Sex differences in the regulation of embryonic brain aromatase

Oestrogen formed from androgen by aromatization plays a critical role in the sexual differentiation of the male brain and behaviour. A question which has still to be answered is what regulates the gender-specific changes in aromatase activity forming oestrogen during sensitive periods of brain growth. Using a primary cell culture technique and sexed embryos, we have shown that in the fetal mouse brain, oestrogen formation in the male is neuronal rather than glial and aromatase activity is regionally localized, being higher in the hypothalamus than in the cortex. The aromatase activity measured from cells in culture has the same enzyme binding affinity (apparent K_m 40 nM) as intact brain samples. Neurones developing in the embryonic male brain (embryonic day (ED) 15) contain higher aromatase activity (V_max, 895 fmol/h/mg protein) than the female (V_max, 604). Although a sex difference exists at early stages of embryonic development (ED 13), the embryonic aromatase system is regulated by steroids later in fetal development. The developing aromatase-containing neuroblasts probably form processes which connect to other aromatase neurones. Immunoreactive staining with an aromatase polyclonal antibody identifies an increase in numbers of aromatase-immunoreactive hypothalamic neuronal cell bodies following testosterone treatment. Testosterone treatment also causes both stimulation of neurite growth and branching as well as functional maturation of aromatase neurones. In particular, there is an increase in aromatase activity per neurone as well as a dramatic increase in the number of neurones expressing the enzyme. Both the functional and morphological changes depend on androgen receptor stimulation for several days in vitro. This conclusion is supported by colocalization studies which reveal a high number of fetal hypothalamic aromatase neurones co-expressing androgen receptor. We conclude that testosterone influences the growth of male hypothalamic neurones containing aromatase at a sensitive period of brain development. Endogenous steroid inhibitors of aromatase, probably formed within the neuroglia, also play a role in the control of oestrogen production. An endogenous 5-reduced metabolite of testosterone, 5-androstanedione, is almost as potent in inhibiting neuronal hypothalamic aromatase activity (K_i = 23 nM) as the synthetic non-steroidal inhibitors such as the imidazole, fadrozole, and the triazoles, arimidex and letrozole. It is clear that the oestrogen-forming capacity of the male hypothalamus has the special characteristics and plasticity of regulation which could affect brain differentiation at specific steroid-sensitive stages in ontogeny.     

Regulation of sex-specific formation of oestrogen in brain development: Endogenous inhibitors of aromatase

Brain sexual differentiation occurs during steroid-sensitive phases in early development, and is affected particularly by exposure to oestrogens formed in the brain by aromatisation of androgen. The organisational effects of oestrogen result in male-specific neuronal morphology, control of reproductive behaviour, and patterns of gonadotrophin secretion. A question which still has to be resolved is what determines changes in aromatase activity effective for the differentiation of sexually dimorphic brain development during sensitive periods of growth. In the mouse, a sex difference exists at early stages of embryonic development in aromatase-containing neurones of the hypothalamus. The embryonic aromatase system is regulated later in foetal development by androgens. Testosterone treatment increases the numbers of aromatase-immunoreactive hypothalamic neuronal cell bodies. Kinetic evidence from studies on the avian brain suggest that endogenous steroid inhibitors of aromatase, probably formed within neuroglia, also have a role in the control of oestrogen production. Inhibitory kinetic constant determination of endogenous androgenic metabolites formed in the brain showed that preoptic aromatase is potently inhibited by 5-androstanedione (K_i = 6 nM) and less strongly by 5β-dihydrotestosterone (K_i = 350 nM). Regulation by steroidal and possibly non-steroidal inhibitors may contribute to the special characteristics and plasticity in aromatase activity which develops at certain stages in ontogeny.     

