On the stereoselective synthesis of (+)-pinoresinol in Forsythia suspensa from its achiral precursor, coniferyl alcohol

The residue from Forsythia suspensa stems, upon removal of soluble enzymes, has provided the first evidence for a stereoselective coupling enzyme in lignan biosynthesis. This preparation catalyses the preferred formation (ca 65%) of (+)-[8,8'-14C]pinoresinol from [8-14C]coniferyl alcohol in the absence of exogenously provided cofactors; addition of H2O2 had little effect on enantiomeric composition. However, when NAD and malate were supplied, the stereoselectivity of the coupling reaction was significantly enhanced and pinoresinol consisting of ca 80% of the (+)-antipode was obtained. Clearly, the insoluble residue contains a specific coupling enzyme which catalyses (+)-pinoresinol formation from coniferyl alcohol. By contrast, when [8-14C]sinapyl alcohol was employed as substrate, only racemic syringaresinols were formed: this non-stereoselective peroxidase-catalysed coupling reaction presumably accounts for the low levels of (-)-pinoresinol encountered in this system when coniferyl alcohol is used as a substrate.     

An extraordinary accumulation of (-)-pinoresinol in cell-free extracts of Forsythia intermedia: evidence for enantiospecific reduction of (+)-pinoresinol

Stereoselective and enantiospecific transformation mechanisms in lignan biogenesis are only now yielding to scientific inquiry: it has been shown that soluble cell-free preparations from Forsythia intermedia catalyse the formation of the enantiomerically pure lignan, (-)-secoisolariciresinol, when incubated with coniferyl alcohol in the presence of NAD(P)H and H2O2. Surprisingly, (-)-pinoresinol also accumulates in this soluble cell-free assay mixture in > 96% enantiomeric excess, even though it is not the naturally occurring antipode present in Forsythia sp. But these soluble cell-free preparations do not engender stereoselective coupling; instead, racemic pinoresinols are first formed, catalysed by an H2O2-dependent peroxidase reaction. An enantiospecific NAD(P)H reductase then converts (+)-pinoresinol, and not the (-)-antipode, into (-)-secoisolariciresinol. Stereoselective synthesis [correction of syntheis] of (+)-pinoresinol from E-coniferyl alcohol is, however, catalysed by an insoluble enzyme preparation in F. suspensa, obtained following removal of readily soluble and ionically bound enzymes; no exogenously supplied cofactors were required other than oxygen, although the reaction was stimulated by NAD-malate addition. Thus, the overall biochemical pathway to enantiomerically pure (-)-secoisolariciresinol has been delineated.     

Trimeric Structure of (+)-Pinoresinol-forming Dirigent Protein at 1.95 ? Resolution with Three Isolated Active Sites

Control over phenoxy radical-radical coupling reactions in vivo in vascular plants was enigmatic until our discovery of dirigent proteins (DPs, from the Latin dirigere, to guide or align). The first three-dimensional structure of a DP ((+)-pinoresinol-forming DP, 1.95 Å resolution, rhombohedral space group H32)) is reported herein. It has a tightly packed trimeric structure with an eight-stranded β-barrel topology for each DP monomer. Each putative substrate binding and orientation coupling site is located on the trimer surface but too far apart for intermolecular coupling between sites. It is proposed that each site enables stereoselective coupling (using either two coniferyl alcohol radicals or a radical and a monolignol). Interestingly, there are six differentially conserved residues in DPs affording either the (+)- or (−)-antipodes in the vicinity of the putative binding site and region known to control stereoselectivity. DPs are involved in lignan biosynthesis, whereas dirigent domains/sites have been implicated in lignin deposition.     

