Interspecific competition between the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum and the gregarious endoparasitoid Glyptapanteles pallipes

We examined interspecific competition between the egg-larval polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) and the gregarious larval endoparasitoid Glyptapanteles pallipes (Hymenoptera: Braconidae). Approximately 72% of multiparasitized Acanthoplusia agnata (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) produced C. floridanum adults, 14% produced G. pallipes adults, and 14% died without producing any parasitoids. Development was delayed and the rate of weight gain was reduced in multiparasitized hosts that produced C. floridanum compared with singly-parasitized hosts. In contrast, only weight was reduced in multiparasitized hosts that produced G. pallipes adults. Compared with single parasitism, the brood size of wasps emerging from multiparasitized hosts was reduced in both species. The percentage of hosts containing precocious larvae of C. floridanum, which are considered to be soldiers, did not increase in response to parasitization by G. pallipes. However, developmental cessation and death of G. pallipes eggs and larvae may be closely related to the number of coexisting precocious larvae.     

Development of the polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum in Trichoplusia ni

Trichoplusia ni (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) parasitized by the polyembryonic egg-larval parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum (Ashmead) (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) attained significantly larger final weights and head capsule widths than unparasitized controls. The difference in weight between parasitized and unparasitized hosts was not entirely accounted for by the weight of the C. floridanum brood. The head capsule widths of all parasitized and unparasitized fifth instars used in the study exceeded the critical threshold of 1.66 mm previously established for T. ni metamorphosis. The critical ratios associated with each T. ni instar of: 1) maximum weight within the instar:head capsule width and 2) maximum weight within the instar:weight at the beginning of the instar differed between parasitized and unparasitized larvae. Development of C. floridanum was synchronized with that of its host. Germ band formation and gastrulation of morulae destined to produce reproductive larvae invariably coincided with the host molt to the ultimate, fifth instar. Reproductive larvae had two instars. Eclosion from the egg to the first instar occurred during day 2 of the host's fifth instar, and ecdysis from the first to the second instar was synchronized with host cocoon spinning. Conversely, embryogenesis of morulae destined to produce precocious larvae began during the host first instar, continued through the second and third instar and ceased during the penultimate, fourth instar. Precocious larvae never molted and died when the host was consumed by the reproductive larvae.

---

Résumé T. ni Hübner parasité par le parasitoïde ovo-larvaire C. floridanum Ashmead à développement polyembryonnaire atteint un poids final signficativement plus élevé avec une capsule céphalique plus grosse que les témoins non parasités, sans subir de mues surnuméraires. La différence de poids entre noctuelles parasitées ou non ne correspondait pas entièrement au poids des C. floridanum. Les largeurs des capsules céphaliques de tous les T. ni du cinquième stade dépassaient toutes le seuil critique de 1,66 mm lié à la métamorphose, mais les seuils critiques de taille du corps:largeur de la capsule céphalique et/ou taille et corps, taille initiale du corps au début du stade associé à la mue, différaient chez T. ni parasités ou non. Les développements de T. ni et de C. floridanum étaient synchrones. La formation de la bande germinative et la gastrulation de la morula produisant la multiplication des larves ont coïncidé invariablement avec la mue de l'hôte donnant le dernier stade. Les larves polyembryonnaires ont présenté deux stades. L'éclosion des oeufs s'est produite le deuxième jour du cinquième stade de T. ni, et le passage du premier au second était synchrone de la formation du cocon de l'hôte. Réciproquement, l'embryogenèse de la morula qui donnait des larves précoces commençait pendant le premier stade de l'hôte et se poursuivait à travers les second et troisième, pour cesser pendant le quatrième et pénultième stade.

