In vivo interactions between ionizing radiation, inflammation and chemical carcinogens identified by increased DNA damage responses

Exposure to ionizing radiation or a variety of chemical agents is known to increase the risk of developing malignancy and many tumors have been linked to inflammatory processes. In most studies, the potentially harmful effects of ionizing radiation or other agents are considered in isolation, mainly due to the large number of experiments required to assess the effects of mixed exposures with different doses and different schedules, and the length of time and expense of studies using disease as the measure of outcome. Here, we have used short-term DNA damage responses to identify interactive effects of mixed exposures. The data demonstrate that exposure to ionizing radiation on two separate occasions ten days apart leads to an increase in the percentage of cells with a sub-G(0) DNA content compared to cells exposed only once, and this is a greater than additive effect. Short-term measurements of p53 stabilization, induction of p21/Cdkn1a and of apoptosis also identify these interactive effects. We also demonstrate similar interactive effects of radiation with the mutagenic chemical methyl-nitrosourea and with a nonspecific pro-inflammatory agent, lipopolysaccharide. The magnitude of the interactive effects is greater in cells taken from mice first exposed as juveniles compared to adults. These data indicate that short-term measurements of DNA damage and response to damage are useful for the identification of interactions between ionizing radiation and other agents.     

Recovery of yeast cells after exposure to ionizing radiation and hyperthermia

Quantitative regularities of recovery of wild-type diploid yeast cells irradiated with gamma-rays (60Co) simultaneously with exposure to high temperatures were studied. It was shown that in conditions of such a combined action the constant of recovery did not depend on the temperature at which the irradiation was carried out. However, with an increase of acting temperature an augmentation in the portion of irreversible component was registered. The analysis of cell inactivation revealed that the augmentation of the irreversible component was accompanied by a continuous increase of cell killing without any postirradiation division after which cells are incapable of recovery. The reproductive death was mainly exerted after ionizing radiation applied alone while in conditions of simultaneous thermoradiation action the interphase killing (cell death without division) predominated. It is concluded on this base that the mechanism of synergistic interaction of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia may be related with cardinal change in mechanisms of cell killing.     

Survival and recovery of yeast cells after combined treatment with ionizing radiation and heat

Cell survival, recovery kinetics and inactivation forms after successive and simultaneous treatments with gamma rays (60Co) and high temperatures were studied in diploid yeast cells capable of recovery. Both the extent and the rate of the recovery were shown to be greatly decreased with increase in the duration of heat treatment (60 degrees C) followed by radiation and with increase in exposure temperature after simultaneous treatment with heat and radiation. A quantitative approach describing the recovery process was used to estimate the probability of recovery per unit time and the irreversible component of damage after the combined treatment with heat and radiation. It was shown that the probability of recovery was independent of the conditions of the treatment with heat and radiation, while the irreversible component gradually increased as a function of the duration of heat treatment (60 degrees C) after sequential treatment with heat and radiation and as a function of the exposure temperature after simultaneous treatment with heat and radiation. The increase in the irreversible component was accompanied by an increase in cell death without postirradiation division. It is concluded on this basis that the synergistic interaction of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia in yeast cells is not related to the impairment of the recovery capacity itself and that it may be attributed to an increased yield of irreversible damage.     

The influence of chemical inhibitors of DNA repair on the recovery of mammalian cell damages induced by ionizing radiation

Using experimental results published by other authors the irreversible component of radiation damage and recovery constant, characterized the probability of recovery of mammalian cells of various origin from radiation damages per unit time, have been calculated. It was shown that the inhibition of postirradiation recovery, displayed in the decreasing of both the rate and the volume of recovery, has occurred due to the increasing in the portion of radiation damages from which the cell is incapable to recover. At the same time the recovery constant was independent on the conditions of combined action in the most cases, being decreasing in small extent only for hydroxyurea and 3-aminobenzamide. It was concluded that the inhibition of recovery is not the main reason of chemical radiosensibilization, but is a quite expected consequence of the increase in the portion of irreversibly damaged cells.     

The prognosis of the portion of irreversible radiation damages after simultaneous action of hyperthermia and ionizing radiation on yeast cells

The results of experimental research of diploid yeasts cells survival after simultaneous action of hyperthermia and ionizing radiation (60Co) have been described. It was shown that the cell ability to liquid holding recovery decreased with an increase in the temperature, at which the exposure was carried out. due to the increase in the irreversible component determining the relative part of radiation damage which cells are incapable to recover. To predict theoretically the relative part of irreversible radiation damage after combined action, the mathematical model was suggested taking into account the synergistic interaction of agents. Good correlation between experimental results and model prediction was demonstrated. The importance of the results obtained for the interpretation of the mechanism of synergistic interaction of various factors is discussed.     

