Multiple acquisition of methanogenic archaeal symbionts by anaerobic ciliates

Anaerobic heterotrichous ciliates (Armophoridae and Clevelandellidae) possess hydrogenosomes that generate molecular hydrogen and ATP. This intracellular source of hydrogen provides the basis for a stable endosymbiotic association with methanogenic archaea. We analyzed the SSU rRNA genes of 18 heterotrichous anaerobic ciliates and their methanogenic endosymbionts in order to unravel the evolution of this mutualistic association. Here, we show that the anaerobic heterotrichous ciliates constitute at least three evolutionary lines. One group consists predominantly of gut-dwelling ciliates, and two to three, potentially four, additional clades comprise ciliates that thrive in freshwater sediments. Their methanogenic endosymbionts belong to only two different taxa that are closely related to free-living methanogenic archaea from the particular ecological niches. The close phylogenetic relationships between the endosymbionts and free-living methanogenic archaea argue for multiple acquisitions from environmental sources, notwithstanding the strictly vertical transmission of the endosymbionts. Since phylogenetic analysis of the small-subunit (SSU) rRNA genes of the hydrogenosomes of these ciliates indicates a descent from the mitochondria of aerobic ciliates, it is likely that anaerobic heterotrichous ciliates hosted endosymbiotic methanogens prior to their radiation. Therefore, our data strongly suggest multiple acquisitions and replacements of endosymbiotic methanogenic archaea during their host's adaptation to the various ecological niches.     

Synchronous Division of an Endosymbiotic Methanogenic Bacterium In the Anaerobic Ciliate Plagiopyla Frontata Kahl

ABSTRACT The life cycle of a methanogenic bacterium, symbiotic within the marine, free-living anaerobic ciliate Plagiopyla frontata , was studied using light microscopy and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). the bacteria are disc-shaped. During the growth phase of the host, bacteria and hydrogenosomes (organelles which ferment pyruvate into acetate and hydrogen) are arranged in conglomerates resembling stacks of coins in which bacteria and hydrogenosomes alternate; hydrogenosomes always cap the ends of the stacks. During the growth phase, numbers of hydrogenosomes and bacteria remain constant (about 5,000 and 3,500 per cell, respectively). Hydrogenosomes increase in volume shortly after cell division. Methanogens increase in volume slowly during the growth phase of the ciliate and rapidly when the ciliate begins to divide. the hydrogenosomes divide mainly during the initial phases of cell division while the methanogens divide synchronously during the last phase of ciliate division. the timing of reproduction of the symbionts is controlled by the host-cell cycle. the ciliate is known to receive an energetic advantage from its symbionts. the suppression of continuous bacterial reproduction may trigger the secretion of excess bacterial production as soluble organic compounds, for use by the ciliate.     

Symbionts and organelles in ancrobic protozoa and fungi

The discovery of methanogenic bacteria as endosymbionts of free-living anaerobic protozoa opened new fields of research in microbial ecology, cell physiology and molecular biology. Recent information from 16S rRNA sequence studies has shown in three cases that endosymbiotic methanogenic bacteria differ from free-living species. Frequently, endosymbiotic methanogens are localized in anaerobic protozoa near hydrogenosomes - organelles that produce H2, C02 and acetate, all of which are substrates for methanogenesis. Hydrogenosomes are also present in anaerobic fungi. The current view is that the organelles are endosymbllont-derived and were probably acquired on several distinct occasions during evolution.     

