Measurements of lipopolysaccharide (endotoxin) in meningococcal protein and polysaccharide preparations for vaccine usage

Lipopolysaccharide (LPS, i.e. endotoxin) present in meningococcal outer-membrane protein and polysaccharide preparations made for vaccine use was quantitated by a silver-stain method following SDS-PAGE. The reactivities of LPS in the preparations were also measured by rabbit pyrogenicity and Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) assay. Although rabbit pyrogenicity and LAL assay are more sensitive than the silver stain method, the latter provided an actual amount of LPS present in the protein or in the polysaccharide. For a meningococcal protein preparation, rabbit pyrogenicity showed about one-tenth, and even less by LAL assay, of the actual amount of LPS. This is because protein-bound LPS in meningococcal protein preparations is about 10-fold less active in causing fever in rabbits, and 20- to 40-fold less active in the gelation of LAL than the same amount of a purified free LPS which is generally used as a reference in quantitating LPS in these two assays. As for the small amount of LPS present in a meningococcal polysaccharide preparation, similar LPS content was obtained when measured by the three methods suggesting that the LPS is not bound to the polysaccharide in contrast to that in the proteins mentioned above. The purified meningococcal LPS was pyrogenic in rabbits at 1 ng/kg.     

Use of reactions with Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) to determine biological activity of lipopolysaccharides from reference and clinical strains of the Bacteroides fragilis group

The aim of this study was to determine and compare a biological activity of lipopolysaccharides (LPS) from reference and clinical strains of strictly anaerobic bacteria belonging to the Bacteroides fragilis group (BFG) by means of quantitative, photometric BET (LAL) method with Limulus polyphemus amoebocyte lysate and chromogenic substrate S-2423. Lipopolysaccharides of five BFG species were extracted by Westphal and Jann method (1965) from eight reference and two clinical strains of B. fragilis group. Crude LPS preparations were purified according to the procedure described by Gmeiner (1975) with ultracentrifugation and nuclease treatment. Biological activities of bacterial endotoxins were determined by quantitative BET method with chromogenic substrate S-2423 (ENDOCHROME kit, Charles River Endosafe Ltd., USA). Tests were performed according to the producer's recommendations. E. coli O55:B5 LPS was applied to compare its activity in reaction with LAL reagent with activities of LPS preparations from rods of the Bacteroides genus. Among examined bacterial compounds the most active in BET method was E. coli O55:B5 LPS. Activities of lipopolysaccharides from five species of BFG rods in reaction with Limulus amoebocyte lysate were differentiated. Greater ability to activate LAL proenzyme revealed lipopolysaccharides of these species of the Bacteroides genus, which are important from the clinical point of view--B. fragilis and B. thetaiotaomicron.     

Enhancement of endotoxicity and reactivity with carbocyanine dye by sonication of lipopolysaccharide

The specificity of endotoxin (lipopolysaccharide, LPS) in the carbocyanine dye reaction was investigated, and then a stoichiometric study of the dye-LPS interaction was conducted with attention to the relationship of biological activities of LPS to the reactivity with the dye. Absorption maxima of some bacterial components in the dye reaction were as follows; LPS from both Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa and lipid A from E. coli LPS, 465 nm; Shigella flexneri LPS, 460 nm; Salmonella minnesota R595 glycolipid, 470 nm; polysaccharide from E. coli LPS, 650 nm; yeast RNA, 620 nm; streptococcal M protein and pyrogenic exotoxin, 610 nm; and free fatty acids, 445-450 nm. The absorbance at 465 nm was increased approximately threefold by sonicating LPS for 1-3 min, which roughly paralleled the decrease in turbidity of the LPS aqueous solution. The Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) gelation activity of LPS increased 10-fold when LPS was sonicated for 0.5-5 min, but it decreased to the control level after further treatment. This decrease, however, was overcome by sonication in the presence of 5 mmol of L-ascorbic acid used as an antioxidant. The LAL gelation activity of LPS was inactivated in parallel with an increase in the ratio (w/w) of dye to LPS from 1.73 to 6.90 in the dye-LPS mixture. Pyrogenicity of LPS was also clearly inactivated when the ratio was over 1.73. The ratios of the height of the beta band at 465 nm (dye-LPS complex) to that of the alpha band at 510 nm (free dye) were increased by sonicating LPS, indicating that the binding character, or stacking tendency, was increased by sonicating LPS.     

