Large is fast, small is tight: determinants of speed and affinity in subunit capture by a periplasmic chaperone

The chaperone/usher pathway assembles surface virulence organelles of Gram-negative bacteria, consisting of fibers of linearly polymerized protein subunits. Fiber subunits are connected through 'donor strand complementation': each subunit completes the immunoglobulin (Ig)-like fold of the neighboring subunit by donating the seventh β-strand in trans. Whereas the folding of Ig domains is a fast first-order process, folding of Ig modules into the fiber conformation is a slow second-order process. Periplasmic chaperones separate this process in two parts by forming transient complexes with subunits. Interactions between chaperones and subunits are also based on the principle of donor strand complementation. In this study, we have performed mutagenesis of the binding motifs of the Caf1M chaperone and Caf1 capsular subunit from Yersinia pestis and analyzed the effect of the mutations on the structure, stability, and kinetics of Caf1M-Caf1 and Caf1-Caf1 interactions. The results suggest that a large hydrophobic effect combined with extensive main-chain hydrogen bonding enables Caf1M to rapidly bind an early folding intermediate of Caf1 and direct its partial folding. The switch from the Caf1M-Caf1 contact to the less hydrophobic, but considerably tighter and less dynamic Caf1-Caf1 contact occurs via the zip-out-zip-in donor strand exchange pathway with pocket 5 acting as the initiation site. Based on these findings, Caf1M was engineered to bind Caf1 faster, tighter, or both faster and tighter. To our knowledge, this is the first successful attempt to rationally design an assembly chaperone with improved chaperone function.     

Conformational states and association mechanism of Yersinia pestis Caf1 subunits

Bacterial infectivity often relies on efficient attachment to the host cells through adhesive extensions. Unveiling the structural basis of the formation of these organelles is of paramount importance for both academic and applicative implications. Computational approaches may fruitfully complement experimental studies by providing information on specific conformational states whose characterization is difficult. Here, we report molecular dynamics characterizations of Yersinia pestis Caf1 subunit in its monomeric-unbound and dimeric states. Data on the monomeric form indicate that it is highly reactive and evolves toward compact states, which likely hamper subunit-subunit association. In line with recent experimental reports, this finding implies that chaperone release and subunit-subunit association must be simultaneous. MD analysis on Caf1 dimer lead to the formation of a novel assembly endowed with a significant stability in the simulation timescale. Using these data, an end-to-end model of the fiber, which well agrees with available experimental data, was also generated.     

A novel self-capping mechanism controls aggregation of periplasmic chaperone Caf1M

The chaperone Caf1M belongs to a family of ATP-independent periplasmic chaperones that together with outer membrane ushers assemble and secrete filamentous adhesion organelles in Gram-negative pathogens. It assists in folding and transport of Caf1 subunits of the F1 capsular antigen of Yersinia pestis, the microbe causing bubonic plague. In the periplasm, Caf1M prevents subunit aggregation by capping the extensive hydrophobic surface of activated Caf1. We found that subunit-free Caf1M exists predominantly as a tetramer [K(d) = (2-30) x 10(-14) M(3) in the 12-37 degrees C interval]. A 2.9 A resolution crystal structure of the Caf1M tetramer reveals that each of the four molecules contribute its subunit binding sequences (the A(1) and G(1) strands) to form an eight-stranded hetero-sandwich with a well-packed phenylalanine-rich hydrophobic core. Tetramerization protects chaperone molecules against enzymatic proteolysis. Deletions in the subunit binding motifs completely abolish tetramer assembly, suggesting that the hetero-sandwich is the main structural feature holding the tetramer together. Arresting tetramer assembly by a deletion of the N-terminal binding motif, while leaving the major subunit binding motif VGVFVQFAI (G(1) strand) intact, results in accumulation of unspecific aggregates. Deletions in the VGVFVQFAI motif abolish both tetramer assembly and aggregation, consistent with the predicted high beta-aggregation propensity for this motif. These results suggest that the packing of the aggregation-prone subunit binding sequences into the hetero-domain is a novel molecular mechanism preventing unspecific aggregation of the free chaperone.     

A protein lacking an essential input to its tertiary structure does fold into a compact globule

It is shown by equilibrium ultracentrifugation, velocity sedimentation, and viscometry that an N-truncated structural protein Caf1 (Cafl_13–149) of the Yersinia pestis capsular antigen fiber exists as a monomer in solution and is capable of folding from denatured state into a compact globular state by itself, without involvement of a chaperone or other subunits. This happens despite the fact that in the norm, important information on the tertiary structure of each Caf1 subunit (specifically, completion of its hydrophobic core) is provided by the “donor” segment Ala1-Thr12 of the neighboring fiber subunit.     

