Modulation of mAb quality attributes using microliter scale fed‐batch cultures

A high‐throughput DoE approach performed in a 96‐deepwell plate system was used to explore the impact of media and feed components on main quality attributes of a monoclonal antibody. Six CHO‐S derived clonal cell lines expressing the same monoclonal antibody were tested in two different cell culture media with six components added at three different levels. The resulting 384 culture conditions including controls were simultaneously tested in fed‐batch conditions, and process performance such as viable cell density, viability, and product titer were monitored. At the end of the culture, supernatants from each condition were purified and the product was analyzed for N‐glycan profiles, charge variant distribution, aggregates, and low molecular weight forms. The screening described here provided highly valuable insights into the factors and combination of factors that can be used to modulate the quality attributes of a molecule. The approach also revealed specific intrinsic differences of the selected clonal cell lines ‐ some cell lines were very responsive in terms of changes in performance or quality attributes, whereas others were less affected by the factors tested in this study. Moreover, it indicated to what extent the attributes can be impacted within the selected experimental design space. The outcome correlated well with confirmations performed in larger cell culture volumes such as small‐scale bioreactors. Being fast and resource effective, this integrated high‐throughput approach can provide information which is particularly useful during early stage cell culture development. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:571–583, 2014     

Using high throughput screening to define virus clearance by chromatography resins

High throughput screening (HTS) of chromatography resins can accelerate downstream process development by rapidly providing information on product and impurity partitioning over a wide range of experimental conditions. In addition to the removal of typical product and process‐related impurities, chromatography steps are also used to remove potential adventitious viral contaminants and non‐infectious retrovirus‐like particles expressed by rodent cell lines used for production. This article evaluates the feasibility of using HTS in a 96‐well batch‐binding format to study removal of the model retrovirus xenotropic murine leukemia virus (xMuLV) from product streams. Two resins were examined: the anion exchange resin Q Sepharose Fast Flow? (QSFF) and Capto adhere?, a mixed mode resin. QSFF batch‐binding HTS data was generated using two mAbs at various pHs, NaCl concentrations, and levels of impurities. Comparison of HTS data to that generated using the column format showed good agreement with respect to virus retentation at different pHs, NaCl concentrations and impurity levels. Results indicate that NaCl concentration and impurity level, but not pH, are key parameters that can impact xMuLV binding to both resins. Binding of xMuLV to Capto adhere appeared to tolerate higher levels of NaCl and impurity than QSFF, and showed some product‐specific impact on binding that was not observed with QSFF. Overall, the results demonstrate that the 96‐well batch‐binding HTS technique can be an effective tool for rapidly defining conditions for robust virus clearance on chromatographic resins. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1984–1994. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Integrated flow-through purification for therapeutic monoclonal antibodies processing

An integrated all flow-through technology platform for the purification of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAb), consisting of activated carbon and flow-through cation and anion exchange chromatography steps, can replace a conventional chromatography platform. This new platform was observed to have excellent impurity clearance at high mAb loadings with overall mAb yield exceeding 80%. Robust removal of DNA and host cell protein was demonstrated by activated carbon and a new flow-through cation exchange resin exhibited excellent clearance of mAb aggregate with high monomer recoveries. A ten-fold improvement of mAb loading was achieved compared to a traditional cation exchange resin designed for bind and elute mode. High throughput 96-well plate screening was used for process optimization, focusing on mAb loading and solution conditions. Optimum operating windows for integrated flow-through purification are proposed based on performance characteristics. The combination of an all flow-through polishing process presents significant opportunities for improvements in facility utilization and process economics.     

A high-throughput approach to developing and optimizing mixed-mode membrane chromatography for protein purification

Membrane chromatography has been established as a viable alternative to packed-bed column chromatography for the purification of therapeutic proteins. Purification via membrane chromatography offers key advantages, including higher productivity and reduced buffer usage. Unlike column chromatography purification, the utilization of high-throughput screening in order to reduce development times and material requirements has been a challenge for membrane chromatography. This research focused on the development of a new, high-throughput screening technique for use in screening membrane chromatography conditions for monoclonal antibody purification. The developed screen utilizes a 96-well plate format, thereby allowing for the screening of multiple different membrane conditions at once. For this study, four mixed-mode cation exchange membranes and one cation exchange membrane were evaluated on the plate. The screen is performed in a similar manner to that of a resin slurry plate screen, however, instead of a single loading step, the antibody feed was loaded in 50 mg/ml increments up to a maximum loading of 450 mg/ml. Performing a similar, incremental loading on a resin plate would be impractical, as mixing times are substantially longer due to pore diffusion limitations. However, due to the significantly faster rate of mass transfer for membranes relative to resin, mixing times could be reduced by up to a factor of sixty on the membrane plate. Additional optimization showed that higher hydrophobicity can potentially lead to slower kinetics and mixing times that may need to be adjusted accordingly. The end result is a screen that has been proven to provide results comparable to those obtained on larger-scale membrane purification runs while also enabling exploration of a much greater operating space and significantly reducing the feed materials required.     

