Isolation and characterization of nitrate reductase-deficient mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana

Summary Chlorate resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana were isolated, of which 10 exhibited a lowered nitrate reductase activity and 51 were chlorate-resistant because of an impaired uptake of chlorate. The 51 mutants of this type are all affected in the same gene. The mutants with a lowered nitrate reductase activity fall into 7 different complementation groups. Three of these mutants grow poorly on media with nitrate as the sole nitrogen source, while the others apparently can reduce sufficient nitrate to bring about growth. In all cases a low nitrate reductase activity coincides with an enhanced nitrite reductase activity. After sucrose gradient centrifugation of wildtype extracts nitrate reductase is found at the 8S position, whereas cytochrome-c reductase is found both at 4 and 8S positions. It is suggested that the functional nitrate reductase is a complex consisting of 4S subunits showing cytochrome-c reductase activity and a Mo-bearing cofactor. All mutants except B25 are capable of assembling the 4S subunits into complexes which for most mutants have a lower S value and exhibit a lower nitrate reductase activity than the wildtype complexes. Since the mutants B25 and B73 exhibit a low xanthine dehydrogenase activity, the Mo-bearing cofactor is probably less available in these mutants than in the wildtype. B73 appears to be the only mutant which is partly repaired by excessive Mo. The possible role of several genes is discussed.     

Uptake of Nitrate by Mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana, Disturbed in Uptake or Reduction of Nitrate

A study of nitrate and chlorate uptake by Arabidopsis thaliana was made with a wildtype and two mutant types, both mutants having been selected by resistance to high chlorate concentrations. All plants were grown on a nutrient solution with nitrate and/or ammonium as the nitrogen source. Uptake was determined from depletion in the ambient solution. Nitrate and chlorate were able to induce their own uptake mechanisms. Plants grown on ammonium nitrate showed a higher subsequent uptake rate of nitrate and chlorate than plants grown on ammonium alone. Mutant B25, which has no nitrate reductase activity, showed higher rates of nitrate and chlorate uptake than the wildtype, when both types were grown on ammonium nitrate. Therefore, the uptake of nitrate is not dependent on the presence of nitrate reductase. Nitrate has a stimulating effect on nitrate and chlorate uptake, whereas some product of nitrate and ammonium assimilation inhibits uptake of both ions by negative feedback. Mutant B 1, which was supposed to have a low chlorate uptake rate, also has disturbed uptake characteristics for nitrate.     

Increased protein content in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana over-expressing nitrate reductase activity

Arabidopsis thaliana was engineered to over-express nitrate reductase (NR) by virtue of the light inducible chimeric gene Lhcb1*3::Nia1*2. The transgenic lines obtained displayed NR activity 2–4 times the level in the wild type, depending on the line. While not displaying advantage with respect to fresh or dry weight, 7-day-old transgenic seedlings did show up to 200% higher protein content than the wild type when grown on solid medium. Up to 30% increase in protein content was also obtained when grown in peat moss for at least 3 weeks. The increase in protein content was evident in several protein bands but was most apparent in that of the large subunit of RuBisCo.     

Nitrate reductase deficient cell lines from diploid cell cultures and lethal mutant M2 plants of Arabidopsis thaliana

Summary Cell suspensions of diploid Arabidopsis thaliana were screened for resistance to chlorate on a medium with ammonium nitrate as the nitrogen source, and after plating on filters to increase the plating efficiency. Thirty-nine lines were selected, four of which were still resistant after two years of subculturing on non-selective medium. Of the latter lines three were nitrate reductase deficient but exhibited some residual nitrate reductase activity; the fourth line showed a high level of enzyme activity. Screening M2-seeds for callus production on selective medium with amino acids as the nitrogen source and chlorate revealed resistant calli in 17 out of 483 M2-groups. Nine well-growing lines, all but one (G3) exhibiting no detectable in vivo nitrate reductase activity, were classified as defective in the cofactor. Two lines (G1 and G3) could be analysed genetically at the plant level. Chlorate resistance was monogenic and recessive. Sucrose gradient fractionation of callus extracts of G1 revealed that a complete enzyme molecule can be assembled. Nitrate reductase activity in G1 could partly be restored by excess molybdenum. It is suggested that G1 is disturbed in the catalytic properties of the cofactor. It appeared that G1 is neither allelic with another molybdenum repairable mutant (B73) nor with another cofactor mutant (B25). Wilting of intact G1 plants could be ascribed to non-closing stomata.     

