Are we failing our teenagers? Value of a family planning service for teenagers within the sexually transmitted disease clinic.

Out of 100 teenage girls attending a sexually transmitted disease clinic for the first time, 77 were found to be using a reliable method of contraception and had similar characteristics to teenage girls attending a family planning clinic. The 23 girls not using any reliable contraception exhibited a different pattern of sexual behaviour and were at high risk of unplanned pregnancy. Subsequently, another group of 23 girls not using contraception when seen at the sexually transmitted disease clinic were actively encouraged to attend a family planning clinic. Their risk of unplanned pregnancy was much reduced, although their pattern of sexual activity was unchanged. Ready availability of contraceptive advice for unprotected teenagers in sexually transmitted disease clinics would reduce their high risk of unplanned pregnancy.     

Changing patterns of teenage pregnancy: population based study of small areas

ObjectivesTo measure the impact of socioeconomic deprivation on rates of teenage pregnancy and the extent of local variation in pregnancy rates in Scotland, and to examine how both have changed over time.Design Population study using routine data from hospital records, aggregated for small areas.Subjects Female teenagers resident in Scotland who were treated for pregnancy in an NHS hospital in either 1981-5 (62 338 teenagers) or 1991-5 (48 514) and who were aged 13-19 at the time of conception.Results From the 1980s to the 1990s pregnancy rates increased differentially according to levels of local deprivation, as measured by the Carstairs index. Among teenagers aged less than 18 the annual pregnancy rate increased in the most deprived areas (from 7.0 to 12.5 pregnancies per 1000 13-15 year olds and from 67.6 to 84.6 per 1000 16-17 year olds), but there was no change, on average, among teenagers in the most affluent areas (3.8 per 1000 13-15 year olds and 28.9 per 1000 16-17 year olds). Among 18-19 year olds the pregnancy rate decreased in the most affluent areas (from 60.0 to 46.3 per 1000) and increased in the most deprived areas (from 112.4 to 116.0 per 1000). The amount of local variation explained by deprivation more than doubled from the 1980s to the 1990s. The proportion of pregnancies resulting in a maternity was positively associated with level of deprivation, but the effect remained similar over time.Conclusion From the 1980s to the 1990s the difference in rates of teenage pregnancy between more affluent and more deprived areas widened. This has implications for allocating resources to achieve government targets and points to important social processes behind the general increase in the number of teenage pregnancies in Scotland.

What is already known on this topic

Rates of teenage pregnancy are considerably higher in the United Kingdom than in other western European countriesIn the United Kingdom rates of teenage pregnancy are known to be higher in areas of greater socioeconomic deprivation, although local variation may also reflect differential access to family planning services

What this study adds

From 1981-5 to 1991-5 rates of teenage pregnancy in Scotland increased more rapidly in areas of greater socioeconomic deprivationIn the 1990s socioeconomic deprivation explained more than 50% of local variation in rates of teenage pregnancy, more than double the amount explained by it in the 1980s     

Contraceptive experience and attitudes to motherhood of teenage mothers

Sexual experience is increasingly common among teenagers. Evidence suggests that while many teenage pregnancies are unintended, teenagers remain less than totally effective users of contraception. This study examines a sample of 102 teenage mothers (under age 20 at delivery) presented at antenatal booking clinics in Bristol Health District England. Of these, 25% were married at time of conception; 31 of them had been pregnant previously; 2/3 had used contraception previously. Contraceptive users were older than nonusers, more likely to be married, and more likely to be white. Most of the older users had been using the pill, and gave varied accounts of why they stopped. Just over 25% of the pregnancies were considered "planned" and about 1/2 the teenagers were upset on hearing the news of the pregnancy. 9 of the study pregnancies failed due to miscarriage (3), stillbirth (4), and neonatal death (2). Most of the girls who lost their babies came from parts of Bristol where infant mortality is high. 28.4% of the sample had previously used contraception but became pregnant without desiring to and were upset at the news. Many had given up a reliable technique (such as the pill) without substituting any alternative. This group presents a challenge for those providing contraceptive services, especially in view of the restricted opportunities available to working class girls.     

