Different modes of interaction in cyanobacterial complexes of plastocyanin and cytochrome f

The highly efficient electron-transfer chain in photosynthesis demonstrates a remarkable variation among organisms in the type of interactions between the soluble electron-transfer protein plastocyanin and it partner cytochrome f. The complex from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 was studied using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and compared to that of the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum. In both systems, the main site of interaction on plastocyanin is the hydrophobic patch. However, the interaction in the Nostoc complex is highly dependent on electrostatics, contrary to that of Phormidium, resulting in a binding constant that is an order of magnitude larger at low ionic strength for the Nostoc complex. Studies of the mixed complexes show that these differences in interactions are mainly attributable to the surface properties of the plastocyanins.     

Plastocyanin-cytochrome f interactions: the influence of hydrophobic patch mutations studied by NMR spectroscopy

Transient complex formation between plastocyanin from Prochlorothrix hollandica and cytochrome f from Phormidium laminosum was investigated using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Binding curves derived from NMR titrations at 10 mM ionic strength reveal a 1:1 stoichiometry and a binding constant of 6 (+/-2) x 10(3) M(-1) for complex formation, 1 order of magnitude larger than that for the physiological plastocyanin-cytochrome f complex from Ph. laminosum. Chemical-shift perturbation mapping indicates that the hydrophobic patch of plastocyanin is involved in the complex interface. When the unusual hydrophobic patch residues of P. hollandica plastocyanin were reverted to the conserved residues found in most other plastocyanins (Y12G/P14L), the binding constant for the interaction with cytochrome f was unaffected. However, the chemical shift perturbation map was considerably different, and the size of the average perturbation decreased by 40%. The complexes of both the wild-type and double mutant plastocyanin with cytochrome f were sensitive to ionic strength, contrary to the physiological complex. The possible implications of these findings for the mechanism of transient complex formation are discussed.     

Role of electrostatics in the interaction between plastocyanin and photosystem I of the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum.

The interactions between photosystem I and five charge mutants of plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum were investigated in vitro. The dependence of the overall rate constant of reaction, k2, on ionic strength was investigated using laser flash photolysis. The rate constant of the wild-type reaction increased with ionic strength, indicating repulsion between the reaction partners. Removing a negative charge on plastocyanin (D44A) accelerated the reaction and made it independent of ionic strength; removing a positive charge adjacent to D44 (K53A) had little effect. Neutralizing and inverting the charge on R93 slowed the reaction down and increased the repulsion. Specific effects of MgCl2 were observed for mutants K53A, R93Q and R93E. Thermodynamic analysis of the transition state revealed positive activation entropies, suggesting partial desolvation of the interface in the transition state. In comparison with plants, plastocyanin and photosystem I of Phormidium laminosum react slowly at low ionic strength, whereas the two systems have similar rates in the range of physiological salt concentrations. We conclude that in P. laminosum, in contrast with plants in vitro, hydrophobic interactions are more important than electrostatics for the reactions of plastocyanin, both with photosystem I (this paper) and with cytochrome f[Schlarb-Ridley, B.G., Bendall, D.S. & Howe, C.J. (2002) Biochemistry41, 3279-3285]. We discuss the implications of this conclusion for the divergent evolution of cyanobacterial and plant plastocyanins.     

Role of charges on cytochrome f from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum in its interaction with plastocyanin

The role of charge on the surface of cytochrome f from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum in the reaction with plastocyanin was investigated in vitro using site-directed mutagenesis. Charge was neutralized at five acidic residues individually and introduced at a residue close to the interface between the two proteins. The effects on the kinetics of the reaction were measured using stopped-flow spectrophotometry, and the midpoint potentials of the mutant proteins were determined. The dependence of the bimolecular rate constant of reaction, k(2), on ionic strength was determined for the reactions of the cytochrome f mutants with wild-type and mutant forms of plastocyanin. Double mutant cycle analysis was carried out to probe for the presence of specific electrostatic interactions. The effects of mutations on Cyt f were smaller than those seen previously for mutants of plastocyanin [Schlarb-Ridley, B. G. et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 3279-3285]. One specific short-range interaction between charged residues of wild-type plastocyanin (Arg93) and wild-type cytochrome f (Asp63) was identified. The kinetic evidence from this study and that of Schlarb-Ridley et al., 2002, appears to conflict with the NMR structure of the P. laminosum complex, which suggests the absence of electrostatic interactions in the final complex [Crowley, P. et al. (2001) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 10444-10453]. The most likely explanation of the apparent paradox is that the overall rate is diffusion controlled and that electrostatics specifically influence the encounter complex and not the reaction complex.     

