Studies on the adjuvant effect of Bordetella pertussis vaccine to sheep erythrocytes in the mouse. I. In vitro enhancement of antibody formation with normal spleen cells.

The adjuvant effect of Bordetella pertussis vaccine (PV) on the antibody response to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) has been studied in vitro with the Mishell-Dutton immunization technique. The addition of PV to cultures of spleen cells obtained from normal non-immunized mice markedly enhanced the plaque-forming cell response to SRBC. The greatest enhancement was evident at 24 hr of culture. PV was also shown to enhance the antibody response of spleen cells that had been depleted of either T lymphocytes or adherent cells, presumably macrophages. In addition, it was found that PV, per se, released into the culture medium a soluble cell-free component(s) that contributed significantly to adjuvanticity. The results suggest that at least one of the ways that PV enhances the in vitro immune response to SRBC is by direct stimulation of precursors of antibody-forming cells.     

In vitro immune response to sheep erythrocytes in macrophage depleted cultures. Restoration with interleukine 1 or a monokine from resident macrophages and stimulation by N-acetyl-muramyl-L-alanyl-D-isoglutamine (MDP)

The involvement of macrophages in the adjuvanticity of N-acetyl-muramyl-L-alanyl-D-isoglutamine (MDP) has been examined. The stimulation of the in vitro primary immune response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) has been studied, because it is known that macrophages cooperate through the mediation of soluble compounds for the induction of the anti-SRBC response. The cultures depleted of macrophages by passing spleen cells on Sephadex G-10 were unable to give any response to SRBC. Their immune responsiveness was fully restored by the addition of either Interleukine 1 (IL 1) obtained from P388D1 cells or a factor able to replace macrophages (FRM) obtained from resident peritoneal macrophages. MDP alone, at any dose, was unable to induce any response in such macrophage depleted cultures, but it was able to enhance the antibody response of these cultures reconstituted with monokines, with the same characteristics in dose effect and timing dependence than in whole spleen cells.     

Effect of a synthetic adjuvant on the induction of primary immune responses in T cell-depleted spleen cultures.

N-acetylmuramyl-L-alanyl-D-isoglutamine (muramyl dipeptide) stimulates in vitro primary immune responses to SRBC in T cell-depleted (nude) spleen cultures. The stimulation of immune responses by muramyl peptide was antigen dependent. A microculture system was used to compare the T cell-replacing activities of several structural analogues of muramyl dipeptide and to compare the activity of muramyl dipeptide to helper T cells. In a limiting dilution analysis with excess helper T cells or muramyl dipeptide, the frequency of B cell precursors that respond to SRBC was similar, ranging from 1.5 to 5 X 10(-5). Decreasing the cell density in microcultures did not affect the efficiency of B cell precursor responses in the presence of muramyl dipeptide. Muramyl dipeptide was examined for mitogenic activity in spleen cell cultures. In serum-free medium, muramyl dipeptide stimulates slight (3-fold) increases in DNA synthetic activity. In medium supplemented with 5 to 20% fetal calf serum, muramyl dipeptide showed no significant mitogenic activity. There are a number of possible explanations for the T cell-replacing activity of muramyl dipeptide. The most likely is that muramyl dipeptide interacts directly with B cells to mimic the helper T cell signal in the inductive stimulus.     

Target cells for the activity of a synthetic adjuvant: muramyl dipeptide.

Muramyl dipeptide (MDP), a synthetic adjuvant, increased the primary response of CBA mice to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). In reconstituted irradiated recipients, cooperation between T and B lymphocytes was required for the expression of adjuvant activity and MDP increased the efficiency of SRBC-educated T cells. The role of T-derived lymphocytes in mediating the MDP adjuvant activity was also demonstrated in irradiated mice and in mice reconstituted with various splenic cellular types of donors which had received SRBC and MDP 24 hr earlier. In our experiments, the macrophage did not seem to be involved, since MDP did not increase the phagocytic capacity of peritoneal exudate cells and MDP- and SRBC-pretreated macrophages had no increased ability to induce an anti-SRBC immune response. These results demonstrate the importance of T lymphocytes as mediators of the adjuvant activity of MDP.     

