A correlated response of a parasite’s virulence and life cycle to selection on its host’s life history

We demonstrate a correlated response of the virulence and the mode of transmission of the microsporidian parasite Edhazardia aedis to selection on the age at pupation of its host, the mosquito Aedes aegypti. We selected three lines of mosquitoes each for early or late pupation and exposed the larvae after zero, two and four generations of selection to a low and a high concentration of the parasite’s spores. Before selection the parasites induced a similar level of mortality in the six lines; after four generations of selection mortality was higher in the mosquitoes selected for late pupation than in those selected for early pupation. Overall, parasite-induced mortality was positively correlated with the mean age at pupation of the matching uninfected line. When they died, mosquitoes selected for early pupation harboured mostly binucleate spores, which are responsible for vertical transmission. Mosquitoes selected for late pupation were more likely to harbour uninucleate spores, which are responsible for horizontal transmission. The parasite enhanced this tendency for horizontal transmission by prolonging the larval period in the lines selected for late pupation, but not in the ones selected for early pupation. These results suggest that the genetic basis of the mosquito’s age at pupation helps to determine the parasite’s mode of transmission: parasites in rapidly developing mosquitoes are benign and transmit vertically, while parasites in slowly developing mosquitoes are virulent and transmit horizontally. Thus, as the host’s life history evolves, the parasite’s performance changes, because the host’s evolution changes the environment in which the parasite develops.     

The contribution of ancestry,chance, and past and ongoing selection to adaptive evolution

The relative contributions of ancestry, chance, and past and ongoing election to variation in one adaptive (larval feeding rate) and one seemingly nonadaptive (pupation height) trait were determined in populations ofDrosophila melanogaster adapting to either low or high larval densities in the laboratory. Larval feeding rates increased rapidly in response to high density, and the effects of ancestry, past selection and chance were ameliorated by ongoing selection within 15–20 generations. Similarly, in populations previously kept at high larval density, and then switched to low larval density, the decline of larval feeding rate to ancestral levels was rapid (15-20 generations) and complete, providing support for a previously stated hypothesis regarding the costs of faster feeding inDrosophila larvae. Variation among individuals was the major contributor to variation in pupation height, a trait that would superficially appear to be nonadaptive in the environmental context of the populations used in this study because it did not diverge between sets of populations kept at low versus high larval density for many generations. However, the degree of divergence among populations (FST) for pupation height was significantly less than expected for a selectively neutral trait, and we integrate results from previous studies to suggest that the variation for pupation height among populations is constrained by stabilizing selection, with a flat, plateau-like fitness function that, consequently, allows for substantial phenotypic variation within populations. Our results support the view that the genetic imprints of history (ancestry and past selection) in outbreeding sexual populations are typically likely to be transient in the face of ongoing selection and recombination. The results also illustrate the heuristic point that different forms of selection-for example directional versus stabilizing selection—acting on a trait in different populations may often not be due to differently shaped fitness functions, but rather due to differences in how the fitness function maps onto the actual distribution of phenotypes in a given population. We discuss these results in the light of previous work on reverse evolution, and the role of ancestry, chance, and past and ongoing selection in adaptive evolution.     

Development time and pupation behavior in theDrosophila melanogaster subgroup (Diptera: Drosophilidae)

This study is an in-depth analysis of intersexual, intraspecific, and interspecific variability in larvopupal developmental time, pupation site preference, and larval and pupal survival of a number of isofemale lines of the speciesDrosophila mauritiana, D. melanogaster, D. sechellia, D. simulans, D. teissieri, andD. yakuba. There was no significant sex differences in pupation height, but females eclosed significantly earlier than males in all species. In addition, the suggestion of a strong negative correlation between larval developmental time and pupation height could not be confirmed in this study. The hypothesis that differences in pupation height provide a basis for niche partitioning between closely related species with overlapping distributions was tested by three planned orthogonal contrast analyses of variance. First, the two speciesD. teissieri andD. yakuba, with largely overlapping distribution, were significantly different in pupation height. Second, the two allopatric, nonoverlapping island speciesD. mauritiana andD. sechellia did not significantly differ in pupation height. However, the absence of a significant difference in the final contrast between the two cosmopolitan speciesD. melanogaster andD. simulans, which are often found together, makes us cautious to accept the hypothesis.     