The role of individual lysine residues in the basic patch on turnip cytochrome f for electrostatic interactions with plastocyanin in vitro.

The role of electrostatic interactions in determining the rate of electron transfer between cytochrome f and plastocyanin has been examined in vitro with mutants of turnip cytochrome f and mutants of pea and spinach plastocyanins. Mutation of lysine residues Lys58, Lys65 and Lys187 of cytochrome f to neutral or acidic residues resulted in decreased binding constants and decreased rates of electron transfer to wild-type pea plastocyanin. Interaction of the cytochrome f mutant K187E with the pea plastocyanin mutant D51K gave a further decrease in electron transfer rate, indicating that a complementary charge pair at these positions could not compensate for the decreased overall charge on the proteins. Similar results were obtained with the interaction of the cytochrome f mutant K187E with single, double and triple mutants of residues in the acidic patches of spinach plastocyanin. These results suggest that the lysine residues of the basic patch on cytochrome f are predominantly involved in long-range electrostatic interactions with plastocyanin. However, analysis of the data using thermodynamic cycles provided evidence for the interaction of Lys187 of cytochrome f with Asp51, Asp42 and Glu43 of plastocyanin in the complex, in agreement with a structural model of a cytochrome f-plastocyanin complex determined by NMR.     

A Brownian dynamics study of the interaction of Phormidium laminosum plastocyanin with Phormidium laminosum cytochrome f

The interaction of Phormidium laminosum plastocyanin (PC) with P. laminosum cytochrome f (cyt f) was studied using Brownian dynamics (BD) simulations. Few complexes and a low rate of electron transfer were observed for wild-type PC. Increasing the positive electrostatic field on PC by the addition of a Zn(2+) ion in the neighborhood of D44 and D45 on PC (as found in crystal structure of plastocyanin) increased the number of complexes formed and the calculated rates of electron transfer as did PC mutations D44A, D45A, E54A, and E57A. Mutations of charged residues on Phormidium PC and Phormidium cyt f were used to map binding sites on both proteins. In both the presence and absence of the Zn(2+) ion, the following residues on PC interact with cyt f: D44, D45, K6, D79, R93, and K100 that lie in a patch just below H92 and Y88 and D10, E17, and E70 located on the upper portion of the PC molecule. In the absence of the Zn(2+) ion, K6 and K35 on the top of the PC molecule also interact with cyt f. Cyt f residues involved in binding PC, in the absence of the Zn(2+) ion, include E165, D187, and D188 that are located on the small domain of cyt f. The orientation of PC in the complexes was quite random in accordance with NMR results. In the presence of the Zn(2+) ion, K53 and E54 in the lower patch of the PC molecule also interact with cyt f and PC interacts with E86, E95, and E123 on the large domain of cyt f. Also, the orientation of PC in the complexes was much more uniform than in the absence of the Zn(2+) ion. The difference may be due to both the larger electrostatic field and the greater asymmetry of the charge distribution on PC observed in the presence of the Zn(2+) ion. Hydrophobic interactions were also observed suggesting a model of cyt f-PC interactions in which electrostatic forces bring the two molecules together but hydrophobic interactions participate in stabilizing the final electron-transfer-active dock.     

