Long-Term Protection against Diphtheria in the Netherlands after 50 Years of Vaccination: Results from a Seroepidemiological Study

Background and Aims

To evaluate the National Immunisation Programme (NIP) a population-based cross-sectional seroepidemiological study was performed in the Netherlands. We assessed diphtheria antitoxin levels in the general Dutch population and in low vaccination coverage (LVC) areas where a relatively high proportion of orthodox Protestants live who decline vaccination based on religious grounds. Results were compared with a nationwide seroepidemiological study performed 11 years earlier.

Methods

In 2006/2007 a national serum bank was established. Blood samples were tested for diphtheria antitoxin IgG concentrations using a multiplex immunoassay for 6383 participants from the national sample (NS) and 1518 participants from LVC municipalities. A cut-off above 0.01 international units per ml (IU/ml) was used as minimum protective level.

Results

In the NS 91% of the population had antibody levels above 0.01 IU/ml compared to 88% in the 1995/1996 serosurvey (p<0.05). On average, 82% (vs. 78% in the 1995/1996 serosurvey, p<0.05) of individuals from the NS born before introduction of diphtheria vaccination in the NIP and 46% (vs. 37% in the 1995/1996 serosurvey, p = 0.11) of orthodox Protestants living in LVC areas had antibody levels above 0.01 IU/ml. Linear regression analysis among fully immunized individuals (six vaccinations) without evidence of revaccination indicated a continuous decline in antibodies in both serosurveys, but geometric mean antibodies remained well above 0.01 IU/ml in all age groups.

Conclusions

The NIP provides long-term protection against diphtheria, although antibody levels decline after vaccination. As a result of natural waning immunity, a substantial proportion of individuals born before introduction of diphtheria vaccination in the NIP lack adequate levels of diphtheria antibodies. Susceptibility due to lack of vaccination is highest among strictly orthodox Protestants. The potential risk of spread of diphtheria within the geographically clustered orthodox Protestant community after introduction in the Netherlands has not disappeared, despite national long-term high vaccination coverage.     

Immunity to diphtheria, six to 15 years after a basic three-dose immunization schedule

The results of a study of the immunity to diphtheria of 283 girls (9-18 years of age) vaccinated at the age of two years with three doses of vaccine, are reported. The rabbit skin test was used to determine the titre of serum diphtheria antitoxin. 55.8% of the subjects were found to be protected (titre greater than or equal to 0.1 IU/ml), 38.9% were only relatively immune (titre greater than or equal to 0.01- less than 0.01 IU/ml), and 5.3% were unprotected (titre less than 0.01 IU/ml). The antitoxin titres showed a tendency to decrease with time. Even so, 6-15 years after vaccination, the percentages of protected and partially protected subjects were still high (95%).     

Persistence of antibody after accelerated immunisation with diphtheria/tetanus/pertussis vaccine.

OBJECTIVE--To determine the persistence of antibody to diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis in children receiving an accelerated schedule of primary immunisation. DESIGN--Controlled study of antibody testing of blood samples from children immunised according to various schedules: three doses of triple vaccine completed at 8-13 calendar months, 6-7 calendar months, before 6 calendar months, or three doses followed by diphtheria/tetanus before age 2. SETTING--Plymouth Health Authority. SUBJECTS--129 children aged 4 years who had received three doses of diphtheria/tetanus/pertussis vaccine with or without a diphtheria/tetanus booster. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Diphtheria and tetanus antitoxin concentrations and antibody titres to pertussis toxin, filamentous haemagglutinin, and agglutinogens 2 and 3. RESULTS--All children had protective concentrations of antitoxin to diphtheria and tetanus (greater than or equal to 0.01 IU/ml). There was no evidence of a significant difference in diphtheria or tetanus antitoxin concentrations and pertussis antibody titres in children immunised with an accelerated course (third dose of triple vaccine before 6 months) compared with those who received a longer course (third dose at 8-13 months) with no booster (geometric mean antitoxin concentration 0.411 (95% confidence interval 0.273 to 0.618) v 0.426 (0.294 to 0.616) for diphtheria and 0.358 (0.231 to 0.556) v 0.299 (0.197 to 0.453) for tetanus; geometric mean antibody titres 903 (500 to 1631) v 1386 (848 to 2266) for pertussis filamentous haemagglutinin, 179 (130 to 248) v 232 (167 to 322) for pertussis toxin, and 2002 (1276 to 3142) v 3591 (2220 to 5809) for agglutinogens 2 and 3). CONCLUSION--Immunisation with three doses of triple vaccine at monthly intervals completed before 6 months of age probably provides adequate protection against diphtheria, tetanus, and whooping cough which will persist until the age of the preschool booster.     