The missing link between hydrogenosomes and mitochondria

Mitochondria typically respire oxygen and possess a small DNA genome. But among various groups of oxygen-shunning eukaryotes, typical mitochondria are often lacking, organelles called hydrogenosomes being found instead. Like mitochondria, hydrogenosomes are surrounded by a double-membrane, produce ATP and sometimes even have cristae. In contrast to mitochondria, hydrogenosomes produce molecular hydrogen through fermentations, lack cytochromes and usually lack DNA. Hydrogenosomes do not fit into the conceptual mold cast by the classical endosymbiont hypothesis about the nature of mitochondria. Accordingly, ideas about their evolutionary origins have focussed on the differences between the two organelles instead of their commonalities. Are hydrogenosomes fundamentally different from mitochondria, the result of a different endosymbiosis? Or are our concepts about the mitochondrial archetype simply too narrow? A new report has uncovered DNA in the hydrogenosomes of anaerobic ciliates. The sequences show that these hydrogenosomes are, without a doubt, mitochondria in the evolutionary sense, even though they differ from typical mitochondria in various biochemical properties. The new findings are a benchmark for our understanding of hydrogenosome origins.     

Hydrogenosomes: convergent adaptations of mitochondria to anaerobic environments

Hydrogenosomes are membrane-bound organelles that compartmentalise the final steps of energy metabolism in a number of anaerobic eukaryotes. They produce hydrogen and ATP. Here we will review the data, which are relevant for the questions: how did the hydrogenosomes originate, and what was their ancestor? Notably, there is strong evidence that hydrogenosomes evolved several times as adaptations to anaerobic environments. Most likely, hydrogenosomes and mitochondria share a common ancestor, but an unequivocal proof for this hypothesis is difficult because hydrogenosomes lack an organelle genome - with one remarkable exception (Nyctotherus ovalis). In particular, the diversity of extant hydrogenosomes hampers a straightforward analysis of their origins. Nevertheless, it is conceivable to postulate that the common ancestor of mitochondria and hydrogenosomes was a facultative anaerobic organelle that participated in the early radiation of unicellular eukaryotes. Consequently, it is reasonable to assume that both, hydrogenosomes and mitochondria are evolutionary adaptations to anaerobic or aerobic environments, respectively.     

Hydrogenosomes in some anaerobic protozoa resemble mitochondria

Abstract Microbodies in six anaerobic ciliated protozoa ( Metopus, Brachonella, Plagiopyla, Parablepharisma, Sonderia, Saprodinium ) were found to be enclosed by two membranes. The inner membrane showed extensive infolding, division stages were observed, and in all genera apart from Sonderia and Parablepharisma , the microbodies contained an hydrogenase and were attached to methanogenic bacteria. Some of these ciliates are related to aerobic species with mitochondria. We believe that the microbodies are hydrogenosomes, that they are derived from mitochondria, and that their biochemical modification has incurred little change in the original mitochondrial ultrastructure. These observations weaken the case for the independent origin of hydrogenosomes from anaerobic prokaryotes.     

The nature of anaerobic fungi and their polysaccharide degrading enzymes

Conclusion The discovery of anaerobic fungi has added a new member to the indigenous microorganisms that inhabit the rumen ecosystem. Anaerobic fungi do not appear essential for the survival of ruminants due to their presence in very low numbers, and sometimes absence, in ruminants fed low fiber diets, but their presence may likely be very important in the digestion of fibrous diets. The anaerobic fungi have adapted well to the rumen environment. They are able to ferment a large array of soluble carbohydrates and can synthesize cellular components in an anaerobic environment. The fungi posses hydrogenosomes for the removal of reducing equivalents in the form of molecular hydrogen and the removal of trace oxygen is a accomplished via removal by NADH oxidase. Their positive synergistic interaction with methanogenic bacteria eludes to their highly evolved role in the rumen environment. The fungi also produce resistant sporangia that allows for transfer of species to a new host in an oxygen environment. The anaerobic fungi posses a highly active array of polysaccharide degrading enzymes that may provide an advantage in the highly competitive rumen ecosystem. The production of specific enzymes that hydrolyze the lignocellulosic fraction of plant walls is unique in rumen microorganisms and allows for their attachment and growth on fibrous plant particles that are not available to the rumen bacteria.     