Role of electrostatics in the interaction between cytochrome f and plastocyanin of the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum

The role of charged residues on the surface of plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum in the reaction with soluble cytochrome f in vitro was studied using site-directed mutagenesis. The charge on each of five residues on the eastern face of plastocyanin was neutralized and/or inverted, and the effect of the mutation on midpoint potentials was determined. The dependence of the overall rate constant of reaction, k(2), on ionic strength was investigated using stopped-flow spectrophotometry. Removing negative charges (D44A or D45A) accelerated the reaction and increased the dependence on ionic strength, whereas removing positive charges slowed it down. Two mutations (K46A, K53A) each almost completely abolished any influence of ionic strength on k(2), and three mutations (R93A, R93Q, R93E) each converted electrostatic attraction into repulsion. At low ionic strength, wild type and all mutants showed an inhibition which might be due to changes in the interaction radius as a consequence of ionic strength dependence of the Debye length or to effects on the rate constant of electron transfer, k(et). The study shows that the electrostatics of the interaction between plastocyanin and cytochrome f of P. laminosum in vitro are not optimized for k(2). Whereas electrostatics are the major contributor to k(2) in plants [Kannt, A., et al. (1996) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1277, 115-126], this role is taken by nonpolar interactions in the cyanobacterium, leading to a remarkably high rate at infinite ionic strength (3.2 x 10(7) M(-1) s(-1)).     

The specificity in the interaction between cytochrome f and plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 is mainly determined by the copper protein

The plastocyanin-cytochrome f complex from Nostoc exhibits relevant structural differences when compared with the homologous complexes from other cyanobacteria and plants, with electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions being differently involved in each case. Here, five negatively charged residues of a recombinant form of cytochrome f from Nostoc have been replaced with either neutral or positively charged residues, and the effects of mutations on the kinetics of electron transfer to wild-type and mutant forms of plastocyanin have been measured by laser flash absorption spectroscopy. Cytochrome f mutants with some negative charges replaced with neutral residues exhibit an apparent electron transfer rate constant with wild-type plastocyanin similar to or slightly higher than that of the wild-type species, whereas the mutants with negative charges replaced with positive residues exhibit a significantly lower reactivity. Taken together, these results indicate that the effects of neutralizing residues at the electrostatically charged patch of cytochrome f are smaller than those previously observed for mutants of plastocyanin, thus suggesting that it is the copper protein which determines the specificity of the electrostatic interaction with the heme protein. Moreover, cross reactions between mutants of both proteins reveal the presence of some short-range specific electrostatic interactions. Our findings also make evident the fact that in Nostoc the main contribution to the electrostatic nature of the complex is provided by the small domain of cytochrome f.     

Laser flash-induced kinetic analysis of cytochrome f oxidation by wild-type and mutant plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119

Oxidation of the soluble, truncated form of cytochrome f by wild-type and mutant species of plastocyanin has been analyzed by laser flash absorption spectroscopy in the cyanobacterium Nostoc (formerly, Anabaena) sp. PCC 7119. At low ionic strengths, the apparent electron transfer rate constant of cytochrome f oxidation by wild-type plastocyanin is 1.34 x 10(4) s(-)(1), a value much larger than those determined for the same proteins from other organisms. Upon site-directed mutagenesis of specific residues at the plastocyanin interaction area, the rate constant decreases in all cases yet to varying extents. The only exception is the D54K variant, which exhibits a higher reactivity toward cytochrome f. In most cases, the reaction rate constant decreases monotonically with an increase in ionic strength. The observed changes in the reaction mechanism and rate constants are in agreement with the location of the mutated residues at the interface area, as well as with the peculiar orientation of the two partners within the Nostoc plastocyanin-cytochrome f transient complex, whose NMR structure has been determined recently. Furthermore, the experimental data herein reported match well the kinetic behavior exhibited by the same set of plastocyanin mutants when acting as donors of electrons to photosystem I [Molina-Heredia, F. P., et al. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 601-605], thus indicating that the copper protein uses the same surface areas-one hydrophobic and the other electrostatic-to interact with both cytochrome f and photosystem I.     

