Analysis of protein and peptide penetration into membranes by depth-dependent fluorescence quenching: theoretical considerations.

Depth-dependent fluorescence quenching in membranes is playing an increasingly important role in the determination of the low resolution structure of membrane proteins. This paper presents a graphical way of visualizing membrane quenching caused by lipid-attached bromines or spin labels with the help of a depth-dependent fluorescence quenching profile. Two methods are presently available to extract information on membrane penetration from quenching: the parallax method (PM; ) and distribution analysis (DA; A. S. Biophys. J. 64:290a (Abstr.); A. S. Methods Enzymol. 278:462-473). Analysis of various experimental and simulated data by these two methods is presented. The effects of uncertainty in the local concentration of quenching lipids (due to protein shielding or nonideality in lipid mixing), the existence of multiple conformations of membrane-bound protein, incomplete binding, and uncertainty in the fluorescence in nonquenching lipid are described. Regardless of the analytical form of the quenching profile (Gaussian function for DA or truncated parabola for PM), it has three primary characteristics: position on the depth scale, area, and width. The most important result, not surprisingly, is that one needs three fitting parameters to describe the quenching. This will keep the measures of the quenching profile independent of each other resulting in the reduction of systematic errors in depth determination. This can be achieved by using either DA or a suggested modification of the PM that introduces a third parameter related to quenching efficiency. Because DA utilizes a smooth fitting function, it offers an advantage for the analysis of deeply penetrating probes, where the effects of transleaflet quenching should be considered.     

A combined NMR and molecular dynamics study of the transmembrane solubility and diffusion rate profile of dioxygen in lipid bilayers

The transmembrane profile of oxygen solubility and diffusivity in a lipid bilayer was assessed by (13)C NMR of the resident lipids (sn-2-perdeuterio-1-myristelaidoyl-2-myristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) in combination with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. At an oxygen partial pressure of 50 atm, distinct chemical shift perturbations of a paramagnetic origin were observed, spanning a factor of 3.2 within the sn-1 chain and an overall factor of 10 from the headgroup to the hydrophobic interior. The distinguishing feature of the (13)C NMR shift perturbation measurements, in comparison to ESR and fluorescence quenching measurements, is that the local accessibility of oxygen is achieved for nearly all carbon atoms in a single experiment with atomic resolution and without the use of a probe molecule. MD simulations of an oxygenated and hydrated lipid bilayer provided an immersion depth distribution of all carbon nuclei, in addition to the distribution of oxygen concentration and diffusivity with immersion depth. All oxygen-induced (13)C NMR chemical shift perturbations could be reasonably approximated by simply accounting for the MD-derived immersion depth distribution of oxygen in the bilayer, appropriately averaged according to the immersion depth distribution of the (13)C nuclei. Second-order effects in the paramagnetic shift are attributed to the collisionally accessible solid angle or to the propensity of the valence electrons in the vicinity of a given nuclear spin to be polarized or delocalized by oxygen. A method is presented to measure such effects. The excellent agreement between MD and NMR provides an important cross-validation of the two techniques.     

Orientation of LamB signal peptides in bilayers: influence of lipid probes on peptide binding and interpretation of fluorescence quenching data.

The orientation in lipid bilayers of the signal sequence of the bacterial protein LamB was studied using binding, circular dichroism, and fluorescence quenching experiments. Measurements were made of binding modifications caused by the incorporation of lipid probes (brominated or nitroxide-labeled phospholipids) used in the parallax fluorescence quenching method of determining peptide penetration depth [Abrams, F. S., and London, E. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5312-5322]. The signal peptide bound to a similar extent to neutral bilayers composed of either egg phosphatidylcholine (EPC) or phosphatidylcholines brominated at various positions on their acyl chains. The fluorescence of a tryptophan in either the 18 or 24 position of the peptide was quenched more by bromines in the 6 and 7 than in the 9 and 10 positions on the lipid hydrocarbon chain. Parallax calculations showed that tryptophan-18 was located only 4 A from the hydrocarbon-water interface, consistent with the peptide adopting a "hammock" configuration in the bilayer, with both termini exposed to the aqueous phase and the central alpha-helix located near the hydrocarbon-water interface. In contrast, the incorporation of 10% nitroxide-labeled lipids into EPC bilayers modified peptide binding in a manner dependent on the position of the nitroxide on the hydrocarbon chain; 7-Doxyl PC reduced the percent peptide bound by about one-half, whereas 12-Doxyl PC had little effect on binding. These binding differences modified tryptophan quenching by these probes, making parallax analysis problematical. In the presence of the positively charged LamB peptide, the incorporation of negatively charged phospholipids into EPC bilayers increased the level of peptide binding and modified tryptophan quenching by nitroxide probes. These results suggest that the nitroxide probe could be partially excluded from negatively charged lipid domains where the peptide preferentially bound. Quite different binding and quenching results were obtained with a negatively charged peptide analogue, showing that the charge on both the peptide and bilayer affects peptide-nitroxide probe interactions.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer between lipid probes detects nanoscopic heterogeneity in the plasma membrane of live cells

