Interaction of molecular probes with living cells and tissues. Part 2

Summary Cultured rat fibroblasts were exposed to 41 cationic fluorescent probes of very varied hydrophilicity/lipophilicity. Outcome of probe-cell interaction fell into one of the following categories: probe failed to enter the cells; probe accumulated on cell surfaces; probe accumulated in mitochondria, and/or in other intracellular regions. The observations were analysed using a Simplistic Chinese Box (SCB) approach, and the following conclusions were reached. It was the hydrophilic probes which failed to enter cells, whilst extremely lipophilic probes were retained on the cell surfaces. Only the slightly lipophilic cationic probes were permeant, and accumulated in mitochondria. Using the probes log P values to model hydrophilicity/lipophilicity, effective cationic mitochondrial stains can be specified numerically so: 0P _probe<+5. This SCB model was used to rationalise a variety of earlier observations on the action of mitochondrial probes. The applicability of the SCB approach to integrate image-based and biochemical investigations was demonstrated by using the action of chlorpromazine on mitochondrial action as a case example.     

Interactions of molecular probes with living cells and tissues. Part 1. Some general mechanistic proposals,making use of a simplistic Chinese box model

Summary A simple and generalised model — termed the simplistic Chinese box [SCB] model — for the interaction of molecular probes with living systems is described. The SCB model includes the following assumptions. That living systems may be considered as built from biologically defined boxes, e.g. whole cell nucleus nucleoli. That movement of molecular probes into and through these boxes is strongly infuenced by box wall permeability, which in turn is largely dependent on the simple physicochemical properties of probe and wall. That retention of probes in boxes is influenced by permeability of the walls and by trapping of probes by boxes and walls, the latter effect also being strongly dependent on simple physicochemical, properties. That important physicochemical properties include electric charge, hydrophilicity/lipophilicity, non-specific protein binding, and molecular size. That, since all these factors can be expressed or modelled numerically, SAR methodology is an appropriate technique for analysing molecular probe investigations. This paper is dedicated to the memory of Prof. A.W. Rogers     

Interactions of molecular probes with living cells and tissues. Part 1. Some general mechanistic proposals, making use of a simplistic Chinese box model

A simple and generalised model-termed the simplistic Chinese box [SCB] model-for the interaction of molecular probes with living systems is described. The SCB model includes the following assumptions. That living systems may be considered as built from biologically defined boxes, e.g. whole cell, nucleus, nucleoli. That movement of molecular probes into and through these boxes is strongly influenced by box wall permeability, which in turn is largely dependent on the simple physicochemical properties of probe and wall. That retention of probes in boxes is influenced by permeability of the walls and by trapping of probes by boxes and walls, the latter effect also being strongly dependent on simple physicochemical properties. That important physicochemical properties include electric charge, hydrophilicity/lipophilicity, non-specific protein binding, and molecular size. That, since all these factors can be expressed or modelled numerically, SAR methodology is an appropriate technique for analysing molecular probe investigations.     

Rapid uptake of lipophilic triphenylphosphonium cations by mitochondria in vivo following intravenous injection: Implications for mitochondria-specific therapies and probes

Background

Mitochondrial dysfunction contributes to a range of pathologies, consequently there is a need to monitor mitochondrial function and to intervene pharmacologically to prevent mitochondrial damage. One approach to this is to deliver antioxidants, probes and pharmacophores to mitochondria by conjugation to the lipophilic triphenylphosphonium (TPP) cation that is taken up selectively by mitochondria driven by the membrane potential.

Conclusions

Oral administration of TPP-conjugated antioxidants protects against mitochondrial damage in vivo. However, there is also a need to deliver molecules rapidly to mitochondria to respond quickly to pathologies and for the real-time assessment of mitochondrial function.

Methods

To see if this was possible we investigated how rapidly TPP cations were taken up by mitochondria in vivo following intravenous (iv) administration.

Results

AlkylTPP cations were accumulated selectively by mitochondria within mice within 5 min of iv injection. The extent of uptake was enhanced 10–30-fold relative to simple alkylTPP cations by attaching functional groups to the TPP cation via long, hydrophobic alkyl chains. Conclusions: Mitochondria-targeted antioxidants, probes and pharmacophores can be delivered into mitochondria within minutes of iv administration.

General significance

These findings greatly extend the utility of mitochondria-targeted lipophilic cations as therapies and probes.     

