Polymorphism identification and quantitative detection of genomic DNA by invasive cleavage of oligonucleotide probes

Flap endonucleases (FENs) isolated from archaea are shown to recognize and cleave a structure formed when two overlapping oligonucleotides hybridize to a target DNA strand. The downstream oligonucleotide probe is cleaved, and the precise site of cleavage is dependent on the amount of overlap with the upstream oligonucleotide. We have demonstrated that use of thermostable archaeal FENs allows the reaction to be performed at temperatures that promote probe turnover without the need for temperature cycling. The resulting amplification of the cleavage signal enables the detection of specific DNA targets at sub-attomole levels within complex mixtures. Moreover, we provide evidence that this cleavage is sufficiently specific to enable discrimination of single-base differences and can differentiate homozygotes from heterozygotes in single-copy genes in genomic DNA.     

A comparison of eubacterial and archaeal structure-specific 5'-exonucleases.

The 5'-exonuclease domains of the DNA polymerase I proteins of Eubacteria and the FEN1 proteins of Eukarya and Archaea are members of a family of structure-specific 5'-exonucleases with similar function but limited sequence similarity. Their physiological role is to remove the displaced 5' strands created by DNA polymerase during displacement synthesis, thereby creating a substrate for DNA ligase. In this paper, we define the substrate requirements for the 5'-exonuclease enzymes from Thermus aquaticus, Thermus thermophilus, Archaeoglobus fulgidus, Pyrococcus furiosus, Methanococcus jannaschii, and Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum. The optimal substrate of these enzymes resembles DNA undergoing strand displacement synthesis and consists of a bifurcated downstream duplex with a directly abutted upstream duplex that overlaps the downstream duplex by one base pair. That single base of overlap causes the enzymes to leave a nick after cleavage and to cleave several orders of magnitude faster than a substrate that lacks overlap. The downstream duplex needs to be 10 base pairs long or greater for most of the enzymes to cut efficiently. The upstream duplex needs to be only 2 or 3 base pairs long for most enzymes, and there appears to be interaction with the last base of the primer strand. Overall, the enzymes display very similar substrate specificities, despite their limited level of sequence similarity.     

Comparison of the catalytic parameters and reaction specificities of a phage and an archaeal flap endonuclease

Flap endonucleases (FENs) catalyse the exonucleolytic hydrolysis of blunt-ended duplex DNA substrates and the endonucleolytic cleavage of 5'-bifurcated nucleic acids at the junction formed between single and double-stranded DNA. The specificity and catalytic parameters of FENs derived from T5 bacteriophage and Archaeoglobus fulgidus were studied with a range of single oligonucleotide DNA substrates. These substrates contained one or more hairpin turns and mimic duplex, 5'-overhanging duplex, pseudo-Y, nicked DNA, and flap structures. The FEN-catalysed reaction properties of nicked DNA and flap structures possessing an extrahelical 3'-nucleotide (nt) were also characterised. The phage enzyme produced multiple reaction products of differing length with all the substrates tested, except when the length of duplex DNA downstream of the reaction site was truncated. Only larger DNAs containing two duplex regions are effective substrates for the archaeal enzyme and undergo reaction at multiple sites when they lack a 3'-extrahelical nucleotide. However, a single product corresponding to reaction 1 nt into the double-stranded region occurred with A. fulgidus FEN when substrates possessed a 3'-extrahelical nt. Steady-state and pre-steady-state catalytic parameters reveal that the phage enzyme is rate-limited by product release with all the substrates tested. Single-turnover maximal rates of reaction are similar with most substrates. In contrast, turnover numbers for T5FEN decrease as the size of the DNA substrate is increased. Comparison of the catalytic parameters of the A. fulgidus FEN employing flap and double-flap substrates indicates that binding interactions with the 3'-extrahelical nucleotide stabilise the ground state FEN-DNA interaction, leading to stimulation of comparative reactions at DNA concentrations below saturation with the single flap substrate. Maximal multiple turnover rates of the archaeal enzyme with flap and double flap substrates are similar. A model is proposed to account for the varying specificities of the two enzymes with regard to cleavage patterns and substrate preferences.     

