Analysis of chloroplast transit peptide function using mutations in the carboxyl-terminal region

Protein import into chloroplasts requires a transit peptide, which interacts with the chloroplast transport apparatus and leads to translocation of the protein across the chloroplast envelope. While the amino acid sequences of many transit peptides are known, functional domains have been difficult to identify. Previous studies suggest that the carboxyl terminus of the transit peptide for ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase small subunit is important for both translocation across the chloroplast envelope and proper processing of the precursor protein. We dissected this region using in vitro mutagenesis, creating a set of mutants with small changes in primary structure predicted to cause alterations in secondary structure. The import behavior of the mutant proteins was assessed using isolated chloroplasts. Our results show that removal of a conserved arginine residue in this region results in impaired processing, but does not necessarily affect import rates. In contrast, substituting amino acids with low reverse turn or amphiphilic potential for other original residues affected import rate but not processing.     

Domains of a Transit Sequence Required for in Vivo Import in Arabidopsis Chloroplasts

Nuclear-encoded precursors of chloroplast proteins are synthesized with an amino-terminal cleavable transit sequence, which contains the information for chloroplastic targeting. To determine which regions of the transit sequence are most important for its function, the chloroplast uptake and processing of a full-length ferredoxin precursor and four mutants with deletions in adjacent regions of the transit sequence were analyzed. Arabidopsis was used as an experimental system for both in vitro and in vivo import. The full-length wild-type precursor translocated efficiently into isolated Arabidopsis chloroplasts, and upon expression in transgenic Arabidopsis plants only mature-sized protein was detected, which was localized inside the chloroplast. None of the deletion mutants was imported in vitro. By analyzing transgenic plants, more subtle effects on import were observed. The most N-terminal deletion resulted in a fully defective transit sequence. Two deletions in the middle region of the transit sequence allowed translocation into the chloroplast, although with reduced efficiencies. One deletion in this region strongly reduced mature protein accumulation in older plants. The most C-terminal deletion was translocated but resulted in defective processing. These results allow the dissection of the transit sequence into separate functional regions and give an in vivo basis for a domain-like structure of the ferredoxin transit sequence.     

Stromal processing peptidase binds transit peptides and initiates their ATP-dependent turnover in chloroplasts.

A stromal processing peptidase (SPP) cleaves a broad range of precursors targeted to the chloroplast, yielding proteins for numerous biosynthetic pathways in different compartments. SPP contains a signature zinc-binding motif, His-X-X-Glu-His, that places it in a metallopeptidase family which includes the mitochondrial processing peptidase. Here, we have investigated the mechanism of cleavage by SPP, a late, yet key event in the import pathway. Recombinant SPP removed the transit peptide from a variety of precursors in a single endoproteolytic step. Whereas the mature protein was immediately released, the transit peptide remained bound to SPP. SPP converted the transit peptide to a subfragment form that it no longer recognized. We conclude that SPP contains a specific binding site for the transit peptide and additional proteolysis by SPP triggers its release. A stable interaction between SPP and an intact transit peptide was directly demonstrated using a newly developed binding assay. Unlike recombinant SPP, a chloroplast extract rapidly degraded both the transit peptide and subfragment. A new degradative activity, distinguishable from SPP, was identified that is ATP- and metal-dependent. Our results indicate a regulated sequence of events as SPP functions during precursor import, and demonstrate a previously unrecognized ATP-requirement for transit peptide turnover.     

