Properties of ionophore-resistant Bacteroides rurninicola enriched by cultivation in the presence of tetronasin

Bacteroides ruminicola M384 was grown in the presence of increasing concentrations of tetronasin, an ionophore that has been developed as a feed additive for ruminants. The resulting culture, B. ruminicola M384/Tn^R, was then maintained in medium containing 0.1 pg tetronasin/ml. Growth of the parent strain was eliminated by the addition of 0.1 ug tetronasin/ml, but the growth rate of B. ruminicola M384/Tn^R, which grew more slowly than the parent strain, was unaffected by adding tetronasin. Bacteroides ruminicola M384/Tn^R retained its resistance to tetronasin even after repeated subculture in the absence of the ionophore, suggesting that a mutation had occurred. The absence of plasmids in individual colonies of B. ruminicola M384/Tn^R implied that the mutation was chromosomal. Bacteroides ruminicola M384/Tn^R was also more resistant to the ionophores monensin and lasalocid and, to a lesser degree, to the antibiotic avoparcin than B. ruminicola M384. Binding of [¹⁴C]tetronasin to B. ruminicola M384/Tn^R was lower than binding of the ionophore to the parent stain, and this difference was eliminated by washing cells with EDTA. The peptidolytic activity of B. ruminicola M384 towards triphenylalanine ( M _r= 460) was unaffected in B. ruminicola M384/Tn^R, but the rate of breakdown of tetra-phenylalanine ( M _r= 607) was decreased. This difference was also abolished by EDTA. It was concluded that growth of B. ruminicola in the presence of tetronasin resulted in a mutation affecting the permeability of the cell envelope, such that permeation of tetronasin and molecules of a similar size ( M _r= 628) was decreased.     

Cleavage of di- and tripeptides by Prevotella ruminicola

The final step in the conversion of protein to amino acids by the common Gram-negative rumen bacterium, Prevotella (formerly Bacteroides) ruminicola , is the cleavage of di- and tripeptides. Dipeptidase and tripeptidase activities were predominantly cytoplasmic, and toluene treatment increased the rate of Ala2 and Ala3 hydrolysis by whole cells, suggesting that transport limited the rate of hydrolysis of extracellular di- and tripeptides. The hydrolysis of Ala2 and Ala3 by whole cells was not affected by protonophores, ionophores or dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, but Ala2 hydrolysis by EDTA-treated cells was inhibited by the Ca2+/H+ ionophore, tetronasin. Ala3 hydrolysis was not affected by protonophores or ionophores in EDTA-treated cells. The dipeptidase of strain M384 was inhibited > 99% by 1,10-phenanthroline and 39% by EDTA but not other protease inhibitors, consistent with the enzyme being a metalloprotease. Tripeptidase was insensitive to protease inhibitors, except for a 33% inhibition by EDTA. Cleavage of tripeptides occurred at the bond adjacent to the N-terminal amino acid. Distinct di-, tri- and oligopeptidase peaks were obtained by anion-exchange liquid chromatography of disrupted cells. Banding patterns on native PAGE using activity staining also indicated that P. ruminicola M384 had separate single dipeptidase and tripeptidase enzymes which hydrolysed a range of peptides. The dipeptidase of strain M384 was different from other strains of P. ruminicola: strains GA33 and B(1)4 had activities which ran at the same R(f); strain GA33 had another band of lower activity; strain 23 had two bands different from those of the other strains. The tripeptidases ran at the same R(f) for the different strains. Dipeptidase activity of all strains was inhibited by 1,10-phenanthroline on gels. Gel permeation chromatography indicated that the M(r) of the dipeptidases from strains M384 and B(1)4 were 115,000 and 114,500 respectively, and 112,500 and 121,500 for the corresponding tripeptidases. Thus the metabolism of small peptides by P. ruminicola involves separate permeases and intracellular peptidases for di- and tripeptides.     

The effect of tetronasin and monensin on fermentation, microbial numbers and the development of ionophore-resistant bacteria in the rumen

The Gram-negative rumen bacteria Fibrobacter succinogenes S85, Prevotella ruminicola M384 and Veillonella parvula L59 were grown in media containing successively increasing concentrations of the ionophores, monensin and tetronasin. All three species became more resistant to the ionophore with which they were grown. Increased resistance to one ionophore caused increased resistance to the other, and cross-resistance to another ionophore—lasalocid—and an antibiotic—avoparcin. Recovery of tetronasin-resistant bacteria from the rumen of monensin-fed sheep increased and vice versa, indicating that similar cross-resistance occurred in vivo.     