The recovery parameters of DNA strand breaks of Ehrlich ascites cells after the combined action of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia

A mathematical model of DNA strand breaks postirradiation repair and the methodology allowing to differentiate the mechanism of inhibition of DNA strand breaks recovery after combined actions of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia have been described in this paper. Using this model and the results published by other authors for DNA strand breaks of Ehrlich ascites cells, there have been obtained the data showing that the portion of DNA-damages that the cell incapable to recover after consecutive thermoradiation action was risen with an increase in thermal load under insignificant change of repair constant. It means the mechanism of DNA strand breaks recovery inhibition is realized in a greater extent through the formation of irreversible damages but not through the damage of repair process itself.     

Quantitative estimation of the recovery parameters of yeast cells irradiated in the presence of cysteamine

Study of the postirradiation recovery parameters of diploid yeast cells showed that the irreversible component of radiation damage was identical after the cell exposure in the presence and absence of cysteamine. On this basis, it is concluded that the radioprotector equally reduced the number of both irreversible and repairable primary radiation damages. Application of the mathematical model of recovery processes to the results obtained allowed us to draw a conclusion that the probability of cell recovery from the radiation damage per time unit was also identical after cell exposure in the presence and absence of cysteamine.     

Liquid holding recovery kinetics in wild-type and radiosensitive mutants of the yeast Saccharomyces exposed to low- and high-LET radiations

Three wild-type diploid yeast strains Saccharomyces ellipsoideus and Saccharomyces cerevisiae and five radiosensitive mutants of S. cerevisiae in the diploid state were irradiated with gamma-rays from 60Co and alpha-particles from 239Pu in the stationary phase of growth. Survival curves and the kinetics of the liquid holding recovery were measured. It was shown that the irreversible component was enhanced for the densely ionizing radiation in comparison to the low-LET radiation while the probability of the recovery was identical for both the low- and high-LET radiations for all the strains investigated. It means that the recovery process itself is not damaged after densely ionizing radiation and the enhanced RBE of the high-LET radiation may be caused by the increased yield of the irreversible damage. A parent diploid strain and all its radiosensitive mutants showed the same probability for recovery from radiation damage. Thus, the mechanism of the enhanced radiosensitivity of the mutant cells might not be related to the damage of the repair systems themselves but with the production of some kind of radiation damage from which cells are incapable to recover.     

Clustered DNA damages induced by x rays in human cells

Although DNA DSBs are known to be important in producing the damaging effects of ionizing radiation in cells, bistranded clustered DNA damages-two or more oxidized bases, abasic sites or strand breaks on opposing DNA strands within a few helical turns-are postulated to be difficult to repair and thus to be critical radiation-induced lesions. Gamma rays can induce clustered damages in DNA in solution, and high-energy iron ions produce DSBs and oxidized pyrimidine clusters in human cells, but it was not known whether sparsely ionizing radiation can produce clustered damages in mammalian cells. We show here that X rays induce abasic clusters, oxidized pyrimidine clusters, and oxidized purine clusters in DNA in human cells. Non-DSB clustered damages comprise about 70% of the complex lesions produced in cells. The relative levels of specific cluster classes depend on the environment of the DNA.     

Low efficiency of repair of critical DNA damage induced by low doses of radiation

This study provides an analysis of the development of cellular response to the critical DNA damage and the mechanisms for limiting the efficiency of repairing such damages induced by low doses of ionizing radiation exposure. Based on the data of many studies, one can conclude that the majority of damages occurring in the DNA of the cells after exposure to ionizing radiation significantly differ in their chemical nature from the endogenous ones. The most important characteristic of radiation-induced DNA damages is their complexity and clustering. Double strand breaks, interstrand crosslinks or destruction of the replication fork and formation of long single-stranded gaps in DNA are considered to be critical damages for the fate of cells. The occurrence of such lesions in DNA may be a key event in the etiology and the therapy of cancer. The appearance in the cells of the critical DNA damage induces a rapid development of a complex and ramified network of molecular and biochemical reactions which are called the cellular response to DNA damage. Induction of the cellular response to DNA damage involves the activation of the systems of cell cycle checkpoints, DNA repair, changes in the expression of many genes, reconstruction of the chromatin or apoptosis. However, the efficiency of repair of the complex DNA damage in cells after exposure to low doses of radiation remains at low levels. The development of the cell response to DNA damages after exposure to low doses of radiation does not reach the desired result due to a small amount of damage, with the progression of the phase cell cycle being ahead of the processes of DNA repair. This is primarily due to the failure of signalization to activate the checkpoint of the cell cycle for its arrest in the case of a small number of critical DNA lesions. In the absence of the arrest of the phase cell cycle progression, especially during the G2/M transition, the reparation mechanisms fail to completely restore DNA, and cells pass into mitosis with a damaged DNA. It is assumed that another reason for the low efficiency of DNA repair in the cells after exposure to low doses of radiation is the existence of a restricted access for the repair system components to the complex damages at the DNA sites of highly compacted chromatin.     

