Comprehensive model for allosteric regulation of mammalian ribonucleotide reductase: refinements and consequences

Reduction of NDPs by murine ribonucleotide reductase (mRR) requires catalytic (mR1) and free radical-containing (mR2) subunits and is regulated by nucleoside triphosphate allosteric effectors. Here we present the results of several studies that refine the recently presented comprehensive model for the allosteric control of mRR enzymatic activity [Kashlan, O. B., et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 462-474], in which nucleotide binding to the specificity site (s-site) drives formation of an active R1(2)R2(2) dimer, ATP or dATP binding to the adenine site (a-site) drives formation of a tetramer, mR1(4a), which isomerizes to an inactive form, mR1(4b), and ATP binding to the hexamerization site (h-site) drives formation of an active R1(6)R2(6) hexamer. Analysis of the a-site D57N variant of mR1, which differs from wild-type mR1 (wt-mR1) in that its RR activity is activated by both ATP and dATP, demonstrates that dATP activation of the D57N variant RR arises from a blockage in the formation of mR1(4b) from mR1(4a), and provides strong evidence that mR1(4a) forms active complexes with mR2(2). We further demonstrate that (a) differences in the effects of ATP versus dATP binding to the a-site of wt-mR1 provide specific mechanisms by which the dATP/ATP ratio in mammalian cells could modulate in vivo RR enzymatic activity, (b) the comprehensive model is valid over a range of Mg(2+) concentrations that include in vivo concentrations, and (c) equilibrium constants derived for the comprehensive model can be used to simulate the distribution of R1 among dimer, tetramer, and hexamer forms in vivo. Such simulations indicate that mR1(6) predominates over mR1(2) in the cytoplasm of normal mammalian cells, where the great majority of RR activity is located, but that mR1(2) may be important for nuclear RR activity and for RR activity in cells in which the level of ATP is depleted.     

Enzymatically active mammalian ribonucleotide reductase exists primarily as an alpha6beta2 octamer

Ribonucleotide reductase synthesizes deoxyribonucleotides, which are essential building blocks for DNA synthesis. The mammalian ribonucleotide reductase is described as an alpha(2)beta(2) complex consisting of R1 (alpha) and R2 (beta) proteins. ATP stimulates and dATP inhibits enzyme activity by binding to an allosteric site called the activity site on the R1 protein. Despite the opposite effects by ATP and dATP on enzyme activity, both nucleotides induce formation of R1 oligomers. By using a new technique termed Gas-phase Electrophoretic-Mobility Macromolecule Analysis (GEMMA), we have found that the ATP/dATP-induced R1 oligomers have a defined size (hexamers) and can interact with the R2 dimer to form an enzymatically active protein complex (alpha(6)beta(2)). The newly discovered alpha(6)beta(2) complex can either be in an active or an inhibited state depending on whether ATP or dATP is bound. Our results suggest that this protein complex is the major form of ribonucleotide reductase at physiological levels of R1-R2 protein and nucleotides.     

Cross-talk between the allosteric effector-binding sites in mouse ribonucleotide reductase

We compared the allosteric regulation and effector binding properties of wild type R1 protein and R1 protein with a mutation in the "activity site" (D57N) of mouse ribonucleotide reductase. Wild type R1 had two effector-binding sites per polypeptide chain: one site (activity site) for dATP and ATP, with dATP-inhibiting and ATP-stimulating catalytic activity; and a second site (specificity site) for dATP, ATP, dTTP, and dGTP, directing substrate specificity. Binding of dATP to the specificity site had a 20-fold higher affinity than to the activity site. In all these respects, mouse R1 resembles Escherichia coli R1. Results with D57N were complicated by the instability of the protein, but two major changes were apparent. First, enzyme activity was stimulated by both dATP and ATP, suggesting that D57N no longer distinguished between the two nucleotides. Second, the two binding sites for dATP both had the same low affinity for the nucleotide, similar to that of the activity site of wild type R1. Thus the mutation in the activity site had decreased the affinity for dATP at the specificity site, demonstrating the interaction between the two sites.     

