A survey of DNA diagnostic laboratories regarding DNA banking.

This article reports the findings of a survey of 148 academically based and commercial DNA diagnostic labs regarding DNA banking (defined as the storage of individual DNA samples in some form with identifiers for later retrieval). The population surveyed consisted of all laboratories listed with HELIX, a national directory of DNA diagnostic labs that includes a fairly comprehensive listing of clinical service labs as well as a large number of research labs. The survey was concerned primarily with the legal and ethical issues that the long-term storage of DNA may raise. The survey inquired into the respondents' policies and procedures concerning (1) the extent of DNA banking and of interest in developing DNA banking in academia and industry and (2) the degree to which DNA banks had developed written internal policies and/or a written depositor's agreement (a signed document defining the rights and obligations of the person from whom the sample was taken and the bank) designed to anticipate or prevent some of the ethical and legal problems that can arise from the long-term retention of DNA. Our research suggests that (1) the activity of DNA banking is growing, particularly in the academic setting, and (2) most academically based DNA banks lack written internal policies, written depositor's agreements, or other relevant documentation regarding important aspects of this activity.     

A review of state legislation on DNA forensic data banking.

Recent advances in DNA identification technology are making their way into the criminal law. States across the country are enacting legislation to create repositories for the storage both of DNA samples collected from convicted offenders and of the DNA profiles derived from them. These data banks will be used to assist in the resolution of future crimes. This study surveys existing state statues, pending legislation, and administrative regulations that govern these DNA forensic data banks. We critically analyzed these laws with respect to their treatment of the collection, storage, analysis, retrieval, and use of DNA and DNA data. We found much variation among data-banking laws and conclude that, while DNA forensic data banking carries tremendous potential for law enforcement, many states, in their rush to create data banks, have paid little attention to issues of quality control, quality assurance, and privacy. In addition, the sweep of some laws is unnecessarily broad. Legislative modifications are needed in many states to better safeguard civil liberties and individual privacy.     

Forensic DNA and bioinformatics

The field of forensic science is increasingly based on biomolecular data and many European countries are establishing forensic databases to store DNA profiles of crime scenes of known offenders and apply DNA testing. The field is boosted by statistical and technological advances such as DNA microarray sequencing, TFT biosensors, machine learning algorithms, in particular Bayesian networks, which provide an effective way of evidence organization and inference. The aim of this article is to discuss the state of art potentialities of bioinformatics in forensic DNA science. We also discuss how bioinformatics will address issues related to privacy rights such as those raised from large scale integration of crime, public health and population genetic susceptibility-to-diseases databases.     

Forensic DNA fingerprinting by liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The determination of the molecular mass of a DNA sequence has several benefits over conventional fragment-length analysis that are advantageous to the forensic field: (i) sequence variation is captured that increases the power of discrimination compared with that obtained by conventional fragment-length analysis. First experiments showed that this increase makes up to 20%-30% for STR analysis. The new technical approach does not invalidate established developments and data, but adds to this information with additional discriminative categories. (ii) ICEMS is faster and cheaper than electrophoresis, does not require internal size standards, allelic ladders, or spectral calibration, which are necessary for fluorescence-based electrophoresis. (iii) ICEMS can unequivocally detect any single sequence variation in DNA molecules with lengths up to 250 nucleotides. This allows for maximum discrimination of forensically relevant DNA fragments, covering all sorts of STRs, SNPs, and also the analysis of the hypervariable segments of mtDNA. More effort, however, needs to be put into software development that escorts the analysis and data interpretation processes to make this technology manageable for the practical user.     

Forensic applications of DNA fingerprinting

In many ways, DNA profiling technology is very similar to the conventional techniques used for forensic identification. As with, for example, blood grouping techniques, the molecular characteristics of the scene of crime sample may be determined and compared with those of the scene of reference samples from suspects and victim. If the molecular characteristics of the crime sample and the suspect are different, then they cannot be from the same person, whereas if they match, then the possibility remains that they may be from a single source. Similar material, such as blood or semen stains, may be used for both biochemical and genetic tests, and the main applications of identification and relationship testing are shared by both techniques. At this point, the similarity ends; DNA profiling has the following characteristics:

1. It is more sensitive, being able to generate sound data from only a tiny amount of even partially degraded biological material.
2. It is capable of resolving mixtures of semen or tissue from up to several individuals.
3. It has a far greater power of discrimination between individuals—sometimes up to 1 millionfold higher than conventional techniques.
4. It provides considerably more information on the nature of relationships, particularly in cases of incest.

As such, the technique represents a quantum leap in forensic identification and relationship testing.     

Statistical analysis of DNA sequencing data (1): accuracy test of DNA data by partial re-sequencing.

To qualify DNA data, we have developed a statistical method of deciding whether the DNA data has an acceptable accuracy in sequencing process. The method is to test the probability of sequencing errors, based on partial re-sequencing. The method was successfully applied to a yeast mitochondrial DNA which is previously sequenced (1). The analysis indicates that the entire sequence is very accurate although we found one base change error on the ND1 gene sequence data by a partial re-sampling. This method is applicable to any DNA data.     

Forensic dentistry joins DNA analysis as important tool for police work.

A Vancouver dentist who works as a teacher, researcher and administrator at the University of British Columbia has a unique extracurricular interest. Dr. David Sweet, one of four forensic odontologists in Canada, has put names to unidentified bodies and the remains of car-crash victims, helped convict child abusers and provided evidence in robbery cases.     

Long-term data storage in DNA.

This article discusses how DNA might be used to store data. It is argued that, at present, DNA would be best employed as a long-term repository (thousands or millions of years). How data-containing DNA might be packaged and how the data might be encrypted, with particular attention to the encryption of written information, is also discussed. Various encryption issues are touched on, such as how data-containing DNA might be differentiated from genetic material, error detection, data compression and reading frame location. Finally, this article broaches the difficulty of constructing very large pieces of DNA in the laboratory and highlights some complications that might arise when attempting to transmit DNA-encrypted data to recipients who are a long period of time in the future.     

Forensic applications.

The introduction of DNA based identity testing has revolutionized the field of forensic analysis of biological materials. Most of the publications during the past year expand earlier studies that began more than seven years ago, on the properties of DNA recovered from different types of evidential materials; these studies examine the suitability of these samples for identity testing, the effect of different environmental insults the population genetics of loci used for identity testing, and the methods used for statistical analysis of the DNA patterns.