Mechanism whereby proliferating cell nuclear antigen stimulates flap endonuclease 1

Human flap endonuclease 1 (FEN1), an essential DNA replication protein, cleaves substrates with unannealed 5'-tails. FEN1 apparently tracks along the flap from the 5'-end to the cleavage site. Proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) stimulates FEN1 cleavage 5-50-fold. To determine whether tracking, binding, or cleavage is enhanced by PCNA, we tested a variety of flap substrates. Similar levels of PCNA stimulation occur on both a cleavage-sensitive nicked substrate and a less sensitive gapped substrate. PCNA stimulates FEN1 irrespective of the flap length. Stimulation occurs on a pseudo-Y substrate that exhibits upstream primer-independent cleavage. A pseudo-Y substrate with a sequence requiring an upstream primer for cleavage was not activated by PCNA, suggesting that PCNA does not compensate for substrate features that inhibit cleavage. A biotin.streptavidin conjugation at the 5'-end of a flap structure prevents FEN1 loading. The addition of PCNA does not restore FEN1 activity. These results indicate that PCNA does not direct FEN1 to the cleavage site from solution. Kinetic analyses reveal that PCNA can lower the K(m) for FEN1 by 11-12-fold. Overall, our results indicate that after FEN1 tracks to the cleavage site, PCNA enhances FEN1 binding stability, allowing for greater cleavage efficiency.     

Oligonucleotide facilitators enhance the catalytic activity of RNA-cleaving DNA enzymes.

From in vitro selection studies, DNA structures have been found that cleave target RNA sequence specifically and show a certain similarity to the well-investigated hammerhead ribozymes. Such DNA enzymes are more resistant to nuclease-mediated degradation than RNA enzymes. On the other hand, their cleavage activity is lower than the activity of hammerhead ribozymes. In the present study, we improved the activity of DNA enzymes by adding oligonucleotide facilitators complementary to the 5' and the 3' ends of the substrate to the cleavage reaction. DNA enzyme activity in vitro was monitored under multiple turnover conditions using short RNA model substrates. We have shown that oligonucleotide facilitators strongly enhance the multiple turnover activity of the DNA enzyme reaction. In one of our model systems with a suitable facilitator combination, we were able to observe a more than 200-fold enhancement of the k(cat)/Km value. The comparison of two DNA enzyme-substrate systems showed that the principal effects of the facilitators were independent of the substrate sequence. However, the degree of facilitator effect was noticeably dependent on the basic catalytic efficiency of DNA enzymes. Furthermore, the efficiency of the DNA enzyme reaction with facilitator was compared with the reaction of a DNA enzyme with a stem sequence extended by the sequence of the facilitator. The multiple turnover activity of such a "long DNA enzyme" is higher than the activity of the short DNA enzyme without facilitators. However, when compared with the multiple turnover reactions of the short DNA enzyme with facilitator, the reaction with the long DNA enzyme is considerably slower. The results obtained with our model systems demonstrate that oligonucleotide facilitators enable DNA enzymes to act as effective multiple turnover catalysts by cleavage of RNA substrates.     

Cleavage specificity of Saccharomyces cerevisiae flap endonuclease 1 suggests a double-flap structure as the cellular substrate

Flap endonuclease 1 (FEN1) is a structure-specific nuclease that cleaves substrates containing unannealed 5'-flaps during Okazaki fragment processing. Cleavage removes the flap at or near the point of annealing. The preferred substrate for archaeal FEN1 or the 5'-nuclease domains of bacterial DNA polymerases is a double-flap structure containing a 3'-tail on the upstream primer adjacent to the 5'-flap. We report that FEN1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Rad27p) exhibits a similar specificity. Cleavage was most efficient when the upstream primer contained a 1-nucleotide 3'-tail as compared with the fully annealed upstream primer traditionally tested. The site of cleavage was exclusively at a position one nucleotide into the annealed region, allowing human DNA ligase I to seal all resulting nicks. In contrast, a portion of the products from traditional flap substrates is not ligated. The 3'-OH of the upstream primer is not critical for double-flap recognition, because Rad27p is tolerant of modifications. However, the positioning of the 3'-nucleotide defines the site of cleavage. We have tested substrates having complementary tails that equilibrate to many structures by branch migration. FEN1 only cleaved those containing a 1-nucleotide 3'-tail. Equilibrating substrates containing 12-ribonucleotides at the end of the 5'-flap simulates the situation in vivo. Rad27p cleaves this substrate in the expected 1-nucleotide 3'-tail configuration. Overall, these results suggest that the double-flap substrate is formed and cleaved during eukaryotic DNA replication in vivo.     

