Isolation of Spectinomycin Resistance Mutations in the 16S rRNA of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and Expression in Escherichia coli and Salmonella

Two single-base mutations in 16S rRNA conferring high-level resistance to spectinomycin were isolated on a plasmid-borne copy of the rrnD operon from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Neither of the mutations (C1066U and C1192U) had appreciable effects on cell growth, but each had differential effects on resistance to spectinomycin and fusidic acid. Both mutations also conferred resistance to spectinomycin in Escherichia coli strains containing deletions of all seven chromosomal rrn operons and expressing plasmid-encoded Salmonella rRNA exclusively. In contrast, when expressed in E. coli strains containing intact chromosomal rrn operons, the strains were sensitive to spectinomycin. However, chromosomal mutations arose that allowed expression of the rRNA-dependent spectinomycin resistance phenotype. It is proposed that in heterogeneous rRNA populations, the native E. coli rRNA out-competes the heterologous Salmonella rRNA for binding to ribosomal proteins, translation factors, or ribosome assembly, thus limiting entry of the antibiotic-resistant 30S subunits into the functioning ribosome pool. Received: 28 September 2001 / Accepted: 26 March 2002     

Modulation of 16S rRNA function by ribosomal protein S12

Ribosomal protein S12 is a critical component of the decoding center of the 30S ribosomal subunit and is involved in both tRNA selection and the response to streptomycin. We have investigated the interplay between S12 and some of the surrounding 16S rRNA residues by examining the phenotypes of double-mutant ribosomes in strains of Escherichia coli carrying deletions in all chromosomal rrn operons and expressing total rRNA from a single plasmid-borne rrn operon. We show that the combination of S12 and otherwise benign mutations at positions C1409-G1491 in 16S rRNA severely compromises cell growth while the level and range of aminoglycoside resistances conferred by the G1491U/C substitutions is markedly increased by a mutant S12 protein. The G1491U/C mutations in addition confer resistance to the unrelated antibiotic, capreomycin. S12 also interacts with the 912 region of 16S rRNA. Genetic selection of suppressors of streptomycin dependence caused by mutations at proline 90 in S12 yielded a C912U substitution in 16S rRNA. The C912U mutation on its own confers resistance to streptomycin and restricts miscoding, properties that distinguish it from a majority of the previously described error-promoting ram mutants that also reverse streptomycin dependence.     

Mapping and spacer identification of rRNA operons of Salmonella typhimurium.

The rRNA operons of Salmonella typhimurium have been characterized with respect to their map position, orientation, and type of tRNA spacer. One of the seven rrn operons was found to be linked to pheA and another was found to be linked to aroE. This information, together with published information about the other five rrn operons, shows that S. typhimurium and Escherichia coli are essentially identical in terms of the number, the map position, and the orientation of all seven operons. S. typhimurium and E. coli were also similar in that four of the rrn spacer regions code for tRNAGlu2 and three code for tRNAAla1B. However, the two species differed in that rrnD coded for tRNAGlu2 and rrnB coded for tRNAAla1B in S. typhimurium. This is the opposite of the arrangement in E. coli. We have tabulated the coordinates of the BamHI and PstI sites flanking six of the S. typhimurium rrn genes and present revisions for the coordinates of some of the E. coli sites.     

Construction and Initial Characterization of Escherichia coli Strains with Few or No Intact Chromosomal rRNA Operons