Production of branched-chain volatile fatty acids by certain anaerobic bacteria.

Net production of isobutyric acid, isovaleric acid, and 2-methylbutyric acid by cultures of Bacteroides ruminicola and Megasphaera elsdenii on media that contained Trypticase or casein hydrolysate continued (up to 5 days) after growth had ceased. Only trace quantities of these acids were produced in a medium that contained a mixture of amino acids that did not include the branched-chain amino acids. M. elsdenii produced increased quantities of the branched-chain fatty acids in a medium that contained Trypticase when glucose was reduced or eliminated from the culture medium. However, B. ruminicola produced increased quantities of branched-chain fatty acids and of phenylacetic acid from Trypticase when glucose was supplied at 3 mg/ml rather than at 1 mg/ml. Single strains of Streptococcus bovis, Selenomonas ruminantium, Bacteroides amylophilus, and Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens did not produce branched-chain fatty acids.     

Production of branched-chain volatile fatty acids by certain anaerobic bacteria

Net production of isobutyric acid, isovaleric acid, and 2-methylbutyric acid by cultures of Bacteroides ruminicola and Megasphaera elsdenii on media that contained Trypticase or casein hydrolysate continued (up to 5 days) after growth had ceased. Only trace quantities of these acids were produced in a medium that contained a mixture of amino acids that did not include the branched-chain amino acids. M. elsdenii produced increased quantities of the branched-chain fatty acids in a medium that contained Trypticase when glucose was reduced or eliminated from the culture medium. However, B. ruminicola produced increased quantities of branched-chain fatty acids and of phenylacetic acid from Trypticase when glucose was supplied at 3 mg/ml rather than at 1 mg/ml. Single strains of Streptococcus bovis, Selenomonas ruminantium, Bacteroides amylophilus, and Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens did not produce branched-chain fatty acids.     

Influence of 1,10-phenanthroline and its analogues, other chelators and transition metal ions on dipeptidase activity of the rumen bacterium, Prevotella ruminicola

Prevotella ruminicola plays a prominent role in the breakdown of peptides in the rumen, a process which contributes to excessive ammonia production and inefficient nitrogen retention in ruminants. Various metal ions and chelators were examined to assess how the metal ion-dependent dipeptidase activity of P. ruminicola M384 might be inhibited. Using sonicated extracts, Cu²⁺, Cr²⁺ and Hg²⁺ were most inhibitory, decreasing Ala₂ breakdown to 15, 15 and 5% of control activity, whereas Co²⁺, Mn²⁺ and Zn²⁺ stimulated activity by 189, 30 and 26%, respectively. The chelators, EDTA, EGTA, TPEN and 1,10-phenanthroline, were inhibitory, as were several phenanthroline analogues. Among the stereoisomers of 1,10-phenanthroline tested, derivatives methylated on C-2 and C-9 were less effective than the parent molecule, but 3,4,7,8-tetramethyl,10-phenanthroline (TMP) was more inhibitory. Titration of the most effective inhibitors showed that EDTA, TPEN and TMP had similar potency and were effective at 0.1 mmol l⁻¹ and above. Thus some metal ions and chelators are potent inhibitors of P. ruminicola dipeptidase, although they are unlikely to be sufficiently specific to peptide metabolism to be useful in vivo.     

Evidence for natural transfer of a tetracycline resistance gene between bacteria from the human colon and bacteria from the bovine rumen.