Secretion of recombinant proteins via the chaperone/usher pathway in Escherichia coli

F1 antigen (Caf1) of Yersinia pestis is assembled via the Caf1M chaperone/Caf1A usher pathway. We investigated the ability of this assembly system to facilitate secretion of full-length heterologous proteins fused to the Caf1 subunit in Escherichia coli. Despite correct processing of a chimeric protein composed of a modified Caf1 signal peptide, mature human interleukin-1beta (hIL-1beta), and mature Caf1, the processed product (hIL-1beta:Caf1) remained insoluble. Coexpression of this chimera with a functional Caf1M chaperone led to the accumulation of soluble hIL-1beta:Caf1 in the periplasm. Soluble hIL-1beta:Caf1 reacted with monoclonal antibodies directed against structural epitopes of hIL-1beta. The results indicate that Caf1M-induced release of hIL-1beta:Caf1 from the inner membrane promotes folding of the hIL-1beta domain. Similar results were obtained with the fusion of Caf1 to hIL-1beta receptor antagonist or to human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor. Following coexpression of the hIL-1beta:Caf1 precursor with both the Caf1M chaperone and Caf1A outer membrane protein, hIL-1beta:Caf1 could be detected on the cell surface of E. coli. These results demonstrate for the first time the potential application of the chaperone/usher secretion pathway in the transport of subunits with large heterogeneous N-terminal fusions. This represents a novel means for the delivery of correctly folded heterologous proteins to the periplasm and cell surface as either polymers or cleavable monomeric domains.     

An extended hydrophobic interactive surface of Yersinia pestis Caf1M chaperone is essential for subunit binding and F1 capsule assembly

A single polypeptide subunit, Caf1, polymerizes to form a dense, poorly defined structure (F1 capsule) on the surface of Yersinia pestis. The caf-encoded assembly components belong to the chaperone-usher protein family involved in the assembly of composite adhesive pili, but the Caf1M chaperone itself belongs to a distinct subfamily. One unique feature of this subfamily is the possession of a long, variable sequence between the F1 beta-strand and the G1 subunit binding beta-strand (FGL; F1 beta-strand to G1 beta-strand long). Deletion and insertion mutations confirmed that the FGL sequence was not essential for folding of the protein but was absolutely essential for function. Site-specific mutagenesis of individual residues identified Val-126, in particular, together with Val-128 as critical residues for the formation of a stable subunit-chaperone complex and the promotion of surface assembly. Differential effects on periplasmic polymerization of the subunit were also observed with different mutants. Together with the G1 strand, the FGL sequence has the potential to form an interactive surface of five alternating hydrophobic residues on Caf1M chaperone as well as in seven of the 10 other members of the FGL subfamily. Mutation of the absolutely conserved Arg-20 to Ser led to drastic reduction in Caf1 binding and surface assembled polymer. Thus, although Caf1M-Caf1 subunit binding almost certainly involves the basic principle of donor strand complementation elucidated for the PapD-PapK complex, a key feature unique to the chaperones of this subfamily would appear to be capping via high-affinity binding of an extended hydrophobic surface on the respective single subunits.     

Structural and functional significance of the FGL sequence of the periplasmic chaperone Caf1M of Yersinia pestis

The periplasmic molecular chaperone Caf1M of Yersinia pestis is a typical representative of a subfamily of specific chaperones involved in assembly of surface adhesins with a very simple structure. One characteristic feature of this Caf1M-like subfamily is possession of an extended, variable sequence (termed FGL) between the F1 and subunit binding G1 beta-strands. In contrast, FGS subfamily members, characterized by PapD, have a short F1-G1 loop and are involved in assembly of complex pili. To elucidate the structural and functional significance of the FGL sequence, a mutant Caf1M molecule (dCaf1M), in which the 27 amino acid residues between the F1 and G1 beta-strands had been deleted, was constructed. Expression of the mutated caf1M in Escherichia coli resulted in accumulation of high levels of dCaf1M. The far-UV circular dichroism spectra of the mutant and wild-type proteins were indistinguishable and exhibited practically the same temperature and pH dependencies. Thus, the FGL sequence of Caf1M clearly does not contribute significantly to the stability of the protein conformation. Preferential cleavage of Caf1M by trypsin at Lys-119 confirmed surface exposure of this part of the FGL sequence in the isolated chaperone and periplasmic chaperone-subunit complex. There was no evidence of surface-localized Caf1 subunit in the presence of the Caf1A outer membrane protein and dCaf1M. In contrast to Caf1M, dCaf1M was not able to form a stable complex with Caf1 nor could it protect the subunit from proteolytic degradation in vivo. This demonstration that the FGL sequence is required for stable chaperone-subunit interaction, but not for folding of a stable chaperone, provides a sound basis for future detailed molecular analyses of the FGL subfamily of chaperones.     