Precursors with altered affinity for Hsp70 in their transit peptides are efficiently imported into chloroplasts

Protein import into chloroplasts is postulated to occur with the involvement of molecular chaperones. We have determined that the transit peptide of ferredoxin-NADP(H) reductase precursor binds preferentially to an Hsp70 from chloroplast stroma. To investigate the role of Hsp70 molecular chaperones in chloroplast protein import, we analyzed the import into pea chloroplasts of preproteins with decreased Hsp70 binding affinity in their transit peptides. Our results indicate that the precursor with the lowest affinity for Hsp70 molecular chaperones in its transit peptide was imported to chloroplasts with similar apparent Km as the wild type precursor and a 2-fold increase in Vmax. Thus, a strong interaction between chloroplast stromal Hsp70 and the transit peptide seems not to be essential for protein import. These results indicate that in chloroplasts the main unfolding force during protein import may be applied by molecular chaperones other than Hsp70s. Although stromal Hsp70s undoubtedly participate in chloroplast biogenesis, the role of these molecular chaperones in chloroplast protein translocation differs from the one proposed in the mechanisms postulated up to date.     

Interaction of plant mitochondrial and chloroplast signal peptides with the Hsp70 molecular chaperone.

Most mitochondrial and chloroplast proteins are synthesized on cytosolic polyribosomes as precursor proteins, with an N-terminal signal sequence that targets the precursor to the correct organelle. In mitochondria, the chaperone Hsp70 functions as a molecular motor, pulling the precursor across the mitochondrial membranes; 97.0% of plant mitochondrial presequences contain an Hsp70 binding site. In chloroplasts, the outer envelope, intermembrane space and a stromal Hsp70 are thought to participate in protein import; 82.5% of chloroplast transit peptides have an Hsp70 binding site. The interaction of signal peptides with Hsp70 during the import process is supported by biochemical and bioinformatic studies.     

Determinants for removal and degradation of transit peptides of chloroplast precursor proteins

The stromal processing peptidase (SPP) cleaves a large diversity of chloroplast precursor proteins, removing an N-terminal transit peptide. We predicted previously that this key step of the import pathway is mediated by features of the transit peptide that determine precursor binding and cleavage followed by transit peptide conversion to a degradable substrate. Here we performed competition experiments using synthesized oligopeptides of the transit peptide of ferredoxin precursor to investigate the mechanism of these processes. We found that binding and processing of ferredoxin precursor depend on specific interactions of SPP with the region consisting of the C-terminal 12 residues of the transit peptide. Analysis of four other precursors suggests that processing depends on the same region, although their transit peptides are highly divergent in primary sequence and length. Upon processing, SPP terminates its interaction with the transit peptide by a second cleavage, converting it to a subfragment form. From the competition experiments we deduce that SPP releases a subfragment consisting of the transit peptide without its original C terminus. Interestingly, examination of the ATP-dependent metallopeptidase activity responsible for degradation of transit peptide subfragments suggests that it may recognize other unrelated peptides and, hence, act separately from SPP as a novel stromal oligopeptidase.     

The import of ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase precursor into chloroplasts is modulated by the region between the transit peptide and the mature core of the protein.

Protein transport across organelles' membranes requires that precursor proteins adopt an unfolded structure in order to be translocated by the import machinery. Ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase precursor, as well as many others, acquires a tightly folded structure that needs to be unfolded before or during its import. Several steps of chloroplast protein import are not fully understood. In particular, the role of different regions of the precursor protein has not been completely elucidated. In this work, we have studied the import into chloroplasts of precursor proteins with inclusions of amino acid spacers between the transit peptide and the mature protein, and with deletions in the N-terminal region of the mature enzyme. We measured the import rate constants for these precursors and the results indicate that the distance between the transit peptide and the core of the mature protein determines the import kinetics. The longer precursors were imported into the organelle faster than the wild type form. Precursors with deletions in the N-terminal region of the mature protein also showed increased import rates compared to the wild type. Homology studies amongst all family members reveal that only chloroplastic proteins possess this region. We suggest that even if the first amino acids of the mature protein do not contribute to its overall structural stability, they condition the kinetic parameters of the import reaction. Besides, the distance between the transit peptide and the mature protein core may be modulating the import rate at which the chloroplast incorporates this protein from the cytosol.     