Previously, we demonstrated conjugal transfer of a specially constructed shuttle vector, pRDB5, from the human colonic anaerobe Bacteroides uniformis to the ruminal anaerobe Prevotella (Bacteroides) ruminicola B(1)4. We have now shown that naturally occurring gene transfer elements in Bacteroides species and Prevotella ruminicola can also be transferred between these two genera. A self-transmissible chromosomal element originally found in a clinical isolate of Bacteroides fragilis (Tcr Emr 12256) was transferred from B. uniformis 0061 to P. ruminicola B(1)4 and from P. ruminicola B(1)4 back to B. uniformis or to another human colonic species, Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron. Similarly, a conjugative plasmid (pRRI4) originally found in P. ruminicola 223 was transferred from P. ruminicola B(1)4 to B. uniformis or B. thetaiotaomicron. pRRI4 could be transferred from the colonic Bacteroides species only if the donor strain contained the Tcr Emr 12256 element in its chromosome. These results show that transfer of naturally occurring elements can be demonstrated under laboratory conditions. Evidence that such transfers may actually have occurred in nature came from our finding that the tetracycline resistance (Tcr) gene on the P. ruminicola plasmid pRRI4 hybridized on high-stringency Southern blots with the Tcr gene found on the Bacteroides Tcr elements. The presence of the same gene in such distantly related genera of bacteria is most likely to have occurred as a result of horizontal transfer.     

Peptidases of the rumen bacterium, Prevotella ruminicola

Prevotella (formerly Bacteroides) ruminicola is a numerous rumen bacterium which plays a significant role in the metabolism of proteins and peptides in the rumen. Measurement of the hydrolysis of synthetic aminopeptidase substrates by sonicated extracts and whole cells of different species of rumen bacteria indicated that P. ruminicola had the greatest range and specific activity of dipeptidyl peptidases among the species tested.Streptococcus bovis hydrolysed some dipeptidyl peptidase substrates to a lesser extent, and several species broke down Ala2-p-nitroanilide, including Ruminobacter amylophilus, Ruminococcus spp. and Veillonella parvula. Dipeptidyl peptidases, which cleave dipeptides from the amino-terminus of longer peptides, were much more active than aminopeptidases removing single amino acids in P. ruminicola. Ion-exchange chromatography of sonicated extracts of P. ruminicola M384 revealed at least four distinct activities: one hydrolysed Ala2-p-nitroanilide, ValAla-p-nitroanilide, Ala4and Ala5; another was an O2-sensitive activity hydrolysing GlyArg-4-methoxynapthylamide, ArgArg-4-methoxynaphthylamide, Gly5 and ValGlySerGlu, similar to dipeptidyl peptidase type I DPP-1); a third hydrolysed GlyPro-p-nitroanilide and GlyPro-4-methoxynapthylamide and was similar to dipeptidyl peptidase type IV XDPP-4); a fourth broke down LysAla-4-methoxynaphthylamide. All of the enzymes, and particularly those active against Ala2-p-nitroanilide and GlyPro-p-nitroanilide, were inhibited by serine protease inhibitors, and all except DPP-4 were inhibited by EDTA. Both DPP-1 and the enzyme hydrolysing LysAla-4-methoxynaphthylamide were inhibited strongly by iodoacetate. DPP-4 was inhibited completely by diprotin A. Competitive inhibition experiments suggested that DPP-1 was less important than the other enzymes in the breakdown of peptide mixtures.     

Evidence for natural transfer of a tetracycline resistance gene between bacteria from the human colon and bacteria from the bovine rumen.

Previously, we demonstrated conjugal transfer of a specially constructed shuttle vector, pRDB5, from the human colonic anaerobe Bacteroides uniformis to the ruminal anaerobe Prevotella (Bacteroides) ruminicola B(1)4. We have now shown that naturally occurring gene transfer elements in Bacteroides species and Prevotella ruminicola can also be transferred between these two genera. A self-transmissible chromosomal element originally found in a clinical isolate of Bacteroides fragilis (Tcr Emr 12256) was transferred from B. uniformis 0061 to P. ruminicola B(1)4 and from P. ruminicola B(1)4 back to B. uniformis or to another human colonic species, Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron. Similarly, a conjugative plasmid (pRRI4) originally found in P. ruminicola 223 was transferred from P. ruminicola B(1)4 to B. uniformis or B. thetaiotaomicron. pRRI4 could be transferred from the colonic Bacteroides species only if the donor strain contained the Tcr Emr 12256 element in its chromosome. These results show that transfer of naturally occurring elements can be demonstrated under laboratory conditions. Evidence that such transfers may actually have occurred in nature came from our finding that the tetracycline resistance (Tcr) gene on the P. ruminicola plasmid pRRI4 hybridized on high-stringency Southern blots with the Tcr gene found on the Bacteroides Tcr elements. The presence of the same gene in such distantly related genera of bacteria is most likely to have occurred as a result of horizontal transfer.     

