Analysis of organelle genomes in a somatic hybrid derived from cytoplasmic male-sterile Brassica oleracea and atrazine-resistant B. campestris

Summary An atrazine-resistant, male-fertile Brassica napus plant was synthesized by fusion of protoplasts from the diploid species B. oleracea and B. campestris. Leaf protoplasts from B. oleracea var. italica carrying the Ogura male-sterile cytoplasm derived from Raphanus sativus were fused with etiolated hypocotyl protoplasts of atrazine-resistant B. campestris. The selection procedure was based on the inability of B. campestris protoplasts to regenerate in the media used, and the reduction of light-induced growth of B. oleracea tissue by atrazine. A somatic hybrid plant that differed in morphology from both B. oleracea and B. campestris was regenerated on medium containing 50 M atrazine. Its chromosome number was 36–38, approximately that of B. napus. Furthermore, nuclear ribosomal DNA from this hybrid was a mixture of both parental rDNAs. Southern blot analyses of chloroplast DNA and an assay involving tetrazolium blue indicated that the hybrid contained atrazine-resistant B. campestris chloroplasts. The hybrid's mitochondrial genome was recombinant, containing fragments unique to each parent, as well as novel fragments carrying putative crossover points. Although the plant was female-sterile, it was successfully used to pollinate B. napus.     

Atrazine-resistant cauliflower obtained by somatic hybridization between Brassica oleracea and ATR-B. napus

Summary Somatic hybridization between Brassica oleracea ssp. botrytis (cauliflower, 2n=18), carrying the Ogura (R1) male-sterile cytoplasm and B. napus (2n= 38), carrying a male-fertile, atrazine-resistant (ATR) cytoplasm, yielded three hybrids (2n=56) and six cauliflower cybrids (2n=18), which were selected for resistance to the herbicide in vitro. The hybrids and cybrids were male fertile and self-compatible. They contained both chloroplasts and mitochondria from the ATR cytoplasm. We found no evidence for mtDNA recombination in any of the regenerated plants. Selfed progeny of the B. oleracea atrazine-resistant cybrids were evaluated for tolerance to the herbicide in the field. Resistant plants exposed to 0.56–4.48 kg/ha (0.5–4.0 pounds/acre) atrazine in the soil showed no damage at any herbicide level, whereas plants of a susceptible alloplasmic line were severely damaged at the lowest level of herbicide application and killed at all higher levels. These atrazine-resistant cauliflower may have potential horticultural use, especially in fields where atrazine carry over is a serious problem.     

Cytoplasmic male sterility in rapeseed (Brassica napus L.)

Summary Restriction patterns of chloroplast (cp) and mitochondrial (mt) DNA in Brassica napus rapeseed reveal the alloplasmic nature of cytoplasmic male sterility in this crop. Both the Shiga and Bronowski systems probably exploit cytoplasmic diversity in B. napus cultivars arising from introgression of cytoplasm from the other rapeseed species, B. campestris. Nuclear genes specific to these systems do not cause sterility in maintainers (Bronowski and Isuzu-natane) because they have a campestris cytoplasm, but give rise to sterility in napus cytoplasms. In the course of hybridization to napus cultivars a line with the triazine resistant cytoplasm (a campestris cytoplasm) has undergone an alteration in the mt genome rendering its restriction pattern more similar than previously to that of napus. The alteration may be an inversion between 7.2 and 3.4 kb in length.     

Synthesis of Ogura male sterile rapeseed (Brassica napus L.) with cold tolerance by protoplast fusion and effects of atrazine resistance on seed yield

Twenty-one cold-tolerant, male sterile Brassica napus somatic hybrids were produced by protoplast fusion. The fusion partners were a coldsensitive, Ogura cytoplasmic male sterile cauliflower inbred (B. oleracea var. botrytis inbred NY7642A) and a cold-tolerant, fertile canola-type B. rapa cv. Candle. Hybridity was confirmed by morphology, isozyme expression, flow cytometry, and DNA hybridization. Organellar analyses revealed a very strong bias for Brassica over Raphanus chloroplasts. Cold tolerance was confirmed by cold chamber studies and chloroplast DNA analyses. Good female fertility with 21.4 ± 3.1 seeds/pod was observed in the field using natural pollination vectors. Total seed yield was significantly greater for the atrazine-sensitive somatic hybrids produced in this study than for atrazine-resistant isolines.Abbreviations CMS cytoplasmic male sterility - IA iodoacetate - cpDNA chloroplast DNA     