More potent linear peptide inhibitors of mammalian ribonucleotide reductase

Mammalian ribonucleotide reductase (mRR) is a chemotherapeutic target. The enzyme is composed of two subunits (mR1 and mR2) and is inhibited by Ac-FTLDADF (denoted P7), corresponding to the C-terminus of mR2, which disrupts mRR quaternary structure by competing with mR2 for binding to mR1. The tripeptide FmocWFF acts similarly. Here we report on the use of small, focused libraries to identify Fmoc derivatives of tetra and hexapeptides having comparable or considerably higher activities than P7 toward inhibition of mRR.     

Mutant R1 proteins from Escherichia coli class Ia ribonucleotide reductase with altered responses to dATP inhibition

Aerobic ribonucleotide reductase from Escherichia coli regulates its level of activity by binding of effectors to an allosteric site in R1, located to the proposed interaction area of the two proteins that comprise the class I enzyme. Activity is increased by ATP binding and decreased by dATP binding. To study the mechanism governing this regulation, we have constructed three R1 proteins with mutations at His-59 in the activity site and one R1 protein with a mutation at His-88 close to the activity site and compared their allosteric behavior to that of the wild type R1 protein. All mutant proteins retained about 70% of wild type enzymatic activity. We found that if residue His-59 was replaced with alanine or asparagine, the enzyme lost its normal response to the inhibitory effect of dATP, whereas the enzyme with a glutamine still managed to elicit a normal response. We saw a similar result if residue His-88, which is proposed to hydrogen-bond to His-59, was replaced with alanine. Nucleotide binding experiments ruled out the possibility that the effect is due to an inability of the mutant proteins to bind effector since little difference in binding constants was observed for wild type and mutant proteins. Instead, the interaction between proteins R1 and R2 was perturbed in the mutant proteins. We propose that His-59 is important in the allosteric effect triggered by dATP binding, that the conserved hydrogen bond between His-59 and His-88 is important for the communication of the allosteric effect, and that this effect is exerted on the R1/R2 interaction.     

Oligomerization status directs overall activity regulation of the Escherichia coli class Ia ribonucleotide reductase

Ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) is a key enzyme for the synthesis of the four DNA building blocks. Class Ia RNRs contain two subunits, denoted R1 (alpha) and R2 (beta). These enzymes are regulated via two nucleotide-binding allosteric sites on the R1 subunit, termed the specificity and overall activity sites. The specificity site binds ATP, dATP, dTTP, or dGTP and determines the substrate to be reduced, whereas the overall activity site binds dATP (inhibitor) or ATP. By using gas-phase electrophoretic mobility macromolecule analysis and enzyme assays, we found that the Escherichia coli class Ia RNR formed an inhibited alpha(4)beta(4) complex in the presence of dATP and an active alpha(2)beta(2) complex in the presence of ATP (main substrate: CDP), dTTP (substrate: GDP) or dGTP (substrate: ADP). The R1-R2 interaction was 30-50 times stronger in the alpha(4)beta(4) complex than in the alpha(2)beta(2) complex, which was in equilibrium with free alpha(2) and beta(2) subunits. Studies of a known E. coli R1 mutant (H59A) showed that deficient dATP inhibition correlated with reduced ability to form alpha(4)beta(4) complexes. ATP could also induce the formation of a generally inhibited alpha(4)beta(4) complex in the E. coli RNR but only when used in combination with high concentrations of the specificity site effectors, dTTP/dGTP. Both allosteric sites are therefore important for alpha(4)beta(4) formation and overall activity regulation. The E. coli RNR differs from the mammalian enzyme, which is stimulated by ATP also in combination with dGTP/dTTP and forms active and inactive alpha(6)beta(2) complexes.     