     

Pattern duplications in larvae of the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum

 Copidosoma floridanum is a polyembryonic wasp that undergoes total cleavage of the egg followed by proliferation of blastomeres to produce up to 2,000 embryos from a single egg. This unusual mode of development raises several questions about how axial polarity is established in individual embryonic primordia. By examining embryonic development of larvae with duplicated structures (conjoined larvae), we determined that conjoined larvae form by mislocalization of two embryonic primordia to a common chamber of the extraembryonic membrane that surrounds individual embryos. Analysis of an anterior marker, Distalless, in mislocalized early embryos indicated that anterior structures form independently of one another. This suggests each embryonic primordium has some intrinsic polarity. However, during germband extension embryos usually fuse in register with each other, resulting in conjoined larvae with heads facing each other. Analysis of the posterior segmental marker, Engrailed, in conjoined embryos suggested that fusion in register initiates during germband extension. Thus, even though embryonic primordia initially have a random axial orientation, conjoined larvae usually possess a common orientation due to reorientation during germband extension. These observations suggest that differential cellular affinities during segmentation play an important role in embryo fusion. Received: 13 June 1996 / Accepted: 15 August 1996     

Intrinsic interspecific competition between the polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum and solitary endoparasitoid Microplitis demolitor in Pseudoplusia includens

Multiparasitism studies were conducted in the laboratory between the egg-larval polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum (Ashmead) (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) and the larval endoparasitoid Microplitis demolitor Wilkinson (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) in the mutual host Pseudoplusia includens (Walker) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Most multiparasitized hosts produced either a C. floridanum brood or died without any parasitoid emergence. Most multiparasitized hosts underwent supernumerary molting; however, multiparasitized hosts that produced a C. floridanum brood exhibited growth characteristics associated with C. floridanum parasitism while multiparasitized hosts that died exhibited growth characteristics more typical of M. demolitor parasitism. Multiparasitized hosts that produced a C. floridanum brood increased in weight, and usually exhibited the behavioral and morphological characteristics associated with initiation of metamorphosis. In contrast, multiparasitized hosts that ultimately died gained little weight and exhibited no characteristics associated with metamorphosis. M. demolitor progeny died in multiparasitized hosts as eggs or first instar larvae, but no direct evidence was found to indicate that physical attack by C. floridanum precocious larvae was responsible for their elimination.

---

Résumé Lors de l'étude au laboratoire du multiparasitisme de Pseudoplusia includens Walker (Lépido. Noctuidae) par le parasitoïde ovolarvaire polyembryonnaire C. floridanum Ashmead (Hyméno. Encyrtidae) et l'endoparasitoïde larvaire M. demolitor Wilkinson (Hyméno. Braconidae), soit les hôtes donnent en majorité C. floridanum, soit ils meurent sans que quoi que ce soit émerge. P. includens non parasité présente 5 stades larvaires; les hôtes parasités par C. floridanum subissent 5 ou 6 stades avant le développement complet du parasitoïde, et les hôtes parasités par M. demolitor muent en stade 5 avant émergence du parasitoïde. Par contre, les hôtes multiparasités muent en stade 7; ceux qui produisent une couvée de C. floridanum ont présenté la croissance caractéristique des hôtes parasités par C. floridanum, tandis que les hôtes multiparasités qui sont morts avaient présenté la croissance caractéristique des hôtes parasités par M. demolitor. La plupart des hôtes multiparasités desquels C. floridanum a émergé ont augmenté de poids et présenté les caractères associés au début de la métamorphose. La descendance de M. demolitor est morte dans les hôtes multiparasités au stade uf ou chenille du premier stade, mais il n'y avait aucum indice d'attaque physique par des larves de C. floridanum qui auraient été responsables de leur élimination.

     

Male soldier caste larvae are non-aggressive in the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum

Polyembryonic wasps are the only parasitoids in which sociality has evolved. Theory implicates both competition and sex ratio manipulation in the evolution of a sterile soldier caste. However, investment in soldiers by males and females is predicted to differ depending upon how offspring are allocated to hosts and the mating system. Here, we compared male and female soldiers in the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum. We found that male and female soldiers are morphologically identical. Unlike females, however, male soldiers were non-aggressive towards all competitors. We discuss these results in relation to theory and polyembryonic wasp biology.     