Structure of the complex between plastocyanin and cytochrome f from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 as determined by paramagnetic NMR. The balance between electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions within the transient complex determines the relative orientation of the two proteins

The complex between cytochrome f and plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Nostoc has been characterized by NMR spectroscopy. The binding constant is 16 mM(-1), and the lifetime of the complex is much less than 10 ms. Intermolecular pseudo-contact shifts observed for the plastocyanin amide nuclei, caused by the heme iron, as well as the chemical-shift perturbation data were used as the sole experimental restraints to determine the orientation of plastocyanin relative to cytochrome f with a precision of 1.3 angstroms. The data show that the hydrophobic patch surrounding tyrosine 1 in cytochrome f docks the hydrophobic patch of plastocyanin. Charge complementarities are found between the rims of the respective recognition sites of cytochrome f and plastocyanin. Significant differences in the relative orientation of both proteins are found between this complex and those previously reported for plants and Phormidium, indicating that electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions are balanced differently in these complexes.     

Chemical modification of spinach plastocyanin using 4-chloro-3,5-dinitrobenzoic acid: characterization of four singly-modified forms

Chemical modification of plastocyanin was carried out using 4-chloro-3,5-dinitrobenzoic acid, which has the effect of replacing positive charges on amino groups with negatively charged carboxyl groups. Four singly-modified forms were obtained which were separated using anion exchange FPLC. The four forms were modified at the N-terminal valine and at lysines 54, 71 and 77. The rates of reaction with mammalian cytochrome c were increased for all four modified plastocyanins. In contrast, the rates of reaction with cytochrome f were inhibited for the forms modified at residues 1, 54 and 77, whereas no effect was observed for the form modified at residue 71. Modification had no effect on either the midpoint redox potential or the reaction with K3Fe(CN)6. These results are consistent with a model in which charged residues on plastocyanin located at or near the binding site for cytochrome f recognize the positively-charged binding site on cytochrome f. In contrast, charged residues located at points on plastocyanin distant from the cytochrome f binding site recognize the net negative charge on the cytochrome f molecule. Based on these considerations, Glu-68 may be within the interaction sphere of cytochrome f, suggesting that cytochrome f may donate electrons to plastocyanin at either Tyr-83 or His-87.     

Expression of plastocyanin and cytochrome f of the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum in Escherichia coli and Paracoccus denitrificans and the role of leader peptides.

The gene for plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum was successfully expressed in Escherichia coli. Expression of the gene for cytochrome f resulted in the production of holocytochrome f in the periplasmic space of E. coli, but the yield was low. Expression in Paracoccus denitrificans yielded no holoprotein. When the region encoding the cytochrome f leader sequence was replaced with more typical bacterial leader sequences (those from the P. laminosum plastocyanin gene and the Paracoccus versutus cytochrome c-550 gene), much higher yields were consistently obtained in both species. Overexpressed proteins were compared to those isolated from P. laminosum and found to be identical in mass, isoelectric point, redox midpoint potential and (for plastocyanin) 1H-NMR spectrum.     

Relation between interface properties and kinetics of electron transfer in the interaction of cytochrome f and plastocyanin from plants and the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum

Cytochrome f and plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Phormidium laminosum react an order of magnitude faster than their counterparts from chloroplasts when long-range electrostatic interactions have been screened out by high salt concentration [Schlarb-Ridley, B. G., et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 3279-3285]. To investigate the relative contributions of the reaction partners to these differences, the reactions of turnip cytochrome f with P. laminosum plastocyanin and P. laminosum cytochrome f with pea plastocyanin were examined. Exchanging one of the plant reaction partners with the corresponding cyanobacterial protein nearly abolished electron transfer at low ionic strength but increased the rate at high ionic strength. This increase was larger for P. laminosum cytochrome f than for P. laminosumplastocyanin. To identify molecular features of P. laminosum cytochrome f that contribute to the increase, the effect of mutations in the N-terminal heme-shielding peptide on the reaction with P. laminosum plastocyanin was determined. Phenylalanine-3 was converted to valine and tryptophan-4 to phenylalanine or leucine. The mutations lowered the rate constant at 0.1 M ionic strength by factors of 0.71 for F4V, 0.42 for W4F, and 0.63 for W4L while introducing little change in the shape of the ionic strength dependence curve. When the N-terminal tetrapeptide (sequence YPFW) was converted into that found in the chloroplast of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (YPVF), the reaction was slowed further (factor of 0.26). The N-terminal heme-shielding peptide was found to be responsible for 75% of the kinetic differences between cytochrome f from chloroplasts and the cyanobacterium when electrostatic interactions were eliminated.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of cytochrome c6 from Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. The heme protein possesses a negatively charged area that may be isofunctional with the acidic patch of plastocyanin

