Suppressor cell influence in selected strains of inbred rats. III. Evidence for nonspecific suppression by a lymphocyte-macrophage cooperation.

Lewis (LE) and Brown-Norway (BN) rats treated in vivo with rabbit anti rat thymocyte serum demonstrate a reversal in relative responsiveness when assayed to mitogens and antigens via lymphocyte transformation, i.e., the BN rat now responds to a greater magnitude than the LE rats. Spleen cells, from both strains, that have been eluted from glass wool columns, demonstrate elevated responses to mitogens and antigens when compared to unfractionated spleen cells. The responses by these unfractionated and nonadherent populations can 1) be further enhanced subsequent to the treatment with anti-thymocyte serum and 2) suppressed after addition of macrophages from either strain, but especially by BN derived macrophages. The adherent cells from LE spleens respond to the above treatments in a similar fashion as the other populations. The responsiveness of adherent BN cells is only partially restored following treatment with anti-thymocyte serum, and is not further suppressed upon the addition of macrophages. These data are indicative of a lymphocyte-macrophage cooperation in this mechanism of suppression.     

Suppressor cell influence in selected strains of inbred rats: I. Strain-dependent mitogen- and antigen-related low responsiveness

Lymphocytes derived from Lewis (LE), Brown-Norway (BN), or the F₁ hybrid (LBNF₁) rats respond in vitro to the mitogens phytohemagglutinin, concanavalin A, and pokeweed mitogen. The magnitude of the response, as determined by incorporation of ³H-thymidine, ¹⁴C-adenine, and ³H-leucine, was highest for LE and lowest for BN animals. These proliferation response differences were observed for lymph node lymphocytes and peripheral blood lymphocytes. The response to antigen, as measured by lymphocyte transformation, reflected the mitogen responsiveness of the strains tested, i.e., LE animals responded to a higher level than did BN animals. Equivalent levels of antibody were found in all animals immunized with antigen. In addition, BN rats are suppressed to a greater magnitude than are LE rats when both strains are primed, rechallenged, and assayed via lymphocyte transformation to the test antigen.     

Activation of rat B lymphocytes. I. Characterization of anti-immunoglobulin responses and isotype density of rat B cells

Spleen cells of two rat strains, Lewis and Brown Norway (BN), have been activated by lectins and by antibodies specific for immunoglobulin isotypes embedded in their cell membranes. Optimal concentrations of antibodies specific for mu, gamma, or delta-chains of rat augments in vitro incorporation of 3H-TdR 5 to 18-fold in Lewis B lymphocytes and 1.5 to 4-fold in BN B lymphocytes. In addition, F(ab')2 fragments of anti-Ig reagents induced Lewis splenic B cells but not BN B cells to incorporate 3H-TdR. Responses to LPS and dextran sulfate, B lymphocyte mitogens, measured by radioactive uptake, were five to 10 times greater in Lewis B cell populations than in BN B cell populations. Density of surface Ig isotypes and capping kinetics were similar in the two rat strains, although the percentage of T cells, T cell subsets, B cells, and Ia+ B cells differed in the spleens of these strains of rats. Both T lymphocytes and macrophages were needed in culture to effect an optimal response. IL-2 restored the response in B cell cultures depleted of T cells and macrophages, and enhanced 3H-TdR uptake in whole spleen cells of Lewis but not BN rats. The strain-dependent responsiveness of B cells to specific anti-Ig reagents or B cell mitogens appears to be associated with inherent (genetic) defects in T cells and B cells or defects in T cell to B cell cooperation in BN rats.     

Functional activation of immune lymphocytes by antigenic stimulation in cell-mediated immunity. IV. Role of macrophage and its soluble factor in antigen-induced MIF production of immune T lymphocytes.

Histocompatibility-linked restriction of macrophage-T lymphocyte interaction in antigen-induced MIF production by sensitized lymphocytes was examined, by using combinations of inbred strain 2, strain 13, and JY-1 guinea pigs. The effective interaction of the antigen-bearing macrophages with the immune T lymphocytes was observed when the donor of the antigen-bearing macrophages and that of the immune lymphocytes shared Ia antigens of the major histocompatibility complex. Identities of B antigens and S antigens were not important for this cooperation. It was further demonstrated that the previously reported soluble factor derived from LPS-stimulated peritoneal adherent cells (macrophages) could help antigenic activation of the immune lymphocytes across the strain barrier provided a small number of macrophages (0.01%) from syngeneic strain were present. These results show that the presence of macrophages is absolutely required to present antigen to immune T lymphocytes in a genetically restricted manner and the soluble factor from macrophages appears to give a nonspecific effect on the lymphocyte activation in addition to or in collaboration with antigenic stimulation.     