Host plant species affects the quality of the generalist Trichoplusia ni as a host for the polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum

Diet of herbivorous insects can influence both the herbivores and their natural enemies. We examined the direct and indirect effects of diet on the interactions between the polyphagous herbivore Trichoplusia ni Hübner (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) and its polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma floridanum Ashmead (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae). To determine how host plant species and host plant iridoid glycoside content affect host caterpillars and their parasitoids, parasitized and unparasitized T. ni were given leaves of either Plantago lanceolata L., which contains the iridoid glycosides aucubin and catalpol, Plantago major L. (Plantaginaceae), which contains only aucubin, or Taraxacum officinale F.H. Wigg (Asteraceae), which contains neither. Survival of unparasitized T. ni was much lower when fed P. major compared with the other two host plants, whereas pupae were smallest when fed T. officinale and developed most slowly when fed P. lanceolata as larvae. Neither aucubin nor catalpol were detected in intact Plantago‐fed T. ni larvae or their hemolymph, and only trace amounts of aucubin were detected in frass, suggesting that these compounds are mostly metabolized in the midgut and are not encountered by the parasitoid. Copidosoma floridanum clutch size was almost doubled when reared from P. lanceolata‐fed T. ni compared with T. officinale‐fed larvae and tripled compared with P. major‐fed larvae, although the percent of parasitoids surviving to adulthood was uniformly high regardless of host diet. The observed variation in C. floridanum fitness among host diets is likely mediated by the effect of the diets on host quality, which in turn may be influenced more by other factors in the host plants than their iridoid glycoside profiles. Interactions between plant metabolites, generalist herbivores like T. ni, and their parasitoids may be predominantly indirect.     

Developmental patterns in the polyembryonic parasitoid wasp Copidosoma koehleri

Polyembryony is a unique mode of development in which multiple genetically identical embryos develop from a single egg. In some polyembryonic species a proportion of the embryos develop into soldier larvae, which attack competitors in the host. We studied the development of the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma koehleri in its host Phthorimaea opercullela. We dissected hosts parasitized by either virgin or mated female wasps at 2day intervals from hatching to the final instars. We documented host mass and head width, the number and size of developing wasps and the presence of a soldier larva. Additionally, we kept a sample of parasitized hosts until emergence of wasps and measured the head width of emerging adults. We characterized wasp development in relation to host development. One half of the broods produced by mated wasps contained one soldier larva throughout development. This suggests that in C. koehleri each female brood produces a single soldier larva, and that the soldier probably survives and grows gradually during host development. Additionally, we found that female broods were larger than male broods during development and also upon emergence. Accordingly, body size was larger for males during development as well as upon emergence. These findings may extend the existing knowledge on polyembryonic development in general, and serve as a baseline for further experiments.     

Both endogenous and environmental factors affect embryo proliferation in the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum

Copidosoma floridanum is a polyembryonic, parasitic wasp of the moth Trichoplusia ni. Following oviposition into a host, the C. floridanum egg initially undergoes complete (holoblastic) cleavage to form a single morula stage embryo. This embryo then undergoes a proliferation phase in which multiple, secondary morulae develop. C. floridanum has also evolved a caste system whereby some secondary morulae develop into soldier larvae whose function is defense whereas others develop into reproductive larvae that become adult wasps. In the current study, we conducted manipulative and candidate gene studies to identify factors affecting the proliferation phase of C. floridanum development. Transplantation of morulae of different ages into different host stages indicated that both embryo age and host environment affected the total number of offspring produced per morula. Morula age and brood size also significantly affected whether offspring of one or both castes were produced in a brood. In contrast, the host environment did not significantly affect caste formation. A putative homolog of the gene hedgehog (Cf-hh) was partially cloned from C. floridanum. In situ hybridization studies indicated that Cf-hh was expressed in secondary morulae during the proliferation phase of development, suggesting a possible role for the Hh signaling pathway in the evolution of polyembryony.     

The polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum produces two castes by differentially parceling the germ line to daughter embryos during embryo proliferation