Transplacental antibodies. Part II: Maternal antibodies against the toxins of C. diphtheriae and C. tetani

Examinations of 297 sera for diphtheria antitoxin and 160 sera for tetanus antitoxin were carried out in 1981. All sera were obtained from the cord blood of mothers between 15 and 34 years of age. The mothers were divided into four age groups each of which was further subdivided into the primipara and multipara subgroups. The aim was to assess the age-specific variations in response to active immunization against diphtheria and tetanus. The protective level of diphtheria antitoxin (at least 0.01 I.U./ml) was recorded in the serum of 96.3% of examinees and the rates of seropositivity were found to fall with increasing age. The protective level of tetanus antitoxin (at least 0.1 I.U./ml) was found in the serum of 95.2% of mothers. The serologic response encountered in groups of older mothers was a clear-cut demonstration that the country-wide mass immunization against tetanus carried out between 1974 and 1975 was highly effective and fully justified. The variations in the diphtheria and tetanus antitoxin levels found in the primipara and multipara subgroups were not statistically significant.     

Diphtheria and tetanus immunity among blood donors in Toronto

OBJECTIVE: To determine the diphtheria and tetanus antitoxin levels among blood donors in Toronto. DESIGN: Cross-sectional seroprevalence study. SETTING: Two fixed-site blood-donation clinics in Toronto from September to November 1994. PARTICIPANTS: Blood donors 20 years of age or older were eligible to participate; of the 781 eligible donors, 710 (90.9%) participated in the study. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Diphtheria and tetanus antitoxin levels and factors associated with disease susceptibility, such as vaccination history, country of birth, age and sex. A diphtheria antitoxin level lower than 0.01 lU/mL and a tetanus antitoxin level lower than 0.15 lU/mL were considered nonprotective. RESULTS: Among the participants, 147 (20.7%) had a diphtheria antitoxin level in the nonprotective range, and 124 (17.5%) had a tetanus antitoxin level that was nonprotective. Increasing age and lack of written vaccination records were associated with susceptibility to the 2 diseases. Birth outside Canada was significantly related to tetanus susceptibility. CONCLUSION: Adults over 50 years of age who did not know their vaccination history were the least likely to be protected against diphtheria and tetanus. The greatest benefit of any immunization strategy would be gained by targeting this group.     

The immunization of children with combined diphtheria and tetanus vaccine in Sweden

Two groups derived from 97 children three-four months of age were vaccinated with diphtheria and tetanus vaccines containing either a routinely prepared diphtheria toxoid or a more purified preparation. Two injections were given with an interval of one month and a third injection was given one year after the first. Prior to the third injection no child was without protection against diphtheria, i.e. had an antitoxin titre less than 0.01 IU ml-1. After the third injection 95 and 94% of the children vaccinated with the routinely and more purified diphtheria toxoids, respectively, had diphtheria antitoxin titres greater than 1 IU ml-1 (estimated to provide protection for at least ten years). Systemic reactions such as fever and malaise occurred in five children. Local reactions greater than 10 cm were observed in three children and reactions greater than 5 but less than or equal to 10 cm were seen in 14% of the children. The routinely prepared combined diphtheria and tetanus vaccine, DT, produced very good immunity against diphtheria with moderate side effects. The use of a more purified diphtheria toxoid in the combined vaccine produced the same immunity and side effects.     