Modification of the radiosensitivity of E. coli cells by factors affecting the yield of photoreactivated damage

A study was made of the influence of irradiation conditions on the yield of the photoreactivable damages in radiosensitive mutants of E. coli cells (E. coli WP2). Pyrimidine dimers were shown to occur in exrA- and recA- mutants irradiated under anoxic conditions, the survival of these mutants being modified depending on cell genotype. The processes of direct excitation of the molecules were involved in the formation of the damages observed. It can be assumed that the lesser oxygen effect observed in exrA- and partially in recA- mutants of E. coli WP2 cells is associated with a contribution of the photoreactivable damages to a lethal effect of ionizing radiation.     

Premolecular period of the postradiation remodelling of cells

Recovery of yeast cells after exposure to ionizing radiation was found in 1957. During the first decade, i.e. in the "premolecular period" of studying the phenomenon, its basic features were revealed: dependence on ploidy of cells, on their energy exchange, on radiation LTE, and others. A mathematical model of recovery was proposed; the damages causing death of irradiated haploid and diploid cells were shown to be double strand breaks of DNA. The concepts of universal biological importance of the cell property to repair genetic damages were formulated.     

Comparative study of RBE of densely ionizing radiation for various types of cell death in yeast

A comparative study of the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of alpha-particles 249Pu for reproductive and interphase forms of killing of haploid and diploid yeast cells of wild-type and their radiosensitive mutants has been carried out. The correlation between the RBE of alpha-particles and cell repair capacity was confirmed for reproductive death: it was the highest for diploid cells, smaller for haploid cells and the smallest for their radiosensitive mutants. To achieve the interphase cell killing much higher irradiation doses were used after which cells were incapable of liquid-holding recovery during the storing of exposed cells in non-nutrient media at 30 degrees C. The RBE values for this form of killing were significantly lower in comparison with reproductive death. These data are an additional argument supporting the point of view that the RBE of densely ionizing radiation is determined not merely by physical processes of energy absorption as it is traditionally believed but also by ability of cells to recover from DNA damages inflicted by ionizing radiation.     

Involvement of DNA polymerase beta in repair of ionizing radiation damage as measured by in vitro plasmid assays

Characteristic of damage introduced in DNA by ionizing radiation is the induction of a wide range of lesions. Single-strand breaks (SSBs) and base damages outnumber double-strand breaks (DSBs). If unrepaired, these lesions can lead to DSBs and increased mutagenesis. XRCC1 and DNA polymerase beta (polbeta) are thought to be critical elements in the repair of these SSBs and base damages. XRCC1-deficient cells display a radiosensitive phenotype, while proliferating polbeta-deficient cells are not more radiosensitive. We have recently shown that cells deficient in polbeta display increased radiosensitivity when confluent. In addition, cells expressing a dominant negative to polbeta have been found to be radiosensitized. Here we show that repair of radiation-induced lesions is inhibited in extracts with altered polbeta or XRCC1 status, as measured by an in vitro repair assay employing irradiated plasmid DNA. Extracts from XRCC1-deficient cells showed a dramatically reduced capacity to repair ionizing radiation-induced DNA damage. Extracts deficient in polbeta or containing a dominant negative to polbeta also showed reduced repair of radiation-induced SSBs. Irradiated repaired plasmid DNA showed increased incorporation of radioactive nucleotides, indicating use of an alternative long-patch repair pathway. These data show a deficiency in repair of ionizing radiation damage in extracts from cells deficient or altered in polbeta activity, implying that increased radiosensitivity resulted from radiation damage repair deficiencies.     

Some effects of radiation hormesis for bacterial and yeast cells

A comparative study of chronic and acute action of ionizing radiation on the processes of aging and dying off of bacterial and yeast cells was carried out. It was ascertained that chronic action of ionizing radiation, 2-10,000 times exceeded the natural background, resulted in slowing down of aging and dying off of both pro- and eukaryotic cells. A single acute irradiation of yeast also resulted in the retardation of dying off of the yeast cells surviving after irradiation. The data is presented demonstrating a great increase in the survival of yeast cells under their repeated irradiation after recovery from potentially lethal radiation.     