Food availability and parasite infection influence the correlated responses of life history traits to selection for age at pupation in the mosquito Aedes aegypti

We selected six lines of mosquito Aedes aegypti for earlier or later pupation and measured the correlated responses of several life history traits: adult size, two fecundity measures and pre-adult survival. We further examined the influence of two environmental parameters – larval food availability and infection by the microsporidian parasite Edhazardia aedis– on the correlated responses. Pre-adult survival did not respond to selection for age at pupation in any environment. For all of the other traits, the environment influenced the correlated response, though the contribution of the different environmental aspects differed among traits. While the correlated response of adult size was influenced only by larval food availability, the likelihood that a female laid eggs was influenced by parasite infection, and the correlated response of the number of eggs was influenced by the interaction of the two environmental parameters. Generally, a deteriorating environment moved the correlated response from one favouring later pupation to one favouring earlier pupation. Larval food availability and parasite infection also influenced the association between the mean wing length and fecundity of the selected lines. At high food availability, there was a positive relationship between adult size and fecundity, while infected mosquitoes reared at low food availability showed the opposite trend. We discuss these results in light of the coevolutionary potential of the host–parasite interaction.     

Genetic variation in pupation height in a population of Drosophila simulans

Preadult mortality of Drosophila simulans in the laboratory is influenced by larval behavior during pupation site choice. The possibility that larvae select a suitable place to pupate may have profound repercussions on their darwinian fitnesses. Twenty-three isofemale lines of a population of D. simulans were analyzed twice for pupation preference, the first time inmediately after being captured, and again after a year of laboratory culture. Pupation height per vial, pupation height on the vial walls, percentage of pupae either in food or on the wall, and egg-to-pupa viability were estimated. A great intrapopulational variation was noticed with an important genetic component for pupation site choice. This suggests a great larval adaptative potential in the population for selecting and using heterogeneous habitats. Time seems not to have modified the population in both the mean values and the phenotypic and genetic variances. Larval viability, however, increased with time. Pupation site choice is discussed on the basis of two independent sets of genes.     

Identification of a genetic network for an ecologically relevant behavioural phenotype in Drosophila melanogaster

Pupation site choice of Drosophila third‐instar larvae is critical for the survival of individuals, as pupae are exposed to various biotic and abiotic dangers while immobilized during the 3–4 days of metamorphosis. This singular behavioural choice is sensitive to both environmental and genetic factors. Here, we developed a high‐throughput phenotyping approach to assay the variation in pupation height in Drosophila melanogaster, while controlling for possibly confounding factors. We find substantial variation of mean pupation height among sampled natural stocks and we show that the Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel (DGRP) reflects this variation. Using the DGRP stocks for genome‐wide association (GWA) mapping, 16 loci involved in determining pupation height could be resolved. The candidate genes in these loci are enriched for high expression in the larval central nervous system. A genetic network could be constructed from the candidate loci, which places scribble (scrib) at the centre, plus other genes known to be involved in nervous system development, such as Epidermal growth factor receptor (Egfr) and p53. Using gene disruption lines, we could functionally validate several of the initially identified loci, as well as additional loci predicted from network analysis. Our study shows that the combination of high‐throughput phenotyping with a genetic analysis of variation captured from the wild can be used to approach the genetic dissection of an environmentally relevant behavioural phenotype.     

Relationships between light dependent fitness of Drosophila melanogaster and D. simulans and their genotypes for pupation site photopreference

The genetic variation in the preference for pupation sites, under conditions of varying white light intensity, was investigated in two Drosophila sibling species. In parallel, an attempt was made to examine the effect on fecundity of the level of light experienced by the flies immediately after their pupation site choice had been made. Larval photopreferences of several selection lines of Drosophila melanogaster and D. simulans were assessed in a gradient of illumination and the genetic architectures influencing this behaviour were investigated from the responses to artificial selection, reciprocal crosses between divergently-selected lines, and a chromosomal analysis. D. simulans responded only to selection for negative larval photopreference, while D. melanogaster responded strongly to selection for positive but weakly to selection for negative photopreferences. Selected lines of flies that repeatedly experienced light conditions grossly at variance with those they preferred (traumatic lines) sometimes diverged in preference from lines that experienced their chosen conditions (rewarded lines). The traumatic lines always diverged from the corresponding rewarded lines in the direction of preferences that were associated with high fitness, as revealed by low response to selection in the rewarded lines. It is suggested that for a given genotype for phototactic behaviour there is a corresponding particular light dependent fitness, as measured by female fecundity.     