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii strains expressing nitrate reductase under control of the cabII-1 promoter: isolation of chlorate resistant mutants and identification of new loci for nitrate assimilation

The Chlamydomonas reinhardtii strain Tx11-8 is a transgenic alga that bears the nitrate reductase gene (Nia1) under control of the CabII-1 gene promoter (CabII-1-Nia1). Approximately nine copies of the chimeric CabII-1-Nia1 gene were found to be integrated in this strain and to confer a phenotype of chlorate sensitivity in the presence of ammonium. We have used this strain for the isolation of spontaneous chlorate resistant mutants in the presence of ammonium that were found to be defective at loci involved in MoCo metabolism and light-dependent growth in nitrate media. Of a total of 45 mutant strains analyzed first, 44 were affected in the MoCo activity (16 Nit⁻, unable to grow in nitrate, and 28 Nit⁺, able to grow in nitrate). All the Nit⁻ strains lacked MoCo activity. Diploid complementation of Nit⁻, MoCo⁻ strains with C. reinhardtii MoCo mutants and genetic analysis indicated that some strains were defective at known loci for MoCo biosynthesis, while three strains were defective at two new loci, hereafter named Nit10 and Nit11. The other 28 Nit⁺ strains showed almost undetectable MoCo activity or activity was below 20% of the parental strain. Second, only one strain (named 23c⁺) showed MoCo and NR activities comparable to those in the parental strain. Strain 23c⁺ seems to be affected in a locus, Nit12, required for growth in nitrate under continuous light. It is proposed that this locus is required for nitrate/chlorate transport activity. In this work, mechanisms of chlorate toxicity are reviewed in the light of our results.     

Toxicity of and mutagenesis by chlorate are independent of nitrate reductase activity in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Summary Spontaneous chlorate-resistant (CR) mutants have been isolated from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii wildtype strains. Most of them, 244, were able to grow on nitrate minimal medium, but 23 were not. Genetic and in vivo complementation analyses of this latter group of mutants indicated that they were defective either at the regulatory locus nit-2, or at the nitrate reductase (NR) locus nit-1, or at very closely linked loci. Some of these nit-1 or nit-2 mutants were also defective in pathways not directly related to nitrate assimilation, such as those of amino acids and purines. Chlorate treatment of wild-type cells resulted in both a decrease in cell survival and an increase in mutant cells resistant to a number of different chemicals (chlorate, methylammonium, sulphanilamide, arsenate, and streptomycin). The toxic and mutagenic effects of chlorate in minimal medium were not found when cells were grown either in darkness or in the presence of ammonium, conditions under which nitrate uptake is drastically inhibited. Chlorate was also able to induce reversion of nit ^– mutants of C. reinhardtii, but failed to produce His ⁺ revertants or Ara^r mutants in the BA-13 strain of Salmonella typhimurium. In contrast, chlorate treatment induced mutagenesis in strain E1F1 of the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus. Genetic analyses of nitrate reductase-deficient CR mutants of C. reinhardtii revealed two types of CR, to low (1.5 mM) and high (15 mM) chlorate concentrations. These two traits were recessive in heterozygous diploids and segregated in genetic crosses independently of each other and of the nit-1 and nit-2 loci. Three her loci and four lcr loci mediating resistance to high (HC) and low (LC) concentrations of chlorate were identified. Mutations at the nit-2 locus, and deletions of a putative locus for nitrate transport were always epistatic to mutations responsible for resistance to either LC or HC. In both nit ⁺ and nit ^– chlorate-sensitive (CS) strains, nitrate and nitrite gave protection from the toxic effect of chlorate. Our data indicate that in C. reinhardtii chlorate toxicity is primarily dependent on the nitrate transport system and independent of the existence of an active NR enzyme. At least seven loci unrelated to the nitrate assimilation pathway and mediating CR are thought to control indirectly the efficiency of the nitrate transporter for chlorate transport. In addition, chlorate appears to be a mutagen capable of inducing a wide range of mutations unrelated to the nitrate assimilation pathway.     

