The cross-road between the mechanisms of protein folding and aggregation; study of human stefin B and its H75W mutant

The role of the aromatic residue at site 75 to protein stability, the mechanism of folding and the mechanism of amyloid-fibril formation were investigated for the human stefin B variant (bearing Y at site 31) and its point mutation H75W. With an aim to reveal the conformation at the cross-road between folding and aggregation, first, the kinetics of folding and oligomer formation by human stefin B(Y31) variant were studied. It was found to fold in three kinetic phases at pH 4.8 and 10% TFE; the pH and solvent conditions that transform the protein into amyloid fibrils at longer times. The same pH leads to the formation of native-like intermediate (known from previous studies of this variant), meaning that the process of folding and amyloid-fibril formation share the same structural intermediate, which is in this case native-like and dimeric. At pH 5.8 and 7.0 stefin B folded to the native state in four kinetic phases over two intermediates. In distinction, the mutant H75W did not fold to completion, ending in intermediate states at all pH values studied: 4.8, 5.8 and 7.0. At pH 4.8 and 5.8, the mutant folded in one kinetic phase to the intermediate of the “molten globule” type, which leads to the conclusion that its mechanism of folding differs from the one of the parent stefin B at the same pH. At pH 7.0 the mutant H75W folded in three kinetic phases to a native-like intermediate, analogous to folding of stefin B at pH 4.8.     

High affinity copper binding by stefin B (cystatin B) and its role in the inhibition of amyloid fibrillation

We show that human stefin B, a protease inhibitor from the family of cystatins, is a copper binding protein, unlike stefin A. We have used isothermal titration calorimetry to directly monitor the binding event at pH 7 and pH 5. At pH 7 stefin B shows a picomolar affinity for copper but at pH 5 the affinity is in the nanomolar range. There is no difference in the affinity of copper between the wildtype stefin B (E31 isoform) and a variant (Y31 isoform), whereas the mutant (P79S), which is tetrameric, does not bind copper. The conformation of stefin B remains unaltered by copper binding. It is known that below pH 5 stefin B undergoes a conformational change and amyloid fibril formation. We show that copper binding inhibits the amyloid fibril formation and, to a lesser degree, the initial aggregation. Similarities to and differences from other copper binding amyloidogenic proteins are discussed.     

In vitro study of stability and amyloid-fibril formation of two mutants of human stefin B (cystatin B) occurring in patients with EPM1

Myoclonus epilepsy of type 1 (EPM1) is a rare monogenic progressive and degenerative epilepsy, also known under the name Unverricht-Lundborg disease. With the aim of comparing their behavior in vitro, wild-type (wt) human stefin B (cystatin B) and the G4R and the R68X mutants observed in EPM1 were expressed and isolated from the Escherichia coli lysate. The R68X mutant (Arg68Stop) is a peptide of 67 amino acids from the N terminus of stefin B. CD spectra have shown that the R68X peptide is not folded, in contrast to the G4R mutant, which folds like wild type. The wild type and the G4R mutant were unfolded by urea and by trifluoroethanol (TFE). It has been shown that both proteins have closely similar stability and that at pH 4.8, where a native-like intermediate was demonstrated, TFE induces unfolding intermediates prior to the major transition to the all-alpha-helical state. Kinetics of fibril formation were followed by Thioflavin T fluorescence while the accompanying changes of morphology were followed by the transmission electron microscopy (TEM). For the two folded proteins the optimal concentration of TFE producing extensive lag phases and high fibril yields was predenaturational, 9% (v/v). The unfolded R68X peptide, which is highly prone to aggregate, formed amyloid fibrils in aqueous solution and in predenaturing 3% TFE. The G4R mutant exhibited a much longer lag phase than the wild type, with the accumulation of prefibrillar aggregates. Implications for pathology in view of the higher toxicity of prefibrillar aggregates to cells are discussed.     