Secretion of Recombinant Proteins via the Chaperone/Usher Pathway in Escherichia coli

F1 antigen (Caf1) of Yersinia pestis is assembled via the Caf1M chaperone/Caf1A usher pathway. We investigated the ability of this assembly system to facilitate secretion of full-length heterologous proteins fused to the Caf1 subunit in Escherichia coli. Despite correct processing of a chimeric protein composed of a modified Caf1 signal peptide, mature human interleukin-1β (hIL-1β), and mature Caf1, the processed product (hIL-1β:Caf1) remained insoluble. Coexpression of this chimera with a functional Caf1M chaperone led to the accumulation of soluble hIL-1β:Caf1 in the periplasm. Soluble hIL-1β:Caf1 reacted with monoclonal antibodies directed against structural epitopes of hIL-1β. The results indicate that Caf1M-induced release of hIL-1β:Caf1 from the inner membrane promotes folding of the hIL-1β domain. Similar results were obtained with the fusion of Caf1 to hIL-1β receptor antagonist or to human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor. Following coexpression of the hIL-1β:Caf1 precursor with both the Caf1M chaperone and Caf1A outer membrane protein, hIL-1β:Caf1 could be detected on the cell surface of E. coli. These results demonstrate for the first time the potential application of the chaperone/usher secretion pathway in the transport of subunits with large heterogeneous N-terminal fusions. This represents a novel means for the delivery of correctly folded heterologous proteins to the periplasm and cell surface as either polymers or cleavable monomeric domains.     

Periplasmic chaperones--preservers of subunit folding energy for organelle assembly

The periplasmic PapD-like chaperones have long been known to be necessary for the assembly of bacterial surface organelles. New structural work now suggests that they control assembly by arresting subunit folding. This step may be required to preserve energy for fiber formation.     

Fiber assembly by the chaperone-usher pathway

Bacterial pathogens utilize the chaperone-usher pathway to assemble extracellular multi-subunit fibers essential for virulence. The periplasmic chaperone facilitates the initial folding of fiber subunits but then traps them in activated folding transition states. Chaperone dissociation releases the folding energy that drives subunit incorporation into the fiber, which grows through a pore formed by the outer-membrane usher.     

Thermodynamic parameters of stabilization of the Yersinia pestis Caf113-149 subunit in compact form

Several experimental methods (circular dichroism, viscosity, intrinsic fluorescence, and fluorescence labeling) were used to study the conformational folding/unfolding transitions in a compact monomeric form of the Caf1_13-149 subunit under the action of guanidine hydrochloride in the temperature range 5–45°C. It has been shown that transitions always occur between two major states (unfolded and compact). This has made it possible to determine all the main thermodynamic functions that characterize the compact state of the Caf1_13-149 subunit: stability temperature T _m, free energy of stabilization ΔG _st, enthalpy ΔH _tr, and heat capacity jump ΔC in collapse of the structure. These data have been confirmed by an independent experiment on melting of fluorescently labeled protein.     

Activation mechanism of HSP16.5 from Methanococcus jannaschii

The small heat shock proteins are the ubiquitous proteins found in a wide range of organisms and function as molecular chaperones by binding to the folding intermediates of their substrates. Although the crystal structure of HSP16.5, a small heat shock protein from Methanococcus jannaschii, revealed that it is a hollow sphere composed of 24 identical subunits, its activation mechanism remains unclear. We found out that HSP16.5 is active only at high temperatures and forms a stable complex with substrate in a stoichiometric manner. We also observed that the conformational change of HSP16.5 is correlated with the increasing hydrophobic site and its activation as a molecular chaperone. However, it is revealed that the conformational change is not accompanied with the change of the secondary structure of a subunit, but correlated with the increasing diameter of HSP16.5. Therefore, it is proposed that the activation mechanism of HSP16.5 involves temperature induced conformational change with size increment of the complex resulting in the exposure of hydrophobic substrate-binding site.     

