A simple modification to improve the accuracy of methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme quantitative polymerase chain reaction

DNA digestion with endonucleases sensitive to CpG methylation such as HpaII followed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) quantitation is commonly used in molecular studies as a simple and inexpensive solution for assessment of region-specific DNA methylation. We observed that the results of such analyses were highly overestimated if mock-digested samples were applied as the reference. We determined DNA methylation levels in several promoter regions in two setups implementing different references: mock-digested and treated with a restriction enzyme that has no recognition sites within examined amplicons. Fragmentation of reference templates allowed removing the overestimation effect, thereby improving measurement accuracy.     

Molecular cloning of PCR fragments with cohesive ends

Use of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) provides a convenient means of generating DNA fragments for insertion into plasmids. Large quantities of the desired insert, bounded by convenient restriction sites, may be synthesized. The primers are chosen to span a known region of interest, and extended at their 5′-ends to include the desired restriction sites. Amplification of the target sequence is followed by precipitation of the product with ammonium acetate and ethanol to remove the primers. A small amount of product is analyzed by gel electrophoresis to ensure correct amplification, the remainder is digested with the appropriate restriction enzyme(s). Restricted insert DNA is added to similarly restricted plasmid DNA in several ratios and incubated with DNA ligase to recircularize. Ligation products are used to transform competent bacteria. Clones containing inserts are identified by restriction digestion of plasmid minipreps from bacterial colonies.     

A novel method for producing partial restriction digestion of DNA fragments by PCR with 5-methyl-CTP.

Partial digestion of DNA fragments is a standard procedure for subcloning analysis and for generating restriction maps. We have developed a novel method to generate a partial digestion for any DNA fragment that can be amplified by PCR. The method involves the incorporation of 5-methyl-dCTP into the PCR product to protect most of the restriction sites. As a result, complete digestion of the modified PCR products with a 5-methyl-dCTP-sensitive enzyme will produce an array of restriction fragments equivalent to a partial restriction enzyme digestion reaction done on unmethylated PCR products. This method reduces the time and material needed to produce partially-digested DNA fragments by traditional methods. Furthermore, using fluorescein-labeled primers in the reaction, we were able to detect the fluorescein-labeled end fragments resulting from the enzyme digestion using a fluorimager or anti-fluorescein-AP antibody and thus determine the restriction maps.     

A sensitive new method for rapid detection of abnormal methylation patterns in global DNA and within CpG islands.

To assess alterations in DNA methylation density in both global DNA and within CpG islands, we have developed a simple method based on the use of methylation-sensitive restriction endonucleases that leave a 5' guanine overhang after DNA cleavage, with subsequent single nucleotide extension with radiolabeled [(3)H]dCTP. The methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes HpaII and AciI have relatively frequent recognition sequences at CpG sites that occur randomly throughout the genome. BssHII is a methylation sensitive enzyme that similarly leaves a guanine overhang, but the recognition sequence is nonrandom and occurs predominantly at unmethylated CpG sites within CpG islands. The selective use of these enzymes can be used to screen for alterations in genome-wide methylation and CpG island methylation status, respectively. The extent of [(3)H]dCTP incorporation opposite the exposed guanine after restriction enzyme treatment is directly proportional to the number of unmethylated (cleaved) CpG sites. The "cytosine-extension assay" has several advantages over existing methods because (a) radiolabel incorporation is independent of the integrity of the DNA, (b) methylation detection does not require PCR amplification or DNA methylase reactions, and (c) it is applicable to ng quantities of DNA. Using DNA extracted from normal human liver and from human hepatocellular carcinoma, the applicability of the assay is demonstrated by the detection of an increase in genome-wide hypomethylation and CpG island hypermethylation in the tumor DNA.     

Microsoft Word macro for analysis of cytosine methylation by the bisulfite deamination reaction

Cytosine methylation at CpG dinucleotides is an important control mechanism in development, differentiation, and neoplasia. Bisulfite genomic sequencing and its modifications have been developed to examine methylation at these CpG dinucleotides. To use these methods, one has to (i) manually convert the sequence to that produced by bisulfite conversion and PCR amplification, taking into account that cytosine residues at CpG dinucleotides may or may not be converted depending on their methylation status, (ii) identify relevant restriction sites that may be used for methylation analysis, and (iii) conduct similar steps with the other DNA strand since the two strands of DNA are no longer complementary after bisulfite conversion. To automate these steps, we have developed a macro that can be used with Microsoft Word. This macro (i) converts genomic sequence to modified sequence that would result after bisulfite treatment facilitating primer design for bisulfite genomic sequencing and methylation-sensitive PCR assay and (ii) identifies restriction sites that are preserved in bisulfite-converted and PCR-amplified product only if cytosine residues at relevant CpG dinucleotides are methylated (and thereby not converted to uracil) in the genomic DNA.     