Association between teenage pregnancy rates and the age and sex of general practitioners: cross sectional survey in Trent 1994-7

This cross-sectional study examined variations in teenage pregnancy rates in the Trent region, UK, and determined possible associations with local general practice characteristics such as the age and sex of the doctors. The study sample included all pregnancies of teenagers, aged 13-19 years, between 1994 and 1997 that resulted in a hospital admission. It also included all 826 general practices in the Trent region between 1994 and 1997. Upon a multivariate analysis, lower teenage pregnancy rates were associated with the presence of a female or young doctor and more nurse time. Practices in deprived areas had higher teenage pregnancy rates. Overall, general practices with female doctors, young doctors, or more nurse time had lower teenage pregnancy rates. These findings may have implications for the mix of health professionals within primary care.     

Teenage pregnancy in the Bahamas: trends and characteristics

This survey of 99 pregnant teenagers in clinics on the island of New Providence, Bahamas, produced data suggesting that they are similar to their counterparts in urban clinics in the U.S.A. The pregnancies usually came from relationships of many months' standing, which were meaningful to the young mothers, rather than from "promiscuous" sexual behavior. Few of the young mothers had been using birth control before they became pregnant, sometimes because of a lack of expectation of needing it or from fear or ignorance about birth control, and sometimes due to an inability to organize their lives sufficiently to find, purchase, and use regularly the contraception that would have prevented the pregnancy. Most of the young mothers felt that abortion was sinful and would not have used it at any time. It is suggested that these general characteristics of teenage pregnancy are common in Western societies and are related to the perceived loneliness and uselessness of the teenage period. The pregnancies often may be seen as an attempt by teenagers, who see relatively little future for themselves in traditional education and employment, to strive for a creative life rooted in loving relationships.     

The prevalent use of contraception among teenagers in Denmark and the corresponding low pregnancy rate

In Denmark the number of births and induced abortions among teenagers has reduced and teenage parenthood is now rare. This paper evaluates the correlation between this observed fertility and reported sexual and contraceptive behaviour. In 1989 a sample of 16-20-year-olds in Denmark was selected at random and personally interviewed about sexual and contraceptive behaviour. Ninety-five per cent of the young women who had experienced sexual intercourse used contraception at the most recent sexual intercourse. In order to support the validity of this finding a model was developed to estimate an expected number of conceptions in the age groups concerned. The model included both the information on coital frequency and use of contraception from the questionnaire and available efficacy rates on contraception. The estimates derived by the model were compared with the registered number of births and induced abortions derived from public registers. The analysis revealed a high accordance between the estimated number of conceptions and the registered number of births and induced abortions for each age group. This underlines the validity of the data on sexual and contraceptive behaviour sampled among teenagers in Denmark. The findings indicate that contraceptive failure is a much greater problem than non-use of contraception for teenagers in Denmark.     

Teenagers' knowledge of emergency contraception: questionnaire survey in south east Scotland.

OBJECTIVE--To determine the level of knowledge of emergency contraception among 14 and 15 year olds. DESIGN--Confidential questionnaire survey. SETTING--10 secondary schools in Lothian, south east Scotland. SUBJECTS--1206 pupils predominantly (98.7%) aged 14 and 15 in the fourth year of secondary school. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Knowledge of the existence of emergency contraception; of its safety, efficacy, and time limits; and of where to obtain it. RESULTS--1121 (93.0%) fourth year pupils aged 14-16 had heard of emergency contraception. 194 girls (32.7%) and 168 boys (27.5%) had experienced sexual intercourse. Of girls who had experienced sexual intercourse, 61 (31.4%) had used emergency contraception. Knowledge of correct time limits was poor, sexually active girls being the most knowledgeable. Pupils attending schools ranked lower than the national average for academic attainment were less likely to have heard of emergency contraception and more likely to have been sexually active. 861 (76.8%) pupils knew they could obtain emergency contraception from their doctor. 925 (82.5%) pupils believed emergency contraception to be effective but 398 (35.5%) thought it more dangerous than the oral contraceptive pill. CONCLUSIONS--One third of sexually active girls aged under 16 in Lothian have used emergency contraception. This may help explain the fairly constant teenage pregnancy rates despite increasing sexual activity. Scottish teenagers are well informed about the existence of emergency contraception. However, many do not know when and how to access it properly. Health education initiatives should target teenagers from less academic schools as they are more likely to be sexually active at a young age and are less well informed about emergency contraception.     