Sexual dimorphism in the developmental regulation of brain aromatase

Steroid sex hormones have an organizational role in gender-specific brain development. Aromatase (cytochrome P450_AR), converting testosterone (T) to estradiol-17β (E₂) is a key enzyme in brain development and the regulation of aromatase determines the availability of E₂ effective for neural differentiation. Gender differences in brain development and behaviour are likely to be influenced by E₂ acting during sensitive periods. This differentiating action has been demonstrated in rodent and avian species, but also probably occurs in primates including humans. In rodents, E₂ is formed in various hypothalamic areas of the brain during fetal and postnatal development. The question considered here is whether hypothalamic aromatase activity is gender-specific during sensitive phases of behavioural and brain development, and when these sensitive phases occur. In vitro preoptic and limbic aromatase activity has been measured in two strains of wild mice, genetically selected for behavioural aggression based on attack latency, and in the BALB/c mouse. Short attack latency males show a different developmental pattern of aromatase activity in hypothalamus and amygdala to long attack latency males. Using primary brain cell cultures of the BALB/c mouse, sex differences in hypothalamic aromatase activity during both early embryonic and later perinatal development can be demonstrated, with higher E₂ formation in males. The sex dimorphisms are brain region specific, since no differences between male and female are detectable in cultured cortical cells. Immunoreactive staining with a polyclonal aromatase antibody identifies a neuronal rather than an astroglial localization of the enzyme. T increases fetal brain aromatase activity and numbers of aromatase-immunoreactive hypothalamic neuronal cell bodies. T appears to influence the growth of hypothalamic neurons containing aromatase. Differentiation of sexually dimorphic brain mechanisms may involve maturation of a gender-specific network of estrogen-forming neurons which are steroid-sensitive in early development.     

Brain formation of oestrogen in the mouse: Sex dimorphism in aromatase development

Steroid sex hormones have an organizational role in gender-specific brain development. Aromatase, converting testosterone (T) to oestradiol-17β (E₂), is a key enzyme in the brain and regulation of this enzyme is likely to determine availability of E₂ effective for neural differentiation. In rodents, oestrogens are formed very actively during male perinatal brain development. This paper reviews work on the sexual differentiation of the brain aromatase system in vitro. Embryonic day 15 mouse hypothalamic culture aromatase activity (AA: mean V_max = 0.9 pmol/h/mg protein) is several times greater than in the adult, whereas apparent K_m is similar for both (30–40 nM). Using microdissected brain areas and cultured cells of the mouse, sex differences in hypothalamic AA during both early embryonic and later perinatal development can be demonstrated, with higher E₂ formation in the male than in the female. The sex differences are brain region-specific, since no differences between male and female are detectable in cultured cortical cells. AA quantitation and immunoreactive staining with an aromatase polyclonal antibody both identify neuronal rather than astroglial localizations of the enzyme. Kainic acid eliminates the gender difference in hypothalamic oestrogen formation indicating, furthermore, that this sex dimorphism is neuronal. Gender-specific aromatase regulation is regional in the brain. Oestrogen formation is specifically induced in cultured hypothalamic neurones of either sex by T, since androgen has no effect on cortical cells. Androgen is clearly involved in the growth of hypothalamic neurones containing aromatase. It appears that differentiation of the brain involves maturation of a gender-specific network of oestrogen-forming neurones.     

Dexamethasone treatment increases neuropeptide Y levels in rat hypothalamic neurones

Immunoreactive glucocorticoid receptors (GR) have previously been demonstrated in neuropeptide Y (NPY) neurones of the rat hypothalamus. To determine whether NPY synthesis is influenced by glucocorticoids, the effect of dexamethasone (DEX) on the levels of immunoreactive NPY in rat hypothalamic neurones was investigated in vivo and in vitro. Daily injections of DEX (0.1 mg/day) for 5 days increased the NPY content of the mediobasal hypothalamus in female rats by 117% (p less than 0.002). Primary cultures of hypothalamic neurones were also sensitive to the effect of glucocorticoids. Intracellular NPY levels were significantly increased (p less than 0.001) compared to control values by 151%, 222% and 268% when cultures were maintained in a defined serum free medium containing DEX 10(-9), 10(-8) and 10(-7) M respectively.     