Protein targeting in parasites with cryptic mitochondria

Many highly specialised parasites have adapted to their environments by simplifying different aspects of their morphology or biochemistry. One interesting case is the mitochondrion, which has been subject to strong reductive evolution in parallel in several different parasitic groups. In extreme cases, mitochondria have degenerated so much in physical size and functional complexity that they were not immediately recognised as mitochondria, and are now referred to as 'cryptic'. Cryptic mitochondrion-derived organelles can be classified as either hydrogenosomes or mitosomes. In nearly all cases they lack a genome and all organellar proteins are nucleus-encoded and expressed in the cytosol. The same is true for the majority of proteins in canonical mitochondria, where the proteins are directed to the organelle by specific targeting sequences (transit peptides) that are recognised by translocases in the mitochondrial membrane. In this review, we compare targeting sequences of different parasitic systems with highly reduced mitochondria and give an overview of how the import machinery has been modified in hydrogenosomes and mitosomes.     

Mitochondria and hydrogenosomes are two forms of the same fundamental organelle

Published data suggest that hydrogenosomes, organelles found in diverse anaerobic eukaryotes that make energy and hydrogen, were once mitochondria. As hydrogenosomes generally lack a genome, the conversion is probably one way. The sources of the key hydrogenosomal enzymes, pyruvate : ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PFO) and hydrogenase, are not resolved by current phylogenetic analyses, but it is likely that both were present at an early stage of eukaryotic evolution. Once thought to be restricted to a few unusual anaerobic eukaryotes, the proteins are intimately integrated into the fabric of diverse eukaryotic cells, where they are targeted to different cell compartments, and not just hydrogenosomes. There is no evidence supporting the view that PFO and hydrogenase originated from the mitochondrial endosymbiont, as posited by the hydrogen hypothesis for eukaryogenesis. Other organelles derived from mitochondria have now been described in anaerobic and parasitic microbial eukaryotes, including species that were once thought to have diverged before the mitochondrial symbiosis. It thus seems possible that all eukaryotes may eventually be shown to contain an organelle of mitochondrial ancestry, to which different types of biochemistry can be targeted. It remains to be seen if, despite their obvious differences, this family of organelles shares a common function of importance for the eukaryotic cell, other than energy production, that might provide the underlying selection pressure for organelle retention.     

A hydrogenosome with pyruvate formate-lyase: anaerobic chytrid fungi use an alternative route for pyruvate catabolism

The chytrid fungi Piromyces sp. E2 and Neocallimastix sp. L2 are obligatory amitochondriate anaerobes that possess hydrogenosomes. Hydrogenosomes are highly specialized organelles engaged in anaerobic carbon metabolism; they generate molecular hydrogen and ATP. Here, we show for the first time that chytrid hydrogenosomes use pyruvate formate-lyase (PFL) and not pyruvate:ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PFO) for pyruvate catabolism, unlike all other hydrogenosomes studied to date. Chytrid PFLs are encoded by a multigene family and are abundantly expressed in Piromyces sp. E2 and Neocallimastix sp. L2. Western blotting after cellular fractionation, proteinase K protection assays and determinations of enzyme activities reveal that PFL is present in the hydrogenosomes of Piromyces sp. E2. The main route of the hydrogenosomal carbon metabolism involves PFL; the formation of equimolar amounts of formate and acetate by isolated hydrogenosomes excludes a significant contribution by PFO. Our data support the assumption that chytrid hydrogenosomes are unique and argue for a polyphyletic origin of these organelles.     

The hydrogenosomes of Psalteriomonas lanterna

Background  

Hydrogenosomes are organelles that produce molecular hydrogen and ATP. The broad phylogenetic distribution of their hosts suggests that the hydrogenosomes of these organisms evolved several times independently from the mitochondria of aerobic progenitors. Morphology and 18S rRNA phylogeny suggest that the microaerophilic amoeboflagellate Psalteriomonas lanterna, which possesses hydrogenosomes and elusive "modified mitochondria", belongs to the Heterolobosea, a taxon that consists predominantly of aerobic, mitochondriate organisms. This taxon is rather unrelated to taxa with hitherto studied hydrogenosomes.     