Atrazine-resistant cytoplasmic male-sterile-nigra broccoli obtained by protoplast fusion between cytoplasmic male-sterile Brassica oleracea and atrazine-resistant Brassica campestris

Summary By using restriction endonuclease digestion patterns, the degree of intraspecific polymorphism of mitochondrial DNA in four diploid species of wheat and Aegilops, Ae. speltoides, Ae. longissima, Ae. squarrosa, and Triticum monococcum, was assessed. The outbreeding Ae. speltoides was found to possess the highest degree of variability, the mean number of nucleotide substitutions among conspecific individuals being 0.027 substitutions per nucleotide site. A very low degree of mtDNA variation was detected among Ae. longissima accessions, with most of the enzyme-probe combinations exhibiting uniform hybridization patterns. The mean number of substitutions among Ae. longissima individuals was 0.001 substitutions per nucleotide site. The domesticated diploid wheat T. monococcum var. monococcum and its conspecific variant T. monococcum var. boeoticum seem to lack mitochondrial DNA variability altogether. Thus, the restriction fragment pattern can be used as a characteristic identifier of the T. monococcum cytoplasmic genome. Similarly, Ae. squarrosa accessions were found to be genetically uniform. A higher degree of variation among accessions is observed when noncoding sequences are used as probes then when adjacent coding regions are used. Thus, while noncoding regions may contain regulatory functions, they are subject to less stringent functional constraints than protein-coding regions. Intraspecific variation in mitochondrial DNA correlates perfectly with the nuclear variability detected by using protein electrophoretic characters. This correlation indicates that both types of variation are selectively neutral and are affected only by the effective population size.     

Transfer of Ogu cytoplasmic male sterility to Brassica juncea and improvement of the male sterile line through somatic cell fusion

Male sterility conferred by ogu cytoplasm of Raphanus sativus has been transferred to Brassica juncea cv RLM 198 from male-sterile B. napus through repeated backcrossing and selection. The male-sterile B. juncea is, however, highly chlorotic and late. It has low female (seed) fertility and small contorted pods. To rectify these defects, protoplasts of the male sterile were fused with normal RLM 198 (green, self fertile). Four dark green, completely male-sterile plants were obtained and identified as putative cybrids. All the plants were backcrossed three times with RLM 198. Mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA analysis of backcross progeny confirmed hybridity of the cytoplasm. The restriction pattern of the chloroplast DNA of progeny plants of three cybrids (Og 1, Og 2, Og 3) was similar to that of the green self-fertile RLM 198 and indicated that the correction of chlorosis resulted from chloroplast substitution. The chloroplast DNA of the lone progeny plant of the fourth cybrid (Og 10) could not be analyzed because the plant was stunted and had only a few leaves. When total cellular DNA was probed with mitochondrial probes coxI and atpA it was found that the cybrids had recombinant mitochondria. The chlorosis-corrected plants were early flowering and had vastly improved seed fertility.     

The combination of polima cms and cytoplasmic triazine resistance in Brassica napus

Summary Protoplast fusion was used to combine cytoplasmic triazine resistance (ctr) and Polima type cytoplasmic male sterility (cms) in Brassica napus. The cybrids produced constitute the major biological input required for the production of commercial single-cross hybrid rapeseed bearing cytoplasmic triazine resistance. The results also indicate that Polima cms is associated with the mitochondrial genome.     

Synthesis of Brassica oleracea/Brassica napus somatic hybrid plants with novel organeile DNA compositions

Summary Broccoli (Brassica oleracea L. italica) hypocotyl protoplasts were fused with mesophyll protoplasts of two B. napus lines, one carrying the Ogura (ogu) cms cytoplasm, and the other carrying a hybrid cytoplasm consisting of ogu mitochondria combined with triazine-tolerance-conferring chloroplasts from ctr cytoplasm. Two male-sterile somatic hybrids were recovered from the fusion of broccoli protoplasts with those of ogu/ctr cybrid B. napus. The ogu mtDNAs and ctr cpDNAs were not altered in these hybrids. Four male-sterile plants were recovered from the somatic hybridization of broccoli with ogu cms B. napus. Three of these possessed mitochondrial genomes that appeared to have resulted from recombination between the ogu and normal B. oleracea (ole) mtDNAs, while the fourth possessed an unrearranged ogu mtDNA. All four of these plants had B. oleracea cpDNA, and none displayed the seedling chlorosis associated with ogu chloroplasts. Most of the plants recovered from these fusions had the chromosome number expected of B. oleracea + B. napus hybrids (2n = 56). The novel cytoplasms may prove to be useful for the molecular analysis of Brassica cms and for the production of hybrid Brassica.     

