Antibody microarray-based profiling of complex specimens: systematic evaluation of labeling strategies

Antibody microarrays have often had limited success in detection of low abundant proteins in complex specimens. Signal amplification systems improve this situation, but still are quite laborious and expensive. However, the issue of sensitivity is more likely a matter of kinetically appropriate microarray design as demonstrated previously. Hence, we re-examined in this study the suitability of simple and inexpensive detection approaches for highly sensitive antibody microarray analysis. N-hydroxysuccinimidyl ester (NHS)- and Universal Linkage System (ULS)-based fluorescein and biotin labels used as tags for subsequent detection with anti-fluorescein and extravidin, respectively, as well as fluorescent dyes were applied for analysis of blood plasma. Parameters modifying strongly the performance of microarray detection such as labeling conditions, incubation time, concentrations of anti-fluorescein and extravidin and extent of protein labeling were analyzed and optimized in this study. Indirect detection strategies whether based on NHS- or ULS-chemistries strongly outperformed direct fluorescent labeling and enabled detection of low abundant cytokines with many dozen-fold signal-to-noise ratios. Finally, particularly sensitive detection chemistry was applied to monitoring cytokine production of stimulated peripheral T cells. Microarray data were in accord with quantitative cytokine levels measured by ELISA and Luminex, demonstrating comparable reliability and femtomolar range sensitivity of the established microarray approach.     

Porous silicon biosensor for detection of viruses

There is a growing need for virus sensors with improved sensitivity and dynamic range, for applications including disease diagnosis, pharmaceutical research, agriculture and homeland security. We report here a new method for improving the sensitivity for detection of the bacteriophage virus MS2 using thin films of nanoporous silicon. Porous silicon is an easily fabricated material that has extremely high surface area to volume ratio, making it an ideal platform for surface based sensors. We have developed and evaluated two different methods for covalent bioconjugation of antibodies inside of porous silicon films, and we show that the pore penetration and binding efficiency depend on the wettability of the porous surface. The resulting films were used to selectively capture dye-labeled MS2 viruses from solution, and a viral concentration as low as 2 x 10(7) plaque-forming units per mL (pfu/mL) was detectable by measuring the fluorescence from the exposed porous silicon film. The system exhibits sensitivity and dynamic range similar to the Luminex liquid array-based assay while outperforming protein micro-array methods.     

Antibody purification-independent microarrays (PIM) by direct bacteria spotting on TiO2-treated slides

The preparation of effective conventional antibody microarrays depends on the availability of high quality material and on the correct accessibility of the antibody active moieties following their immobilization on the support slide. We show that spotting bacteria that expose recombinant antibodies on their external surface directly on nanostructured-TiO(2) or epoxy slides (purification-independent microarray - PIM) is a simple and reliable alternative for preparing sensitive and specific microarrays for antigen detection. Variable domains of single heavy-chain antibodies (VHHs) against fibroblast growth factor receptor 1 (FGFR1) were used to capture the antigen diluted in serum or BSA solution. The FGFR1 detection was performed by either direct antigen labeling or using a sandwich system in which FGFR1 was first bound to its antibody and successively identified using a labeled FGF. In both cases the signal distribution within each spot was uniform and spot morphology regular. The signal-to-noise ratio of the signal was extremely elevated and the specificity of the system was proved statistically. The LOD of the system for the antigen was calculated being 0.4ng/mL and the dynamic range between 0.4ng/mL and 10μg/mL. The microarrays prepared with bacteria exposing antibodies remain fully functional for at least 31 days after spotting. We finally demonstrated that the method is suitable for other antigen-antibody pairs and expect that it could be easily adapted to further applications such as the display of scFv and IgG antibodies or the autoantibody detection using protein PIMs.     

High-throughput optimization of surfaces for antibody immobilization using metal complexes

Using a high-throughput surface discovery approach, we have generated a 1600-member library of metal-containing surfaces and screened them for antibody binding potential. The surface library assembly involved graft modification of argon plasma-treated polyvinylidenedifluoride (PVDF) membranes with alternating maleic anhydride-styrene copolymer followed by anhydride ring opening with a range of secondary amines and microarray contact printing of transition metal complexes. The microarrays of metal-containing surfaces were then tested for their antibody binding capacity by incubation with a biotinylated mouse antibody in a chemiluminescence assay. A total of 11 leads were identified from the first screen, constituting a "hit" rate of 0.7%. A smaller 135-member surface library was then synthesized and screened to optimize existing hits and generate additional leads. To demonstrate the applicability of these surfaces to other formats, high-binding surface leads were then transferred onto Luminex beads for use in a bead flow cytometric immunoassay. The novel one-step antibody coupling process increased assay sensitivity of a Luminex tumor necrosis factor immunoassay. These high-binding surfaces do not require prior incorporation of polyhistidine tags or posttreatments such as oxidation to achieve essentially irreversible binding of immunoglobulin G.     

