Mixed culture of killer and sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains in batch and continuous fermentations

This paper presents a kinetic study of the dynamics of the population of two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains (designated K1 and 522D) in mixed culture. These two strains are commonly used in wine making. The K1 strain (killer yeast) secretes a glycoprotein (killer toxin) which causes the death of the 522D strain (sensitive yeast). Initially, the mixed cultures were realized in batch fermentations. Initial concentrations of killer yeast were 5 and 10% of the total population. The influence of the killer strain on the sensitive cultures was measured in comparison with a reference fermentation. The reference fermentation was inoculated only with the sensitive strain. Results show that an initial concentration of 10% of killer strain affects the microbial population balance and the rate of ethanol production. However the fermentation was only slightly disturbed when the proportion of killer to sensitive yeast at the beginning of mixed culture was 5%. To achieve total displacement by the killer yeast at low concentrations, the mixed cultures were carried out in a continuous system. The results obtained in continuous fermentations with the same strains have shown that a level of contamination as low as 0.8% of killer strain was sufficient to completely displace the original sensitive population after 150 h incubation.     

Mixed culture of killer and sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains in batch and continuous fermentations

This paper presents a kinetic study of the dynamics of the population of two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains (designated K1 and 522D) in mixed culture. These two strains are commonly used in wine making. The K1 strain (killer yeast) secretes a glycoprotein (killer toxin) which causes the death of the 522D strain (sensitive yeast). Initially, the mixed cultures were realized in batch fermentations. Initial concentrations of killer yeast were 5 and 10% of the total population. The influence of the killer strain on the sensitive cultures was measured in comparison with a reference fermentation. The reference fermentation was inoculated only with the sensitive strain. Results show that an initial concentration of 10% of killer strain affects the microbial population balance and the rate of ethanol production. However the fermentation was only slightly disturbed when the proportion of killer to sensitive yeast at the beginning of mixed culture was 5%. To achieve total displacement by the killer yeast at low concentrations, the mixed cultures were carried out in a continuous system. The results obtained in continuous fermentations with the same strains have shown that a level of contamination as low as 0.8% of killer strain was sufficient to completely displace the original sensitive population after 150 h incubation.     

Killer phenotype of indigenous yeasts isolated from Argentinian wine cellars and their potential starter cultures for winemaking

Of 31 yeasts, from different surfaces of two cellars from the northwest region of Argentina, 11 expressed killer activity against the sensitive strain Saccharomyces cerevisiae P351. Five of these killer yeasts were identified as S. cerevisiae by phenotypic tests and PCR-RFLP analysis. Two S. cerevisiae killer strains, Cf5 and Cf8, were selected based on their excellent kinetic and enological properties as potential autochthonous mixed starter cultures to be used during wine fermentation. They could dominate the natural microbiota in fermentation vats and keep the typical sensorial characteristics of the wine of this region.     

Killer activity of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains: partial characterization and strategies to improve the biocontrol efficacy in winemaking

Killer yeasts are considered potential biocontrol agents to avoid or reduce wine spoilage by undesirable species. In this study two Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains (Cf8 and M12) producing killer toxin were partially characterized and new strategies to improve their activity in winemaking were evaluated. Killer toxins were characterized by biochemical tests and growth inhibition of sensitive yeasts. Also genes encoding killer toxin were detected in the chromosomes of both strains by PCR. Both toxins showed optimal activity and production at conditions used during the wine-making process (pH 3.5 and temperatures of 15–25 °C). In addition, production of both toxins was higher when a nitrogen source was added. To improve killer activity different strategies of inoculation were studied, with the sequential inoculation of killer strains the best combination to control the growth of undesired yeasts. Sequential inoculation of Cf8–M12 showed a 45 % increase of killer activity on sensitive S. cerevisiae and spoilage yeasts. In the presence of ethanol (5–12 %) and SO₂ (50 mg/L) the killer activity of both toxins was increased, especially for toxin Cf8. Characteristics of both killer strains support their future application as starter cultures and biocontrol agents to produce wines of controlled quality.     