Ribosome-DnaK interactions in relation to protein folding

Bacterial ribosomes or their 50S subunit can refold many unfolded proteins. The folding activity resides in domain V of 23S RNA of the 50S subunit. Here we show that ribosomes can also refold a denatured chaperone, DnaK, in vitro, and the activity may apply in the folding of nascent DnaK polypeptides in vivo. The chaperone was unusual as the native protein associated with the 50S subunit stably with a 1:1 stoichiometry in vitro. The binding site of the native protein appears to be different from the domain V of 23S RNA, the region with which denatured proteins interact. The DnaK binding influenced the protein folding activity of domain V modestly. Conversely, denatured protein binding to domain V led to dissociation of the native chaperone from the 50S subunit. DnaK thus appears to depend on ribosomes for its own folding, and upon folding, can rebind to ribosome to modulate its general protein folding activity.     

Chaperone Caf1M stabilizes hybrid proteins containing sequences of F1 antigen subunit from Yersinia pestis

The Yersinia pestis (causative agent of plague) capsule antigen is a homopolymer of Caf1 protein. Export of the subunits is mediated by the periplasmic chaperone Caf1M. To study the mechanism of Caf1M activity, two hybrid genes including coding sequences for the Caf1 signal peptide, human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) or interleukin-1 (IL-1) receptor antagonist, and mature Caf1 were constructed and expressed in Escherichia coli. We have shown that in the absence of Caf1M the majority of Caf1 moieties within the hybrid proteins undergo proteolysis in the periplasmic space, presumably by the DegP protease. The coexpression of a gene for chaperone Caf1M significantly increased the amount of full-size hybrid proteins in the periplasm, probably as a result of stabilization of the subunits spatial structure within the hybrid. This effect was not observed in JCB571 cells, which lack periplasmic disulfide isomerase DsbA, essential for Caf1M activity.     

Chaperone Caf1M Stabilizes Hybrid Proteins Containing Sequences of F1 Antigen Subunit from Yersinia pestis

The Yersinia pestis(causative agent of plague) capsule antigen is a homopolymer of Caf1 protein. Export of the subunits is mediated by the periplasmic chaperone Caf1M. To study the mechanism of Caf1M activity, two hybrid genes including coding sequences for the Caf1 signal peptide, human granulocyte–macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) or interleukin-1 (IL-1) receptor antagonist, and mature Caf1 were constructed and expressed in Escherichia coli.We have shown that in the absence of Caf1M the majority of Caf1 moieties within the hybrid proteins undergo proteolysis in the periplasmic space, presumably by the DegP protease. The coexpression of a gene for chaperone Caf1M significantly increased the amount of full-size hybrid proteins in the periplasm, probably as a result of stabilization of the subunit's spatial structure within the hybrid. This effect was not observed in JCB571 cells, which lack periplasmic disulfide isomerase DsbA, essential for Caf1M activity.     

Molecular basis of two subfamilies of immunoglobulin-like chaperones.

The initial encounter of a microbial pathogen with the host often involves the recognition of host receptors by different kinds of bacterial adhesive organelles called pili, fimbriae, fibrillae or afimbrial adhesins. The development of over 26 of these architecturally diverse adhesive organelles in various Gram-negative pathogens depends on periplasmic chaperones that are comprised of two immunoglobulin-like domains. All of the chaperones possess a highly conserved sheet in domain 1 and a conserved interdomain hydrogen-bonding network. Chaperone-subunit complex formation depends on the anchoring of the carboxylate group of the subunit into the conserved crevice of the chaperone cleft and the subsequent positioning of the COOH terminus of subunits along the exposed edge of the conserved sheet of the chaperone. We discovered that the chaperones can be divided into two distinct subfamilies based upon conserved structural differences that occur in the conserved sheet. Interestingly, a subdivision of the chaperones based upon whether they assemble rod-like pili or non-pilus organelles that have an atypical morphology defines the same two subgroups. The molecular dissection of the two chaperone subfamilies and the adhesive fibers that they assemble has advanced our understanding of the development of virulence-associated organelles in pathogenic bacteria.     