Citizens' advice in general practice.

OBJECTIVE--To examine the introduction of citizens advice bureau sessions into general practice. DESIGN--Prospective survey of 150 consecutive attenders. SETTING--10 Practices in south Birmingham that volunteered to participate. OUTCOME MEASURES--The social characteristics of the population attending, the problems presented, the social security and other payments obtained, and the health problems mentioned during the sessions. RESULTS--Advice requested covered the whole range offered by the citizens advice bureaus. Thirty nine of 150 attenders obtained payments totalling 58,300.58 pounds for year 1991-2, of which 54,929.58 pounds was recurring. People mentioning health problems were significantly more likely to be entitled to unclaimed benefits. CONCLUSIONS--The provision of citizens advice bureau sessions in general practice is an effective way of providing advice on life problems and securing proper payment of benefits, particularly to patients with health problems. This service complements rather than detracts from other citizens advice bureau activities.     

King's Termination Study II: Contraceptive Practice before and after Outpatient Termination of Pregnancy

A selection of psychological and social factors present in 360 women who underwent legal termination of pregnancy are related to their contraceptive practice. One-third of the group were ignorant about contraceptive methods, ignorance being more common in women from social classes IV and V and in those under the age of 19. Nearly half of those who had some knowledge of contraceptive practice became pregnant after knowingly taking a risk. A total of 41% had been using some form of contraception immediately before conception. The reliability of contraceptive methods used was found to be inversely related to neuroticism scores obtained from the Eysenck Personality Inventory, neuroticism being highest in women who had not used any form of contraception.Of 91% of the group seen three months after their termination 86% were using reliable contraceptive methods. A follow-up study one or two years after termination has shown that 81% of the 215 women contacted so far are using a reliable method of contraception; two unwanted pregnancies have occurred but both were due to contraceptive failure. This satisfactory outcome has been ascribed to the system of counselling all women before and after termination.     

Why is the number of pregnancies among teenagers decreasing?

The issue of pregnancy among adolescent women has received considerable attention from the media. Contrary to common belief, both the numbers and the rates of such pregnancies, even when data on abortion are included, have been declining. Patterns of contraception may account for some of the decrease; however, more study is required. In the past, unmarried teenagers who became pregnant either got married or put the baby up for adoption. Now they can either have an abortion or keep the baby. Solutions to the problems of pregnancy among teenagers must therefore be addressed to these altered social consequences rather than to misleading comments about "epidemics", with their suggestion of increased rates of pregnancy.     

Seasonality of birth and conception to teenagers in Texas

We study the births to teenagers during the years 1964-2000 and analyze separately the three main racial/ethnic groups in Texas (White, Hispanic, and African American), as well as married and unmarried teens during the years 1994-2000. By using traditional statistical methods of analysis and a filter based on the multiresolution wavelet analysis, we draw inferences about the times of the year when adolescent females of different racial/ethnic and marital groups have the highest probability for pregnancy ending in live birth. Multiple factors influencing teen pregnancy are identified and associated with temporal features of social, cultural, educational, and familial processes. In particular, we detect links between unmarried teen conception times and school terms, and weekly birth patterns associated with scheduled c-sections that differ according to racial/ethnic groups.     