The isolation and survival characterization of radiation and chemical-mutagen sensitive mutants of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Chlorate-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana were isolated in order to find nitrate reductase-less mutants. It appeared that chlorate resistance in higher plants can arise by mutations concerning two different mechanisms: (1) a lower reduction rate of chlorate due to a lower level of nitrate reductase activity; (2) a lower increase in content of chlorate and/or chlorite and of chloride after chlorate treatment. One mutant of the first type and two mutants of the second type are described. The nitrate reductase-less mutant grows poorly on a medium with nitrate as the only nitrogen source but is not blocked in the uptake of nitrate. Both the other mutants exhibit a nitrate reductase activity equal to or higher than that of the wild type, but probably have a much lowered uptake of chlorate. The latter two mutants belong to the same complementation group, whereas the nitrate reductase-less mutant belongs to a different group.     

Identification and characterization of a chlorate-resistant mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana with mutations in both nitrate reductase structural genes NIA1 and NIA2

Mutant plants defective in the assimilation of nitrate can be selected by their resistance to the herbicide chlorate. In Arabidopsis thaliana, mutations at any one of nine distinct loci confer chlorate resistance. Only one of the CHL genes, CHL3, has been shown genetically to be a nitrate reductase (NR) structural gene (NIA2) even though two NR genes (NIA1 and NIA2) have been cloned from the Arabidopsis genome. Plants in which the NIA2 gene has been deleted retain only 10% of the wildtype shoot NR activity and grow normally with nitrate as the sole nitrogen source. Using mutagenized seeds from the NIA2 deletion mutant and a modified chlorate selection protocol, we have identified the first mutation in the NIA1 NR structural gene. nia1, nia2 double mutants have only 0.5% of wild-type shoot NR activity and display very poor growth on media with nitrate as the only form of nitrogen. The nial-1 mutation is a single nucleotide substitution that converts an alanine to a threonine in a highly conserved region of the molybdenum cofactor-binding domain of the NR protein. These results show that the NIA1 gene encodes a functional NR protein that contributes to the assimilation of nitrate in Arabidopsis.     

The correlation between the protein composition of cytoplasmic membranes and the formation of nitrate reductase A,chlorate reductase C and tetrathionate reductase in Proteus mirabilis wild type and some chlorate resistant mutants

Three genotypically different chlorate resistant mutants, chl I, chl II and chl III, appeared to lack completely nitrate reductase A, chlorate reductase C and tetrathionate reductase activity. Fumarate reductase is only partially affected in chl I and chl III and unaffected in chl II. Formate dehydrogenase is only partially diminished in chl II, hydrogenase is diminished in chl I and chl II and completely absent in chl III.Subunits of nitrate reductase A, chlorate reductase C and tetrathionate reductase have been identified in protein profiles of purified cytoplasmic membranes from the wild type and the three mutant strains, grown under various conditions. Only the presence and absence of the largest subunits of these enzymes appeared to be correlated with their repression and derepression in the wild type membranes. On the cytoplasmic membranes of the chl I and chl III mutants these subunits lack for the greater part. In the chl II mutant, however, these subunits are inserted in the membrane all together after anaerobic growth with or without nitrate.A model for the repression/derepression mechanism for the reductases has been proposed. It includes repression by cytochrome b components, whereas the redox-state of the nitrate reductase A molecule itself is also involved in its derepression under anaerobic conditions.     

Chlorate toxicity in Aspergillus nidulans. Studies of mutants altered in nitrate assimilation.