Rapid quantitation of methylation differences at specific sites using methylation-sensitive single nucleotide primer extension (Ms-SNuPE).

We have developed a rapid quantitative method (Ms-SNuPE) for assessing methylation differences at specific CpG sites based on bisulfite treatment of DNA followed by single nucleotide primer extension. Genomic DNA was first reacted with sodium bisulfite to convert unmethylated cytosine to uracil while leaving 5-methylcytosine unchanged. Amplification of the desired target sequence was then performed using PCR primers specific for bisulfite-converted DNA and the resulting product isolated and used as a template for methylation analysis at the CpG site(s) of interest. This methylation-sensitive technique has several advantages over existing methods used for detection of methylation changes because small amounts of DNA can be analyzed including microdissected pathology sections and it avoids utilization of restriction enzymes for determining the methylation status at CpG sites.     

Global methylation screening in the Arabidopsis thaliana and Mus musculus genome: applications of virtual image restriction landmark genomic scanning (Vi-RLGS)

Understanding the role of ‘epigenetic’ changes such as DNA methylation and chromatin remodeling has now become critical in understanding many biological processes. In order to delineate the global methylation pattern in a given genomic DNA, computer software has been developed to create a virtual image of restriction landmark genomic scanning (Vi-RLGS). When using a methylation- sensitive enzyme such as NotI as the restriction landmark, the comparison between real and in silico RLGS profiles of the genome provides a methylation map of genomic NotI sites. A methylation map of the Arabidopsis genome was created that could be confirmed by a methylation-sensitive PCR assay. The method has also been applied to the mouse genome. Although a complete methylation map has not been completed, a region of methylation difference between two tissues has been tested and confirmed by bisulfite sequencing. Vi-RLGS in conjunction with real RLGS will make it possible to develop a more complete map of genomic sites that are methylated or demethylated as a consequence of normal or abnormal development.     

Cytosine methylation occurs in a CDC48 homologue and a MADS-box gene during adventitious shoot induction in Petunia leaf explants

The DNA methylase inhibitors, 5-azacytidine and 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine inhibited adventitious shoot induction in Petunia leaf cultures. Cytosine methylation status at CCGG sites in shoot- and callus-inducing culture treatments was analysed by coupled restriction enzyme digestion (HpaII or MspI) and random amplification. Two differentially methylated genomic DNA bands from the PCR products were cloned (OPU9-1 and OPU9-2) and sequenced. The open reading frames contained in OPU9-1 and OPU9-2 showed similarity to CDC48 and MADS-box genes, respectively. Cytosine methylation was restored at CCGG sites when the leaf explants were transferred from medium containing the drugs to medium without the drugs, simultaneously recovering the ability to develop adventitious shoot buds. Furthermore, combined bisulphite treatment and restriction analysis revealed differential methylation of CGCG sites in the drug-treated and control cultures. These results demonstrate that cytosine methylation at CCGG and CGCG sites within a MADS-box gene and a CDC48 homologue, among others, shows strong positive correlation with adventitious shoot bud induction in Petunia leaf explants.     

Improved Quantification of DNA Methylation Using Methylation-Sensitive Restriction Enzymes and Real-Time PCR

Heterogeneity of cells with respect to the DNA methylation status at a specific CpG site is a problem when assessing methylation status. We have developed a simple two-step method for the quantification of the percent of cells that display methylation at a specific CpG site in the promoter of a specific gene. The first step is overnight digestion of genomic DNA (optimal conc. 20ng/5μl) with a relevant methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme (optimal 2 units). This is followed by real time PCR, using the SYBR® Green method, with primers that bracket the site cleaved by the enzyme. By including fully methylated and fully non-methylated DNA in each PCR plate, the errors caused by non-specific digestion or incomplete digestion can be measured and used to adjust the raw results and thus increase specificity. The method can detect differences in methylation status if these are more than 10%. No specialized equipment is required beyond the real-time PCR system and the method can be adapted for any of the 53 commercially available methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes.     

DNA methylation: a profile of methods and applications

Ever since methylcytosine was found in genomic DNA, this epigenetic alteration has become a center of scientific attraction, especially because of its relation to gene silencing in disease. There is currently a wide range of methods designed to yield quantitative and qualitative information on genomic DNA methylation. The earliest approaches were concentrated on the study of overall levels of methylcytosine, but more recent efforts havefocused on the study ofthe methylation status of specific DNA sequences. Particularly, optimization of the methods based on bisulfite modification of DNA permits the analysis of limited CpGs in restriction enzyme sites (e.g., combined bisulfite restriction analyses and methylation-sensitive single nucleotide primer extension) and the overall characterization based on differential methylation states (e.g., methylation-specific PCR, MethyLight, and methylation-sensitive single-stranded conformational polymorphism) and allows very specific patterns of methylation to be revealed (bisulfite DNA sequencing). In addition, novel methods designed to search for new methylcytosine hot spots have yielded further data without requiring prior knowledge of the DNA sequence. We hope this review will be a valuable tool in selecting the best techniques to address particular questions concerning the cytosine methylation status of genomic DNA.     