Mitochondrial accumulation of a lipophilic cation conjugated to an ionisable group depends on membrane potential, pH gradient and pK a: implications for the design of mitochondrial probes and therapies

Mitochondria play key roles in a broad range of biomedical situations, consequently there is a need to direct bioactive compounds to mitochondria as both therapies and probes. A successful approach has been to target compounds to mitochondria by conjugation to lipophilic cations, such as triphenylphosphonium (TPP), which utilize the large mitochondrial membrane potential (Δψ_m, negative inside) to drive accumulation. This has proven effective both in vitro and in vivo for a range of bioactive compounds and probes. However so far only neutral appendages have been targeted to mitochondria in this way. Many bioactive functional moieties that we would like to send to mitochondria contain ionisable groups with pK _a in the range that creates an assortment of charged species under physiological conditions. To see if such ionisable compounds can also be taken up by mitochondria, we determined the general requirements for the accumulation within mitochondria of a TPP cation conjugated to a carboxylic acid or an amine. Both were taken up by energised mitochondria in response to the protonmotive force. A lipophilic TPP cation attached to a carboxylic acid was accumulated to a greater extent than a simple TPP cation due to the interaction of the weakly acidic group with the pH gradient (ΔpH). In contrast, a lipophilic TPP cation attached to an amine was accumulated less than the simple cation due to exclusion of the weakly basic group by the ΔpH. From these data we derived a simple equation that describes the uptake of lipophilic cations containing ionisable groups as a function of Δψ_m, ΔpH and pK _a. These findings may facilitate the rational design of additional mitochondrial targeted probes and therapies.     

Mitochondrial functional changes during hepatic hyperplasia and azo dye carcinogenesis.

Resting and active-state respiratory velocities, respiratory control, high amplitude volume changes, and latent ATPase activities were examined in hepatic mitochondria from rats fed 3'-methyl-4-dimethylaminoazobenzene (3'MeDAB) for production of liver tumors and from rats in three phases of liver regeneration subsequent to subtotal hepatectomies. Tetrabutylammonium bromide, a lipophilic probe capable of selectively inhibiting phosphorylating oxidation or uncoupling oxidation from phosphorylation, was used to detect subtle alterations in lipophilicity characteristics of the organelles and it was concluded that mitochondria from pre-hyperplastic, hyperplastic, and neoplastic tissues had a higher than normal degree of membrane lipophilicity at specific functional sites. Control of respiration by ADP was markedly augmented in all experimental groups; this behavior, plus depressed sensitivity to swelling agents and energized contraction, were similar in mitochondria from hepatomas and from 3-day regenerating livers. These mitochondrial functions were even more pronounced, however, in cells in pre-hyperplastic states (6 and 16 h subsequent to partial hepatectomy). Many forms of liver damage result in mitochondrial alterations which elevate the capacity for oxidative phosphorylation. Such changes associated with induction of azo dye oncogenesis are mimicked by the degree of hyperplasia in the tissue following the first mitotic wave of regeneration; implications relevant to hepatocarcinogenesis are discussed.     

Targeting lipophilic cations to mitochondria

Mitochondrial function and dysfunction contributes to a range of important aspects of biomedical research. Consequently there is considerable interest in developing approaches to modify and report on mitochondria in cells and in vivo. One approach has been to target bioactive molecules to mitochondria by conjugating them to lipophilic cations. Due to the large mitochondrial membrane potential, the cations are accumulated within mitochondria inside cells. This approach had been used to develop mitochondria-targeted antioxidants that selectively block mitochondrial oxidative damage and prevent some types of cell death and also to develop probes of mitochondrial function. Here we outline some of the background to the development of these compounds.     

Monitoring of relative mitochondrial membrane potential in living cells by fluorescence microscopy

Permeant cationic fluorescent probes are shown to be selectively accumulated by the mitochondria of living cells. Mitochondria-specific interaction of such molecules is apparently dependent on the high trans- membrane potential (inside negative) maintained by functional mitochondria. Dissipation of the mitochondrial trans-membrane and potential by ionophores or inhibitors of electron transport eliminates the selective mitochondrial association of these compounds. The application of such potential-dependent probes in conjunction with fluorescence microscopy allows the monitoring of mitochondrial membrane potential in individual living cells. Marked elevations in mitochondria- associated probe fluorescence have been observed in cells engaged in active movement. This approach to the analysis of mitochondrial membrane potential should be of value in future investigations of the control of energy metabolism and energy requirements of specific biological functions at the cellular level.     