Kinetic modeling of kefiran production in mixed culture of Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens and Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Growth and kefiran production rates of Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens were significantly enhanced in a mixed culture with Saccharomyces cerevisiae as compared with those in a pure culture. Because a positive effect on growth and kefiran production of L. kefiranofaciens in a mixed culture was observed, the elucidation of interaction between L. kefiranofaciens and S. cerevisiae may lead to higher productivity. Hence, microbial performance of each strain was investigated and analyzed by a mathematical model. The mathematical model for kefiran fermentation in a mixed culture of L. kefiranofaciens and S. cerevisiae was established, and the impact of S. cerevisiae on cell growth, kefiran formation, and substrate assimilation of L. kefiranofaciens were considered. The behavior of L. kefiranofaciens in a mixed culture was predicted using a developed mathematical model in this work, and the predictions were compared with the results from mixed culture experiments. The overall mathematical model is capable of describing the behavior of S. cerevisiae in a mixed culture as a lactic acid consumer, nitrogen source competitor and protective function inducer for L. kefiranofaciens. Furthermore, the constructed model described the phenomena in mixed cultures under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Finally, the optimal inoculation ratios of S. cerevisiae to L. kefiranofaciens at 7-fold and 10-fold under aerobic and anaerobic conditions were obtained by applying the mixed culture model, respectively.     

Monitoring of killer yeast populations in mixed cultures: influence of incubation temperature of microvinifications samples

Killer yeasts are frequently used to combat and prevent contamination by wild-type yeasts during wine production and they can even dominate the wine fermentation. Stuck and sluggish fermentations can be caused by an unbalanced ratio of killer to sensitive yeasts in the bioreactor, and therefore it is important to determine the proportion of both populations. The aim of this study was to provide a simple tool to monitor killer yeast populations during controlled mixed microvinifications of killer and sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Samples were periodically extracted during vinification, seeded on Petri dishes and incubated at 25 and 37?°C; the latter temperature was assayed for possible inactivation of killer toxin production. Colonies developed under the described conditions were randomly transferred to killer phenotype detection medium. Significant differences in the killer/sensitive ratio were observed between both incubation temperatures in all microvinifications. These results suggest that 37?°C seems a better option to determine the biomass of sensitive yeasts, in order to avoid underestimation of sensitive cells in the presence of killer yeasts during fermentations. Incubation at a toxin-inhibiting temperature clearly showed the real ratio of killer to sensitive cells in fermentation systems.     

Effects of Fusariotoxin T-2 on Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces carlsbergensis

A Fusarium metabolite, T-2 toxin, inhibits the growth of Saccharomyces carlsbergensis and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The growth inhibitory concentrations of T-2 toxin were 40 and 100 μg/ml, respectively, for exponentially growing cultures of the two yeasts. S. carlsbergensis was more sensitive to the toxin and exhibited a biphasic dose-response curve. Addition of the toxin at 10 μg/ml of S. carlsbergensis culture resulted in a retardation of growth as measured turbidimetrically, after only 30 to 40 min. This action was reversible upon washing the cells free of the toxin. The sensitivity of the yeasts to the toxin was dependent upon the types and concentrations of carbohydrates used in the growth media. The sensitivity of the cells to the toxin decreased in glucose-repressed cultures. These results suggest that T-2 toxin interferes with mitochondrial functions of these yeasts.     

Stability and expression of a plasmid-containing killer toxin cDNA in batch and chemostat cultures of saccharomyces cerevisiae

A chimeric plasmid (pYT760-ADH1) containing the yeast killer toxin-immunity cDNA was transformed into a leucine-histidine mutant (AH22) and into four industrial toxin-sensitive yeasts. The chimeric plasmid was very stable and expressed toxin production (89.5 +/- 4.8% killer cells) in two of the transformed yeasts that contained the 2mu plasmid, but was lost within 10 generations from two other transformed pickle yeasts that did not contain the 2mu plasmid. It suggested that plasmid stability was dependent on the presence of the 2mu plasmid which is naturally present in some yeasts. The plasmid was extremely stable (100% killer cells) and expressed more toxin in the mutant strain AH22. The effects of dilution rate, D(h(-1)) on plasmid stability and toxin expression were studied in transformed AH22 (AH22/T3) and Montrachet 522 (522/T1) wine yeast grown in glucose-limited chemostat cultures. The results show that killer toxin production by AH22/T3 cells increased as a function of D(h(-1)) and that plasmid stability reached 100% at D >/= 0.09 +/- 0.01 h(-1). However, with Montrachet 522/T1 transformed cells, 100% plasmid stability was seen at D >/= 0.18 +/- 0.02. h(-1). We also challenged the AH22/T3 in chemostat culture (D = 0.25 h(-1)) with an equal number of untransformed cells (AH22). Transformed cells dominated the population (100%) within 8-10 h of growth, a time equivalent to two mean residence time.     