Studies on the biological role of dna methylation; IV. Mode of methylation of DNA in E. coli cells

Two pairs of restriction enzyme isoschizomers were used to study in vivo methylation of E. coli and extrachromosomal DNA. By use of the restriction enzymes MboI (which cleaves only the unmethylated GATC sequence) and its isoschizomer Sau3A (indifferent to methylated adenine at this sequence), we found that all the GATC sites in E. coli and in extrachromosomal DNAs are symmetrically methylated on both strands. The calculated number of GATC sites in E. coli DNA can account for all its m6Ade residues. Foreign DNA, like mouse mtDNA, which is not methylated at GATC sites became fully methylated at these sequences when introduced by transfection into E. coli cells. This experiment provides the first evidence for the operation of a de novo methylation mechanism for E. coli methylases not involved in restriction modification. When the two restriction enzyme isoschizomers, EcoRII and ApyI, were used to analyze the methylation pattern of CCTAGG sequences in E. coli C and phi X174 DNA, it was found that all these sites are methylated. The number of CCTAGG sites in E. coli C DNA does not account for all m5Cyt residues.     

Copy number variations of 11 macronuclear chromosomes and their gene expression in Oxytricha trifallax

Genome-wide methylation studies frequently lack adequate controls to estimate proportions of background reads in the resulting datasets. To generate appropriate control pools, we developed technique termed nMETR (non-methylated tag recovery) based on digestion of genomic DNA with methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme, ligation of adapter oligonucleotide and PCR amplification of non-methylated sites associated with genomic repetitive elements. The protocol takes only two working days to generate amplicons for deep sequencing. We applied nMETR for human DNA using BspFNI enzyme and retrotransposon Alu-specific primers. 454-sequencing enabled identification of 1113 nMETR tag sites, of them ~65% were parts of CpG islands. Representation of reads inversely correlated with methylation levels, thus confirming nMETR fidelity. We created software that eliminates background reads and enables to map and annotate individual tags on human genome. nMETR tags may serve as the controls for large-scale epigenetic studies and for identifying unmethylated transposable elements located close to genomic CpG islands.     

Cleavage of a model DNA replication fork by a methyl-specific endonuclease

Epigenetic DNA methylation is involved in many biological processes. An epigenetic status can be altered by gain or loss of a DNA methyltransferase gene or its activity. Repair of DNA damage can also remove DNA methylation. In response to such alterations, DNA endonucleases that sense DNA methylation can act and may cause cell death. Here, we explored the possibility that McrBC, a methylation-dependent DNase of Escherichia coli, cleaves DNA at a replication fork. First, we found that in vivo restriction by McrBC of bacteriophage carrying a foreign DNA methyltransferase gene is increased in the absence of homologous recombination. This suggests that some cleavage events are repaired by recombination and must take place during or after replication. Next, we demonstrated that the enzyme can cleave a model DNA replication fork in vitro. Cleavage of a fork required methylation on both arms and removed one, the other or both of the arms. Most cleavage events removed the methylated sites from the fork. This result suggests that acquisition of even rarely occurring modification patterns will be recognized and rejected efficiently by modification-dependent restriction systems that recognize two sites. This process might serve to maintain an epigenetic status along the genome through programmed cell death.     

DNA adenine methylation changes dramatically during establishment of symbiosis

The DNA adenine methylation status on specific 5'-GANTC-3' sites and its change during the establishment of plant-microbe interactions was demonstrated in several species of alpha-proteobacteria. Restriction landmark genome scanning (RLGS), which is a high-resolution two dimensional DNA electrophoresis method, was used to monitor the genomewide change in methylation. In the case of Mesorhizobium loti MAFF303099, real RLGS images obtained with the restriction enzyme MboI, which digests at GATC sites, almost perfectly matched the virtual RLGS images generated based on genome sequences. However, only a few spots were observed when the restriction enzyme HinfI was used, suggesting that most GANTC (HinfI) sites were tightly methylated and specific sites were unmethylated. DNA gel blot analysis with the cloned specifically unmethylated regions (SUMs) showed that some SUMs were methylated differentially in bacteroids compared to free-living bacteria. SUMs have also been identified in other symbiotic and parasitic bacteria. These results suggest that DNA adenine methylation may contribute to the establishment and/or maintenance of symbiotic and parasitic relationships.     