A Scoring Tool to Identify East African HIV-1 Serodiscordant Partnerships with a High Likelihood of Pregnancy

Introduction

HIV-1 prevention programs targeting HIV-1 serodiscordant couples need to identify couples that are likely to become pregnant to facilitate discussions about methods to minimize HIV-1 risk during pregnancy attempts (i.e. safer conception) or effective contraception when pregnancy is unintended. A clinical prediction tool could be used to identify HIV-1 serodiscordant couples with a high likelihood of pregnancy within one year.

Methods

Using standardized clinical prediction methods, we developed and validated a tool to identify heterosexual East African HIV-1 serodiscordant couples with an increased likelihood of becoming pregnant in the next year. Datasets were from three prospectively followed cohorts, including nearly 7,000 couples from Kenya and Uganda participating in HIV-1 prevention trials and delivery projects.

Results

The final score encompassed the age of the woman, woman’s number of children living, partnership duration, having had condomless sex in the past month, and non-use of an effective contraceptive. The area under the curve (AUC) for the probability of the score to correctly predict pregnancy was 0.74 (95% CI 0.72–0.76). Scores ≥7 predicted a pregnancy incidence of >17% per year and captured 78% of the pregnancies. Internal and external validation confirmed the predictive ability of the score.

Discussion

A pregnancy likelihood score encompassing basic demographic, clinical and behavioral factors defined African HIV-1 serodiscordant couples with high one-year pregnancy incidence rates. This tool could be used to engage African HIV-1 serodiscordant couples in counseling discussions about fertility intentions in order to offer services for safer conception or contraception that align with their reproductive goals.     

Profile of young people's advice clinic in reproductive health, 1988-93.

For an unprepared sexually active teenager the 1990s present a minefield of potential problems in addition to the most obvious problems of unplanned pregnancy and sexually transmitted disease. Promoting the importance of a healthy sexual and reproductive life to young people requires openness, better sex education, realistic discussion of related issues, and provision of contraception, as well as support if things go wrong. The Woodhouse Park Clinic in south Manchester opened in October 1988 with the aim of providing weekly advice sessions to young people up to the age of 18. Advice is given on topics such as substance misuse and smoking as well as on family planning. Attendance has steadily increased over the years; from April to June 1993 the average number of attenders per session was 39, one third of whom were young men.     

Age of mother and pregnancy outcome in the 1981 Arkansas birth cohort

Higher levels of obstetric risk observed among teenage mothers seem to be an artifact of lower socioeconomic status and inferior access to health care rather than biological immaturity. In a study of matched Arkansas birth-infant death records for 1978, the proxy variables for health access (month care started and number of visits) have the strongest association with each of the dependent variables. The indicators of social status (education, race, and marital status) have a weaker association, and there is virtually no age effect observable once the affects of socioeconomic status and health access have been controlled for. A series of stepwise regression analyses shows that the multiple partial for health access indicators and mortality is 0.036, while the same coefficients for social status indicators and age are 0.001 and 0.006, respectively. Similar results are obtained using the other dependent variables. Health consequences of adolescent pregnancy usually include higher rates of malnutrition and prematurity and lower birth weight. It seems that the elevated morbidity and mortality among newborns delivered by teenagers are not a result of biologic factors. After the effects of lower status and health care access have been removed, the apparent biological disadvantages attributed to teenagers disappear, and, in the case of mortality and birth weight, are replaced by a slight advantage. This advantage is observed through the use of statisitical controls and will not be observed in the population at large unless there are changes in the policies governing access to contraception, abortion, and health care by adolescents, especially those at the youngest ages.     

Effectiveness of abortion as birth control.