Redox Interactions between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces uvarum in Mixed Culture under Enological Conditions

Wine yeast starters that contain a mixture of different industrial yeasts with various properties may soon be introduced to the market. The mechanisms underlying the interactions between the different strains in the starter during alcoholic fermentation have never been investigated. We identified and investigated some of these interactions in a mixed culture containing two yeast strains grown under enological conditions. The inoculum contained the same amount (each) of a strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and a natural hybrid strain of S. cerevisiae and Saccharomyces uvarum. We identified interactions that affected biomass, by-product formation, and fermentation kinetics, and compared the redox ratios of monocultures of each strain with that of the mixed culture. The redox status of the mixed culture differed from that of the two monocultures, showing that the interactions between the yeast strains involved the diffusion of metabolite(s) within the mixed culture. Since acetaldehyde is a potential effector of fermentation, we investigated the kinetics of acetaldehyde production by the different cultures. The S. cerevisiae-S. uvarum hybrid strain produced large amounts of acetaldehyde for which the S. cerevisiae strain acted as a receiving strain in the mixed culture. Since yeast response to acetaldehyde involves the same mechanisms that participate in the response to other forms of stress, the acetaldehyde exchange between the two strains could play an important role in inhibiting some yeast strains and allowing the growth of others. Such interactions could be of particular importance in understanding the ecology of the colonization of complex fermentation media by S. cerevisiae.     

Pichia anomala DBVPG 3003 Secretes a Ubiquitin-Like Protein That Has Antimicrobial Activity

The yeast strain Pichia anomala DBVPG 3003 secretes a killer toxin (Pikt) that has antifungal activity against Brettanomyces/Dekkera sp. yeasts. Pikt interacts with β-1,6-glucan, consistent with binding to the cell wall of sensitive targets. In contrast to that of toxin K1, secreted by Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Pikt killer activity is not mediated by an increase in membrane permeability. Purification of the toxin yielded a homogeneous protein of about 8 kDa, which showed a marked similarity to ubiquitin in terms of molecular mass and N-terminal sequences. Pikt is also specifically recognized by anti-bovine ubiquitin antibodies and, similar to ubiquitin-like peptides, is not absorbed by DEAE-cellulose. However, Pikt differs from ubiquitin in its sensitivity to proteolytic enzymes. Therefore, Pikt appears to be a novel ubiquitin-like peptide that has killer activity.     

The Species-Specific Acquisition and Diversification of a K1-like Family of Killer Toxins in Budding Yeasts of the Saccharomycotina

Killer toxins are extracellular antifungal proteins that are produced by a wide variety of fungi, including Saccharomyces yeasts. Although many Saccharomyces killer toxins have been previously identified, their evolutionary origins remain uncertain given that many of these genes have been mobilized by double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) viruses. A survey of yeasts from the Saccharomyces genus has identified a novel killer toxin with a unique spectrum of activity produced by Saccharomyces paradoxus. The expression of this killer toxin is associated with the presence of a dsRNA totivirus and a satellite dsRNA. Genetic sequencing of the satellite dsRNA confirmed that it encodes a killer toxin with homology to the canonical ionophoric K1 toxin from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and has been named K1-like (K1L). Genomic homologs of K1L were identified in six non-Saccharomyces yeast species of the Saccharomycotina subphylum, predominantly in subtelomeric regions of the genome. When ectopically expressed in S. cerevisiae from cloned cDNAs, both K1L and its homologs can inhibit the growth of competing yeast species, confirming the discovery of a family of biologically active K1-like killer toxins. The sporadic distribution of these genes supports their acquisition by horizontal gene transfer followed by diversification. The phylogenetic relationship between K1L and its genomic homologs suggests a common ancestry and gene flow via dsRNAs and DNAs across taxonomic divisions. This appears to enable the acquisition of a diverse arsenal of killer toxins by different yeast species for potential use in niche competition.     

Phenotypic expression of Kluyveromyces lactis killer toxin against Saccharomyces spp.

The secretion of killer toxins by some strains of yeasts is a phenomenon of significant industrial importance. The activity of a recently discovered Kluyveromyces lactis killer strain against a sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain was determined on peptone-yeast extract-nutrient agar plates containing as the carbon source glucose, fructose, galactose, maltose, or glycerol at pH 4.5 or 6.5. Enhanced activity (50 to 90% increase) was found at pH 6.5, particularly on the plates containing galactose, maltose, or glycerol, although production of the toxin in liquid medium was not significantly different with either glucose or galactose as the carbon source. Results indicated that the action of the K. lactis toxin was not mediated by catabolite repression in the sensitive strain. Sensitivities of different haploid and polyploid Saccharomyces yeasts to the two different killer yeasts S. cerevisiae (RNA-plasmid-coded toxin) and K. lactis (DNA-plasmid-coded toxin) were tested. Three industrial polyploid yeasts sensitive to the S. cerevisiae killer yeast were resistant to the K. lactis killer yeast. The S. cerevisiae killer strain itself, however, was sensitive to the K. lactis killer yeast.     