Conjugal transfer of a shuttle vector from the human colonic anaerobe Bacteroides uniformis to the ruminal anaerobe Prevotella (Bacteroides) ruminicola B(1)4.

Prevotella ruminicola (formerly Bacteroides ruminicola) is an anaerobic, gram-negative, polysaccharide-degrading bacterium which is found in the rumina of cattle. Since P. ruminicola is thought to make an important contribution to digestion of plant material in rumina, the ability to alter this strain genetically might help improve the efficiency of rumen fermentation. However, previously there has been no way to introduce foreign DNA into P. ruminicola strains. In this study we transferred a shuttle vector, pRDB5, from the colonic species Bacteroides uniformis to P. ruminicola B(1)4. The transfer frequency was 10(-6) to 10(-7) per recipient. pRDB5 contains sequences from pBR328, a cryptic colonic Bacteroides plasmid pB8-51, and a colonic Bacteroides tetracycline resistance (Tcr) gene. pRDB5 was mobilized out of B. uniformis by a self-transmissible Bacteroides chromosomal element designated Tcr Emr 12256. pRDB5 replicated in Escherichia coli as well as in Bacteroides spp. and was also mobilized from E. coli to B. uniformis by using IncP plasmid R751. However, direct transfer from E. coli to P. ruminicola B(1)4 was not detected. Thus, to introduce cloned DNA into P. ruminicola B(1)4, it was necessary first to mobilize the plasmid from E. coli to B. uniformis and then to mobilize the plasmid from B. uniformis to P. ruminicola B(1)4.     

Conjugal transfer of a shuttle vector from the human colonic anaerobe Bacteroides uniformis to the ruminal anaerobe Prevotella (Bacteroides) ruminicola B(1)4.

Prevotella ruminicola (formerly Bacteroides ruminicola) is an anaerobic, gram-negative, polysaccharide-degrading bacterium which is found in the rumina of cattle. Since P. ruminicola is thought to make an important contribution to digestion of plant material in rumina, the ability to alter this strain genetically might help improve the efficiency of rumen fermentation. However, previously there has been no way to introduce foreign DNA into P. ruminicola strains. In this study we transferred a shuttle vector, pRDB5, from the colonic species Bacteroides uniformis to P. ruminicola B(1)4. The transfer frequency was 10(-6) to 10(-7) per recipient. pRDB5 contains sequences from pBR328, a cryptic colonic Bacteroides plasmid pB8-51, and a colonic Bacteroides tetracycline resistance (Tcr) gene. pRDB5 was mobilized out of B. uniformis by a self-transmissible Bacteroides chromosomal element designated Tcr Emr 12256. pRDB5 replicated in Escherichia coli as well as in Bacteroides spp. and was also mobilized from E. coli to B. uniformis by using IncP plasmid R751. However, direct transfer from E. coli to P. ruminicola B(1)4 was not detected. Thus, to introduce cloned DNA into P. ruminicola B(1)4, it was necessary first to mobilize the plasmid from E. coli to B. uniformis and then to mobilize the plasmid from B. uniformis to P. ruminicola B(1)4.     

Heterologous expression of the Bacteroides ruminicola xylanase gene in Bacteroides fragilis and Bacteroides uniformis

A cloned xylanase gene from the ruminal bacterium Bacteroides ruminicola 23 was transferred by conjugation into the colonic species Bacteroides fragilis and Bacteroides uniformis by using the Escherichia coli-Bacteroides shuttle vector pVAL-1. The cloned gene was expressed in both species, and xylanase specific activity in crude extracts was found to be at least 1400-fold greater than that found in the B. ruminicola strain. Analysis of crude extract proteins from the recombinant B. fragilis by SDS-PAGE demonstrated a new 60,000 molecular weight protein. The xylanase activity expressed in both E. coli and B. fragilis was capable of degrading xylan to xylooligosaccharides in vitro. This is the first demonstration that colonic Bacteroides species can express a gene from a ruminal Bacteroides species.     