ELISA for the routine determination of antitoxic immunity to tetanus

Serum samples from 727 persons with different vaccination histories were assessed for tetanus antitoxin content in an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and tested for tetanus toxin neutralization activity in mice in order to compare the results obtained by the two methods. Neutralizing antibody activities in sera from individuals previously completely vaccinated correlated well with results obtained by ELISA and the accuracy increased with increasing antitoxin concentration in serum. This correlation was observed in sera from persons vaccinated recently as well as in sera from persons vaccinated many years ago. In sera from persons with an incomplete vaccination history ELISA was found to be an unreliable tool for the prediction of in vivo results. Many of these sera had antitoxin levels by ELISA far above the in vivo values, probably due to the presence of non specific or low avidity antitoxin which is detected in ELISA. The lowest ELISA value reliably predictive of protective antibody activity in serum irrespective of vaccination history was found to be 0.16 IU/ml. It was concluded that ELISA is useful for larger population studies as an initial test, but sera with an antitoxin content below 0.16 IU/ml should also be assessed in a neutralization system.     

Duration of immunity in children who received a primary complex of inoculations with ADT-M anatoxin and an assessment of postponed secondary revaccination against diphtheria and tetanus (the results of an epidemiologic trial)

The prolonged observations of the immunological effectiveness of adsorbed diphtheria-tetanus toxoid with reduced antigen content in children who had received the primary course of immunization with this preparation showed that the preparation induced the development of prolonged and intensive immunity to both infections. In 2-3 years after the first booster immunization the protective level of diphtheria antitoxin was registered in 89.9% and that of tetanus antitoxin, in 99% of children. 6 years later the level of immunity remained practically unchanged: the titers of diphtheria antitoxin above the protection level were determined in 92% and those of tetanus antitoxin, in 97% of children. These data made it possible to increase intervals between booster immunizations to 6-7 years in children of this category. The results of the epidemiological trial made to find out the possibility of a change in the timing of the second booster immunization confirmed the expediency of postponing booster immunization from 6 and 11 years to 9 and 16 years of age.     

Study of diphtheria anatoxins in immunochemical and tissue culture assays

Equine diphtheria antitoxins from different manufacturers were studied. Their immunochemical interaction with diphtheria toxin, toxoid, and antigens of Corynebacterium diphtheriae in ELISA and immunoblotting assays as well as biological activity in CHO cell assay were compared. The discovered differences between antitoxin samples with stated equal activity in IU/ml point to heterogeneity of antigen composition in preparations used for immunization. Mentioned methods allow to standardize antitoxins basing on their biological activity and immunochemical characteristics.     

Antibody status to poliomyelitis,measles, rubella,diphtheria and tetanus,Ontario, 1969-70: deficiencies discovered and remedies required.

A serologic survey was made in 15 health unit areas, testing some 5000 individuals in the age groups 4 to 6, 11 to 13, 15 to 17 and 23 to 45 years. Two types of serious deficiency were found. Only 65% of children 4 to 6 years old had antibodies to all three types of poliovirus, the antibodies being due almost entirely to immunization with Salk vaccine. Even in children who had had six or more doses only 74% had antibodies to the three types. The high percentage of students 11 to 13 and 15 to 17 years old with poliovirus antibodies can be attributed largely to natural infection and to Sabin vaccine in the mass campaign of 1962, as well as to Salk vaccine. In children who had received Sabin vaccine as well as Salk vaccine a very high level of immunity was found. The immunity of the school-age population will decline to an insufficient level unless Sabin vaccine is used after immunization with Salk vaccine. Of children 4 to 6 years old 18% had no diphtheria antitoxin and 6% had no tetanus antitoxin. Even in those who had had six or more doses of the antigens 5% had no diphtheria antitoxin and 1 to 2% had no tetanus antitoxin. This apparently refractory state is probably due to the use of unadsorbed toxoids, and it is clear that adsorbed toxoids should be used. In the adults, diphtheria antitoxin was found in only 55% and tetanus antitoxin in only 38%.     