High‐throughput process development of purification alternatives for the protein avidin

With an increased number of applications in the field of the avidin‐biotin technology, the resulting demand for highly‐purified protein avidin has drawn our attention to the purification process of avidin that naturally occurs in chicken egg white. The high‐throughput process development (HTPD) methodology was exploited, in order to evaluate purification process alternatives to commonly used ion‐exchange chromatography. In a high‐throughput format, process parameters for aqueous two‐phase extraction, selective precipitation with salts and polyethylene glycol, and hydrophobic interaction and mixed‐mode column chromatography experiments were performed. The HTPD strategy was complemented by a high‐throughput tandem high‐performance liquid chromatography assay for protein quantification. Suitable conditions for the separation of avidin from the major impurities ovalbumin, ovomucoid, ovotransferrin, and lysozyme were identified in the screening experiments. By combination of polyethylene glycol precipitation with subsequent resolubilization and separation in a polyethylene glycol/sulfate/sodium chloride two‐phase system an avidin purity of 77% was obtained with a yield >90% while at the same time achieving a significant reduction of the process volume. The two‐phase extraction and precipitation results were largely confirmed in larger scale with scale‐up factors of 230 and 133, respectively. Seamless processing of the avidin enriched bottom phase was found feasible by using mixed‐mode chromatography. By gradient elution a final avidin purity of at least 97% and yield >90% was obtained in the elution pool. The presented identification of a new and beneficial alternative for the purification of the high value protein thus represents a successful implementation of HTPD for an industrially relevant purification task. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 31:957–973, 2015     

A versatile noninvasive method for adsorber quantification in batch and column chromatography based on the ionic capacity

Within the Quality by Design (QbD) framework proposed by the International Conference on Harmonisation (ICH), high‐throughput process development (HTPD) and mechanistic modeling are of outstanding importance for future biopharmaceutical chromatography process development. In order to compare the data derived from different column scales or batch chromatographies, the amount of adsorber has to be quantified with the same noninvasive method. Similarly, an important requirement for the implementation of mechanistic modeling is the reliable determination of column characteristics such as the ionic capacity Λ for ion‐exchange chromatography with the same method at all scales and formats. We developed a method to determine the ionic capacity in column and batch chromatography, based on the adsorption/desorption of the natural, uv‐detectable amino acid histidine. In column chromatography, this method produces results comparable to those of classical acid?base titration. In contrast to acid?base titration, this method can be adapted to robotic batch chromatographic experiments. We are able to convert the adsorber volumes in batch chromatography to the equivalent volume of a compressed column. In a case study, we demonstrate that this method increases the quality of SMA parameters fitted to batch adsorption isotherms, and the capability to predict column breakthrough experiments. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:666–677, 2016     

Controlling the time evolution of mAb N‐linked glycosylation ‐ Part II: Model‐based predictions

N‐linked glycosylation is known to be a crucial factor for the therapeutic efficacy and safety of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and many other glycoproteins. The nontemplate process of glycosylation is influenced by external factors which have to be tightly controlled during the manufacturing process. In order to describe and predict mAb N‐linked glycosylation patterns in a CHO‐S cell fed‐batch process, an existing dynamic mathematical model has been refined and coupled to an unstructured metabolic model. High‐throughput cell culture experiments carried out in miniaturized bioreactors in combination with intracellular measurements of nucleotide sugars were used to tune the parameter configuration of the coupled models as a function of extracellular pH, manganese and galactose addition. The proposed modeling framework is able to predict the time evolution of N‐linked glycosylation patterns during a fed‐batch process as a function of time as well as the manipulated variables. A constant and varying mAb N‐linked glycosylation pattern throughout the culture were chosen to demonstrate the predictive capability of the modeling framework, which is able to quantify the interconnected influence of media components and cell culture conditions. Such a model‐based evaluation of feeding regimes using high‐throughput tools and mathematical models gives rise to a more rational way to control and design cell culture processes with defined glycosylation patterns. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:1135–1148, 2016     