Different propensity to form amyloid fibrils by two homologous proteins-Human stefins A and B: searching for an explanation

By using ThT fluorescence, X-ray diffraction, and atomic force microscopy (AFM), it has been shown that human stefins A and B (subfamily A of cystatins) form amyloid fibrils. Both protein fibrils show the 4.7 A and 10 A reflections characteristic for cross beta-structure. Similar height of approximately 3 nm and longitudinal repeat of 25-27 nm were observed by AFM for both protein fibrils. Fibrils with a double height of 5.6 nm were only observed with stefin A. The fibril's width for stefin A fibrils, as observed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), was in the same range as previously reported for stefin B (Zerovnik et al., Biochem Biophys Acta 2002;1594:1-5). The conditions needed to undergo fibrillation differ, though. The amyloid fibrils start to form at pH 5 for stefin B, whereas in stefin A, preheated sample has to be acidified to pH < 2.5. In both cases, adding TFE, seeding, and alignment in a strong magnetic field accelerate the fibril growth. Visual analysis of the three-dimensional structures of monomers and domain-swapped dimers suggests that major differences in stability of both homologues stem from arrangement of specific salt bridges, which fix alpha-helix (and the alpha-loop) to beta-sheet in stefin A monomeric and dimeric forms.     

Differences in the effects of TFE on the folding pathways of human stefins A and B.

Trifluoroethanol (TFE) has been used to probe differences in the stability of the native state and in the folding pathways of the homologous cysteine protein inhibitors, human stefin A and B. After complete unfolding in 4.5 mol/L GuHCl, stefin A refolded in 11% (vol/vol) TFE, 0.75 mol/L GuHCl, at pH 6.0 and 20 degrees C, with almost identical first-order rate constants of 4.1 s-1 and 5.5 s-1 for acquisition of the CD signal at 230 and 280 nm, respectively, rates that were markedly greater than the value of 0.11 s-1 observed by the same two probes when TFE was absent. The acceleration of the rates of refolding, monitored by tyrosine fluorescence, was maximal at 10% (vol/vol) TFE. Similar rates of refolding (6.2s-1 and 7.2 s-1 for ellipticity at 230 and 280 nm, respectively) were observed for stefin A denatured in 66% (vol/vol) TFE, pH 3.3, when refolding to the same final conditions. After complete unfolding in 3.45 mol/L GuHCl, stefin B refolded in 7% (vol/vol) TFE, 0.57 mol/L GuHCl, at pH 6.0 and 20 degrees C, with a rate constant for the change in ellipticity at 280 nm of 32.8 s-1; this rate was only twice that observed when TFE was absent. As a major point of distinction from stefin A, the refolding of stefin B in the presence of TFE showed an overshoot in the ellipticity at 230 nm to a value 10% greater than that in the native protein; this signal relaxed slowly (0.01 s-1) to the final native value, with little concomitant change in the near-ultraviolet CD signal; the majority of this changes in two faster phases. After denaturation in 42% (vol/vol) TFE, pH 3.3, the kinetics of refolding to the same final conditions exhibited the same rate-limiting step (0.01 s-1) but were faster initially. The results show that similarly to stefin A, stefin B forms its hydrophobic core and predominant part of the tertiary structure faster in the presence of TFE. The results imply that the alpha-helical intermediate of stefin B is highly structured. Proteins 1999;36:205-216.     

The role of protein stability, solubility, and net charge in amyloid fibril formation

Ribonuclease Sa and two charge-reversal variants can be converted into amyloid in vitro by the addition of 2,2,2-triflouroethanol (TFE). We report here amyloid fibril formation for these proteins as a function of pH. The pH at maximal fibril formation correlates with the pH dependence of protein solubility, but not with stability, for these variants. Additionally, we show that the pH at maximal fibril formation for a number of well-characterized proteins is near the pI, where the protein is expected to be the least soluble. This suggests that protein solubility is an important determinant of fibril formation.     