Effects of mitochondria-selective fluorescent probes on mitochondrial movement in Arabidopsis mesophyll cells evaluated by using the quantification

Mitochondria-selective fluorescent probes such as MitoTracker are often used for mitochondria imaging in various plants. Although some of the probes are reported to induce mitochondria dysfunction in animal cells, the effect on plant cells remains to be determined. In the present study, we applied quantitative methods to analyze mitochondrial movement, speed frequency, and speed-angle changes, based on trajectory analysis of mitochondria in mesophyll protoplast cells of Arabidopsis thaliana expressing the mitochondria-localized fluorescent protein. Using the quantitative method, we assessed whether MitoTracker Red (FM and CMXRos) induce mitochondria dysfunction in A. thaliana. Although both the fluorescent probes well-stained mitochondria, the CMXRos probe, not the FM probe, gave a severe effect on mitochondrial movement at the low concentration (10 nM), indicating a MitoTracker-induced mitochondria dysfunction in A. thaliana. These results revealed that our quantitative method based on mitochondrial movement can be used to determine the appropriate concentrations of mitochondria-selective fluorescent probes in plants.     

Respiratory control depression by tetraalkylammonium bromides in rat liver mitochondria.

Six different lipophilic (hydrophobic) organic cations, tetraethyl-, tetrapropyl, tetrabutyl-, tetrapentyl-, tetrahexyl-, and tetraheptylammonium bromide, depressed respiratory control in rat liver mitochondria. Evaluation of mitochondrial responses in terms of a quadratic equation in log P (an index of lipophilicity) indicated that the NADH dehydrogenase receptor site for inhibitor (diminution of control of glutamate, alpha-ketoglutarate, and beta-hydroxybutyrate respiration) was more lipophilic than receptor sites for flavin-linked substrates (reduction of control of succinate, choline and alpha-glycerophosphate respiration). The succinate dehydrogenase receptor site for inhibition by the tetraalkylammonium bromides was more hydrophillic (less lipophilic) than the choline or alpha-glycerophosphate dehydrogenase receptor sites. Depression of respiratory control may be a function of charge density and of lipophilicity at specific inner membranal sites and the susceptible site may differ for different respiratory substrates.     

Inhibition of mitochondrial respiration by neutral, monocationic, and dicationic bis-pyridines related to the dopaminergic neurotoxin 1-methyl-4-phenylpyridinium cation (MPP+)

The cytotoxic effect of the dopaminergic neurotoxin 1-methyl-4-phenylpyridinium (MPP+) is believed to be associated with a compromise in cellular energy arising as a consequence of its persistent inhibition of mitochondrial respiration. MPP+ is a rather weak inhibitor of electron transport, but it undergoes passive accumulation inside actively respiring mitochondria in response to the transmembrane electrochemical potential gradient. In order to test the prediction that dicationic analogs of MPP+ might be concentrated to a much greater extent and thereby exert especially potent inhibition of respiration on the intact organelle, we synthesized four differently spaced bis-pyridines, each in neutral, monocationic, and dicationic forms, and evaluated their inhibitory activities in intact mitochondria and in electron transport particles (ETP). Compared to the neutrals, the monocations and especially the dications exhibit reduced inhibition in ETP, but the inhibition in mitochondria is enhanced selectively for the cationic inhibitors presumably on account of their accumulation in the mitochondrial matrix. This enhancement is limited by the relatively poor ability of the cationic bis-pyridines to enter mitochondria, as judged from experiments which evaluated the rate of onset of inhibition (without preincubation), in the absence and presence of tetraphenylborate (TPB-). The dications appear to be transported less well than the monocations, and only the most lipophilic dication exhibited a substantially greater accumulation-dependent enhancement of inhibitory activity on mitochondria than did the corresponding monocation. The compounds studied here constitute a novel class of respiratory chain probes which may be useful for a variety of studies on mitochondria.     

Dicarbocyanine fluorescent probes of membrane potential block lymphocyte capping, deplete cellular ATP and inhibit respiration of isolated mitochondria.