DNA building blocks: keeping control of manufacture

Ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) is the only source for de novo production of the four deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) building blocks needed for DNA synthesis and repair. It is crucial that these dNTP pools are carefully balanced, since mutation rates increase when dNTP levels are either unbalanced or elevated. RNR is the major player in this homeostasis, and with its four different substrates, four different allosteric effectors and two different effector binding sites, it has one of the most sophisticated allosteric regulations known today. In the past few years, the structures of RNRs from several bacteria, yeast and man have been determined in the presence of allosteric effectors and substrates, revealing new information about the mechanisms behind the allosteric regulation. A common theme for all studied RNRs is a flexible loop that mediates modulatory effects from the allosteric specificity site (s-site) to the catalytic site for discrimination between the four substrates. Much less is known about the allosteric activity site (a-site), which functions as an on-off switch for the enzyme's overall activity by binding ATP (activator) or dATP (inhibitor). The two nucleotides induce formation of different enzyme oligomers, and a recent structure of a dATP-inhibited α(6)β(2) complex from yeast suggested how its subunits interacted non-productively. Interestingly, the oligomers formed and the details of their allosteric regulation differ between eukaryotes and Escherichia coli. Nevertheless, these differences serve a common purpose in an essential enzyme whose allosteric regulation might date back to the era when the molecular mechanisms behind the central dogma evolved.     

The enantioselectivities of the active and allosteric sites of mammalian ribonucleotide reductase

Here we examine the enantioselectivity of the allosteric and substrate binding sites of murine ribonucleotide reductase (mRR). L-ADP binds to the active site and L-ATP binds to both the s- and a-allosteric sites of mR1 with affinities that are only three- to 10-fold weaker than the values for the corresponding D-enantiomers. These results demonstrate the potential of L-nucleotides for interacting with and modulating the activity of mRR, a cancer chemotherapeutic and antiviral target. On the other hand, we detect no substrate activity for L-ADP and no inhibitory activity for N3-L-dUDP, demonstrating the greater stereochemical stringency at the active site with respect to catalytic activity.     

Structure-based optimization of peptide inhibitors of mammalian ribonucleotide reductase

Mammalian ribonucleotide reductase (mRR), a potential target for cancer intervention, is composed of two subunits, mR1 and mR2, whose association is critical for enzyme activity. In this article we describe the structural features of the mRR-inhibitor Ac-F-c[ELAK]-DF (Peptide 3) while bound to the mR1 subunit as determined by transferred NOEs. Peptide 3 is a cyclic analogue of the N-acetylated form of the heptapeptide C-terminus of the mR2 subunit (Ac-FTLDADF), which is the link between the two subunits and previously shown to be the minimal sequence inhibitor mRR by competing with mR2 for binding to mR1. Structural refinement employing an ensemble-based, full-relaxation matrix approach resulted in two structures varying in the conformations of F(1) and the cyclic lactam side chains of E(2) and K(5). The remainder of the molecule, both backbone and side chains, is extremely well-defined, with an RMSD of 0.54 A. The structural features of this conformationally constrained analogue provide unique insight into the requirements for binding to mR1, critical for further inhibitor development.     

Allosteric control of three B12-dependent (class II) ribonucleotide reductases. Implications for the evolution of ribonucleotide reduction

Three separate classes of ribonucleotide reductases are known, each with a distinct protein structure. One common feature of all enzymes is that a single protein generates each of the four deoxyribonucleotides. Class I and III enzymes contain an allosteric substrate specificity site capable of binding effectors (ATP or various deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates) that direct enzyme specificity. Some (but not all) enzymes contain a second allosteric site that binds only ATP or dATP. Binding of dATP to this site inhibits the activity of these enzymes. X-ray crystallography has localized the two sites within the structure of the Escherichia coli class I enzyme and identified effector-binding amino acids. Here, we have studied the regulation of three class II enzymes, one from the archaebacterium Thermoplasma acidophilum and two from eubacteria (Lactobacillus leichmannii and Thermotoga maritima). Each enzyme has an allosteric site that binds ATP or various deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates and that regulates its substrate specificity according to the same rules as for class I and III enzymes. dATP does not inhibit enzyme activity, suggesting the absence of a second active allosteric site. For the L. leichmannii and T. maritima enzymes, binding experiments also indicate the presence of only one allosteric site. Their primary sequences suggest that these enzymes lack the structural requirements for a second site. In contrast, the T. acidophilum enzyme binds dATP at two separate sites, and its sequence contains putative effector-binding amino acids for a second site. The presence of a second site without apparent physiological function leads to the hypothesis that a functional site was present early during the evolution of ribonucleotide reductases, but that its function was lost from the T. acidophilum enzyme. The other two B12 enzymes lost not only the function, but also the structural basis for the site. Also a large subgroup (Ib) of class I enzymes, but none of the investigated class III enzymes, has lost this site. This is further indirect evidence that class II and I enzymes may have arisen by divergent evolution from class III enzymes.     

