Ex vivo analysis of synergistic anion binding to FbpA in Gram-negative bacteria

Ferric binding protein, FbpA, is a member of the transferrin superfamily whose function is to move an essential nutrient, iron, across the periplasm and into the cytosol through formation of a ternary complex containing Fe (3+) and a synergistic anion, X. Here we utilize SUPREX ( stability of unpurified proteins from rates of H/D exchange) to determine the identification and distribution of the synergistic anion in FeFbpA-X species in periplasmic preparations from Gram-negative bacteria. SUPREX is a mass spectrometry-based technique uniquely suited for thermodynamic analyses of protein-ligand complexes in complex biological mixtures such as periplasmic preparations. Model binary mixtures of FeFbpA-Cit and FeFbpA-PO 4 were initially characterized by SUPREX due to the likely presence of citrate and phosphate ions in the periplasm. Ex vivo SUPREX analyses were performed on FeFbpA-X species overexpressed in an Escherichia coli cell line and on endogenous FeFbpA-X species in Neisseria gonorrheae. Detected in the E. coli periplasmic extract were two distinct populations of FbpA, including one in which the protein was unliganded (i.e., apoFbpA) and one in which the protein was bound to iron and the synergistic anion, phosphate (i.e., FeFbpA-PO 4). FeFbpA-PO 4 was the only population of FbpA molecules detected in the N. gonorrheae periplasmic extract. This work provides the first determination of the identity of the in vivo anion bound to FeFbpA-X in the periplasm and substantiates the hypothesis that the synergistic anion plays a structural and functional role in FbpA-mediated transport of iron across the periplasm and into the cytosol.     

In vivo interaction of the Escherichia coli integration host factor with its specific binding sites.

The histone-like protein integration host factor (IHF) of Escherichia coli binds to specific binding sites on the chromosome or on mobile genetic elements, and is involved in many cellular processes. We have analyzed the interaction of IHF with five different binding sites in vitro and in vivo using UV laser footprinting, a technique that probes the immediate environment and conformation of a segment of DNA. Using this generally applicable technique we can directly compare the binding modes and interaction strengths of a DNA binding protein in its physiological environment within the cell to measurements performed in vitro. We conclude that the interactions between IHF and its specific binding sites are identical in vitro and in vivo. The footprinting signal is consistent with the model of IHF-binding to DNA proposed by Yang and Nash (1989). The occupancy of binding sites varies with the concentration of IHF in the cell and allows to estimate the concentration of free IHF protein in the cell.     

Correlation of levels of folded recombinant p53 in escherichia coli with thermodynamic stability in vitro

The amount of folded functional protein in a cell is controlled by a number of factors, including the relative rates of its biosynthetic and specific degradation processes, and its intrinsic thermodynamic stability. Mutation-induced loss of stability is a common cause of disease. Many oncogenic mutants of the tumour suppressor p53, for example, reduce the intrinsic thermodynamic stability of the protein in vitro. We have analysed the level of recombinant folded human p53 core domain (p53C) and its mutants in Escherichia coli spanning a stability range of 6 kcal/mol to assess the effects of intrinsic thermodynamic stability in vivo in the absence of specific ubiquitin-mediated pathways in human cells. The levels of folded protein were measured fluorimetrically in living cells by fusing the gene of p53C upstream to that of green fluorescent protein and measuring the fluorescence relative to a control at various temperatures. At a fixed temperature, the amount of fluorescence is correlated with the thermodynamic stability of the mutant. The level of each protein varied with temperature according to a sigmoid curve that paralleled the melting in vitro, but the apparent T(m) was lower in vivo, because steady-state levels are observed rather than true thermodynamic equilibria. Our results show clearly that changes in the intrinsic thermodynamic stability of p53 reduce the level of folded and hence functional p53 substantially in E. coli, and provide insights into the correlation between protein instability and disease at the cellular level.     