Eggs of the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum undergo a clonal phase of proliferation, which results in the formation of thousands of embryos called secondary morulae and two castes called reproductive and soldier larvae. C. floridanum establishes the germ line early in development, and prior studies indicate that embryos with primordial germ cells (PGCs) develop into reproductive larvae while embryos without PGCs develop into soldiers. However, it is unclear how embryos lacking PGCs form and whether all or only some morulae contribute to the proliferation process. Here, we report that most embryos lacking PGCs form by division of a secondary morula into one daughter embryo that inherits the germ line and another that does not. C. floridanum embryos also incorporate 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BrdU), which allows PGCs and other cell types to be labeled during the S phase of the cell cycle. Continuous BrdU labeling indicated that all secondary morulae cycle during the proliferation phase of embryogenesis. Double labeling with BrdU and the mitosis marker anti-phospho-histone H3 indicated that the median length of the G2 phase of the cell cycle was 18 h with a minimum duration of 4 h. Mitosis of PGCs and presumptive somatic stem cells in secondary morulae was asynchronous, but cells of the inner membrane exhibited synchronous mitosis. Overall, our results suggest that all secondary morulae contribute to the formation of new embryos during the proliferation phase of embryogenesis and that PGCs are involved in regulating both proliferation and caste formation.     

Costs and consequences of superparasitism in the polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma koehleri (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae)

Abstract.  1. Polyembryonic wasps provide dramatic examples of intra-specific developmental conflict. In these parasitoids, each egg proliferates into a clonal lineage of genetically identical larvae. If more than one egg is laid in a host (superparasitism), individuals of different clones may compete for food resources.
2. In the polyembryonic encyrtid Copidosoma koehleri , one larva per clone can differentiate into a sterile soldier. It is shown that soldiers are always females, and that they attack intra-specific competitors.
3. Research hypotheses were that (a) clones that develop in superparasitised hosts suffer heavier mortality than clones that develop in singly parasitised hosts, and (b) female clones cause higher mortality to their competitors than male clones, hence larval survival is lower in superparasitised hosts that contain females than in male-only broods.
4. The potential frequency of superparasitism in C. koehleri was manipulated by varying parasitoid–host ratios and exposure durations.
5. As parasitoid densities and exposure durations increased, the frequency of superparasitism rose, brood sizes increased, but the number of hosts that completed development was reduced. The number of offspring per parasitoid female decreased with increasing parasitoid–host ratios. Offspring size and longevity were inversely correlated with brood size. As superparasitism rates increased, fewer all-male broods were produced. Male–female broods were female-biased, suggesting selective killing of males by female soldiers. All-female broods were significantly smaller than all-male broods at high parasitoid densities only, possibly reflecting aggression among soldiers of competing clones.
6. The results support the working hypotheses, and suggest that female larvae outcompete males in superparasitised hosts.     

Caste formation in the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae): in vivo and in vitro analysis

The polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum produces two morphologically distinct types of larvae in its host Trichoplusia ni. Reproductive larvae consume the host, pupate, and form adult wasps, whereas precocious larvae manipulate the sex ratios of the reproductive caste and defend the brood against interspecific competitors. The previous study indicated that morphogenesis of the reproductive caste was associated with a 9-day competency period, and that ecdysteroids of host origin were required for completion of embryogenesis. Here we investigated whether factors associated with the host environment mediate morphogenesis of precocious larvae and caste determination. Embryogenesis of precocious larvae was found to be synchronized with specific stages of the host first-fourth instars. However, development of precocious larvae did not depend on environmental factors specifically associated with these host stages. Elevation of the host juvenoid titer using the analogue methoprene induced T. ni to undergo a supernumerary sixth instar, but did not alter the proportion of wasp embryos that developed into precocious and reproductive larvae. In contrast, embryos competent to initiate morphogenesis developed into precocious larvae when transplanted into novel host stages such as pupae. Development of precocious larvae was arrested by ablation of the host's source of ecdysteroids, but could be rescued dose-dependently by injection of 20-hydroxyecdysone. In vitro rearing studies confirmed that completion of embryogenesis of the precocious caste required an exogenous pulse of 20-hydroxyecdysone. Combined with previous studies, our results indicate that embryos forming precocious and reproductive larvae acquire the competence to undergo morphogenesis at different times. However, we find no evidence to suggest that caste determination is mediated by environmental factors associated with a specific stage of the host.     

Isolation of novel microsatellite markers for the social parasitoid wasp, Copidosoma floridanum (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae)

We developed and characterized nine microsatellite loci for the polyembryonic wasp Copidosoma floridanum (Ashmead) (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae). Eight of the nine loci were polymorphic and did not deviate from Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium. Our results will contribute to studies on the population genetic structure of C. floridanum.     