Enhanced antibody response in retrovirus-infected mice treated with endotoxin or nontoxic polysaccharide derivative

Friend leukemia virus (FLV) is a retrovirus which causes marked suppression of the immune response of genetically susceptible mice. In the present study the depressed antibody response to sheep erythrocytes by spleen cells from FLV-infected mice was partially reversed by injection of either a bacterial endotoxin or a nontoxic polysaccharide derivative directly into infected mice or by addition to spleen cell cultures from these mice immunized in vitro with sheep red blood cells (SRBC). The endotoxin and PS in a dose-related manner markedly increased the antibody responsiveness of the spleen cells to SRBC. Thus these results indicate that the nontoxic polysaccharide derivative has properties equivalent to the toxic endotoxin in enhancing the antibody responsiveness of FLV-suppressed spleen cells to a T-cell-dependent antigen like SRBC.     

Restoration and stimulation of the in vitro immune response of B cells to sheep erythrocytes by interleukins and muramyl dipeptide (MDP)

MDP, a synthetic muramyl dipeptide, is capable of increasing the primary in vitro antibody response, to sheep erythrocytes, of purified B cells restored with a monokine and helper T cell factors, including Interleukin 2 and the late-acting T cell replacing factor (TRF). First, the possibility that the adjuvanticity of MDP could be due to the elaboration of Interleukin 1, caused by its effect on macrophages, was excluded. In addition, a kinetic study showed that the effect of MDP was greater when added later, concomitantly with or one day after the helper T cell factors. Therefore, it appears that MDP acts directly on B cells, in a late stage of their differentiation to antibody-producing cells.     

Activation of distinct helper and suppressor T cells in experimental trypanosomiasis.

Spleen cells taken from mice soon after infection with Trypanosoma brucei S 42 enhance the primary in vitro antibody response of normal spleen cells to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), but do not affect their response to DNP-Ficoll. Spleen cells harvested later in the infection (day 6 onwards) suppress the antibody response of normal spleen cells to both SRBC and DNP-Ficoll. The enhancing and suppressive effects of "infected" spleen cells are sensitive to treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 anti-serum and complement, and can be mediated by nylon wool-purified populations of T cells. The enhancing T cell is sensitive to ALS, not lost within 4 weeks of adult thymectomy, and bears the Ly-1+, 23- phenotype. The suppressor T cell is insensitive to ALS, lost within 20 weeks of adult thymectomy, and bears the Ly-1+, 23+ phenotype. The significance of the activation of distinct helper and suppressor T cells is discussed in relation to the pathogenesis of trypanosomiasis.     

In vivo immunostimulating activity of the 163-171 peptide of human IL-1 beta

The stimulating effect of a synthetic nonapeptide (fragment 163-171) of human interleukin 1 beta (IL-1 beta) on antibody responses to both T helper-dependent and T helper-independent antigens was investigated. It was shown that the nonapeptide enhanced the antibody response, as evaluated in the hemolytic plaque assay, of spleen cells from mice immunized with sheep red blood cells (SRBC). The activity of the 163-171 peptide on the primary response to SRBC was dose-dependent, being maximal when the peptide was inoculated at 100 mg/kg together with the antigen. Moreover, the 163-171 peptide was also effective in enhancing the secondary response to SRBC. The effect of the 163-171 peptide was to augment the frequency of cells specific for the antigen, inasmuch as no increase was ever observed in spleen cell numbers after treatment. In all these studies, human recombinant IL-1 beta gave effects qualitatively comparable to those of the 163-171 peptide, with a maximal activity at 20 ng/kg. Both the 163-171 peptide and human recombinant IL-1 beta were also able to enhance the in vivo immune response to a T helper-independent antigen such as SIII, a poorly immunogenic polysaccharidic antigen from Streptococcus pneumoniae type III. It can therefore be proposed that this synthetic nonapeptide of human IL-1 beta may represent a good candidate for use as adjuvant in vaccines.     

Immunological activities of muramyl peptides

Muramyl peptides are endowed with numerous modulatory effects on the immune and nervous systems. Studies with synthetic muramyl dipeptide (MDP), the smallest unit of bacterial cell walls that can replace Mycobacteria in Freund's complete adjuvant, revealed that this glycopeptide can regulate several functions of cells involved in the immune response. The adjuvanticity of MDP and the MDP-induced activation of macrophages against tumors were found to be potentiated in vitro and in vivo with monoclonal anti-MDP antibodies. When used on immunoadsorbent columns, the anti-MDP antibodies removed the somnogenic and pyrogenic activities contained in supernatants of stimulated rabbit peritoneal macrophages. Based on these data a hypothesis is put forward to explain the immuno- and neuro-modulatory effects of muramyl peptides.     

Granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor augments the primary antibody response by enhancing the function of antigen-presenting cells

Purified, recombinant-derived murine granulocyte-monocyte colony-stimulating factor was found to enhance the primary in vitro immune response to SRBC by murine spleen cells. In determining the mechanism of this augmentation, it was found that only splenic adherent cells and neither resting nor activated T cells nor B cells expressed specific receptors for GM-CSF. When splenic adherent cells were pulsed briefly with GM-CSF before addition to macrophage-depleted cultures, they reconstituted the PFC response to a significantly greater degree than did control macrophages. Splenic adherent cells incubated overnight with SRBC plus GM-CSF were also more efficient antigen-presenting cells than splenic adherent cells incubated with antigen alone. The mechanism of this enhanced antigen presentation was found to be due to a GM-CSF-dependent increase in the level of IL 1 secretion and Ia antigen expression. Consistent with these data was the finding that GM-CSF augmented IL 2 production by splenic T cells in response to suboptimal concentrations of Con A. Finally, the day 5 in vivo antibody response (as measured by serum titers) of mice immunized with a low dose of SRBC was enhanced by two daily inoculations of GM-CSF. Thus, the role that GM-CSF plays in augmenting immune responses may not be solely accounted for by its ability to cause the proliferation or differentiation of macrophages, but more than likely includes its ability to enhance the function of antigen-presenting macrophages.     

In Vitro Reconstitution of Anti-Sheep Erythrocyte Antibody Response of T Cell-Depleted Spleen Cells by Allogeneic T Cells or by Factors Derived from Them

Restoration of the impaired antibody response to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) in cultures of mouse spleen cells, which were deprived of thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells) by treatment with anti-mouse brain-associated θ (BAθ) antiserum and complement, was studied by adding a small portion of syngeneic or allogeneic normal spleen cells in vitro. Allogeneic spleen cells had a far greater effect than syngeneic spleen cells on the restoration, as far as the normal spleen cells added were able to recognize the alloantigens on the anti-BAθ serum-treated spleen cells (bone marrow-derived lymphocytes). Treatment of the allogeneic spleen cells with mitomycin C did not affect their activity in the restoration of the impaired antibody response. The possibility that the role of T cells in the antibody response to SRBC may be replaced by a nonspecific mediator derived from T cells reacting with allogeneic cells was proven by the finding that supernatant of the mixed allogeneic spleen cell cultures restored the impaired anti-SRBC antibody response of the T cell-depleted spleen cells. The effect of such culture supernatant on the restoration of the antibody response was greatest when it was added to the T cell-depleted spleen cell cultures one day after cultivation with SRBC, suggesting that the effectiveness may result from triggering of the proliferation and differentiation of antibody-forming cell precursors, which have already reacted with the antigen, to antibody-forming cells.     

A reverse effect of in vitro and in vivo concanavalin A-induced spleen cells on anti-sheep red blood cells response detected with a new method based on flow cytometry

A simple flow cytometric method for detecting humoral immunity against sheep red blood cells (SRBC) is described. The SRBC were incubated with the serum from SRBC-immunized mice, monoclonal anti-SRBC, or the supernatant which was obtained from the in vitro primary culture of spleen cells with SRBC. The antibodies which bound to SRBC were estimated by means of an immunofluorescence and a flow cytometry. When the channel number of the peak in the histogram of flow cytometry was measured as an index of fluorescence intensity of SRBC, the number significantly correlated with the concentration of IgM and IgG classes of anti-SRBC. The flow cytometry method and hemagglutination (HA) test, as a classic method, were compared in SRBC-immune sera and monoclonal anti-SRBC antibody. The sensitivity determined with flow cytometry was much higher than that with HA. The minimum detectable concentration of anti-SRBC antibody was found to be 3.4 ng/ml by the flow cytometry. The dose response of SRBC in in vitro primary culture was detected by the flow cytometry, not by HA, and the response increased with the dose of SRBC. Using this method, the effect of in vitro and in vivo concanavalin A (Con A)-induced spleen cells on humoral response against SRBC was examined in an in vitro culture system. Anti-SRBC response (IgM and IgG) was found to be suppressed by in vitro Con A-induced lymphocytes, but enhanced by in vivo Con A-induced lymphocytes. Thus, this new approach is found to be a good method for detecting the in vitro primary humoral antibody response, which is known to have a low reactivity.     