This paper reports the first site-directed mutagenesis analysis of any cytochrome c6, a heme protein that performs the same function as the copper-protein plastocyanin in the electron transport chain of photosynthetic organisms. Photosystem I reduction by the mutants of cytochrome c6 from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 has been studied by laser flash absorption spectroscopy. Their kinetic efficiency and thermodynamic properties have been compared with those of plastocyanin mutants from the same organism. Such a comparative study reveals that aspartates at positions 70 and 72 in cytochrome c6 are located in an acidic patch that may be isofunctional with the well known "south-east" patch of plastocyanin. Calculations of surface electrostatic potential distribution in the mutants of cytochrome c6 and plastocyanin indicate that the changes in protein reactivity depend on the surface electrostatic potential pattern rather than on the net charge modification induced by mutagenesis. Phe-64, which is close to the heme group and may be the counterpart of Tyr-83 in plastocyanin, does not appear to be involved in the electron transfer to photosystem I. In contrast, Arg-67, which is at the edge of the cytochrome c6 acidic area, seems to be crucial for the interaction with the reaction center.     

Surface interactions in the complex between cytochrome f and the E43Q/D44N and E59K/E60Q plastocyanin double mutants as determined by 1H-NMR chemical shift analysis

A combination of site-directed mutagenesis and NMR chemical shift perturbation analysis of backbone and side-chain protons has been used to characterize the transient complex of the photosynthetic redox proteins plastocyanin and cytochrome f. To elucidate the importance of charged residues on complex formation, the complex of cytochrome f and E43Q/D44N or E59K/E60Q spinach plastocyanin double mutants was studied by full analysis of the (1)H chemical shifts by use of two-dimensional homonuclear NMR spectra. Both mutants show a significant overall decrease in chemical shift perturbations compared with wild-type plastocyanin, in agreement with a large decrease in binding affinity. Qualitatively, the E43Q/D44N mutant showed a similar interaction surface as wild-type plastocyanin. The interaction surface in the E59K/E60Q mutant was distinctly different from wild type. It is concluded that all four charged residues contribute to the affinity and that residues E59 and E60 have an additional role in fine tuning the orientation of the proteins in the complex.     

The interactions of cyanobacterial cytochrome c6 and cytochrome f,characterized by NMR

During oxygenic photosynthesis, cytochrome c(6) shuttles electrons between the membrane-bound complexes cytochrome bf and photosystem I. Complex formation between Phormidium laminosum cytochrome f and cytochrome c(6) from both Anabaena sp. PCC 7119 and Synechococcus elongatus has been investigated by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Chemical-shift perturbation analysis reveals a binding site on Anabaena cytochrome c(6), which consists of a predominantly hydrophobic patch surrounding the heme substituent, methyl 5. This region of the protein was implicated previously in the formation of the reactive complex with photosytem I. In contrast to the results obtained for Anabaena cytochrome c(6), there is no evidence for specific complex formation with the acidic cytochrome c(6) from Synechococcus. This remarkable variability between analogous cytochromes c(6) supports the idea that different organisms utilize distinct mechanisms of photosynthetic intermolecular electron transfer.     