Summary It had previously been held that chlorate is not itself toxic, but is rendered toxic as a result of nitrate reductase-catalysed conversion to chlorite. This however cannot be the explanation of chlorate toxicity in Aspergillus nidulans, even though nitrate reductase is known to have chlorate reductase activity. Among other evidence against the classical theory for the mechanism of chlorate toxicity, is the finding that not all mutants lacking nitrate reductase are clorate resistant. Both chlorate-sensitive and resistant mutants lacking nitrate reductase, also lack chlorate reductase. Data is presented which implicates not only nitrate reductase but also the product of the nirA gene, a positive regulator gene for nitrate assimilation, in the mediation of chlorate toxicity. Alternative mechanisms for chlorate toxicity are considered. It is unlikely that chlorate toxicity results from the involvement of nitrate reductase and the nirA gene product in the regulation either of nitrite reductase, or of the pentose phosphate pathway. Although low pH has an effect similar to chlorate, chlorate is not likely to be toxic because it lowers the pH; low pH and chlorate may instead have similar effects. A possible explanation for chlorate toxicity is that it mimics nitrate in mediating, via nitrate reductase and the nirA gene product, a shut-down of nitrogen catabolism. As chlorate cannot act as a nitrogen source, nitrogen starvation ensures.     

Mutants of Azotobacter vinelandii altered in the regulation of nitrate assimilation

The two enzymes involved in the assimilatory pathway of nitrate in Azotobacter vinelandii are corregulated. Nitrate reductase and nitrite reductase are inducible by nitrate and nitrite. Ammonium represses induction by nitrate of both reductases. Repression by ammonium is higher in media containing 2-oxo-glutarate as carbon source than in media containing sucrose. Mutants in the gene ntrC lost nitrate and nitrite reductase simultaneously. Ten chlorate-resistant mutants with a new phenotype were isolated. In media without ammonium they had a normal phenotype, being sensitive to the toxic effect of chlorate. In media containing low ammonium concentrations they were resistant to chlorate. These mutants seem to be affected in the repression of nitrate and nitrite reductases by ammonium.     

Nitrate Utilization by Nitrate Reductase-deficient Barley Mutants

Two nitrate reductase-deficient barley mutants were studied for growth on nitrate and ammonium sources of nitrogen and for resistance to chlorate. Although nitrate reductase-deficient mutants in some species are chlorate-resistant (unable to reduce chlorate to chlorite), the barley mutants used in these studies when grown on nitrate and treated with chlorate were only slightly more resistant to chlorate than the control. When grown to maturity on vermiculite supplemented with either nitrate or ammonium nutrient solutions, the mutants produced as much dry weight and reduced nitrogen per plant as the control. The in vivo and in vitro nitrate reductase activities in the roots and shoots of the mutants grown on nitrate were consistently less than 10% of the control. To avoid the possibility that the mutants received reduced nitrogen from microbial sources, excised embryos were cultured under sterile conditions. Again the mutants were capable of growth and reduced nitrogen accumulation with nitrate as the sole source of nitrogen. In spite of the low apparent nitrate reductase activity, the nitrate reductase-deficient mutants are capable of substantial nitrate reduction.     

Isolation and characterization of Nicotiana plumbaginifolia nitrate reductase-deficient mutants: genetic and biochemical analysis of the NIA complementation group

Summary Two hundred and eleven nitrate reductase-deficient mutants (NR^–) were isolated from mutagenized Nicotiana plumbaginifolia protoplast cultures by chlorate selection and regenerated into plant. More than 40% of these clones were classified as cnx and presumed to be affected in the biosynthesis of the molybdenum cofactor, the remaining clones being classified as nia mutants. A genetic analysis of the regenerated plants confirmed this proportion of nia and cnx clones. All mutants regenerated were found to carry monogenic recessive mutations that impaired growth on nitrate as sole nitrogen source. Mutants propagated by grafting on N. tabacum systematically displayed a chlorotic leaf phenotype. This chlorosis was therefore related to the NR deficiency. The observation of leaves with NR^– chlorotic sectors surrounded by NR⁺ wild-type tissues suggeests that an NR deficiency is not corrected by diffusible factors. Periclinal chimeras between wild-type tobacco and the NR^– graft were also observed. In this type of chimeric tissue chlorosis was no longer detectable when NR⁺ cells were in the secondmost (L2) layer, but was still detectable when NR^– cells were in the secondmost layer. The genetic analysis of nia mutants revealed that they belong to a single complementation group. However three nia mutants were found to complement some of the other nia mutants. The apoenzyme of nitrate reductase was immunologically detected in several nia mutants but not in other members of this complementation group. Some of the nia mutants, although they were NR^–, still displayed methylviologenitrate reductase activity at a high level. These data show that the nia complementation group corresponds to the structural gene of nitrate reductase. Some of the mutations affecting this structural gene result in the overproduction of an inactive nitrate reductase, suggesting a feedback regulation of the level of the apoenzyme in the wild type.     

