Hyaluronidase activity and glycosaminoglycan synthesis in the amputated newt limb: comparison of denervated, nonregenerating limbs with regenerates.

Amputated, regenerating forelimbs have been compared with the contralateral, denervated non-regenerating limb stumps in the adult newt Notophthalmus viridescens, with respect to hyaluronidase activity and the incorporation of ³H-acetate into glycosaminoglycans (GAG). At 10 days after amputation, which is the time of maximum hyaluronate production in the early growing regenerate, incorporation of ³H-acetate into GAG (cpm/mg protein) in the denervated, nonregenerating limb stump was approximately 50% of that in the contralateral regenerating limbs. At this stage, hyaluronate was the major GAG being produced, but the ratio of incorporation into hyaluronate relative to chondroitin sulfate was reduced in the denervated limbs. In intact, nonamputated limbs, the incorporation into GAG was 5% of that in the regenerating limb 10 days after amputation, and 10% of that in the denervated stumps.At 25 days, cartilage is forming and chondroitin sulfate synthesis predominates in the normal regenerate whilst the contralateral, denervated limb stumps are forming scars. GAG synthesis in the latter was less than one-quarter the level seen in the regenerating limbs, mostly due to low incorporation into chondroitin sulfate.Hyaluronidase activity, which appears in the regenerating limb during differentiation of skeletal elements (20–45 days), was not detectable in limbs denervated early enough to prevent regeneration. However, limbs denervated after formation of the blastema will regenerate without nerve, and hyaluronidase activity in such limbs was normal. Thus, hyaluronidase activity appears when regeneration reaches the cartilage deposition stage, with or without nerve.     

Limb regeneration following the discontinuation of growth hormone therapy in the hypophysectomized newt,Notophthalmus viridescens

Untreated adult newts do not undergo normal limb regeneration following hypohysectomy. A fibrocellular dermal barrier (cicatrix) atypically forms between the apical epithelium and the underlying mesenchymal tissues. Historically, continuous administration of growth hormone or of prolactin in combination with thyroxine restored regenerative capacity to these newts. In a previous investigation, we demonstrated that the initial effect of these two hormone treatments, when administered on alternate days to hypophysectomized newts beginning eight days post-amputation, was to facilitate the erosion of the fibrocellular barrier and establish the epithelial mesenchymal interface that is observed in a regenerating limb. The present investigation was designed to evaluate the necessity of continuous hormone therapy to maintain limb regeneration in hypophysectomized newts. One, two, or three injections of growth hormone or of prolactin in combination with thyroxine was administered on successive alternate days to hypophysectomized newts either immediately following limb amputation (ID) or beginning eight days post-amputation (DD). The ID and DD newts receiving one, two, or three injections of growth hormone showed evidence of regeneration to the digitiform stage by day 30 post-amputation, while those receiving prolactin and thyroxine underwent wound healing. While both hormone treatments initially promoted a dermis-free apical epithelium, only hypophysectomized newts that had received growth hormone were able to continue regenerating. We have, therefore, concluded that discontinuous growth hormone therapy is sufficient to initiate and maintain the conducive environment for limb regeneration to advanced stages in the hypophysectomized newt. While initiating this process, prolactin and thyroxine therapy on a discontinuous regime does not maintain regeneration. The direct and indirect role of growth hormone in supporting limb regeneration in normal and hypophysectomized newts is discussed.     

The effect of hypophysectomy upon cholinesterase activity in the forelimbs of regenerating adult Notophthalmus news

In order to study endocrine influence upon cholinesterase activity during regeneration, adult newts were hypophysectomized either prior to limb transection or during regeneration. Homogenates of limb tissues were assayed for cholinesterase activity during each stage of regeneration.In animals with pituitaries intact, cholinesterase activity in regenerating limb tissues decreases soon after amputation, and then it rises to the level of activity in intact limbs of normal animals, during the period of differentiation. In hypophysectomized newts there seems to be no alteration of this basic pattern of activity, but removal of the pituitary does result in more elevated levels of enzymatic activity. In the intact forelimbs of control newts undergoing regeneration, cholinesterase activity greatly increases as the other transected limb begins to regenerate but it returns to normal as regeneration progresses. If these animals are hypophysectomized, no such increase is observed during the early stages of regeneration. Rather, there is an initial decrease in cholinesterase activity that is followed by an increase in such activity.These data are compatible with the hypothesis that the pituitary modulates cholinesterase activity in the limb tissues of adult newts.     