RNA template-dependent 5' nuclease activity of Thermus aquaticus and Thermus thermophilus DNA polymerases

DNA replication and repair require a specific mechanism to join the 3'- and 5'-ends of two strands to maintain DNA continuity. In order to understand the details of this process, we studied the activity of the 5' nucleases with substrates containing an RNA template strand. By comparing the eubacterial and archaeal 5' nucleases, we show that the polymerase domain of the eubacterial enzymes is critical for the activity of the 5' nuclease domain on RNA containing substrates. Analysis of the activity of chimeric enzymes between the DNA polymerases from Thermus aquaticus (TaqPol) and Thermus thermophilus (TthPol) reveals two regions, in the "thumb" and in the "palm" subdomains, critical for RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity. There are two critical amino acids in those regions that are responsible for the high activity of TthPol on RNA containing substrates. Mutating glycine 418 and glutamic acid 507 of TaqPol to lysine and glutamine, respectively, increases its RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity 4-10-fold. Furthermore, the RNA-dependent DNA polymerase activity is controlled by a completely different region of TaqPol and TthPol, and mutations in this region do not affect the 5' nuclease activity. The results presented here suggest a novel substrate binding mode of the eubacterial DNA polymerase enzymes, called a 5' nuclease mode, that is distinct from the polymerizing and editing modes described previously. The application of the enzymes with improved RNA-dependent 5' nuclease activity for RNA detection using the invasive signal amplification assay is discussed.     

Analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms with solid phase invasive cleavage reactions

Using microparticles as the capture surface and fluorescence resonance energy transfer as the detection technology, we have demonstrated the feasibility of performing the invasive cleavage reaction on a solid phase. An effective tool for many genomic applications, the solution phase invasive cleavage assay is a signal amplification method capable of distinguishing nucleic acids that differ by only a single base mutation. The method positions two overlapping oligonucleotides, the probe and upstream oligonucleotides, on the target nucleic acid to create a complex recognized and cleaved by a structure-specific 5′-nuclease. For microarray and other multiplex applications, however, the method must be adapted to a solid phase platform. Effective cleavage of the probe oligonucleotide occurred when either of the two required overlapping oligonucleotides was configured as the particle-bound reagent and also when both oligonucleotides were attached to the solid phase. Positioning probe oligonucleotides away from the particle surface via long tethers improved both the signal and the reaction rates. The particle-based invasive cleavage reaction was capable of distinguishing the ApoE Cys158 and Arg158 alleles at target concentrations as low as 100 amol/assay (0.5 pM).     

Reconstituted Okazaki fragment processing indicates two pathways of primer removal

Eukaryotic Okazaki fragments are initiated by an RNA/DNA primer and extended by DNA polymerase delta (pol delta) and the replication clamp proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA). Joining of the fragments by DNA ligase I to generate the continuous double-stranded DNA requires complete removal of the RNA/DNA primer. Pol delta extends the upstream Okazaki fragment and displaces the downstream RNA/DNA primer into a flap removed by nuclease cleavage. One proposed pathway for flap removal involves pol delta displacement of long flaps, coating of those flaps by replication protein A (RPA), and sequential cleavage of the flap by Dna2 nuclease followed by flap endonuclease 1 (FEN1). A second pathway involves reiterative single nucleotide or short oligonucleotide displacement by pol delta and cleavage by FEN1. We measured the length of FEN1 cleavage products on flaps strand-displaced by pol delta in an oligonucleotide system reconstituted with Saccharomyces cerevisiae proteins. Results showed that in the presence of PCNA and FEN1, pol delta displacement synthesis favors formation and cleavage of primarily short flaps, up to eight nucleotides in length; still, a portion of flaps grows to 20-30 nucleotides. The proportion of long flaps can be altered by mutations in the relevant proteins, sequence changes in the DNA, and reaction conditions. These results suggest that FEN1 is sufficient to remove a majority of Okazaki fragment primers. However, some flaps become long and require the two-nuclease pathway. It appears that both pathways, operating in parallel, are required for processing of all flaps.     

Optimizing the substrate specificity of a group I intron ribozyme

Group I ribozymes can repair mutant RNAs via trans-splicing. Unfortunately, substrate specificity is quite low for the trans-splicing reaction catalyzed by the group I ribozyme from Tetrahymenathermophila. We have used a systematic approach based on biochemical knowledge of the function of the Tetrahymena ribozyme to optimize its ability to discriminate against nonspecific substrates in vitro. Ribozyme derivatives that combine a mutation which indirectly slows down the rate of the chemical cleavage step by weakening guanosine binding with additional mutations that weaken substrate binding have greatly enhanced specificity with short oligonucleotide substrates and an mRNA fragment derived from the p53 gene. Moreover, compared to the wild-type ribozyme, reaction of a more specific ribozyme with targeted substrates is much less sensitive to the presence of nonspecific RNA competitors. These results demonstrate how a detailed understanding of the biochemistry of a catalytic RNA can facilitate the design of customized ribozymes with improved properties for therapeutic applications.     