Biological activity of lipopolysaccharides from clinical Bacteroides fragilis strains isolated in Poland determined in reaction with limulus amoebocyte lysate

The aim of this study was to determine a biological activity of lipopolysaccharides (LPS) from clinical Bacterioides fragilis strains isolated in Poland by means of quantitative, photometric BET (LAL) method with Limulus polyphemus amoebocyte lysate and chromogenic substrate S-2423. Lipopolysaccharides were extracted from nine clinical B. fragilis strains by the procedure of Westphal and Jann (1965). Crude LPS preparations were purified with ultracentrifugation. Biological activities of bacterial endotoxins were determined by quantitative BET method with chromogenic substrate S-2423 (ENDOCHROME kit). Tests were performed according to the recommendations of the producer (Charles River Endosafe Ltd., USA). E. coli O55:B5 LPS and LPS preparations from reference B. fragilis strains were applied to compare the results of examinations. Activities of endotoxins from clinical B. fragilis strains isolated in Poland determined in reaction with Limulus amoebocyte lysate were differentiated. Among endotoxins of clinical B. fragilis strains the most active was the preparation from strain cultured in the case of pancreatic ulcer (B. fragilis 80/81 LPS). Lipopolysaccharides of examined B. fragilis strains were less active in BET test than E. coli O55:B5 LPS.     

Lipopolysaccharides of the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa

Lipopolysaccharides (LPS) of two isolates of Microcystis aeruginosa were extracted with phenol/water and purified. Cesium chloride gradient ultracentrifugation of these preparations yielded only one fraction. The LPS contained significant amounts of 3-deoxy-D-manno-octulosonic acid, glucose, 3-deoxy sugars, glucosamine, fatty acids, fatty acid esters, hexoses, and phosphate. Heptose, a characteristic sugar component of the polysaccharide moiety of LPS of most gram-negative bacteria was absent. Lipopolysaccharides and lipid A hydrolysate of LPS preparations were active in mouse lethality and Limulus lysate gelation. The lipid A moiety was slightly less active in toxicity and Limulus lysate gelation assays than the intact LPS. The LPS and lipid A moiety of the two isolates of M. aeruginosa were less active in toxicity in mice and Limulus test than LPS of Salmonella abortus equi.     

Detection of bacterial endotoxin in human tissues

Detection of bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in the absence of overt infection is a challenging problem in tissue homogenates and other complex samples. We found that conventional Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) assays are not suitable for this purpose due to interference from beta-glucan-like molecules. In contrast, a modified LAL assay that is unaffected by beta-glucan-like molecules was able to detect LPS in infected tissue and in a subset of clinically aseptic tissues. A two-step LAL assay was used to exclude the possibility of false positives due to nonspecific amidases. False positives due to sample color were also excluded, as were false negatives due to assay inhibition. This is the first report to successfully detect LPS in tissue in the absence of overt infection. This approach may be extremely useful in assessing recent hypotheses that subclinical levels of bacteria contribute to a wide range of chronic diseases.     

Comparison of the rabbit pyrogen test and Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) assay for endotoxin in hepatitis B vaccines and the effect of aluminum hydroxide.