Is androgen-dependent aromatase activity sexually differentiated in the rat and dove preoptic area?

Aromatase activity is higher in the male than in the female anterior hypothalamic-preoptic area (POA) in both the avian and the rodent adult brain. This sex difference is abolished after castration of the male and restored by androgen treatment. Gonadectomy has no effect on POA aromatase in the female. The aim of this study was to find out whether sex dimorphism in adult POA aromatase is only due to a sex difference in circulating gonadal hormones or dependent upon sexual differentiation of the brain. Aromatase activity was measured in vitro in microdissected POA samples using a sensitive radiometric assay. We examined the effects of gonadectomy and testosterone treatment on enzyme activity in adult rats and doves of both sexes. We also studied the effects of neonatal gonadectomy and hormone substitution in male and female rats. The results suggest that levels of POA aromatase in the adult depend primarily on gonadal activity, but that mechanisms involved in the regulation of aromatase activity and enzyme induction may be sex-specific and could result from sexual differentiation of the brain in early life. Further work will be required to determine the developmental stage when this occurs and the exact mechanism(s) responsible for increased sensitivity of the adult male POA to the inductive effect of testosterone.     

Is androgen-dependent aromatase activity sexually differentiated in the rat and dove preoptic area?

Aromatase activity is higher in the male than in the female anterior hypothalamic-preoptic area (POA) in both the avian and the rodent adult brain. This sex difference is abolished after castration of the male and restored by androgen treatment. Gonadectomy has no effect on POA aromatase in the female. The aim of this study was to find out whether sex dimorphism in adult POA aromatase is only due to a sex difference in circulating gonadal hormones or dependent upon sexual differentiation of the brain. Aromatase activity was measured in vitro in microdissected POA samples using a sensitive radiometric assay. We examined the effects of gonadectomy and testosterone treatment on enzyme activity in adult rats and doves of both sexes. We also studied the effects of neonatal gonadectomy and hormone substitution in male and female rats. The results suggest that levels of POA aromatase in the adult depend primarily on gonadal activity, but that mechanisms involved in the regulation of aromatase and enzyme induction may be sex-specific and could result from sexual differentiation of the brain in early life. Further work will be required to determine the developmental stage when this occurs and the exact mechanism(s) responsible for increased sensitivity of the adult male POA to the inductive effect of testosterone.     

Steroid control of sexual behavior and brain aromatase in the dove: effects of nonaromatizable androgens, methyltrienolone (R1881), and 5 alpha-dihydrotestosterone

This study examines the effects of nonaromatizable androgens, methyltrienolone (R1881) and 5 alpha-dihydrotestosterone (DHT) on aggressive courtship and vocal behavior in the male ring dove. Since androgens may influence behavior by increasing the formation of estrogen in the brain, the effects of R1881 and DHT on brain aromatase activity were also studied using an in vitro microassay. Under conditions in which testosterone induced aggressive courtship patterns, the nonaromatizable androgens were ineffective. But DHT and R1881 induced vocal behavior with equal efficiency, indicating that androgens can influence mechanisms of vocal behavior without conversion to estrogens. The behavioral effectiveness of both hormones was reduced (approximately 50%) when the period between castration and treatment was doubled. Testosterone propionate increased formation of E2 from 3H-testosterone in both the preoptic (POA) and anterior hypothalamic areas. Neither of the nonaromatizable androgens affected POA aromatase activity. The results suggest that only the aromatizable androgen, testosterone, which is also required specifically for male courtship, increases preoptic formation of estrogen.     

The effect of PGE2 on activity and thermosensitivity of hypothalamic neurones in rat brain slices.

Using brain slices the effect of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) on neurones from different locations of the rat hypothalamus was analysed. PGE2 (150 ng), when injected into the perfusion chamber, influences all hypothalamic neurones studied. The pattern of firing rate changes after PGE2 is variable, but the depressive effect predominates--72% of neurones decrease their firing rate in long-term experiments. PGE2 also lowers the thermosensitivity of warm sensitive neurones and increases the thermosensitivity of temperature insensitive neurones.     