Nitrate and nitrite reductase negative mutants of N2-fixingAzospirillum spp.

Chlorate resistant spontaneous mutants ofAzospirillum spp. (syn.Spirillum lipoferum) were selected in oxygen limited, deep agar tubes with chlorate. Among 20 mutants fromA. brasilense and 13 fromA. lipoferum all retained their functional nitrogenase and 11 from each species were nitrate reductase negative (nr^–). Most of the mutants were also nitrite reductase negative (nir^–), only 3 remaining nir⁺. Two mutants from nr⁺ nir⁺ parent strains lost only nir and became like the nr⁺ nir^– parent strain ofA. brasilense. No parent strain or nr⁺ mutant showed any nitrogenase activity with 10 mM NO ₃ ^– . In all nr^– mutants, nitrogenase was unaffected by 10 mM NO ₃ ^– . Nitrite inhibited nitrogenase activity of all parent strains and mutants including those which were nir^–. It seems therefore, that inhibition of nitrogenase by nitrate is dependent on nitrate reduction. Under aerobic conditions, where nitrogenase activity is inhibited by oxygen, nitrate could be used as sole nitrogen source for growth of the parent strains and one mutant (nr^– nir^–) and nitritite of the parent strains and 10 mutants (all types). This indicates the loss of both assimilatory and dissimilatory nitrate reduction but only dissimilatory nitrite reduction in the mutants selected with chlorate.     

Isolation and characterization of cell lines of Nicotiana tabacum lacking nitrate reductase

Summary Chlorate-resistant cell lines were established from survivors after plating allodihaploid cells of Nicotiana tabacum into solid medium containing 20 mM chlorate and amino acids as sole nitrogen source. Data characterizing 9 of the most resistant lines are presented. The mutational origin of these lines was inferred on the basis of the enhancement of the variant frequency by mutagen treatment, and of the persistance of the variant phenotype in cell progeny during growth in the absence of selection for more than 3 years and in plants regenerated from two of the lines.Seven lines completely lacked in vivo nitrate reductase (NR) activity and two lines exhibited low (less than 5% of the wild type) NR activity. The abolition of NR activity was found to be not due to an impaired induction by nitrate. Data reported elsewhere show that one of the NR-negative mutants simultaneously lacks xanthine dehydrogenase activity. This pleiotropic mutation is interpreted to affect the synthesis of a molybdenum-containing cofactor, whereas the 8 other lines carry mutations specifically affecting the synthesis of the NR. Both types of NR-negative mutants were unable to grow on minimal medium containing nitrate as sole nitrogen source, but grew well on amino acids. They proved extremely sensitive to the standard medium containing nitrate and ammonium. Differences between the NR-negative mutants with respect to chlorate resistance suggest that chlorate inhibits cultured N tabacum cells not only via its NR-catalysed conversion to chlorite, but also by NR-independent mechanisms.     

Isolation of molybdenum cofactor defective cell lines of Nicotiana tabacum

Summary Thirty-nine chlorate resistant cell lines were isolated after plating ethylmethane sulphonate treated allodihaploid cells of Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi on agar medium containing 20 mM chlorate. Thirty-two of these cell lines grew as well on nitrate medium as on amino acid medium and three other cell lines grew well on amino acid medium but poorly on nitrate medium. Four other cell lines, 042, P12, P31 and P47 which could grow on amino acid medium, but not on nitrate medium, were examined further. They lacked in vitro nitrate reductase activity but were able to accumulate nitrate. All lines possessed nitrite reductase activity. Lines 042, P12, and P31 had a cytochrome c reductase species which was the same size as the wild type nitrate reductase associated cytochrome c reductase species, whilst the cytochrome c reductase species in line P47 was slightly smaller. All four lines lacked xanthine dehydrogenase activity and neither nitrate reductase nor xanthine dehydrogenase activity was restored by subculture of the four lines into either nitrate medium or glutamine medium supplemented with 1 mM sodium molybdate. These four lines are different from other molybdenum cofactor defective cell lines so far described in N. tabacum and possess similar properties to certain other cnx mutants described in Aspergillus nidulans.     