Towards characterization of DNA structure under physiological conditions in vivo at the single-molecule level using single-pair FRET

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) under in vivo conditions is a well-established technique for the evaluation of populations of protein bound/unbound nucleic acid (NA) molecules or NA hybridization kinetics. However, in vivo FRET has not been applied to in vivo quantitative conformational analysis of NA thus far. Here we explored parameters critical for characterization of NA structure using single-pair (sp)FRET in the complex cellular environment of a living Escherichia coli cell. Our measurements showed that the fluorophore properties in the cellular environment differed from those acquired under in vitro conditions. The precision for the interprobe distance determination from FRET efficiency values acquired in vivo was found lower (～31%) compared to that acquired in diluted buffers (13%). Our numerical simulations suggest that despite its low precision, the in-cell FRET measurements can be successfully applied to discriminate among various structural models. The main advantage of the in-cell spFRET setup presented here over other established techniques allowing conformational analysis in vivo is that it allows investigation of NA structure in various cell types and in a native cellular environment, which is not disturbed by either introduced bulk NA or by the use of chemical transfectants.     

Purification and characterization of the DNA-binding protein Ner of bacteriophage Mu

The construction is described of a plasmid (pL-ner) which directs the high-level production of the bacteriophage Mu Ner protein in Escherichia coli. The protein, recovered in the soluble cellular fraction, was susceptible to in vivo proteolytic processing, in many host strains, but not in E. coli B, a natural lon- prototroph. A simple purification method is described which takes advantage of the basic nature of the protein. The purified protein was shown to be physically and chemically homogeneous and to have an amino acid sequence identical to that predicted for the authentic protein. The protein was also shown to have in vitro biological activity, as measured by specific binding to a DNA fragment containing the consensus Ner-binding sequence, and in vivo biological activity as the protein produced by the pL-ner plasmid allowed lysogenic-like maintenance of a Mu prophage c mutant unable to synthesise a functional Mu repressor.     

SUPREX (Stability of Unpurified Proteins from Rates of H/D Exchange) analysis of the thermodynamics of synergistic anion binding by ferric-binding protein (FbpA), a bacterial transferrin

SUPREX (stability of unpurified proteins from rates of H/D exchange) is a H/D exchange- and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)-based technique for characterizing the equilibrium unfolding/refolding properties of proteins and protein-ligand complexes. Here, we describe the application of SUPREX to the thermodynamic analysis of synergistic anion binding to iron-loaded ferric-binding protein (Fe(3+)FbpA-X, X = synergistic anion). The in vivo function of FbpA is to transport unchelated Fe(3+) across the periplasmic space of certain Gram-negative bacteria, a process that requires simultaneous binding of a synergistic anion. Our results indicate that Fe(3+)FbpA-X is not a so-called "ideal" protein system for SUPREX analyses because it does not exhibit two-state folding properties and it does not exhibit EX2 H/D exchange behavior. However, despite these nonideal properties of the Fe(3+)FbpA-X protein-folding/unfolding reaction, we demonstrate that the SUPREX technique is still amenable to the quantitative thermodynamic analysis of synergistic anion binding to Fe(3+)FbpA. As part of this work, the SUPREX technique was used to evaluate the DeltaDeltaG(f) values of four synergistic anion-containing complexes of Fe(3+)FbpA (i.e., Fe(3+)FbpA-PO(4), Fe(3+)FbpA-citrate, Fe(3+)FbpA-AsO(4), and Fe(3+)FbpA-SO(4)). The DeltaDeltaG(f) value obtained for Fe(3+)FbpA-citrate relative to Fe(3+)FbpA-PO(4) (1.45 +/- 0.44 kcal/mol), is in good agreement with that reported previously (1.98 kcal/mol). The value obtained for Fe(3+)FbpA-AsO(4) (0.58 +/- 0.45 kcal/mol) was also consistent with that reported previously (0.68 kcal/mol), but the measurement error is very close to the magnitude of the value. This work (i) demonstrates the utility of the SUPREX method for studying anion binding by FbpA, (ii) provides the first evaluation of a DeltaDeltaG(f) value for Fe(3+)FbpA-SO(4), -1.43 +/- 0.17 kcal/mol, and (iii) helps substantiate our hypothesis that the synergistic anion plays a role in controlling the lability of iron bound to FbpA in the transport process.     