The rabbit pyrogen test and Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) assay have been used to detect endotoxins in vaccines, but interactions between the endotoxins and proteins or aluminum hydroxide can interfere with the results. Currently, the rabbit pyrogen test is used to detect endotoxin in hepatitis B (HB) vaccines even though the HB surface protein, the active ingredient, is over-expressed in and purified from eukaryotic cells which lack endotoxin. Therefore, we examined the possibility of replacing the animal tests with the more efficient LAL test. To this end, we determined whether the aluminum hydroxide in the HB vaccines affects the rabbit pyrogen test and the LAL assay. HB vaccines and HB protein solutions spiked with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) produced almost the same dose-dependent temperature rise in rabbits, indicating that the aluminum hydroxide in the HB vaccine does not interfere with the pyrogenic response in rabbit. In contrast, a spike recovery study showed that aluminum hydroxide interfered with the LAL clot and kinetic assays; however, the LAL clot assay was effective at detecting endotoxin without loss of LAL activity after serial dilution of the samples. Furthermore, there was good correlation in the LAL clot assay between the amount of LPS added and the amount recovered. However, both turbidimetric and chromogenic kinetic assays displayed no correlation between the LPS amount added and recovered. Our results suggest that the LAL clot assay is sensitive and reliable when samples are properly prepared, and can be used to replace the rabbit pyrogen test for the detection of endotoxin in HB vaccines.     

Detection of Lipopolysaccharides in Phospholipids and Liposomes Using the Limulus Test

Abstract

LPS (lipopolysaccharides) represent a feared pyrogenic impurity in parenterals and raw materials used for their production. In liposome dispersions detection of LPS via the standard Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) test was proved unreliable in presence of phospholipids (liposomes). Attempts were made either to eliminate or inactivate disturbances of the LAL test by phospholipid(s). Common methods to overcome inhibition of the test, such as dilution of the sample, removal of the inhibiting substance by centrifugation or its inactivation by addition of detergents, were found not successful when LPS was present in liposome membrane-bound form. Another means to remove inhibiting substances is ultrafiltration. Ultrafiltration of aqueous lipid dispersions cannot be performed due to clogging of the filter membrane. Ultrafiltration upon addition of organic solvents turned out to be difficult due to the very limited resistance of celluloseacetate filter membranes against these solvents. Nevertheless a test protocol for detection of lipopolysaccharides in phospholipids and liposomes could be worked out and validated. It comprises dissolution of the phospholipid or liposomesNin pyrogen-free ethanol/water mixtures, ultrafiltration through pyrogen-free Ultrasart D20 units (Sartorius AG, Gottingen), reconstitution of the residue in pyrogen-free water or buffer and LAL testing. This procedure has been shown to allow for quantitative detection of LPS from minute amounts of 0.5 EU/ml up to very high amounts of 1000 EU/ml in liposomes in a reliable and reproducible manner. Recovery of LPS in all cases was fairly high i.e. one to two dilution steps below the theoretical LPS content.     

Dissociation between the interleukin 1-inducing capacity and Limulus reactivity of lipopolysaccharides from gram-negative bacteria

In this study we compared the interleukin 1 (IL 1)-inducing capacity and the reactivity in the Limulus amoebocyte assay (LAL) of purified lipopolysaccharides (LPSs) from various bacterial strains. LPSs differed greatly in their capacities (on a weight basis) to induce IL 1 release from serum-free cultured human monocytes. LPS species that induced high levels of IL 1 release from human monocytes exhibited a high thiobarbiturate-reactive 2-keto-3-deoxy-octonic acid (KDO) content. No relationship was found between the IL 1-inducing activity and the LAL reactivity of purified LPSs. Filtration experiments in which membranes of decreasing size-exclusion limits were used demonstrated that molecular species of LPS with an apparent Mr below 3,000 may induce IL 1, whereas only species with an apparent Mr above 8,000 are recognized in the LAL assay. The latter observation suggests that the reaction with LAL requires an aggregated form of LPS. These results indicate that biologically active LPS species can cross dialysis membranes in vivo although no LAL reactive material is detected in the blood compartment. The Limulus assay is an insufficient criterion for the absence of LPS in biological fluids.     