Screening and assessment of performance and molecule quality attributes of industrial cell lines across different fed‐batch systems

The major challenge in the selection process of recombinant cell lines for the production of biologics is the choice, early in development, of a clonal cell line presenting a high productivity and optimal cell growth. Most importantly, the selected candidate needs to generate a product quality profile which is adequate with respect to safety and efficacy and which is preserved across cell culture scales. We developed a high‐throughput screening and selection strategy of recombinant cell lines, based on their productivity in shaking 96‐deepwell plates operated in fed‐batch mode, which enables the identification of cell lines maintaining their high productivity at larger scales. Twelve recombinant cell lines expressing the same antibody with different productivities were selected out of 470 clonal cell lines in 96‐deepwell plate fed‐batch culture. They were tested under the same conditions in 50 mL vented shake tubes, microscale and lab‐scale bioreactors in order to confirm the maintenance of their performance at larger scales. The use of a feeding protocol and culture conditions which are essentially the same across the different scales was essential to maintain productivity and product quality profiles across scales. Compared to currently used approaches, this strategy has the advantage of speeding up the selection process and increases the number of screened clones for getting high‐producing recombinant cell lines at manufacturing scale with the desired performance and quality. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:160–170, 2016     

A practical strategy for using miniature chromatography columns in a standardized high‐throughput workflow for purification development of monoclonal antibodies

The emergence of monoclonal antibody (mAb) therapies has created a need for faster and more efficient bioprocess development strategies in order to meet timeline and material demands. In this work, a high‐throughput process development (HTPD) strategy implementing several high‐throughput chromatography purification techniques is described. Namely, batch incubations are used to scout feasible operating conditions, miniature columns are then used to determine separation of impurities, and, finally, a limited number of lab scale columns are tested to confirm the conditions identified using high‐throughput techniques and to provide a path toward large scale processing. This multistep approach builds upon previous HTPD work by combining, in a unique sequential fashion, the flexibility and throughput of batch incubations with the increased separation characteristics for the packed bed format of miniature columns. Additionally, in order to assess the applicability of using miniature columns in this workflow, transport considerations were compared with traditional lab scale columns, and performances were mapped for the two techniques. The high‐throughput strategy was utilized to determine optimal operating conditions with two different types of resins for a difficult separation of a mAb monomer from aggregates. Other more detailed prediction models are cited, but the intent of this work was to use high‐throughput strategies as a general guide for scaling and assessing operating space rather than as a precise model to exactly predict performance. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:626–635, 2014     

A high‐throughput sample preparation method for cellular proteomics using 96‐well filter plates

A high‐throughput sample preparation protocol based on the use of 96‐well molecular weight cutoff (MWCO) filter plates was developed for shotgun proteomics of cell lysates. All sample preparation steps, including cell lysis, buffer exchange, protein denaturation, reduction, alkylation and proteolytic digestion are performed in a 96‐well plate format, making the platform extremely well suited for processing large numbers of samples and directly compatible with functional assays for cellular proteomics. In addition, the usage of a single plate for all sample preparation steps following cell lysis reduces potential samples losses and allows for automation. The MWCO filter also enables sample concentration, thereby increasing the overall sensitivity, and implementation of washing steps involving organic solvents, for example, to remove cell membranes constituents. The optimized protocol allowed for higher throughput with improved sensitivity in terms of the number of identified cellular proteins when compared to an established protocol employing gel‐filtration columns.     

Enhanced production of l‐lactic acid by Lactobacillus thermophilus SRZ50 mutant generated by high‐linear energy transfer heavy ion mutagenesis

The aim of this study was to improve l ‐lactic acid production of Lactobacillus thermophilus SRZ50. For this purpose, high efficient heavy‐ion mutagenesis technique was performed using SRZ50 as the original strain. To enhance the screening efficiency for high yield l ‐lactic acid producers, a scale‐down from shake flask to microtiter plate was developed. The results showed that 24‐well U‐bottom MTPs could well alternate shake flasks for L. thermophilus cultivation as a scale‐down tool due to its a very good comparability to the shake flasks. Based on this microtiter plate screening method, two high l ‐lactic acid productivity mutants, A59 and A69, were successfully screened out, which presented, respectively, 15.8 and 16.2% higher productivities than that of the original strain. Based on fed‐batch fermentation, the A69 mutant can accumulate 114.2 g/L l ‐lactic acid at 96 h. Hence, the proposed traditional microbial breeding method with efficient high‐throughput screening assay was proved to be an appropriate strategy to obtain lactic acid‐overproducing strain.     