Immunoassays based on electrochemical detection using microelectrode arrays

We show that CombiMatrix's VLSI arrays of individually addressable electrodes, using conventional CMOS integrated circuitry, can be used in detecting various analytes via immunoassay protocols. These microarrays provide over 1000 electrodes per square centimeter. The chips are coated with a porous material on which specific affinity tags are synthesized proximate to selected electrode sites. CombiMatrix microarrays are used to develop spatially multiplexed assay formats for biological entities over a wide range of sizes, from small molecules to cells. Antibodies are tagged with coded affinity labels and then allowed to self-assemble on the appropriate electrode assay sites. Each analyte-specific antibody is chaperoned to individual, predetermined locations by the self-assembly process. The resulting chip can perform numerous different analyte-specific immunoassays, simultaneously. We present new detection technologies based upon the use of the active individually addressable microelectrodes on the chip: redox enzyme amplified electrochemical detection. The results for human alpha1 acid glycoprotein, ricin, M13 phage, Bacillus globigii spores, and fluorescein indicate that this method is one of the most sensitive available, with limits of detection in the attomole range. The detection range is 4-5 logs of analyte concentration, with an assay volume of 50 microl or less. The system provides for a host of multiplexed immunoassays because of the large number of electrodes available. We show how the assays can be optimized for maximum performance on the CombiMatrix microarray platform.     

Optical readout of gold nanoparticle-based DNA microarrays without silver enhancement

We present a novel readout scheme for gold nanoparticle-based DNA microarrays relying on "Laser-Induced Scattering around a NanoAbsorber". It provides direct counting of individual nanoparticles present on each array spot and stable signals, without any silver enhancement. Given the detection of nanometer-sized particles, which minimize the steric hindrance, the linear dynamic range of the method is particularly large and well suited for microarray detection.     

Real-time DNA microarray analysis

We present a quantification method for affinity-based DNA microarrays which is based on the real-time measurements of hybridization kinetics. This method, i.e. real-time DNA microarrays, enhances the detection dynamic range of conventional systems by being impervious to probe saturation in the capturing spots, washing artifacts, microarray spot-to-spot variations, and other signal amplitude-affecting non-idealities. We demonstrate in both theory and practice that the time-constant of target capturing in microarrays, similar to all affinity-based biosensors, is inversely proportional to the concentration of the target analyte, which we subsequently use as the fundamental parameter to estimate the concentration of the analytes. Furthermore, to empirically validate the capabilities of this method in practical applications, we present a FRET-based assay which enables the real-time detection in gene expression DNA microarrays.     

Comparison of ovalbumin quantification using forward-phase protein microarrays and suspension arrays

We employed ovalbumin (a simulant used for ricin and botulism toxins in biodefense applications) and its high affinity polyclonal antibody as a model system to examine the sensitivity, dynamic range, linearity, and reproducibility of forward-phase array results in comparison to suspension arrays. It was found that protein microarrays had a dynamic range of 4 orders of magnitude and a sensitivity of less than 1 pg/mL, respectively. The dynamic range and sensitivity of suspension arrays were close to 2 orders of magnitude and 0.25 ng/mL, respectively. The sensitivity we observed for the suspension arrays is comparable to that reported for enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) in the literature. We used ovalbumin samples with two different purities, 38.0% and 76.0% (w/w), as determined by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). These samples were used to evaluate the effect of impure samples on detection. The data obtained from the forward-phase protein arrays gave values that were consistent with the PAGE data. The data from the suspension arrays were not as consistent and may indicate that this format may not give as reliable data with impure samples. Knowledge of the advantages and disadvantages of the two proteomic methods would allow their more rational use in clinical diagnosis.     