Phenotypic expression of Kluyveromyces lactis killer toxin against Saccharomyces spp

The secretion of killer toxins by some strains of yeasts is a phenomenon of significant industrial importance. The activity of a recently discovered Kluyveromyces lactis killer strain against a sensitive Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain was determined on peptone-yeast extract-nutrient agar plates containing as the carbon source glucose, fructose, galactose, maltose, or glycerol at pH 4.5 or 6.5. Enhanced activity (50 to 90% increase) was found at pH 6.5, particularly on the plates containing galactose, maltose, or glycerol, although production of the toxin in liquid medium was not significantly different with either glucose or galactose as the carbon source. Results indicated that the action of the K. lactis toxin was not mediated by catabolite repression in the sensitive strain. Sensitivities of different haploid and polyploid Saccharomyces yeasts to the two different killer yeasts S. cerevisiae (RNA-plasmid-coded toxin) and K. lactis (DNA-plasmid-coded toxin) were tested. Three industrial polyploid yeasts sensitive to the S. cerevisiae killer yeast were resistant to the K. lactis killer yeast. The S. cerevisiae killer strain itself, however, was sensitive to the K. lactis killer yeast.     

Improved ethanol tolerance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in mixed cultures with Kluyveromyces lactis on high-sugar fermentation

The influence of non-Saccharomyces yeast, Kluyveromyces lactis, on metabolite formation and the ethanol tolerance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in mixed cultures was examined on synthetic minimal medium containing 20% glucose. In the late stage of fermentation after the complete death of K. lactis, S. cerevisiae in mixed cultures was more ethanol-tolerant than that in pure culture. The chronological life span of S. cerevisiae was shorter in pure culture than mixed cultures. The yeast cells of the late stationary phase both in pure and mixed cultures had a low buoyant density with no significant difference in the non-quiescence state between both cultures. In mixed cultures, the glycerol contents increased and the alanine contents decreased when compared with the pure culture of S. cerevisiae. The distinctive intracellular amino acid pool concerning its amino acid concentrations and its amino acid composition was observed in yeast cells with different ethanol tolerance in the death phase. Co-cultivation of K. lactis seems to prompt S. cerevisiae to be ethanol tolerant by forming opportune metabolites such as glycerol and alanine and/or changing the intracellular amino acid pool.     

The costs and benefits of killer toxin production by the yeast Pichia kluyveri

Numerous yeast species in many genera are able to produce and excrete extracellular toxic proteins (mycocins) that can kill other specific sensitive yeasts. Natural distributions of killer yeasts suggest that they may be important in maintaining community composition and provide a benefit to the toxin producing cells. The fact that not all yeasts are killers and that polymorphisms exist within some killer species suggests there may be a cost associated with killer toxin production. This study focuses on the costs and benefits associated with toxin production by the yeast Pichia kluyveri. Strains differing in their ability to kill were obtained by tetrad dissection. One parent strain produced spores that exhibited a trade-off between killing ability and intrinsic growth rate. A killer clone from this strain was able to maintain a higher proportion of cells than a non-killer when grown with the same sensitive yeast under laboratory-simulated natural conditions. On the other hand, when grown with a yeast not sensitive to Pichia kluyveri toxin, the non-killer maintained a higher proportion of the total community than did the killer clone. The data support the hypothesis that there are both costs and benefits to producing killer toxin, and based on this, selection may favor different phenotypes in different conditions.     

Mutual antagonism among killer yeasts: competition between K1 and K2 killers and a novel cDNA-based K1-K2 killer strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutually antagonistic K1 and K2 killer strains compete when mixed and serially subcultured. At pH 4.6, where the K1 killer toxin is more stable in vitro, the K1 strain outcompeted the K2 strains at both 18 and 30 degrees C. At pH 4.0, closer to the in vitro pH optimum of the K2 killer toxin, the K1 strain again predominated at 18 degrees C, but at 30 degrees C the K2 strains became the sole cell type on subculture. To show more clearly that these results were dependent upon the respective killer toxins, control experiments were conducted with isogenic, nonkiller strains cured of the dsRNA-based killer virions. Such nonkiller strains were unable to compete with antagonistic killers under conditions where their isogenic killer parents could, strongly suggesting that the killer phenotype was important in these competitions. Double K1-K2 killer strains cannot stably exist, as their dsRNA genomes compete at a replicative level. Using recombinant DNA methodology, a stable K1-K2 killer strain was constructed. This strain outcompeted both K1 and K2 killers when serially subcultured under conditions where either the K1 or the K2 strains would normally predominate in mixed cultures. Such a double killer may be useful in commercial fermentations, where there is a risk of contamination by killer yeasts.     