Pupation site and emergence time influence the mating success of bagworm females,Oiketicus kirbyi

In commercial oil palm plantations in Costa Rica, we tested the hypotheses that pupation site and emergence time affect the mating success of protogynous female bagworms,Oiketicus kirbyi (Guilding) (Lepidoptera: Psychidae). Greater proportions of female than male pupae on upper leaves of oil palms and greater proportions of mated females in the upper rather than lower crown strata support the hypothesis that selection of pupation site by female larvae influences the mating success of adults. Increasing captures of males with increasing trap height further suggest that enhanced mating success of females in tree tops may be attributed either to most effective dissemination of sex pheromone on higher sites, or to males foraging predominantly in the upper strata of oil palms. As the majority of females pupated in the middle rather than upper crown of oil palms, selection of pupation site by females may be affected by additional as yet unknown factors. Emergence of females significntly preceded emergence of males. Increasing proportions of mated females throughout the emergence seasons probably resulted from an increased ‘availability’ of males. In tropical rainforests with local variations inO. kirbyi developmental time and stage, protogyny may represent an evolutionary strategy that furthers outbreeding.     

The genetics of foraging behaviour: artificial selection for food choice in larvae of the fruitfly,Drosophila melanogaster

Artificial selection for choice between high protein content and high energy content of food was performed for 44 generations of fruitfly larvae. There were significant responses to selection both in a line selected to choose high energy food and in a line selected to choose high protein food. Both lines showed a significantly higher preference for the selected food type than did the control line. The line selected for high energy food also showed a significant increase in response over the generations. Since the selection resulted in lines that differed significantly from controls and from each other, there must be some genetic basis for food choice behaviour. Realized heritability was very low in both selected lines. Viability, as measured by larval weight, pupation time, emergence time and adult size, was significantly higher for flies raised on high protein food than for those raised on high energy food.     

Genetics and ecology of Drosophila melanogaster larval foraging and pupation behaviour

In this paper we show that, (1) Drosophila melanogaster larvae utilize a variety of pupal microhabitats in an orchard, (2) variation in larval foraging path length, pupation distance from the food and pupal microhabitat preference (on or off the fruit) is genetically based and, (3) variation in these behaviours can be maintained in a spatially heterogenous environment since there is a reversal in pupation site suitability in wet and dry pupal microhabitats. Differences in path length in both laboratory and natural populations can be attributed to genes on the second pair of chromosomes and is under simple genetic control, whereas differences in pupal height are polygenically inherited (the second pair of chromosomes influences pupal height three times more than the third pair). Pupae collected from on-fruit sites had shorter foraging path lengths and lower pupal heights than off-fruit populations. Populations from the orchard maintained their field pupal microhabitat preferences even after 1 year of rearing them in the laboratory. Larvae with the sitter larval phenotype (short path lengths and low pupal heights tended to pupate more on-fruit than those with the rover phenotype (long path lengths and high pupal heights). To determined if these genetically based differences in microhabitat preference contributed to fitness, larval pupation behaviour was studied in a “field assay” (dish with fruit on soil) with soil water content varied. At low soil water contents, pupal survivorship was significantly better on the fruit whereas, at high soil water contents, survivorship was better in the soil. There was a reversal in which microhabitat (dry or wet) was a better site for pupation. In the field environment where soil water content fluctuates in space and time, such a reversal would explain the maintenance of genetic variation for these larval behaviours. Another selective agent acting on D. melanogaster larvae in our orchard is parasitization by Asobara tabida. This parasitoid parasitizes larvae with high locomotory scores (e.g. rovers) significantly more than those with low scores (sitters). This study relates laboratory phenotypes to field phenotypes thereby linking the ecological, behavioural and genetic components of larval habitat selection in D. melanogaster.     