A dual-tag microarray platform for high-performance nucleic acid and protein analyses

DNA microarrays serve to monitor a wide range of molecular events, but emerging applications like measurements of weakly expressed genes or of proteins and their interaction patterns will require enhanced performance to improve specificity of detection and dynamic range. To further extend the utility of DNA microarray-based approaches we present a high-performance tag microarray procedure that enables probe-based analysis of as little as 100 target cDNA molecules, and with a linear dynamic range close to 10⁵. Furthermore, the protocol radically decreases the risk of cross-hybridization on microarrays compared to current approaches, and it also allows for quantification by single-molecule analysis and real-time on-chip monitoring of rolling-circle amplification. We provide proof of concept for microarray-based measurement of both mRNA molecules and of proteins, converted to tag DNA sequences by padlock and proximity probe ligation, respectively.     

Quantitative,multiplexed detection of bacterial pathogens: DNA and protein applications of the Luminex LabMAP system

Escherichia coli, Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes and Campylobacter jejuni are bacterial pathogens commonly implicated in foodborne illnesses. Generally used detection methods (i.e., culture, biochemical testing, ELISA and nucleic acid amplification) can be laborious, time-consuming and require multiple tests to detect all of the pathogens. Our objective was to develop rapid assays to simultaneously detect these four organisms through the presence of antigen or DNA using the Luminex LabMAP system. For nucleic acid detection, organism-specific capture probes corresponding to the 23S ribosomal RNA gene (rrl) were coupled covalently to LabMAP microspheres. Target molecules included synthetic complementary oligonucleotides and genomic DNA isolated from ATCC type strains or other well-characterized strains of each organism. Universal PCR primers were designed to amplify variable regions of bacterial 23S ribosomal DNA, yielding biotinylated amplicons of 86 to 109 bp in length. Varying quantities of targets were hybridized to the combined microsphere sets, labeled with streptavidin-R-phycoerythrin and analyzed on the Luminex(100) system. Results of nucleic acid detection assays, obtained in 30 to 40 min following amplification, correctly and specifically identified each bacterial species with a detection sensitivity of 10(3) to 10(5) genome copies. Capture-sandwich immunoassays were developed with organism-specific antibodies coupled to different microsphere sets. Microspheres were incubated with organism-specific standards and reactivity was assessed with biotinylated detection antibodies and streptavidin-R-phycoerythrin. In the immunoassays, microsphere-associated fluorescence was organism concentration dependent with detectable response at < or = 1000 organisms/ml and with no apparent cross-reactivity. We have demonstrated that the Luminex LabMAP system is a rapid, flexible platform capable of simultaneous, sensitive and specific detection of pathogens. The practical significance of this multiplexing approach would be to provide more timely, economical and comprehensive information than is available with conventional isolation and identification methodologies.     

Microarray-based kinetic colorimetric detection for quantitative multiplex protein phosphorylation analysis

Commonly used colorimetric detection applied to protein microarrays with enzymatic signal amplification leads to non‐linear signal production upon increase in analyte concentration, thereby considerably limiting the range and accuracy of quantitative readout interpretation. To extend the detection range, we developed a kinetic colorimetric detection protocol for the analysis of ELISA microarrays designed to measure multiple phosphorylated proteins using the platforms ArrayTube? and ArrayStrip?. With our novel quantification approach, microarrays were calibrated over a broad concentration range spanning four orders of magnitude of analyte concentration with picomolar threshold. We used this design for the simultaneous quantitative measurement of 15 phosphorylated proteins on a single chip.     

Development and comparison of two assay formats for parallel detection of four biothreat pathogens by using suspension microarrays

Microarrays provide a powerful analytical tool for the simultaneous detection of multiple pathogens. We developed diagnostic suspension microarrays for sensitive and specific detection of the biothreat pathogens Bacillus anthracis, Yersinia pestis, Francisella tularensis and Coxiella burnetii. Two assay chemistries for amplification and labeling were developed, one method using direct hybridization and the other using target-specific primer extension, combined with hybridization to universal arrays. Asymmetric PCR products for both assay chemistries were produced by using a multiplex asymmetric PCR amplifying 16 DNA signatures (16-plex). The performances of both assay chemistries were compared and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed. The developed microarrays detected multiple signature sequences and an internal control which made it possible to confidently identify the targeted pathogens and assess their virulence potential. The microarrays were highly specific and detected various strains of the targeted pathogens. Detection limits for the different pathogen signatures were similar or slightly higher compared to real-time PCR. Probit analysis showed that even a few genomic copies could be detected with 95% confidence. The microarrays detected DNA from different pathogens mixed in different ratios and from spiked or naturally contaminated samples. The assays that were developed have a potential for application in surveillance and diagnostics.     