The Escherichia coli genome carries seven rRNA (rrn) operons, each containing three rRNA genes. The presence of multiple operons has been an obstacle to many studies of rRNA because the effect of mutations in one operon is diluted by the six remaining wild-type copies. To create a tool useful for manipulating rRNA, we sequentially inactivated from one to all seven of these operons with deletions spanning the 16S and 23S rRNA genes. In the final strain, carrying no intact rRNA operon on the chromosome, rRNA molecules were expressed from a multicopy plasmid containing a single rRNA operon (prrn). Characterization of these rrn deletion strains revealed that deletion of two operons was required to observe a reduction in the growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio. When the number of deletions was extended from three to six, the decrease in the growth rate was slightly more than the decrease in the rRNA/protein ratio, suggesting that ribosome efficiency was reduced. This reduction was most pronounced in the Delta7 prrn strain, in which the growth rate, unlike the rRNA/protein ratio, was not completely restored to wild-type levels by a cloned rRNA operon. The decreases in growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio were surprisingly moderate in the rrn deletion strains; the presence of even a single operon on the chromosome was able to produce as much as 56% of wild-type levels of rRNA. We discuss possible applications of these strains in rRNA studies.     

Spectinomycin interacts specifically with the residues G1064 and C1192 in 16S rRNA, thereby potentially freezing this molecule into an inactive conformation.

The upper stem of helix 34, consisting of the base-paired sequences C1063G1064U1065 and A1191C1192G1193, is suggested to be involved in the binding of spectinomycin. In E. coli 16S rRNA, each of the three mutations at position C1192 confers resistance to spectinomycin. In chloroplast ribosomes from tobacco plants and algae, resistance is conferred by single mutations at positions 1064, 1191, and 1193 (E. coli numbering). Since each of these mutations disrupt any of the three basepairs in the upper stem of helix 34, it has been postulated that spectinomycin can bind to this region and inhibit protein synthesis, only if its nucleotides are basepaired. We have tested this hypothesis by introducing disruptive and compensatory mutations that alter the basepair G1064-C1192. Using the specialized ribosome system, the translational activity of such mutants was determined, in the absence and presence of spectinomycin. We show that any of the three disruptive mutations A1064, C1064, and U1064 confer resistance, in accordance with the model for spectinomycin binding. Compensatory mutations A1064U1192, C1064G1192, and U1064A1192, however, maintained the resistance. This indicates that a basepaired conformation as such is not sufficient for spectinomycin binding, but rather that a G-C pair at positions 1064 and 1192 is required. In addition, we find that the translational activity of specialized ribosomes containing the mutations C1064G1192 is 5-fold lower compared to that of ribosomes containing any of the other mutations introduced, regardless whether spectinomycin is present or not. Since the introduction of C1064G1192 is expected to increase the stability of the upper stem of helix 34, we suggest that these mutations impair ribosome function by preventing the (transient) disruption of the upper stem. By analogy, we speculate that spectinomycin blocks protein synthesis by stabilizing the upper stem. In both cases, the 30S subunit would be frozen into an inactive conformation.     

Involvement of ribosomal ribonucleic acid operons in Salmonella typhimurium chromosomal rearrangements.

As part of our efforts to understand factors influencing chromosomal organization and rearrangements, we studied a family of Salmonella typhimurium tandum duplication mutants. We found that the duplications were originally generated by unequal recombination between pairs of similarly oriented ribosomal ribonucleic acid operons (rrn). This demonstration involved the physical isolation of the duplicated material as circular deoxyribonucleic acid excised from the duplication. The four rrn operons involved embraced the ilv pur D segment of the chromosome and occurred at positions closely analogous to those previously observed for Escherichia coli. The interval between rrnC and rrnA of S. typhimurium was similar in size to that of E. coli (43 versus 39 kilobases), as was the interval between rrnB and rrnE (94 versus 91 kilobases). The rrnA-to-rrnB interval of S. typhimurium, however, was 155 kilobases, substantially greater than the 126 kilobases observed for E. coli.     