Circadian clocks and life-history related traits: Is pupation height affected by circadian organization in<Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila melanogaster</Emphasis>?

InD. melanogaster, the observation of greater pupation height under constant darkness than under constant light has been explained by the hypothesis that light has an inhibitory effect on larval wandering behaviour, preventing larvae from crawling higher up the walls of culture vials prior to pupation. If this is the only role of light in affecting pupation height, then various light : dark regimes would be predicted to yield pupation heights intermediate between those seen in constant light and constant darkness. We tested this hypothesis by measuring pupation height under various light : dark regimes in four laboratory populations ofDrosophila melanogaster. Pupation height was the greatest in constant darkness, intermediate in constant light, and the least in a light/dark regime of LD 14:14 h. The results clearly suggest that there is more to light regime effects on pupation height than mere behavioural inhibition of wandering larvae, and that circadian organization may play some role in determining pupation height, although the details of this role are not yet clear. We briefly discuss these results in the context of the possible involvement of circadian clocks in life-history evolution.     

DIRECTIONAL AND STABILIZING DENSITY-DEPENDENT NATURAL SELECTION FOR PUPATION HEIGHT IN DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

Six populations of Drosophila melanogaster have been kept at extreme population densities, three high and three low, for 175 generations. Larvae from the high density populations pupate 50%-100% higher than larvae from the low density populations. At high larval test densities there is both a directional and a stabilizing component to selection, with viabilities ranging from 0.14 to 0.992, depending on the choice of pupation site. The directional component is stronger on the populations which have evolved at low densities, while the stabilizing component is stronger on the populations which have evolved at high densities. There is no indication that the evolution of this trait, in response to density, has altered its phenotypic plasticity.     

The Effect of Resource pH on Pupation Height in Drosophila (Diptera: Drosophilidae)

This paper describes the effects of the pH of the larval resource on the pupation height of two cosmopolitan species of Drosophila: D. melanogaster and D. hydei. The pH levels of artificial media were modified using solutions of acids (hydrochloric, acetic, and citric) and a positive relationship was found between pupation height and resource pH; i. e., the more acidic the resource, the closer the larvae pupated to the resource surface. The clearest trends were between pupation height and the final pH of the resource, the larvae apparently responding to the pH they encountered just before pupation commenced. When using natural resources a difference in pupation height was found between the types of fruits used but there was no obvious trend linking pupation height with pH. This suggests that some other environmental factor(s) was (were) overriding the effects of pH, and consequently resource pH may play only a minor role in determining pupation behavior in nature.     

EXPERIMENTAL EVOLUTION OF ACCELERATED DEVELOPMENT IN DROSOPHILA. 1. DEVELOPMENTAL SPEED AND LARVAL SURVIVAL

Developmental time is a trait of great relevance to fitness in all organisms. In holometabolous species that occupy ephemeral habitat, like Drosophila melanogaster, the impact of developmental time upon fitness is further exaggerated. We explored the trade-offs surrounding developmental time by selecting 10 independent populations from two distantly related selection treatments (CB_1-5 and CO_1-5) for faster development. After 125 generations, the resulting accelerated populations (ACB_1-5 and ACO_1-5) displayed net selection responses for development time of -33.4 hours (or 15%) for ACB and -38.6 hours (or 17%) for ACO. Since most of the change in egg-to-adult developmental time was accounted for by changes in larval duration, the “accelerated” larvae were estimated to develop 25-30% faster than their control/ancestor populations. The responses of ACB and ACO lines were remarkably parallel, despite being founded from populations evolved independently for more than 300 generations. On average, these “A” populations developed from egg to adult in less than eight days and produced fertile eggs less than 24 hours after emerging. Accelerated populations showed no change in larval feeding rate, but a reduction in pupation height, the latter being a trait relating to larval energetic expenditure in wandering prior to pupation. This experiment demonstrates the existence of a negative evolutionary correlation between preadult developmental time and viability, as accelerated populations experienced a severe cost in preadult survivorship. In the final assay generation, viability of accelerated treatments had declined by more than 10%, on average. A diallel cross demonstrated that the loss of viability in the ACO lines was not due to inbreeding depression. These results suggest the existence of a rapid development syndrome, in which the fitness benefits of fast development are balanced by fitness costs resulting from reduced preadult survivorship, marginal larval storage of metabolites, and reduced adult size.     