Conformational changes during amyloid fibril formation of pancreatic thiol proteinase inhibitor: effect of copper and zinc

Pancreatic thiol proteinase inhibitor (PTPI), a variant of cystatin superfamily of cysteine protease inhibitors, has been isolated from pancreas of Capra hircus. In the present study, we examined the effects of acid denaturation and a co-solvent on PTPI with a focus on protein conformational changes and amyloid fibril formation. The results demonstrate that PTPI can form amyloid like fibrils. Acid denaturation as studied by CD and fluorescence spectroscopy showed that PTPI populates three partly unfolded species, a native like state at pH 3.0, a structured molten globule at pH 1.0 and partly unfolded species at pH 2.0, from each of which amyloid like fibrils grow as assessed by Thioflavin T (ThT) spectroscopy. Effect of trifluoroethanol (TFE) on acid induced states of PTPI was analyzed. TFE stabilized each of the three acid-induced intermediates at predenaturational concentrations (10%) and accelerated fibril formation. Morphology of the protein species at the beginning and end of reactions was observed using transmission electron microscopy. Solvent conditions were decisive for final fibril morphology. Biometals, Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ produced a concentration dependent decline in ThT fluorescence suggesting deaggregation of the fibrils. When added prior to amyloid fibril initiation 50 μM Cu²⁺ or 10 μM Zn²⁺ prevented any amyloid aggregation. Implications for therapeutics in view of Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ as essential micronutrients are suggested.     

Similar toxicity of the oligomeric molten globule state and the prefibrillar oligomers

We report that a mutant of human stefin B is in a molten globule conformation. It has all the spectroscopic characteristics for such a state. We also demonstrate that the molten globule is oligomeric, eluting on SEC within a similar MW range than the higher order oligomers of the wild type protein, which is confirmed by DLS and AFM. Both, the higher oligomers and the molten globule state bind ANS, implying a high degree of hydrophobic patches exposure and partial opening of the structure. Finally, we demonstrate that the oligomeric molten globule is as toxic as the prefibrillar aggregates obtained at acid pH or the higher order oligomers prepared at neutral pH.     

Amyloid fibril formation by human stefins: Structure,mechanism & putative functions

Many questions in the field of protein aggregation to amyloid fibrils remain open. In this review we describe predominantly in vitro studies of oligomerization and amyloid fibril formation by human stefins A and B. In human stefin B amyloidogenesis in vitro we have observed some general and many specific properties of its prefibrillar oligomers and amyloid fibrils. One characteristic feature in common to stefins and cystatins (and possibly some other amyloid proteins) is domain-swapping. In addition to solution structure of the domain-swapped dimer of stefin A, we recently have determined 3D structure of stefin B tetramer, which proved to be composed from two domain-swapped dimers, whose interaction occurs by a proline switch in the loop surrounding the conserved Pro 74. Studying the mechanism of fibril formation by stefin B, we found that the nucleation and fibril elongation reactions have energies of activation (E_a’s) in the range of proline isomerisation, strongly indicating importance of the Pro at site 74 and/or other prolines in the sequence. Correlation between toxicity of the prefibrillar oligomers and their interaction with acidic phospholipids was demonstrated. Stefin B was shown to interact with amyloid-beta peptide of Alzheimer’s disease in an oligomer specific manner, both in vitro and in the cells. It also has been shown that endogenous stefin B (with E at site 31) but especially the EPM1 mutant R68X and Y31-stefin B variant, and to a lesser extent EPM1 mutant G4R, are prone to form aggregates in cells.     

Differences in aggregation properties of three site-specific mutants of recombinant human stefin B

We describe expression, purification, and characterization of three site-specific mutants of recombinant human stefin B: H75W, P36G, and P79S. The far- and near-UV CD spectra have shown that they have similar secondary and tertiary structures to the parent protein. The elution on gel-filtration suggests that recombinant human stefin B and the P36G variant are predominantly monomers, whereas the P79S variant is a dimer. ANS dye binding, reflecting exposed hydrophobic patches, is highest for the P36G variant, both at pH 5 and 3. ANS dye binding also is increased for stefin B and the other two variants at pH 3. Under the chosen conditions the highest tendency to form amyloid fibrils has been shown for the recombinant human stefin B. The P79S variant demonstrates a longer lag phase and a lower rate of fibril formation, while the P36G variant is most prone to amorphous aggregation. This was demonstrated by ThT fluorescence as a function of time and by transmission electron microscopy.     