The effect of platelet-activating factor and its antagonist--BN 52021--on immune reactions in vivo in mice and in vitro

The effect produced by the injection of platelet activation factor (PAF) and its antagonist BN 52021 on the intensity of humoral immune response in (CBA x C57BL)F1 mice was studied. PAF was found to stimulate the formation of antibodies to sheep red blood cells. In addition PAF stimulated the phagocytic activity of mouse peritoneal macrophages. The stimulation of immune response under the action of PAF may be attributed to an increase in the phagocytic activity of macrophages. The stimulating effect of PAF on immune response in vivo was abolished by the injection of BN 52021, the antagonist of PAF. At the same time the dose-dependent decrease of immune response was observed after the injection of BN 52021. Indomethacin, an inhibitor of prostaglandin synthesis, when administered to mice treated with BN 52021, abolished the BN 52021-induced suppression of humoral immune response. Mouse peritoneal macrophages, treated in vitro with BN 52021, were found to produce significantly more prostaglandin E than control macrophages. Thus, BN 52021 induced the suppression of humoral immune response in vivo; this suppression was probably due to the action of prostaglandin E2, a messenger of the second order. Besides, the PAF antagonist BN 52021 significantly decreased leukotriene B4 production by macrophages in vitro. BN 52021 may be supposed to switch over the synthesis and/or secretion of arachidonic acid from the lipoxygenase pathway to the cycloxygenase one.     

Allogeneic recognition and killing capacity of immune macrophages in mixed macrophage cultures (MMC).

Stimulation of DNA and RNA synthesis did not occur in mixed macrophage cultures (MMC) consisting of macrophages growing in different allogeneic combinations, compared with syngeneic cultures. Incubation of immune macrophages with either macrophages bearing those alloantigens used for immunization or unrelated alloantigens led to suppression of ³HTdR incorporation. Specific killing, studied by ⁸⁶Rb uptake, was effected by immune macrophages growing in contact with target macrophages bearing the sensitizing alloantigens. Repeated immunization was found to be important for optimal macrophage cytotoxic capacity. Cell crowding was important for maximum killing effect, and no killing occurred when immune macrophages were separated from the specific allogeneic target cells. Immune spleen cells were capable of arming nonimmune macrophages and rendering them cytotoxic. This suggests that macrophage cytotoxicity may be due to a product(s) derived from lymphocytes and attached to the macrophage surface.     

Effect of cell-free murine liver extract on lymphocyte blastogenesis in vitro.

The effect of cell-free liver extract (LE) on the proliferation of spleen cells in vitro was examined using [³H]thymidine incorporation. LE inhibited the blastogenic response of murine lymphocytes stimulated with plant mitogens, phytohemagglutinin, and concanavalin A and in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Suppression of cell proliferation occurred whether the LE was syngeneic or allogeneic to the responding cells. This effect was observed only when LE was present in cultures, as preincubation of cells with LE did not impair their capacity to respond to stimulation. Profound suppression of proliferation was achieved with the addition of LE to the culture up to 48 hr after the onset of stimulation. However, the inhibitory effect was readily reversible upon removal of LE from the culture. Furthermore, although LE was capable of suppressing the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes, LE did not interfere with their capacity for cytolysis. These findings indicate the presence of a potent inhibitor of lymphocyte proliferation in a cell-free extract of murine liver.     

The function of macrophages in antigen recognition by guinea pig T lymphocytes. III. Genetic analysis of the antigens mediating macrophage-T lymphocyte interaction.

Activation of immune T lymphocytes by antigen-pulsed macrophages is mediated by the Ia antigens of the guinea pig MHC or the products of closely linked genes. Studies using combinations of macrophages and T cells derived from outbred animals with different Ia antigens and/or Ir gene products have demonstrated that sharing of Ir gene products between macrophage and T cells is not sufficient for effective macrophage-T cell interaction. The role of the Ia antigens in the absence of the linked Ir gene products could not be directly examined because we were unable to identify an animal which bore the full complement of Ia antigens in the absence of the Ir gene that is normally associated with them. The results of these studies support the concept of the functional expression of the Ir gene product in the macrophage.     

Separation of functionally distinct subpopulations of Corynebacterium parvum-activated macrophages with predominantly stimulatory or suppressive effect on the cell-mediated cytotoxic T cell response.