Transfer of the Brassica tournefortii cytoplasm to B. napus for the production of cytoplasmic male sterile B. napus

The donor-recipient fusion method was used to combine the cytoplasm of Brassica lournefortii with the nucleus of B. napus for the production of cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) plants. X-ray-irradiated mesophyll protoplasts of B. tournefortii were fused with iodoacetamide (lOA)-inactivated hypocotye protoplasts of B. napus . Selective conditions of IOA concentrations and X-ray doses were determined, which resulted in recovery of fusion products and inhibition of further growth of unfused parental cells. In total, 54 plants were obtained from different fusion experiments, of which 25 were verified as cybrids or partial hybrids. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analyses using 5 mitochondrial gene probes revealed that 20 of the 25 fusion-derived plants had mtDNA either identical, or with varying degrees of similarity, to B. lournefortii . These plants were classified into four groups on the basis of pollen viability and number. Seven plants were categorised as male sterile since they did not produce pollen or had non-viable pollen. Of the male sterile plants, five had a mtDNA pattern identical to B. tournefortii and a nuclear DNA content corresponding to B. napus . The nuclear-mito-chondrial constitution of these plants thus indicates that the combination of B. tournefortii cytoplasm with the B. napus nucleus results in CMS. Furthermore, mtDNA analysis of the two additional male sterile plants which displayed a rearranged mtDNA, revealed that the only mtDNA similarity shared among all male sterile plants was specific for B. tournefortii atp6 pattern. This indicates that the atp6 region of B. tournefortii may be involved in the expression of CMS.     

Production of new CMS Brassica oleracea by transfer of `Anand' cytoplasm from B. rapa through protoplast fusion

New types of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in Brassica oleracea would be useful for F₁ hybrid seed production. The `Anand' cytoplasm derives from the wild species B. tournefortii. Rapid cycling stocks of B. rapa and B. oleracea were used in cybridization experiments as donor and recipient of `Anand' (=`tour') CMS, respectively. Prior to fusion with PEG, donor protoplasts were inactivated with 30 krad γ-rays and recipient ones with 3 mM iodoacetate, respectively. No calli were obtained from the pre-treated protoplasts. The frequency of shoot regeneration was 21–43% in untreated B. oleracea controls, but only 0–0.5% in `Anand' B. rapa. Putative cybrids were regenerated from about 3% of the calli from fused protoplasts. Regenerated plants were analyzed for nuclear DNA content, plant and flower morphology, pollen production, female fertility, cold tolerance, and organelle composition. Eighty-one percent of the regenerated controls and 63% of fusion-derived plants were diploid. The rest showed DNA contents corresponding to 2x–4x, 4x, or higher ploidy levels, presumably due to somatic doubling in vitro and/or fusions in which the donor nucleus was not completely eliminated. Sixty-four percent of the cybrids had stamens and petals varying in size and shape and were male-sterile, with indehiscent anthers. Their phenotype was otherwise similar to that of B. oleracea. The remaining plants had normal flowers and were male-fertile. Data from crosses with fertile pollinators indicated good female fertility in some of the sterile lines, both after hand and insect pollinations in cages. Mitochondrial (mt) segregation in the cybrids was slightly biased towards `Anand' mitochondria, and the presence of `Anand' mtDNA fragments was strongly associated with male sterility. Evidence of mtDNA rearrangements was obtained in some cybrids. Segregation of chloroplasts was slightly biased towards B. oleracea. The presence of `Anand' chloroplasts with a B. oleracea nucleus did not result in cold temperature chlorosis, as seen in `Ogura' CMS plants. Received: 22 February 1996 / Accepted: 10 May 1996     

Linkage between an isozyme marker and a restorer gene in radish cytoplasmic male sterility of rapeseed (Brassica napus L.)

Summary Co-segregation studies of isozyme markers and male fertility restoration showed that a restorer gene from radish was introduced into rapeseed along with an isozyme marker (Pgi-2). The radish chromosome segment carrying these genes was introgressed into rapeseed through homoeologous recombination, substituting for some of the rapeseed alleles. By crossing heterozygous restored plants to male-sterile lines and to maintainers, tight linkage was found between the restorer gene and the marker. The recombination fraction was estimated at 0.25 ± 0.02%. Although few restored plants lacked the radish isozyme marker, it was still possible to distinguish male-fertile from male-sterile plants by their PGI-2 patterns. Furthermore, homozygous and heterozygous restored plants could be separated by specific PGI-2 phenotypes. Thus, the Pgi-2 marker is now currently used in restorer breeding programs.     