Major differences in stability and dimerization properties of two chimeric mutants of human stefins

Stefins A and B are cysteine proteinase inhibitors that have considerable sequence similarity but marked differences in their stability and folding properties. Two chimeric proteins were designed to shed light on these differences. The chimeric mutants have been expressed in Escherichia coli and have been isolated. The first, A37B, consists of 37 residues of stefin A, comprising the N-terminal and the alpha-helix, joined to 61 residues of stefin B; the second, A61B, consists of 61 N-terminal residues of stefin A, followed by 37 residues of stefin B. Spectroscopic properties of the chimeric proteins (absorption, CD, and NMR spectra), together with activity measurements, have confirmed that both have well-defined tertiary structure and are active as cysteine proteinase inhibitors. Characterization consisted of GuHCl denaturation, ANS binding as a function of pH, and monitoring of dimerization under partially denaturing conditions. The c(m) values are 1.3 M GuHCl for A61B as compared with 2.7 M GuHCl for stefin A, and 2.1 M GuHCl for A37B as compared with 1.4 M GuHCl for stefin B (all at pH 7.5, 25 degrees C). However (G degrees (N-U) is lower for both chimeric proteins (18 +/- 3 kJ/mol) than for the parent stefins (28 +/- 3 kJ/mol). In pH denaturation, unlike stefin B, neither chimeric mutant unfolds to I(N) below pH 5.4. At pH 3, where stefin B forms a molten globule and stefin A is native, both A37B and A61B show increased ANS fluorescence and aggregate visibly. Dimers at pre-denaturation conditions are observed in all the proteins under study, but they remain "trapped" only in stefin A.     

Characterization of the molten globule of human serum retinol-binding protein using NMR spectroscopy

The molten globule state is a partially folded conformer of proteins that has been the focus of intense study for more than two decades. This non-native fluctuating conformation has been linked to protein-folding intermediates, to biological function, and more recently to precursors in amyloid fibril formation. The molten globule state of human serum retinol-binding protein (RBP) has been postulated previously to be involved in the mechanism of ligand release (Ptitsyn, O. B., et al. (1993) FEBS Lett. 317, 181-184). Conserved residues within RBP have been identified and proposed to be key to folding and stability, although a link to a molten globule state has not previously been shown (Greene, L. H., et al. (2003) FEBS Lett. 553, 39-44). In this work, a detailed characterization of the acid-induced molten globule of RBP is presented. Using stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy in the presence of 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid (ANS), we show that RBP populates a state with molten-globule-like characteristics early in refolding. To gain insight into the structural features of the molten globule of RBP, we have monitored the denaturant-induced unfolding of this ensemble using NMR spectroscopy. The transition at the level of individual residues is significantly more cooperative than that found previously for the archetypal molten globule, alpha-lactalbumin (alpha-LA); this difference may be due to a predominantly beta-sheet structure present in RBP in contrast to the alpha-helical nature of the alpha-LA molten globule.     

Conformational prerequisites for formation of amyloid fibrils from histones

We demonstrate that bovine core histones are natively unfolded proteins in solutions with low ionic strength due to their high net positive charge at pH 7.5. Using a variety of biophysical techniques we characterized their conformation as a function of pH and ionic strength, as well as correlating the conformation with aggregation and amyloid fibril formation. Tertiary structure was absent under all conditions except at pH 7.5 and high ionic strength. The addition of trifluoroethanol or high ionic strength induced significant alpha-helical secondary structure at pH 7.5. At low pH and high salt concentration, small-angle X-ray scattering and SEC HPLC indicate the histones are present as a hexadecamer of globular subunits. The secondary structure at low pH was independent of the ionic strength or presence of TFE, as judged by FTIR. The data indicate that histones are able to adopt five different relatively stable conformations; this conformational variability probably reflects, in part, their intrinsically disordered structure. Under most of the conditions studied the histones formed amyloid fibrils with typical morphology as seen by electron microscopy. In contrast to most aggregation/amyloidogenic systems, the kinetics of fibrillation showed an inverse dependence on histone concentration; we attribute this to partitioning to a faster pathway leading to non-fibrillar self-associated aggregates at higher protein concentrations. The rate of fibril formation was maximal at low pH, and decreased to zero by pH 10. The kinetics of fibrillation were very dependent on the ionic strength, increasing with increasing salt concentration, and showing marked dependence on the nature of the ions; interestingly Gdn.HCl increased the rate of fibrillation, although much less than NaCl. Different ions also differentially affected the rate of nucleation and the rate of fibril elongation.     