Selective isolation of bacteria with dipeptidyl aminopeptidase type I activity from the sheep rumen

Five-hundred-and-six fresh isolates of rumen bacteria were tested for their ability to hydrolyse the synthetic substrate for dipeptidyl aminopeptidase type I, GlyArg-4-methoxy-2-naphthylamide (GlyArg-MNA), using a gel overlay technique. Twelve positive isolates were small Gram-negative rods which resembled Bacteroides ruminicola in their biochemical and morphological properties. SDS-PAGE of whole cell extracts indicated that two were similar to B. ruminicola strain B14, six resembled B. ruminicola strain M384, and four were similar to B. ruminicola GA33. All hydrolysed GlyArg-MNA, Ala2 and Ala5, and showed no activity against Leu-MNA. Ala3 and Ala2, but no Ala4, was produced from Ala5. The different groups had different, distinctive activity profiles. The two remaining positive isolates were Lactobacillus spp. with an exceptionally high Leu-MNA activity. It was concluded that, although different strains may only be distantly related, B. ruminicola forms the most important group of bacteria in the rumen to possess a dipeptidyl aminopeptidase type I activity.     

Plasmid-associated transfer of tetracycline resistance in Bacteroides ruminicola.

Tetracycline resistance was transferred at frequencies between 10(-7) and 10(-6) per recipient cell in anaerobic matings between two strains of the strictly anaerobic rumen bacterium Bacteroides ruminicola. The donor strain, 223/M2/7, was a multiple-plasmid-bearing tetracycline-resistant strain from the ovine rumen, and the recipient, F101, was a rifampin-resistant mutant of B14, a bovine strain belonging to B. ruminicola subsp. brevis. Resistance transfer could occur in the presence of DNase, but not in dummy mating mixtures in which filtrate from a donor culture replaced donor cells. Acquisition of tetracycline resistance by the recipient was accompanied by the appearance of a 19.5-kilobase pair plasmid (designated pRRI4) which was homologous with a plasmid of similar size and restriction pattern present in the donor strain. A transconjugant (F115) carrying pRRI4 was also able to act as a donor of tetracycline resistance and plasmid DNA in matings with another recipient. Derivatives of F115 that had spontaneously lost tetracycline resistance lacked detectable plasmid DNA. It is concluded that pRRI4 mediated the transfer of tetracycline resistance. Transfer of resistance was not detectably enhanced by pregrowth of the donor in medium containing tetracycline. Transfer of tetracycline resistance was not detected from 223/M2/7 to a strain, 23 belonging to B. ruminicola subsp. ruminicola.     

Plasmid-associated transfer of tetracycline resistance in Bacteroides ruminicola

Tetracycline resistance was transferred at frequencies between 10(-7) and 10(-6) per recipient cell in anaerobic matings between two strains of the strictly anaerobic rumen bacterium Bacteroides ruminicola. The donor strain, 223/M2/7, was a multiple-plasmid-bearing tetracycline-resistant strain from the ovine rumen, and the recipient, F101, was a rifampin-resistant mutant of B14, a bovine strain belonging to B. ruminicola subsp. brevis. Resistance transfer could occur in the presence of DNase, but not in dummy mating mixtures in which filtrate from a donor culture replaced donor cells. Acquisition of tetracycline resistance by the recipient was accompanied by the appearance of a 19.5-kilobase pair plasmid (designated pRRI4) which was homologous with a plasmid of similar size and restriction pattern present in the donor strain. A transconjugant (F115) carrying pRRI4 was also able to act as a donor of tetracycline resistance and plasmid DNA in matings with another recipient. Derivatives of F115 that had spontaneously lost tetracycline resistance lacked detectable plasmid DNA. It is concluded that pRRI4 mediated the transfer of tetracycline resistance. Transfer of resistance was not detectably enhanced by pregrowth of the donor in medium containing tetracycline. Transfer of tetracycline resistance was not detected from 223/M2/7 to a strain, 23 belonging to B. ruminicola subsp. ruminicola.     