S. aureus MscL is a pentamer in vivo but of variable stoichiometries in vitro: implications for detergent-solubilized membrane proteins

While the bacterial mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) is the best studied biological mechanosensor and serves as a paradigm for how a protein can sense and respond to membrane tension, the simple matter of its oligomeric state has led to debate, with models ranging from tetramers to hexamers. Indeed, two different oligomeric states of the bacterial mechanosensitive channel MscL have been resolved by X-ray crystallography: The M. tuberculosis channel (MtMscL) is a pentamer, while the S. aureus protein (SaMscL) forms a tetramer. Because several studies suggest that, like MtMscL, the E. coli MscL (EcoMscL) is a pentamer, we re-investigated the oligomeric state of SaMscL. To determine the structural organization of MscL in the cell membrane we developed a disulfide-trapping approach. Surprisingly, we found that virtually all SaMscL channels in vivo are pentameric, indicating this as the physiologically relevant and functional oligomeric state. Complementing our in vivo results, we purified SaMscL and assessed its oligomeric state using three independent approaches (sedimentation equilibrium centrifugation, crosslinking, and light scattering) and established that SaMscL is a pentamer when solubilized in Triton X-100 and C(8)E(5) detergents. However, performing similar experiments on SaMscL solubilized in LDAO, the detergent used in the crystallographic study, confirmed the tetrameric oligomerization resolved by X-ray crystallography. We further demonstrate that this stoichiometric shift is reversible by conventional detergent exchange experiments. Our results firmly establish the pentameric organization of SaMscL in vivo. Furthermore they demonstrate that detergents can alter the subunit stoichiometry of membrane protein complexes in vitro; thus, in vivo assays are necessary to firmly establish a membrane protein's true functionally relevant oligomeric state.     

Thermodynamic stability measurements on multimeric proteins using a new H/D exchange- and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry-based method

We recently reported on a new H/D exchange- and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry-based technique, termed SUPREX, that removes several important limitations associated with measuring the thermodynamic stability of proteins. In contrast to conventional spectroscopy-based techniques for characterizing the equilibrium unfolding behavior of proteins, SUPREX is amenable to the thermodynamic analysis of both purified and unpurified proteins using mg to ng quantities of material. Here we report on the application of SUPREX to the analysis of multimeric protein systems. Included in this work are the SUPREX results we obtained in studies on six model multimeric proteins including the GCN4p1 dimer, the coil-V(a)L(d) trimer, the 4-oxalocrotonate tautomerase (4-OT) hexamer, the Trp repressor (TrpR) dimer, the Arc repressor (ArcR) dimer, and an ArcR mutant (the (DOA20)ArcR) dimer which contained two destabilizing mutations including an Asp to Ala mutation at position 20 and an amide to ester bond mutation between amino acid (aa) residues 19 and 20. As part of the work described here, we present a new method for the analysis of SUPREX data that is generally applicable to both monomeric and multimeric protein systems. Our results on the model proteins in this study indicate that this new method can be used to determine folding free energies for proteins with the accuracy and precision of conventional spectroscopy-based methods.     

Histone-DNA binding free energy cannot be measured in dilution-driven dissociation experiments

Despite decades of study on nucleosomes, there has been no experimental determination of the free energy of association between histones and DNA. Instead, only the relative free energy of association of the histone octamer for differing DNA sequences has been available. Recently, a method was developed based on quantitative analysis of nucleosome dissociation in dilution experiments that provides a simple practical measure of nucleosome stability. Solution conditions were found in which nucleosome dissociation driven by dilution fit well to a simple model involving a noncooperative nucleosome assembly/disassembly equilibrium, suggesting that this approach might allow absolute equilibrium affinity of the histone octamer for DNA to be measured. Here, we show that the nucleosome assembly/disassembly process is not strictly reversible in these solution conditions, implying that equilibrium affinities cannot be obtained from these measurements. Increases in [NaCl] or temperature, commonly employed to suppress kinetic bottlenecks in nucleosome assembly, lead to cooperative behavior that cannot be interpreted with the simple assembly/disassembly equilibrium model. We conclude that the dilution experiments provide useful measures of kinetic but not equilibrium stability. Kinetic stability is of practical importance: it may govern nucleosome function in vivo, and it may (but need not) parallel absolute thermodynamic stability.     

A split-ubiquitin-based assay detects the influence of mutations on the conformational stability of the p53 DNA binding domain in vivo

Many mutations in the human tumor suppressor p53 affect the function of the protein by destabilizing the structure of its DNA binding domain. To monitor the effects of those mutations in vivo the stability of the DNA binding domain of p53 and some of its mutants was investigated with the split-ubiquitin (split-Ub) method. The split-Ub-derived in vivo data on the relative stability of the mutants roughly correlate with the quantitative data from in vitro denaturation experiments as reported in the literature. A variation of this assay allows visualizing the difference in stability between the wild-type p53 core and the mutant p53(V143A) by a simple growth assay.     