Hydrogenosomes under microscopy

A hydrogenosome is a hydrogen-producing organelle, evolutionary related to mitochondria and is found in Parabasalia protozoa, certain chytrid fungi and certain ciliates. It displays similarities to and differences from mitochondria. Hydrogenosomes are spherical or slightly elongated organelles, although very elongated hydrogenosomes are also found. They measure from 200 nm to 1 μm, but under stress conditions can reach up to 2 μm. Hydrogenosomes are surrounded by two closely apposed membranes and present a granular matrix. Cardiolipin has been detected in their membranes, and frataxin, which is a conserved mitochondrial protein involved in iron metabolism, was also recently found. Hydrogenosomes have one or multiple peripheral vesicles, which incorporate calcium. The peripheral vesicle can be isolated from the hydrogenosomal matrix and can be considered as a distinct hydrogenosomal compartment. Dysfunctional hydrogenosomes can be removed by an autophagic process and further digested by lysosomes. Hydrogenosomes divide in three different ways, like mitochondria, by segmentation, partition and the heart form. They may divide at any phase of the cell cycle. Nucleoid or electron dense deposits found in hydrogenosomes can be considered artifacts or dysfunctional hydrogenosomes. The hydrogenosome does not contain a genome, although DNA has already been detected in one anaerobic ciliate. Hydrogenosomes can be considered as good drug targets since their metabolism is distinct from mitochondria.     

Hydrogenosome behavior during the cell cycle in Tritrichomonas foetus

The hydrogenosome is an unusual organelle found in several trichomonad species and other protists living in oxygen poor or anoxic environments. The hydrogenosome behavior in the protist Tritrichomonas foetus, parasite of the urogenital tract of cattle, is reported here. The hydrogenosomes were followed by light and transmission electron microscopy during the whole cell cycle. Videomicroscopy, immunofluorescence microscopy, and immunocytochemistry were also used. It is shown that the hydrogenosomes divide at any phase of the cell cycle and that the organellar division is not synchronized. During the interphase the hydrogenosomes are distributed mainly along the axostyle and costa, and at the beginning of mitosis migrate to around the nucleus. Three forms of hydrogenosome division were seen: (1). segmentation, where elongated hydrogenosomes are further separated by external membranous profiles; (2). partition, where rounded hydrogenosomes, in a bulky form, are further separated by a membranous internal septum and, (3). a new dividing form: heart-shaped hydrogenosomes, which gradually present a membrane invagination leading to the organelle division. The hydrogenosomes divide at any phase of the cell cycle. A necklace of intramembranous particles delimiting the outer hydrogenosomal membrane in the region of organelle division was observed by freeze-etching. Similarities between hydrogenosomes and mitochondria behavior during the cell cycle are discussed.     

Methanogenic bacteria as endosymbionts of the ciliate Nyctotherus ovalis in the cockroach hindgut

Production of methane in the hindgut of the cockroach Periplaneta americana was found to vary, depending on the feeding regimen. Methane production was positively correlated with the numbers of the ciliate Nyctotherus ovalis living in the cockroach hindgut. Defaunation of the cockroaches by means of low concentrations of metronidazole (Flagyl) resulted in a quick drop of methane production. Addition of the methanogenic substrates acetate and formate to isolated hindguts stimulated methane production. Inside the ciliate cells, autofluorescing bacteria could be demonstrated which were presumed to be methanogens. Electron microscopy revealed that the bacteria resembled Methanobrevibacter and that they were closely associated with organelles which contained infolded membranes and which were presumably hydrogenosomes.     