In vitro potency and selectivity of the non-steroidal androgen aromatase inhibitor CGS 16949A compared to steroidal inhibitors in the brain.

A sensitive in vitro 3H2O microassay for aromatase activity was used to evaluate the potency and selectivity of three aromatase inhibitors in mammalian (gerbil) and avian (ring dove) hypothalamus. The steroidal inhibitors, 1,4,6-androstatrien-3,17-dione (ATD) and 4-hydroxy-androstenedione (4-OH-A) were compared with a new non-steroidal imidazole inhibitor, CGS 16949A [4-(5,6,7,8-tetrahydroimidazo-[1,5-a]-pyridin-5-yl)benzonitrile HCl]. Adult male dove hypothalamic aromatase is highly active [Vmax = 5.3 pmol testosterone (T) converted/h/mg protein], has high substrate binding affinity (Km = 4.0 nM), and direct involvement in control of sexual behaviour. With [1 beta-3H]T or [1 beta-3H]A as substrate, male dove preoptic aromatase activity was inhibited more effectively and selectively by CGS 16949A. Thus, Kis and IC50s for aromatization were approximately 50 times lower for the non-steroidal inhibitor, and inhibition of the other major androgen-metabolizing enzymes (5 alpha/beta-reductase) occurred at concentrations at least one order of magnitude greater than for ATD and 4-OH-A. Neonatal male gerbil hypothalamic aromatase activity (Vmax = 1.3 pmol T converted/h/mg protein) was lower than in the dove. Aromatase inhibition by CGS 16949A is more potent in the neonatal gerbil than in the dove (Kis of 0.03 and 0.60 nM, respectively, with A as substrate). We conclude that the imidazole is an effective aromatase inhibitor in both the adult and developing brain.     

Gender Differences in the Effects of Prenatal Stress on Brain Development and Behaviour

An increased incidence of anxiety, depression and attention deficits in children has been linked to psychological stress during pregnancy. Subjection of a pregnant rat to stress at a time when the foetal limbic and hypothalamic pituitary adrenal (HPA) axes develop results in anxiogenic and depressive behaviour and learning and attention deficits in the offspring, which depend on its gender, intensity and timing of the maternal stress and behaviour being tested. Maternal stress increases corticosterone levels in the foetal brain, decreases foetal testosterone and brain aromatase activity in males, and alters brain catecholamine activity to that in females. Learning deficits, reductions in hippocampal neurogenesis, LTP and dendritic spine density in the prefrontal cortex are more readily seen in prenatally-stressed males, while anxiety, depression and increased response of the HPA axis to stress are more prevalent in females. Genders may differ in the sensitivity of developing brain areas to stress hormones. Special issue dedicated to Dr. Moussa Youdim.     

Changes in aromatase activity in the brain of the male ring dove (Streptopelia risoria) during the breeding cycle

Aromatase activity was measured in striatal and hypothalamic regions of the brain of the male ring dove throughout its breeding cycle. The enzyme activity in the anterior hypothalamus and hyperstriatum was significantly reduced in broody birds. A reduction in plasma LH and the number of spermatogonia per tubule cross-section were also observed at this time. The results support the view that testosterone is involved in the control of aromatase activity in the anterior hypothalamus and hyperstriatum. The enzyme activity in the posterior hypothalamus, paleostriatum and archistriatum showed no changes throughout the breeding cycle, indicating that other factors in addition to testosterone are involved in controlling the enzyme in these tissues.     