Dependence of the radiosensitivity of yeast cells on the LET of radiations. Experiments on haploid cells

The previously developed model was used to study the dependence of radiosensitivity (D0(-1) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (the wild type and radiosensitive mutant) on linear energy transfer (LET) of ionizing radiation. D0(-1) (L) of haploid yeasts was shown to be associated, to a certain extent, with the capacity of radiation damages repair. As to the wild-type cells, the above function was represented by a curve showing a maximum, while a descending curve was characteristic of the radiosensitive mutant cells deficient in radiation damages repair. The influence of the repair processes on cell radiosensitivity decreased with increasing LET.     

Mathematical model of a simultaneous combined effect of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia

A mathematical model has been proposed suggesting that the synergistic action of a combination of ionizing radiation and hyperthermia is conditioned by additional lethal damages arising from the interaction of "sub-lesions" induced by both agents. The model describes quantitatively the synergism of the combined action of the agents used and predicts the maximal value of the synergistic effect and conditions in which it can be achieved.     

Effect of elevated temperatures on the radiation sensitivity of yeast cells of different species

Summary The influence of hyperthermia on the survival of irradiated yeast cells of different species has been studied. The experiments reported in the paper have shown: (1) simultaneous action of ionizing radiation and high temperatures appeared to increase the radiation response by a factor of approximately 2.7 for diploid and only by a factor of 1.5 for haploid cells of wild-type; (2) the combined action of high temperature and ionizing radiation had no synergistic effect for rad51 mutant diploid yeast cells; (3) heating before or after irradiation did not alter the radiation response of yeast cells; (4) enhancement of yeast cell sensitivity by simultaneous action of hyperthermia and²³⁹Pu--particles was negligible; (5) the magnitude and the rate of liquid holding recovery is lowered with increasing of irradiation temperature. On this basis, it was concluded that possible mechanism for thermal sensitization of yeast cells may involve the reduced capacity of cells to recover damages resulted from the combined action of both modalities.     

Rescue of mitomycin C- or psoralen-inactivated Micrococcus radiodurans by additional exposure to radiation or alkylating agents

The processing of damaged DNA was altered in a mitomycin C-sensitive mutant (mtcA) of Micrococcus radiodurans. Even though the mutant retained resistance to 254-nm UV radiation, it did not, in contrast to the wild-type strain, show any excessive DNA degradation or cell death when incubated with chloramphenicol after sublethal doses of either UV light or mitomycin C. The results suggest the constitutive synthesis of an enzyme system responsible for wild-type proficiency in the repair of mitomycin C-induced damage. An alternative system able to repair damage caused by mitomycin C was demonstrated in the mtcA background. In this strain, additional damage inflicted upon the cellular DNA effected a massive rescue of cells previously inactivated by mitomycin C. Rescue was provoked by ionizing radiation, by UV light, or by simple alkylating agents. Cells treated with psoralen plus near-UV radiation could be rescued only when inactivation was due primarily to psoralen-DNA interstrand cross-links rather than to monoadducts. The rescue of inactivated cells was prevented in the presence of chloramphenicol. These results can be interpreted most readily in terms of an alternative repair system able to overcome DNA interstrand cross-links produced by mitomycin C or psoralen plus near-UV light, but induced only by the more abundant number of damages produced by radiation or simple alkylating agents.     

Attempted base excision repair of ionizing radiation damage in human lymphoblastoid cells produces lethal and mutagenic double strand breaks

A significant proportion of cellular DNA damages induced by ionizing radiation are produced in clusters, also called multiply damaged sites. It has been demonstrated by in vitro studies and in bacteria that clustered damage sites can be converted to lethal double strand breaks by oxidative DNA glycosylases during attempted base excision repair. To determine whether DNA glycosylases could produce double strand breaks at radiation-induced clustered damages in human cells, stably transformed human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells that inducibly overexpress the oxidative DNA glycosylases/AP lyases, hNTH1 and hOGG1, were assessed for their radiation responses, including survival, mutation induction and the enzymatic production of double strand breaks post-irradiation. We found that additional double strand breaks were generated during post-irradiation incubation in uninduced TK6 control cells. Moreover, overproduction of either DNA glycosylase resulted in significantly increased double strand break formation, which correlated with an elevated sensitivity to the cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of ionizing radiation. These data show that attempted repair of radiation damage, presumably at clustered damage sites, by the oxidative DNA glycosylases can lead to the formation of potentially lethal and mutagenic double strand breaks in human cells.