Comparative analysis of plastocyanin–cytochrome f complex formation in higher plants,green algae and cyanobacteria

Mechanisms of the complex formation between plastocyanin and cytochrome f in higher plants (Spinacia oleracea and Brassica rapa), green microalgae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and two species of cyanobacteria (Phormidium laminosum and Nostoc sp.) were investigated using combined Brownian and molecular dynamics simulations and hierarchical cluster analysis. In higher plants and green algae, electrostatic interactions force plastocyanin molecule close to the heme of cytochrome f. In the subsequent rotation of plastocyanin molecule around the point of electrostatic contact in the vicinity of cytochrome f, copper (Cu) atom approaches cytochrome heme forming a stable configuration where cytochrome f molecule behaves as a rather rigid body without conformational changes. In Nostoc plastocyanin molecule approaches cytochrome f in a different orientation (head‐on) where the stabilization of the plastocyanin–cytochrome f complex is accompanied by the conformational changes of the G188E189D190 loop that stabilizes the whole complex. In cyanobacterium P. laminosum, electrostatic preorientation of the approaching molecules was not detected, thus indicating that random motions rather than long‐range electrostatic interactions are responsible for the proper mutual orientation. We demonstrated that despite the structural similarity of the investigated electron transport proteins in different photosynthetic organisms, the complexity of molecular mechanisms of the complex formation increases in the following sequence: non‐heterocystous cyanobacteria – heterocystous cyanobacteria – green algae – flowering plants.     

Transient binding of plastocyanin to its physiological redox partners modifies the copper site geometry

The transient complexes of plastocyanin with cytochrome f and photosystem I are herein used as excellent model systems to investigate how the metal sites adapt to the changes in the protein matrix in transient complexes that are involved in redox reactions. Thus, both complexes from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 (former Anabaena sp. PCC 7119) have been analysed by X-ray absorption spectroscopy. Our data are consistent with a significant distortion of the trigonal pyramidal geometry of the Cu coordination sphere when plastocyanin binds to cytochrome f, no matter their redox states are. The resulting tetrahedral geometry shows a shortening of the distance between Cu and the S(delta) atom of its ligand Met-97, with respect to the crystallographic structure of free plastocyanin. On the other hand, when plastocyanin binds to photosystem I instead of cytochrome f, the geometric changes are not significant but a displacement in charge distribution around the metal centre can be observed. Noteworthy, the electronic density around the Cu atom increases or decreases when oxidised plastocyanin binds to cytochrome f or photosystem I, respectively, thus indicating that the protein matrix affects the electron transfer between the two partners during their transient interaction.     

Crystal structures of wild-type and mutant plastocyanins from a higher plant, Silene

Plastocyanin functions as an electron carrier between the cytochrome b6f complex and photosystem I. The crystal structures of the wild-type and E43K/D44K double mutant from the higher plant, Silene, have been determined at 2.0 and 1.75 A resolution, respectively. The wild-type plastocyanin comprises two monomers per asymmetric unit, one of which shows the unusually great distance between the copper ion and the Ndelta1 atom of H87 because of the hydrogen bond network formation between H87 and symmetry-related G10. The root mean square deviation for Ca atoms between the wild-type and mutant plastocyanins is 0.44 A, however, the electrostatic potential maps of their molecular surfaces are remarkably different. The low electron-transfer rate in the E43K/D44K mutant results from the hindrance of electrostatic interactions, not from the structural change due to the mutation.     

Kinetic studies on a cross-linked complex between plastocyanin cytochrome f

A cross-linked complex between plastocyanin and cytochrome f was prepared by incubation in the presence of a water soluble carbodiimide and its kinetic properties were studied. The optical spectra, oxidation-reduction potentials and isoelectric pH of plastocyanin and cytochrome f did not change upon the formation of the cross-linked complex. Studies on the ionic strength effect on the electron transfer rate from cross-linked plastocyanin to ferricyanide indicated that the negative charge on the reaction site of plastocyanin was masked upon the cross-linking. It was also suggested that the sign of the net charge near the cytochrome f heme edge changed from positive to negative upon the cross-linking. On the other hand, electrostatic interactions between cross-linked plastocyanin and P700 seemed to be essentially the same as those in the case of native plastocyanin, although the rate of electron transfer from cross-linked plastocyanin to P700 was severely reduced. We also measured the intra-complex electron transfer from cytochrome f to plastocyanin. This suggested that the covalently cross-linked complex is a valid model of the electron transfer encounter complex. Based on these results, the reaction sites of plastocyanin with P700 and cytochrome f were discussed.