Increased protein kinase C activity in the central nervous system of the newt during limb regeneration.

Protein kinase C (PKC) activity was examined in the CNS of the newt Pleurodeles waltlii undergoing regeneration after limb amputation. In the spinal cord and brain of control newts, the level of PKC activity was virtually the same for the cytosolic and the particulate fractions. At days 7 and 14 after amputation of two limbs, a twofold increase in overall PKC activity occurred in the spinal cord and accounted for increased membrane-bound activity, while cytosolic activity was not significantly impaired. In contrast, overall PKC activity was not affected in brain. However, a twofold increase in the brain particulate fraction occurred at day 14 while cytosolic activity decreased proportionately. Similar alterations were observed in newts undergoing one or multiple limb amputations. Such changes in PKC activity neither occurred in the CNS of newt after limb denervation nor in the CNS of limb amputated frog Rana temporaria, an Amphibian which is unable to regenerate. Taken together, these results provide evidence that PKC of the CNS is involved in the regeneration process of newts. Changes in activation-associated PKC distribution proceeded through different mechanisms: long-lasting increase in membrane bound activity with a net increase of overall activity in the spinal cord, and long-term redistribution of enzyme activity to the particulate fraction in brain.     

Forelimb regeneration in thyroidectomized adult newts following organ culture and autografting of the thyroid glands

Summary Thyroidectomy and organ culture of adult newt thyroid glands three days prior to forelimb amputation was followed by autografting the glands subcutaneously into the animal's lower jaw region 9, 18 or 25 days postamputation (GC^{9, 18, 25} day series). This was an attempt, utilizing 515 animals, to elucidate further the role of the thyroids in regeneration. Amputated limbs of the thyroidectomized (Thx) and autografted muscle explant (MC = sham) cases underwent stumping or were significantly delayed in their regeneration rate and displayed abnormal morphogenesis compared with control regenerates. In the GC⁹ series newts, regenerates were identical to controls 45 days postamputation. However, regenerates of the GC¹⁸ series cases exhibited delayed and abnormal development at 45 days; but they were not as delayed and had fewer abnormalities than those cases in the Thx and MC groups. Results of the GC²⁵ series newts were similar to those of the Thx group. Within 5 days of autografting the thyroids, epidermal moulting resumed and long-term survival ensued. We conclude that normal limb regeneration in the adult newt is thyroid hormone(s) dependent, specifically the later stages of growth, differentiation and morphogenesis.Supported by grant A-1208 from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada to R.A.L.     

Nerve interactions and regenerative processes occurring in newt limbs fused end-to-end

Peripheral nerve interactions and regenerative phenomena were studied in newt forelimbs fused end to end. After simple fusion, one or two spikelike structures regenerated at the plane of fusion in 88% of the cases. When one of the limbs was denervated at the time of fusion, no regeneration occurred from the plane of fusion. If the limbs were fused and one was amputated at the shoulder more than 10 days after fusion, regeneration from the amputation surface did not occur. When the limbs were reamputated 30 days later, regeneration of left limbs from the proximodistally reversed right limb stumps followed. If one of the limbs was denervated at the time of fusion, and amputation was subsequently carried out through the formerly denervated limb, regeneration always took place after the first amputation. On the basis of these results it is postulated that when regenerating nerves of opposite proximodistal polarity meet head-on, the majority of fibers, at least, do not grow into territories occupied by the other nerve. These results have also demonstrated that full limb regeneration can occur at a greater distance from the midline than the end of a normal limb. These experiments also provide a technique for artificially elongating peripheral nerves.     