Immunity to tetanus: tetanus antitoxin and anti-BIIb in human sera

Immunity to tetanus was investigated in 157 individuals aged between 1 and 77 years using, for the evaluation of both tetanus antitoxin and antibody to fragment BIIb (anti-BIIb), an easily performed ELISA that gave reproducible results. Among these people 72% were protected against tetanus (tetanus antitoxin titres greater than 0.06 IU ml-1). Anti-BIIb titres greater than 0.15 U ml-1 were found in 75% of the males vs 57% of the females (P less than 0.02) with marked variations according to age. Furthermore, 13 out of 41 individuals with antitoxin titres less than 0.06 IU ml-1 (not protected against tetanus) were found to have anti-BIIb titres greater than 0.15 U ml-1. These data raise questions as to the significance and protective effect of anti-BIIb against tetanus.     

青海省2006年14岁以下儿童百日咳白喉破伤风抗体水平监测

调查青海省0~14岁健康儿童百日咳、白喉、破伤风抗体水平,抽样评价预防接种质量。在全省六州一地一市各选择1个县,对0~14岁健康儿童进行抗体检测。结果显示,百日咳、白喉、破伤风抗体阳性率分别为93.42%、94.96%和92.93%。不同地区0~14岁健康儿童百日咳、白喉和破伤风抗体阳性率虽有差别,但都达到较高的抗体水平;个别地区抗体水平低,说明青海省儿童计划免疫工作存在薄弱环节。     

昆明市西山区2009年人群4种免疫抗体水平的监测分析

为了解昆明市西山区2009年健康人群中麻疹IgG、白喉IgG、乙肝表面抗原、乙肝表面抗体、乙脑IgG的免疫水平,评价预防接种效果,按卫生部《预防接种工作规范》(2005年版)人群免疫水平监测方法开展了调查。结果显示,白喉抗体总阳性率57.67%,1～4岁组白喉抗体阳性率为89.71%,白喉疫苗在计划免疫人群中实施效果较好,其它人群未能达到免疫成功率;麻疹抗体总阳性率69.71%,未能达到保护水平,而1～6岁组麻疹抗体阳性率为88.10%,达到计划免疫规程人群抗体阳性率85%的指标;乙肝表面抗原阳性率1.57%,乙肝抗体阳性率75.55%,但1～6岁组抗体阳性率较高,然后随年龄增加而降低;乙脑全人群抗体阳性率为70.53%,经过多次乙脑强化免疫,在人群中构建了较为有效的免疫屏障。西山区四种疫苗预防接种工作在国家免费所针对人群中实施效果较好,学龄前人群抗体阳性率较高,除乙脑疫苗接种人群外其它人群因未开展加强免疫工作,未能形成有效抗体免疫屏障,需定期开展重点人群强化免疫工作。     

The titration of tetanus antitoxin IV. Studies on the sensitivity and reproducibility of the toxin neutralization test

The quality of tetanus toxin affected the sensitivity of the toxin neutralization (TN) test greatly. By using purified toxin a minimum level of 0.001 IU/ml of tetanus antitoxin could be detected whereas with crude toxin a level of 0.025 IU/ml only could be detected. The TN test described in this report permitted titration of tetanus antitoxin in twofold dilution steps from levels as low as 0.001 IU/ml using 0.6 ml of serum only at the L+/5000 level of purified tetanus toxin. Treatment of the sera with 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) did not affect the TN titres showing that the TN test detects the neutralizing antibodies (IgG) which are not affected by 2-ME. The TN test was found to be a highly sensitive and reproducible test.     