Signal amplification by rolling circle amplification on DNA microarrays

While microarrays hold considerable promise in large-scale biology on account of their massively parallel analytical nature, there is a need for compatible signal amplification procedures to increase sensitivity without loss of multiplexing. Rolling circle amplification (RCA) is a molecular amplification method with the unique property of product localization. This report describes the application of RCA signal amplification for multiplexed, direct detection and quantitation of nucleic acid targets on planar glass and gel-coated microarrays. As few as 150 molecules bound to the surface of microarrays can be detected using RCA. Because of the linear kinetics of RCA, nucleic acid target molecules may be measured with a dynamic range of four orders of magnitude. Consequently, RCA is a promising technology for the direct measurement of nucleic acids on microarrays without the need for a potentially biasing preamplification step.     

A highly sensitive DNA bead-based suspension array for the detection and species identification of bovine piroplasms

Piroplasms are among the most harmful tick-borne pathogens for livestock and sensitive and specific diagnostic methods for rapid detection and identification of the different species are needed for effective control. Reverse Line Blot has been the molecular technique of choice but it is laborious, time-consuming and highly susceptible to subjective variation in the interpretation of the hybridisation signal. Here, an oligonucleotide multiplex suspension microarray (Luminex® microsphere system) was developed for bovine piroplasms. Probes previously used in Reverse Line Blot for Babesia divergens, Babesia bovis, Babesia occultans, Babesia bigemina and Theileria buffeli, and a catch-all Theileria and Babesia control probe, were included in the Luminex assay together with newly designed probes for Theileria annulata and Babesia major. An internal amplification control that was detected with a Luminex probe was included to monitor for inhibition. Serially diluted linearised recombinant plasmids of the different species were used to assess the analytical sensitivity and specificity, and the detection limit of the Luminex assay was determined using serial dilutions of infected blood from an animal with a known level of T. annulata parasitaemia. The assay was then validated on 214 bovine blood samples analysed in parallel by Reverse Line Blot and Luminex. The Luminex assay proved to be highly specific and more sensitive than Reverse Line Blot, detecting 0.05 parasites/μl of blood. Technically, the Luminex procedure was rapid, provided high throughput screening, transformed the subjective interpretation of Reverse Line Blot results into numerical objective values, and allowed more flexibility in array preparation than Reverse Line Blot. The method described herein can substantially improve the detection of piroplasm carriers and thus better protect livestock trade and facilitate preventive control programs.     

A cancer protein microarray platform using antibody fragments and its clinical applications

Antibody microarrays have shown great potential for measurement of either a spectrum of target proteins in proteomics or disease-associated antigens in molecular diagnostics. Despite its importance, the applications of antibody microarrays are still limited by a variety of fundamental problems. Among them, cross-reactivity significantly limits the multiplexing ability in parallel sandwich immunoassays. As a result, it is very important to design new capture probes in order to incorporate a universal label into the assay configuration. In this report, an antibody fragments (F(ab')2) microarray platform for serum tumor markers was developed. Each antigen was detected at different concentrations to assemble its calibration curve, and combinations of different markers were tested to examine the specificity of simultaneous detection based on the F(ab')2 microarrays. Diagnostics of serum samples with this cancer antibody microarray platform and immunoradiometric assays (IRMA) were also performed. Wide range calibration curves (0-1280 U mL(-1)) were obtained for each tumor marker. Comparative studies demonstrated that such F(ab')2 microarrays exhibited both moderately improved sensitivity and better specificity than full-sized monoclonal antibody microarrays. It is also demonstrated that this microarray platform is quantitative, highly specific and reasonably sensitive. More importantly, clinical applications of our F(ab')2 microarray platform for upwards of 100 patient serum samples clearly show its potential in cancer diagnostics.     

Nanosphere lithography-based platform for developing rapid and high sensitivity microarray systems

A novel gold nanoarray (NA)-based platform was developed for microarray applications. This novel approach is based upon the principle of nanosphere lithography and can be used for one-step antibody immobilization. The developed platform was checked by functionalizing with cysteine followed by capturing biotinylated antibody and detecting it with dye-conjugated steptravidin. An immunoassay was performed with spiked samples containing human fetuin A antigen. The minimum limits of detection (LOD) of human fetuin A for NA-based and conventional microarray platforms were 50 pg/mL and 50 ng/mL, respectively. The developed approach was highly reproducible and unlike conventional microarray approaches the use of a spotting system was omitted because immobilization was controlled and directed on the predefined arrays. This approach could be an ideal alternative for developing microarrays. And, the ease of the strategy also allows the high throughput production of the microarrays.