Isolation, Purification, and Characterization of a Killer Protein from Schwanniomyces occidentalis

The yeast Schwanniomyces occidentalis produces a killer toxin lethal to sensitive strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Killer activity is lost after pepsin and papain treatment, suggesting that the toxin is a protein. We purified the killer protein and found that it was composed of two subunits with molecular masses of approximately 7.4 and 4.9 kDa, respectively, but was not detectable with periodic acid-Schiff staining. A BLAST search revealed that residues 3 to 14 of the 4.9-kDa subunit had 75% identity and 83% similarity with killer toxin K2 from S. cerevisiae at positions 271 to 283. Maximum killer activity was between pH 4.2 and 4.8. The protein was stable between pH 2.0 and 5.0 and inactivated at temperatures above 40°C. The killer protein was chromosomally encoded. Mannan, but not β-glucan or laminarin, prevented sensitive yeast cells from being killed by the killer protein, suggesting that mannan may bind to the killer protein. Identification and characterization of a killer strain of S. occidentalis may help reduce the risk of contamination by undesirable yeast strains during commercial fermentations.     

Killer Toxin of Kluyveromyces phaffii DBVPG 6076 as a Biopreservative Agent To Control Apiculate Wine Yeasts

The use of Kluyveromyces phaffii DBVPG 6076 killer toxin against apiculate wine yeasts has been investigated. The killer toxin of K. phaffii DBVPG 6076 showed extensive anti-Hanseniaspora activity against strains isolated from grape samples. The proteinaceous killer toxin was found to be active in the pH range of 3 to 5 and at temperatures lower than 40°C. These biochemical properties would allow the use of K. phaffii killer toxin in wine making. Fungicidal or fungistatic effects depend on the toxin concentration. Toxin concentrations present in the supernatant during optimal conditions of production (14.3 arbitrary units) exerted a fungicidal effect on a sensitive strain of Hanseniaspora uvarum. At subcritical concentrations (fungistatic effect) the saturation kinetics observed with the increased ratio of killer toxin to H. uvarum cells suggest the presence of a toxin receptor. The inhibitory activity exerted by the killer toxin present in grape juice was comparable to that of sulfur dioxide. The findings presented suggest that the K. phaffii DBVPG 6076 killer toxin has potential as a biopreservative agent in wine making.     

Occurrence and Growth of Killer Yeasts during Wine Fermentation

Sixteen wine fermentations were examined for the presence of killer yeasts. Killer property and sensitivity to killer action were found in isolates of Saccharomyces cerevisiae but not in isolates of Kloeckera, Candida, Hansenula, and Torulaspora spp. Several killer and killer-sensitive strains of S. cerevisiae were differentiated by colony morphology, and this property was used to monitor their growth kinetics in mixed cultures in grape juice. Killer-sensitive strains died off within 24 to 48 h during mixed-strain fermentation. Killer action was demonstrated at pH 3.0 and pH 3.5 and over the range of 15 to 25°C but depended on the proportion of killer to killer-sensitive cells at the commencement of fermentation. The dominance of killer strains in mixed-strain fermentations was reflected in the production of ethanol, acetic acid, and glycerol.     

Interactions between Kluyveromyces marxianus and Saccharomyces cerevisiae in tequila must type medium fermentation

Traditional tequila fermentation is a complex microbial process performed by different indigenous yeast species. Usually, they are classified in two families: Saccharomyces and Non-Saccharomyces species. Using mixed starter cultures of several yeasts genera and species is nowadays considered to be beneficial to enhance the sensorial characteristics of the final products (taste, odor). However, microbial interactions occurring in such fermentations need to be better understood to improve the process. In this work, we focussed on a Saccharomyces cerevisiae/Kluyveromyces marxianus yeast couple. Indirect interactions due to excreted metabolites, thanks to the use of a specific membrane bioreactor, and direct interaction due to cell-to-cell contact have been explored. Comparison of pure and mixed cultures was done in each case. Mixed cultures in direct contact showed that both yeast were affected but Saccharomyces rapidly dominated the cultures whereas Kluyveromyces almost disappeared. In mixed cultures with indirect contact the growth of Kluyveromyces was decreased compared to its pure culture but its concentration could be maintained whereas the growth of Saccharomyces was enhanced. The loss of viability of Kluyveromyces could not be attributed only to ethanol. The sugar consumption and ethanol production in both cases were similar. Thus the interaction phenomena between the two yeasts are different in direct and indirect contact, Kluyveromyces being always much more affected than Saccharomyces.