Modulation of the immune response by anaphylatoxin in the microenvironment of the interacting cells

It was shown that the anaphylatoxins C3a and C5a can modulate in vitro immunological reactivities. C3a suppresses both the in vitro polyclonal antibody response and the specific antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) of both mouse spleen cells and human peripheral blood cells. The target cell in the mouse for C3a appears to be an Lyt-1+2- suppressor-inducer cell and macrophages appear not to be required. In contrast to C3a, C5a enhances in vitro responses of mice. Both the response to SRBC and the mixed lymphocyte reaction are enhanced by C5a. This enhancement appears to be through an Ia- macrophage that contains receptors for C5a. It appears that enhancement may be brought about by interleukin 1, which is released when Ia- macrophages are pulsed with C5a. It is suggested that these anaphylatoxins, when present in high concentrations in the microenvironment of the interacting cells of the immune system, play a dynamic role in the regulation of the immune response. Peptide fragments cleaved from the Fc portion of antibody, complexed with antigen in this microenvironment, may have a similar regulating role.     

Participation of the dopaminergic system in the immune response-stimulating effect of muramyl dipeptide

It has been shown that administration of muramyl dipeptide (MDP) in a dose of 1 mg/kg simultaneously with SRBC (5 x 10(6) immunization resulted in a considerable increase of immune response. Stimulation of the immune response is prevented by preliminary blockade of dopamine receptors with haloperidol, that testifies to the activation of the dopaminergic system by certain MDP dosages.     

A study of the mechanism of Con A-induced immunosuppression in vivo

The plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) is suppressed in a dose-related manner when concanavalin A (Con A) is administered intravenously to mice prior to or after immunization with antigen. The magnitude of suppression as well as the duration of the Con A effect greatly depends on the concentration of antigen used for immunization. Although profound suppression of the anti-SRBC PFC response is observed in intact mice pretreated with Con A for 4-24 hr, spleen cells from these mice do not exhibit suppressive activity when transferred into normal recipients or when cotransferred with normal spleen cells into irradiated recipients. Moreover, the cells from Con A-treated mice respond as normal spleen cells to SRBC when transferred alone into irradiated hosts. Suppression of the anti-SRBC PFC is only observed when adoptive hosts of cells from Con A-treated mice are also injected with Con A within 48 hr (but not 72 hr) of cell transfer and immunization. This time course of responsiveness to the suppressive effects of Con A is similar to that observed in normal mice and in irradiated recipients of normal spleen cells. The immune response to SRBC is also suppressed in adoptive hosts of normal spleen cells that are pretreated with Con A 4-24 hr prior to irradiation and cell transfer. Although functionally inactive when transferred into adoptive hosts, spleen cells from mice pretreated with Con A for 4-24 hr can suppress a primary antibody response to SRBC in vitro. The suppressive activity, which cannot be detected in the spleens of mice when the interval between pretreatment and assay is longer than 24 hr, is present in a subpopulation that bears the Thy 1.2 and Lyt 2 phenotype. Taken together the results obtained in in vivo and in vitro functional assays suggest that a suppressor cell population is activated following in vivo treatment with Con A, but that the cells rapidly lose their state of activation when removed from a Con A environment. This phenomenon is in all probability responsible for the failure to demonstrate suppressive activity in the spleens of Con A-treated mice using in vivo functional assays.     

In vivo regulation of humoral and cellular immune responses of mice by a synthetic adjuvant, N-acetyl-muramyl-L-alanyl-D-isoglutamine, muramyl dipeptide for MDP.

In vitro immunizations by T-dependent or T-independent antigens can be modulated by muramyl dipeptide (MDP). Enhancement or suppression of the antibody responses was observed according to the spleen-cell concentrations. Data presented here show that MDP can also suppress the immune response in vivo if used at relatively high dosage and injected before the antigen (SRBC). In vitro generation of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte recovered from mice which had been treated by MDP under the same experimental conditions was also decreased whereas macrophage cytostatic activity was not affected. By MDP pretreatment, a significant increase of antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity was observed.     

Functional characteristics of Peyer's patch lymphoid cells. IV. Effect of antigen feeding on the frequency of antigen-specific B cells.