Direct evidence for excitonically coupled chlorophylls a and b in LHC II of higher plants by nonlinear polarization spectroscopy in the frequency domain

Human stefin B (cystatin B) is an intracellular cysteine proteinase inhibitor broadly distributed in different tissues. Here, we show that recombinant human stefin B readily forms amyloid fibrils in vitro. It dimerises and further oligomerises, starting from the native-like acid intermediate, I(N), populated at pH 5. On standing at room temperature it produces regular (over 4 microm long) fibrils over a period of several months. These have been visualised by transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy. Their cross-sectional diameter is about 14 nm and blocks of 27 nm repeat longitudinally. The fibrils are smooth, of unbranched surface, consistent with findings of other amyloid fibrils. Thioflavin T fluorescence spectra as a function of time were recorded and Congo red dye binding to the fibrils was demonstrated. Adding 10% (v/v) trifluoroethanol resulted in an increased rate of fibrillation with a typical lag phase. The finding that human stefin B, in contrast to the homologue stefin A, forms amyloid fibrils rather easily should promote further studies of the protein's behaviour in vivo, and/or as a model system for fibrillogenesis.     

Surfactant-mediated amyloidogenesis behavior of stem bromelain; a biophysical insight

Neurodegenerative disorders are mainly associated with amyloid fibril formation of different proteins. Stem bromelain (SB), a cysteine protease, is known to exist as a molten globule state at pH 10.0. It passes through the identical surrounding (pH 10.0) in the gut epithelium of intestine upon oral administration. Protein–surfactant complexes are widely employed as drug carriers, so the nature of surfactant toward protein is of great interest. The present work describes the effect of cationic surfactants (CTAB & DTAB) and their hydrophobic behavior toward amyloidogenesis behavior of SB at pH 10.0. Multiple approaches including light scattering, far UV-CD, turbidity measurements, and dye binding assay (ThT, Congo red and ANS) were performed to measure the aggregation propensity of SB. Further, we monitored the hydrodynamic radii of aggregates formed using dynamic light scattering technique. Structure of fibrils was also visualized through fluorescence microscopy as well as TEM. At pH 10.0, low concentration of CTAB (0–200 μM) induced amyloid formation in SB as evident from a prominent increase in turbidity and light scattering, gain in β-sheet content, and enhanced ThT fluorescence intensity. However, further increase in CTAB concentration suppressed the fibrillation phenomenon. In contrast, DTAB did not induce fibril formation at any concentration used (0–500 μM) due to lower hydrophobicity. Net negative charge developed on protein at high pH (10.0) might have facilitated amyloid formation at low concentration of cationic surfactant (CTAB) due to electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions.     

Amyloid fibril formation by a domain of rat cell adhesion molecule

Amyloid fibrils are protein aggregates implicated in several amyloidotic diseases. Cellular membranes with local decrease in pH and dielectric constant are associated with the amyloid formation. In this study, domain 1 of cell adhesion molecule CD2 (CD2-1) is used for studying amyloid fibril formation in a water/trifluoroethanol (TFE) mixture. CD2-1 is an all beta-sheet protein similar in topology to the amyloidogenic light chain variable domain, which deposits as amyloid in light chain amyloidosis at acidic pH. When incubated at pH 2.0 in the presence of 18% TFE, CD2-1 initiates the process to assemble into amyloid fibrils. It has been shown that TFE induces CD2-1 conformational change with a chemical transition (C(m)) of 18% (v/v). ANS (1-anilinonapthalene-8-sulfonic acid) binding was used to show that the hydrophobic surface becomes exposed under these solvent conditions. Our studies indicate that partial formation of a non-native conformation and the exposure of the hydrophobic interior could be the origins of oligomerization and fibril formation of CD2-1.     

Oligopeptide-mediated acceleration of amyloid fibril formation of amyloid beta(Abeta) and alpha-synuclein fragment peptide (NAC).