Sex differences and androgen-dependent regulation of aromatase (CYP19) mRNA expression in the developing and adult rat brain

Sex differences, androgen dependence and asymmetries of aromatase activity have been reported during ontogeny of the rat. It remains to be elucidated, however, whether the changes in aromatase activity are reflected by similar changes in specific mRNA levels. In addition, very little is known regarding mechanism(s) underlying such differential regulation of aromatase expression. To address these questions, we have employed the in situ hybridization (ISH) technique to examine specific mRNA levels in the brain of both male and female rats at selected stages of development. In prenatal stages of development, at gestational day (GD) 18 and 20, aromatase mRNA was detected in several hypothalamic and limbic brain regions. Semiquantitative analysis of aromatase mRNA did not reveal statistically significant sex differences in any of these regions (except in one experiment at GD20, when a sex difference was found in the medial preoptic nucleus). In contrast, clear sex differences were determined at postnatal day (PN) 2; male animals contained significantly more aromatase mRNA in the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BST) and thesexually dimorphic nucleus of the preoptic area (SDN) compared to female rats. Four days later in development, at PN6, sex differences of aromatase mRNA signals were observed in the BST, but were no longer detectable in the SDN. At PN15 and in adult animals, no sex differences could be determined. The effect of flutamide treatment (50 mg/kg/day) was investigated in GD20 fetuses as well as in adult rats. No statistically significant changes in aromatase mRNA expression were found in either case. In summary, our results suggest that differential regulation of aromatase mRNA expression during the critical period of sexual differentiation might, in part, account for the establishment of some of the many sexually dimorphic parameters of the rat brain. The role of androgens in the regulation of the sex-specific and developmental expression of aromatase mRNA in the rat brain remains to be clarified.     

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) mediates bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) effects on cultured striatal neurones

Bone morphogenetic proteins are members of the transforming growth factor-beta superfamily that have multiple functions in the developing nervous system. One of them, bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2), promotes the differentiation of cultured striatal neurones, enhancing dendrite growth and calbindin-positive phenotype. Bone morphogenetic proteins have been implicated in cooperative interactions with other neurotrophic factors. Here we examined whether the effects of BMP-2 on cultured striatal neurones are mediated or enhanced by other neurotrophic factors. BMP-2 had a cooperative effect with low doses of brain-derived neurotrophic factor or neurotrophin-3 (but not with other neurotrophic factors such as glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor, neurturin or transforming growth factor-beta 2) on the number of calbindin-positive striatal neurones. Moreover, BMP-2 induced phosphorylated Trk immunoreactivity in cultured striatal neurones, suggesting that neurotrophins are involved in BMP-2 neurotrophic effects. The addition of TrkB-IgG or antibodies against brain-derived neurotrophic factor abolished the effects of BMP-2 on the number and degree of differentiation of calbindin-positive striatal neurones. Indeed, BMP-2 treatment increased brain-derived neurotrophic factor protein levels in treated cultures media and BDNF immunocytochemistry revealed that this neurotrophin was produced by neuronal cells. Taken together, these results indicate that brain-derived neurotrophic factor mediates the effects of BMP-2 on striatal neurones.     

Studies on oestrogen-2/4-hydroxylase activity in mammalian brain, using a radioenzymatic assay method

The activity of oestrogen-2/4-hydroxylase in brain tissue was studied using a radioenzymatic assay which controlled for non-specific formation of catechol oestrogen. The ontogeny of enzyme activity in male and female rat brain was examined between 1 and 70 days of age. Until 10 days of age, both sexes showed low enzyme activity. Between days 10 and 15 enzyme activity in the female significantly increased but was unchanged in the male. Male brain enzyme activity increased between days 15 and 20 whereas activity was unchanged in the female. Both males and females showed increases in enzyme activity between 20 and 25 days of age. Thereafter enzyme activity plateaued but at all ages between day 20 and day 70 male brain enzyme activity was significantly greater than in the female. A study of the distribution of the oestrogen-2/4-hydrolase in the sheep hypothalamus revealed that the stalk/median eminence had approx 10 times greater activity than either the anterior, medial or posterior hypothalamus. These findings are discussed in relation to sexual differentiation of the brain.     

Enzymic inactivation of neurotensin by hypothalamic and brain extracts of the rat.