3,3'-Dipropylthiodicarbocyanine iodide, a widely used fluorescent probe of membrane potential, was found to inhibit anti-Ig antibody, induced capping of mouse lymphocytes. The dye also lowered the cell ATP content. Experiments with isolated mitochondria revealed that the probe had a potent inhibitory action at site I of the respiratory chain. This mitochondrial blockade helps to explain the ATP depletion and blockade of capping, and gives cause for caution in the use of this dye as a probe of cell membrane potential. Three related dicarbocyanine dyes had similar toxic effects, but two cyanine dyes with much longer alkyl side chains, which have been used as probes of membrane fluidity, did not.     

Fluorescent cationic probes of mitochondria. Metrics and mechanism of interaction.

Mitochondria strongly accumulate amphiphilic cations. We report here a study of the association of respiring rat liver mitochondria with several fluorescent cationic dyes from differing structural classes. Using gravimetric and fluorometric analysis of dye partition, we find that dyes and mitochondria interact in three ways: (a) uptake with fluorescence quenching, (b) uptake without change in fluorescence intensity, and (c) lack of uptake. For dyes that quench upon uptake, the extent of quenching correlates with the degree of aggregation of the dye to dimers, as predicted by theory (Tomov, T.C. 1986. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods. 13:29-38). Also predicted is the relationship observed between quenching and the mitochondria concentration when constant dye is titrated with mitochondria. Not predicted is the relationship observed between quenching and dye concentration when constant mitochondria are titrated with dye. Because a limit to dye uptake exists, in this case, the degree of quenching decreases as dye is added. A Langmuir isotherm analysis gives phenomenological parameters that predict quenching when it is observed as a function of dye concentration. By allowing for a decrease in membrane potential, caused by incorporation of cationic dye into the lipid bilayer, a modification of the Tomov theory predicts the dye titration data. We present a model of cationic dye-mitochondria interaction and discuss the use of these as probes of mitochondrial membrane potential.     

Effect of the lipophilic/hydrophilic character of cationic triarylmethane dyes on their selective phototoxicity toward tumor cells.

The observation that enhanced mitochondrial transmembrane potential is a prevalent tumor cell phenotype has provided the conceptual basis for the development of mitochondrial targeting as a novel therapeutic strategy for both chemo- and photochemotherapy of neoplastic diseases. Because the plasma transmembrane potential is negative on the inner side of the cell and the mitochondrial transmembrane potential is negative on the inner side of this organelle, extensively conjugated cationic molecules (dyes) displaying appropriate structural features are driven electrophoretically through these membranes and tend to accumulate inside energized mitochondria. As a result of the higher mitochondrial transmembrane potential typical of tumor cells, a number of cationic dyes preferentially accrue and are retained for longer periods in the mitochondria of these cells compared to normal cells. This differential in both drug loading and retention brings about the opportunity to attack and destroy tumor cells with a high degree of selectivity. Only a small subset of the cationic dyes known to accumulate in energized mitochondria mediate the destruction of tumor cells with a high degree of selectivity, and the lack of a reliable model to describe the structural determinants of this tumor specificity has prevented mitochondrial targeting from becoming a more reliable therapeutic strategy. We describe here a systematic study of how the molecular structure of closely related cationic triarylmethanes affects the selectivity with which these dyes mediate the photochemical destruction of tumor cells. Based on our observations of how the lipophilic/hydrophilic character of these dyes affects tumor selectivity, we propose a simple model to assist in the design of new drugs tailored specifically for imaging and selective destruction of neoplastic tissue via mitochondrial targeting.     

Inhibitory probes of mitochondrial ATPase and the action of DDT

Chemical inhibitors were used as probes of mitochondrial ATPase to determine the site of action of DDT on oligomycin-sensitive mitochondrial ATPase (OS-ATPase) using whole mitochondria isolated from red coxal muscle of the American cockroach. Several plotting procedures were employed to delineate the form of inhibition. Relative potency and joint action were used to detect similar action, synergism, and antagonism between DDT and the inhibitory probes DCCD, Nbf-CI, and oligomycin. DDT demonstrated not (strictly) competitive kinetics and may be acting as an uncompetitive inhibitor. DDT and DCCD produced similar additive action. At limiting concentrations of DCCD, inhibition was reduced in the presence of DDT. Effects shown by oligomycin were not altered by DDT. DDT enhanced the effects of Nbf-CI. These interactions, together with the demonstration of not (strictly) competitive kinetics, indicate that DDT may be acting on the membrane sector as an allosteric modifier.     