Recall Responses to Tetanus and Diphtheria Vaccination Are Frequently Insufficient in Elderly Persons

Demographic changes and a more active life-style in older age have contributed to an increasing public awareness of the need for lifelong vaccination. Currently many older persons have been vaccinated against selected pathogens during childhood but lack regular booster immunizations. The impact of regular vaccinations when started late in life was analyzed in an open, explorative trial by evaluating the immune response against tetanus and diphtheria in healthy older individuals. 252 persons aged above 60 years received a booster vaccination against tetanus, diphtheria, pertussis and polio and a subcohort (n=87) was recruited to receive a second booster vaccination against tetanus, diphtheria and pertussis 5 years later. The percentage of unprotected individuals at the time of enrollment differed substantially for tetanus (12%) and diphtheria (65%). Despite protective antibody concentrations 4 weeks after the first vaccination in almost all vaccinees, antibodies had again dropped below protective levels in 10% (tetanus) and 45% (diphtheria) of the cohort after 5 years. Protection was restored in almost all vaccinees after the second vaccination. No correlation between tetanus- and diphtheria-specific responses was observed, and antibody concentrations were not associated with age-related changes in the T cell repertoire, inflammatory parameters, or CMV-seropositivity suggesting that there was no general biological “non-responder type.” Post-vaccination antibody concentrations depended on pre-existing plasma cells and B cell memory as indicated by a strong positive relationship between post-vaccination antibodies and pre-vaccination antibodies as well as antibody-secreting cells. In contrast, antigen-specific T cell responses were not or only weakly associated with antibody concentrations. In conclusion, our findings demonstrate that single shot vaccinations against tetanus and/or diphtheria do not lead to long-lasting immunity in many elderly persons despite administration at relatively short intervals. Sufficient antigen-specific B cell memory B generated by adequate priming and consecutive booster vaccinations and/or exposure is a prerequisite for long-term protection.

Trial Registration

EU Clinical Trials Register (EU-CTR); EudraCT number 2009-011742-26; www.clinicaltrialsregister.eu/ctr-search/trial/2009-011742-26/AT     

Evaluation of the immunological effectiveness of the planned vaccinal prophylaxis of diphtheria and tetanus in Sverdlovsk and Sverdlovsk Province

The level and intensity of antitoxic immunity to diphtheria and tetanus in children and adolescents were determined. The presence of tetanus antitoxin in titers exceeding the protective level in 96.3-98.5% of the examined children and adolescents is indicative of a high actual coverage by immunization. Protective titers against diphtheria were lower. There was no essential difference in the levels of protection in children immunized according to the vaccination schedule and in those immunized with some deviations from this schedule. A considerable part of newborns and children aged 3 months had antibodies to diphtheria and tetanus antitoxins. After the third booster immunization changes in antidiphtheria immunity characteristics occurred only in 2.5% of the vaccines and no changes in antitetanus immunity characteristics were observed.     

The immunization of adults against diphtheria in Sweden

Two hundred and three women who disclaimed vaccination against diphtheria were divided into four groups and injected with either 2.0 or 6.25 Lf of a routine diphtheria toxoid or of a more purified preparation. One hundred and twenty-six of these women who did not show a secondary antibody response were given a second and a third injection one month and one year, respectively, after the first injection. Prebooster (third injection) antitoxin titres of greater than or equal to 0.01 IU ml-1 (the minimum level for protection) were found in 22 and 37% of those who received 2.0 and 6.25 Lf, respectively. Postbooster titres of greater than or equal to 1.0 IU ml-1 (calculated to give a protection of at least ten years of duration) were found in 23 and 58% of those who received 2.0 and 6.25 Lf, respectively. The rate of untoward reactions was low. Fever of short duration occurred in five women. Four out of the five women received 6.25 Lf of the more purified diphtheria toxoid and one 2 Lf of the routine toxoid. Local reactions greater than 10 cm were observed in three women. All received the higher dose, 6.25 Lf of diphtheria toxoid. Local reactions greater than 5 but less than or equal to 10 cm occurred in up to 13% (6.25 Lf of diphtheria toxoid). No significant difference between the groups of women vaccinated with routine or more purified toxoid was found. It was concluded that the diphtheria toxoids in the two doses of 2 Lf and 6.25 Lf did not induce a satisfactory immune response. To induce adequate protection the dose of diphtheria vaccine needs to be the same for adults and children, i.e. 12.5 Lf.     