Improving grain yield in backcross populations from Avena sativa × A. sterilis matings by using independent culling for harvest index and vegetative growth index or unit straw weight

Summary Grain yield was selected in Avena sativa X A. sterilis populations of segregates by applying independent culling for harvest index and either vegetative growth index or unit straw weight. Samples of lines intensively selected for harvest index had high harvest index but low grain yield because they had low vigor. Populations intensively selected for growth rate index or unit straw weight had high biological yield but low harvest index. Intensive selection for grain yield per se resulted in samples with high grain yield, but they were late and tall. Samples selected for harvest index at a 25% selection intensity first and subsequently selected for vegetative growth index or unit straw weight had grain yield as high as the samples selected for grain yield per se and vegetative growth index, and they had acceptable heading date and plant height. Backcrosses three and four were best, among the various BC generations, for selecting oat lines with high grain yield and suitable agronomic traits. CI 7463 was superior to CI 8044 as a recurrent parent, and B 445 was inferior to other A. sterilis accessions as a donor parent.Journal Paper No. J-12287 of the Iowa Agric, and Home Econ. Exp. Stn., Ames, IA 50011. Project 2447. This research was supported in part by a grant from the World Food Institute, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA     

Crawl-out behaviour in response to predation cues in an aquatic gastropod: insights from artificial selection

Local adaptation to predation often occurs in populations experiencing stable predator regimes. Under such conditions, prey species may respond by fine-tuning their behavioural defences towards a local optimum, although it is often difficult to ascertain whether such local adaptation is due to selection on fixed traits, developmental plasticity that is dependent on relatively long term exposure to environmental cues or phenotypic plasticity that can respond rapidly to a changing environment. Here we investigate whether anti-predator behaviour in two populations of the freshwater gastropod Lymnaea stagnalis responded to artificial selection. Previous work had shown that populations of this species showed a higher level of innate avoidance behaviour (crawling above the water line) in the presence of predatory fish compared with sites lacking this predation threat. By selectively breeding from high and low response selection lines, we demonstrated that this crawl-out behaviour responds rapidly to artificial selection: high response selection lines showed a significant increase and low response selection lines a significant decrease in avoidance compared with non-selected control lines. This suggests that the crawl out response in this species is heritable, and that there is potential for a response to selection in natural populations, which may produce the divergence in the plasticity of crawl out behaviour found between gastropod populations experiencing high and low predation intensity.     

A genetic correlation between age at pupation and melanization immune response of the yellow fever mosquito Aedes aegypti

To investigate the evolutionary cost of an immune response, we selected six lines of the mosquito Aedes aegypti for earlier or later pupation and measured the extent to which this selection procedure changed the mosquito's ability to encapsulate and melanize a negatively charged Sephadex bead. After 10 generations of selection, the age at pupation in the two selection regimes differed by about 0.7 days, accompanied by an increase of wing length of the mosquitoes selected for late pupation. Among the mosquitoes that had been selected for early pupation, only 6% had strongly or completely melanized the bead, while among the individuals that had been selected for late pupation, 32% had melanized the bead. Thus, our results suggest a genetic correlation between age at pupation and immunocompetence. As a consequence, mosquitoes that respond to increased intense parasite pressure with more effective immunity are predicted to pay for the increased defense with slower development.     