Precultures Grown under Fed‐Batch Conditions Increase the Reliability and Reproducibility of High‐Throughput Screening Results

One essential task in bioprocess development is strain selection. A common screening procedure consists of three steps: first, the picking of colonies; second, the execution of a batch preculture and main culture, e.g., in microtiter plates (MTPs); and third, the evaluation of product formation. Especially during the picking step, unintended variations occur due to undefined amounts and varying viability of transferred cells. The aim of this study is to demonstrate that the application of polymer‐based controlled‐release fed‐batch MTPs during preculture eliminates these variations. The concept of equalizing growth through fed‐batch conditions during preculture is theoretically discussed and then tested in a model system, namely, a cellulase‐producing Escherichia coli clone bank containing 32 strains. Preculture is conducted once in the batch mode and once in the fed‐batch mode. By applying the fed‐batch mode, equalized growth is observed in the subsequent main culture. Furthermore, the standard deviation of cellulase activity is reduced compared to that observed in the conventional approach. Compared with the strains in the batch preculture process, the first‐ranked strain in the fed‐batch preculture process is the superior cellulase producer. These findings recommend the application of the fed‐batch MTPs during preculture in high‐throughput screening processes to achieve accurate and reliable results.     

Development and application of an automated, low-volume chromatography system for resin and condition screening

A small-volume chromatography system was developed for rapid resin and parameter screening and applied to the purification of a therapeutic monoclonal antibody from a key product-related impurity. Accounting for constraints in peripheral volume, gradient formation, column integrity, and fraction collection in microtiter plates, the resulting system employed 2-mL columns and was successfully integrated with plate-based methods for rapid sample analysis (e. g., use of automated liquid handlers, plate readers, and HPLC). Several cation-exchange chromatography resins were screened using automated programs and tailored gradients for the combination of a particular resin and a given antibody feedstock produced during Phase 1 development. Results from the tailored gradient runs were used to select a resin, and to arrive at efficient stepwise elution schedules for the chosen resin. By maintaining a constant residence time, final operating parameters were successfully scaled to representative bed heights and column diameters up to 2.6 cm (106 mL). This approach significantly improved throughput while reducing development time and material consumption.     

Implementation of a Fully Automated Microbial Cultivation Platform for Strain and Process Screening

Advances in molecular biotechnology have resulted in the generation of numerous potential production strains. Because every strain can be screened under various process conditions, the number of potential cultivations is multiplied. Exploiting this potential without increasing the associated timelines requires a cultivation platform that offers increased throughput and flexibility to perform various bioprocess screening protocols. Currently, there is no commercially available fully automated cultivation platform that can operate multiple microbial fed‐batch processes, including at‐line sampling, deep freezer off‐line sample storage, and complete data handling. To enable scalable high‐throughput early‐stage microbial bioprocess development, a commercially available microbioreactor system and a laboratory robot are combined to develop a fully automated cultivation platform. By making numerous modifications, as well as supplementation with custom‐built hardware and software, fully automated milliliter‐scale microbial fed‐batch cultivation, sample handling, and data storage are realized. The initial results of cultivations with two different expression systems and three different process conditions are compared using 5 L scale benchmark cultivations, which provide identical rankings of expression systems and process conditions. Thus, fully automated high‐throughput cultivation, including automated centralized data storage to significantly accelerate the identification of the optimal expression systems and process conditions, offers the potential for automated early‐stage bioprocess development.     

High‐throughput cell quantification assays for use in cell purification development – enabling technologies for cell production

High‐throughput screening (HTS) technology is gaining increasing importance in downstream process development of cell‐based products. The development of such HTS‐technologies, however, is highly dependent on the availability of robust, accurate, and sensitive high‐throughput cell quantification methods. In this article, we compare state‐of‐the‐art cell quantification methods with focus on their applicability in HTS‐platforms for downstream processing of cell‐based products. Sensitivity, dynamic range, and precision were evaluated for four methods that differ in their respective mechanism. In addition, we evaluated the performance of these methods over a range of buffer compositions, medium densities, and viscosities, representing conditions found in many downstream processing methods. We found that CellTiter‐Glo? and flow cytometry are excellent tools for high‐throughput cell quantification. Both methods have broad working ranges (3–4 log) and performed well over a wide range of buffer compositions. In comparison, CyQuant® Direct and CellTracker? had smaller working ranges and were more sensitive to changes in buffer composition. For fast and sensitive quantification of a single cell type, CellTiter‐Glo? performed best, while for more complex cell mixtures flow cytometry is the method of choice. Our analysis will facilitate the selection of the most suitable method for a specific application and provides a benchmark for future HTS development in downstream processing of cell‐based products.     