Mutations in the processing site of the precursor of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase small subunit: effects on import,processing, assembly and stability

The small subunit (SSU) of Rubisco is synthesized in the cytosol in a precursor form. Upon import into the chloroplast, it is proteolytically processed at a Cys-Met bond to yield the mature form of the protein. To assess the importance of the Met residue for recognition and processing by the stromal peptidase, we substituted this residue with either Thr, Arg or Asp. The mutant precursor proteins were imported into isolated chloroplasts, and the products of the import reactions were analyzed. Mutants containing Thr or Arg residues at the putative processing site were processed to a single peptide, comigrating with the wild-type protein. N-terminal radio-sequencing revealed that these mutants were processed at the Cys-Thr and the Cys-Arg bond, respectively. After import of the Asp-containing mutant, four processed forms of the protein were observed. Analysis of the most abundant one, co-migrating with the wild-type protein, demonstrated that this species was also a product of correct processing, at the Cys-Asp bond. All the correctly processed peptides were found to be associated with the holoenzyme of Rubisco, and remained stable within the chloroplast, like the wild-type protein. The results of this study, together with previous ones, suggest that proper recognition and processing of the SSU precursor are more affected by residues N-terminal to the processing site than by the residue on the C-terminal side of this site.     

A pentapeptide motif related to a pigment binding site in the major light-harvesting protein of photosystem II, LHCII, governs substrate-dependent plastid import of NADPH:protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase A

NADPH:protochlorophyllide (Pchlide) oxidoreductase (POR) A is the only known example thus far of a nucleus-encoded plastid protein that is imported to its final destination in a substrate-dependent, Pchlide-regulated manner. Previous work has shown that the cytosolic PORA precursor (pPORA) does not utilize the general import site but uses a distinct translocon designated the Pchlide-dependent translocon complex. Here we demonstrate that a pentapeptide motif, threonine-threonine-serine-proline-glycine (TTSPG) in pPORA's transit peptide (transA), is involved in Pchlide-dependent transport. Deletion of this motif from the COOH-terminal end of transA abolished both Pchlide binding and protein import. Incorporation of the TTSPG motif into normally non-Pchlide-responsive transit sequences conferred the pigment binding properties onto the engineered chimeric precursors but was insufficient to render protein import substrate dependent. An additional motif was identified in the NH(2)-terminal part of transA that was needed for binding of the precursor to the Pchlide-dependent translocon complex. Point mutations of the TTSPG motif identified glycine as the Pchlide binding site. By analogy to the major light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein of photosystem II, we propose that the peptidyl carbonyl oxygen of glycine may bind directly or via a water molecule to the central Mg atom of the pigment.     

Interaction of the targeting sequence of chloroplast precursors with Hsp70 molecular chaperones.

We have analyzed the interaction of DnaK and plant Hsp70 proteins with the wild-type ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase precursor (preFNR) and mutants containing amino-acid replacements in the targeting sequence. Using an algorithm already developed [Rüdiger, S., Germeroth, L., Schneider-Mergener, J. & Bukau, B. (1997) EMBO J. 16, 1501-1507] we observed that 75% of the 727 plastid precursor proteins analyzed contained at least one site with high likelihood of DnaK binding in their transit peptides. Statistical analysis showed a decrease of DnaK binding site frequency within the first 15 amino-acid residues of the transit peptides. Using fusion proteins we detected the interaction of DnaK with the transit peptide of the folded preFNR but not with the mature region of the protein. Discharge of DnaK from the presequence was favored by addition of MgATP. When a putative DnaK binding site was artificially added at the N-terminus of the mature protein, we observed formation of complexes with bacterial and plant Hsp70 molecular chaperones. Reducing the likelihood of DnaK binding by directed mutagenesis of the presequence increased the release of bound DnaK. The Hsp70 proteins from plastids and plant cell cytosol also interacted with the preFNR transit peptide. Overall results are discussed in the context of the proposed models to explain the organelle protein import.     

Carboxyl-terminal sequences can influence the in vitro import and intraorganellar targeting of chloroplast protein precursors.