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between matched carbocyanine lipid analogs in the plasma membrane outer leaflet of RBL mast cells was used to investigate lateral distributions of lipids and to develop a general method for quantitative measurements of lipid heterogeneity in live cell membranes. FRET measured as fluorescence quenching of long-chain donor probes such as DiO-C18 is greater with long-chain, saturated acceptor probes such as DiI-C16 than with unsaturated or shorter-chain acceptors with the same chromophoric headgroup compared at identical concentrations. FRET measurements between these lipid probes in model membranes support the conclusion that differential donor quenching is not caused by nonideal mixing or spectroscopic differences. Sucrose gradient analysis of plasma membrane-labeled, Triton X-100-lysed cells shows that proximity measured by FRET correlates with the extent of lipid probe partitioning into detergent-resistant membranes. FRET between DiO-C16 and DiI-C16 is sensitive to cholesterol depletion and disruption of liquid order (Lo) by short-chain ceramides, and it is enhanced by cross linking of Lo-associated proteins. Consistent results are obtained when homo-FRET is measured by decreased fluorescence anisotropy of DiI-C16. These results support the existence of nanometer-scale Lo/liquid disorder heterogeneity of lipids in the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane in live cells.     

Use of fluorescence anisotropy determinations for indicating the physiological status of hybridoma cell cultures

The evolution of lipid compartment fluidity during culture of hybridoma cells was studied by fluorescence polarization measurements. The probe partition between the plasma membrane and intracytoplasmic compartments was determined by a quenching fluorescence method. A progressive decrease of the plasma membrane fluidity was observed during the growth phase with an increase during stationary and degeneration phases of the culture. These data suggest that fluidity parameters could be used to follow the behaviour of hybridoma cell cultures.     

Iodide penetration into lipid bilayers as a probe of membrane lipid organization.

The quenching efficiency of iodide as a penetrating fluorescence quencher for a membrane-associated fluorophore was utilized to measure the molecular packing of lipid bilayers. The KI quenching efficiency of tryptophan-fluorescence from melittin incorporated in DMPC bilayer vesicles peaks at the phase transition temperature (24 degrees C) of DMPC, whereas acrylamide quenching efficiency does not depend on temperature. The ability of iodide to penetrate the hydrocarbon region of the bilayer was examined by measuring the fluorescence quenching of the pyrene-phosphatidylcholine incorporated into DMPC vesicles (pyrene was attached to the 10th carbon of the sn-2 chain). The quenching efficiency of pyrene by iodide again shows a maximum at the lipid phase transition. We conclude that iodide penetrates the membrane hydrocarbon region at phase transition through an increased number of bilayer defects. The magnitude of change in quenching efficiency of iodide during lipid phase transition provides a sensitive technique to probe the lipid organization in membranes.     

Biosynthetic incorporation of fluorescent carbazolylundecanoic acid into membrane phospholipids of LM cells and determination of quenching constants and partition coefficients of hydrophobic quenchers

A fluorescence quenching method was developed for determining partition coefficients and diffusional rates of small molecules in cell membranes. This method involves quenching the fluorescence of carbazole-labeled membranes by hydrophobic molecules that partition into membranes. Cell membrane phospholipids of mouse LM cells in tissue culture were biosynthetically labeled with the carbazole moiety by supplementing the growth media with 11-(9-carbazolyl)undecanoic acid. Plasma membranes, microsomes, and mitochondria were isolated free of nonmembranous neutral lipids, and the incorporation of the fluorescent probe was characterized. Quenching studies of the carbazole moiety by a series of N-substituted picolinium perchlorate salts showed that the carbazole moiety was located in the hydrophobic interior of the membrane bilayer. The carbazole fluorescence also was quenched by the hydrophobic quenchers lindane, methoxychlor, and 1,1-dichloro-2,2-bis(rho-chlorophenyl)ethylene, indicating that these compounds partitioned into the membrane. Stern-Volmer quenching constants determined by fluorescence lifetime and intensity measurements were identical, as expected for dynamic quenching. The effects of different lipid compositions on quenching constants and partition coefficients were determined by comparing different membrane fractions. These parameters also were measured in membranes from cells in which the phospholipid composition was altered by substituting ethanolamine for choline in the growth medium. Changes in the lipid composition produced changes in the bimolecular quenching constants. For example, bimolecular quenching constants for 1,1-dichloro-2,2-bis(rho-chlorophenyl)ethylene were higher in mitochondrial membranes than in plasma membranes and microsomes. They were also higher in dispersions made from membrane phospholipids as compared with intact membranes or total lipid dispersion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Identification of lipid-accessible sites on the nephrops 16-kDa proteolipid incorporated into a hybrid vacuolar H(+)-ATPase: site-directed labeling with N-(1-Pyrenyl)cyclohexylcarbodiimide and fluorescence quenching analysis