Diphtheria in Lao PDR: Insufficient Coverage or Ineffective Vaccine?

Background

During late 2012 and early 2013 several outbreaks of diphthe-ria were notified in the North of the Lao People’s Democratic Republic. The aim of this study was to determine whether the re-emergence of this vaccine-preventable disease was due to insufficient vaccination coverage or reduction of vaccine effectiveness within the affected regions.

Methods

A serosurvey was conducted in the Huaphan Province on a cluster sampling of 132 children aged 12–59 months. Serum samples, socio-demographic data, nutri-tional status and vaccination history were collected when available. Anti-diphtheria and anti-tetanus IgG antibody levels were measured by ELISA.

Results

Overall, 63.6% of participants had detectable diphtheria antibodies and 71.2% tetanus antibodies. Factors independently associated with non-vaccination against diphtheria were the distance from the health centre (OR: 6.35 [95% CI: 1.4–28.8], p = 0.01), the Lao Theung ethnicity (OR: 12.2 [95% CI:1,74–85, 4], p = 0.01) and the lack of advice on vac-cination given at birth (OR: 9.8 [95% CI: 1.5–63.8], (p = 0.01) while the level of maternal edu-cation was a protective factor (OR: 0.08 [95% CI: 0.008–0.81], p = 0.03). Most respondents claimed financial difficulties as the main reason for non-vaccination. Out of 55 children whose vaccination certificates stated that they were given all 3 doses of diphtheria-containing vaccine, 83.6% had diphtheria antibodies and 92.7% had tetanus antibodies. Furthermore, despite a high prevalence of stunted and underweight children (53% and 25.8%, respectively), the low levels of anti-diphtheria antibodies were not correlated to the nutritional status.

Conclusions

Our data highlight a significant deficit in both the vaccination coverage and diphtheria vaccine effectiveness within the Huaphan Province. Technical defi-ciencies in the methods of storage and distribution of vaccines as well as unreliability of vac-cination cards are discussed. Several hypotheses are advanced to explain such a decline in immunity against diphtheria and recommendations are provided to prevent future outbreaks.     

Chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis: T cell deficiency associated with B cell dysfunction in man

Routine immunologic screening of four patients with chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis (CMC) revealed that they manifested positive Schick tests in vivo despite adequate diphtheria toxoid immunization and the presence of circulating hemagglutinating antibody to diphtheria. Plasma from these individuals was found to neutralize Schick toxin in rabbits. Unlike normal individuals who preferentially make IgG neutralizing antibody to diphtheria toxin when immunized, these patients with CMC have neutralizing activity in plasma fractions containing IgM. IgM is predominantly an intravascular protein which would account for the failure of our patients to neutralize Schick toxin in vivo. These findings suggest that T cell deficiency as it occurs in CMC may lead to B cell dysfunction in man.     

A comparison of the indirect haemagglutination test with the toxin neutralization test for the estimation of diphtheria antitoxin in mouse sera

Serum samples from 42 groups of mice immunized for different immunization periods with various doses of Adsorbed Diphtheria-Tetanus Vaccine, Adsorbed Diphtheria-Tetanus and Pertussis Vaccine and a standard diphtheria toxoid were assayed for their diphtheria antitoxin content by indirect haemagglutination (IHA) and by toxin neutralization (TN) tests. A very good correlation of 0.91 was obtained between the results of the two methods. There was no statistically significant difference between the IHA and the TN titres obtained. Adsorption with sheep red cells and treatment of the sera with 2-mercaptoethanol had no effect on the IHA titres. The minimum level of antitoxin detectable by the IHA test was 0.00039 IU ml-1. IHA proved to be a sensitive, specific and reproducible method which can be used reliably for the assay of diphtheria antitoxin in mouse sera.