The transit peptide of the lumenal 33-kDa oxygen-evolving polypeptide (OEE1) is capable of directing the import and targeting of the foreign protein dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) to the thylakoid lumen. The import results from the first part of this study indicate that methotrexate cannot block the import or intraorganellar targeting of OEE1-DHFR in chloroplasts in contrast to that reported for the import of cytochrome oxidase subunit IV (COXIV)-DHFR in mitochondria. These results suggest that the fusion of the OEE1 transit sequence to DHFR affected the protein's methotrexate binding properties. We further examined and compared the transport characteristics of a number of carboxyl-terminal truncated native chloroplast precursors to determine whether carboxyl domains contribute to the import and intraorganellar targeting mechanism of these proteins. The plastid precursors chosen for this study are targeted to one of the following chloroplast compartments: the stroma, the thylakoid membrane, and the lumen. In most cases, removal of carboxyl domains had a dramatic effect on one or more stages of the translocation pathway, such as import, processing, and intraorganellar targeting. The effects of carboxyl deletions varied from precursor to precursor and were dependent on the extent of the deletion. These combined results suggest that carboxyl domains in the mature part of the proteins can influence the function of the transit peptide, and as a result play an important role in determining the import and targeting competence of chloroplast precursors.     

Complete processing of a small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase from pea requires the amino acid sequence Ile-Thr-Ser

Chloroplast import and processing of two precursor proteins with mutations in the carboxyl-terminal region of the transit peptide were examined in vitro. Deletion mutations were introduced into the 57-amino acid transit peptide of a chloroplast protein, the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase, from pea. A mutant, PSd48/57, in which nine carboxyl-terminal amino acids of the transit peptide had been deleted, was imported and processed to a series of 13- to 18-kDa polypeptides including the 14-kDa mature small subunit. In contrast, processing of a mutant, PSd45/57, in which an additional three amino acids had been removed, resulted in a series of polypeptides which did not include the mature small subunit. Whereas PSd48/57 was imported as efficiently as the wild-type precursor, import of PSd45/57 was only 25% as efficient as that of the authentic precursor. The mutant precursor proteins PSd48/57 and PSd45/57 are distinguished by a three-amino acid sequence, Ile-Thr-Ser, located in the carboxyl-terminal region of the transit peptide. We show that all or part of this sequence is required for correct processing.     

A truncated analog of a pre-light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein II transit peptide inhibits protein import into chloroplasts

It is unclear how transit peptides target nuclear-encoded precursor proteins to the chloroplast. This study establishes the feasibility of using synthetic peptides as competitive inhibitors of chloroplast protein import and as probes for the function of domains within transit peptides. We show that peptide pL(1-20), MAASTMALSSPAFAGKAVNY, an analog of the NH2 terminus of a pre-light harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein II from Arabidopsis, inhibits the import of several Arabidopsis and pea precursor proteins into pea chloroplasts. Inhibition occurs at a step between the initial binding of precursors to the chloroplast and the first proteolytic cleavage event and is not due to interference with ATP availability or chloroplast integrity. Presumably this reflects specific binding of the peptide to the import machinery in the chloroplast envelope. Our data are consistent with the suggestion (Karlin-Neumann, G. A., and Tobin, E. M. (1986) EMBO J. 5, 9-13) that two conserved blocks of amino acids near the NH2-terminus of transit peptides (spanned by peptide pL(1-20] participate in protein targeting. Computer analysis also shows peptide pL(1-20) lacks the amphiphilic properties characteristic of pre-sequences of many nuclear-encoded mitochondrial proteins. This shows a difference in the mechanisms for targeting proteins to chloroplasts and mitochondria.     