Peritoneal cells (PEC) from mice injected ip with Corynebacterium parvum (CP) showed greatly enhanced suppressive activity on the growth of syngeneic tumor cells and on the generation of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro. On the other hand, CP-activated PEC exhibited increased immunostimulatory (accessory or A cell) activity as measured by the restoration of the CTL response of nonadherent spleen cells. After fractionation of the CP-activated PEC according to cell size by velocity sedimentation, the mutually antagonistic A cell and immunosuppressive activities were clearly separated and found to be associated with functionally distinct subpopulations of macrophages. Thus A cell function was detected in fractions rich in small and medium sized macrophages which were probably derived from recently arrived monocytes. Immunosuppressive (and anti-tumor) activity was associated with the largest macrophages which were almost devoid of A cell function and probably represented a highly activated and differentiated macrophage subpopulation.     

Human monocyte and macrophage modulation of lymphocyte proliferation.

The effects of human monocytes and mature human macrophages on lymphocyte proliferation in response to PHA and allogeneic lymphocytes were examined. Monocytes enhanced and macrophages markedly suppressed lymphocyte proliferation to both stimuli. Monocyte enhancement of lymphocyte proliferation was, in part, due to a soluble mediator. Macrophage suppression was not due to (a) media depletion, (b) soluble lymphotoxins or inhibitors of proliferation, (c) media depletion, (d) macrophage production of prostaglandins, (e) decreased lymphocyte survival, or (f) induction of suppressor lymphocytes. These data emphasize the dichotomy of human monocyte and macrophage effects on lymphocyte proliferation and suggest, by exclusion, that macrophage suppression may require cell-cell contact.     

Cellular and metabolic requirements for induction of macrophage procoagulant activity by murine hepatitis virus strain 3 in vitro.

The cellular basis for the variation in induction of monocyte procoagulant activity (PCA) by murine hepatitis virus strain 3 (MHV-3) was examined using a set of recombinant inbred strains of mice derived from the resistant (A/J) and susceptible C57B1/6J (B) progenitors. Induction of PCA by MHV-3 required live virus and host protein and RNA synthesis. Absolute restriction for induction of PCA was observed at the level of the macrophage. Peritoneal macrophages from resistant parental A/J and RI strains (AXB5) could not be induced to express PCA when stimulated by MHV-3 alone or in the presence of lymphocytes from susceptible and H-2 compatible RI mice (AXB3) although they did respond to endotoxin (LPS). In contrast, macrophages from both susceptible (AXB3) and semisusceptible (AXB1) RI strains of mice expressed a similar increase in PCA after stimulation with MHV-3 in the absence of lymphocytes. The levels of PCA expressed by macrophages in the presence of Thy-1.2+ lymphocytes correlated with susceptibility to disease. Thy-1.2+ lymphocytes from susceptible RI AXB3 mice could induce levels of PCA in macrophages from semisusceptible RI AXB1 mice equivalent to that seen in cultures of macrophages and lymphocytes from susceptible mice. Further subfractionation of Thy-1.2+ cells demonstrated that L3T4+ cells instructed macrophages to produce PCA. Thy-1.2+ cells from MHV-3 immunized resistant AXB5 mice, but not from non-immunized mice, were able to suppress induction of PCA. This suppressor cell activity could be detected 4 days after immunization, reaching maximal activity at day 7 with significant suppression even at 28 days. The PCA was shown to have direct prothrombin cleaving activity (prothrombinase) by ELISA and immunofluorescence staining using the mAb 3D4.3. These results demonstrate that induction of a unique PCA (prothrombinase) is restricted at the level of the macrophage and define a regulatory role for T lymphocytes in its induction.     

Suppression of lymphokine production: I. Macrophage-mediated inhibition of MIF production

Macrophages have been found to suppress the in vitro production by stimulated T lymphocytes of a lymphokine, migration inhibitory factor. When macrophages isolated from primary MSV-induced tumors were added to antigen-stimulated MSV-immune spleen cells, a complete suppression of MIF production was observed. This suppression was nonspecific, since MIF production by antigen-stimulated alloimmune spleen cells and by PHA-stimulated normal spleen cells was also inhibited. Suppressor macrophages could also be induced by inoculation with Corynebacterium parvum, whereas light mineral oil-induced peritoneal macrophages had no detectable effect on MIF production. The failure to detect MIF in the supernatants of stimulated cultures containing activated macrophages appeared to be due to inhibition of lymphokine production rather than to absorption or inactivation of MIF or to interference with the assay for detection of MIF. Macrophages were able to suppress MIF production only when added during the first 4–5 hr of culture and they had no effect when added later. These data show that activated macrophages can nonspecifically suppress lymphokine production and that this appears to be due to inhibition of an early step in lymphocyte stimulation.     