An historical perspective on lignan biosynthesis: Monolignol,allylphenol and hydroxycinnamic acid coupling and downstream metabolism

This review describes discoveries from this laboratory on monolignol, allylphenol and hydroxycinnamic acid coupling, and downstream metabolic conversions, affording various lignan skeleta. Stereoselective 8-8′ coupling (dirigent protein-mediated) of coniferyl alcohol to afford (+)-pinoresinol is comprehensively discussed, as is our current mechanistic/kinetic understanding of the protein’s radical-radical binding, orientation and coupling properties, and insights gained for other coupling modes, e.g. affording (−)-pinoresinol. In a species dependent manner, (+)- or (−)-pinoresinols can also undergo enantiospecific reductions, catalyzed by various bifunctional pinoresinol-lariciresinol reductases (PLR), to afford lariciresinol and then secoisolariciresinol. With X-ray structures giving a molecular basis for differing PLR enantiospecificities, comparisons are made herein to the X-ray structure of the related enzyme, phenylcoumaran benzylic ether reductase, capable of 8-5′ linked lignan regiospecific reductions. Properties of the enantiospecific secoisolariciresinol dehydrogenase (also discovered in our laboratory and generating 8-8′ linked matairesinol) are summarized, as are both in situ hybridization and immunolocalization of lignan pathway mRNA/proteins in vascular tissues. This entire 8-8′ pathway thus overall affords secoisolariciresinol and matairesinol, viewed as cancer preventative agent precursors, as well as intermediates to cancer treating substances, such as podophyllotoxin derivatives. Another emphasis is placed on allylphenol/hydroxycinnamic acid coupling and associated downstream metabolism, e.g. affording the antiviral creosote bush lignan, nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA), and the fern lignans, blechnic/brainic acids. Regiospecific 8-8′ allylphenol coupling is described, as is characterization of the first enantiospecific membrane-bound polyphenol oxidase, (+)-larreatricin hydroxylase, involved in NDGA formation. Specific [¹³C]-labeling also indicated that Blechnum lignans arise from stereoselective 8-2′ hydroxycinnamic acid coupling. Abbreviations: CD – circular dichroism; e.e. – enantiomeric excess; DP – dirigent protein; ESI-MS – electrospray ionization mass spectrometry; MALDI -TOF – matrix assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight; MALLS – multiangle laser light scattering; PLR – pinoresinol lariciresinol reductase; SDH – secoisolariciresinol dehydrogenase. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Dirigent proteins: molecular characteristics and potential biotechnological applications

Dirigent proteins (DIRs) are thought to play important roles in plant secondary metabolism. They lack catalytic activity but direct the outcome of bimolecular coupling reactions toward regio- and stereospecific product formation. Functionally described DIRs confer specificity to the oxidative coupling of coniferyl alcohol resulting in the preferred production of either (+)- or (?)-pinoresinol, which are the first intermediates in the enantiocomplementary pathways for lignan biosynthesis. DIRs are extracellular glycoproteins with high β-strand content and have been found in all land plants investigated so far. Their ability to capture and orientate radicals represents a unique naturally evolved concept for the control of radical dimerization reactions. Although oxidative coupling is commonly used in biological systems, its wider application in chemical synthesis is often limited by insufficient selectivity. This minireview gives an overview of functionally described DIRs and their molecular characteristics and wants to inspire further research for their use in biotechnological applications.     

Stereochemical Difference in Secoisolariciresinol Formation between Cell-free Extracts from Petioles and from Ripening Seeds of Arctium lappa L.

Cell-free extracts from ripening seeds of Arctium lappa L. catalyzed the enantioselective formation of (-)-pinoresinol, (-)-lariciresinol and (-)-secoisolariciresinol from achiral coniferyl alcohol in the presence of NADPH and H₂O₂. The enantioselectivity of the lignan formation was opposite to that of the (+)-secoisolariciresinol formation catalyzed by cell-free extracts from petioles of the same plant species.     

Formation of the lignan, (-) secoisolariciresinol, by cell free extracts of Forsythia intermedia

A crude cell-free extract from Forsythia intermedia catalyses the formation of (-)secoisolariciresinol, and not its (+) enantiomer, when incubated with coniferyl alcohol in the presence of NAD(P)H and H2O2. This is the first report of an enzyme reaction specifically involved in the coupling reaction between two phenylpropanoid monomers to afford an optically pure lignan.     