Proton translocation by the vacuolar H(+)-ATPase is mediated by a multicopy transmembrane protein, the 16-kDa proteolipid. It is proposed to assemble in the membrane as a hexameric complex, with each polypeptide comprising four transmembrane helices. The fourth helix of the proteolipid contains an intramembrane acidic residue (Glu140) which is essential for proton translocation and is reactive toward N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD). Current theoretical models of proton translocation by the vacuolar ATPase require that Glu140 should be protonated and in contact with the membrane lipid. In this study we present direct support for this hypothesis. Modification with the fluorescent DCCD analogue N-(1-pyrenyl)cyclohexylcarbodiimide, coupled to fluorescence quenching studies and bilayer depth measurements using the parallax method, was used to probe the position of Glu140 with respect to the bilayer. Glutamate residues were also introduced mutagenically as targets for the fluorescent probe in order to map additional lipid-accessible sites on the 16-kDa proteolipid. These data are consistent with a structural model of the 16-kDa proteolipid oligomer in which the key functional residue Glu140 and discrete faces of the second and third transmembrane helices of the 16-kDa proteolipid are exposed at the lipid-protein interface.     

A new method for quenching correction leads to revisions of data in receptor autoradiography

Differential quenching of beta-emission affects strongly the analysis of receptor distribution patterns in quantitative receptor autoradiography with tritiated ligands. Different methods for the quenching correction have been described in the past, but some of these are of limited value, if a detailed anatomical parcellation is necessary. Other methods correct exclusively local variations in lipid concentration, which is an important, but only one of several factors causing quenching. A new method for the measurement of quenching (or autoradiographic efficiency) is presented, which permits an anatomically detailed and direct determination of the total quenching without lipid extraction procedures. This method is based on the measurement of autoradiographic efficiency in cryostat sections homogeneously labeled with tritiated formaldehyde by an underlying gelatine section containing this labeled compound. Regional and layer specific measurements of autoradiographic efficiency in cortical and subcortical regions of the human and rat brain are reported. A significant correlation was found between the density of myelin and autoradiographic efficiency but other factors were also shown to influence differential quenching. The use of the here presented correction procedure leads to revisions of the laminar distribution patterns reported for different receptors in human and rat cortical areas. Our results show, that a complete quenching correction is necessary for the mapping of receptor distributions with tritiated ligands.     

Measuring membrane penetration with depth-dependent fluorescence quenching: Distribution analysis is coming of age

Depth-dependent fluorescence quenching by lipid-attached quenchers (e.g., bromine atoms and doxyl groups) is an important tool for determining the penetration of proteins and peptides into lipid bilayers. Extracting quantitative information and accurate calculations of the depth of the fluorophore are complicated by thermal disorder, resulting in broad distributions of the transverse positions of both quenchers and fluorophores. Twenty-one years ago a methodology called distribution analysis (DA) was introduced, based on the emerging view of the complexity of the transverse organization of lipid bilayer structure. The method is aimed at extracting quantitative information on membrane penetration, such as position and width of fluorophore's distribution along the depth coordinate and its exposure to the lipid phase. Here we review recent progress in refining the DA method and illustrate its applications to protein–membrane interactions. We demonstrate how basic assumptions of the DA approach can be validated using molecular dynamics simulations and how the precision of depth determination is improved by applying a new protocol based on a combination of steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence quenching. Using the example of the MPER fragment of the membrane-spanning domain of the HIV-1 gp41 fusion protein, we illustrate how DA applications and computer simulations can be used together to reveal the molecular organization of a protein–membrane complex. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.     