The hydrophobic core of Escherichia coli thioredoxin shows a high tolerance to nonconservative single amino acid substitutions.

A set of single amino acid substitutions has been constructed at positions Leu42 and Leu78 in the hydrophobic core of Escherichia coli thioredoxin. This protein is required for the in vivo assembly of filamentous bacteriophages such as M13. Almost all the mutants retain this activity regardless of the change in size, hydrophobic nature, or charge of the substitution. Determination of the free energies of unfolding of the mutants containing charged residues shows that these are significantly destabilized as would be expected from simple considerations of the hydrophobic effect. Thioredoxin therefore represents a class of proteins where the often observed correlation between a particular biological activity and thermodynamic stability is not evident for single mutants in the all-or-none assay used. Native thioredoxin is very stable. Thus, structurally single mutants may not perturb the folding equilibrium or the dynamic behavior sufficiently for the effects to be sensed in vivo.     

Deciphering the role of the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities of SH3 domains on their aggregation inside bacteria

The formation of insoluble deposits by globular proteins underlies the onset of many human diseases. Recent studies suggest a relationship between the thermodynamic stability of proteins and their in vivo aggregation. However, it has been argued that, in the cell, the occurrence of irreversible aggregation might shift the system from equilibrium, in such a way that it could be the rate of unfolding and associated kinetic stability instead of the conformational stability that controls protein deposition. This is an important but difficult to decipher question, because kinetic and thermodynamic stabilities appear usually correlated. Here we address this issue by comparing the in vitro folding kinetics and stability features of a set of non-natural SH3 domains with their aggregation properties when expressed in bacteria. In addition, we compare the in vitro stability of the isolated domains with their effective stability in conditions that mimic the cytosolic environment. Overall, the data argue in favor of a thermodynamic rather than a kinetic control of the intracellular aggregation propensities of small globular proteins in which folding and unfolding velocities largely exceed aggregation rates. These results have implications regarding the evolution of proteins.     

Polytopic membrane protein folding and assembly in vitro and in vivo

The insertion and folding of proteins in biological membranes during protein synthesis in vivo is fundamental to membrane biogenesis. At present, however, certain molecular aspects of this process can only be understood by complementary studies in vitro. We bring together in vitro and in vivo results, highlighting how the studies inform each other and increase our knowledge of the folding and assembly of polytopic membrane proteins. A notable recent advance is the high-resolution crystal structure of the protein machinery responsible for membrane protein insertion into the endoplasmic reticulum. This provides an opportunity to combine in vitro and in vivo studies at a more sophisticated level and address mechanistic aspects of polytopic protein insertion and folding. Quality control is another important aspect of membrane biogenesis, and we give an overview of the current understanding of this process, focusing on cystic fibrosis as a well-studied paradigm. Mutations in the associated membrane protein, the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), can cause the quality control mechanisms to prevent the mutant protein reaching its normal site of action, the cell surface. In vitro studies of CFTR shed light on the possible origins of other clinically relevant folding mutants and highlight the potential synergy between in vitro and in vivo approaches.     

Fluorescence-detected circular dichroism of ethidium in vivo and bound to deoxyribonucleic acid in vitro

Fluorescence-detected circular dichroism (FDCD) spectra are reported for ethidium in Escherichia coli cells and bound to E. coli DNA in vitro. FDCD bands are observed at 325 and 385 nm. These bands change amplitude as the ethidium to DNA ratio changes. Spectra are similar for in vivo and in vitro measurements. However, the bands at 325 and 385 nm disappear when ethidium binds to macromolecules without intercalating between base pairs. The results demonstrate that FDCD spectra can be measured in cell suspensions and indicate that ethidium binds to nucleic acids in E. coli cells by intercalation.     