Appendage-restricted gene induction using a heated agarose gel for studying regeneration in metamorphosed Xenopus laevis and Pleurodeles waltl

Amphibians and fish often regenerate lost parts of their appendages (tail, limb, and fin) after amputation. Limb regeneration in adult amphibians provides an excellent model for appendage (limb) regeneration through 3D morphogenesis along the proximodistal, dorsoventral, and anteroposterior axes in mammals, because the limb is a homologous organ among amphibians and mammals. However, manipulating gene expression in specific appendages of adult amphibians remains difficult; this in turn hinders elucidation of the molecular mechanisms underlying appendage regeneration. To address this problem, we devised a system for appendage-specific gene induction using a simplified protocol named the “agarose-embedded heat shock (AeHS) method” involving the combination of a heat-shock-inducible system and insertion of an appendage in a temperature-controlled agarose gel. Gene expression was then induced specifically and ubiquitously in the regenerating limbs of metamorphosed amphibians, including a frog (Xenopus laevis) and newt (Pleurodeles waltl). We also induced gene expression in the regenerating tail of a metamorphosed P. waltl newt using the same method. This method can be applied to adult amphibians with large body sizes. Furthermore, this method enables simultaneous induction of gene expression in multiple individuals; further, the data are obtained in a reproducible manner, enabling the analysis of gene functions in limb and tail regeneration. Therefore, this method will facilitate elucidation of the molecular mechanisms underlying appendage regeneration in amphibians, which can support the development of regenerative therapies for organs, such as the limbs and spinal cord.     

Increased slow transport in axons of regenerating newt limbs after a nerve conditioning lesion

We have previously shown that a nerve conditioning lesion (CL) made 2 weeks prior to amputation results in an earlier onset of limb regeneration in newts. Studies in fish and mammals demonstrate that when a CL precedes a nerve testing lesion, slow component b (SCb) of axonal transport is increased compared to axons that had not received a CL. We wanted to know whether the earlier initiation of limb regeneration after a CL was associated with an increase in SCb transport. The transport of [35S]methionine labeled SCb proteins was measured by using SDS-PAGE, fluorography, and scintillation counting. The rate of transport and quantity of SCb proteins was determined at 7, 14, 21, and 28 days after injection of [35S]methionine into the motor columns of normal; single lesioned (i.e., transection axotomy, amputation axotomy, or sham CL followed by amputation); and double-lesioned limb axons (i.e., nerve transection CL followed 2 weeks later by amputation axotomy). The rate of SCb transport in axons of unamputated newt limbs was 0.19 mm/day. There was an increase in the amount of labeled SCb proteins transported in axons regenerating as the result of a single lesion but no acceleration in the rate of SCb transport, which was 0.21 mm/day in axons that received a sham CL followed by limb amputation. The rate of SCb transport doubled (0.40 mm/day) and the amount of labeled SCb proteins being transported was increased when amputation was preceded by a CL. This study demonstrates that the earlier onset of limb regrowth, seen when amputation follows a CL, is associated with an increased transport of SCb proteins. This suggests that limb regeneration is, in part, regulated by axonal regrowth. We propose that the blastema requires a minimum quantity of innervation before progressing to the next stage of limb regeneration, and that the transport of SCb proteins determines when that quantity will be available.     

Changes in the Distribution of Fibronectin During Limb Regeneration in Newts Using Immunocytochemistry

The distribution of fibronectin in regenerating newt limbs was studied using immunocytochemistry. At appropriate intervals after the initial amputation at the elbow (10–30 days), animals were reamputated at the shoulder and processed for light microscopy. The peroxidase-antiperoxidase technique was used to localize affinity-purified antibodies to fibronectin in limb tissues. At the amputation site, fibronectin was associated with basal laminae and connective tissues adjacent to dedifferentiating limb tissues destined to form the regeneration blastema. Accumulation and growth of the blastema was accompanied by the apparent de novo synthesis of fibronectin, where it appeared randomly in the interstitium between blastemal cells. The onset of chondrogenesis was characterized by a central condensation of prechondroblasts that formed the cartilage anlagen. Fibronectin formed an amorphous network between presumptive chondroblasts. As the mature cartilage phenotype was expressed and chondrocytes became isolated in lacunae, fibronectin was greatly reduced and then disappeared. The extracellular matrix surrounding undifferentiated blastemal cells still contained fibronectin. Fibronectin was also found in high concentrations between differentiating myoblasts. A condensation of fibronectin was also observed beneath the epidermis at the distal limb tip at the onset of digit formation. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that fibronectin may play a key role in the morphogenetic events that result in the spatial organization and subsequent differentiation of cells during pattern formation in the regenerating limb.     