Somatic hybridization between male sterile Nicotiana tabacum and N. glutinosa through protoplast fusion

Summary Protoplasts derived from suspension cultured cells of cytoplasmic male sterile Nicotiana tabacum (N. debneyi cytoplasm) and of fertile N. glutinosa were fused with the aid of polyethylene glycol (PEG). Out of 1,089 colonies developed from PEG-treated protoplasts, 29 restored whole plants.A somatic hybrid plant was selected on the basis of isoelectrofocusing analysis of Fraction I protein in leaves of regenerated plants. A newly created hybrid contained small subunits of both parents but only a N. glutinosa type large subunit.Male sterile character was conserved in a hybrid plant while leaf morphology was intermediate between the parents. By tobacco mosaic virus infection tests, the hybrid's leaves showed resistant symptoms, hypersensitive local lesions, which were due to N. glutinosa nuclear genome expression.Abbreviations PEG Polyethylene glycol - TMV Tobacco mosaic virus     

Microsporogenesis in a normal line and in the ogu cytoplasmic male-sterile line of Brassica napus

Summary Under an intermediate temperature regime (23° C/18° C; day/night), microsporogenesis in stamens of the ogu cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) line of Brassica napus terminated by the tetrad stage, although in some cases degeneration of the sporogenous tissue occurred prior to meiosis. In most cases the tetrads were collapsed and bounded by a sparse exine, but contained many organelles. Also, the tapetum in CMS anthers was abnormal and often highly vacuolated by the tetrad stage. Under low temperature conditions (18° C/15° C; day/night), neither microsporogenous nor tapetal tissues were observed. In the normal stamens, no differences were observed under different temperature regimes. In conjunction with the adjoining paper, this study demonstrates that temperature conditions strongly affect the cytological processes associated with microsporogenesis in the CMS anthers.     

Characterization of a partial male fertility derived from Ogura-cms in progeny of a resynthesized Brassica napus

Summary The inheritance of a partial male fertile phenotype in somatic hybrid B. napus plants that carried novel mtDNA was investigated over five backcross generations to B. napus Triton. The recurrent parent and the original somatic hybrid both contained chloroplasts resistant to atrazine. The F₁ population contained mainly plants that were partial fertile, and some of the plants differed in mtDNA. The partial fertility predominated in the progeny of each backcross generation, but fully male sterile and fertile plants were also obtained. However, the sterility/fertility of these latter plants was not stable; both the fully male sterile and the male fertile plants produced progeny that were again predominantly partial male fertile. This pattern of predominant partial fertility but occasional sterile and fertile plants persisted in different nuclear backgrounds. Neither the male sterility nor the male fertility could be fixed and made stable. Test crosses indicated that restorer genes were probably not associated with appearance of male fertile plants. The evidence indicates that the behavior of the partial male fertility is cytoplasmic, and probably controlled by the chondriome.     

Microsporogenesis in a normal line and in the ogu cytoplasmic male-sterile line of Brassica napus

Summary In the ogu cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) line of Brassica napus, stamen morphology was influenced by temperature conditions. Under a high temperature regime (27° C/23° C; day/ night) CMS stamens had a near-normal morphology, but microsporogenesis proceeded to a maximum of the microspore stage. However, compared to the normal stamens, the occurrence of sporopollenin-like deposits in the tapetum and deposition of exine on the microspores was sparse. Also, the tapetal cells of the CMS line were often highly vacuolate and failed to degenerate at the same stage as the normal. Ultrastructural changes in the mitochondrial matrix and cristae plus dilation of the endoplasmic reticulum, which occurred during development in sporogenous tissues of the normal line, were often lacking or mistimed in the mutant. Due to extensive variation, even between adjacent locules, the cytological differences between the normal and CMS anthers cannot be ascribed as the cause of male sterility in the ogu CMS line of B. napus, rather they may be the consequence of it.     