Development of nonradioactive microtiter plate assays for nuclease activity

We have developed two microtiter plate assays for the detection of DNA cleavage by nucleases, using 3'-biotinylated oligonucleotide substrates. In the covalently linked oligonucleotide nuclease assay (CLONA), the biotinylated substrates are phosphorylated at the 5' end to facilitate their covalent immobilization on CovaLink NH plates. The cleavage of the covalently immobilized substrate by nucleases results in biotin release. The uncleaved substrate molecules are detected with an enzyme-avidin conjugate. The affinity-linked oligonucleotide nuclease assay (ALONA) makes use of substrates with a digoxigenin on the 5' end of the 3'-biotinylated DNA strand. The substrate binds specifically to the wells of streptavidin-coated microtiter plates, in which the nuclease reaction takes place. Uncleaved substrate retains the digoxigenin label, which is detected with an enzyme-labeled anti-digoxigenin antibody. We assessed the efficiency of these two assays by measuring S1 nuclease and DNase I activities, and the inhibitory effect of EDTA and aurintricarboxylic acid on the reaction. Both methods are more convenient than the standard radioactive nuclease assay and are suitable for high-throughput screening of potential nuclease inhibitors, nucleases, and catalytic antibodies. The ALONA assay was found to be more sensitive than the CLONA assay, with a performance similar to that of the standard nuclease assay.     

DNA ligase I competes with FEN1 to expand repetitive DNA sequences in vitro

Repeat sequences in various genomes undergo expansion by poorly understood mechanisms. By using an oligonucleotide system containing such repeats, we recapitulated the last steps in Okazaki fragment processing, which have been implicated in sequence expansion. A template containing either triplet or tandem repeats was annealed to a downstream primer containing complementary repeats at its 5'-end. Overlapping upstream primers, designed to strand-displace varying numbers of repeats in the downstream primer, were annealed. Human DNA ligase I joined overlapping segments of repeats generating an expansion product from the primer strands. Joining efficiency decreased with repeat length. Flap endonuclease 1 (FEN1) cleaved the displaced downstream strand and together with DNA ligase I produced non-expanded products. However, both expanded and non-expanded products formed irrespective of relative nuclease and ligase concentrations tested or enzyme addition order, suggesting the pre-existence and persistence of intermediates leading to both outcomes. FEN1 activity decreased with the length of repeat segment displaced presumably because the flap forms structures that inhibit cleavage. Increased MgCl(2) disfavored ligation of substrate intermediates that result in expansion products. Examination of expansion in vitro enables dissection of substrate and replication enzyme dynamics on repeat sequences.     

Inhibition of Mycobacterium smegmatis topoisomerase I by specific oligonucleotides

DNA topoisomerase I from Mycobacterium smegmatis unlike many other type I topoisomerases is a site specific DNA binding protein. We have investigated the sequence specific DNA binding characteristics of the enzyme using specific oligonucleotides of varied length. DNA binding, oligonucleotide competition and covalent complex assays show that the substrate length requirement for interaction is much longer ( approximately 20 nucleotides) in contrast to short length substrates (eight nucleotides) reported for Escherichia coli topoisomerase I and III. P1 nuclease and KMnO(4) footprinting experiments indicate a large protected region spanning about 20 nucleotides upstream and 2-3 nucleotides downstream of the cleavage site. Binding characteristics indicate that the enzyme interacts efficiently with both single-stranded and double-stranded substrates containing strong topoisomerase I sites (STS), a unique property not shared by any other type I topoisomerase. The oligonucleotides containing STS effectively inhibit the M. smegmatis topoisomerase I DNA relaxation activity.     

Amplification of DNA sequences in Epstein-Barr virus and human immunodeficiency virus using DNA polymerase from Thermus thermophilus

Using thermophilic DNA-polymerase from Thermus thermophilus we have amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) specific DNA sequences of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). DNA-polymerase from Thermus thermophilus (the molecular mass of 80 to 86 kDa) differs in its physico-chemical properties from DNA-polymerase from the Thermus acquaticus (the molecular mass of 62 to 68 kDa). To amplify the specific EBV DNA sequence oligonucleotide primers for the virus replicon region (oriP-region) were used. As a result of amplification, a specific 405 b.p. DNA fragment was produced. Primers for the virus Gag region were used for amplification of HIV DNA. The possibility to conduct amplification cycles under two temperature conditions was demonstrated.     