Hormone action in newt limb regeneration: insulin and endorphins

Although several hormones have been linked to newt limb regeneration, a cohesive hypothesis as to how these hormones control the process is yet to emerge. A critical review of the traditional approaches and a reevaluation of currently operative assumptions and interpretations of results precede the data on insulin and beta-endorphin. Results from in vivo and in vitro experiments on insulin are summarized, showing that insulin not only promotes various cellular events but also is essential for the expression of the mitogenic effect of nerves on cultured newt limb blastemata. Furthermore, the strong likelihood that insulin may be the common link in promoting limb regeneration in hypophysectomized newts that received pituitary hormone replacement therapy or a nutritional supplement is discussed. The status of beta-endorphin in regeneration is also explored. Data are presented to show that vertebrates with regenerating capacity (newts, tadpoles) have higher levels of plasma beta-endorphin than that found in species where the capacity to regenerate is either restricted (frogs) or totally lost (mammals). beta-Endorphin-like immunoreactivity has been localized in the epidermis of a regenerating newt blastema, as well as in the intermediate lobe of the pituitary gland of axolotl, newt, and Xenopus. A possible opiate connection in vertebrate limb regeneration, in particular, wound healing, is discussed.     

Injury, nerve, and wound epidermis related electrophoretic and fluorographic protein patterns in forelimbs of adult newts

Polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis and [35S]methionine fluorography were used to examine proteins in regenerating newt limbs, amputated denervated limbs, unamputated denervated limbs, and separated blastema mesodermal core and wound epidermis. A total of 27 protein electrophoretic bands were obtained from amputated limbs and 24 bands from unamputated limbs. Amputation resulted in the appearance of 4 new bands and the loss of 1 band as compared to unamputated limbs. These 5 banding differences were apparent on stained gels 3 days postamputation and were maintained through 10 weeks postamputation (complete regenerate stage). Only one band in unamputated limbs was always detectable on fluorographs, whereas virtually all of the stainable bands of amputated limbs were visible on fluorographs. Amputation clearly stimulated a marked, generalized increase in the synthesis of limb proteins. The 5 amputation induced changes were equally evident in stained gels of both innervated and denervated limbs. Amputated denervated limbs possessed a full set of fluorographic bands (including the 5 differences) through 18 days postamputation. However, denervation without amputation was not sufficient to alter the stainable banding pattern. Wound epidermis and mesodermal core both displayed the 5 banding differences and had identical banding patterns with the exception of one epidermal specific band. This band was also present in whole limb skin but was absent in unamputated mesodermal limb tissue. This was the only band of unamputated limbs that was consistently detectable by fluorography. It is concluded that amputation induces nerve independent changes in protein synthesis that are common to both mesodermal core and wound epidermis. These changes may represent preparation for cellular proliferation.     

Stress and changes in the blood of newts,Notophthalmus viridescens,during early regeneration

Summary During the summers of 1984 and 1985, adult red-spotted newts,Notophthalmus viridescens, were maintained in the laboratory at 23°±0.5°C under natural photoperiods. From each of the experimental animals, the right forelimb was amputated just proximal to the elbow. Control newts were not manipulated surgically. Eight, 15, and 22 days after the time of amputation, equal numbers of regenerating and control animals were sacrificed, and blood smears of each individual were prepared with Wright's stain.Mean differential counts of leukocytes of the two groups of newts indicated that the relative number of neutrophils increased and the relative number of lymphocytes decreased in the regenerating animals as compared to their controls (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2). Earlier studies had shown that lymphopenia and neutrophilia occur in red-spotted newts treated with hydrocortisone or with ACTH or subjected to environmental stress (Bennett and Daigle 1983). Consequently, it is suggested that amputation and/or early regeneration may stimulate the increased production of hormones associated with stress in vertebrates, which may, in turn, influence regeneration, itself, and that the detailed study of the distribution of leukocytes inNotophthalmus viridescens may provide an assay with which to study the regulation of regeneration in this species.     

Effects on adult newt limb regeneration of partial and complete skin flaps over the amputation surface.