Stereochemical diversity in lignan biosynthesis of Arctium lappa L

The stereochemistry of lignan biosynthesis in Arctium lappa L. is regulated organ-specifically. (+)-Secoisolariciresinol [81% enantiomeric excess (e.e.)] was isolated from A. lappa petioles. In sharp contrast, lignans whose predominant enantiomers have the opposite absolute configuration to that of (+)-secoisolariciresinol [i.e., (-)-matairesinol (>99% e.e.), (-)-arctigenin (>99% e.e.), and (-)-secoisolariciresinol (65% e.e.)] were isolated from seeds of the species. The stereochemical diversity of secoisolariciresinol was demonstrated with enzyme preparations from A. lappa petioles and seeds. Thus, a petiole enzyme preparation catalyzed the formation of (+)-pinoresinol (33% e.e.), (+)-lariciresinol (30% e.e.), and (+)-secoisolariciresinol (20% e.e.) from achiral coniferyl alcohol in the presence of NADPH and H202, whereas that from ripening seeds catalyzed the formation of (-)-pinoresinol (22% e.e.), (-)-lariciresinol (>99% e.e.), and (-)-secoisolariciresinol (38% e.e.) under the same conditions. In addition, the ripening seed enzyme preparation mediated the selective formation of the optically pure (>99% e.e.) (-)-enantiomer of matairesinol from racemic (+/-)-secoisolariciresinols in the presence of NADP. These results indicate that the stereochemical mechanism for lignan biosynthesis in A. lappa varies with organs, suggesting that multiple lignan-synthesizing isozymes are involved in the stereochemical control of lignan formation in A. lappa.     

Influence of methyl jasmonate and coniferyl alcohol on pinoresinol and matairesinol accumulation in a Forsythia × intermedia suspension culture

The accumulation of the lignans pinoresinol and matairesinol (both predominantly as glucosides) in a Forsythia 2 intermedia cell suspension culture was enhanced about three- and sevenfold, respectively, by the addition of methyl jasmonate to the cell culture medium. Cells accumulated 0.86ǂ.19 mg/g dry weight pinoresinol and 2.24ǃ.00 mg/g dry weight matairesinol. Feeding experiments with the precursor coniferyl alcohol resulted in a fast increase in the pinoresinol content, but matairesinol accumulation was not influenced. The racemic ratio of pinoresinol was 77dž% (+)-pinoresinol in methyl jasmonate-treated cells and 21Dž% (+)-pinoresinol in cells fed with coniferyl alcohol.     

Secondary and quaternary structures of the (+)-pinoresinol-forming dirigent protein

The (+)-pinoresinol-forming dirigent protein is the first protein capable of stereoselectively coupling two coniferyl alcohol derived radical species, in this case to give the 8-8' linked (+)-pinoresinol. Only dimeric cross-linked dirigent protein structures were isolated when 1-ethyl-3-[3-(dimethylamino)-propyl]carbodiimide was used as cross-linking agent, whereas the associated oxidase, presumed to generate the corresponding free radical substrate, was not detected. Native Forsythia intermedia dirigent protein isoforms were additionally subjected to MALDI-TOF and ESI-MS analyses, which established the presence of both monomeric masses of 23-25 kDa and dimeric dirigent protein species ranging from 46 to 49 kDa. Analytical ultracentrifugation, sedimentation velocity, and sedimentation equilibrium analyses of the native dirigent protein in open solution confirmed further its dimeric nature as well as a propensity to aggregate, with the latter being dependent upon both temperature and solution ionic strength. Circular dichroism analysis suggested that the dirigent protein was primarily composed of beta-sheet and loop structures.     