The effects of oligopeptides on the secondary structures of Abeta and NAC, a fragment of alpha-synuclein protein, were studied by circular dichroism (CD) spectra. The effects of oligopeptides on the amyloid fibril formation were also studied by fluorescence spectra due to thioflavine-T. The oligopeptides were composed of a fragment of Abeta or NAC and were interposed by acidic or basic amino acid residues. The peptide, Ac-ELVFFAKK-NH2, which involved a fragment Leu-Val-Phe-Phe-Ala at Abeta(17-21), had no effect on the secondary structures of Abeta(1-28) in 60% or 90% trifluoroethanol (TFE) solutions at both pH 3.2 and pH 7.2. However, it showed pronounced effects on the secondary structure of Abeta(1-28) at pH 5.4. The Ac-ELVFFAKK-NH2 reduced the alpha-helical content, while it increased the beta-sheet content of Abeta(1-28). In phosphate buffer solutions at pH 7.0, Ac-ELVFFAKK-NH2 had little effect on the secondary structures of Abeta(1-28). However, it accelerated amyloid fibril formation when monitored by fluorescence spectra due to thioflavine-T. On the other hand, LPFFD, a peptide known as a beta-sheet breaker, caused neither an appreciable extent of change in the secondary structure nor amyloid fibril formation in the same buffer solution. The peptide, Ac-ETVK-NH2, which involved a fragment Thr-Val at NAC(21-22), had no effect on the secondary structure of NAC in 90% TFE and in isotonic phosphate buffer. However, Ac-ETVK-NH2 in water with small amounts of NaN3 and hexafluoroisopropanol greatly increased the beta-sheet content of NAC after standing the solution for more than 1 week. Interestingly, in this solution. Ac-ETVK-NH2, accelerated the fibril formation of NAC. It was concluded that an oligopeptide that involves a fragment of amyloidogenic proteins could be a trigger for the formation of amyloid plaques of the proteins even when it had little effect on the secondary structures of the proteins as monitored by CD spectra for a short incubation time.     

Putative alternative functions of human stefin B (cystatin B): binding to amyloid‐beta,membranes, and copper

We describe studies performed thus far on stefin B from the family of cystatins as a model protein for folding and amyloid fibril formation studies. We also briefly mention our studies on aggregation of some of the missense EPM1 mutants of stefin B in cells, which mimic additional pathological traits (gain in toxic function) in selected patients with EPM1 disease. We collected data on the reported interactors of stefin B and discuss several hypotheses of possible cytosolic alternative functions.     

2,2,2-Trifluoroethanol-Induced structural change of peanut agglutinin at different pH: A comparative account

Peanut Agglutinin (PNA) is a legume lectin with a unique open quarternary structure. It is a homotetrameric protein, the monomeric subunit of which is made up of 3 beta sheets. The structural change in this protein has been induced by 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) at two different pH. At neutral pH, PNA exists as a homotetramer, while at pH 2.5, it is known to dissociate to a dimer. The effect of TFE has been studied at both the pH by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence, far and near UV Circular Dichroism, ANS binding and dynamic light scattering. At low pH, 15% TFE is found to induce a molten globule like state that shows maximum ANS binding. Increasing concentration of TFE increases alpha helical content and the compactness of the protein. The compact PNA at higher concentration of TFE is structurally different from the native structure. The effect of TFE at neutral pH on PNA is somewhat different from that observed at low pH. TFE does not induce molten globule like state at this pH. The detailed study of the structural change of PNA by TFE has been presented.     

pH induced structural alterations in an aspartic protease from Vigna radiata indicating an alkali induced molten globule state

pH-dependent transitions in secondary and tertiary structure are described for a plant aspartic protease from Vigna radiata. The enzyme was pH stable with pH optima of 3.0. The Lineweaver Burk analysis at various pH yielded pKa values of 3.3 and 4.29 indicating acidic amino acids at the active site of the enzyme. The structural changes exemplified compact secondary structure collapsed tertiary structure and exposure of hydrophobic patches at pH 10. The changes at pH 10 are typical of a molten globule state. This alkali induced molten globule is novel since acid induced molten globule state is more reported.