DNA methylation. Inhibition of de novo and maintenance methylation in vitro by RNA and synthetic polynucleotides

A partially purified HeLa cell DNA methylase will methylate a totally unmethylated DNA (de novo methylation) at about 3-4% the rate it will methylate a hemimethylated DNA template (maintenance methylation). Our evidence suggests that many, if not most, dCpdG sequences in a natural or synthetic DNA can be methylated by the enzyme. There is a powerful inhibitor of DNA methylase activity in crude extracts which has been identified as RNA. The inhibition of DNA methylase by RNA may indicate that this enzyme is regulated in vivo by the presence of RNA at specific chromosomal sites. The pattern of binding of RNA to DNA in the nucleosome structure and the DNA replication complex may determine specific sites of DNA methylation. An even more potent inhibition of DNA methylase activity is observed with poly(G), but not poly(C), poly(A), or poly(U). The only other synthetic polynucleotides studied which inhibit DNA methylation as well as poly(G) are the homopolymers poly(dC).poly(dG) and poly (dA).poly(dT). These results point out the unique importance of the guanine residue itself in the binding of the DNA methylase to dCpdG, the site of cytosine methylation. The surprising inhibition of the methylation reaction by poly(dA).poly(dT), which is itself not methylated by the enzyme, suggests the possible involvement of adjacent A and T residues in influencing the choice of sites of methylation by the enzyme.     

The Escherichia coli dam DNA methyltransferase modifies DNA in a highly processive reaction

The Escherichia coli dam adenine-N6 methyltransferase modifies DNA at GATC sequences. It is involved in post-replicative mismatch repair, control of DNA replication and gene regulation. We show that E. coli dam acts as a functional monomer and methylates only one strand of the DNA in each binding event. The preferred way of ternary complex assembly is that the enzyme first binds to DNA and then to S-adenosylmethionine. The enzyme methylates an oligonucleotide containing two dam sites and a 879 bp PCR product with four sites in a fully processive reaction. On lambda-DNA comprising 48,502 bp and 116 dam sites, E. coli dam scans 3000 dam sites per binding event in a random walk, that on average leads to a processive methylation of 55 sites. Processive methylation of DNA considerably accelerates DNA methylation. The highly processive mechanism of E. coli dam could explain why small amounts of E. coli dam are able to maintain the methylation state of dam sites during DNA replication. Furthermore, our data support the general rule that solitary DNA methyltransferase modify DNA processively whereas methyltransferases belonging to a restriction-modification system show a distributive mechanism, because processive methylation of DNA would interfere with the biological function of restriction-modification systems.     

Detection of DNA Methylation by Dnmt3a Methyltransferase using Methyl-Dependent Restriction Endonucleases

DNA methylation at cytosine residues in CpG sites by DNA methyltransferases (MTases) is associated with various cell processes. Eukaryotic MTase Dnmt3a is the key enzyme that establishes the de novo methylation pattern. A new in vitro assay for DNA methylation by murine MTase Dnmt3a was developed using methyl-dependent restriction endonucleases (MD-REs), which specifically cleave methylated DNA. The Dnmt3a catalytic domain (Dnmt3a-CD) was used together with KroI and PcsI MD-REs. The assay consists in consecutive methylation and cleavage of fluorescently labeled DNA substrates, then the reaction products are visualized in polyacrylamide gel to determine the DNA methylation efficiency. Each MD-RE was tested with various substrates, including partly methylated ones. PcsI was identified as an optimal MDRE. PcsI recognizes two methylated CpG sites located 7 bp apart, the distance roughly corresponding to the distance between the active centers of the Dnmt3a-CD tetramer. An optimal substrate was designed to contain two methylated cytosine residues and two target cytosines in the orientation suitable for methylation by Dnmt3a-CD. The assay is reliable, simple, and inexpensive and, unlike conventional methods, does not require radioactive compounds. The assay may be used to assess the effectiveness of Dnmt3a inhibitors as potential therapeutic agents and to investigate the features of the Dnmt3a-CD function.     

Bacteriophage T2 and T4, dam+ and damh and Eco dam+ methylation: preference at different sites

We present a method for determining preference for methylation at minor methylation sites. The target DNA sequence is first subjected to computer-assisted analysis to predict which restriction endonuclease(s) will generate fragments that will contain only one or two likely minor methylation site(s). The target DNA is then methylated in vitro with a radioactive methyl-group donor and subjected to digestion by the chosen restriction enzyme(s). The amount of radioactivity in the various fragments is determined, after separating them using polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. We documented the effect of nearby bases on the methylation preference and the relative preference for methylation at some specific minor methylation sites.