Determinants for cleavage of the chlorophyll a/b binding protein precursor: a requirement for a basic residue that is not universal for chloroplast imported proteins

We demonstrate that the precursor of the major light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein (LHCP of Photosystem II), encoded by a Type I gene, contains distinct determinants for processing at two sites during in vitro import into the chloroplast. Using precursors from both pea and wheat, it is shown that primary site processing, and release of a approximately 26-kD peptide, depends on an amino-proximal basic residue. Substitution of an arginine at position -4 resulted in an 80% reduction in processing, with the concomitant accumulation of a high molecular weight intermediate. Cleavage occurred normally when arginine was changed to lysine. The hypothesis that a basic residue is a general requirement for transit peptide removal was tested. We find that the precursors for the small subunit of Rubisco and Rubisco activase do not require a basic residue within seven amino acids of the cleavage site for maturation. In the wheat LHCP precursor, determinants for efficient cleavage at a secondary site were identified carboxy to the primary site, beyond what is traditionally called the transit peptide, within the sequence ala-lys-ala-lys (residues 38-41). Introduction of this sequence into the pea precursor, which has the residues thr-thr-lys-lys in the corresponding position, converted it to a substrate with an efficiently recognized secondary site. Our results indicate that two different forms of LHCP can be produced with distinct NH2-termini by selective cleavage of a single precursor polypeptide.     

Loss of efficient import and thylakoid insertion due to N- and C-terminal deletions in the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein.

C-terminally truncated precursors of wheat light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein (LHCP) were synthesized to investigate the origin of the two forms (about 25 kD and 26 kD) of the mature protein observed upon in vitro import into the chloroplast. Precursors p delta 13 and p delta 27, lacking 13 and 27 amino acids, respectively, were successfully imported, and both gave rise to two smaller forms proportional to the size of their deletions. These results demonstrate that there are two N-terminal sites that are cleaved during import of the LHCP precursor, undoubtedly contributing to the heterogeneity of LHCP found in vivo. Significantly, p delta 27 yielded only 50% of mature LHCP when compared with wild type. Although the products of p delta 27 import were localized to the thylakoids, in contrast to p delta 13 they were not correctly inserted into the membranes, indicating that residues essential for this step are missing. p delta 27 is distinguished from p delta 13 by lacking the carboxy end of a domain highly conserved between LHCP of photosystems II and I. Other specific precursor mutants with larger C-terminal deletions were not efficiently transported into the organelle in time course experiments, nor did they insert directly into the thylakoids using chloroplast lysates, in an assay independent of translocation across the envelope. In addition, the mutant p delta 18n, lacking the first 18 amino acids of mature LHCP, was only found bound to the chloroplast envelope. However, both p delta 18n and the mature protein, i.e., LHCP, synthesized in vitro without its 34-amino acid transit peptide inserted into the thylakoids in chloroplast lysates. The overall conformation of the mutant precursor polypeptides was probed using the chloroplast soluble processing enzyme in an organelle-free reaction optimized for the LHCP precursor and the more general protease trypsin. A tightly folded, protease-resistant conformation was not apparent to explain the loss of efficient import.     

Synthetic transit peptides inhibit import and processing of mitochondrial precursor proteins

We have demonstrated that a synthetic peptide corresponding to the rat mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase (mMDH) transit peptide (TP-28) inhibits the binding of pre-mMDH to isolated mitochondria. Synthetic peptides derived from chloroplast transit peptide sequences, which have a similar net charge, did not inhibit import. In addition, this peptide (TP-28) inhibits import of ornithine transcarbamylase, another mitochondrial matrix protein, thus suggesting that common import pathways exist for both mMDH and ornithine transcarbamylase. A smaller synthetic peptide corresponding to residues 1-20 of the mMDH transit peptide (TP-20) also inhibits binding. However, several substitutions for leucine-13 in the smaller peptide relieve import inhibition, thus providing evidence that this neutral residue plays a crucial role in transit peptide binding to the mitochondrial surface. Proteolytic processing of pre-mMDH by a mitochondrial matrix fraction to both the mature and intermediate forms of mMDH was also inhibited by TP-28. The ability of synthetic peptides to inhibit distinct steps in the import of mitochondrial precursor proteins corresponds precisely to their ability to interact with the same components used by transit peptides on intact precursors. Furthermore, inhibition at multiple points along the import pathway reflects the functions of several independent structures contained within transit peptides.     