A comparison of two strains of the anaerobic ciliate Trimyema compressum

Two strains of the anaerobic ciliate Trimyema compressum, isolated from different habitats, were compared. The cytoplasm of the ciliates contained hydrogenosome-like microbodies and methanogenic bacteria; the latter were lost during continued cultivation. In addition both strains harbored a non-methanogenic endosymbiont, which was lost in strain K. The ciliates lacked cytochromes, cytochrome oxidase and catalase but contained superoxide dismutase. Hydrogenase activity could be demonstrated only in strain N. In monoxenic culture strain K needed sterols as growth factors. The cells of both strains reacted similarly with respect to oxygen tolerance (up to 0.5 mg O₂/l), inhibition of growth by cyanide and azide, and resistance to antimycin A. Only cells of strain N showed growth inhibition by chloramphenicol. It is concluded that Trimyema compressum is an anaerobic, microaerotolerant organism, its microbodies show more resemblance to hydrogenosomes than to mitochondria.     

The N‐Terminal Sequences of Four Major Hydrogenosomal Proteins Are Not Essential for Import into Hydrogenosomes of Trichomonas vaginalis

The human pathogen Trichomonas vaginalis harbors hydrogenosomes, organelles of mitochondrial origin that generate ATP through hydrogen‐producing fermentations. They contain neither genome nor translation machinery, but approximately 500 proteins that are imported from the cytosol. In contrast to well‐studied organelles like Saccharomyces mitochondria, very little is known about how proteins are transported across the two membranes enclosing the hydrogenosomal matrix. Recent studies indicate that—in addition to N‐terminal transit peptides—internal targeting signals might be more common in hydrogenosomes than in mitochondria. To further characterize the extent to which N‐terminal and internal motifs mediate hydrogenosomal protein targeting, we transfected Trichomonas with 24 hemagglutinin (HA) tag fusion constructs, encompassing 13 different hydrogenosomal and cytosolic proteins of the parasite. Hydrogenosomal targeting of these proteins was analyzed by subcellular fractionation and independently by immunofluorescent localization. The investigated proteins include some of the most abundant hydrogenosomal proteins, such as pyruvate ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PFO), which possesses an amino‐terminal targeting signal that is processed on import into hydrogenosomes, but is shown here not to be required for import into hydrogenosomes. Our results demonstrate that the deletion of N‐terminal signals of hydrogenosomal precursors generally has little, if any, influence upon import into hydrogenosomes. Although the necessary and sufficient signals for hydrogenosomal import recognition appear complex, targeting to the organelle is still highly specific, as demonstrated by the finding that six HA‐tagged glycolytic enzymes, highly expressed under the same promoter as other constructs studied here, localized exclusively to the cytosol and did not associate with hydrogenosomes.     

Methanogenic bacteria as endosymbionts of the ciliate Nyctotherus ovalis in the cockroach hindgut.

Production of methane in the hindgut of the cockroach Periplaneta americana was found to vary, depending on the feeding regimen. Methane production was positively correlated with the numbers of the ciliate Nyctotherus ovalis living in the cockroach hindgut. Defaunation of the cockroaches by means of low concentrations of metronidazole (Flagyl) resulted in a quick drop of methane production. Addition of the methanogenic substrates acetate and formate to isolated hindguts stimulated methane production. Inside the ciliate cells, autofluorescing bacteria could be demonstrated which were presumed to be methanogens. Electron microscopy revealed that the bacteria resembled Methanobrevibacter and that they were closely associated with organelles which contained infolded membranes and which were presumably hydrogenosomes.     