Methanococcus jannaschii Flap Endonuclease: Expression, Purification, and Substrate Requirements

The flap endonuclease (FEN) of the hyperthermophilic archaeon Methanococcus jannaschii was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. FEN retained activity after preincubation at 95°C for 15 min. A pseudo-Y-shaped substrate was formed by hybridization of two partially complementary oligonucleotides. FEN cleaved the strand with the free 5′ end adjacent to the single-strand–duplex junction. Deletion of the free 3′ end prevented cleavage. Hybridization of a complementary oligonucleotide to the free 3′ end moved the cleavage site by 1 to 2 nucleotides. Hybridization of excess complementary oligonucleotide to the free 5′ end failed to block cleavage, although this substrate was refractory to cleavage by the 5′-3′ exonuclease activity of Taq DNA polymerase. For verification, the free 5′ end was replaced by an internally labeled hairpin structure. This structure was a substrate for FEN but became a substrate for Taq DNA polymerase only after exonucleolytic cleavage had destabilized the hairpin. A circular duplex substrate with a 5′ single-stranded branch was formed by primer extension of a partially complementary oligonucleotide on virion X174. This denaturation-resistant substrate was used to examine the effects of temperature and solution properties, such as pH, salt, and divalent ion concentration on the turnover number of the enzyme.     

Signal amplification through nucleotide extension and excision on a dendritic DNA platform

Techniques that provide strong signal amplification are useful in diagnostic applications, especially in detecting low concentrations of non-amplifiable target molecules. A versatile and strong signal amplification method based on activities of a DNA polymerase to generate high concentrations of pyrophosphate (PPi) is described. The generation of PPi is catalyzed by nucleotide extension and excision activities of a DNA polymerase on an oligonucleotide cassette. The signal is generated upon enzymatic conversion of PPi to ATP and ATP levels subsequently detected with firefly luciferase. Bioluminesence produced by an oligonucleotide cassette consisting of just two polymerase reaction sites is sufficient to detect them at low attomole levels. The attachment of a large number of these oligonucleotide cassettes to DNA dendrimers enabled the detection of such polyvalent substrate molecules at low zeptomole (10^–21 mol) concentrations. The extent of signal amplification obtained with dendrimer substrates is comparable to exponential target amplifications provided by nucleic acid amplification methods. The attachment of such PPi-generating dendritic DNA platforms to ligands that mediate target recognition would potentially permit detection of extremely low concentrations of analytes in diagnostic assays.     

I-BasI and I-HmuI: two phage intron-encoded endonucleases with homologous DNA recognition sequences but distinct DNA specificities

I-HmuI and I-BasI are two highly similar nicking DNA endonucleases, which are each encoded by a group I intron inserted into homologous sites within the DNA polymerase genes of Bacillus phages SPO1 and Bastille, respectively. Here, we present a comparison of the DNA specificities and cleavage activities of these enconucleases with homologous target sites. I-BasI has properties that are typical of homing endonucleases, nicking the intron-minus polymerase genes in either host genome, three nucleotides downstream of the intron insertion site. In contrast, I-HmuI nicks both the intron-plus and intron-minus site in its own host genome, but does not act on the target from Bastille phage. Although the enzymes have distinct DNA substrate specificities, both bind to an identical 25bp region of their respective intron-minus DNA polymerase genes surrounding the intron insertion site. The endonucleases appear to interact with the DNA substrates in the downstream exon 2 in a similar manner. However, whereas I-HmuI is known to make its only base-specific contacts within this exon region, structural modeling analyses predict that I-BasI might make specific base contacts both upstream and downstream of the site of intron insertion. The predicted requirement for base-specific contacts in exon 1 for cleavage by I-BasI was confirmed experimentally. This explains the difference in substrate specificities between the two enzymes, including the observation that the former enzyme is relatively insensitive to the presence of an intron upstream of exon 2. These differences are likely a consequence of divergent evolutionary constraints.     

Cleavage of oligoribonucleotides by a ribozyme derived from the hepatitis delta virus RNA sequence.

A self-cleaving RNA sequence from hepatitis delta virus was modified to produce a ribozyme capable of catalyzing the cleavage of RNA in an intermolecular (trans) reaction. The delta-derived ribozyme cleaved substrate RNA at a specific site, and the sequence specificity could be altered with mutations in the region of the ribozyme proposed to base pair with the substrate. A substrate target size of approximately 8 nucleotides in length was identified. Octanucleotides containing a single ribonucleotide immediately 5' to the cleavage site were substrates for cleavage, and cleavage activity was significantly reduced only with a guanine base at that position. A deoxyribose 5' to the cleavage site blocked the reaction. These data are consistent with a proposed secondary structure for the self-cleaving form of the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme in which a duplex forms with sequences 3' to the cleavage site, and they support a proposed mechanism in which cleavage involves attack on the phosphorus at the cleavage site by the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group.