On the use of partition coefficients to characterize the distribution of fluorescent membrane probes between coexisting gel and fluid lipid phase: an analysis of the partition behavior of 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene

The distribution of the fluorescent membrane probe 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene between coexisting gel and fluid phospholipid phases in multilamellar vesicles has been examined using fluorescence quenching by spin-labeled phosphatidylcholine. For both thermally-induced and Ca2+-induced lipid phase separation, the ratio of probe concentration in the fluid liquid-crystal phase to that in the gel phase is found to be independent of either the probe concentration or the relative amounts of gel and fluid lipid phases, and hence is an equilibrium concentration ratio, or partition coefficient.     

The effect of overhanging nucleotides on fluorescence properties of hybridising oligonucleotides labelled with Alexa-488 and FAM fluorophores

In order to rationally select and design probes for real-time PCR, we have determined the influence of the overhang region of the complementary strand on the resulting fluorescence from a hybridising probe. A series of target oligonucleotides, each with a unique 3' overhang (4 bases), was hybridised to either 5' fluorescein (FAM)- or Alexa-488-labelled probes, and the changes in fluorescence properties were monitored. We found that the number of guanine bases in the overhang region of the target oligonucleotides was proportional to the amount of fluorescence quenching observed for both the FAM and Alexa-488 dyes. FAM appeared to be more sensitive to guanine-induced quenching with three and four guanine bases resulting in greater than a twofold decrease in the quantum yield of the fluorophore compared to the no-overhang target. In addition, we found that adenine bases caused fluorescence quenching of the Alexa-488-labelled probe, whereas the FAM-labelled probe appeared insensitive. The quenching data, generated with the steady-state fluorescence measurements, displayed a linear correlation with that obtained using a fluorescent thermal cycler, suggesting the applicability to real-time PCR measurements. Anisotropy data from the series of duplexes correlated with the fluorescence quantum yield, suggesting that quenching was accompanied by increased dye mobility.     

Resolution of plasma membrane lipid fluidity in intact cells labelled with diphenylhexatriene

The partitioning of fluorescence probes into intracellular organelles poses a major problem when fluorescence methods are applied to evaluate the fluidity properties of cell plasma membranes with intact cells. This work describes a method for resolution of fluidity parameters of the plasma membrane in intact cells labelled with the fluorescence polarization probe 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH). The method is based on selective quenching, by nonradiative energy transfer, of the fluorescence emitted from the plasma membrane after tagging the cell with a suitable membrane impermeable electron acceptor. Such selective quenching is obtained by chemical binding of 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonate (TNBS), or by incorporation of $\text{N-}\text{bixinoyl}$ glucosamine (BGA) to DPH-labelled cells. The procedures for determination of lipid fluidity in plasma membranes of intact cells by this method are simple and straightforward.     

On measuring biomembrane microviscosity using pyrene luminescence in aerobic conditions

The movement of pyrene in a lipid bilayer is shown to occur not only in the lateral but also transmembrane direction. Within the excited state lifetime, the pyrene monomer elevates from the depth to the polar region of the membrane and emits a luminescence photon. The excimer does not exhibit any marked transmembrane movement. The luminescence quenching efficiency of monomers and excimers depends on the depth of penetration of the quencher into the membrane. In the lipid bilayer, pyrene luminescence is strongly quenched by oxygen. The binding of pyrene to membrane proteins protects it from quenching. It has been concluded that the widely used estimations of membrane viscosity from pyrene luminescence intensity are incorrect.     

Use of pyrene as a luminescence indicator of the viscosity of model and biological membranes

The pyrene movement in a lipid bilayer has been shown to occur not only in the lateral but also transmembrane direction. Within the excited state lifetime the pyrene monomer elevates from the depth to the polar regions of the membrane and emits a luminescence photon. The excimer does not exhibit any marked transmembrane movement while luminescing from the hydrophobic regions. The luminescence quenching efficiency of monomers and excimers depends on the depth of quencher penetration into the membrane. In the lipid bilayer the pyrene luminescence is strongly quenched by molecular oxygen. The pyrene binding to membrane proteins protects it from quenching. A conclusion has been made that the carrying out estimations of membrane viscosity from pyrene luminescence require considerable correction.     

A new method for quenching correction leads to revisions of data in receptor autoradiography

Summary Differential quenching of -emission affects strongly the analysis of receptor distribution patterns in quantitative receptor autoradiography with tritiated ligands. Different methods for the quenching correction have been described in the past, but some of these are of limited value, if a detailed anatomical parcellation is necessary. Other methods correct exclusively local variations in lipid concentration, which is an important, but only one of several factors causing quenching. A new method for the measurement of quenching (or autoradiographic efficiency) is presented, which permits an anatomically detailed and direct determination of the total quenching without lipid extraction procedures. This method is based on the measurement of autoradiographic efficiency in cryostat sections homogeneously labeled with tritiated formaldehyde by an underlying gelatine section containing this labeled compound. Regional and layer specific measurements of autoradiographic efficiency in cortical and subcortical regions of the human and rat brain are reported. A significant correlation was found between the density of myelin and autoradiographic efficiency but other factors were also shown to influence differential quenching. The use of the here presented correction procedure leads to revisions of the laminar distribution patterns reported for different receptors in human and rat cortical areas. Our results show, that a complete quenching correction is necessary for the mapping of receptor distributions with tritiated ligands.     