Iron hydrogenases and the evolution of anaerobic eukaryotes

Hydrogenases, oxygen-sensitive enzymes that can make hydrogen gas, are key to the function of hydrogen-producing organelles (hydrogenosomes), which occur in anaerobic protozoa scattered throughout the eukaryotic tree. Hydrogenases also play a central role in the hydrogen and syntrophic hypotheses for eukaryogenesis. Here, we show that sequences related to iron-only hydrogenases ([Fe] hydrogenases) are more widely distributed among eukaryotes than reports of hydrogen production have suggested. Genes encoding small proteins which contain conserved structural features unique to [Fe] hydrogenases were identified on all well-surveyed aerobic eukaryote genomes. Longer sequences encoding [Fe] hydrogenases also occur in the anaerobic eukaryotes Entamoeba histolytica and Spironucleus barkhanus, both of which lack hydrogenosomes. We also identified a new [Fe] hydrogenase sequence from Trichomonas vaginalis, bringing the total of [Fe] hydrogenases reported for this organism to three, all of which may function within its hydrogenosomes. Phylogenetic analysis and hypothesis testing using likelihood ratio tests and parametric bootstrapping suggest that the [Fe] hydrogenases in anaerobic eukaryotes are not monophyletic. Iron-only hydrogenases from Entamoeba, Spironucleus, and Trichomonas are plausibly monophyletic, consistent with the hypothesis that a gene for [Fe] hydrogenase was already present on the genome of the common, perhaps also anaerobic, ancestor of these phylogenetically distinct eukaryotes. Trees where the [Fe] hydrogenase from the hydrogenosomal ciliate Nyctotherus was constrained to be monophyletic with the other eukaryote sequences were rejected using a likelihood ratio test of monophyly. In most analyses, the Nyctotherus sequence formed a sister group with a [Fe] hydrogenase on the genome of the eubacterium Desulfovibrio vulgaris. Thus, it is possible that Nyctotherus obtained its hydrogenosomal [Fe] hydrogenase from a different source from Trichomonas for its hydrogenosomes. We find no support for the hypothesis that components of the Nyctotherus [Fe] hydrogenase fusion protein derive from the mitochondrial respiratory chain.     

Hydrogenosomes: eukaryotic adaptations to anaerobic environments.

Like mitochondria, hydrogenosomes compartmentalize crucial steps of eukaryotic energy metabolism; however, this compartmentalization differs substantially between mitochondriate aerobes and hydrogenosome-containing anaerobes. Because hydrogenosomes have arisen independently in different lineages of eukaryotic microorganisms, comparative analysis of the various types of hydrogenosomes can provide insights into the functional and evolutionary aspects of compartmentalized energy metabolism in unicellular eukaryotes.     

Protein import into hydrogenosomes of Trichomonas vaginalis involves both N-terminal and internal targeting signals: a case study of thioredoxin reductases

The parabasalian flagellate Trichomonas vaginalis harbors mitochondrion-related and H₂-producing organelles of anaerobic ATP synthesis, called hydrogenosomes, which harbor oxygen-sensitive enzymes essential to its pyruvate metabolism. In the human urogenital tract, however, T. vaginalis is regularly exposed to low oxygen concentrations and therefore must possess antioxidant systems protecting the organellar environment against the detrimental effects of molecular oxygen and reactive oxygen species. We have identified two closely related hydrogenosomal thioredoxin reductases (TrxRs), the hitherto-missing component of a thioredoxin-linked hydrogenosomal antioxidant system. One of the two hydrogenosomal TrxR isoforms, TrxRh1, carried an N-terminal extension resembling known hydrogenosomal targeting signals. Expression of hemagglutinin-tagged TrxRh1 in transfected T. vaginalis cells revealed that its N-terminal extension was necessary to import the protein into the organelles. The second hydrogenosomal TrxR isoform, TrxRh2, had no N-terminal targeting signal but was nonetheless efficiently targeted to hydrogenosomes. N-terminal presequences from hydrogenosomal proteins with known processing sites, i.e., the alpha subunit of succinyl coenzyme A synthetase (SCSα) and pyruvate:ferredoxin oxidoreductase A, were investigated for their ability to direct mature TrxRh1 to hydrogenosomes. Neither presequence directed TrxRh1 to hydrogenosomes, indicating that neither extension is, by itself, sufficient for hydrogenosomal targeting. Moreover, SCSα lacking its N-terminal extension was efficiently imported into hydrogenosomes, indicating that this extension is not required for import of this major hydrogenosomal protein. The finding that some hydrogenosomal enzymes require N-terminal signals for import but that in others the N-terminal extension is not necessary for targeting indicates the presence of additional targeting signals within the mature subunits of several hydrogenosome-localized proteins.