Isolation of temperature-sensitive mutants of 16 S rRNA in Escherichia coli

Temperature-sensitive mutants have been isolated following hydroxylamine mutagenesis of a plasmid containing Escherichia coli rRNA genes carrying selectable markers for spectinomycin resistance (U1192 in 16 S rRNA) and erythromycin resistance (G2058 in 23 S rRNA). These antibiotic resistance alleles, originally identified by Morgan and co-workers, enable us to follow expression of cloned rRNA genes in vivo. Recessive mutations causing the loss of expression of the cloned 16 S rRNA gene were identified by the loss of the ability of cells to survive on media containing spectinomycin. The mutations were localized by in vitro restriction fragment replacement followed by in vivo marker rescue and were identified by DNA sequence analysis. We report here seven single-base alterations in 16 S rRNA (A146, U153, A350, A359, A538, A1292 and U1293), five of which produce temperature-sensitive spectinomycin resistance and two that produce unconditional loss of resistance. In each case, loss of ribosomal function can be accounted for by disruption of base-pairing in the secondary structure of 16 S rRNA. For the temperature-sensitive mutants, there is a lag period of about two generations between a shift to the restrictive temperature and cessation of growth, implying that the structural defects cause impairment of ribosome assembly.     

Selection for intragenic suppressors of lethal 23S rRNA mutations in Escherichia coli identifies residues important for ribosome assembly and function

Mutations in several functionally important regions of the 23S rRNA of E. coli increase the levels of frameshifting and readthrough of stop codons. These mutations include U2555A, U2555G, ΔA1916 and U2493C. The mutant rRNAs are lethal when expressed at high levels from a plasmid, in strains also expressing wild type rRNA from chromosomal rrn operons. The lethal phenotype can be suppressed by a range of second-site mutations in 23S rRNA. However, analysis of the functionality of the double mutant rRNAs in heterogeneous ribosome populations shows that in general, the second site mutations do not restore function. Instead, they prevent the assembly, or entry of the mutant 50S subunits into the functioning 70S ribosome and polysome pools, by affecting the competitiveness of the mutant subunits for association with 30S particles. The second-site mutations lie in regions of the 23S rRNA involved in subunit assembly, intersubunit bridge formation and interactions of the ribosome with tRNAs and factors. These second site suppressor mutations thus define functionally important rRNA nucleotides and this approach may be of general use in the functional mapping of large RNAs.     

Identification of a single base change in ribosomal RNA leading to erythromycin resistance.

The molecular basis of a mutation conferring an erythromycin-resistance phenotype was explored, as an approach to the role of 23 S rRNA in the peptidyl-transferase activity of 50 S ribosomal subunits. Mutagenization of an Escherichia coli strain, which carried the multicopy plasmid pLC7-21 containing the rrnH operon, led to the production of an erythromycin-resistant strain. Plasmid pBFL1 isolated from this mutant was able to transform the sensitive RecA- strain EM4 and to induce a "dissociated" type of antibiotic resistance. Two ribosome populations occurred in EM4/pBFL1: normal particles coded for by the seven rrn chromosomal genes and mutated particles containing rRNA of plasmid origin. The latter particles displayed in vitro lower affinity and susceptibility to erythromycin than wild type particles. The mutation within plasmid pBFL1 was mapped by a multiple primer extension technique. Three synthetic primers were used to sequence the central loop in domain V of 23 S rRNA, leading to identification of a C to U transition at position 2611. This base change was proved to be responsible for the erythromycin-resistance phenotype by the plasmid-plasmid marker rescue technique. A molecular explanation for the rrn mutations leading, respectively, to undissociated and to dissociated types of resistance to the MLSb (macrolide-lincosamide-synergimycin B) group of antibiotics is proposed. These results and some literature data support the notion that rRNA bases involved in antibiotic resistance play a conformational role in the ribosomal binding sites for the MLSb antibiotics.     