A novel, bipartite transit peptide targets OEP75 to the outer membrane of the chloroplastic envelope.

OEP75 is an outer envelope membrane component of the chloroplastic protein import apparatus and is synthesized in the cytoplasm as a higher molecular weight precursor (prOEP75). During its own import, prOEP75 is processed first to an intermediate (iOEP75) and subsequently to the mature form (mOEP75). Experiments conducted with stromal extracts indicated that iOEP75 was generated from prOEP75 by the activity of the stromal processing peptidase. The specific processing site was determined and used to divide the prOEP75 transit peptide into N- and C-terminal domains. To determine the targeting functions of the two domains of the transit peptide and of the mature region of prOEP75, we created a deletion mutant construct from prOEP75 and chimeric constructs between domains of prOEP75 and the precursor to a small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase. Analysis of these constructs by in vitro chloroplastic protein import assays revealed that the transit peptide of prOEP75 is bipartite in that the N- and C-terminal portions contain chloroplastic and intraorganellar targeting information, respectively.     

Effect of precursor protein phosphorylation on import into isolated chloroplasts from Chlamydomonas.

In higher plants, chloroplast-destined precursor proteins are thought to be phosphorylated. Mediated by a specific 14-3-3 protein, these phosphorylated proteins bind to the chloroplast surface and are subsequently imported into the chloroplast. We demonstrate that also in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii the precursor of the small subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase becomes phosphorylated by a plant protein kinase and that the phosphorylation site is located in the transit peptide. The phosphorylation status of the precursor protein regulates its import into chloroplasts especially at an early step during this process. The possible physiological function is discussed.     

Secondary structure and folding of a functional chloroplast precursor protein.

Ferredoxin is a chloroplast stroma protein which is cytosolically synthesized as a precursor with an amino-terminal extension called the transit sequence that is needed for the post-translational uptake by the chloroplast. To characterize the secondary and tertiary structure elements, the full precursor, the holo- and apo- (without iron-sulfur cluster) forms of the mature protein, and the chemically synthesized transit peptide were obtained and analyzed separately. Circular dichroism, tryptophan fluorescence quenching, and protease accessibility experiments indicate that the precursor has a low content of defined secondary structure and resembles unfolded proteins; these properties are due to both the mature part and the transit sequence. This result provides an explanation for the lack of cytosolic factor requirement of this protein for import. In an import competition assay, the isolated transit peptide had an affinity for the chloroplasts comparable to the full precursor. Interestingly and of possible importance to the import process, the transit peptide has conformational flexibility as it adopts alternative secondary structures in different environments.     

RAP,the Sole Octotricopeptide Repeat Protein in Arabidopsis,Is Required for Chloroplast 16S rRNA Maturation

The biogenesis and activity of chloroplasts in both vascular plants and algae depends on an intracellular network of nucleus-encoded, trans-acting factors that control almost all aspects of organellar gene expression. Most of these regulatory factors belong to the helical repeat protein superfamily, which includes tetratricopeptide repeat, pentatricopeptide repeat, and the recently identified octotricopeptide repeat (OPR) proteins. Whereas green algae express many different OPR proteins, only a single orthologous OPR protein is encoded in the genomes of most land plants. Here, we report the characterization of the only OPR protein in Arabidopsis thaliana, RAP, which has previously been implicated in plant pathogen defense. Loss of RAP led to a severe defect in processing of chloroplast 16S rRNA resulting in impaired chloroplast translation and photosynthesis. In vitro RNA binding and RNase protection assays revealed that RAP has an intrinsic and specific RNA binding capacity, and the RAP binding site was mapped to the 5′ region of the 16S rRNA precursor. Nucleoid localization of RAP was shown by transient green fluorescent protein import assays, implicating the nucleoid as the site of chloroplast rRNA processing. Taken together, our data indicate that the single OPR protein in Arabidopsis is important for a basic process of chloroplast biogenesis.