Pinoresinol-lariciresinol reductase: Substrate versatility,enantiospecificity, and kinetic properties

Two western red cedar pinoresinol-lariciresinol reductase (PLR) homologues were studied to determine their enantioselective, substrate versatility, and kinetic properties. PLRs are downstream of dirigent protein engendered, coniferyl alcohol derived, stereoselective coupling to afford entry into the 8- and 8′-linked furofuran lignan, pinoresinol. Our investigations showed that each PLR homolog can enantiospecifically metabolize different furofuran lignans with modified aromatic ring substituents, but where phenolic groups at both C4/C4′ are essential for catalysis. These results are consistent with quinone methide intermediate formation in the PLR active site. Site-directed mutagenesis and kinetic measurements provided additional insight into factors affecting enantioselectivity and kinetic properties. From these data, PLRs can be envisaged to allow for the biotechnological potential of generation of various lignan skeleta, that could be differentially “decorated” on their aromatic ring substituents, via the action of upstream dirigent proteins.     

Formation of lignans (-)-secoisolariciresinol and (-)-matairesinol with Forsythia intermedia cell-free extracts

In vivo labeling experiments of Forsythia intermedia plant tissue with [8-14C]- and [9,9-2H2,OC2H3]coniferyl alcohols revealed that the lignans, (-)-secoisolariciresinol and (-)-matairesinol, were derived from two coniferyl alcohol molecules; no evidence for the formation of the corresponding (+)-enantiomers was found. Administration of (+-)-[Ar-3H]secoisolariciresinols to excised shoots of F. intermedia resulted in a significant conversion into (-)-matairesinol; again, the (+)-antipode was not detected. Experiments using cell-free extracts of F. intermedia confirmed and extended these findings. In the presence of NAD(P)H and H2O2, the cell-free extracts catalyzed the formation of (-)-secoisolariciresinol, with either [8-14C]- or [9,9-2H2,OC2H3]coniferyl alcohols as substrates. The (+)-enantiomer was not formed. Finally, when either (-)-[Ar-3H] or (+-)-[Ar-2H]secoisolariciresinols were used as substrates, in the presence of NAD(P), only (-)- and not (+)-matairesinol formation occurred. The other antipode, (+)-secoisolariciresinol, did not serve as a substrate for the formation of either (+)- or (-)-matairesinol. Thus, in F. intermedia, the formation of the lignan, (-)-secoisolariciresinol, occurs under strict stereochemical control, in a reaction or reactions requiring NAD(P)H and H2O2 as cofactors. This stereoselectivity is retained in the subsequent conversion into (-)-matairesinol, since (+)-secoisolariciresinol is not a substrate. These are the first two enzymes to be discovered in lignan formation.     

Small Glycosylated Lignin Oligomers Are Stored in Arabidopsis Leaf Vacuoles

Lignin is an aromatic polymer derived from the combinatorial coupling of monolignol radicals in the cell wall. Recently, various glycosylated lignin oligomers have been revealed in Arabidopsis thaliana. Given that monolignol oxidation and monolignol radical coupling are known to occur in the apoplast, and glycosylation in the cytoplasm, it raises questions about the subcellular localization of glycosylated lignin oligomer biosynthesis and their storage. By metabolite profiling of Arabidopsis leaf vacuoles, we show that the leaf vacuole stores a large number of these small glycosylated lignin oligomers. Their structural variety and the incorporation of alternative monomers, as observed in Arabidopsis mutants with altered monolignol biosynthesis, indicate that they are all formed by combinatorial radical coupling. In contrast to the common believe that combinatorial coupling is restricted to the apoplast, we hypothesized that the aglycones of these compounds are made within the cell. To investigate this, leaf protoplast cultures were cofed with ¹³C₆-labeled coniferyl alcohol and a ¹³C₄-labeled dimer of coniferyl alcohol. Metabolite profiling of the cofed protoplasts provided strong support for the occurrence of intracellular monolignol coupling. We therefore propose a metabolic pathway involving intracellular combinatorial coupling of monolignol radicals, followed by oligomer glycosylation and vacuolar import, which shares characteristics with both lignin and lignan biosynthesis.     