Characterization of Limulus amoebocyte lysate-reactive material from hollow-fiber dialyzers.

Hollow-fiber hemodialyzers containing cellulose-based membranes have been shown to produce positive results with the Limulus amoebocyte lysate test. This study was undertaken to determine whether endotoxin was causing the reaction. Rinses from 45 parallel-plate and hollow-fiber dialyzers from eight different manufacturers were tested before and after treatment with cellulase, using three lysates and four Limulus amoebocyte lysate methods. In addition, four in vitro cellular methods--human leukocytic pyrogen, lymphocytic activating factor, peritoneal macrophage, and arginase release--were used to evaluate endotoxin activity. The substance causing the reaction was identified by chromatographic methods. Results indicate that the Limulus amoebocyte lysate reactive material is cellulose derived and not pyrogenic.     

A novel endotoxin-specific assay by turbidimetry with Limulus amoebocyte lysate containing beta-glucan

The gelation of standard Limulus amoebocyte lysate (LAL) is triggered by the addition of a small amount of beta-glucan (1-1000 ng/ml plasma), but in the presence of an excessive amount of beta-glucan (1 mg/ml plasma), the gelation becomes insensitive to beta-glucan. Utilizing this property, a method to determine quantitatively the amount of endotoxin circulating in humans was developed. When a modified LAL, or LAL-ES, which contains an excessive amount of CM-curdlan as beta-glucan, was used for the assay, a linear relation in the logarithmic scales was obtained between the gelation time measured by the turbidimetry (min) and the concentration of endotoxin. This relation was not affected by a considerable amount of beta-glucan (100 ng/ml). The sensitivity of the endotoxin assay was estimated to be as low as 3 pg/ml. The following aspects of the method were found by clinical application to normal and febrile subjects. (1) Using both LAL and LAL-ES, it was possible to distinguish the effect of endotoxin from that of beta-glucan in plasma, i.e., bacterial sepsis from fungal sepsis. (2) The amount of circulating endotoxin determined by the present method showed good correlation to those obtained by chromogenic assay using modified LAL devoid of Factor G which could be activated by beta-glucan.     

Lethality for mice and chick embryos, pyrogenicity in rabbits and ability to gelate lysate from amoebocytes of Limulus polyphemus by lipopolysaccharides from Bacteroides, Fusobacterium and Veillonella

Phenol-water extracted lipopolysaccharides (LPS) from Veillonella, Fusobacterium nucleatum, Bacteroides fragilis and Bacteroides melaninogenicus were lethal for mice and 11-days-old chick embryos, pyrogenic in rabbits, and gelated Limulus amoebocyte lysate. Mouse lethality was considerably enhanced by actinomycin-D. In all test systems the endotoxin activity of Veillonella and Fusocbacterium LPS was comparable to that of LPS from Salmonella enteritidis, which was included as a reference endotoxin. The endotoxicity of the Bacteroides LPS was very low. While nanograms of the Veillonella and Fusobacterium LPS killed the chick embryos and gelated the Limulus lysates, microgram amounts of the Bacteroides LPS were needed to give positive reaction in the same test systems. As much as 74 microgram of the most active B. fragilis LPS were required to give a typical biphasic fever response in rabbits. A significant correlation was found between all test results (r = 0.90-0.98, p less than 0.001).     

Early detection of the Limulus amebocyte lysate reaction evoked by endotoxins

The gelation of Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) evoked by bacterial endotoxins can be detected earlier than with usual methods by using laser scattering photometry to recognize the formation of small particles of clotted enzyme produced when the reaction mixture is agitated. The appearance of these small particles means that the influence of endotoxins has stimulated activation of the clotting enzyme across the LAL cascade, and the timing of their appearance is related to endotoxin concentration. This new method can be used for quick and sensitive endotoxin assay. The average endotoxin level of healthy volunteers was assayed to be 0.0738 pg/ml [0.0312-0.3445 pg/ml] (n = 11) within 70 min from the start of the assay.     