A sensitive and specific radioimmunoassay has been developed to study inactivation of neurotensin by hypothalamic and brain peptidases. Degrading activity of peptidases from both hypothalamus and brain seems to have similar activity. These peptidases are temperature- and time- dependent. Brain and hypothalamic enzymes of particulate fractions can be differentiated on the basis of the pH effects; brain peptidase(s) has (have) maximal activity at pH 7.4 and hypothalamic peptidase(s) displaying a maximal activity at pH 5.8. Kidneys and liver extracts contain enzyme(s) degrading neurotensin.     

Aromatase-immunoreactive cells are present in mouse brain areas that are known to express high levels of aromatase activity

The transformation of testosterone into estradiol in the brain plays a key role in several behavioral and physiological processes, but it has been so far impossible to localize precisely the cells of the mammalian brain containing the relevant enzyme, viz., aromatase. We have recently established an immunohistochemical technique that allows the visualization of aromatase-immunoreactive cells in the quail brain. In this species, a marked increase in the optical density of aromatase-immunoreactive cells is observed in subjects that have been treated with the aromatase inhibitor, R76713 or racemic Vorozole. This increased immunoreactivity, associated with a total blockade of aromatase activity, has been used as a tool in the present study in which the distribution of aromatase-immunoreactive material has been reassessed in the brain of mice pretreated with R76713. As expected, the aromatase inhibitor increases the density of the immunoreactive signal in mice. Strongly immunoreactive cells are found in the lateral septal region, the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, the central amygdala, and the dorso-lateral hypothalamus. A less dense signal is also present in the medial preoptic area, the nucleus accumbens, several hypothalamic nuclei (e.g., paraventricular and ventromedial nuclei), all divisions of the amygdala, and several regions of the cortex, especially the cortex piriformis. These data demonstrate that, contrary to previous claims, aromatase-immunoreactive cells are present in all brain regions that have been shown previously to contain high aromatase activity.     

Co-localization of hypocretin-1 and hypocretin-2 in the cat hypothalamus and brainstem

Hypocretin-1 (hcrt-1) and hypocretin-2 (hcrt-2) are two recently discovered hypothalamic neuropeptides. In the present study, using double immunofluorescent techniques, the co-localization of hcrt-1 and hcrt-2 was examined in neuronal soma and fibers/terminals located, respectively, in the cat hypothalamus and brainstem. In the hypothalamus, all hcrt-1 positive neuronal soma also displayed hcrt-2 immunoreactivity. In the brainstem, both hcrt-1 and hcrt-2 antibodies labeled the same fibers/terminals, indicating that hcrt-1 and hcrt-2 co-localize not only in the neuronal soma (hypothalamus) but also in their fibers/terminals (brainstem). If both peptides are released following neuronal activity, then the distinct effects of these peptides in the brain are likely to depend on the types of postsynaptic receptors that are activated.     

Effect of Testosterone on Neuronal Morphology and Neuritic Growth of Fetal Lamb Hypothalamus-Preoptic Area and Cerebral Cortex in Primary Culture

Testosterone plays an essential role in sexual differentiation of the male sheep brain. The ovine sexually dimorphic nucleus (oSDN), is 2 to 3 times larger in males than in females, and this sex difference is under the control of testosterone. The effect of testosterone on oSDN volume may result from enhanced expansion of soma areas and/or dendritic fields. To test this hypothesis, cells derived from the hypothalamus-preoptic area (HPOA) and cerebral cortex (CTX) of lamb fetuses were grown in primary culture to examine the direct morphological effects of testosterone on these cellular components. We found that within two days of plating, neurons derived from both the HPOA and CTX extend neuritic processes and express androgen receptors and aromatase immunoreactivity. Both treated and control neurites continue to grow and branch with increasing time in culture. Treatment with testosterone (10 nM) for 3 days significantly (P < 0.05) increased both total neurite outgrowth (35%) and soma size (8%) in the HPOA and outgrowth (21%) and number of branch points (33%) in the CTX. These findings indicate that testosterone-induced somal enlargement and neurite outgrowth in fetal lamb neurons may contribute to the development of a fully masculine sheep brain.