Host plant, host plant chemistry and the polyembryonic parasitoid Copidosoma sosares: indirect effects in a tritrophic interaction

Host plant identity and host plant chemistry have often been shown to influence host finding and acceptance by natural enemies but comparatively less attention has been paid to the tritrophic effects of host plant and host plant chemistry on other natural enemy fitness correlates, such as survivorship, clutch size, body size, and sex ratio. Such studies are central to understanding both the selective impact of plants on natural enemies as well as the potential for reciprocal selective impact of natural enemies on plant traits. We examined the effects of host plant and host plant chemistry in a tritrophic system consisting of three apiaceous plants (Pastinaca sativa, Heracleum sphondylium and H. mantegazzianum), the parsnip webworm (Depressaria pastinacella) and the polyembryonic parasitic wasp Copidosoma sosares. All of these plants produce furanocoumarins, known resistance factors for parsnip webworms. Furanocoumarin concentrations were correlated neither with the presence nor the number of webworms on a given plant. Concentrations of two furanocoumarins were negatively associated with C. sosares fitness correlates: isopimpinellin with the likelihood that a given webworm would be parasitized and xanthotoxin with both within‐brood survivorship (of all‐male and mixed‐sex broods) and clutch size. Brood sex ratio and body sizes of individual wasps were not correlated with furanocoumarin chemistry. Because additive genetic variation exists in P. sativa for furanocoumarin chemical traits, these are subject to selection by webworms through herbivory. Third trophic level selective impacts on furanocoumarin traits may include selection for reduced production of those chemicals that affect parasitoid survivorship yet do not influence host plant choice by the herbivore. That such might be the case is suggested by patterns of furanocoumarin production in populations of P. sativa with different histories of infestation; in the Netherlands, where parasitism rates of webworms by C. sosares are high, plants produce lower levels of all linear furanocoumarins and proportionately less isopimpinellin than do midwestern U.S. populations of P. sativa, where natural enemies of the webworm are effectively absent.     

Unisexual broods and sex ratios in a polyembryonic encyrtid parasitoid (Copidosoma sp.: Hymenoptera)

Summary We examined brood sex ratios of an undetermined species of Copidosoma. Most broods (65%) were unisexual, with a greater proportion of female broods. Some mixed broods contained extremely small proportions of wasps of the opposite sex. Our results imply that the female-biased sex rations in this species cannot be explained by local mate competition theory.     

Benefits of self-superparasitism in a polyembryonic parasitoid

Macrocentrus grandii is a polyembryonic parasitoid, with embryos that divide asexually within the host (European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis) to produce broods of clonal offspring. From a biological control standpoint, polyembryony seems advantageous because each parasitized host yields multiple parasitoids with minimal time and egg investment. When we observed M. grandii in the field, however, we found that the parasitoid virtually always invested additional time and, if possible, stings into hosts that it had already stung, apparently reducing some of the advantages of polyembryony. We therefore investigated and found support for two potential benefits that can be gained by self-superparasitism in this system. First, multiple stings allowed production of mixed-sex broods: 27% of multiply-stung versus 0% of singly-stung hosts produced mixed-sex broods. Second, multiple stings increased mean parasitoid progeny produced per host, primarily by reducing the chance of complete brood failure. Our results indicate substantial benefit for a second sting, but little benefit for three or more stings, even though M. grandii was sometimes observed to invest more than two stings within a single host. However, we also found that within-host larval competition is prevalent, suggesting that supernumerary stings may pay off in competition against conspecific larvae. Such additional investment within a single host would be particularly beneficial when hosts, rather than eggs, are limiting, but would decrease the overall efficacy of M. grandii as a biological control agent.     

Copidosoma truncatellum (Dalman) and C.floridanum (Ashmead) (Hymenoptera, Encyrtidae), two frequently misidentified polyembryonic parasitoids of caterpillars (Lepidoptera)

Abstract In this paper it is shown that Copidosoma floridanum , a polyembryonic parasitoid of the caterpillars of Plusiinae, has almost invariably been misidentified as Copidosoma truncatellum. Both species, and also a third (chilensis) which has been synonymized incorrectly with truncatellum , are diagnosed and characters to separate them reliably are presented.