Gelatin of Limulus amoebocyte lysate by simple polysaccharides

The Limulus lysate gelatin activity of several simple polysaccharides including yeast mannans and bacterial dextrans was investigated. The mannans from Saccharomyces cerevisiae wild and mutant strains possessing dense branches showed positive gelatin activity at concentrations of 1 microgram/ml or more regardless of differences in their chemical structure. However, two synthetic mannans possessing linear structures with alpha 1 leads to 2 and alpha 1 leads to 6 linkages also gave positive reactions at concentrations of 10 microgram/ml or more and 500 microgram/ml or more, respectively. The dextran from Leuconostoc mesenteroides IAM 1046 consisting of a dense branching moiety displayed reactivity at concentrations of 100 microgram/ml or more, while the dextrans devoid of such branches were negative in this reaction. The optimal concentration for Limulus lysate gelatin could not be determined for any of the polysaccharides and lipopolysaccharides (LPS) tested in this study. The gelation activity of the polysaccharides was stable to treatment with 100 mM NaOH at 30 C for 72 hr. The minimum concentration for the gelation activity of LPS treated with 100 mM NaOH under the same conditions was reduced from 10(-6) approximately(-9) microgram/ml to 1-10 microgram/ml. The above findings demonstrate that the major part of Limulus lysate gelation activity of LPS depends on the alkali-degradable lipid A moiety, and that such simple polysaccharides are also able to participate in this activity even though the extent of participation is very low.     

Preliminary assessment of removal of pyrogenic lipopolysaccharides with colloidal zirconia adsorbents.

Preliminary evaluation of bare or polymer-coated colloidal monoclinic zirconia of nominal particle size 100 nm indicated that it is an effective adsorbent for pyrogenic lipopolysaccharides (LPS) as measured by chemical and Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) assays. Zirconia at 50 micrograms ml-1 adsorbed 99.95% of added E. coli O128 LPS. Residual LPS levels below 0.1 ng ml-1 were easily attained. Colloidal zirconia was able to remove LPS from solution in the presence of bovine albumin (BSA). Some LPS contaminating BSA lacked affinity for zirconia. Preadsorption of phosphate onto bare zirconia blocked LPS adsorption. However, phosphated-oligomeric glycidyl (epoxy) pentaerythritol-coated colloidal zirconia could be derivatized with imidazole-containing ligands to produce an LPS-binding surface. Preliminary results of adsorption of LPS by the coated particles indicated a reduced level of LPS binding compared to bare zirconia, probably because the particles aggregated during the derivatization process, reducing the effective surface available for LPS adsorption.     

The concentration, physical state, and purity of bacterial endotoxin affect its detoxification by ionizing radiation

Increasing concentrations of a highly purified bacterial lipopolysaccharide preparation, the U.S. Reference Standard Endotoxin, were exposed to increasing doses of ionizing radiation from a 60Co source. At identical radiation doses both the structural change and Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) reactivity were progressively smaller with increasing concentrations of the lipopolysaccharide in an aqueous medium. Under the experimental conditions used, there was a linear relationship between the endotoxin concentration and radiation dose for the structural changes. In contrast to endotoxin in aqueous medium, endotoxin irradiated in its dry state showed no decrease in LAL reactivity and rabbit pyrogenicity. Endotoxin exposed to radiation in water in the presence of albumin showed a much smaller decrease in LAL and pyrogenic activities than expected. The results show that the concentration, physical state, and purity of endotoxin influence its structural and functional alteration by ionizing radiation.     