The influence of the wound epithelium on the cellular events preceding blastema formation was examined by comparing dedifferentiation, DNA labeling indices, and mitotic indices of the distal mesodermal tissues in control regenerating newt forelimbs and in amputated forelimbs covered with a flap of full thickness skin. Three kinds of results were seen following the skin-flap graft operations. Epidermal migration across the amputation surface was completely inhibited in 22% (8) of the cases and these limbs repaired the amputation wound but did not form regeneration blastemas. In 11% (4) of the experimental limbs, essentially normal wound epithelia displaced the skin flaps and the limb stumps formed blastemas and regenerated. The majority of the skin grafts (67%) exhibited epidermal migration restricted to the free edges of the flaps. These limbs formed eccentric blastemas on the ventral side of the limb next to the dermis-free epidermis and regenerated laterally in that direction.     

Normal newt limb regeneration requires matrix metalloproteinase function

Newts regenerate lost limbs through a complex process involving dedifferentiation, migration, proliferation, and redifferentiation of cells proximal to the amputation plane. To identify the genes controlling these cellular events, we performed a differential display analysis between regenerating and nonregenerating limbs from the newt Notophthalmus viridescens. This analysis, coupled with a direct cloning approach, identified a previously unknown Notophthalmus collagenase gene (nCol) and three known matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) genes, MMP3/10a, MMP3/10b, and MMP9, all of which are upregulated within hours of limb amputation. MMP3/10b exhibits the highest and most ubiquitous expression and appears to account for the majority of the proteolytic activity in the limb as measured by gel zymography. By testing purified recombinant MMP proteins against potential substrates, we show that nCol is a true collagenase, MMP9 is a gelatinase, MMP3/10a is a stromelysin, and MMP3/10b has an unusually broad substrate profile, acting both as a stromelysin and noncanonical collagenase. Exposure of regenerating limbs to the synthetic MMP inhibitor GM6001 produces either dwarfed, malformed limb regenerates or limb stumps with distal scars. These data suggest that MMPs are required for normal newt limb regeneration and that MMPs function, in part, to prevent scar formation during the regenerative process.     

An extracellular matrix molecule of newt and axolotl regenerating limb blastemas and embryonic limb buds: immunological relationship of MT1 antigen with tenascin.

Several well-characterized extracellular matrix (ECM) components have been localized to the amphibian limb regenerate, but the identification and characterization of novel ECM molecules have received little attention. Here we describe, using mAb MT1 and immunocytochemistry, an ECM molecule expressed during limb regeneration and limb development. In limb stumps, mAb MT1 reactivity was restricted to tendons, myotendinous junctions, granules in the basal layers of epidermis, periosteum (newts) and perichondrium (axolotls). In regenerating limbs, reactivity in the distal limb stump was first detected 5 days and 1 day after amputation of newt and axolotl limbs, respectively. In both species, mAb MT1 recognized what appeared to be an abundant blastema matrix antigen, localized in both thin and thick cords between and sometimes closely associated with blastema cells. Reactivity was generally uniform throughout the blastema except for a particularly thick layer that was present immediately beneath the wound epithelium. During redifferentiation stages, mAb MT1 reactivity persisted among blastema cells and redifferentiating cartilage but was lost proximally in areas of muscle and connective tissue differentiation. During the entire period of embryonic limb development, mAb MT1 reactivity was seen in the ECM of the mesenchyme and in a layer beneath the limb bud ectoderm, similar to its distribution during regeneration. Considerable mAb MT1 reactivity was also associated with the developing somites. The reactivity of mAb MT1 in blastema and limb bud was similar if not identical to that of a polyclonal Ab against tenascin (pAbTN), a large, extracellular matrix glycoprotein implicated in growth control, inductive interactions, and other developmental events. This pAbTN effectively competed against mAb MT1 binding on blastema sections. In immunoblots, both mAb MT1 and pAbTN recognized a very high molecular weight (approximately Mr 1000 x 10(3)) protein in blastema extracts of both newts and axolotls. mAb MT1 immunoprecipitated a protein of Mr 1000K size which reacted to both mAb MT1 and pAbTN in immunoblots. These data show that tenascin is in the matrix of the urodele blastema and limb bud, and suggest that mAb MT1 identifies urodele tenascin.     