Asymmetric somatic hybrids of Brassica: partial transfer of B. campestris genome into B. oleracea by cell fusion

Summary To examine the possibility of producing asymmetric somatic hybrids of Brassica having a complete genome of one species and a part of the other, we fused inactivated B. oleracea protoplasts with X-irradiated B. campestris protoplasts. The plants obtained were studied with regard to their morphology, isozymes and chromosomes. The morphology of the hybrids was similar to B. oleracea in 9 out of 22 hybrids studied and the rest showed the intermediate phenotype of the parents. Analysis of three isozymes, leucine aminopeptidase, acid phosphatase and esterase indicated that ten hybrids lost B. campestris-specific bands in one or more of the three isozymes examined. The chromosome analysis showed that 90% of the hybrids were aneuploids. In addition, abnormal chromosomes were often found in root tip cells. These results suggested that the hybrids obtained were asymmetric in nature and resulted from elimination of B. campestris chromosomes by X-ray irradiation.     

Interspecific somatic hybridization between Brassica napus and Brassica hirta (Sinapis alba L.)

Summary Somatic hybridization between Brassica napus and B. hirta (or Sinapis alba) is described. No cybrid plant with B. napus nucleus exhibiting cytoplasmic male sterility was recovered. Somatic hybrids were identified morphologically and, for some of them, by cytological observations. They were also characterised by Southern hybridization of nuclear rDNA. Chloroplast and mitochondrial DNA restriction analysis showed that 2 plants out of 14 have B. hirta ctDNA, one the B. napus mtDNA and the other a hybrid. Nine possess B. napus ctDNA with a hybrid mtDNA. For six of them, mtDNA patterns present novel bands, suggesting intergenomic recombination during fusion. These hybrids will be included in the breeding program.     

A new cytoplasmic male sterile genotype in the sugar beet Beta vulgaris L.: a molecular analysis

Summary Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from fertile (N) and possibly new cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) genotypes was studied in the sugar beet Beta vulgaris L. It was found by restriction endonuclease analysis that BMC-CMS, a cytoplasm that was derived from the wild beet Beta maritima, contained a unique type of mtDNA which is distinguishable from both the N and S-CMS, the only other CMS genotype that is currently availabe in B. vulgaris L. The organization of three genes: coxI, coxII and cob, was analyzed by hybridization with heterologous probes from maize. These genes have a similar structure in N and BMC-CMS that is different from S-CMS. It is concluded that BMC-CMS is a novel CMS genotype in the sugar beet.     

Diploid Brassica napus somatic hybrids: characterization of nuclear and organellar DNA

Summary Five somatic hybrids between Brassica campestris and B. oleracea were obtained. Molecular, morphological and cytological information all suggest that the resynthesized B. napus plants were hybrids. All five plants were diploid (2n=38) and had mainly bivalents at meiosis. Seedset was low after selfing but normal after crossing with B. napus. Molecular proof of the hybrid nature of these plants was obtained by hybridization of a rDNA repeat to total DNA. Analysis of chloroplast DNA restriction patterns revealed that all hybrids had chloroplasts identical to the B. oleracea parent. The analysis of mitochondrial DNA indicated that three hybrids had restriction patterns identical to those of B. campestris, and the other two had restriction patterns similar to those of B. oleracea. The 11.3 kb plasmid present in mitochondria of the B. campestris parent was also found in mitochondria of all five hybrids. This suggests that the plasmid from a B. campestris type of mitochondria was transferred into mitochondria of a B. oleracea type.     

Direct transfer of a cold-tolerant Ogura male-sterile cytoplasm into cabbage (Brassica oleracea ssp. capitata) via protoplast fusion

Cold tolerant cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata) was produced by the fusion of leaf protoplasts from fertile cabbage and cold-tolerant Ogura CMS broccoli lines. The cabbage lines tested showed great variation in plant regeneration from unfused protoplasts; three with high regenerability were selected as the fusion partners. Several procedures for eliminating the nuclear DNA of the broccoli fusion partner were tested. Diploid cabbage plants were identified by flow cytometry and morphological characters. Gamma-irradiation (30 krad) was the most successful procedure; isolation of cytoplasts from broccoli leaf protoplasts, followed by gamma-irradiation of the cytoplast fraction, also produced diploids. UV-irradiation of the broccoli protoplasts was less effective. PCR using primers for an Ogura CMS-specific mitochondrial DNA sequence permitted the identification of cybrids likely to be CMS. Over 200 diploid plants with the CMS-specific sequence were obtained from 66 independent fusion products and three cabbage lines. Plants were ready for transfer into soil within 8 months after fusion. The plants identified as CMS by PCR produced male-sterile flowers. Our procedures permit the transfer of a desirable male-sterile cytoplasm into cabbage much more rapidly than conventional backcrossing procedures. Received: 4 June 1996 / Accepted: 2 August 1996