Modelling of steric structure of a periplasmic molecular chaperone Caf1M of Yersinia pestis, a prototype member of a subfamily with characteristic structural and functional features

Abstract Steric structure of Caf1M, a periplasmic molecular chaperone of Yersinia pestis , was reconstructed by computer modelling based on a statistically significant primary structure homology between Caf1M and PapD protein from Escherichia coli , and using the known atomic coordinates obtained by the X-ray crystallography for PapD. In the three-dimensional model of Caf1M an accessory sequence between F1 and G1 β-strands (as compared to PapD) can form a strain-specific part of the binding pocket of surface organell subunits. This accessory sequence decreases the depth of the binding pocket. The characteristic structural feature of the subfamily of periplasmic molecular chaperones with the accessory sequence (Caf1M subfamily) is the existence of exposed to a solvent Cys residues in F1 and G1 β-strands which can form disulfide bond in the putative binding pocket. The characteristic functional feature of Caf1M subfamily is the chaperoning of more simple compositions of virulence-associated surface organells (in the case of Y. pestis a capsule consists of only F1 protein). Highly conserved R₈₂ and D₉₃, located at the domain surface remote from the putative subunit binding pocket, can participate in direct contacts with the conserved portion of molecular usher proteins.     

Illustration of HIV-1 protease folding through a molten-globule-like intermediate using an experimental model that implicates alpha-crystallin and calcium ions

The folding of HIV-1 protease to its active form involves the coordination of structure formation and dimerization, which follows a hierarchy consisting of folding nuclei spanning from the active site, hinge region, and dimerization domain. However, the biochemical characteristics of the folding intermediates of this protein remain to be elucidated. In an experimental model, the denaturation of the tethered dimer of HIV-1 protease by guanidine hydrochloride revealed an alternative conformation resembling the molten-globule state. The molten-globule state binds to the molecular chaperone alpha-crystallin and prevents its aggregation; however, the chaperone alone failed to reconstitute HIV-1 protease into its active form. Calcium ion assisted in the release of active enzyme from the chaperone complex. Alpha-crystallin, a member of the small heat-shock protein, assists proteins to fold correctly; however, the underlying principle of signals responsible for chaperone-mediated protein folding remains enigmatic. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy has been employed to provide the evidence of calcium binding to alpha-crystallin and to decipher the effect of calcium binding on the chaperone-mediated refolding of HIV-1 protease. On the basis of our spectroscopic data, we propose that calcium ions interact with the carboxyl groups of the surface-exposed acidic amino acids of alpha-crystallin bringing electrostatic interference, which plays a pivotal role in inducing conformational changes in the chaperone responsible for the release of the active enzyme.     

Donor strand complementation mechanism in the biogenesis of non-pilus systems

The F1 antigen of Yersinia pestis belongs to a class of non-pilus adhesins assembled via a classical chaperone-usher pathway. Such pathways consist of PapD-like chaperones that bind subunits and pilot them to the outer membrane usher, where they are assembled into surface structures. In a recombinant Escherichia coli model system, chaperone-subunit (Caf1M:Caf1n) complexes accumulate in the periplasm. Three independent methods showed that these complexes are rod- or coil-shaped linear arrays of Caf1 subunits capped at one end by a single copy of Caf1M chaperone. Deletion and point mutagenesis identified an N-terminal donor strand region of Caf1 that was essential for polymerization in vitro, in the periplasm and at the cell surface, but not for chaperone-subunit interaction. Partial protease digestion of periplasmic complexes revealed that this region becomes buried upon formation of Caf1:Caf1 contacts. These results show that, despite the capsule-like appearance of F1 antigen, the basic structure is assembled as a linear array of subunits held together by intersubunit donor strand complementation. This example shows that strikingly different architectures can be achieved by the same general principle of donor strand complementation and suggests that a similar basic polymer organization will be shared by all surface structures assembled by classical chaperone-usher pathways.     

Deranged expression of molecular chaperones in brains of patients with Alzheimer's disease

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is one of the disorders caused by protein conformational changes and recent studies have shown that several chaperone proteins are involved in this process. As information of chaperone expression in AD brain is limited, we aimed to study the expressional pattern of chaperones in several brain regions, as this may be essential to understand how folding defects can lead to disease. We studied the concomitant expressional patterns of molecular chaperones in seven brain regions of adults with AD using two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2-DE) and matrix-associated laser desorption ionization mass spectroscopy (MALDI-MS). We unambiguously identified and quantified nine different chaperone proteins. Six chaperone proteins, heat shock protein 60 (HSP 60), HSP 70 RY, heat shock cognate (HSC) 71, alpha crystallin B chain, glucose regulated protein (GRP) 75, and GRP 94 showed aberrant expressional patterns depending on brain region. HSP 70.1, GRP 78 and T-complex 1 (TCP-1) epsilon subunit did not show any significant expressional change. These findings are compatible with neuropathological and biochemical abnormalities in AD brain and this report presents the first approach to quantify nine different chaperones simultaneously at the protein level in individual AD brain regions providing evidence for the relevance of aberrant chaperone expression to AD neuropathology.