Enhancement by effectors and substrate nucleotides of R1-R2 interactions in Escherichia coli class Ia ribonucleotide reductase

Ribonucleotide reductases are a family of essential enzymes that catalyze the reduction of ribonucleotides to their corresponding deoxyribonucleotides and provide cells with precursors for DNA synthesis. The different classes of ribonucleotide reductase are distinguished based on quaternary structures and enzyme activation mechanisms, but the components harboring the active site region in each class are evolutionarily related. With a few exceptions, ribonucleotide reductases are allosterically regulated by nucleoside triphosphates (ATP and dNTPs). We have used the surface plasmon resonance technique to study how allosteric effects govern the strength of quaternary interactions in the class Ia ribonucleotide reductase from Escherichia coli, which like all class I enzymes has a tetrameric alpha(2) beta(2) structure. The component alpha(2)called R1 harbors the active site and two types of binding sites for allosteric effector nucleotides, whereas the beta(2) component called R2 harbors the tyrosyl radical necessary for catalysis. Our results show that only the known allosteric effector nucleotides, but not non-interacting nucleotides, promote a specific interaction between R1 and R2. Interestingly, the presence of substrate together with allosteric effector nucleotide strengthens the complex 2-3 times with a similar free energy change as the mutual allosteric effects of substrate and effector nucleotide binding to protein R1 in solution experiments. The dual allosteric effects of dATP as positive allosteric effector at low concentrations and as negative allosteric effector at high concentrations coincided with an almost 100-fold stronger R1-R2 interaction. Based on the experimental setup, we propose that the inhibition of enzyme activity in the E. coli class Ia enzyme occurs in a tight 1:1 complex of R1 and R2. Most intriguingly, we also discovered that thioredoxin, one of the physiological reductants of ribonucleotide reductases, enhances the R1-R2 interaction 4-fold.     

Redox studies of subunit interactivity in aerobic ribonucleotide reductase from Escherichia coli

Ribonucleotide reductase is a heterodimeric (alpha(2)beta(2)) allosteric enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of ribonucleotides to deoxyribonucleotides, an essential step in DNA biosynthesis and repair. In the enzymatically active form aerobic Escherichia coli ribonucleotide reductase is a complex of homodimeric R1 and R2 proteins. We use electrochemical studies of the dinuclear center to clarify the interplay of subunit interaction, the binding of allosteric effectors and substrate selectivity. Our studies show for the first time that electrochemical reduction of active R2 generates a distinct Met form of the diiron cluster, with a midpoint potential (-163 +/- 3 mV) different from that of R2(Met) produced by hydroxyurea (-115 +/- 2 mV). The redox potentials of both Met forms experience negative shifts when measured in the presence of R1, becoming -223 +/- 6 and -226 +/- 3 mV, respectively, demonstrating that R1-triggered conformational changes favor one configuration of the diiron cluster. We show that the association of a substrate analog and specificity effector (dGDP/dTTP or GMP/dTTP) with R1 regulates the redox properties of the diiron centers in R2. Their midpoint potential in the complex shifts to -192 +/- 2 mV for dGDP/dTTP and to -203 +/- 3 mV for GMP/dTTP. In contrast, reduction potential measurements show that the diiron cluster is not affected by ATP (0.35-1.45 mm) and dATP (0.3-0.6 mm) binding to R1. Binding of these effectors to the R1-R2 complex does not perturb the normal docking modes between R1 and R2 as similar redox shifts are observed for ATP or dATP associated with the R1-R2 complex.     

Ribonucleotide reductase from Escherichia coli. Identification of allosteric effector sites by chromatography on immobilized effectors.