Strategic assay deployment as a method for countering analytical bottlenecks in high throughput process development: Case studies in ion exchange chromatography

High throughput approaches to facilitate the development of chromatographic separations have now been adopted widely in the biopharmaceutical industry, but issues of how to reduce the associated analytical burden remain. For example, acquiring experimental data by high level factorial designs in 96 well plates can place a considerable strain upon assay capabilities, generating a bottleneck that limits significantly the speed of process characterization. This article proposes an approach designed to counter this challenge; Strategic Assay Deployment (SAD). In SAD, a set of available analytical methods is investigated to determine which set of techniques is the most appropriate to use and how best to deploy these to reduce the consumption of analytical resources while still enabling accurate and complete process characterization. The approach is demonstrated by investigating how salt concentration and pH affect the binding of green fluorescent protein from Escherichia coli homogenate to an anion exchange resin presented in a 96‐well filter plate format. Compared with the deployment of routinely used analytical methods alone, the application of SAD reduced both the total assay time and total assay material consumption by at least 40% and 5%, respectively. SAD has significant utility in accelerating bioprocess development activities. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2012     

High‐throughput protein refolding screening method using zeolite

We established a 96‐well‐plate‐based refolding screening system using zeolite. In this system, protein denatured and solubilized with 6 M guanidine hydrochloride is adsorbed onto zeolite placed in a 96‐well plate. The refolding conditions can be tested by incubating the samples with refolding buffers under various conditions of pH, salts, and additives. In this study, we chose green fluorescent protein as the model protein. Green fluorescent protein was expressed as inclusion bodies, and we tested the effects of four pH conditions and six additives on its refolding. The results demonstrate that green fluorescent protein was more efficiently refolded with zeolite than with the conventional dilution method. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Multi‐dimensional fractionation and characterization of crude protein mixtures: Toward establishment of a database of protein purification process development parameters

A multi‐dimensional fractionation and characterization scheme was developed for fast acquisition of the relevant molecular properties for protein separation from crude biological feedstocks by ion‐exchange chromatography (IEX), hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC), and size‐exclusion chromatography. In this approach, the linear IEX isotherm parameters were estimated from multiple linear salt‐gradient IEX data, while the nonlinear IEX parameters as well as the HIC isotherm parameters were obtained by the inverse method under column overloading conditions. Collected chromatographic fractions were analyzed by gel electrophoresis for estimation of molecular mass, followed by mass spectrometry for protein identification. The usefulness of the generated molecular properties data for rational decision‐making during downstream process development was equally demonstrated. Monoclonal antibody purification from crude hybridoma cell culture supernatant was used as case study. The obtained chromatographic parameters only apply to the employed stationary phases and operating conditions, hence prior high throughput screening of different chromatographic resins and mobile phase conditions is still a prerequisite. Nevertheless, it provides a quick, knowledge‐based approach for rationally synthesizing purification cascades prior to more detailed process optimization and evaluation. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2012; 109: 3070–3083. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Purification of cell culture‐derived modified vaccinia ankara virus by pseudo‐affinity membrane adsorbers and hydrophobic interaction chromatography

A purification scheme for cell culture‐derived smallpox vaccines based on an orthogonal downstream process of pseudo‐affinity membrane adsorbers (MA) and hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) was investigated. The applied pseudo‐affinity chromatography, based on reinforced sulfated cellulose and heparin‐MA, was optimized in terms of dynamic binding capacities, virus yield and process productivity. HIC was introduced as a subsequent method to further reduce the DNA content. Therefore, two screens were undertaken. First, several HIC ligands were screened for different adsorption behavior between virus particles and DNA. Second, elution from pseudo‐affinity MA and adsorption of virus particles onto the hydrophobic interaction matrix was explored by a series of buffers using different ammonium sulfate concentrations. Eventually, variations between different cultivation batches and buffer conditions were investigated.The most promising combination, a sulfated cellulose membrane adsorber with subsequent phenyl HIC resulted in overall virus particle recoveries ranging from 76% to 55% depending on the product batch and applied conditions. On average, 61% of the recovered virus particles were infective within all tested purification schemes and conditions. Final DNA content varied from 0.01% to 2.5% of the starting material and the level of contaminating protein was below 0.1%. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2010;107: 312–320. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.