Fluorescence quenching in model membranes An analysis of the local phospholipid environments of diphenylhexatriene and gramicidin A′

Interactions between the fluorophors diphenylhexatriene or gramicidin A′ and lipids are examined using a spin-labeled phosphatidylcholine as a fluorescence quenching probe. It is found that in phospholipid vesicles of mixed lipid composition at temperatures where phospholipids are completely in the liquid crystal phase, several different species of phosphatidylcholines are randomly distributed around the fluorophors. In vesicles of mixed lipid composition which can undergo thermally induced phase separations, the fluorescence quenching observed at lower temperatures reflects a non-random distribution of lipids around each fluorophor. This observation is explained in terms of the partition of fluorophor between a spin-labeled lipid-rich liquid crystal phase, and a spin-labeled lipiddepleted gel phase. Gramicidin A′ strongly favors partition into the liquid crystal phase, whereas diphenylhexatriene partitions about equally between the two lipid phases. A method is described utilizing fluorescence quenching for the calculation of the partition coefficient for a fluorophor. The partition coefficients so calculated are shown to be in good agreement with previously reported values derived from other methods. It is also shown that Ca²⁺-induced lipid phase separations can be monitored by fluorescence quenching.     

Protein-dependent Reduction of the Pyrene Excimer Formation in Membranes

The presence of proteins in lipid bilayers always decreases the excimer formation rate of pyrene and pyrene lipid analogues in a way that is related to the protein-to-lipid ratio. Energy transfer measurements from intrinsic tryptophans to pyrene have shown (Engelke et al., 1994), that in microsomal membranes, the excimer formation rate of pyrene and pyrene fatty acids is heterogeneous within the membrane plane, because a lipid layer of reduced fluidity surrounds the microsomal proteins. This study investigates whether of not liposomes prepared from egg yolk phosphatidylcholine with incorporated gramicidin A give results comparable to those from microsomal membranes. The results indicate that the influence of proteins on the lipid bilayer cannot be described by one unique mechanism: Small proteins such as gramicidin A obviously reduce the excimer formation rate by occupying neighboring positions of the fluorescent probe and thus decrease the pyrene collision frequency homogeneously in the whole membrane plane, while larger proteins are surrounded by a lipid boundary layer of lower fluidity than the bulk lipid. The analysis of the time-resolved tryptophan fluorescence of gramicidin A incorporated liposomes reveals, that the tryptophan quenching by pyrene is stronger for tryptophans located closely below the phospholipid headgroup region because of the pyrene enrichment in this area of the lipid bilayer. Received: 29 December 1996/Revised: 15 May 1996     

Lateral diffusion in model membranes is independent of the size of the hydrophobic region of molecules.

We have systematically investigated the probe size and shape dependence of lateral diffusion in model dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine membranes. Linear hydrophobic polymers, which differ in length by an order of magnitude, were used to explore the effect on the lateral diffusion coefficient of hydrodynamic restrictions in the bilayer interior. The polymers employed are isoprenoid alcohols--citronellol, solanesol, and dolichol. Tracer lateral diffusion coefficients were measured by fluorescence photobleaching recovery. Despite the large difference in lengths, the nitrobenzoxadiazole labelled alcohols all diffuse at the rate of lipid self-diffusion (5.0 x 10(-12) m2 s-1, 29 degrees C) in the liquid crystal phase. Companion measurements in isotropic polymer solution, in gel phase lipid membranes and with nonpolar fluorescent polyaromatic hydrocarbons, show a marked dependence of the lateral diffusion coefficient on the probe molecule size. Our results in the liquid crystal phase are in accord with free area theory which asserts that lateral diffusion in the membrane is restricted by the surface-free area. Probe molecules which are significantly longer than the host phospholipid, seven times longer in the case of dolichol, are still restricted in their lateral motion by the surface properties of the bilayer in the liquid crystal phase. Fluorescence quenching experiments indicate that the nitrobenzoxadiazole label does not reside at the aqueous interface, although it must reside in close proximity according to the diffusion measurements.