Influence of trans-membrane potential and of hydrophobic interactions on dye accumulation in mitochondria of living cells

The lipophilic cationic fluorescent dye azopentylmethylindocarbocyanine (APMC) specifically stains the mitochondria in living cells. The dye contains a photosensitive diazirine ring and is suitable for photoaffinity labelling of mitochondrial proteins. By a combination of photoaffinity labelling of cell cultures of mouse fibroblasts (LM) with APMC, lysis of the labelled cells, subsequent micro-gel electrophoresis and detection of the fluorescence of the labelled proteins in the gel lanes with a sensitive microfluorimeter, we determined the number, apparent molecular masses, and relative intensity of the labelled proteins. In LM cells, three proteins with apparent molecular masses of 31, 40, and 74 kDa were labelled with high intensity, and proteins of 28, 29, 44, 48, 49, 66, and 105 kDa with low intensity. Two effects mainly determine the binding of lipophilic dye cations to mitochondrial proteins in living cells: (1) interaction of the trans-membrane potential of the inner mitochondrial membrane with the dye cations; and (2) hydrophobic interactions between the strongly lipophilic proteins of the inner membrane and the lipophilic dye molecules. Preincubation of the cell cultures with drugs that dissipate the trans-membrane potential, such as valinomycin, 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) and 3-chlorcarbonylcyanidephenylhydrazon (CCCP), strongly reduces or even prevents APMC labelling of mitochondrial proteins. The influence of hydrophobic interactions was investigated by competitive staining experiments using dyes with very different lipophilic properties. The lipophilicity of the dyes was characterized by their R _m values in reversed phase thin-layer chromatography. Prestaining with an excess of strongly lipophilic cationic acridine and phenanthridine dyes, such as pentyl acridinium orange chloride (PAO), nonyl acridinium orange chloride (NAO) and tetramethylpropidium chloride (MP), respectively, completely prevents protein labelling with APMC. Obviously, the dyes occupy the same mitochondrial binding sites as APMC. At equal concentrations the intensity of the 40-kDa signal is strongly reduced, whereas the 31-kDa and 74-kDa signals are unaffected. Using phenanthridine dyes with lower lipophilicity, namely propidium chloride (P), M, and N reduces the peak of the 40-kDa protein in APMC labelling, indicating that the 40-kDa protein preferentially binds lipophilic dye cations.     

Adaphostin and other anticancer drugs quench the fluorescence of mitochondrial potential probes

Fluorescent dyes are widely used to monitor changes in mitochondrial transmembrane potential (DeltaPsim). When MitoTracker Red CMXRos, tetramethylrhodamine methyl ester (TMRM), and 3,3'dihexyloxacarbocyanine iodide (DiOC6(3)) were utilized to examine the effects of the experimental anticancer drug adaphostin on intact cells or isolated mitochondria, decreased fluorescence was observed. In contrast, measurement of tetraphenylphosphonium uptake by the mitochondria using an ion-selective microelectrode failed to show any effect of adaphostin on DeltaPsim. Instead, further experiments demonstrated that adaphostin quenches the fluorescence of the mitochondrial dyes. Structure-activity analysis revealed that the adamantyl and p-aminobenzoic acid moieties of adaphostin are critical for this quenching. Anticancer drugs containing comparable structural motifs, including mitoxantrone, aminoflavone, and amsacrine, also quenched the mitochondrial probes. These results indicate the need for caution when mitochondrial dyes are utilized to examine the effects of xenobiotics on DeltaPsim and suggest that some previously reported direct effects of anticancer drugs on mitochondria might need re-evaluation.     

Dicarbocyanine fluorescent probes of membrane potential block lymphocyte capping,deplete cellular ATP and inhibit respiration of isolated mitochondria

3,3′-Dipropylthiodicarbocyanine iodide, a widely used fluorescent probe of membrane potential, was found to inhibit anti-Ig antibody, induced capping of mouse lymphocytes. The dye also lowered the cell ATP content. Experiments with isolated mitochondria revealed that the probe had a potent inhibitory action at site I of the respiratory chain. This mitochondrial blockade helps to explain the ATP depletion and blockade of capping, and gives cause for caution in the use of this dye as a probe of cell membrane potential.Three related dicarbocyanine dyes had similar toxic effects, but two cyanine dyes with much longer alkyl side chains, which have been used as probes of membrane fluidity, did not.