesis in response to elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. With increasing temperature and drought duration, the percentage enhancement of daily net CO₂ uptake caused by elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations increases. Thus net CO₂ uptake, productivity, and the potential area for cultivation of CAM species will be enhanced by the increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentrations and the increasing temperatures associated with global climate change.