Diversity of genome structure in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi populations

The genomes of most strains of Salmonella and Escherichia coli are highly conserved. In contrast, all 136 wild-type strains of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi analyzed by partial digestion with I-CeuI (an endonuclease which cuts within the rrn operons) and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and by PCR have rearrangements due to homologous recombination between the rrn operons leading to inversions and translocations. Recombination between rrn operons in culture is known to be equally frequent in S. enterica serovar Typhi and S. enterica serovar Typhimurium; thus, the recombinants in S. enterica serovar Typhi, but not those in S. enterica serovar Typhimurium, are able to survive in nature. However, even in S. enterica serovar Typhi the need for genome balance and the need for gene dosage impose limits on rearrangements. Of 100 strains of genome types 1 to 6, 72 were only 25.5 kb off genome balance (the relative lengths of the replichores during bidirectional replication from oriC to the termination of replication [Ter]), while 28 strains were less balanced (41 kb off balance), indicating that the survival of the best-balanced strains was greater. In addition, the need for appropriate gene dosage apparently selected against rearrangements which moved genes from their accustomed distance from oriC. Although rearrangements involving the seven rrn operons are very common in S. enterica serovar Typhi, other duplicated regions, such as the 25 IS200 elements, are very rarely involved in rearrangements. Large deletions and insertions in the genome are uncommon, except for deletions of Salmonella pathogenicity island 7 (usually 134 kb) from fragment I-CeuI-G and 40-kb insertions, possibly a prophage, in fragment I-CeuI-E. The phage types were determined, and the origins of the phage types appeared to be independent of the origins of the genome types.     

Spontaneous spectinomycin resistance mutations of the chloroplast rrn16 gene in Daucus carota callus lines

Bioballistic transformation of carrot Daucus carota L. callus cultures with a plasmid containing the aadA (aminoglycoside 3'-adenyltransferase) gene and subsequent selection oftransformants on a selective medium containing spectinomycin (100-500 mg/l) yielded ten callus lines resistant to this antibiotic. PCR analysis did not detect exogenous DNA in the genomes of spectinomycin-resistant calluses. Resistance proved to be due to spontaneous mutations that occurred in two different regions of the chloroplast rrn16 gene, which codes for the 16S rRNA. Six lines displayed the G > T or G > C transverions in position 1012 of the rrn16 gene, and three lines had the A > G transition in position 1138 of the gene. Chloroplast mutations arising during passages of callus cultures in the presence of spectinomycin were described in D. carota for the first time. The cause of spectinomycin resistance was not identified in one line. The mutations observed in the D. carota plastid genome occurred in the region that is involved in the formation of a double-stranded region at the 3' end of the 16S rRNA and coincided in positions with the nucleotide substitutions found in spectinomycin-resistant plants of tobacco Nicotiana tabacum L. and bladderpod Lesquerella fendleri L.     

Inactivation of the RluD pseudouridine synthase has minimal effects on growth and ribosome function in wild-type Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica

The Escherichia coli rluD gene encodes a pseudouridine synthase responsible for the pseudouridine (Ψ) modifications at positions 1911, 1915, and 1917 in helix 69 of 23S rRNA. It has been reported that deletion of rluD in K-12 strains of E. coli is associated with extremely slow growth, increased readthrough of stop codons, and defects in 50S ribosomal subunit assembly and 30S-50S subunit association. Suppressor mutations in the prfB and prfC genes encoding release factor 2 (RF2) and RF3 that restore the wild type-growth rate and also correct the ribosomal defects have now been isolated. These suppressors link helix 69 Ψ residues with the termination phase of protein synthesis. However, further genetic analysis reported here also reveals that the slow growth and other defects associated with inactivation of rluD in E. coli K-12 strains are due to a defective RF2 protein, with a threonine at position 246, which is present in all K-12 strains. This is in contrast to the more typical alanine found at this position in most bacterial RF2s, including those of other E. coli strains. Inactivation of rluD in E. coli strains containing the prfB allele from E. coli B or in Salmonella enterica, both carrying an RF2 with Ala246, has negligible effects on growth, termination, or ribosome function. The results indicate that, in contrast to those in wild bacteria, termination functions in E. coli K-12 strains carrying a partially defective RF2 protein are especially susceptible to perturbation of ribosome-RF interactions, such as that caused by loss of h69 Ψ modifications.