Ribonucleotide reductase is responsible for the production of deoxyribonucleotides by catalyzing the reduction of ribonucleoside diphosphates. The enzyme is allosterically regulated in a complex way by the nucleoside triphosphates, ATP, dTTP, dGTP, dCTP, and dATP. Ribonucleotide reductase consists of two nonidentical subunits, proteins B1 and B2. Both substrates and allosteric effectors bind exclusively to B1. Binding of protein B1 to dTTP or dATP covalently coupled to Sepharose and elution with concentration gradients of the different nucleoside triphosphate effectors gave information about (1) the arrangement of the effector binding sites on protein B1 and (2) the affinity of the effectors for these sites. Protein B1 thus has two classes of effector binding sites. One class binds all effectors, as demonstrated by elution of the protein from dTTP-Sepharose with dATP, dGTP, ATP, or dCTP. The second class binds only dATP or ATP, since dATP and ATP were the only nucleotides which eluted protein B1 from dATP-Sepharose. These results confirm earlier data obtained by dialysis binding experiments. The eluting concentrations obtained for the different nucleoside triphosphates in experiments with dTTP-Sepharose could be used to calculate unknown dissociation constants for protein B1 -effector binary complexes. This was possible, since a plot of the eluting concentrations vs. known dissociation constants was linear.     

Structure of the large subunit of class Ib ribonucleotide reductase from Salmonella typhimurium and its complexes with allosteric effectors

The three-dimensional structure of the large subunit of the first member of a class Ib ribonucleotide reductase, R1E of Salmonella typhimurium, has been determined in its native form and together with three allosteric effectors. The enzyme contains the characteristic ten-stranded alpha/beta-barrel with catalytic residues at a finger loop in its center and with redox-active cysteine residues at two adjacent barrel strands. Structures where the redox-active cysteine residues are in reduced thiol form and in oxidized disulfide form have been determined revealing local structural changes. The R1E enzyme differs from the class Ia enzyme, Escherichia coli R1, by not having an overall allosteric regulation. This is explained from the structure by differences in the N-terminal domain, which is about 50 residues shorter and lacks the overall allosteric binding site. R1E has an allosteric substrate specificity regulation site and the binding site for the nucleotide effectors is located at the dimer interface similarly as for the class Ia enzymes. We have determined the structures of R1E in the absence of effectors and with dTTP, dATP and dCTP bound. The low affinity for ATP at the specificity site is explained by a tyrosine, which hinders nucleotides containing a 2'-OH group to bind.     

Estimation of binding constants for the substrate and activator of Rhodobacter sphaeroides adenosine 5'-diphosphate-glucose pyrophosphorylase using affinity capillary electrophoresis

Binding constants were determined for the activator fructose-6-phosphate (F6P) and substrate adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) (in the presence and absence of F6P) to the recombinant wild-type (WT) Rhodobacter sphaeroides adenosine 5'-diphosphate-(ADP)-glucose pyrophosphorylase (ADPGlc PPase) using affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE). In these binding studies, the capillary is initially injected with a plug of sample containing ADPGlc PPase and noninteracting standards. The sample is then subjected to increasing concentrations of F6P or ATP in the running buffer and electrophoresed. Analysis of the change in the migration times of ADPGlc PPase, relative to those of the noninteracting standards, as a function of the varying concentration of F6P or ATP yields a binding constant. The values obtained were in good agreement with kinetic parameters obtained from steady state activity assays. The method was extended to examine the F6P binding constants for the R33A and R22A enzymes and the ATP binding constants for the R8A enzyme in the presence and absence of F6P. The R33A enzyme has been shown by activity assays to be insensitive to F6P activation, indicating a defect in binding or in downstream transmission of the allosteric signal required for full activation. ACE indicated no apparent binding of F6P, supporting the former hypothesis. The R22A enzyme was shown by activity assays to have a approximately 15-fold decrease in apparent affinity for F6P compared to that of WT while ACE indicated an affinity comparable to that of WT; potential reasons for this discrepancy are discussed. The R8A enzyme as measured by activity assays exhibits reduced fold-activation by F6P compared to that of WT but increased apparent affinity for ATP in the presence of F6P. The ACE results were in good agreement with the activity assay data, confirming the increased affinity for ATP in the presence of F6P. This method demonstrates the quantitative ability of ACE to study different binding sites/ligand interactions in allosteric enzymes.     