The frequency of B cells in Peyer's patches from normal BDF(1) and sheep red blood cell (SRBC)-fed BDF(1) mice that could respond to antigenic determinants on SRBC and trinitrophenyl (TNP) was determined using an in vitro system of limiting dilution analysis. In normal mice, one B cell in 1.9 x 10(4) Peyer's patch cells could be induced to an anti-SRBC response and one B cell in 3.6 x 10(4) Peyer's patch cells could be induced to an anti-TNP response. The frequency of B cells capable of responding to SRBC in normal mice was similar in Peyer's patches and spleen. However, after feeding mice SRBC for 3 weeks, there was a 6-fold reduction in the frequency of B cells in Peyer's patches capable of responding to SRBC but no change in the frequency of B cells capable of responding to TNP. The average clone size of Peyer's patch B cells responding to SRBC was similar in normal and SRBC-fed mice. Although antigen-feeding does not stimulate Peyer's patch B cells in situ to humoral antibody synthesis, antigen-feeding can markedly alter the reactivity of the antigen-sensitive cell population in Peyer's patches. We previously demonstrated that T cells in Peyer's patches could be specifically carrier primed for helper function by SRBC feeding. We have now demonstrated that antigen-feeding reduced significantly the frequency of B cells in Peyer's patches capable of responding to the fed antigen. Peyer's patches appear to serve an important function as a sampling site for intestinal antigens.     

Antibody formation in mouse bone marrow. VIII. Dependence on potentially circulating memory cells: a study with parabiotic mice.

Mouse bone marrow barely contains antibody-producing plaque-forming cells (PFC) during the primary response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). However, during the secondary response, the number of IgM, IgG, and IgA PFC in the bone marrow can rise to a level which surpasses the number of PFC in all the other lymphoid organs together. In the present paper we investigated whether the capacity of immune mice to react upon a booster injection of SRBC with a bone marrow PFC response can be transferred from immune to nonimmune mice. Therefore, mice primed with SRBC 6 months previously and nonprimed syngeneic mice were joined for parabiosis and were separated from each other at various intervals after joining. These separated mice were subsequently immunized with SRBC. It was found that, after 3 weeks of parabiosis, the nonprimed members reacted upon an injection of SRBC with a bone marrow IgM, IgG, and IgA PFC response as high as did the previously primed members. Furthermore it could be demonstrated by means of cell transfer experiments that, after a period of parabiosis of 3 weeks, the bone marrow and spleen of the normal mice contained about as many memory cells as the bone marrow and spleen of the immune mice. These results suggest that antibody formation in mouse bone marrow is dependent on a population of potentially circulating memory cells.     

In vivo immune response suppression by the supernatant from concanavalin A-activated spleen cells.

Supernatants from concanavalin A- (Con A) activated murine spleen cells have been shown to suppress the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). The present study examined the effect of such Con A-activated spleen cell supernatants (herein termed CONS) on the in vivo immune response to SRBC in C57BL/6, BALB/c and CDF1 mice. CONS derived from BALB/c spleen cells suppressed direct PFC 4 and 8 days after immunization with 2 X 10(8) SRBC. CONS also suppressed indirect PFC 8 days after immunization, as well as serum hemagglutinins to SRBC. The PFC response of C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice was suppressed as much as that of BALB/c (H-2d) by CONS derived from BALB/c mice, indicating a lack of H-2 specificity of the CONS. In addition to suppression of the antibody response to SRBC, in vivo CONS administration resulted in reduction in spleen cell number. This reduction was not sufficient to explain the decreased PFC response. When the CONS was separated into less than 10,000 m.w. and greater than or equal to 10,000 m.w. fractions, the immunosuppressive activity was found in the less than 10,000 m.w. fraction. This observation suggests that intact interferon, SIRS, and MIF were not responsible for the results obtained.     

Eimeria tenella and E. acervulina: lymphokines secreted by an avian T cell lymphoma or by sporozoite-stimulated immune T lymphocytes protect chickens against avian coccidiosis

The role of avian lymphokines as nonspecific immunomodulators of host immunity against the intracellular parasite Eimeria was investigated. Prophylactic treatment of normal chickens with crude cell-free supernatants obtained from JMV-1 culture, concanavalin A (Con A)-stimulated normal spleen cells, or sporozoite-stimulated immune T cells prior to inoculation with E. tenella or E. acervulina conferred significant protection. These crude cell-free culture supernatants also inhibited intracellular development of eimerian parasites in vitro. Avian macrophages pretreated with these supernatant preparations showed inhibitory activity against Eimeria. This inhibitory activity could not be ascribed to anti-Eimeria antibody, complement, or cell-free Marek's disease virus and was therefore considered to be due to immunomodulating lymphokines present in the culture supernatants. These results suggest that JMV-1-transformed T lymphoblastoid cells, immune T lymphocytes, and Con A-stimulated normal spleen cells secrete lymphokines that can enhance host immunity in a nonspecific manner and implicate cell-mediated immunity as a major mechanism of the protective host immune response against eimerian infections.