Indole transport across Escherichia coli membranes

Indole has many, diverse roles in bacterial signaling. It regulates the transition from exponential to stationary phase, it is involved in the control of plasmid stability, and it influences biofilm formation, virulence, and stress responses (including antibiotic resistance). Its role is not restricted to bacteria, and recently it has been shown to include mutually beneficial signaling between enteric bacteria and their mammalian hosts. In many respects indole behaves like the signaling component of a quorum-sensing system. Indole synthesized within the producer bacterium is exported into the surroundings where its accumulation is detected by sensitive cells. A view often repeated in the literature is that in Escherichia coli the AcrEF-TolC and Mtr transporter proteins are involved in the export and import, respectively, of indole. However, the evidence for their involvement is indirect, and it has been known for a long time that indole can pass directly through a lipid bilayer. We have combined in vivo and in vitro approaches to examine the relative importance of protein-mediated transport and direct passage across the E. coli membrane. We conclude that the movement of indole across the E. coli membrane under normal physiological conditions is independent of AcrEF-TolC and Mtr. Furthermore, direct observation of individual liposomes shows that indole can rapidly cross an E. coli lipid membrane without the aid of any proteinaceous transporter. These observations not only enhance our understanding of indole signaling in bacteria but also provide a simple explanation for the ability of indole to signal between biological kingdoms.     

Creating a completely “cell‐free” system for protein synthesis

Cell‐free protein synthesis is a promising tool to take biotechnology outside of the cell. A cell‐free approach provides distinct advantages over in vivo systems including open access to the reaction environment and direct control over all chemical components for facile optimization and synthetic biology integration. Promising applications of cell‐free systems include portable diagnostics, biotherapeutics expression, rational protein engineering, and biocatalyst production. The highest yielding and most economical cell‐free systems use an extract composed of the soluble component of lysed Escherichia coli. Although E. coli lysis can be highly efficient (>99.999%), one persistent challenge is that the extract remains contaminated with up to millions of cells per mL. In this work, we examine the potential of multiple decontamination strategies to further reduce or eliminate bacteria in cell‐free systems. Two strategies, sterile filtration and lyophilization, effectively eliminate contaminating cells while maintaining the systems’ protein synthesis capabilities. Lyophilization provides the additional benefit of long‐term stability at storage above freezing. Technologies for personalized, portable medicine and diagnostics can be expanded based on these foundational sterilized and completely “cell‐free” systems. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 31:1716–1719, 2015     

A DEAD-box RNA helicase promotes thermodynamic equilibration of kinetically trapped RNA structures in vivo

RNAs must assemble into specific structures in order to carry out their biological functions, but in vitro RNA folding reactions produce multiple misfolded structures that fail to exchange with functional structures on biological time scales. We used carefully designed self-cleaving mRNAs that assemble through well-defined folding pathways to identify factors that differentiate intracellular and in vitro folding reactions. Our previous work showed that simple base-paired RNA helices form and dissociate with the same rate and equilibrium constants in vivo and in vitro. However, exchange between adjacent secondary structures occurs much faster in vivo, enabling RNAs to quickly adopt structures with the lowest free energy. We have now used this approach to probe the effects of an extensively characterized DEAD-box RNA helicase, Mss116p, on a series of well-defined RNA folding steps in yeast. Mss116p overexpression had no detectable effect on helix formation or dissociation kinetics or on the stability of interdomain tertiary interactions, consistent with previous evidence that intracellular factors do not affect these folding parameters. However, Mss116p overexpression did accelerate exchange between adjacent helices. The nonprocessive nature of RNA duplex unwinding by DEAD-box RNA helicases is consistent with a branch migration mechanism in which Mss116p lowers barriers to exchange between otherwise stable helices by the melting and annealing of one or two base pairs at interhelical junctions. These results suggest that the helicase activity of DEAD-box proteins like Mss116p distinguish intracellular RNA folding pathways from nonproductive RNA folding reactions in vitro and allow RNA structures to overcome kinetic barriers to thermodynamic equilibration in vivo.     

Outsider to insider: resetting the natural host niche of commensal E. coli K-12

The status of E. coli K-12 as an exclusively non-invasive, non-pathogenic bacterium has almost been incontrovertible. Our recent finding that a mutation in one of its main architectural protein, HU, converts E. coli K-12 to an actively invasive form suggests that gaining host cell entry might be an expedient survival tactic for traditional commensals during certain altered host conditions. The mutant E. coli (SK3842) exhibits properties usually associated with pathogenic bacteria: host cell invasion, phagosomal disruption and intracellular replication. However, unlike the situation with some pathogens, internalized SK3842 imparts anti-apoptotic and cyto-protective effects rather than lethality on the host cell, both in vitro and in vivo. Here, we show that SK3842 also provides colonization resistance against other invasive pathogens--a trait not shared by the parental commensal strain. Thus, the altered lifestyle of SK3842 encompasses characteristics both from traditional pathogens as well as beneficial probiotic strains.