Abnormal Limb Regeneration without Tumor Production in Adult Newts Directed by Carcinogens, 20-Methylcholanthrene and Benzo (α) pyrene

The effects of potent carcinogens, 20-methylcholanthrene (MC) and benzo(α)pyrene (BP), on limb regeneration were studied in adult newts. A microcrystal of these carcinogens was administered directly to the blastema of forelmibs on day 7 after amputation. The formation of the regeneration cone was delayed and the cone was shifted in abnormal polarity depending upon the site of micro-crystal administration. These carcinogens affected morphogenesis of skeletal structures of regenerating limbs. Subregeneration and superregeneration of either or both carpals and digits, absence of either or both ulna and radius, and accessory limb formation have been recorded as abnormalities caused by these carcinogens. Non-carcinogenic benzocompounds did not show such effects as those of MC and BP. The regeneration blastema of the limb appears to be resistant to carcinogenic effects of the carcinogens used since tumor formation has never been observed in our study so far.     

Denervation Effects on Limb Regeneration in Postmetamorphic Xenopus laevis

The effects of denervation on limb regeneration of postmetamorphic Xenopus laevis in the early to late stages of regeneration were studied. Limbs that were denervated immediately after amputation did not show any signs of regeneration. Moreover regenerating limbs denervated 20, 30, 40 and 60 days after amputation showed significant regression of regenerates. After this regression of regenerates, the regenerative capacity was not restored during a long observation period. Denervation reduced both protein synthesis (³H leucine autoradiography) and mitotic activity of regenerating limbs even in later stages of regeneration. These results on the role of the nerve in limb regeneration of Xenopus were compared with results in Xenopus and urodeles reported previously.     

The interaction of nerves of opposite regenerating polarity in fused newt forelimbs

Previous studies involving nerve interactions and limb regenerative processes were carried out on adult newts after their forelimbs were amputated through the distal radius and ulna and fused end-to-end. On the basis of limb regeneration results at the junction of the fused limbs, it was postulated that regenerating nerves from each limb (i.e., nerves of opposite polarity) would not invade the foreign territory of the contralateral limb if it were already normally innervated. A direct study of this nerve interaction, however, was not made in this earlier study. The present investigation was designed to obtain direct histological and electrophysiological evidence for the interaction of nerves of opposite regenerating polarity in fused newt forelimbs. The primary objective was to determine how the regenerating nerves would interact in the establishment of innervation territories-first, at the fusion zone, which represents the junction of the normal innervation territories of the nerves of each limb; and secondly, half way up one of the limbs, where interaction would occur in a territory normally innervated by only one of the regenerating nerves. The results showed that when nerves of opposite regenerating polarity approached one another at the junction of the fused limbs a discontinuation of axonal growth occurred; no indication of overlap of nerves into foreign territory was seen. When the nerves were allowed to interact within one of the fused limbs, however, an overlap of nerve fibers and a functional "double innervation" of that limb was demonstrated. These results are discussed in terms of possible mechanisms for the establishment of innervation territories in salamander limbs. The question of nerve-muscle reinnervation specificity is also raised.     

Retinoic acid enhances monoclonal antibody WE3 reactivity in the regenerate epithelium of the adult newt.

Monoclonal antibody (mAb) WE3 recognizes an antigen that is developmentally expressed in the wound epithelium during adult newt limb regeneration. Experiments were designed to determine whether retinoic acid (RA), dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and administered by intraperitoneal injection, would enhance the temporal appearance of the WE3 antigen. RA given on days 1 or 4 after amputation, when the WE3 antigen is not yet detectable, resulted in moderate reactivity to mAb 2 days after injection and strong reactivity throughout the wound epithelium 4 days after injection. DMSO alone had no enhancing effect. RA also caused limb skin epidermis to exhibit reactivity to mAb WE3, initially near the amputation level, but then also more proximally. By 4 and 6 days after RA injection, epidermis of the flank, eye lid, and unamputated hind limbs also became strongly reactive to mAb WE3. Outer layers of skin epidermis were shed, resulting in an epidermis only one or two cells thick. Epidermis of newts given DMSO alone remained non-reactive to mAb WE3. When RA was given on days 7 and 10 after amputation, when a low level of mAb WE3 reactivity is already present in the wound epithelium, a considerable enhancement of mAb WE3 reactivity occurred through the next few days. No such enhancement was seen with DMSO alone. RA also greatly increased mAb WE3 reactivity in the wound epithelium of denervated limbs, in which case the wound epithelial reactivity to mAb WE3 is normally low. Retinol palmitate also increased mAb WE3 reactivity. The results raise the possibility that the WE3 antigen is a component of most if not all retinoid target tissues in newts.