A model of dirigent proteins derived from structural and functional similarities with allene oxide cyclase and lipocalins

Dirigent proteins impart stereoselectivity on the phenoxy radical-coupling reaction, yielding optically active lignans from two molecules of coniferyl alcohol. By an unknown mechanism, they direct the coupling of two phenoxy radicals toward the formation of optically active (+)- or (-)-pinoresinol. We show here that the dirigent protein AtDIR6 from Arabidopsis thaliana is a homodimeric all-beta protein in the superfamily of calycins. Based on its homology with calycins, the structure of AtDIR6 was modeled using allene oxide cyclase as template. The structural model of AtDIR6 was supported experimentally by confirmation of a predicted disulfide bridge and by the characterization of two N-linked glycans at the solvent-exposed protein surface. The model shows AtDIR6 as an eight-stranded antiparallel β-barrel with a central hydrophobic cavity for substrate binding, suggesting that dirigent proteins evolved from hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins. The data are fully consistent with the current view of the dirigent protein mode of action, according to which each subunit of the homodimer captures one of the substrate radicals and orients them in a way that precludes undesired reaction channels, thus favoring the formation of the optically pure coupling product.     

Dirigent phenoxy radical coupling: advances and challenges

The past seven years have witnessed significant progress in the biochemical characterization of dirigent (monolignol radical binding) proteins in vitro, as well as in the delineation of their associated metabolic networks in planta. Interestingly, both the stereoselective and regiospecific control over phenoxy radical-radical coupling appears to have evolved during the transition of plants to a land base for lignan, norlignan and ellagitannin biosynthesis.     

Ferulate–coniferyl alcohol cross-coupled products formed by radical coupling reactions

Radical coupling reactions between ethyl ferulate (Et-FA), a simple model for feruloyl polysaccharides in planta, and coniferyl alcohol (CA), a monolignol, were studied in order to better understand the polymer cross-coupling interactions among polysaccharides and monolignols or lignin, mediated by ferulate (FA), in plant cell walls. Cross-coupled FA/CA dimers produced in an aqueous buffer (pH 5.0) containing peroxidase/hydrogen peroxide were isolated and characterized by NMR. The total coupling products were characterized by 2D ¹³C–¹H correlation (HSQC) NMR spectroscopy and GC–MS. Results from this study showed that ferulate readily cross-couples with coniferyl alcohol through free radical coupling mechanisms producing a series of cross-coupled FA/CA dimers with β-O-4-, β-5-/8-5-, and 8-β-linkages; the syntheses and isolation of β-5- and 8-5-cross-coupled dimers are reported here. The transformation from 8-β-coupled FA/CA hydroxyl esters into lactones through intramolecular transesterification is demonstrated for the first time and mechanisms behind these transformations are discussed. The finding of both β-5- and 8-5-cross-coupled dimers in this study suggests that analogs of both may be present in plant cell walls. Finally it is suggested that ferulates in plants indeed react with monolignols through free radical mechanisms producing a more diverse array of cross-coupled dimers than previously reported.     

Biosynthesis of antimalarial lignans from Holostylis reniformis

Holostylis reniformis biosynthesizes 8-8′ linked lignans without 9,9′-oxygenation. To elucidate the biosynthetic pathways to these lignans, the reputed precursors [U-¹⁴C]phenylalanine, [9-³H₁]coniferyl alcohol, and [9-³H₁]isoeugenol were administered to roots of the plant, which led to the incorporation of ³H and ¹⁴C into ten 2,7′ linked-lignans (aryltetralone lignans) and two 7,7′-epoxylignans (furan lignans). These administration experiments demonstrated that the lignans were propenylphenol-derived and that H. reniformis can exhibit regioselective control over radical-radical coupling (via isoeugenol radicals). Regiospecific control over propenylphenol-derived lignan biosynthesis was observed, together with diastereoselective control of C2-C7′ bond formation for the aryltetralone lignans (7′R). These experiments provide evidence that isoeugenol is a biosynthetic intermediate to the aryltetralone and furan lignans.     