Nitric oxide-induced anti-mitogenic effects in high and low responder rat strains.

Nitric oxide (NO) has multiple biologic functions: in the brain it acts as a neuronal messenger; elsewhere, it causes smooth muscle relaxation, inhibition of platelet aggregation, inhibition of leukocyte adhesion, inhibition of tumor growth, and microbiostasis. Our studies show that production of NO is responsible for the unusual unresponsiveness of BN rat spleen cells to mitogens. NG-monomethyl-L-arginine (NGMMA), a potent competitive inhibitor for NO synthase, reverses this defect. Lysed RBC or NGMMA were shown to enhance mitogen-induced spleen cell proliferation only one- to twofold in Lewis rats (that have normal mitogen responsiveness) but act to stimulate BN rat T cells by 10- to 100-fold. NGMMA-enhanced proliferation was significantly diminished by prior depletion of macrophages. Surprisingly, NO did not inhibit IL-2 production in 48-h cultures of BN rat spleen cells, and exogenous IL-2 was ineffective in releasing NO-mediated suppression. These studies indicate that NO produced by macrophages can completely and reversibly inhibit T cell proliferation. The BN rat appears to be unique in its production of very high levels of NO, making it an especially useful animal model for studying the biologic control and functional consequences of NO generation.     

Nature of the antigenic complex recognized by T lymphocytes. V. Genetic predisposition of independent F1 T cell subpopulations responsive to antigen-pulsed parental macrophages.

Nonimmune (2 x 13)F1 guinea pig T lymphocytes initially stimulated with trinitrophenyl- (TNP) modified macrophages from one parental strain and then treated with bromodeoxyuridrine (BUdR) and light are unable to be primed subsequently with TNP-modified macrophages of the same parental strain. In contrast, these BUdR and light treated F1 T cells can be primed with TNP-modified macrophages of the other parental strain. These results demonstrate that in a nonimmune F1 animal two T cell subpopulations exist before priming that are genetically predisposed to respond to antigen associated with macrophages derived from one or the other parent.     

Changes in the composition of canine respiratory cells obtained by bronchial lavage following irradiation or drug immunosuppression.

Canine respiratory cells, obtained by bronchial lavage, and blood leukocytes were monitored to observe cellular changes following acute and chronic immunosuppression. Irradiation (350 R) produced bone marrow suppression and prompt peripheral blood leukopenia, but did not affect recovery of pulmonary alveolar macrophages or lymphocytes for 12 days after. Treatment for 6 weeks with daily methylprednisolone (1 mg/kg) caused a progressive decrease in the number of recoverable respiratory lymphocytes, whereas alternate day methylprednisolone (2 mg/kg) had less effect. Cyclophosphamide in combination with steroids generally augmented the progressive loss of blood and respiratiory lymphocytes. Recovery of alveolar macrophages was not changed appreciably. Thus, the population of lung macrophages, sampled by pulmonary lavage, withstood acute and chronic forms of immunosuppression very well. In contrast, canine lymphocytes seem more susceptible to injury, especially to drug regimens containing steroids.     

Suppression of lymphokine production: II. Macrophage-dependent inhibition of production of macrophage activating factor

The ability of different populations of macrophages to affect the production of macrophage activating factor (MAF) by stimulated T lymphocytes was investigated. We found that activated macrophages, infiltrating MSV-induced regressing tumors or macrophages recovered from the peritoneum of mice injected with Corynebacterium parvum, were able to actively suppress the production of MAF. MAF production by antigen-stimulated MSV-immune or -alloimmune spleen cells and by normal spleen cells stimulated by Con A was susceptible to macrophage-dependent suppression to a similar extent. In contrast, resident macrophages or those elicited by light mineral oil or proteose-peptone did not affect MAF production. While suppressor macrophages added at the time of the lymphocyte stimulation inhibited MAF production, the same cells added 4–6 hr after stimulation were ineffective. Therefore, it seems that the macrophages suppressed the early events of lymphocyte activation leading to MAF production. Suppressor macrophages, by inhibiting MAF production, may limit the expansion of the cytotoxic activity. This regulation of macrophage functions, mediated by the effects of suppressor macrophages on T lymphocytes, could be responsible for an insufficient antitumor cytotoxic response by macrophages.     

Reaginic antibody formation in the mouse. IX. Enhancement of suppressor and helper cell activities of primed spleen cells.