The selection of pupation sites by the stalk-eyed fly Diopsis thoracica (Diptera: Diopsidae) and pupal parasitism in some rice cultivars

Six rice cultivars (lines (TKM6, OS6, ADNY 11, IR28, Rexero and IR579-48-1) were used to determine the pupation sites of Diopsis thoracica and their effects on pupal parasitism. There was a general preference for pupation on the first three outer leaf sheaths. Preference was also observed for healthy tillers compared with damaged ones, except in OS6 where there was no significant difference between pupation on healthy and damaged tillers. Pupae on the first two outer leaf sheaths were heavily parasitised by the eulophid Tetrastichus (Neotrichoporoides) sp. (Hymenoptera). The level of parasitism ranged from 17·6% in OS6 to 58·8% in Rexero, with an overall mean of 38·9% for the entire experimental plot. The number of parasites per pupa ranged from 0·5 in OS6 to 3·0 in Rexero, with an overall mean of 1·37. There was a strong relationship between (a) parasitism (%) (r = 0·68); (b) number of parasites per pupa per variety (r = 0·90) and pupal length. The relationship between parasitism (%) and parasite density was very strong (r = 0·89), but a marginal improvement in relationship was obtained when parasitism (%) was correlated with log parasite density (r = 0·94), thus possibly suggesting weak interaction between the parasites.     

EXPERIMENTAL EVOLUTION OF RESISTANCE IN BRASSICA RAPA: CORRELATED RESPONSE OF TOLERANCE IN LINES SELECTED FOR GLUCOSINOLATE CONTENT

The evolutionary response of plant populations to selection for increased defense may be constrained by costs of defense. The purpose of this study was to investigate such constraints on the evolution of defense due to a cost of defense manifested as a trade-off between defense and tolerance. Variation in the response to artificial damage (tolerance) among lines of Brassica rapa that had been artificially selected for foliar glucosinolate content (defense) was examined. Leaf area was removed from replicates of three selection lines (high glucosinolates, control, and low glucosinolates) at three damage levels (0%, 20%, and 60% damage). An external cost of defense would result in a statistically significant selection line by damage treatment interaction, with those selected for high defense expressing less tolerance than those selected for low defense. Damage treatment had a significant overall effect on estimated total fitness, with fitness declining with increasing damage level. Further, selection line also had a significant overall effect on estimated total fitness, with low-defense selection lines having higher fitness compared to both control and high-defense selection lines. More importantly, a cost of defense in terms of tolerance was demonstrated by a significant selection line-by-damage treatment interaction. This interaction was in the direction to demonstrate a genetic trade-off between defense and tolerance, with low-defense selection lines decreasing estimated total fitness in response to damage less than both control and high-defense selection lines. Variation in tolerance among selection lines was due to the greater ability of low-defense lines to maintain fruit and seed production despite the presence of damage. In terms of tolerance, this cost of glucosinolate production in B. rapa could constrain the evolution of increased defense and, in so doing, maintain individuals within the population that are poorly defended yet tolerant.     

GENETIC VARIATION IN CACTOPHILIC DROSOPHILA FOR OVIPOSITION ON NATURAL YEAST SUBSTRATES

Theory predicts that environmental heterogeneity in space or in time can maintain genetic polymorphism. Stable polymorphisms are expected to be more readily maintained if there are genotype specific habitat preferences. Genotype specific preferences for oviposition sites in Drosophila could be a major factor promoting habitat selection, and thus the maintenance of genetic variation. This hypothesis is being tested using the cactophilic species, D. buzzatii and D. aldrichi, where available evidence indicates a potential for such habitat selection, the habitats (oviposition sites) being yeast species found in the natural environment of these flies (cactus rots). Genetic variation for oviposition preferences was tested using isofemale lines—for D. buzzatii, a total of 60 lines from seven localities widely distributed through the species range in Australia, and for D. aldrichi, 21 lines from three of these localities. Females were given a choice of five yeast species as oviposition sites. Genetic variation for oviposition preferences on these natural substrates was demonstrated. There was significant variation among isofemale lines within populations in their patterns of preferences for oviposition on the five yeast species. However, analyses of preferences for each yeast species separately showed that the genetic variation for preferences relates to only three of the five species. Heritabilities of individual female preferences for these three species were low, ranging up to 9%. Little geographic differentiation was apparent among populations, most likely due to similar selection regimes within each population. Within populations, this kind of habitat selection could act to maintain polymorphisms, both at loci determining the habitat preferences and at other loci in linkage disequilibrium with them.