Direct photoaffinity labeling of the catalytic site of mouse ribonucleotide reductase by CDP

Ribonucleotide reductase reduces all four ribonucleoside diphosphates to the deoxyribonucleotides required for DNA synthesis. The enzyme is composed of two nonidentical subunits, M1 and M2. The 89-kilodalton M1 subunit contains at least two allosteric sites which, by binding nucleotide effectors, regulate the catalytic activity and substrate specificity of the enzyme. We now show that in addition, protein M1 contains a substrate-binding (catalytic) site which is specifically photolabeled after UV irradiation in the presence of the natural substrate, [32P]CDP. The photolabeling of protein M1 by [32P]CDP required the presence of the second subunit, protein M2, and ATP, the positive allosteric effector for CDP reduction. The negative effectors, dATP, dGTP, and dTTP, inhibited the photolabeling of wild type protein M1. Deoxy-ATP did not inhibit the labeling of a mutant protein M1 that is resistant to feedback inhibition by dATP. In addition, hydroxyurea and 4-methyl-5-aminoisoquinoline thiosemicarbazone, two inhibitors of ribonucleotide reductase which affect protein M2, also inhibited the [32P]CDP labeling of protein M1. These data provide new insights into the role and interaction of the two ribonucleotide reductase subunits, proteins M1 and M2, and the mechanism of action of the allosteric effectors.     

An active ribonucleotide reductase from Arabidopsis thaliana cloning, expression and characterization of the large subunit.

In all living organisms, deoxyribonucleotides, the DNA precursors, are produced by reduction of the corresponding ribonucleotides catalyzed by ribonucleotide reductase. In mammals as in Escherichia coli, the enzyme consists of two proteins. Protein R1 is the proper reductase as it contains, in the substrate binding site, the reducing active cysteine pair. Protein R2 provides a catalytically essential organic radical. Here we report the cloning, expression, purification and characterization of protein R1 from Arabidopsis thaliana. Expression in E. coli was made possible by coexpression of tRNAArg4 which is required for the utilization of AGA and AGG as codons for arginines. Protein R1 shows extensive similarities with protein R1 from mammals: (a) it shows 69% amino-acid sequence identity to human and mouse R1 protein; (b) it is active during CDP reduction by dithiothreitol, in the presence of protein R2 [Sauge-Merle, S., Laulhère, J.-P., Coves, J., Ménage, S., Le Pape, L. & Fontecave, M. (1997) J. Biol. Inorg. Chem. 2, 586-594]; (c) activity is stimulated by thioredoxin and ATP and is inhibited by dATP, showing that as in the mammalian enzyme, the plant ribonucleotide reductase seems to be allosterically regulated by positive (ATP) and negative (dATP) effectors.     

Studies on the allosteric nature of acetate kinase from Bacillus stearothermophilus.

Fructose 1,6-bisphosphate (FBP) stimulates the reaction of Bacillus stearothermophilus acetate kinase (AK). FBP changes the reaction curve for ATP from a sigmoidal type to a Michaelis-Menten one. The binding of FBP to AK was studied by an equilibrium dialysis method and by measuring changes in fluorescence. The extent of binding of FBP to the enzyme paralleled its activation. In addition, the binding constant for FBP increased in the presence of substrate, ATP. These results suggest that FBP is an allosteric activator of B. stearothermophilus AK. Only two moles of FBP bound to this tetrameric enzyme. No cooperativity was found for the binding of FBP. These observations support the previous conclusion, that a set of two subunits in the tetramer is a unit of the enzymatic function. A model is presented to interpret the sigmoidal kinetics for ATP, the absence of cooperativity for FBP binding, and the allosteric activation by FBP of this enzyme. The kinetic properties of the enzyme can be explained quantitatively by this model.