Several models used to study the effectiveness of abortion in population limitation are examined. The Keyfitz model, based on the probability that an individual woman will conceive in a given month, is extended and public implications of legal abortions are discussed. A model more appropriate for a population of women rather than a single woman can be developed by relating the probability of conception and the sterile intervals to the number of birth and the number of women in the population. The effectiveness of abortion as a birth control method is studied using this model and includes: 1) abortion effectiveness combined with efficient contraception (95% effective); 2) the sensitivity of abortion to gestation when a contraceptive of lower efficiency is used; 3) these effects modified for prolonged lactation; 4) the effect of changing the monthly probability of conception and the monthly efficiency of contraception. Abortion later in pregnancy is advantageous when efficient contraception is absent. The effectiveness of abortion to gestation is approximately the same whether lactation is included or absent, although abortion is more effective at all gestations and for all contraceptives efficiencies in the absence of lactation. The sensitivity of the effectiveness of abortion to the probability of conception decreases as monthly effectiveness of contraception increases. The probability of conception and the monthly effectiveness of contraception are difficult parameters to measure in the population. The effect of abortion averaged over the entire population at risk of pregnancy is different from its effect on certain subgroups. For U.S. females the probability of conception may be between .06 and .16, and from the model it is indicated that the effectiveness of abortion would be from 1 to 1.13 abortions per live birth. The application of the model suggests that the expenditures for abortion services in this population are a reasonable investment, although investment for efficient contraception is also suggested.     

Family planning method change and dropouts in the Philippines

Pregnancy prevention techniques are classified into 2 general categories as the coitus-connected and coitus-independent. The former include rhythm, withdrawal, condom, and foam while the latter include such methods as oral contraception, IUDs, and male and female sterilization. The use of contraception hinges on motivation and the acceptability of the method. This article is a report on 1 particular study where data was collected in 1971-1972 through 1321 interviews resulting from a series of audits of family planning clinics with the purpose of determining the accuracy of information reported in clinic records and ascertaining the number of acceptors who had discontinued use of a family planning method or moved from the area served by the clinic. The findings revealed that: 1) Coitus-independent methods are more effective in the prevention of pregnancy that coitus-dependent ones, 2) Women who change from a coitus-dependent method are more likely to change to a coitus-independent method, while the changes from the latter method are usually to a method in the same general category, 3) In this population the IUD provides the maximum protection from conception with the minimum likelihood of program dropout.     

Deliveries in teenagers at a Newfoundland general hospital.

A study of deliveries in teenagers was undertaken for the year 1975 in a hospital that had recorded 2797 births, 371 (13%) of which were to women under 20 years of age. Conception had occurred out of wedlock in 314 (85%) of the 371 pregnancies; 124 of the 314 women had married during the pregnancy, most often in the 3rd or 4th month of gestation. The peak months for conception out of wedlock were June and December. This was not the first pregnancy for 65 women (18%), 21 of whom had married during a previous pregnancy. Of the "heads of the households" 36% were labourers and 27% were unemployed. Cesarean section was the method of delivery for 51 (14%) of the women, and 63 (17%) were reported as having had toxemia. There were seven perinatal deaths and seven infants had severe congenital abnormalities. The frequency of low birth weight was 6% overall but 13% for the infants of single women. Five women underwent tubal ligation post partum.     

Lessons from an audit of unplanned pregnancies.

To determine the effectiveness of contraceptive use a two year audit of pregnant women registered in one group practice was carried out. The methods of contraception used by women with unplanned pregnancies were studied and the rates of failure assessed. Of the 518 pregnancies during the study, 187 (36%) were unplanned. Unplanned pregnancies were most common in the 15-19 age group (54 out of 187), and women aged under 25 used contraceptives less reliably than women aged 25 and over. The combined pill was the most effective method of contraception in all age groups. The methods that resulted in most unplanned pregnancies were the sheath in women aged 25 and over and incorrect use of oral contraceptive or no contraception in those aged under 25. The fear of side effects was an important reason why women did not use the combined pill, being cited by 22 out of 134 women, and inappropriate medical advice was cited by a further 20 women. More discussion between doctors and patients and readily available information on the use of oral contraceptives might help to reduce the number of unplanned pregnancies.