Characterization of a chlorate-hypersensitive,high nitrate reductase Arabidopsis thaliana mutant

Summary A population of A. thaliana, produced by self-fertilization of ethylmethane sulfonate treated plants, was exposed to chlorate in the watering solution, and plants showing early susceptibility symptoms were rescued. Among the progeny lines of these plants five were shown to be repeatably chlorate-hypersusceptible. One of these lines (designated C-4) possessed elevated activity of nitrate reductase (NR). The NR activity of mutant C-4 was higher than that of normal plants throughout the life cycle. Nitrite reductase and glutamine synthetase activities of C-4 were normal, as were chlorate uptake rate and tissue nitrate content. The elevated NR activity apparently was responsible for the chlorate hypersusceptibility of C-4. Inheritance studies of NR indicated that the elevated activity of C-4 was probably controlled by a single recessive allele.     

Isolation and characterization of two new negative regulatory mutants for nitrate assimilation inChlamydomonas reinhardtii obtained by insertional mutagenesis

Plasmid DNA carrying either the nitrate reductase (NR) gene or the argininosuccinate lyase gene as selectable markers and the correspondingChlamydomonas reinhardtii mutants as recipient strains have been used to isolate regulatory mutants for nitrate assimilation by insertional mutagenesis. Identification of putative regulatory mutants was based on their chlorate sensitivity in the presence of ammonium. Among 8975 transformants, two mutants, N1 and T1, were obtained. Genetic characterization of these mutants indicated that they carry recessive mutations at two different loci, namedNrg1 andNrg2. The mutation in N1 was shown to be linked to the plasmid insertion. Two copies of the nitrate reductase plasmid, one of them truncated, were inserted in the N1 genome in inverse orientation. In addition to the chlorate sensitivity phenotype in the presence of ammonium, these mutants expressed NR, nitrite reductase and nitrate transport activities in ammonium-nitrate media. Kinetic constants for ammonium (¹⁴C-methylammonium) transport, as well as enzymatic activities related to the ammonium-regulated metabolic pathway for xanthine utilization, were not affected in these strains. The data strongly suggest thatNrg1 andNrg2 are regulatory genes which specifically mediate the negative control exerted by ammonium on the nitrate assimilation pathway inC. reinhardtii.     

Effect of growth conditions on the synthesis of nitrate reductase components in chlorate resistant mutants of Escherichia coli K 12.

The chlorate resistant mutants of $\text{Escherichia coli}$ synthetize, in variable quantities, proteins which give immunocomplex with specific nitrate reductase antiserum. The biosynthesis of these cross reacting materials presents the same type of regulation as nitrate reductase of the wild type. C.R.M. biosynthesis is repressed by oxygen and even in the presence of nitrate, the oxygen inhibition is not reversed with chlorate mutants and wild type. With anaerobically grown cells, nitrate acts as an inducer and increases the amount of antibody-precipitable material, three times in mutants and even four times with Chl-E.     

Genetic relationship between nitrogen fixation and nitrate utilization in Cylindrospermum fertilissimum

Summary A series of nitrate reductaseless mutants of the blue-green alga (cyanobacterium), Cylindrospermum fertilissimum, have been isolated by selecting clones resistant to chlorate. Chlorate resistant mutants obtained spontaneously showed partial block in nitrate utilization and nitrogen fixation. Resistant derivatives were also obtained after NG mutagenesis. Some of these mutants were found to be double mutants, i.e., blocked in assimilation of nitrate and dinitrogen, simultaneously showing loss of heterocyst diffentiation. All the chlorate resistant/nitrate reductaseless mutants were either partially or completely blocked in utilization of dinitrogen supporting the proposed commonality between nitrogenase and nitrate reductase in the blue-green alga, Cylindrospermum fertilissimum.