Regulation of Peroxidase-Dependent Oxidation of Phenolics by Ascorbic Acid: Different Effects of Ascorbic Acid on the Oxidation of Coniferyl Alcohol by the Apoplastic Soluble and Cell Wall-Bound Peroxidases from Epicotyls of Vigna angularis

Intercellular washing fluid (IWF) and washed cell walls obtainedfrom epicotyls of Vigna angularis catalyzed the oxidation ofconiferyl alcohol in the presence of hydrogen peroxide, indicatingthe presence of both soluble and bound peroxidases in the cellwalls. The products of oxidation of coniferyl alcohol were identicalin both cases. Ascorbic acid inhibited the oxidation of coniferylalcohol. The inhibition was due to the rapid reduction of anoxidized intermediate of coniferyl alcohol by ascorbic acid,with resultant regeneration of coniferyl alcohol. However, theinhibitory effects of ascorbic acid were different in the caseof IWF and cell walls. Ascorbic acid completely inhibited theoxidation of coniferyl alcohol by IWF peroxidase as long asascorbic acid was available, whereas the oxidation of coniferylalcohol by cell wall-bound peroxidase was competitively inhibitedby ascorbic acid. Ascorbic acid was present in cell walls andlignin was formed in cell walls during aging of stem. Basedon these results, a possible function for ascorbic acid in theregulation of oxidation of phenolics in cell walls is discussed. (Received March 19, 1993; Accepted May 24, 1993)     

Hinokinin biosynthesis in Linum corymbulosum Reichenb

Due to their peculiar stereochemistry and numerous biological activities, lignans are of widespread interest. As only a few biosynthetic steps have been clarified to date, we aimed to further resolve the molecular basis of lignan biosynthesis. To this end, we first established that the biologically active lignan (−)-hinokinin could be isolated from in vitro cultures of Linum corymbulosum. Two hypothetical pathways were outlined for the biosynthesis of (−)-hinokinin. In both pathways, (+)-pinoresinol serves as the primary substrate. In the first pathway, pinoresinol is reduced via lariciresinol to secoisolariciresinol by a pinoresinol–lariciresinol reductase, and methylenedioxy bridges are formed later. In the second pathway, pinoresinol itself is the substrate for formation of the methylenedioxy bridges, resulting in consecutive production of piperitol and sesamin. To determine which of the proposed hypothetical pathways acts in vivo , we first isolated several cDNAs encoding one pinoresinol-lariciresinol reductase ( PLR-Lc1 ), two phenylcoumaran benzylic ether reductases ( PCBER-Lc1 and PCBER-Lc2 ), and two PCBER-like proteins from a cDNA library of L. corymbulosum. PLR-Lc1 was found to be enantiospecific for the conversion of (+)-pinoresinol to (−)-secoisolariciresinol, which can be further converted to give (−)-hinokinin. Hairy root lines with significantly reduced expression levels of the plr-Lc1 gene were established using RNAi technology. Hinokinin accumulation was reduced to non-detectable levels in these lines. Our results strongly indicate that PLR-Lc1 participates in (−)-hinokinin biosynthesis in L. corymbulosum by the first of the two hypothetical pathways via (−)-secoisolariciresinol.     

Coniferyl ferulate incorporation into lignin enhances the alkaline delignification and enzymatic degradation of cell walls

Incorporating ester interunit linkages into lignin could facilitate fiber delignification and utilization. In model studies with maize cell walls, we examined how partial substitution of coniferyl alcohol (a normal monolignol) with coniferyl ferulate (an ester conjugate from lignan biosynthesis) alters the formation and alkaline extractability of lignin and the enzymatic hydrolysis of structural polysaccharides. Coniferyl ferulate moderately reduced lignification and cell-wall ferulate copolymerization with monolignols. Incorporation of coniferyl ferulate increased lignin extractability by up to 2-fold in aqueous NaOH, providing an avenue for producing fiber with less noncellulosic and lignin contamination or of delignifying at lower temperatures. Cell walls lignified with coniferyl ferulate were more readily hydrolyzed with fibrolytic enzymes, both with and without alkaline pretreatment. Based on our results, bioengineering of plants to incorporate coniferyl ferulate into lignin should enhance lignocellulosic biomass saccharification and particularly pulping for paper production.