Investigations on the Specificity of the Limulus Test for the Detection of Endotoxin

Lysates obtained from amoebocytes of Limulus polyphemus, the horseshoe crab, showed gel formation after the addition of bacterial endotoxin. In contrast to living gram-negative bacteria, viable gram-positive microorganisms did not cause gelation of lysate. Nevertheless, peptidoglycan isolated from the cell walls of various gram-positive organisms did induce the reaction. However, the activity of peptidoglycan was 1,000 to 400,000 times less than that of Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide. After exposure to lysozyme, peptidoglycan no longer gelled amoebocyte lysate, therefore apparently excluding endotoxin contamination. Gelation of amoebocyte lysate by endotoxin or peptidoglycan was inhibited by different concentrations of sodium polystyrolsulfonate. Whereas these studies confirm the specificity of the Limulus test for bacterial endotoxins, they also indicate that other substances of bacterial origin should be investigated for their ability to gel amoebocyte lysate.     

Feasibility of on-chip detection of endotoxin by LAL test

The LAL (Limulus amebocyte lysate) test for the detection and quantification of endotoxin is based on the gelation reaction between endotoxin and LAL from a blood extract ofLimulus polyphemus. The test is labor intensive, requiring dedicated personnel, a relatively long reaction time (approximately 1 h), relatively large volumes of samples and reagents and the detection of the end-point is rather subjective. To solve these problems, a miniaturized LOC (labon-a-chip) prototype, 62 mm (L)×18 mm (W), was fabricated using PDMS (polydimethylsiloxane) bonded to glass. Using this prototype, in which 2 mm (W)×44.3 mm (L)×100 μm(D) microfluidic channel was constructed, turbidometric and chromogenic assay detection methods were compared, and the chromogenic method was found the most suitable for a small volume assay. In this assay, the kinetic-point method was more accurate than the end-point method. The PDMS chip chickness was found to be minimized to around 2 mm to allow sufficient light transmittance, which necessitated the use of a glass slide bonding for chip rigidity. Due to this miniaturization, the test time was reduced from 1 h to less than 10 min, and the sample volume could be reduced from 100 toca. 4.4 μL. In summation, this study suggested that the LOC using the LAL test principle could be an alternative as a semi-automated and reliable method for the detection of endotoxin.     

Limulus amoebocyte lysate assay for detection and quantitation of endotoxin in a small-volume parenteral product.

A Limulus amoebocyte lysate gel-clotting method for the determination of endotoxin in a small-volume parenteral product has been described. Sample dilution with 0.1 M potassium phosphate monobasic buffer (pH 8.0) effectively eliminated assay interference, whereas dilution with water did not. The threshold pyrogenic dose for Escherichia coli EC-2 and O127:B8 endotoxins was determined to be 1.0 ng of endotoxin per kg of body weight. Not more than 1.0 ng of endotoxin (the threshold pyrogenic dose) per the highest recommended human dose or the USP pyrogen test dose per kg of body weight, whichever dose is more stringent, is a logical limit for the quantity of bacterial endotoxin in small-volume parenteral products. Excellent correlation was attained when this criterion was used to compare the Limulus amoebocyte lysate assay with the USP pyrogen test.     

Simple, sensitive, and quick protocol to detect less than 1 ng of bacterial lipopolysaccharide

Detection and quantitation of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) are important for quality assurance of pharmaceutical, biopharmaceutical products and for several research and industrial aspects. The widely available assays for LPS detection are the normal, or chromogenic, and the synthetic LAL (Limulus amebocyte lysate). Unfortunately, both assays are expensive and could not distinguish between different types of bacterial LPS, while LPS silver nitrate staining requires more than 20 hr and can only detect 5 ng LPS. The current modified protocol was able to detect less than 0.5 ng LPS in a polyacrylamide-urea gel. The procedure is rapid, inexpensive, and reproducible. It depends on introducing two modifications to improve the staining sensitivity in sample buffer and staining procedure. The results revealed that excluding the reducing agent sucrose to use instead glycerol, and replacing SDS with DOC, as well as incorporation of 4 M urea in stacking and separating gels, increased the sensitivity up to 150 pg. In summary, the gels were fixed, carbohydrates moieties were oxidized to create active aldehydes, and the gels were silver stained using non-ammoniacal silver nitrate.