Attempts were made to increase the activity of suppressor cells in vitro. Antigen-specific suppressor cells were induced by i.v. injections of urea-denatured ovalbumin (UD-OA) into OA-primed mice. Nonadherent splenic lymphocytes from the UD-OA-treated mice were incubated at 37 degrees C for 24 hr with either OA or OA-bearing macrophages and lymphocytes harvested from the culture were examined for the ability to suppress primary anti-hapten antibody response on nonirradiated mice to DNP-OA. The results showed that the suppressive activity of the lymphocytes increased after culture of the cells with OA or OA-bearing macrophages. Similar results were obtained when nylon column-purified T cell-rich fraction of the lymphocytes were similarly cultured. The suppressive activity was associated with theta-bearing lymphocytes and was specific for OA. Suppressor cells were not induced by the culture of OA-primed lymphocytes with OA. The helper function of splenic lymphocytes from both UD-OA-treated mice and OA-primed mice was enhanced by the culture of the cells with OA-bearing macrophages but not by culture with OA in the absence of macrophages.     

Mechanism and specificity of macrophage-mediated cytotoxity.

The cytotoxic effect of macrophages derived from alloimmunized mice (immune macrophages) was found to be immunologically specific. The immune macrophages killed only target macrophages carrying the alloantigens used for immunization in mixed macrophage cultures (MMC) under optimal conditions of contact between effector and target cells. T-sensitized lymphocytes, but not B cells, were capable of arming nonimmune macrophages and conferring upon them cytotoxic activity; the arming factor, which seemed to be a T mediator or T-cell receptor (membrane component) was removable by trypsin. Frequent rinsing or addition of hydrocortisone significantly decreased the cytotoxicity of the MMC. Pretreatment of peritoneal cells with anti-θ antisera and complement markedly decreased immune macrophage cytotoxic activity. It is suggested that the presence of a very small number of T-sensitized lymphocytes is required for strong cytotoxic activity to be manifested by the macrophages.     

Regulation of immunoglobulin production in human peripheral bood leukocytes: cellular interactions.

The intercellular influences regulating immunoglobulin (Ig) synthesis by normal human peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) were investigated in cells stimulated by pokeweed mitogen (PWM). This system was shown to be totally T lymphocyte dependent as purified B lymphocytes (less than or equal to 1% T lymphocytes) failed to make significant amounts of Ig. No evidence was obtained for an Ig class switch as all classes of Ig (IgM, IgG, IgA) were shown to be produced in increasing amounts over a 6-day time period. T lymphocytes demonstrated maximum helper effect when mixed with equal numbers of B cells. This helper effect was mediated through the dual mechanisms of increasing the number of B lymphocytes containing cytoplasmic Ig and by increasing the maturity of these B lymphocytes as demonstrated by an increasing Ig production per B lymphocyte. When present in higher numbers, T lymphocytes were also capable of suppressing Ig production. This T-mediated suppression was first evident as a decrease in the Ig produced per B lymphocyte (decreased maturity). With maximum T suppression Ig-containing B lymphocyte numbers were also diminished. T lymphocyte help was relatively independent of macrophages (phagocytic cells) and did not require DNA synthesis for expression. Both T help and suppression were shown to cross allogeneic barriers. Immature T lymphocytes (thymocytes) were incapable of mediating either activity. Normal human PBL contain T lymphocytes campable of mediating both T help and suppression and the Ig produced by PBL was shown to be the balance of these activities. This balance probably represent the participation of distinct T lymphocyte subpopulations analogous to the T helper (Ly 1+) and T suppressor (Ly 2+, 3+) populations in the mouse.     

The suppressive effect of a supernate from concanavalin A-activated human lymphocytes: effects of concanavalin A-activated lymphocytes and their supernates on cytotoxic and mixed lymphocyte reactions.

The effects of Concanavalin A-treated human peripheral blood lymphocytes and their supernatants were evaluated on the MLC reaction and on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes assessed by cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Experiments were performed with both allogeneic and xenogenic sensitization. It was found that Con A-activated cells suppressed the MLC and CML reactions in allogeneic and xenogeneic systems. On the other hand, the SIRS-like supernate was able to suppress the MLC reaction and blastogenesis, but had no suppressive effect on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes. We found no difference in the magnitude of suppression, whether or not Con A-activated lymphocytes were syngeneic to the responder cells. This finding suggests that there is no requirement for allogeneic restriction in the interaction between suppressor and suppressed cells, and demonstrates a soluble human suppressor substance capable of suppressing some cell-mediated reactions.