The Effect of Monensin on Pure and Mixed Cultures of Rumen Bacteria

The antibiotic monensin was added to pure cultures of Bacteroides ruminicola, Selenomonas ruminantium, Anaerovibrio lipolytica and Megasphaera elsdenii. These organisms, representing succinate- and propionate-producing rumen bacteria, were not affected by monensin up to 10 μg/ml. Methanobacterium ruminantium was slightly inhibited by monensin, Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens, Ruminococcus albus and Streptococcus bovis were inhibited to differing extents by monensin at concentrations between 0.1 and 10 μg/ml. Bacteroides succinogenes was inhibited at first by monensin at >0.5 μg/ml but after a prolonged lag phase adapted to grow in the presence of monensin at concentrations below 5 μg/ml.
Monensin (1 μg/ml) almost completely stopped the digestion of chopped straw and dewaxed cotton fibres by rumen contents incubated in vitro. The digestion of grass and powdered filter paper was not significantly reduced under these conditions, but when the concentration of monensin was increased to between 3 and 5 μg/ml, the digestion of these substrates was reduced.     

Effect of the novel ionophore tetronasin (ICI 139603) on ruminal microorganisms.

The antimicrobial activity of the novel ionophore tetronasin (formerly ICI 139603) was compared with that of monensin for the growth of ruminal bacteria, protozoa, and an anaerobic fungus. The potency of tetronasin toward most bacteria and the fungus was an order of magnitude or more greater than that of monensin. Lactobacillus casei was 55 times more sensitive to tetronasin than to monensin, indicating a potential role for tetronasin in reversing lactic acidosis. Bacteria with a gram-positive ultrastructure were generally sensitive to the ionophores and unable to adapt to grow in their presence. The exception was the cellulolytic Ruminococcus flavefaciens, which adapted during successive cultivation on media with increasing ionophore concentrations to grow at 100-fold higher concentrations of tetronasin than were initially lethal to the organism. Gram-negative bacteria were more resistant and generally able to adapt to grow in the presence of both ionophores. An in vivo trial with cattle and in vitro growth experiments indicated that the effect of tetronasin on ciliate protozoa was minor. In vitro experiments measuring hydrogen production by Neocallimastix frontalis suggested that this fungus would be unable to survive in ruminants receiving tetronasin.     

Sequence analysis of the plasmid pRRI2 from the rumen bacterium Prevotella ruminicola 223/M2/7 and the use of pRRI2 in Prevotella/Bacteroides Shuttle Vectors.

pRRI2 is a small cryptic plasmid from the rumen bacterium Prevotella ruminicola 223/M2/7 which has been used for the construction of shuttle vectors (pRH3 and pRRI207) that replicate in many Bacteroides/Prevotella strains as well as in Escherichia coli. Sequence analysis of pRRI2 reveals that it is a 3240-bp plasmid carrying two clear open reading frames. Rep, encoded by ORF1, shows 48 and 47% amino acid sequence identity with RepA proteins from Bacteroides vulgatus and Bacteroides fragilis, respectively. ORF2, named Pre, shares 34% amino acid sequence identity with a putative plasmid recombination protein from the Flavobacterium spp. plasmid pFL1 and 30% amino acid sequence identity with BmpH from B. fragilis Tn5520. Disruption of ORF1 with HindIII prevents replication and maintenance in Bacteroides spp. hosts, but shuttle vectors carrying pRRI2 interrupted within ORF2, by EcoRI*, are able to replicate. pRRI2 shows no significant similarity with the only other P. ruminicola plasmid to have been studied previously, pRAM4.     

Effect of the novel ionophore tetronasin (ICI 139603) on ruminal microorganisms

The antimicrobial activity of the novel ionophore tetronasin (formerly ICI 139603) was compared with that of monensin for the growth of ruminal bacteria, protozoa, and an anaerobic fungus. The potency of tetronasin toward most bacteria and the fungus was an order of magnitude or more greater than that of monensin. Lactobacillus casei was 55 times more sensitive to tetronasin than to monensin, indicating a potential role for tetronasin in reversing lactic acidosis. Bacteria with a gram-positive ultrastructure were generally sensitive to the ionophores and unable to adapt to grow in their presence. The exception was the cellulolytic Ruminococcus flavefaciens, which adapted during successive cultivation on media with increasing ionophore concentrations to grow at 100-fold higher concentrations of tetronasin than were initially lethal to the organism. Gram-negative bacteria were more resistant and generally able to adapt to grow in the presence of both ionophores. An in vivo trial with cattle and in vitro growth experiments indicated that the effect of tetronasin on ciliate protozoa was minor. In vitro experiments measuring hydrogen production by Neocallimastix frontalis suggested that this fungus would be unable to survive in ruminants receiving tetronasin.